Phase_2_Rockefeller_Greenhouse_Building_Permit-Bid_Project_Manual.pdf

PROJECT MANUAL

JANUARY 5TH, 2026

PERMIT/BID SET

City of Cleveland

Rockefeller Greenhouse Campus Renovations

Greenhouse Building

750 East 88th Street Cleveland, OH 44108

IKM INCORPORATED

1001 Huron Road Suite 102

Cleveland, OH. 44115 IKM Project No. 22-062

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 02 – Project Information

Campus Renovations – Greenhouse Building 01.05.2026 – PERMIT/BID SET IKM Project #: 22-062

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 02 - Project Information - PAGE 1 OF 1

SECTION 00 01 02

PROJECT INFORMATION

PART 1 GENERAL

1.01 PROJECT IDENTIFICATION

A. Project Name: City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse Campus Renovations – Greenhouse Building, located at 750 East 88th Street, Cleveland, OH 44108.

B. IKM Architecture Project Number: 22-062.

C. The Owner, hereinafter referred to as Owner: City of Cleveland

D. Owner's Project Manager: Joseph Mestnik, RA.

1. Department: Mayor's Office of Capital Projects.

2. Address: Cleveland City Hall, 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A.

3. City, State, Zip: Cleveland, OH 44114.

4. Phone: 216-664-2374.

5. E-mail: jmestnik@clevelandohio.gov.

1.02 NOTICE TO PROSPECTIVE BIDDERS

A. These documents constitute an Invitation to Bid to and request for qualifications from General Contractors for the construction of the project described below.

1.03 PROJECT DESCRIPTION

A. Summary Project Description: Renovations, alterations, and deferred maintenance improvements to the Rockefeller Greenhouse Building located on the Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse campus. Work includes building structure with historic significance to the City of Cleveland..

B. Contract Scope: Construction, demolition, renovation, hazardous material removal, construction financing, and facility operations during occupancy.

C. Contract Terms: Lump sum (fixed price, stipulated sum).

D. The currently occupied premises at the project site are open for examination by bidders only during the following hours:

1. Monday through Friday: 9:00am to 3:00pm.

1.04 PROJECT CONSULTANTS

A. The Architect, hereinafter referred to as Architect: IKM Architecture.

1. Address: 1001 Huron Road East, Suite 102.

2. City, State, Zip: Cleveland, OH, 44115.

3. Phone: 216-678-9456.

1.05 PROCUREMENT DOCUMENTS

A. Availability of Documents: Complete sets of procurement documents may be obtained:

1. From Owner at the Project Manager's address listed above.

PART 2 PRODUCTS (NOT USED)

PART 3 EXECUTION (NOT USED)

END OF SECTION

This page intentionally left blank

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 03 – Project Directory

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 03 - Project Directory - PAGE 1 OF 2

SECTION 00 01 03

PROJECT DIRECTORY

PART 1 GENERAL

1.01 SECTION INCLUDES

A. Identification of project team members and their contact information.

1.02 OWNER:

A. Name: City of Cleveland

1. Address Line 1: Mayor's Office of Capital Project - Division of Architecture and Site Development.

2. Address Line 2: Cleveland City Hall, 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A.

3. City: Cleveland.

4. State: OH.

5. Zip Code: 44114.

6. Telephone: 216-664-2374.

7. Fax:216-664-4220.

B. Primary Contact: All correspondence from the Contractor to the Architect will be through this party, unless alternate arrangements are mutually agreed upon at preconstruction meeting.

1. Title: Chief Architect.

2. Name: Joseph Mestnik, RA.

3. Email: jmestnik@clevelandohio.gov.

1.03 CONSULTANTS:

A. Architect: Design Professional of Record. All correspondence from the Contractor regarding construction documents authored by Architect's consultants will be through this party, unless alternate arrangements are mutually agreed upon at preconstruction meeting.

1. Company Name: IKM Architecture

a. Address Line 1: 1001 Huron Road East, Suite 102.

b. City: Cleveland.

c. State: OH.

d. Zip Code: 44115.

e. Telephone: 216-678-9456.

2. Primary Contact:

a. Title: IKM Architecture, Project Manager.

b. Name: Adam Yaracs, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP.

c. Email: ayaracs@ikminc.com.

B. Landscape Architecture Consultant:

1. Company Name: Knight & Stolar, Inc..

a. Address Line 1: 3029 Prospect Avenue East #1.

b. City: Cleveland.

c. State: OH.

d. Zip Code: 44115.

e. Telephone: 216-391-0910.

2. Primary Contact:

a. Title: Landscape Architect.

b. Name: Kathy Jankowski.

c. Email: kj@kslarch.com.

C. Structural Engineering Consultant:

1. Company Name: Osborn Engineering.

a. Address Line 1: 1111 Superior Avenue, Suite 2100.

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 03 – Project Directory

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 03 - Project Directory - PAGE 2 OF 2

b. City: Cleveland.

c. State: OH.

d. Zip Code: 44114.

e. Telephone: 216-861-2020.

2. Primary Contact:

a. Title: Structural Engineer.

b. Name: Charlie Hetman.

c. Email: chetman@osborn-eng.com.

D. Mechanical, Electrical, Plumbing, AV/IT Engineering Consultant:

1. Company Name: Algebra AEC.

a. Address Line 1: 11410 Uptown Avenue.

b. City: Cleveland.

c. State: OH.

d. Zip Code: 44106.

e. Telephone: 216-714-2542.

2. Primary Contact:

a. Title: Principal.

b. Name: Shariq Ali, PE, LEED AP.

c. Email: shariq@algebra.engineering.

E. Exterior Envelope Consultant:

1. Company Name: Finley Consulting Group, LLC.

a. Address Line 1: 7783 Creekside Parkway.

b. City: Macedonia.

c. State: OH.

d. Zip Code: 44056.

e. Telephone: 216-214-9933.

2. Primary Contact:

a. Title: Principal.

b. Name: David Finley, CEP.

c. Email: dave@finleycg.com.

