RFI_27a_attach1.pdf

REQUEST FOR INFORMATION

R E

Q U

E S

T O

R S

E C

T

IO

N

From: Date:

To:

1. Solicitation Number:

W91364-19-B-7001

2. Location of Project:

Mansfield Ohio ANG

3. Information Requested: (Include Specification Section and/or Drawing Number and Page if inquiring about a discrepancy)

Requesting Clarifications:

1. The Architectural Design Narrative indicates the following: Under Sustainability Criteria, “Although the project has not been required to receive a LEED Certification, the project is being design to be LEED Certifiable. See Sustainability Narrative and Checklist for additional details.”

Requesting location of the “Sustainability Narrative” and “Checklist” which is referenced.

2. Under “Tab D – ANG Design Policy” The index references: “Section 9 Sustainability Design.

Development and resource Conservation…21.”

Requesting location of Section 9.

3. Section 01 33 29 “Sustainability Reporting” references a HPSB Checklist as allegedly being attached to the section:

“1.4 Guiding Principles Validation (GPV) Provide construction related sustainability documentation to verify achievement of ISWG Guiding Principles Validation (GPV). Provide the following for GPV:

a) Refer to Attachment 1, HPSB Checklist at the end of this specification section.”

Requesting location of this checklist.

Attachments: Date Response Required:

By: Title:

Requestor's FAX Number: Requestor's Telephone Number:

R E

S P

O N

S E

To: Date:

Response:

1. See Appx C of Vol 1 Basis of Design - attached

2. https://www.wbdg.org/ffc/ang/engineering-technical-letters-angetl/15-01-01

3. This checklist is provided as Appx C of Vol 1 Basis of Design

This information is a clarification of the solicitation/contract and does not change the contract terms or conditions.

This information is a proposed change to the solicitation/contract. An amendment will be issued.

Contracting Officer:

haleyb Text Box #27

CH2M HILL - HDR JV

Basis of Design

Appendix C – Sust. Design & Energy Conserv.

ANGETL 15-01-01, 1 May 15

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

General Information PBXP132166 Project Number (e.g. ABCD123456) Repair MX Hangar Project Title Major Renovation and/or Addition Project Category Mansfield Lahm ANG Base Base Name Mansfield City * Ohio State * Conus CONUS * Chris Manz / CH2M PM Name $ PA ($k) 40,000 Building Size (SF) 2019 Program Year (FY####) B-3 Project Phase 2015 Design Started (FY####)

2/1/2016 BOD (MM/DD/YY)

MIL Not in pursuit of LEED Pursuing formal LEED® Certification

Date Project Registered with USGBC (MM/DD/YY) LEED® 2009 LEED® Rating System 49 LEED® Points Status ANG Certifiable LEED® Certification Level Goal Per ANG Design Instruction Certified LEED® Certification Level Status 0 LEED® Points Awarded by GBCI (e.g. 42) 0 LEED® Certification Level Awarded by GBCI_Code 0 LEED® Certification Level Awarded by GBCI 18 LEED® Energy and Water Points Status

Date Project Certified by GBCI (MM/DD/YY) $0 Registration Fees ($) $0 Certification Fees ($)

- LEED® Access ID 105% HPSB Compliant Met requirement Water Conservation Achieved (% below EPAct 1992) 31% Energy Efficiency Achieved (% below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA

Standard 90.1-2010) N/A LEED® Energy and Water Points Awarded by GBCI Not Complete All LEED General Information complete 2/8/2019 Automatic Date Yes EPAct 2005 Compliant 11/1/2018 Date Scoresheet Completed or Revised * LEED® 2009 Scoresheet version

Federal Requirements

Complete

0 0Fees ($)

Registration Certification

Date Project Registered (MM/DD/YY)

Date Project Certified by GBCI (MM/DD/YY)

0 LEED Points Awarded by GBCI (e.g. 42)

LEED Certification Level Awarded by GBCI

N/A LEED Energy and Water Points Awarded by GBCI

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 1

VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

Color Coding: See Instructions Tab for more detail Recommended (not required) Yes or N/A Maybe

LEED Prerequisite No

* required entry

Federal Requirements for High Performance and Sustainable Buildings (HPSB) & UFC 1-200-02 HPSB I: Employ Integrated Design Principles (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-2)

2 Possible Points 2

Yes HPSB I.1 Integrated Design

The project has been following LEED v3 Integrated Design Criteria

Yes HPSB I.2 Commissioning Fundamentsl commissioning is specified 1

1 Possible Points (HPSB only) 3 Yes UFC para 2-3.1 Site selection This is a previously developed site 1

Yes 35 Mitigation of Heat Island Effect The existing roof meets this criteria. It is not being replaced

ROOF - The existing roof is a White EPDM. This roof will remain

N/A

The project scope does not include replacing enough asphalt to make it possible to achieve this credit. Adding this asphalt replacement to the scope of would add enormous cost with chance of payback.

SITE - The existing site is 90% black asphalt. There is no intent to replace the paving. All new paving will be light colored concrete

N/A WALLS - The existing walls are brown. 0

Yes UFC para 2-3.3 Reduction of Light Pollution 0

Yes HPSB III.3-4 Stormwater Management

Due to site conditions and cost constraints the design has not been able to achiev both the quality and Quantity reqirements for this criteria.

The Site is mostly paved. The paving is not being altered in this contract. The paving that is being replaced is concrete.

4 Possible Points 2 Yes HPSB II.1 1

Yes Reduce energy use 30% below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-2010 or if not - achieve maximum energy efficiency that is lifecycle cost effective

The design performs 30% or better then ASHRAE 90.1, 2010.

30.8% Insert percentage below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1- 2010 in terms of energy use (e.g. 32)

63.2 Insert building energy intensity (kBtu/yr-sqft) calculated IAW 10

CFR 433

N/A HPSB II.2 0

N/A Installed solar hot water heater system or found installation not lifecycle cost effective. First Cost, ROI and maintenance cost were cited as reasons to not pursue this.

Solar Hot water system was considered for Locker room use. The ROI for installation was not acceptable.

N/A Insert generation capacity (MMBtu/yr)

0.0% Insert percentage of demand

N/A HPSB II.3 0

N/A Installed renewable energy elements or projects were not lifecycle cost effective First Cost, ROI and maintenance cost were cited as reasons to not pursue this.

Renewable Energy was considered. Orientation and shading interfered with power production.

Renewable energy types (check below)

No Entry Required Custom Entry

Drop-Down Box

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 2

Ryan.Tushner Ellipse

VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

0.0 Insert generation capacity (kW)

0.0% Insert percentage of total building Yes HPSB II.4 1

Yes Water Metering: Select N/A if no service

Yes Electric Metering: Select N/A if no service

Yes Natural Gas Metering: Select N/A if no service N/A Steam Metering: Select N/A if no service

HPSB III: Protect and Conserve Water (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-5) 3 Possible Points 3

Yes HPSB III.1 Indoor Water Project anticipates 35% savings using ultra low flow fixtures.

Yes HPSB III.2 Outdoor Water The design is using drought tolerant landscaping with no irrigation.

Yes HPSB III.4 1

Yes Water efficient measures were implemented with heating and cooling equipment when life cycle effective

HPSB IV: Enhance Indoor Environmental Quality (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-6) 6 Possible Points 5

Yes HPSB IV.1 Thermal Comfort The design will follow ASHRAE 189.1 criteria 1

Yes HPSB IV.2 Ventilation The design will follow ASHRAE 189.1criteria 1

Yes HPSB IV.3 The design will follow ASHRAE 189.1 criteria 1

N/A HPSB IV.4 Daylighting 0

Yes HPSB IV.5 Low Emitting Materials Specifications will be written to use only low VOC materials.

Yes HPSB IV.6 Protect Indoor Air Quality during Construction Specifications will be writtent to require Contractor compliance with SMACNA IAQ standards.

Yes HPSB IV.7 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control

Federal Guideline will meet this criteria. The design will provide smoking areas outside.

6 Possible Points 6

Yes HPSB V.1 Recycled Content

Specs are written to provide products that typically can be found with high recycled content.

Yes HPSB V.2 Biologically-based Products

Specs are written to require rapidly renewable laminated wood and FSC certied wood.

Yes HPSB V.3 Environmentally Preferable Products

Specs are written to identy products that meet the environmental preferable criteria.

Yes HPSB V.4 Waste and Materials Management - Recycling

A waste management spec includes target thresholds for construction waste recycling.

Yes HPSB V.5 1 60.0% Insert percentage diverted from landfill

Yes Data element is not applicable

Yes HPSB V.6 1 Possible Points 21

22 Federal Requirements - Yes or N/A 0 Federal Requirements - Maybe 0 Federal Requirements - No

105% Percentage of Federal Requirements Met

Moisture Control

Solar PV

Solar CP

Solar Thermal Electric

Geothermal

GSHP Wind

Hydro Waste to Energy

Renewables were not

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 3

VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

LEED® Credits and/or Prerequisites that meet HPSB/UFC Requirements LEED® Credits and/or Prerequisites that align closely with HPSB/UFC Requirements LEED® Credits that meet ANG Energy & Water Criteria (may depend on technologies & strategies)

Sustainable Sites 6 Sustainable Sites Possible Points 26

Yes Prereq 1 Construction Activity Pollution Prevention (HPSB GP3) Required Yes Credit 1 1 No Credit 2 5 No Credit 3 1 No Credit 4.1 6 Yes Credit 4.2 1 No Credit 4.3 3 Yes Credit 4.4 2 No Credit 5.1 1 No Credit 5.2 1 No Credit 6.1 1 Yes Credit 6.2 1 No Credit 7.1 Heat Island Effect - Non-Roof (UFC) 1 Yes Credit 7.2 Heat Island Effect - Roof (UFC) 1 No Credit 8 Light Pollution Reduction 1

Option 2 Select which LEED® Interior Lighting Option was used

6 Possible Points 10 Yes Prereq 1 Required

4 Credit 1 Water Efficient Landscaping (HPSB GP3) 2 to 4 2 Reduce Potable Water Use by 50% (HPSB GP3) 2 4 No Potable Use or Irrigation (HPSB GP3) 2

No Credit 2 2 2 Credit 3 Water Use Reduction (HPSB GP3) 2 to 4

2 30% Reduction (HPSB GP3) 2 3 35% Reduction (HPSB GP3) 1 4 40% Reduction (HPSB GP3) 1

Energy & Atmosphere 15 Possible Points 35

Yes Prereq 1 Required Yes Prereq 2 Minimum Energy Performance (HPSB GP2) Required Yes Prereq 3 Fundamental Refrigerant Management (HPSB GP5) Required 10 Credit 1 Optimize Energy Performance (HPSB GP2) 1 to 19

1 12% for New Buildings/8% for Existing Building Renovations 1 2 14% for New Buildings/10% for Existing Building Renovations 1 3 16% for New Buildings/12% for Existing Building Renovations 1 4 18% for New Buildings/14% for Existing Building Renovations 1 5 20% for New Buildings/16% for Existing Building Renovations 1 6 22% for New Buildings/18% for Existing Building Renovations 1 7 24% for New Buildings/20% for Existing Building Renovations 1 8 26% for New Buildings/22% for Existing Building Renovations 1 9 28% for New Buildings/24% for Existing Building Renovations 1 10 30% for New Buildings/26% for Existing Building Renovations 1 11 32% for New Buildings/28% for Existing Building Renovations 1 12 34% for New Buildings/30% for Existing Building Renovations 1 13 36% for New Buildings/32% for Existing Building Renovations 1 14 38% for New Buildings/34% for Existing Building Renovations 1 15 40% for New Buildings/36% for Existing Building Renovations 1

Site Selection Development Density & Community Connectivity

Alternative Transportation - Public Transportation Access

Innovative Wastewater Technologies

Water Use Reduction - 20% Reduction (HPSB GP3)

Stormwater Design - Quantity Control (HPSB GP3) Stormwater Design - Quality Control (HPSB GP3)

Alternative Transportation - Low-Emitting & Fuel Efficient Vehicles

Site Development - Maximize Open Space

Alternative Transportation - Parking Capacity Site Development - Protect or Restore Habitat

LEED® 2009 Checklist

Fundamental Commissioning of the Building Energy Systems (HPSB GP1)

Brownfield Redevelopment

Alternative Transportation - Bicycle Storage & Changing Rooms

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 4

VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

16 42% for New Buildings/38% for Existing Building Renovations 1 17 44% for New Buildings/40% for Existing Building Renovations 1 18 46% for New Buildings/42% for Existing Building Renovations 1 19 48%+ for New Buildings/44%+ for Existing Building Renovations 1

0 Credit 2 On-Site Renewable Energy (HPSB GP2) 1 to 7 1 On-site 1% 1 2 On-site 3% 1 3 On-site 5% 1 4 On-site 7% 1 5 On-site 9% 1 6 On-site 11% 1 7 On-site 13% 1

No Credit 3 2 Yes Credit 4 2 Yes Credit 5 3 No Credit 6 2

6 Possible Points 14 Yes Prereq 1 Storage & Collection of Recyclables (HPSB GP5) Required

0 Credit 1.1 Building Reuse - Maintain Existing Walls Floors & Roof 1 to 3 1 Maintain 55% of Existing Walls Floors & Roof 1 2 Maintain 75% of Existing Walls Floors & Roof 1 3 Maintain 95% of Existing Walls Floors & Roof 1

No Credit 1.2 1 2 Credit 2 Construction Waste Management (HPSB GP5) 1 to 2

1 50% Recycled or Salvaged 1 2 75% Recycled or Salvaged 1

0 Credit 3 Materials Reuse 1 to 2 1 5% of value of material reused content 1 2 10% of value of material reused content 1

1 Credit 4 1 to 2 1 10% of value of material recycled content 1 2 20% of value of material reused content 1

2 Credit 5 Regional Materials 1 to 2 1 10% Extracted, Processed & Manufactured 1 2 20% Extracted, Processed & Manufactured 1

No Credit 6 1 Yes Credit 7 1

11 Possible Points 15 Yes Prereq 1 Minimum IAQ Performance (HPSB GP4) Required Yes Prereq 2 Environmental Tobacco Smoke (ETS) Control (HPSB GP4) Required Yes Credit 1 1 Yes Credit 2 1 Yes Credit 3.1 1

Maybe Credit 3.2 1 Yes Credit 4.1 1 Yes Credit 4.2 1 Yes Credit 4.3 1 Yes Credit 4.4 1 Yes Credit 5 1 Yes Credit 6.1 1 Yes Credit 6.2 1 Yes Credit 7.1 1 No Credit 7.2 We need client to agree to administer survey 1 No Credit 8.1 1

Outside Air Delivery Monitoring

Low Emitting Materials, Flooring Systems (HPSB GP4) Low Emitting Materials, Composite Wood & Agrifiber Products (HPSB GP4)

Construction IAQ Management Plan, During Construction (HPSB GP4) Construction IAQ Management Plan, Before Occupancy (HPSB GP4) Low Emitting Materials, Adhesives & Sealants (HPSB GP4) Low Emitting Materials, Paints & Coatings (HPSB GP4)

Increased Ventilation

Enhanced Commissioning (HPSB GP1)

