Appendix_C_-_Sustainability_Checklists_and_References.pdf

Air Force Sustainability Requirements Scoresheet HPSB COMPLIANCE (Updated Jan 2017) * required entry

General Information ABCD Project ID (e.g. ABCD12345) 123456789012345678 Real Property Unique ID (RPUID) Bldg 1810 Facility Number KC46A Two Bay General Purpose MX Hangar

Building Name

Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst Installation Trenton City NJ State Yes CONUS

AMC MAJCOM

USACE Construction Agent Turek, Rafal AFCEC DM/CM (Last Name, First Name)

$72,000,000.00 PA

90,437 Building Size (SF) 2019 Program Year (FY####) 95% Design Project Phase 10/30/17 Design Started (MM/DD/YY)

01/09/18 BOD (MM/DD/YY)

GBI GP Guiding Principles Compliance Certification Method

100% HPSB Compliant 49% Energy Efficiency Achieved (% below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA

Standard 90.1-2013) 2017V1 Scoresheet version

Federal Requirements

Complete

7/15/2018 Date Project Registered (MM/DD/YY)

Date Project Certified (MM/DD/YY)

10/19/2018 1

Color Coding: See Instructions Tab for more detail Yes or N/A No Recommended not Required

90.1-2013 HPSB I: Employ Integrated Design Principles (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-2) Total Points 2 Possible Points 2

Yes HPSB I.1 Integrated Design 1 Yes HPSB I.2 Commissioning 1

HPSB II: Optimize Energy Performance (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-3) Total Points 5 Possible Points 5

Yes HPSB II.1 Energy Efficiency 1

Yes Reduce energy use 30% below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-2013 or IECC, or if not - achieve maximum energy efficiency that is lifecycle cost effective

49.3% Insert percentage below ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1-2013 or IECC, in terms of energy use (e.g. 32)

22.102 Insert building energy intensity (kBtu/yr-sqft) calculated IAW 10 CFR

Yes Roof Attributes (Recommended) 1 Select roof types (Check below)

Energy Efficient Products 1 Yes

N/A HPSB II.2 On-site Renewable Energy 1

N/A Installed renewable energy elements or projects were not lifecycle cost effective Renewable energy types (check below)

0.0 Insert generation capacity (kW)

0.0% Insert percentage of total building

N/A HPSB II.3 On-site Renewable Energy - Solar Hot Water Heater System 1

N/A Installed solar hot water heater system or found installation not lifecycle cost effective

0.0 Insert generation capacity (MMBtu/yr)

0.0% Insert percentage of demand

Yes HPSB II.4 Metering 1 Yes Electric Metering: Select N/A if no service Yes Natural Gas Metering: Select N/A if no service N/A Steam Metering: Select N/A if no service

HPSB III: Protect and Conserve Water (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-4) Total Points 6 Possible Points 6

Yes HPSB III.1 Indoor Water 1 Yes Indoor Water Metering 1 N/A HPSB III.2 Outdoor Water 1 N/A Outdoor Water Metering 1 N/A HPSB III.3 Alternative Water 1 N/A HPSB III.4 Stormwater Management (LID Documentation per UFC 3-210-10) 1

0.0 Change in Impervious Area (SF)

$0.00 Pre-Award Cost Estimate ($)

N/A Project addressed EISA 438 EISA Technical Constraints

0.0%

Percent Increase in Stormwater Runoff for 95 Percentile Storm (%) -or- Percent Increase in Stormwater Runoff from continuous simulation model, published data, studies, or other established tools (Reference UFC 3-210-10 Figure 2-1 Implementation of EISA Section 438)

Off-Site LID Features Locations 0 Integrated Management Practices Employed

Drop-Down Box No Entry Required Custom Entry

Solar PV

Solar CP

Solar Thermal Electric

Geothermal

GSHP Wind

Hydro Waste to Energy

Renewables were not lifecycle cost effective

Cool roof

Green roof

Solar electric

Solar thermal

Solar Passive

Retaining stormwater impact receving water flow

Site too small to infiltrate significant volume

State or local restrict water harvesting

Shallow bedrock, contaminated soil, high ground water table, underground utilities

