Attachment C3 - CSO Design Coordination_Key Decision Tracking Log.xlsx
XLSX spreadsheet 56 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- REQ - 0009198
- Issued by
- Wayne County, Michigan
About this file
This is a Design Coordination Key Decision Tracking Log for CSO (Combined Sewer Overflow) Facilities Improvements managed by the Great Lakes Water Authority (GLWA) for the Hazen-CDM Cross Coordination Project. The document outlines preliminary design recommendations and specifications for nine CSO facilities across Michigan, including St. Aubin SDF, Belle Isle RTB, Baby Creek SDF, Conner Creek RTB, Hubbell Southfield RTB, Leib CSO, Oakwood CSO, Puritan Fenkell RTB, and Seven Mile RTB. The log tracks 22 design decision items spanning multiple disciplines including screening technology, disinfection systems, chemical storage and handling, mixing systems, chlorination control strategies, odor control, electrical systems, architectural rehabilitation, and safety improvements. Key design specifications include Romag screen technology with rehabilitation of existing screens, FRP chemical storage tanks certified to RTP-1 standards, centrifugal sealless magnetic drive pumps, polyethylene piping with fused joints at certain facilities and PVC piping at others, Gas Masterrr induction mixers, and colorimetric TRC analyzers by Swan. The document was last revised on August 16, 2023, and references related technical memoranda and basis of design documents for coordination purposes.
The tracking log emphasizes standardization across facilities while accommodating site-specific variations. Design coordination notes indicate that specifications such as chemical piping materials and joint types have been evaluated during conceptual design phases and adjusted based on input from GLWA operations and maintenance staff preferences. Safety improvements across all nine CSOs include fall protection enhancements for ladders and hatches and replacement of lift cylinders with lift-assisted hatches on dewatering pump access plates. Architectural rehabilitation work is assigned to project code 2200061 for all facilities. Supporting coordination items include influent sampling requirements, screen flushing system specifications, and floor coating timing. The document references related technical materials and design basis documentation maintained in the CSO Control Program SharePoint repository, indicating ongoing design development and multi-disciplinary coordination among project teams.
View the file
Other files
Show all 19
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Hazen-CDM Cross Coordination
| Project: | Design Services of CSO Facilities Improvements | ||||||
| Owner: | Great Lakes Water Authority (GLWA) | ||||||
| Revised: | 8/16/23 | ||||||
| GLWA CSO Facilities Design Coordination | |||||||
| Item No. | Description | Preliminary Recommendation | Comments / Notes | ||||
| St. Aubin SDF (STA) | Leib CSO | Oakwood CSO | |||||
| 1 | Screen Technology | Romag | |||||
| (Rehab Existing) | Romag | Not part of scope (existing screens are perf. Plate technology) | |||||
| 2 | Chemical Storage Tank | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | |||
| 3 | Chemical Pump Technology | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | |||
| 4 | Feed pump discharge configuration (e.g. manifold loop like CON, BC) vs. dedicated pump per mixing chamber) | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations to each mixing chamber* | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations to each mixing chamber* | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations dedicated to each storm pump.* | *Pressurized recirculation loop feeding flow control valves. Evaluated during conceptual design and during Jacobs CS-299 project. | ||
| 5 | Chemical Piping | Polyethylene: |
*fused joint with flanged joints at equipment (i.e., no glued joints) *Chem Proline®pipe by Asahi/America or Equal
| *Based on input from GLWA plumbers and products they've used | Sch 80 PVC - | |||
| *flanged or glued joints only | Sch 80 PVC - | |||
| *flanged or glued joints only | Flanges joints at all equipment | |||
| 6 | Chemical Valves, Isolation | Vented Ball Valves - |
-Sch 80 PVC -True Union Joints Vented Ball Valves - -Sch 80 PVC -True Union Joints Vented Ball Valves - -Sch 80 PVC -True Union Joints
| 7 | Chemical Valves, Throttling/Flow Control | Diaphragm Valve or Globe Valve | Materials of construction will be chemically compatible with application. |
| 8 | Chemical Mixing | Induction mixers - |
*Gas Mastrrr Mixers (No Water Champ per GLWA).
*Explosion proof motors for hazardous areas *oil reservoirs to maintain seals during intermittent operation Induction mixers - *Gas Mastrrr Mixers (No Water Champ per GLWA).
*Explosion proof motors for hazardous areas
| *oil reservoirs to maintain seals during intermittent operation | Injection ring on discharge piping of each storm pump. | At STA Hazen is evaluating the use of Gas Masterrr's NV type mixer for Prechlor location. | ||
| 9 | Chlorination Control Strategy | *Manual |
*Flow Pacing with dose set point
| *The primary disinfection control strategy operating mode will be TRC mode. | Manual; Flow Pacing w/ dose set point; ICT with TRC feedback; Machine Learning | Manual; Flow Pacing w/ dose set point; ICT with TRC feedback; Machine Learning | |||||
| 10 | TRC Analyzer | Colorimetric (Swan or equal) | Colorimetric (Swan) | Colorimetric (Swan) | Recommendation based on GLWA's pilot experience and feedback from Macomb County's experience. Also amperometric style (Reagentless) can become saturated, resulting in control reliability issues. |
&"-,Bold"&14EOWC Water Treatment and Supply Program Action Item Log &D
&P of &N
Draft All CSOs
| GLWA CSO Facilities Design Coordination | |||||||||||||||
| Item No. | Description | Preliminary Recommendation | Comments / Notes | ||||||||||||
| Baby Creek SDF (BC) | Belle Isle RTB (BLI) | Conner Creek RTB (CON) | Hubbell Southfield RTB (HS) | Leib CSO | Oakwood CSO | Puritan Fenkell RTB (PF) | Seven Mile RTB (SM) | St. Aubin SDF (STA) | BC | ||||||
| Screening | 1 | Screen Technology | Romag | Not part of scope (existing screens are perf. Plate technology) | Romag | ||||||||||
| (Rehab Existing) | BLI | ||||||||||||||
| 2 | Screen Clogging Mitigation | Adding spray bars on backside of screens to mitigate build up of solids in trough | |||||||||||||
| Disinfection | 3 | Chemical Storage Tank | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | FRP (RTP-1 Certified) | CON | |||||||||
| 4 | Chemical Pump Technology | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | Centrifugal seal less, magnetic drive pumps | HS | ||||||||||
| 5 | Feed pump discharge configuration (e.g. manifold loop like CON, BC) vs. dedicated pump per mixing chamber) | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations to each mixing chamber* | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations dedicated to each storm pump.* | Manifold loop with dedicated flow control valve stations to each mixing chamber* | *Pressurized recirculation loop feeding flow control valves. Evaluated during conceptual design and during Jacobs CS-299 project. | LEIB | |||||||||
| 6 | Chemical Piping | Sch 80 PVC - | |||||||||||||
| *flanged or glued joints only | Sch 80 PVC - | ||||||||||||||
| *flanged or glued joints only | Polyethylene: |
*fused joint with flanged joints at equipment (i.e., no glued joints) *Chem Proline®pipe by Asahi/America or Equal
| *Based on input from GLWA plumbers and products they've used | Need to update pipe type and joints. Recently GLWA O&M staff requested fused joint piping. | OKW | |||
| 7 | Chemical Valves, Isolation | Vented Ball Valves - |
-Sch 80 PVC -True Union Joints Vented Ball Valves - -Sch 80 PVC -True Union Joints Vented Ball Valves - -Sch 80 PVC
| -True Union Joints or flanged | PF | ||||||
| 8 | Chemical Valves, Throttling/Flow Control | Diaphragm Valves | Materials of construction will be chemically compatible with application. | SM | |||
| 9 | Chemical Mixing | Induction mixers - |
*Gas Mastrrr Mixers (No Water Champ per GLWA).
*Explosion proof motors for hazardous areas *oil reservoirs to maintain seals during intermittent operation Injection ring on discharge piping of each storm pump. Induction mixers - *Gas Mastrrr Mixers (No Water Champ per GLWA).
*Explosion proof motors for hazardous areas
| *oil reservoirs to maintain seals during intermittent operation | At STA Hazen is evaluating the use of Gas Masterrr's NV type mixer for Prechlor location. | STA | |||||
| 10 | Chlorination Control Strategy | Manual; Flow Pacing w/ dose set point; ICT with TRC feedback; Machine Learning | Manual; Flow Pacing w/ dose set point; ICT with TRC feedback; Machine Learning | *Manual |
*Flow Pacing with dose set point *The primary disinfection control strategy operating mode will be TRC mode.
| 11 | TRC Analyzer | Colorimetric (Swan) | Colorimetric (Swan) | Colorimetric (Swan or equal) | Recommendation based on GLWA's pilot experience and feedback from Macomb County's experience. Also amperometric style (Reagentless) can become saturated, resulting in control reliability issues. | ||||||||
| 12 | Automatic Filter System (upstream of TRC Analyzer) | S.P. Kinney Model AP | |||||||||||
| 13 | Chemical Unloading Station | Does GLWA have a preference such as a certain existing installation to mimic or certain parameters that they would like monitored and displayed on control panel and/or Ovation? | |||||||||||
| Odor Control | 14 | ||||||||||||
| Flushing & Dewatering | 15 | ||||||||||||
| HVAC | 16 | ||||||||||||
| Electrical | 17 | Will replace all buckets for MCCs | |||||||||||
| Site | 18 | ||||||||||||
| Architectural | 19 | Architectural Rehabilitation - address architectural deficiencies | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | 2200061 - Architectural Rehab | |
| Safety | 20 | Fall Protection | 2200061 - Fall protection for ladders, hatches, etc. (ALL 9 CSOs) | ||||||||||
| 21 | Hatch Lift Assist | 2200061 - Replace lift cylinders for hatches or replaces hatches new (All 9 CSOs) | Will upgrade plates over dewatering pumps to be lift assisted hatches | ||||||||||
| Supporting Infrastructure | 22 |
O&M Needs
| GLWA CSO Facilities Design Coordination | ||||||||||||
| Item No. | Description | Comments / Notes | ||||||||||
| Baby Creek SDF (BC) | Belle Isle RTB (BLI) | Conner Creek RTB (CON) | Hubbell Southfield RTB (HS) | Leib CSO | Oakwood CSO | Puritan Fenkell RTB (PF) | Seven Mile RTB (SM) | St. Aubin SDF (STA) | ||||
| Screening | 1 | Screen Technology | ||||||||||
| Disinfection | 2 | Chemical Storage Tank | ||||||||||
| 3 | Chemical Pump Technology | |||||||||||
| 4 | Feed pump discharge configuration (e.g. manifold loop like CON, BC) vs. dedicated pump per mixing chamber) | |||||||||||
| 5 | Chemical Piping | |||||||||||
| 6 | Chemical Valves, Isolation | |||||||||||
| 7 | Chemical Valves, Throttling/Flow Control | |||||||||||
| 8 | Chemical Mixing | |||||||||||
| 9 | Chlorination Control Strategy | |||||||||||
| 10 | TRC Analyzer | |||||||||||
| 11 | Automatic Filter System (upstream of TRC Analyzer) | |||||||||||
| 12 | Chemical Unloading Station | |||||||||||
| Odor Control | ||||||||||||
| Flushing & Dewatering | ||||||||||||
| HVAC | ||||||||||||
| Electrical | ||||||||||||
| Site | ||||||||||||
| Architectural | Architectural Rehabilitation - address architectural deficiencies | |||||||||||
| Safety | Fall Protection | |||||||||||
| Hatch Lift Assist | ||||||||||||
| Supporting Infrastructure |
Add'l Coordination
| Item No. | Description | Preliminary Recommendation (if applicable) | Comments / Notes | ||
| St. Aubin SDF (STA) | Leib CSO | Oakwood CSO | |||
| Influent Sampling | TSS | Multiparameter | Multiparemeter | ||
| Romag Screen Flushing | Pipe w/ orifice | ||||
| Various Hatch work | Coordinate timing & document updates | ||||
| Various floor coatings | Coordinate timing & document updates |
Key TMs
| 270010 - Leib/ OKW | ||
| No. | Name | Link |
| 18 | Chlorine Dose Response Results and ICT Model | Wastewater Engineering - TM-18 Chlorine Dose Response Results and ICT Model.pdf - All Documents (sharepoint.com) |
| 270006 - STA | ||
| 1A | Screning Evaluation | 2200061 R-Task 2-001A-TM1A-STA Screen Eval_Draft.pdf |
| BODR | Basis of Design | 2200061_GLWA_CSO Improvements_30% BODR.pdf |
../../../../../../../Forms/AllItems.aspx?csf=1&web=1&e=4zYQPL&cid=435fda2f%2D5a28%2D47db%2Da69c%2D6fea789d36f2&FolderCTID=0x012000DD88D4A64B39D442B43B0EBC05FE878F&id=%2Fsites%2FCSOControlProgram%2FShared%20Documents%2FGeneral%2FWWE%2F001%20PROJ%2FCSO%2F%5FMULTI%2FCIP270004%20%2D%202101475%20%2D%20OKW%2C%20Leib%20Imp%2C%20CON%20%26%20BC%20CFD%20%28DES%29%2F06%20Deliverables%2FTask%20B%20%2D%20Concep%20DES%2FTMs%2FFinal%20TM%27s%2FTM%2D18%20Chlorine%20Dose%20Response%20Results%20and%20ICT%20Model%2Epdf&parent=%2Fsites%2FCSOControlProgram%2FShared%20Documents%2FGeneral%2FWWE%2F001%20PROJ%2FCSO%2F%5FMULTI%2FCIP270004%20%2D%202101475%20%2D%20OKW%2C%20Leib%20Imp%2C%20CON%20%26%20BC%20CFD%20%28DES%29%2F06%20Deliverables%2FTask%20B%20%2D%20Concep%20DES%2FTMs%2FFinal%20TM%27s../../../../../../../../../../../../../../../../:b:/s/CSOControlProgram/Ee97j6uv4m1Eqtn0k6Zu5DIB6KZTqMOb2fIYXRJQUYoYDA?e=dtBxCE../../../../../../../../../../../../../../../../:b:/s/CSOControlProgram/Eb-CJg6KVp9AoUsM8AoZZxsBXMCrFZ8ufORMQ3I6nUz3uw?e=YNjj1H image1.png
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .