85 Exhibit J_Houlton_LEED_NC_Scorecard.pdf

Exhibit J

Houlton LPOE - Main Port Building

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No Notes

Base Bid Item(s):

Main Port Building

Required by P100

(when related to item in scope)

1 IP 1 Design Team can document

3 0 13

1 LT 2 Project location will earn

1 1 LT 3 Project location will earn

5 LT 4 Location not eligible

5 LT 5 Location not eligible

1 LT 6 Location not eligible

1 LT 7 Required parking exceeds numbers

1 LT 8 Green Vehicles 5% EV or 10% EV-ready spaces

& level 2 chargers Two dual head level 2 EV chargers are planned

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No

1 0 9

Y SS p1 ESC required regardless of scope;

plan required

1 SS 1 Design Team can document

2 SS 2 Requires significant landscaping

1 SS 3 Requires pedestrian infrastructure

3 SS 4 Requires infiltration

2 SS 5 Amount of hardscaping makes credit unachievable

1 SS 6 Not assumed due to project security

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No

3 3 5

Y WE p1

Y WE p2 No irrigation supports achievement

Y WE p3 Building-Level Water Metering LEED scope should have water meters

2 WE 1 No irrigation supports achievement

1 2 3 WE 2 P1,00 flow rates save @25% water

If the following flow rates are accepted, 35% reduction is possible:1.0gpm kitchen, 0.35 gpm lav, 0.125 gpf urinal

Upgrade plumbing fixtures to lower flow rates Kitchen faucet 1.5 gpm, other IgCC-2018

Section 601.3.2.1 (WC 1.28 gpf, Urinal (.5 gpf), lavs 0.5 gpm), shower 2.0 gpm)

2 WE 3 Building size makes credit unachievable

1 WE 4 Consider areas/uses that can be submetered

LEED BD+C v4/4.1

Cooling Tower/Process Water Use

Outdoor Water Use Reduction

Indoor Water Use Reduction

Light Pollution Reduction

Water Efficiency

Outdoor Water Use Reduction

Indoor Water Use Reduction

Open Space

Rainwater Management

Heat Island Reduction

Surrounding Density and Diverse Uses

Access to Quality Transit

Bicycle Facilities

Reduced Parking Footprint

Site Assessment

Site Development--Protect or Restore Habitat

Water Metering

Please note that the scorecard below relates to the LEED status of the Main Port Building only. Base scope of the other buildings are not sufficient to support LEED Certification. At a minimum, LEED

Certification would require: HVAC modernization (equipment and ventilation per ASHRAE Standard

62.1), commissioning, upgrade of plumbing fixtures, and building level water and energy metering.

Without these LEED prerequisites, these buildings cannot be included in LEED boundary.

LEED v4 for BD+C: New Construction

Integrative Process

Location and Transportation

Sensitive Land Protection

High Priority Site

Sustainable Sites

Construction Activity Pollution Prevention

Bid

LEED

Plus No

Notes Base Bid Item(s):

Main Port Building

Required by P100

(when related to item in scope)

13 4 16

Y EA p1

Y EA p2

Y EA p3

Y EA p4

5 1 EA 1 Monitoring-based commissioning could be added

1.8.4 references GSA Commissioning Guide which requires HVAC and Envelope commissioning

7 2 9 EA 2 Project is currently showing 7 points with HVAC system 1 and 9 points with HVAC system 2

(18.7% and 23.9% savings respectively)

During Final Concept phase, additional energy modeling with selected choices will be performed and credits identified

Replace roof, façade panels, doors and windows

Replace HVAC system and lighting

Add BAS system

Replace fluorescent LED lighting

1 EA 3 Advanced Energy Metering Submeter any part of energy more than 10%

2 EA 4 Not assumed in mission critical buildings;

does P1.00 allow?