PART 2 PRODUCTS - NOT USED

PART 3 EXECUTION - NOT USED

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 10 - Table of Contents

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 10 – Table of Contents - PAGE 1 OF 4

SECTION 00 01 10

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PROCUREMENT AND CONTRACTING REQUIREMENTS

DIVISION 00 -- PROCUREMENT AND CONTRACTING REQUIREMENTS

00 01 02 - Project Information

00 01 03 - Project Directory

00 01 10 - Table of Contents

00 01 15 - List of Drawing Sheets

00 31 00 - Available Project Information

00 40 00 – Procurement Forms and Supplements

00 43 36 - Proposed Subcontractors Form

00 50 00 - Contracting Forms and Supplements

SPECIFICATIONS

DIVISION 01 -- GENERAL REQUIREMENTS

01 10 00 - Summary

01 20 00 - Price and Payment Procedures

01 21 00 – Allowances

01 25 00 – Substitution Procedures

01 30 00 – Administrative Requirements

01 31 14 – Facility Services Coordination

01 32 16 – Construction Progress Schedule

01 40 00 – Quality Requirements

01 45 33 – Code-Required Special Inspections and Procedures

01 50 00 - Temporary Facilities and Controls

01 51 00 - Temporary Utilities

01 52 13 - Field Offices and Sheds

01 55 00 - Vehicular Access and Parking

01 56 39 – Temporary Tree and Plant Protection

01 58 13 - Temporary Project Signage

01 60 00 – Product Requirements

01 70 00 – Execution and Closeout Requirements

01 74 19 – Construction Waste Management and Disposal

01 78 00 – Closeout Submittals

01 79 00 – Demonstration and Training

01 91 13 – General Commissioning Requirements

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 10 – Table of Contents - PAGE 2 OF 4

DIVISION 02 -- EXISTING CONDITIONS

02 41 19 – Selective Demolition

02 41 20 – Selective Site Demolition

DIVISION 03 -- CONCRETE

03 01 30 – Patching of Cast-in-Place Concrete

03 30 00 – Cast-in-Place Concrete

03 64 23 – Pressure Epoxy Injection

DIVISION 04 -- MASONRY

04 01 00 – Maintenance of Masonry

04 01 20 – Unit Masonry Restoration

04 01 21 – Brick Masonry Repair and Replacement

04 01 27 – Repointing with Cement-Lime Mortar

04 05 01 – Masonry Mortar and Grout

DIVISION 05 -- METALS

05 50 00 - Metal Fabrications

DIVISION 06 -- WOOD, PLASTICS, AND COMPOSITES

06 10 00 - Rough Carpentry

06 10 53 - Miscellaneous Rough Carpentry

06 40 23 – Interior Architectural Woodwork

DIVISION 07 -- THERMAL AND MOISTURE PROTECTION

07 21 00 - Thermal Insulation

07 21 19 – Foamed in Place Insulation

07 54 23 - Thermoplastic Single-Ply Membrane Roofing - Adhered

07 62 00 - Sheet Metal Flashing and Trim

07 65 00 - Flexible Flashing

07 72 00 - Roof Accessories

07 92 00 - Joint Sealants

07 92 02 – Joint Sealants – Concrete Application

DIVISION 08 -- OPENINGS

08 11 13 - Hollow Metal Doors and Frames

08 17 43 – Composite Fiberglass Doors and Frames

08 31 00 - Access Doors and Panels

08 71 00 - Door Hardware

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 10 – Table of Contents - PAGE 3 OF 4

08 80 00 – Glazing

08 88 63 – Greenhouse Glass Lite Replacement

DIVISION 09 -- FINISHES

09 05 61 - Common Work Results for Flooring Preparation

09 21 16 - Gypsum Board Assemblies

09 30 00 - Tiling

09 51 00 - Acoustical Ceilings

09 91 13 - Exterior Painting

09 91 23 - Interior Painting

DIVISION 10 -- SPECIALTIES

10 44 00 - Fire Protection Specialties

10 51 13 - Metal Lockers

10 56 17 - Wall Mounted Standards and Shelving

DIVISION 12 -- FURNISHINGS

12 36 00 - Countertops

DIVISION 23 – HEATING, VENTILATING, AND AIR-CONDITIONING (HVAC)

23 05 17 Sleeves and Sleeve Seals for HVAC Piping

23 05 29 Hangers and Supports for HVAC Piping and Equipment

23 05 93 Testing, Adjusting, and Balancing for HVAC

23 07 19

23 08 00

HVAC Piping Insulation

Commissioning of HVAC systems

23 23 00 Refrigerant Piping

23 81 26.13 Small-Capacity Split-System Air Conditioners

DIVISION 25 -- INTEGRATED AUTOMATION

25 05 00 Common Work Results for Integrated Automation

25 11 16 Integrated Automation Network Routers, Bridges, Switches, Hubs, and Modems

25 11 19 Integrated Automation Network Laptop

25 12 00 Integrated Automation Network Gateways

25 14 00 Integrated Automation Local Control Units

25 15 00 Integrated Automation Software

25 35 00 Integrated Automation Instrumentation and Terminal Devices for HVAC

25 35 13 Integrated Automation Actuators and Operators

25 35 16 Integrated Automation Sensors and Transmitters

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 10 – Table of Contents - PAGE 4 OF 4

25 36 19 Integrated Automation Current Sensors

25 35 23 Integrated Automation Control Dampers

25 36 19 Integrated Automation Sensors and Transmitters

DIVISION 26 -- ELECTRICAL

26 05 05 Selective Demolition for Electrical

26 05 19 Low-Voltage Electrical Power Conductors and Cables

26 05 26 Grounding and Bonding for Electrical Systems

26 05 29 Hangers and Supports for Electrical Systems

26 05 33.13 Conduit for Electrical Systems

26 05 33.16 Boxes for Electrical Systems

26 05 53 Identification for Electrical Systems

26 08 00 Commissioning of Electrical Systems

26 09 23 Lighting Control Devices

26 24 16 Panelboards

26 27 26 Wiring Devices

26 28 16.16 Enclosed Switches

26 56 00 Exterior Lighting

DIVISION 32 – EXTERIOR IMPROVEMENTS

32 14 41 – Granite Paving

32 14 45 – Granite Cleaning

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 15 – List of Drawing Sheets

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 15 – List of Drawing Sheets - PAGE 1 OF 2

SECTION 00 01 15

LIST OF DRAWING SHEETS

GREENHOUSE BUILDING

Architectural

A0 Greenhouse Cover Sheet

A000 General Notes and Door and Frame Types and Schedule

AL101 Life Safety Plans

LS100 Landscape Plan

Structural

S001GH General Notes

S002GH General Notes

S101GH Greenhouse Repair Plan

S102GH Greenhouse Enlarged Repair Plan

S103GH Greenhouse Enlarged Repair Plan

S201GH Greenhouse Elevation Repairs

S202GH Greenhouse Elevation Repairs

S301GH Typical Concrete Repair Details and Notes

S302GH Typical Masonry Repair Details

S303GH Typical Concrete Repair Details

S304GH Typical Concrete Details

Architectural

A100 Demolition Plan - Overall

A100a Demolition Floor Plan – Partial Area A

A100b Demolition Floor Plan – Partial Area B

A100c Demolition Floor Plan – Partial Area C

A100d Demolition Floor Plan – Partial Area D

A100e Demolition Floor Plan – Reference Photos

A101 Demolition Roof Plan

A102 Demolition Elevations, Sections, and Details

A201 First Floor Plan

A201a First Floor Plan – Partial Area A

A201b First Floor Plan – Partial Area B

A201c First Floor Plan – Partial Area C

A201d First Floor Plan – Partial Area D

A202 Lean-to and Basement

A203 Roof Plan

A300a First Floor Reflected Ceiling Plan – Partial Area A

A400 Exterior Elevations

A500 Exterior Details

A501 Roof Details

A502 Roof Details

A700 Interior Elevations, Sections and Details

A701 Interior Elevations, Sections and Details

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 01 15 – List of Drawing Sheets