Non-potable water demand to small Structural, plumbing, and other mods not feasible

Soil infiltration capacity limited

State or local restrict use of green Other

10/19/2018 2

$0.00 Final LID Construction Cost ($) 0 Post Construction Analysis (Name of DOR)

HPSB IV: Enhance Indoor Environmental Quality (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-5) Total Points 8 Possible Points 8

Yes HPSB IV.1 Thermal Comfort 1 Yes HPSB IV.2 Ventilation 1 Yes HPSB IV.3 Daylighting 1 Yes HPSB IV.4 1 Yes HPSB IV.5 Low Emitting Materials 1 Yes HPSB IV.6 Protect Indoor Air Quality during Construction 1 Yes HPSB IV.7 Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control 1 Yes HPSB IV.8 Occupant Health and Wellness 1

HPSB V: Reduce Environmental Impact of Materials (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-6) Total Points 5 Possible Points 5

Yes HPSB V.1 Recycled Content 1 Yes HPSB V.2 Biologically-based Products 1 Yes HPSB V.3 Ozone Depleting Substances 1 Yes HPSB V.4 Waste and Materials Management - Recycling 1 Yes HPSB V.5 Waste and Materials Management - Divert 60% from Disposal 1

Yes 60% or greater diverted 60.0% Insert percentage diverted from landfill

HPSB VI: Address Climate Change Risk (UFC 1-200-02 para 2-7) Total Points 1 Possible Points 1

Yes HPSB VI.1 Address Climate Change Risk 1 Possible Points 27

27 Federal Requirements - Yes or N/A 0 Federal Requirements - No

100% Percentage of Federal Requirements Met

Moisture Control

Bio-Retention

Infiltration Trench

Soil Amendments

Dry Wells Inlet Pollution Removal Device

Permeable Pavement/Pavers

Filter Strips Grassed Swells

Rain Barrels/Cisterns

Tree Box Filters Vegetated Buffers Vegetated Roof

Other

10/19/2018 3

Federal Requirements for High Performance and Sustainable Buildings (HPSB) & UFC 1-200-02 Instructions: Provide a common or project specific justification for an element to be non-applicable, when completed, the Scoresheet tab will allow an N/A response.

Justification for Non-Applicable Answers Common Justification Project Specific Justification Complete?

HPSB I: Employ Integrated Design Principles (UFC 1-200-02, 2-2) HPSB I.1 Integrated Design Applicable HPSB I.2 Commissioning Applicable HPSB II: Optimize Energy Performance (UFC 1-200-02, 2-3) HPSB II.1 Energy Efficiency Applicable HPSB II.1 Energy Efficient Products Applicable HPSB II.2 On-site Renewable Energy NA LCCE Yes HPSB II.3 On-site Renewable Energy - Solar Hot Water Heater System NA LCCE Yes HPSB II.4 Metering HPSB II.4 Electric Metering: Select N/A if no service Applicable HPSB II.4 Natural Gas Metering: Select N/A if no service Applicable HPSB II.4 Steam Metering: Select N/A if no service NA Mission Restriction No service Yes HPSB III: Protect and Conserve Water (UFC 1-200-02, 2-4) HPSB III.1 Indoor Water Applicable HPSB III.1 Indoor Water Metering: Select N/A if no service Applicable HPSB III.2 Outdoor Water NA No permanent irrigation Yes HPSB III.2 Outdoor Water Metering: Select N/A if no service NA No permanent irrigation Yes

HPSB III.3 Alternative Water NA No alternative water source used on the project

Yes

HPSB III.4 Stormwater Management

HPSB III.4 Project addressed EISA 438 Mission Restriction Infiltration facility is a Bird/Aircraft Strike Hazard(BASH) concern for JBMDL and the users.

Yes

HPSB IV: Enhance Indoor Environmental Quality (UFC 1-200-02, 2-5) HPSB IV.1 Thermal Comfort Applicable HPSB IV.2 Ventilation Applicable HPSB IV.3 Daylighting Applicable HPSB IV.4 Moisture Control Applicable HPSB IV.5 Low Emitting Materials Applicable HPSB IV.6 Protect Indoor Air Quality during Construction Applicable HPSB IV.8 Occupant Health and Wellness Applicable HPSB V: Reduce Environmental Impact of Materials (UFC 1-200-02, 2-6) HPSB V.1 Recycled Content Applicable HPSB V.2 Biologically based products Applicable HPSB V.3 Ozone Depleting Substances Applicable HPSB V.4 Waste and Materials Management - Recycling Applicable HPSB V.5 Waste and Materials Management - Divert 60% from Disposal Applicable HPSB VI: Adress Climate Change Riskd (UFC 1-200-02, 2-7)

HPSB VI.1 Address Climate Change Risk Applicable

2016 UFC‐GPC NC DoD Scoping Checklist © 2016‐2017 GREEN BUILDING INITIATIVE, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

2016 Guiding Principles Compliance for New Construction

Department of Defense (GPC NC DoD) Scoping Checklist

Instructions

The GPC NC DoD Scoping Checklist is for use during the planning stage to identify all goals for the project, as relate to meeting the Federal Guiding

Principles (via compliance with UFC 1‐200‐02 "High Performance and Sustainable Building Requirements"), and to define requirements for the project. After identifying elements that are not applicable to the project (see Answer Selections below), the remaining elements must all be met.

This DOD review is in alignment with UFC 1‐200‐02 for the purposes of this validation. "Guiding Principles" are met when the requirements of UFC 1‐

200‐02 are met.

Answer Selections:

"Yes" means an element will be fully achieved, or highest resource efficiency achieved, with LCCA supporting documentation.

"Not Applicable" ("N/A") is to be used only when:

Mission precludes the element (e.g. facility mission prohibits the use of windows);

Location of installation restricts or precludes achievement of element (e.g. there is no local recycling);

Location conditions mean that the element is not part of the project (e.g. there is no meter for steam because there is no steam); or

LCCA does not support any compliance with this requirement.

Justification must be provided during third‐party assessment for each element marked "N/A", and for any LCCA supporting partial or no compliance to a requirement.

Unless otherwise noted, all line items must be indicated. If a choice has not been selected, include a note. The project's achievement from third‐ party assessment will not be negatively impacted as a result of indicating "N/A," or where LCCA supports partial or no compliance to a requirement.

The intent is for the project team to determine during the planning stage if any of the Guiding Principles (UFC 1‐200‐02 requirements) are not applicable, and that the remaining requirements must be fully met (with LCCA).

UFC Applicability

UFC 1‐200‐02, revised December 1st, 2016, is effective for the following projects:

• Design‐Bid‐Build projects that have not proceeded beyond 35% design completion as of 12/01/2016

• Design‐Build projects that have not proceeded beyond date of RFP issuance as of 12/01/2016. When an RFP is issued in multiple phases or steps, use the date of the last phase of the RFP issuance.

Projects that have a delay ‐ either planned or unintentional ‐ of more than 18 months between design completion and the solicitation of offers for construction must be re‐evaluated to determine if any design revision is necessary due to changes in criteria (including codes and standards) or site infrastructure (e.g. water supply for fire department vehicle access).

Any new building or modernization where the above is applicable must meet the following:

• UFC 1‐200‐02 High Performance and Sustainable Buildings Requirements (December 01 2016)

• UFC 3‐530‐01 Interior & Exterior Lighting Systems and Controls, With Change 3 (Change/Revision Date: June 01 2016)

NOTE: The evaluation must also include retroactive requirements that have been included in the new editions of the criteria.