1.9.2.8 GRID-INTERACTIVE EFFICIENT

BUILDINGS

5 EA 5 Would require adding PV

1 EA 6 Not available for certain MEP typologies

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No

8 0 5

Y MR p1 Assumes recycling storage area can be identified; building recycling policy will be required

Y MR p2 Assumes specs can require CWM plan

5 MR 1 Reuse of building will earn points More than 75% of applicable materials are bring retained

1 1 MR 2 Team will identify 20 products with EPDs in DD phase

4.8.5 may not be available regionally (10 yards+ concrete or asphalt require EPDs)

2 MR 3

1 1 MR 4 Building Products - Material Ingredients Team will identify 20 products with material ingredient disclosure in DD phase

1 1 MR 5 Assumes specs can require

CWM plan and diversion

1.9.2.3 requires diversion of 50% of C&D waste from landfill

Energy and Atmosphere

Fundamental Commissioning and Verification

Minimum Energy Performance

Demand Response/ Grid Harmonization

Renewable Energy Production

Building Products - Sourcing of Raw Materials

Enhanced Refrigerant Management

Building-Level Energy Metering

Fundamental Refrigerant Management

Enhanced Commissioning

Construction and Demolition Waste Management

Building Products - Environmental Product Declarations

Optimize Energy Performance

Storage and Collection of Recyclables

Construction and Demolition Waste Management Planning

Building Life-Cycle Impact Reduction

Materials and Resources

Bid

LEED

Plus No

Notes Base Bid Item(s):

Main Port Building

Required by P100

(when related to item in scope)

6 2 8

Y EQ p1 Outdoor air sensors required for all OA

Replace ventilation system in building and vehicle inspection area

Must meet ASHRAE 62.1 AND outdoor airflow monitoring

Y EQ p2 Assumes no smoking signs can be included

1 1 EQ 1 Project will meet enhanced outdoor air quality;

extra credit requires walk off matts and filtration Replace ventilation system in base building

3 EQ 2 Assumes some use of interior paints, insulation, adhesives, ceilings, and wall panels which would be low emitting; product selection will be reviewed in DD phase

1 EQ 3 Required for occupied buildings

2 EQ 4 Requires IAQ testing before occupancy;

as the project will be contuially occupied, it is unlikely that the credit can be achieved

Phased project and always occupied building

1 EQ 5

Would require desk fans to provide individual thermal control

1 1 EQ 6 Assumes dimmers can be included, task lights may be required on desks Replace remaining fluorescent fixtures and provide controls

3 EQ 7

No changes to building layout

1.9.2.7 DESIGNING FOR DAYLIGHT Assumed

not required

1 EQ 8 Assumed based on existing windows in non-secure occupied areas Existing window locations do not earn credit

1 EQ 9

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No

3 3 0

1 IN 1.1 Will be reviewed in Design Development.

1 IN 1.2 Will be reviewed in Final Concept

1 IN 1.3

Will require purchasing policy

Replace remaining fluorescent fixtures and provide controls

1 IN 1.4 Will be reviewed in Final Concept

1 IN 1.5 Will be reviewed in Final Concept

1 IN 2 Team earns this credit Base

Bid

LEED

Plus

No

3 1 0

1 RP 1.2

1 RP 1.3

1 RP 1.4

1 RP 1.5

RP 1.6

Base

Bid

LEED

Plus No

41 13 56

Certified 40 to 49 points Silver 50 to 59 points Gold 60 to 79 points Platinum 80 to 110

Regional Priority: Thermal Comfort

Exemplary Performance, Pilot, or Innovation LEED Accredited Professional

Regional Priority

Pilot - Integrated Product Analysis

Exemplary Performance, Pilot, or Innovation

Exemplary Performance, Pilot, or Innovation

Regional Priority: High Priority Site

Regional Priority: Rainwater Management

Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control

Total

Regional Priority: Building Life Cycle Impact Reduction

Regional Priority: Optimize Energy (6 points)

Innovation in Design - Low Mercury Lighting

Quality Views

Acoustic Performance

Innovation

Daylight

Thermal Comfort

Interior Lighting

Indoor Air Quality Assessment

Low-Emitting Materials

Construction Indoor Air Quality Management Plan

Indoor Environmental Quality

Minimum Indoor Air Quality Performance

Based on a review of items that are included in the Base scope or which can be associated to those items or the project location/existing conditions, the project will be at a LEED Certified Level. Obtaining LEED Gold appears challenging for the Main Port Building. Please see the Concept Design Narrative for more information.

Base scope for the other buildings on campus do not support a LEED Certification, as all LEED prerequisites do not appear to be met.

Enhanced Indoor Air Quality Strategies