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 01 15 – List of Drawing Sheets - PAGE 2 OF 2

A702 Interior Elevations, Sections and Details

A703 Enlarged RCP, Sections and Details

A820 Interior Details

AF101 First Floor Finish Plan

Plumbing

P001 General Plumbing

P100 Basement Plumbing Plan

P101 First Floor Plumbing Plan

P501 Plumbing Details + Schedules

Mechanical

M001 General Mechanical

M100 Mechanical Basement Plan

M101 Mechanical First Floor

M102 Roof HVAC Plan

M501 Mechanical Details + Schedules

M701 Mechanical Controls

M702 Mechanical Controls

Electrical

E001 General Electrical

E100 Basement Power Plan

E101 First Floor Power Plan

E102 Roof Power Plan

E201 First Floor and Basement Lighting Plans

E501 Electrical Schedules

E601 Greenhouse Oneline

City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse 00 31 00 – Available Project Information

PART D - DETAIL SPECIFICATIONS - SECTION 00 31 00 - Available Project Information - PAGE 1 OF 1

SECTION 00 31 00

AVAILABLE PROJECT INFORMATION

PART 1 GENERAL

1.01 EXISTING CONDITIONS

A. Certain information relating to existing surface and subsurface conditions and structures is available to bidders but will not be part of Contract Documents, as follows:

B. Hazardous Material Survey: Entitled Hazardous Materials Inspection Report, dated June 30, 2023.

1. A Copy of this report is included at the end of this specification section for review.

1.02 PERMITS

A. Owner has obtained the following permits and/or approvals, that are required to be secured prior to commencement of construction work on this project:

1. Zoning Board of Appeals approvals.

2. Planning commission approvals.

3. Historic Preservation commission approvals.

PART 2 PRODUCTS (NOT USED)

PART 3 EXECUTION (NOT USED)

3.01 OBTAINMENT OF PERMITS

A. Contractor to obtain the following required permits, at no cost to Owner:

1. Building Permit for all trades.

B. Building Permit Procedures: When required to obtain this permit:

1. Complete and file permit application(s) with appropriate agency.

2. Pay required fees.

3. Do not commence execution of any item of work for which a permit has not been obtained.

HAZARDOUS MATERIALS INSPECTION REPORT

City of Cleveland

Rockefeller Greenhouse 750 E 88th Street

Cleveland, Ohio 44108

(L&A Project 23-0045)

Prepared for:

Mr. Jonathan Lusin Principal

IKM Architects 1001 Huron Rd East

Suite 102 Cleveland, Ohio 44115

(216)-678-9456

Prepared by:

Lawhon & Associates, Inc.

1441 King Ave

Columbus, Ohio 43212

(614) 481-8600

June 30, 2023

Table of Contents

Section 1.0 Introduction ................................................................................................ Page 1

Section 2.0 Asbestos Containing Materials............................................................ Pages 1 - 2 Section 2.1 Methodology

Section 3.0 Asbestos Containing Material Summaries .......................................... Pages 3 - 6 Section 3.1 Confirmed Asbestos Containing Materials Section 3.2 Presumed Asbestos Containing Materials Section 3.3 Less Than 1% Asbestos

Section 3.4 Non Asbestos Containing Materials

Section 4.0 Other Environmental Hazards .............................................................. Pages 6 - 8

Section 4.1 Lead Based Paint Section 4.2 Lead Solder Joints Section 4.3 Florescent Bulbs & Light Ballasts Section 4.4 Refrigerants Section 4.5 Mercury Section 4.6 Stored Drums/ Oil Staining

Section 5.0 Conclusions ....................................................................................... Pages 8 - 9 Section 5.1 Summary of Results

Schedule of Appendices

A. Inspector‘s Certifications B. Asbestos Bulk Sample Location Diagram C. Inventory of Asbestos Containing Materials D. Asbestos Bulk Sample Summary E. Asbestos Laboratory Analysis Certificates and Chain of Custody F. Lead Paint Laboratory Certificates and Chain of Custody

Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 1 of 9 City of Cleveland- Rockefeller Greenhouse Cleveland, Ohio

Hazardous Materials Inspection Report City of Cleveland- Rockefeller Greenhouse

Cleveland, Ohio 44108

1.0 Introduction

Lawhon & Associates, Inc. (L&A) conducted a hazardous materials inspection at City of Cleveland- Rockefeller Greenhouse, 750 E 88th Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44108. The inspection was conducted on May 2, 2023 by Mr. Jordan Mederer Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) Certified Asbestos Hazard Evaluation Specialist (CAHES) [AHES #ES35005], And Mr. Aris Neace Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) Certified Asbestos Hazard Evaluation Specialist (CAHES) [AHES #ES36144], of L&A.

The consultant’s certifications are attached in Appendix A.

L&A inspected all accessible materials (for the presence of asbestos containing materials) throughout the main greenhouse building, the administration building, nursery and storage buildings (2 each) and garages (2 each). This report should not be utilized as a remediation design or bidding document. This report conforms to the EPA NESHAPs regulations prior to renovation/ demolition for this project.

2.0 Asbestos Containing Material Summaries

Asbestos containing materials are governed by the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) National Emission Standards of Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) during a demolition. These materials are defined as containing greater than one percent asbestos. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) govern building materials containing any amount of asbestos.

The Clean Air Act (CAA) of 1970 required the EPA to develop and enforce regulations to protect the general public from exposure to airborne contaminants that are known to be hazardous to human health; therefore, EPA promulgated the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) (Title 40, CFR Part 61) on April 6, 1973. NESHAP is intended to minimize the release of asbestos fibers during certain activities (i.e., renovations, demolition, and installations). It specifies work practices to be followed during renovations of buildings (except apartment buildings that have no more than four dwelling units), which contain a specific amount of friable asbestos.

NESHAP requires that buildings be inspected for asbestos containing building materials (ACBM) prior to renovation/demolition projects regardless of the age of the structure.

NESHAP also requires owners and operators subject to the asbestos rules to notify delegated state and local agencies and/or the regional EPA offices before demolition or renovation activities begin. In addition, NESHAP requires the removal of all regulated asbestos containing materials (RACM) prior to demolition. Regulated Asbestos- Containing Materials (RACM) are (a) friable asbestos material, which are materials easily reduced to powder with hand pressure (b) Category I non-friable ACM that has become friable, (c) Category I non-friable ACM that will be or has been subjected to sanding, grinding, cutting or abrading, or (d) Category II non-friable ACM that has a high probability of becoming or has become crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by the forces expected to act on the material in the course of demolition or renovation operations. (Category I non-friable materials consist of materials such as resilient floor covering products, roofing products, gaskets, and packing. Category II non-friable materials consist of all other non-friable materials such as transite.). NESHAP also

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 2 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio requires all ACM (including Category I and II) be removed prior to intentional burning, such as for a fire department training exercise.

The Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulates asbestos activities within the state. Professionals performing asbestos related activities must be certified/ licensed by OEPA.

2.1 Methodology

A list of suspect ACMs was compiled from the investigation of the buildings.

Materials were categorized into RACM, Category I, and Category II materials.

L&A inventoried and procured confirmatory samples of suspect asbestos containing materials.

Materials suspected of containing asbestos were grouped into homogeneous areas for bulk sampling purposes. A homogeneous area is composed of specific material that appears to be the same in color, texture, date of installation or location (e.g., grey spray-applied fireproofing in a specific construction unit).

The number of bulk samples to be procured for each identified homogeneous area of suspected Surfacing Materials, Thermal System Insulations, and Miscellaneous Materials were determined in accordance with 40 CFR 763.

Specifically, Friable and Nonfriable Surfacing Materials (i.e., fireproofing, acoustical plaster, decorative plaster, hard plaster, and textured coatings) were sampled following the guidelines set forth by the USEPA in the document “Asbestos in Buildings - Simplified Sampling Scheme Friable Surfacing Materials.” Based upon the square footage of the homogenous surfacing materials, either a minimum of 3, 5, or 7 bulk samples were randomly procured and analyzed. For Thermal System Insulation (TSI), at least 3 random samples of each homogeneous area of TSI were procured and analyzed and 1 sample of patched TSI if it was <6 linear or square feet. For Miscellaneous Materials (MM), at least 2 random samples of each homogeneous area of MM were procured and analyzed.

Bulk sample locations for suspect materials sampled by L&A, and the name and signature and asbestos hazard evaluation specialist number of each person who collected samples are shown on the Asbestos Bulk Sample Diagram found in Appendix B.

Samples were placed into clean sealed containers and identified with a unique sample number. Sampling tools were decontaminated between each sampling episode.

All samples were sent to certified National Voluntary Lab Accredited Program laboratories. The lab utilized for bulk sample Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) analysis for this assessment was SanAir Technologies Laboratories, SATL (NVLAP # 600227-0) located at 11709 Chesterdale Road, Cincinnati, Ohio 45246. Samples were analyzed by the EPA Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) 600 Method. Samples reported with low concentrations of asbestos, < 3% asbestos content, were reanalyzed using the EPA Point Count Method to determine a more accurate content.

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 3 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

3.0 Asbestos Containing Materials Summaries

The following tables present ACM summaries. A site diagram depicting bulk sample locations can be found in Appendix B. An inventory of ACM projected to be impacted or included in the scope of work can be found in Appendix C. A bulk sample summary form summarizing the asbestos bulk samples collected and analyzed is attached in Appendix D. Laboratory analysis certificates and chain of custody information can be found in Appendix E.

3.1 Confirmed Asbestos Containing Materials

The following is a list of materials projected to be impacted by the renovation project confirmed to contain asbestos:

Confirmed Asbestos Containing Material

Main Greenhouse

9”x9” Floor Tile (3) Black Window Glazing Compound (2)

White Window Glazing Compound (2) Grey Window Frame Putty (2)

Transite Planter I (2) Transite Planter II (2)

Admin Building

9”x9” Brown Floor Tile and Associated Black Mastic (3)

9”x9” Black and Green Floor Tile and Associated Black Mastic (3)

Black Wood Panel Mastic (2)

Garage 1

Exterior Window Caulk (2)

Notes: (1) RACM

(2) Category II Non-Friable

(3) Category I Non-Friable

3.2 Assumed Asbestos Containing Materials

As a result of the inspection, no materials are assumed to contain asbestos. All suspect asbestos containing materials projected to be impacted have been sampled, previously sampled, or determined to be homogeneous with other suspect materials sampled in other areas of the building. If suspect materials are uncovered/encountered during renovations that are not listed in the tables above or below, those materials should be assumed to contain asbestos and remain undisturbed until further investigation/testing determines otherwise.

3.3 Materials Containing 1% or Less Asbestos

The following is a list of materials sampled and confirmed to contain 1% or less asbestos by PLM Point Count analysis. These materials are not regulated by EPA; however, will still need properly removed in accordance with OSHA

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 4 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio asbestos standards. EPA notification is not required for abatement of these materials.

Materials Containing 1% or Less Asbestos

Drywall/Joint Compound II

Drywall/ Joint Compound (Cactus Room Only) Wood Door Glazing Compound

Glass Block Interior Window Glazing Compound

EPA regulations do not apply to these materials, however OSHA does regulate <1% asbestos materials. The following are the implications for the contractor:

1. Work practice requirements and prohibitions that must be observed REGARDLESS of the exposure levels and of the percentage of asbestos in the installed construction materials are:

29 CFR 1926.1101(g)(1)(ii), which requires: wet methods, or wetting agents, to control employee exposures during asbestos handling, mixing, removal, cutting, application, and cleanup.

The material should be thoroughly wet at all times during handling, mixing, removal, cutting, application, cleanup and up until it is containerized. This will minimize the potential for exposure through dry dust and fiber release.

29 CFR 1926.1101(g)(1)(iii), which requires: prompt clean-up and disposal of wastes and debris contaminated with asbestos into leak-tight containers.

The Contractor should provide a “leak-tight container.” The trailer is required to be equipped with a bladder bag or lined with polyethylene sheeting which should be taped to seal shut. “Prompt clean-up and disposal” means that asbestos material is to be cleaned up as it is removed and before it dries.

29 CFR 1926.1101(g)(3)(i), which prohibits: high-speed abrasive disc saws that are not equipped with point-of-cut ventilator or enclosures with HEPA filtered exhaust air;

To reduce dry dust and fiber release exposure.

29 CFR 1926.1101(g)(3)(ii), which prohibits: compressed air used to remove asbestos, or materials containing asbestos, unless the compressed air is used in conjunction with an enclosed ventilation system designed to capture the dust cloud created by the compressed air;

To reduce dry dust and fiber release exposure.

29 CFR 1926.1101(g)(3)(iv), which prohibits: employee rotation as a means of reducing employee exposure to asbestos.

Contractor cannot manipulate work shifts as a means of artificially reducing the Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL).

At the start of demolition operations involving materials containing <1% asbestos, a contractor must produce an “Initial Negative Exposure Assessment” in accordance with 29

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 5 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

CFR 1926.1101 (f)(2)(iii)(A-C) to demonstrate that the airborne concentrations of asbestos will not exceed the (PELs).

In order to avoid the need to comply with the elements of the standard that are applicable when either asbestos PEL is exceeded, the contractor conducting the demolition project must produce an initial negative exposure assessment for his/her employees.

There are three potential approaches provided under 29 CFR 1926.1101(f)(2) for producing a negative exposure assessment. These are the use of objective data, previous air monitoring results, or current air monitoring results. If the contractor cannot produce a negative exposure assessment with objective data or previous air monitoring results, then the contractor must conduct asbestos exposure monitoring. Until the contractor is able to produce a negative exposure assessment for his/her employees, the contractor must comply with the elements of the standard that are applicable when either asbestos PEL is exceeded.

2. Disposal: The demolition waste, debris contaminated with less than 1 percent asbestos, in accordance with EPA regulations may go to a C&DD landfill. Each landfill has an internal policy on accepting this waste stream. The Demolition Contractor is responsible for confirming acceptance of this material by their chosen landfill and incorporating associated fees in their bid.

3.4 Non-Asbestos Containing Materials

The following table lists materials sampled with laboratory analysis revealing no asbestos detected. If any additional suspect materials not listed in this table or already confirmed or assumed to contain asbestos, that material must be assumed to contain asbestos until further proves otherwise.

Non-Asbestos Containing Material

Main Greenhouse

Felt Paper associated with Cement Work Bench White Sink Undercoating

Drywall/Joint Compound I Grey Window Caulk

Boiler Rope Gasket Glazing Frame to Brick Caulk

Grey Door Caulk 2’x2’ Textured Ceiling Panel

2’x2’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Large Fissure Black Mastic Associated with 9” Floor Tile

Concrete Planter Coating

Administration Building

Tan Carpet Mastic Drywall/Joint Compound

Interior Window Caulk Interior Window Glazing Compound

Tan Duct Mastic Grey Fire Putty

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 6 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

Non-Asbestos Containing Material

Administration Building (Cont.)

Boiler Chinking 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Large Hole/Large Fissure

2’x4’ Textured Ceiling Panel 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Small Hole

Garage 1

Interior Window Glazing Compound

Nursery/Storage 1

Cardboard Wall Insert

4.0 Other Environmental Hazards

4.1 Lead Based Paint

L&A conducted limited lead-based paint testing of the windows at Putnam Hall. The intent of the testing was to determine if lead-based paint is present on the windows for general compliance with the OSHA Lead in Construction Standard 1926.62 and should not be construed as a full Lead Based Paint Inspection as defined by HUD.

The bulk paint samples were placed into clean, sealed bags and labeled with unique identifiers. The samples were submitted to a laboratory certified under the National Lead Laboratory Accreditation Program (NLLAP). The lab used for lead-based paint sample analysis for this project was SanAir Laboratories (NLLAP #162952) located at 1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139. Laboratory Accreditation Certificates and Lead Based Paint Analysis Chain of Custody information can be found in Appendix F. All Bulk Lead Based Paint samples were analyzed by the Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy (AAS) for total concentration of lead. The regulatory limit for this method of analysis is 0.5% lead by weight, as established by EPA/HUD.

If paint with small quantities of lead is turned into dust from abrasion or other means, lead hazard dust may result. A lead hazard is defined as a “material such as lead-based paint, lead-containing dust, lead-contaminated soil, and lead-contaminated water pipes containing a level of lead at or in excess of the level hazardous to human health as set forth in rule 3701-32-07 of the Administrative Code (HUD Guidelines).”

The table below summarizes bulk samples collected and analyzed for lead-based paint content, reported as percent lead by weight. Samples with results exceeding the regulatory limit of 0.5% lead by weight are listed in bold text below.

Lead-Based Paint Bulk Sample Results

Sample Number Location Component Color Substrate Result % by

Weight LBP-1 Showroom Door/Frame Brown Wood 0.632 LBP-2 Potting Room Brick Wall Tan Brick 0.015

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 7 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

Sample Number Location Component Color Substrate Result % by

Weight LBP-3 Potting Room Pipe Tan Cast Iron <0.008 LBP-4 Storage 1 Brick Tan Brick <0.010 LBP-5 Storage 1 Brick White Brick <0.009 LBP-6 Garage 1 Door Frame Red Metal 0.563 LBP-7 Storage 3 Brick Grey Brick 1.456

OSHA recognizes any amount of lead in paint as a potential hazard, even if reported concentrations are below the regulatory limit. All work procedures impacting or disturbing painted window surfaces needs to be performed by all contractors/ workers in accordance with OSHA Standard 29 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)

1926.62 lead exposure in construction. It is recommended that all contractors that impact painted building materials perform personal air monitoring on their employees to ensure that they are not being exposed to lead above the Action Level (AL) or Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL), or maintain a negative exposure assessment.

4.2 Lead Solder Joints

L&A observed lead solder joints associated with the storm and sanitary piping throughout the buildings. The bulk lead material should be separated from construction demolition and debris waste, containerized and properly recycled, should this piping be demolished as part of the project.

4.3 Florescent Bulbs and Light Ballasts

L&A observed fluorescent light bulbs and associated ballasts throughout the structures. If these are to be impacted by renovation/ demolition activities, they should be removed and recycled because the fluorescent bulbs are assumed to contain mercury, or other potentially hazardous heavy metals. Furthermore, light ballasts potentially contain PCB oils and are normally labeled “Contains No PCBs” if PCBs are not present. All light ballasts will need to be investigated prior to impact from renovation activities. Ballasts not identified with a “Contains No PCBs” label, will need to be disposed of as a regulated hazardous material; ballasts containing a “Contains No PCBs” label should be containerized and recycled. All removal, packaging, and handling of these materials should be performed by a trained contractor. The contractor should remove and package this material and safely transport off-site.

4.4 Refrigerants

L&A observed potential Refrigerant/Freon containing items (such as refrigerators, water fountains, window a/c units, etc.) throughout the structure(s).

Refrigerants/Freon routinely contain chlorofluorocarbons (CFC’s) which are known to deplete Ozone if released into the atmosphere. These items need to have the Freon properly removed and disposed of by a qualified contractor prior to demolition activities.

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 8 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

4.5 Mercury

L&A observed mercury containing thermostats in the Administration Building. These items should be removed prior to renovation/ demolition, safely packaged and transported off-site prior to impact from demolition activities.

4.6 Stored Drums/ Oil Staining

L&A observed four (4) 50-gallon drums in the Garage #2. These drums were labeled as anti-freeze, washer solvent or kerosene/oil. These drums should be removed from the structure prior to impact from demolition activities. Additionally, there is oil staining throughout this structure.

5.0 Conclusions

Lawhon & Associates, Inc. (L&A) conducted a limited hazardous materials inspection at City of Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse. The inspection was conducted on May 2, 2023 by Mr. Jordan Mederer and Mr. Aris Neace.

L&A inspected all accessible materials (for the presence of asbestos containing materials) throughout the renovation areas.

5.1 Summary of Results

As a result of the asbestos containing materials survey the following asbestos containing materials are present and projected to be impacted by the project.

These materials must be removed by an OEPA licensed asbestos abatement contractor prior to impact from renovations:

Main Greenhouse:

• 9”x9” Floor Tile/Black Mastic

• Black Window Glazing

• White Window Glazing

• Grey Window Frame Putty

• Glass Block Interior Window Glazing Compound

• Wood Door Glazing Compound

• Transite Planter I

• Transite Planter II Admin Building

• 9”x9” Brown Floor Tile/Black Mastic

• 9”x9” Black and Green Floor Tile/Black Mastic

• Black Wood Panel Mastic Garage 1

• Window Caulk

Limited Hazardous Materials Inspection Report Page 9 of 9

Cleveland, Ohio

This report should not be utilized as a remediation design or bidding document for either building. This report conforms to the EPA NESHAPs requirements prior to renovation. If you have any questions please contact Jordan Mederer at (614) 481-8600, extension 142.

Sincerely, Jordan Mederer, AHES #35005 Practice Leader, HBM

Aris Neace, AHES #36144 Environmental Technician

APPENDIX A

Inspector’s Certifications hio MIke DeWine, Governor Jon, Husted, Lt. Governor Laurle A. Stevenson, Director

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

7114t2022

Jordan Mederer Lawhon & Associates, lnc.

1441 Kino Avenue ColumbuS, oH 43212

RE: Evaluation Specialist Certification Number: ES35005 Expi ration D ale: 8 I I 12023

Dear Jordan Mederer:

This letter and enclosed certification card approves your request to be certified as an asbestos Evaluation Specialist. You must present voiri card ubon reqiJest at anv proiect site while performing dLties. Copies of cards are not acceptable as pioof of certifibation.

This certification mav be revoked bv the Director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Aoencv (EPA) for violation of any of the requirements of 3745-22 or 3745-20 of the Ohio AdminisTratirie bodei lf you have any questions, please contact the Asbestos Program at 614-644-0226 or by email at as'bestosl icensi nb @epa. ohio.qov.

Sincerely, H Joshua S. Koch Manaqer, Business Operations Support Section Ohio EPA - Division of Air Pollutiori Control

Hazard Evaluation Specialist Asbestos

Jordan Mederer fy:;io Lawhon & Associ{ei'tll"!'9'i (

'r\rrrr rrr 'r\ i*jln:xi1',,;' : i r A;"''

Gertification N-umber Expiration Date

ES35005 --,.- '\,0. P.O. Box 1049. Columbus, OH 43216-1049 epa.ohio.gov . (614) 644-3020. (614) 644-3184 (fax) not Vahd rf Altered

Fnvtronrnental P Asbestos Program rotectton AgencY qa

\--n ffitrio l}i Ohio Hnvironmenral

Protection Agency

Mike DeWine, Governor Jon Husted, Lt. Governor Anne M. Vogel, Director

Michael Neace Lawhon & Associates, lnc.

1441 King Avenue Columbus, OH 43212

RE: Evaluation Soecialist Certification Number: ES36'l 44 Expiration D ale: 3124 I 2024

Dear Michael Neace:

This letter and enclosed certification card approves your request to be certified as an asbestos Evaluation Soecialrst. You must oresent vour card uoon reouest at anv proiect site while performing di.rties. Copies of cards are not acceptable as pioof of certlfibation.

This certification may be revoked by the Director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for violation of any of the requirements of 3745-22 or 3745-20 of the Ohio Adminisirativ'e Code.

lf you have any questions, please contact the Asbestos Program at614-644-0226 or by email at asbestoslicensinq@epa.ohio.qov.

212212023

Sincerely, F oanla* W.. Sct/r*".t/*t*a.* Brandon Schwendeman Manaoer. Business Ooerations Suooort Section ohio EPA - Division of Air Pollution Control

Hazard Evalu ation SpecialistMichael Neace

Lawhon & 1441 King Colu mbus

Certification Nu

Es36144 tt"""";ffi oH $212 i

IO

mber Expiration Date 3/24/24

50 West Town Street. Suite r00 . P,O. Box 1049 . Columbus, OH 43216-1049 epa.ohio.gov . (614) 644-3020 . (614) 644-3184 (fax)

Agency

APPENDIX B

Asbestos Bulk Sample Location Diagram c) c9

. E" i F!

I

I h!

: FF

ht l l

!EE

:-l h

F*

I *F i'it

I

.le

I

I

1n72A23952t7^M Add:6ktucs/22Sr c4arCpebdRocbr&rC'*Dbu*_Re2$2_cryorkdandR'ckeretb.centuGe_stlEPLAN_R21M ffi ;to,tn lr

IP

l@ lm

IP

B

IF

l,= lr l5 lo lrt!

IE

o-g,) i..)

R so wG c' A i\(:

rtl ro le

.b b o l(̂' Fl

H o qo F vb L

'Tl t5 aF.

w

,,-a.:

0..

a

?L w t-o I orL qt[<m o

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

22-062 City o{ Cleveland Rockefeller Greenhouse

ENLARGED PLANS @

4n7no2395157^M Add€ikkD2S2 CqorCkehdRockreb'Grft^MuF R2U2S2 Cdor*vdaidRo*.i.k,&eihde S|TEPUN R23.M

9F

P iEE n ri q

D l.o ''l ll"',1 -11 - O i 22-062 CityofClevelandRockefellerGreenhouse

I l:a o liqt ] ,"**n=o

"ro*.

NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

a km etno*952514u Audesk66/22s2_olorcBebndRMkedbrc'€nbu*-R23D2s2_cryor*ydddR{kerek'cG.ho@_strEpN_R23M ffi .E.lc .la ls

It lci la l> lo lm td t<lm l4 til-

F l8 lvtt

IE

tz rE

N

E a a

D :ol rl:vl ol t l,-nl F |tqrl

22-062 Cityof cleveland RockefellerGreenhouse

ENLARGED PLANSNOT FOR CONSTRUCTION

'g

O

APPENDIX C

Inventory of Asbestos Containing Materials

IN

VE

N

TO

RY

O F

A

SB

ES

TO

S C

O

NT

A

IN

IN

G

M A

TE

R

IA

LS

C ity o f C le ve la nd

R oc ke fe lle r G re en ho us e ke fe lle r G re en ho us e C ity o f C le ve

A pp en di x

In ve nt or y of

A C

M s

Lo ca tio ns ro xi m at e

Q ua nt

EP

N

ES

H

A P

C la ss ifi ca tio n om m en ts ai n G re en ho us e B ui ld in g

9” x9

” F lo or T ile (B la ck

M as tic D oe s

N ot on ta in A sb es to s)

Br ea kr oo m

, R ea r O ce sq ua re fe et at eg or y I

W in do w s/ G la zi ng P an es w ith

A C

M B ck po un d an d/ or W hi te

C om po un d an d G re y

Fr am e Pu tty

Th ro ug ho ut A ll G re en ho us e Ar ea s

(E xc lu de s Fr on t

Lo bb y Ar ea a nd R ea r P ot tin g R oo m

/ B re ak R oo m

Ar ea s)

,2 s qu ar e

(e st im at ed s f o f m at er ia l p er p an e) eg or y

II

(p lia bl e, co ul d be tr ea te d as eg or y

I f or d em o)

Tr an si te

P la nt er

I D is pl ay H ou se

B

(W es t n ea r d oo r t o

Po tte ry R oo m s qu ar e eg or y

II

Tr an si te

P la nt er

II

D is pl ay

H ou se

A, A, B, A, B, C a nd L ea n-to

4, sq ua re eg or y

II

G la ss B lo ck

In te rio r W in do w G la zi ng po un d Br ea k

R oo m , R ea r O w in do w s (7 s qu ar e fe et

<1

, O

SH

A

O nl y

W oo d D oo r G la zi ng C om po un d

D oo r F ro m P ot te ry R oo m to D is pl ay H ou se

B ea ch (1 s qu ar e fo ot

<1

, O

SH

A

O nl y

D ry w al l/ Jo in t C om po un d

C ac tu s

R oo m (W es t W al l) sq ua re

<1

, O

SH

A O nl y

A dm in is tr at io n

B ui ld in g

9” x9

” F lo or T ile s

(B ro w n, B la ck a

G re en ) a nd A ss oc ia te d Bl ac k

M tic

Ex po se d-

O ffi ce

E nt ry , S ta ir

La nd in g, O ffi ce

M ec ha ni ca l R oo m , S to ra ge b y

O ffi

Be ne at h

” V

C T-

O ffi ce

, T oi le t, To ile t E ry at h

C ar pe t-

O ffi ce

, O ffi at h

C as ew or k- O ffi tic O nl y

Be ne at h

Sk im

C oa t- O ffi sq ua re sq ua re sq ua re qu ar e sq ua re eg or y I

(R

AC

M in

M ec ha ni ca l

R oo m w he re it da m ag ed

IN

VE

N

TO

RY

O F

A

SB

ES

TO

S C

O

NT

A

IN

IN

G

M A

TE

R

IA

LS

o f C le ve ke fe lle r G re en ho us e ke fe lle r G re en ho us e C ity o f C le ve en di x

In ve nt or y of

A C

Lo ca tio ns ro xi m at e

Q ua

EP

N

ES

H

A P

C la ss ifi ca tio n m en ts

Bl ac k W oo d

Pa ne l M tic

Ex po se d-

O ffi

Pr es um ed

B en ea th

W oo d Pa ne lin g- O ffi ce s an d sq ua re sq ua re eg or y

II

G ar ag e

Ex te rio r W in do w C au lk

G ar ag e w in do w s

(1 sq ua re

C at eg or y

II

Ex te rio r

Tr an si te

P la nt er s Be tw ee n G ar ag e an d

N ur se ry

S to ra ge sq ua re fe et sf of d eb ris o n gr ou in va rio us p la

AC

M (s ig ni fic an t da m ag e an d de br

APPENDIX D

Asbestos Bulk Sample Summary

ASBESTOS BULK SAMPLE SUMMARY

City of Cleveland - Rockefeller Greenhouse

Bold text denotes an Asbestos Containing Material; as defined by EPA and OSHA

Italic Text denotes an Material Containing Less than 1% Asbestos; for OSHA

Legend Abbreviation: Definition: Abbreviation: Definition:

NAD No Asbestos Detected PC Point Count Method Performed

City of Cleveland Appendix D

Sample Number

Hom.

Area #

Material Sampled Sample Location Percent Asbestos

Main Greenhouse

1a 1b

1a 1b

9”x9” Floor Tile Black Mastic

Break Room 5% Chrysotile

NAD

2a 2b

1a 1b

9”x9” Floor Tile Black Mastic

Break Room 5% Chrysotile

NAD

3 2 Felt Paper associated with Cement Work Bench

Potting Room NAD

4 2 Felt Paper associated with Cement Work Bench

Potting Room NAD

5 3 White Sink Undercoating Kitchen NAD

6 3 White Sink Undercoating Kitchen NAD

7a

7b

4a

4b

Drywall I

Joint Compound I Lobby

NAD

NAD

8a

8b

4a

4b

Drywall I

Joint Compound I Lobby

NAD

NAD

9a

9b

5a

5b

Drywall II

Joint Compound II Cactus Room

NAD

0.75% Chrysotile (PC)

10a

10b

5a

5b

Drywall II

Joint Compound II Cactus Room

NAD

0.5% Chrysotile (PC)

11 6 Black Window Glazing Compound Tropical Showhouse 5% Chrysotile

12 6 Black Window Glazing Compound Tropical Showhouse 5% Chrysotile

13 7 White Window Glazing Compound Tropical Showhouse 8% Chrysotile

14 7 White Window Glazing Compound Tropical Showhouse 8% Chrysotile

15 8 Grey Window Frame Putty Tropical Showhouse 5% Chrysotile

Legend

Hom.

Area #

Material Sampled Sample Location Percent Asbestos

16 8 Grey Window Frame Putty Tropical Showhouse 5% Chrysotile

17 9 Grey Window Caulk Tropical Showhouse NAD

18 9 Grey Window Caulk Tropical Showhouse NAD

19 10 Glazing Frame to Brick Caulk Main Show Room NAD

20 10 Glazing Frame to Brick Caulk Main Show Room NAD

21 11 Glass Block Interior Window Glazing Compound Break Room 0.25% Chrysotile (PC)

22 11 Glass Block Interior Window Glazing Compound Break Room 0.25% Chrysotile (PC)

23 12 Grey Door Caulk Potting Room NAD

24 12 Grey Door Caulk Potting Room NAD

25 13 Wood Door Glazing Compound Show Room 0.75% Chrysotile (PC)

26 13 Wood Door Glazing Compound Show Room 0.5% Chrysotile (PC)

27 14 Transite Planter I 2B 15% Chrysotile

28 14 Transite Planter I 2B 15% Chrysotile

29 15 Transite Planter II 8A 10% Chrysotile

30 15 Transite Planter II 8A 10% Chrysotile

31 16 Boiler Rope Gasket Mech Room NAD

32 16 Boiler Rope Gasket Mech Room NAD

33 17 2’x2’ Textured Ceiling Panel Lobby NAD

34 17 2’x2’ Textured Ceiling Panel Lobby NAD

Legend

Hom.

Area #

Material Sampled Sample Location Percent Asbestos

35 18 2’x2’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Large Fissure Office NAD

36 18 2’x2’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Large Fissure Office NAD

37 19 Concrete Planter Coating 2B NAD

38 19 Concrete Planter Coating 2B NAD

39 19 Concrete Planter Coating 1B NAD

40 19 Concrete Planter Coating 1B NAD

41 19 Concrete Planter Coating 2B NAD

Administration Building

42a 42b

20a 20b

9”x9” Brown Floor Tile Black Mastic

Mechanical Room 7% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

43a 43b

20a 20b

9”x9” Brown Floor Tile Black Mastic

Mechanical Room 7% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

44a 44b

21a 21b

9”x9” Black and Green Floor Tile Black Mastic

Office 5 3% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

45a 45b

21a 21b

9”x9” Black and Green Floor Tile Black Mastic

Office 5 5% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

46 22 Tan Carpet Mastic 2nd Floor NAD

47 22 Tan Carpet Mastic 2nd Floor NAD

48a

48b

23a

23b

Drywall

Joint Compound Office 1

NAD

NAD

49a

49b

23a

23b

Drywall

Joint Compound Office 1

NAD

NAD

Legend

Hom.

Area #

Material Sampled Sample Location Percent Asbestos

50a

50b

23a

23b

Drywall

Joint Compound Office 2

NAD

NAD

51 24 Interior Window Caulk 2nd Floor NAD

52 24 Interior Window Caulk 2nd Floor NAD

53 25 Interior Window Glazing Compound Vestibule NAD

54 25 Interior Window Glazing Compound Vestibule NAD

55 26 Tan Duct Mastic Mech Room NAD

56 26 Tan Duct Mastic Mech Room NAD

57 27 Black Wood Panel Mastic Office 5 8% Chrysotile

58 27 Black Wood Panel Mastic Office 5 8% Chrysotile

59 28 Grey Fire Putty Mens Locker Room NAD

60 28 Grey Fire Putty Mens Locker Room NAD

61 29 Boiler Chinking Mech Room NAD

62 29 Boiler Chinking Mech Room NAD

63 30 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Large Hole/Large Fissure

Office 5 NAD

64 30 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Large Hole/Large Fissure

Office 4 NAD

65 31 2’x4’ Textured Ceiling Panel Office 3 NAD

66 31 2’x4’ Textured Ceiling Panel Office 3 NAD

67 32 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Small Hole Office 2 NAD

Legend

Hom.

Area #

Material Sampled Sample Location Percent Asbestos

68 32 2’x4’ Ceiling Panel – Pin Hole/Small Hole Office 2 NAD

Garage 1

69 33 Interior Window Glazing Compound Garage 1 NAD

70 33 Interior Window Glazing Compound Garage 1 NAD

71 34 Window Caulk Garage 1 5% Chrysotile

72 34 Window Caulk Garage 1 5% Chrysotile

Nursery & Storage 1

73 35 Cardboard Wall Insert Nursery/Storage 1 NAD

74 35 Cardboard Wall Insert Nursery/Storage 1 NAD

APPENDIX E

Asbestos Laboratory Analysis Certificates

Chain of Custody

SanAir ID#: 23024555

Project #: 23-0045 Project Name: IKM Rockefeller Greenhouse Report Date: 5/11/2023

Analysis Report prepared for

Dear Jordan Mederer, We at SanAir would like to thank you for the work you recently submitted. The 76 sample(s) were received on Thursday, May 04, 2023 via UPS. The final report(s) is enclosed for the following sample(s): 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 9, 10, 21, 22, 25, 26.

These results only pertain to this job and should not be used in the interpretation of any other job. This report is only complete in its entirety. Refer to the listing below of the pages included in a complete final report.

Sincerely, Sandra Sobrino Asbestos & Materials Laboratory Manager SanAir Technologies Laboratory

Final Report Includes:

- Cover Letter

- Analysis Pages

- Disclaimers and Additional Information

Sample conditions:

- 80 samples in Good condition.

10501 Trade Ct., N. Chesterfield, VA 23236 | 804.897.1177 | Fax: 804.897.0070 | www.SanAir.com | IAQ@SanAir.com

23-0045Project Number:

P.O. Number:

Project Name: IKM Rockefeller Greenhouse

5/2/2023Collected Date:

5/4/2023 10:15:00 AMReceived Date:

5/11/2023 9:57:34 AM

23024555 SanAir ID Number

FINAL REPORT

Lawhon & Associates, Inc.Name:

Address: 1441 King Ave

Columbus, OH 43212

614-481-8600 ext. 142Phone:

Analyst: Mayes, Jean | Pisula, Nicholas | Hogrefe, Sarah | Drakes, Renaldo

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116 Stereoscopic Components

SanAir ID / Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-fibrous Asbestos Fibers 1 / 23024555-001 9"x9" Floor Tile/ Mastic, Break Room Main Greenhouse, Floor Tile

Brown Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

95% Other 5% Chrysotile

1 / 23024555-001 9"x9" Floor Tile/ Mastic, Break Room Main Greenhouse, Mastic

Black Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

100% Other None Detected

2 / 23024555-002 9"x9" Floor Tile/ Mastic, Break Room Main Greenhouse, Floor Tile

Brown Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

95% Other 5% Chrysotile

2 / 23024555-002 9"x9" Floor Tile/ Mastic, Break Room Main Greenhouse, Mastic

Black Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

100% Other None Detected

3 / 23024555-003 Felt Paper A/ W Cement Work Bench, Potting Room

Black Fibrous

Homogeneous

60% Cellulose 40% Other None Detected

4 / 23024555-004 Felt Paper A/ W Cement Work Bench, Potting Room

Black Fibrous

Homogeneous

60% Cellulose 40% Other None Detected

5 / 23024555-005 Sink Undercoating, Kitchen Main Greenhouse

White Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

100% Other None Detected

6 / 23024555-006 Sink Undercoating, Kitchen Main Greenhouse

White Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

100% Other None Detected

7 / 23024555-007 Drywall I/ Joint Compound I, Lobby Main Greenhouse, Drywall

Grey Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

5% Cellulose 95% Other None Detected

7 / 23024555-007 Drywall I/ Joint Compound I, Lobby Main Greenhouse, Joint Compound

White Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

100% Other None Detected

Analyst:

Analysis Date: 5/11/2023 Date: 5/11/2023

Approved Signatory:

23-0045Project Number:

P.O. Number:

Project Name: IKM Rockefeller Greenhouse

5/2/2023Collected Date:

5/4/2023 10:15:00 AMReceived Date:

5/11/2023 9:57:34 AM

23024555 SanAir ID…