Proposal_Score_Sheet_BPM003384_-_NS.pdf

PDF 139 KB Posted

Attached to
Master Agreement AZ|CTR057595
Contract number
CTR057595
Issued by
Arizona

About this file

This document is an evaluation scoresheet for a Request for Statement of Qualification (SOQ) for Hydro Engineering Services issued by the Arizona Game and Fish Department (AZGFD) under solicitation number BPM00384. The evaluation involves scoring proposals from multiple engineering firms, including Cardno Inc, Dowl Hkm, J2 Engineering and Environmental Design LLC, JE Fuller Hydrology & Geomorphology Inc, Natural Channel Design Inc, NextGen Engineering Inc, Stantec Consulting Services Inc, TetraTech, and Wilson & Co.

The SOQ was evaluated across four key criteria: Project Experience (40 points maximum), Overall Experience (20 points), Design Philosophy/Process/QA/QC (15 points), and Common Problems (15 points), with an additional 10 points for Overall Quality of Proposal. JE Fuller Hydrology & Geomorphology Inc received the highest total score of 83 points, ranking first in the evaluation. The evaluation was completed on 05/27/21 by Nara Sin, Project Manager for the AZGFD Statewide Services Delivery Vehicle (SSDV), with the final ranking listing JE Fuller first, followed by Wilson & Co, DOWL Hkm, Stantec, and Cardno Inc.

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
BPM003384_Due_Diligence_Check_List.pdf PDF
BPM003_2.PDF PDF
CERT-416374195.pdf PDF
Evaluation_Narrative_for_BPM003384_-NS.pdf PDF
Evaluation_Score_BPM003384.pdf PDF
Fuller_Certificate_-_AZ_G_F_5-1-21_to_5-1-22.pdf PDF
JEFuller-SOQ-BPM003384.pdf PDF
JE_Fuller_Negotiations_Sheet_8-10-21Fuller.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
SAM_EntityInformation-JE_Fuller.pdf PDF
ST1A87_1.PDF PDF
STAZMA_1.PDF PDF
STAZ_Mail_-_BPM003384_-_Evaluation_Committee_ENGSERVICES-_HYDRO.pdf PDF
pds_drodriguez_pg1.jpeg JPEG file
CTR057595_Renewal_Yr4.pdf PDF
JE_Fuller_Negotiations_Sheet_8-10-21Fuller.pdf PDF
Arizona_Game_and_Fish_Department_JE_Fuller_Hydrology___Geomorphology_25_GL_24_AU_WC_PROF_24__8-21-2025_1293635259.pdf PDF
EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY_BPM003384.pdf PDF
Evaluation_for_Committee_Members_-drodriguez.pdf PDF
Guidelines_for_Evaluation_for_Committee_Members.pdf PDF
JEFuller_CORRECTED_O_A_for_BPM003384_signed.pdf PDF
JE_Fuller_AZ_Corp_Commision_report.docx DOCX document
STAZMA_2.PDF PDF
STAZMail_to_Unsucessfuls-_10-14-21_Solicitation_-_BPM003384__Hydro_Engineering_Services.pdf PDF
pds_drodriguez_pg2.jpeg JPEG file
pds_drodriguez_pg3.jpeg JPEG file
BPM003384_-_Evaluation_SPO_Form_120_-_Procurement_Disclosure_Statement_narasin.pdf PDF
CERT-902318121.pdf PDF
CTR057595_YR5_Contract_Renewal_AZGFD_Signed.pdf PDF
CTR057595__JE_Fuller_Hydrological_Engineering_Services_-Insurance.pdf PDF
CTR057595__JE_Fuller_Hydrological_Engineering_Services_Executed_-_YR2.pdf PDF
Evaluation_Team_Meeting_Sign_in_Sheet.docx DOCX document
JE_Fuller_BAFO_Sheet_9-15-21-Signed.pdf PDF
JE_Fuller_Negotiations_Sheet_6-18-2021__6-21-21_Fuller.pdf PDF
Proposal_Score_Sheet_BPM003384.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
ST21E9_1.PDF PDF
STAZMA_3.PDF PDF
hydro_evals_June_2021_gbleyl.pdf PDF
CTR057595_JE_Fuller_Hydrological_Engineering_Services-YR3.pdf PDF
Evaluation_Narrative_for_BPM003384_-_NS.pdf PDF
Proposal_Score_Sheet_BPM003384.xlsx_-_drodriguez.pdf PDF
RFP_BPM003384_Hydro_Eng_Services_Award_Determination.docx DOCX document
RFP_BPM003384_Hydro_Eng_Services_Award_Determination.pdf PDF
RFP_BPM003384_Hydro_Eng_Services_Award_Determination_signed.pdf PDF
STAZMA_4.PDF PDF
STAZMail_10-14-21-_NOA-_BPM003384__Hydro_Engineering_Services_-_JE_Fuller.pdf PDF
TO_JE_Fuller_BAFO_Sheet_9-15-21.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
Show all 46

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

40 28 32 25 35 20 15 30 31 32

20 15 13 15 18 10 10 18 15 17

15 12 14 12 13 10 10 12 12 12

15 12 12 12 10 10 10 8 8 12

10 8 9 10 7 9 6 8 8 9

100 75 80 74 83 59 51 76 74 82 I hereby attest that the points awarded to each bidder listed above were scored in accordance with the established evaluation criterita and represent my best judgement of the bidder's proposal. As indicated by the highest total score, my ranking of the proposals are:

SIGNATURE

PRINTED NAME TITLE

DEPARTMENT DATE

Offerors

N ex tG en

E ng in ee rin g

In c

St an te c

C on su lti ng

Se rv ic es

In c

Te tra

T ec h In c

W ils on

C o.

C ar dn o

In c

D ow l H km

J 2 E ng in ee rin g an d En vi ro nm en ta l D es ig n

LL

C

JE

F ul le r H yd ro lo gy

G eo m or ph ol og y In c

N at ur al

C ha nn el

D es ig n In c

Design Philosophy, Process, QA/QC

ARIZONA GAME AND FISH DEPARTMENT

Request for Statement of Qualification for Hydro Engineering Services Solicitation BPM003384

6 TetraTech 7 J2 8 Natural Channel 9 Next Gen

1 JE Fuller 2 Wilson & Co 3 DOWL Hkm 4 Stantec 5 Cardno

Project Experience

M ax im um

P oi nt s

TOTAL POINTS

Evaluator's name:

Overall Experience

Common Problems

Overall Quality of Proposal

Nara Sin Project Manager

AZGFD SSDV 05/27/21

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .