Proposal_Score_Sheet_BPM003384.xlsx_-_drodriguez.pdf

Offerors

ARIZONA GAME AND FISH DEPARTMENT

M ax im um

P oi nt s

C ar dn o

In c

D ow l H km

J 2 E ng in ee rin g an d En vi ro nm en ta l D es ig n

LL

C

JE

F ul le r H yd ro lo gy

G eo m or ph ol og y In c

N at ur al

C ha nn el

D es ig n In c

N ex tG en

E ng in ee rin g

In c

St an te c

C on su lti ng

Se rv ic es

In c

Te tra

T ec h In c

W ils on

C o.

Request for Statement of Qualification for Hydro Engineering Services Solicitation BPM003384

Evaluator's name:

Project Experience 40 28

Overall Experience 20 16

Design Philosophy, Process, QA/QC 15 12

Common Problems 15 12

Overall Quality of Proposal 10 10

TOTAL POINTS 100 78 70 60 68 46 48 58 62 74

I hereby attest that the points awarded to each bidder listed above were scored in accordance with the established evaluation criterita and represent my best judgement of the bidder's proposal. As indicated by the highest total score, my ranking of the proposals are:

DOWL - 3 JE Fuller - 4 Wilson -2 CARDO -1 TETRA -5

Stantec - 7 NEXT Gen - 8 J2 - 6 NATURAL - 9

SIGNATURE

Jose Daniel Rodriguez Watercraft Law Enforcement Programs Coordinator

PRINTED NAME TITLE

DEPARTMENT DATE

Arizona Game and Fish Department 6/8/2021

1. Project Experience (Maximum 40 Points) -List of relevant projects completed within the last 5 years. Please list the location of the project and the personnel who worked on that project that would be working with AGFD. Please list what items of work which that person was responsible for on that project. Please do not list items that were consulted out. A resume should be provided for each person listed. Resumes will not be part of the page count.

2. Overall experience. (Maximum 20 Points) Provide any relevant organizational charts, resumes, and projects created as a team. Please list what design services will be performed in house versus subcontracted. Provide a list of all sub-consultants.

3. Design Philosophy (Maximum 15 Points) Provide factors your firm would consider for each study or design for each category.

4. Common Problems (Maximum 15 Points) List the common problems that you have seen with each criteria or challenges to design. How you have overcome these problems. Provide reference for projects listed with company/agency name, contact person and phone number

5. Overall Quality of Proposal (Maximum 10 Points)