Controllability of Systems, Thermal Comfort Thermal Comfort, Design (HPSB GP4)

Indoor Chemical & Pollutant Source Control Controllability of Systems, Lighting (HPSB GP4)

Thermal Comfort, Verification Daylight & Views - Daylight 75% of Spaces (HPSB GP4)

Certified Wood (HPSB GP5) Rapidly Renewable Materials (HPSB GP5)

Recycled Content (HPSB GP5)

Building Reuse - Maintain 50% of Interior Non-Structural Elements

Enhanced Refrigerant Management (HPSB GP5) Measurement & Verification (HPSB GP2) Green Power

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 5

VERSION (ANG v2015(1) ) LEED® 2009 * required entry

No Credit 8.2 1

3 Possible Points 6 Yes Credit 1.1 Innovation in Design 1.1 1

Select if ID 1.1 was for energy and/or water Green Cleaning Yes Credit 1.2 Innovation in Design 1.2 1

Select if ID 1.2 was for energy and/or water Regional materials > 30% No Credit 1.3 Innovation in Design 1.3 1

Select if ID 1.3 was for energy and/or water No Credit 1.4 Innovation in Design 1.4 1

Select if ID 1.4 was for energy and/or water No Credit 1.5 Innovation in Design 1.5 1

Select if ID 1.5 was for energy and/or water Yes Credit 2 LEED® Accredited Professional 1

2 Possible Points 4 Yes Credit 1.1 Regional Priority 1.1 Optimize Energy >20% 1

Energy Select if RP 1.1 was for energy and/or water No Credit 1.2 Regional Priority 1.2 Stormwater Quantity 1

Water Select if RP 1.2 was for energy and/or water Yes Credit 1.3 Regional Priority 1.3 Stormwater Quality 1

Water Select if RP 1.3 was for energy and/or water No Credit 1.4 Regional Priority 1.4 1

Select if RP 1.4 was for energy and/or water Possible Points 110

49 Total LEED® Yes Points 1 Total LEED® Maybe Points

22 Total LEED® No Points 23 Total LEED® Energy and Water Related Points

Certified LEED® Certification Status

N/A LEED® Horizontal Benchmark Level Horizontal N/A

N/A LEED® Utility Benchmark Level Utilities N/A

N/A LEED® Industrial Benchmark Level Industrial N/A

LEED®: Certified: 40-49 points, Silver: 50-59 points, Gold: 60-79 points, Platinum: 80-110

Daylight & Views - Views for 90% of Spaces

Attachment 2 v2015(1) - 6

PBXP132166

Repair MX Hangar

Mansfield Lahm ANG BaseB-3

11/1/2018

Base Name

Project Phase

Date Scoresheet Completed or Revised

Is Project EPAct 2005 Compliant? (Yes/No) YES

Proposed/Estimated Energy Performance of Facility:

Proposed Building Performance without Receptacle and Process Loads (kBTU):

1329749

Energy Consumption of Receptacle and Process Loads (kBTU):

1086764

Proposed Building Performance (kBTU): 2416513

EPAct 2005 Scoresheet

Life Cycle Cost Analysis Performed? (Yes/No) NO

EPAct 2005 Percentage Improvement Formula:

(Refer to UFC 3-400)

100 * (Baseline Building Performance - Proposed Building Performance) / (Baseline Building Performance - Receptacle and Process Loads):

Percentage Improvement without Receptacle and Process loads and in accordance with EPAct

2005:

30.80%

Baseline Building Performance of Facility as Designed to ASHRAE 90.1-2004 Requirements:

Baseline Building Performance without Receptacle and Process Loads (kBTU):

1921610

Energy Consumption of Receptacle and Process Loads (kBTU)

1086764

Baseline Building Performance (kBTU): 3008374

Project Number (e.g. ABCD123456)

Project Title

Attachment 2 - EPsct 2005 Tab