Notes and Justification i.a LCCA Format

Yes KC46 A LCCA and Energy Summary

Notes and Justification

1.a Sustainable Locations

Yes 90% Design Analysis, Chapter III‐Site Development

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.1.3 Evaluation of the Site Yes 90% Design Analysis, Chapter III‐Site Development

Yes Drawings and Specifications, 90% Design Analysis, Chapter III‐

1.b Integrated Design

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.1 Integrated Design Yes VE Final Report

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.1.1 Integrated Planning Yes VE Final Report

Yes Narrative from lead architect, mech and elec eng

1.c Commissioning

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.2 Commissioning Yes Drawings and Specifications= Spec 0191 00.15‐ Total Building

Notes and Justification 2.a Energy Efficiency

Commercial & Multi‐Family

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.1.1 Commercial and Multi‐

Family High‐Rise Residential Buildings

Yes Energy Performance‐ KC46A Federal Energy Summary

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.1.2 Low‐Rise Residential

Buildings

Not Applicable

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.1.3 Renovations Not Applicable

Yes KC‐46 Hangar Specs‐ 01 33 29, 1.6.2‐Energy Efficient Products

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.1.5 Standby Powered Devices Yes

Yes

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.3.1 ECA Requirements Yes

2.b Renewable and Clean Energy

Yes Drop box‐ Life Cycle Cost analysis. KC 46 A LCCA and Energy Su

Yes KC 46 A LCCA and Energy Summary

2.c Metering

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.4 Metering Yes AMRS Meter Specifications‐ 2.0 Electric meters. Need to iden

Notes and Justification 3.a Indoor Water Use

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.1 Indoor Water Yes DA‐2‐Plumbing/9. Plumbing Fixtures. P‐601.fixture schedule

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.1.1 Indoor Water Metering Yes AMRS Meter Specifications‐3.0 Water, Gas and Steam. Need

3.b Outdoor Water Use

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.2.1 Water for Landscaping Yes No permanent irrgation installed for outdoor water use.

Not Applicable No permanent irrigation on project.

3.c Alternative Water

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.3 Alternative Water Not Applicable

3.d Stormwater Management

Not Applicable METF Narrative.

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.3 Energy Compliance Analysis

(ECA)

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.2.1 Solar Domestic Hot Water

(SDHW)

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.1.2 Evaluation for Design

Strategies

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐2.1.4 Site Integration and Design of the Building

3. Protect and Conserve Water

2. Optimize Energy Performance

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.3.1 Stormwater Management

i. Life‐Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA)

UFC 1‐200‐02, 1‐7 Life‐Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA)

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐4.2.2 Outdoor Water Metering

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.2 On‐Site Renewable Ennergy

Building Type ‐ Select the building type most applicable to your project.

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.1.4 Energy Efficient Products

1. Employ Integrated Design Principles

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐3.3.2 Narrative Requirements

Notes and Justification 4.a Ventilation and Thermal Comfort

Yes IEQ‐Mech Calcs 62.1, Thermal Comfort Narrative.

4.b Daylighting and Lighting Controls

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.2 Daylighting Not Applicable Daylighting Narrative

Yes Spec 265100‐ Did not find 265600‐Drawings and Specs, Electr

4.c Indoor Air Quality

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.3.1 Moisture Control Yes On site absorptive materials to be protected. Materials that sh

Yes Meet ASHRAE 189.1‐2014 8.4.2‐Materials requirements for VO

Yes Spec 013329‐ 1.6.5. IAQ during Construction

Yes No smoking policy and signage

4.d Occupant Health and Wellness

Yes IEQ‐Occupant health and wellness narrative.

Notes and Justification 5.a Material Content and Performance

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐6.1.1 Recycled Content Yes 01 33 29‐ 1.6.6

Yes 01 33 29‐ 1.6.7

Yes 01 33 29‐ 1.6.8

5.b Waste Diversion and Materials Management

Yes Architectural drawing‐ IF‐101, A6 identifies recycling bins.

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐6.2.2 Waste Diversion Yes Spec 017419‐ 60% waste diversion identified.

Notes and Justification 6.a Address Climate Change Risks

Yes

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐6.2.1 Storage and Collection of

Recyclables

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.4 Occupant Health and Wellness

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐6.1.4 Ozone Depleting Substances

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐6.1.2 Biologically‐Based Products

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.3.2 Reduce Volatile Organic

Compounds (VOC) (Low‐Emitting Materials)

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.3.4 Environmental Tobacco

Smoke Control

6. Assess and Consider Climate Change Risks

5. Reduce the Environmental Impact of Materials

4. Enhance Indoor Environmental Quality

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.3.3 Protect Indoor Air Quality

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐7 Address Climate Change Risks

UFC 3‐530‐01 Interior & Exterior Lighting Systems and Controls

UFC 1‐200‐02, 2‐5.1 Ventilation and Thermal

Comfort

PROVIDED "AS IS" ; DISCLAIMER:

THIS MATERIAL AND ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS PROVIDED TO ALL RECIPIENTS ON AN “AS IS” BASIS. TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY

APPLICABLE LAW, GREEN BUILDING INITIATIVE (ALONG WITH ALL CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS MATERIAL) HEREBY DISCLAIM ALL REPRESENTATIONS, WARRANTIES AND/OR

COVENANTS, EITHER EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY OR AT COMMON LAW, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, TITLE, VALIDITY, AND/OR NON‐INFRINGEMENT.

This Material is provided to you ("You" or "Recipient") by Green Building Initiative only for your use in association with only a proposed or active U.S. Department of

Defense (DoD) new construction or modernization project which seeks to be in compliance with the Federal Guiding Principles (UFC 1‐200‐02 requirements) (the "Scope of Use"). The Material may only be used for and within this Scope of Use.

Without limiting the foregoing, Recipients of this Material are explicitly prohibited from doing the following (without first obtaining Green Building Initiative's prior written consent):

(i) revising, altering, modifying, making derivatives of, or otherwise amending this Material in any way;

(ii) removing, altering, covering or obscuring this Legal Notice or any other copyright notices or other proprietary rights notices that are contained or embedded in this Material (the "Existing Notices") or insert any other copyright or proprietary notices that are inconsistent with the Existing Notices; or

(iii) using this Material for any purpose that is not within (or violates the parameters of) the Scope of Use (as set forth above)

Unauthorized use of this Material is strictly prohibited, is a violation of copyright and other intellectual property rights, and is actionable under law.

Recipient is permitted to make references to, or to cite, this Material provided the Recipient fully acknowledges Green Building Initiative's copyright ownership of this

Material and gives Green Building Initiative full copyright attribution. The proper copyright notice for this Material is as follows: "©2016‐2017 Green Building Initiative, Inc. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED."

The Green Building Initiative®, the Green Building Initiative logo® and Green Building Initiative Guiding Principles Compliance GPC logoTM (among others) are trademarks, service marks and/or trade names (collectively “Marks”) owned by Green Building Initiative and all rights are reserved therein.

Recipient acknowledges and agrees that Green Building Initiative is the sole and exclusive owner of all rights, title and interest in and to this Material and all Marks.

Absent a separate contract between each Recipient and Green Building Initiative, nothing in this document grants (either expressly or impliedly) to any Recipient of this

Material any right or license in the Material, in any information or other contents in this Material, or to any other intellectual property owned or controlled by the Green

Building Initiative (including, without limitation, any of the Marks).

CONDITIONS OF USE:

This "2016 Guiding Principles Compliance for New Construction Department of Defense (GPC NC DoD) Scoping Checklist" ("Material") is proprietary to Green Building

Initiative, Inc. ("Green Building Initiative") and/or its successors and assigns.

NEXT STEPS

LEGAL NOTICE

Third‐Party Guiding Principles Compliance Assessment

For third‐party assessment of compliance to Guiding Principles, contact Green Building Initiative (GBI) at 503.274.0448. Registering and ordering a third‐party assessment from GBI allows access to the GPC NC DoD Survey, which includes any selections made within this Scoping Checklist, and a supplemental Technical Manual. Each GPC NC for Department of Defense assessment includes a third‐party review of the completed GPC NC DoD

Survey and supporting documentation as part of the 100% Design Submittal phase, as well as an On‐site Assessment by the third‐party assessor.

Supplementary reviews can be purchased for an additional fee if the team prefers to have a document review prior to 100% submittals.

Contact GBI to get started: 503.274.0448

©2016‐2017 GREEN BUILDING INITIATIVE, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.