ACM and LBP Survey Report NASJRB Buildings 1604 1606 1608 1626 and 1632.pdf

Asbestos Survey and Lead-Based Paint (LBP) Sampling Report

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and the

Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Fort Worth, Texas 76113

January 10, 2020

Terracon Project No. 95197819

Prepared for:

The Johnson-McAdams Firm

Collierville, Tennessee 38107

Prepared by:

Terracon Consultants, Inc.

Fort Worth, Texas 76118

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Project Objective

2.0 SITE DESCRIPTION

3.0 FIELD ACTIVITIES

3.1 Visual Assessment

3.2 Physical Assessment

3.3 Sample Collection

3.4 Sample Analysis

4.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW

5.0 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

6.0 GENERAL COMMENTS

APPENDIX A CONFIRMED ASBESTOS-CONTAINING MATERIALS

APPENDIX B ASBESTOS SURVEY SAMPLE SUMMARY

APPENDIX C LEAD-BASED PAINT SAMPLE RESULTS

APPENDIX D ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL LABORATORY DATA

APPENDIX E LEAD-BASED PAINT ANALYTICAL LABORATORY DATA

APPENDIX F LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 1

ASBESTOS SURVEY AND LEAD-BASED PAINT (LBP)

SAMPLING REPORT

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and

Structures Associated with Area 1632

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Terracon Consultants, Inc. (Terracon) conducted an asbestos survey and lead-based paint

(LBP) sampling prior to the proposed demolition of Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and the structures associated with area 1632 located at the Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base

(NASJRB) in Fort Worth, Texas. The asbestos survey and lead-based paint sampling was conducted on December 10-11, 2019 by two State of Texas licensed asbestos inspectors/State of Texas certified lead risk assessors and a State of Texas license asbestos consultant in general accordance with Terracon Proposal No. P95197819 dated

December 3, 2019.

1.1 Project Objective

The objective of the asbestos survey was to identify the presence and location of accessible friable and nonfriable ACM present on the interior and exterior of Buildings

1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and the structures associated with area 1632 located at the above referenced address.

Although reasonable effort was made to survey accessible suspect materials, additional suspect but unsampled materials could be located in walls, in voids or in other concealed areas. Suspect ACM samples were collected in general accordance with the sampling protocols outlined in Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulation 40 CFR 763

(Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act, AHERA). Samples were delivered to an accredited laboratory for analysis by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM).

The Texas Asbestos Health Protection Rules (TAHPR) and EPA regulation 40 CFR 61, Subpart M, The National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) requires that an asbestos survey be performed prior to renovation or demolition activities.

The objective of the LBP sampling was to identify accessible LBP on the interior and exterior of Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and the structures associated with area 1632 located at the above referenced address.

Asbestos Survey and Lead-Based Paint Sampling NASJRB ■ Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632 ■ Fort Worth, Texas 76113 January 10, 2020 ■ Terracon Project No. 95197819

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 2

The LBP sampling was limited to readily observable and accessible surfaces. Based on information provided by the client, the structures are proposed for demolition.

It should be understood this limited LBP sampling is not considered to be comprehensive in nature, and the results are not intended to be used to determine lead hazards, develop abatement plans, or prepare detailed cost estimates for abatement. Accessible materials which have not been specifically evaluated should be tested prior to disturbance of the material

Regulatory agencies (HUD, TDSHS) have defined LBP as a paint or other surface coating that contain >5,000 parts per million (ppm) of lead or more than 0.5% of lead by weight for buildings that meet the definition of target housing. The Occupational Safety and Health

Administration (OSHA) define LBP as a paint which contains lead, regardless of the concentration. Due to the nature of the site, the OSHA regulations will apply to the construction and/or demolition activities, since the site does not meet the definition of a child occupied facility or target housing under HUD and TDSHS.

2.0 SITE DESCRIPTION

Building 1604

Building 1604 measures approximately 3,000 square feet. The single-story structure is primarily utilized as office space. The interior walls consist of textured drywall and ceramic wall tile on drywall and the floors consist of carpet, vinyl floor tile, and ceramic floor tile on a concrete substrate. The ceilings consist of textured drywall, spline ceiling tile, and a lay-in ceiling tile system. The exterior walls are constructed of an exterior finished insulation system (EFIS) and the roof is a pitched asphalt shingle roof. Fireproofing was not observed on the wood deck on the day of the survey.

Building 1606

Building measures approximately 1000 square feet. The single-story structure is primarily utilized as storage. The interior walls consist of textured drywall and fiberglass insulated metal. The floors consist of vinyl floor tile and unfinished concrete. The ceilings consist of textured drywall and a lay-in ceiling tile system in areas that are not exposed to the metal deck. The exterior walls and roof consist of corrugated metal. Fireproofing was not observed on the metal deck on the day of the survey.

Building 1608

Building 1608 measures approximately 3,300 square feet. The single-story structure is primarily utilized as storage. The interior walls and ceilings consist of corrugated metal

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 3 with the exception of the restroom. The interior walls and ceilings of the restroom consist of textured drywall. The floors are unfinished concrete throughout the building. The exterior walls and roof consist of corrugated metal. Fireproofing was not observed on the metal deck on the day of the survey.

Building 1626

Building 1626 measures approximately 300 square feet. The portable structure is constructed on a movable wood foundation. The interior and exterior walls and roof consist of fiberglass panels and the floor consists of wood.

Area 1632

The structures associated with the area designated as 1632 consist of a fuel station with a metal canopy, a concrete enclosed tank farm with three (3) metal above-ground fuel tanks, and a small masonry building with a metal roof, unfinished CMU walls, and an unfinished concrete floor.

3.0 FIELD ACTIVITIES

The asbestos survey and LBP sampling were conducted by Mr. Chad Champagne, a Texas

Department of State Health Services (TDSHS) licensed asbestos inspector (License No.

60-3112) and certified lead risk assessor (Certification No. 2071012), Mr. Andrew Cassidy, a TDSHS licensed asbestos inspector (License No. 60-3726) and certified lead risk assessor (Certification No. 2071119), and Mr. Stephen Rhodes, a TDSHS asbestos consultant (License No. 10-5826). Copies of licenses and certifications are attached in

Appendix E. The asbestos survey was conducted in general accordance with the sample collection protocols established in EPA regulation 40 CFR 763, the Asbestos Hazard

Emergency Response Act (AHERA). A summary of survey activities is provided below.

3.1 Visual Assessment

Interior and exterior building components were surveyed and homogeneous areas of suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACM) were visually identified and documented.

Although reasonable effort was made to survey accessible suspect materials, additional suspect but unsampled materials could be located in walls, in voids, or in other concealed areas. Suspect ACM samples were collected in general accordance with the sampling protocols outlined in Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulation 40 CFR 763

(Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act, AHERA). Samples were delivered to an accredited laboratory for analysis by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM).

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 4

Our survey activities began with visual observation of the interior and exterior of the buildings/structures scheduled for demolition to identify homogeneous areas of suspect

ACM. A homogeneous area consists of building materials that appear similar throughout in terms of color, texture, and date of application. The assessment was conducted throughout visually accessible areas of the building. Building materials identified as concrete, glass, wood, masonry, metal or rubber were not considered suspect ACM.

Terracon conducted a visual assessment of each area where environmental sampling was conducted. The visual assessment included evaluating the condition of painted surfces. The information gathered in the visual assessment was utilized in determining the collection points of the LBP samples.

It should be noted that suspect LBP, other than those identified during the sampling, may exist within the building and/or on the building exterior. If suspect LBP is identified, those materials should be assumed to LBP until testing can be performed to determine if lead is present in the paint.

3.2 Physical Assessment

A physical assessment of each homogeneous area of suspect ACM was conducted to assess the friability and condition of the materials. A friable material is defined by the EPA as a material which can be crumbled, pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure when dry. Friability was assessed by physically touching suspect materials.

3.3 Sample Collection

Based on results of the visual observation, bulk samples of suspect ACM were collected in general accordance with AHERA sampling protocols. Random samples of suspect materials were collected in each homogeneous area. Sample team members collected bulk samples using wet methods as applicable to reduce the potential for fiber release. Samples were placed in sealable containers and labeled with unique sample numbers using an indelible marker.

Two hundred and forty-two (242) bulk samples were collected from sixty-eight (68) homogeneous areas of suspect ACM. A summary of suspect ACM samples collected during the survey is included as Appendix A.

A total of thirty-nine (39) paint chip samples were collected. A summary of LBP samples collected is included in Appendix C.

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 5

3.4 Sample Analysis

Suspect ACM samples were delivered under proper chain of custody to Cates

Laboratories, of Dallas, Texas, an accredited National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation

Program (NVLAP) (Lab No. 200569-0) and TDSHS (License No. 30-0287) licensed laboratory for analysis by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) with dispersion staining techniques per EPA Method 600/R-93/116. The percentage of asbestos where applicable, was determined by microscopic visual estimation.

The LBP sampling was conducted by scraping approximately one square inch of paint from the supporting substrate. The samples were submitted to Environmental Hazards

Services, L.L.C. of Richmond, VA, a National Environmental Laboratory Accreditation

Program (NELAP) certified (Certificate No. T104704248-11-3) and AIHA accredited (Lab

ID: 100420) accredited laboratory. The analysis was performed by Flame Atomic

Absorption Spectrophotometry, EPA method (EPA SW846 7000B). The lower limit of detection (LOD) for this analytical method ranges from <32 ppm to <130 ppm based on the weight of the sample. Sample results reported below the LOD may contain lead at a concentration below the analytically defined LOD.

4.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW

The State of Texas has established the TAHPR which requires any asbestos-related activity to be performed by an individual licensed by the State of Texas, through the

TDSHS. An asbestos related activity consists of the disturbance (whether intentional or unintentional), removal, encapsulation, or enclosure of asbestos, including preparations or final clearance, the performance of asbestos surveys, the development of management plans and response actions, asbestos project design, the collection or analysis of asbestos samples, monitoring for airborne asbestos, bidding for a contract for any of these activities, or any other activity required to be licensed under TAHPR.

Abatement must be performed by a State of Texas licensed asbestos abatement contractor in accordance with a project design prepared by a State of Texas licensed asbestos consultant. In addition, third party air monitoring must be conducted during the abatement activities.

The asbestos NESHAP (40 CFR Part 61 Subpart M) regulates asbestos fiber emission and asbestos waste disposal practices. It also requires the identification and classification of existing building materials prior to demolition or renovation activity. Under NESHAP, asbestos containing building materials are classified as either friable, Category I nonfriable or Category II nonfriable ACM. Friable materials are those that, when dry, may be crumbled, pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure. Category I nonfriable ACM includes packing, gaskets, resilient floor coverings and asphalt roofing products containing

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 6 more than 1% asbestos. Category II nonfriable ACM are any materials other than

Category I materials that contain more than 1% asbestos.

Friable ACM, Category I and II nonfriable ACM in poor condition and has become friable or which will be subject to drilling, sanding, grinding, cutting, or abrading and which could be crushed or pulverized during anticipated renovation or demolition activities are considered regulated ACM (RACM). The TAHPR and NESHAP require that written notification be submitted before beginning renovation projects which include the disturbance of any asbestos-containing material (ACM) in a building or facility, or before the demolition of a building or facility, even when no asbestos is present. This written notification must be provided to the TDSHS at least 10 working days prior to the commencement of asbestos abatement or demolition activities. Removal of RACM must be conducted by a State of Texas licensed asbestos contractor. In addition, third party air monitoring must be performed during the abatement.

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Asbestos standard for the construction industry (29 CFR 1926.1101) regulates workplace exposure to asbestos.

The OSHA standard requires employee exposure to airborne asbestos fibers be maintained below 0.1 asbestos fibers per cubic centimeter of air (0.1 f/cc).

The OSHA standard classifies construction and maintenance activities which could disturb

ACM and specifies work practices and precautions which employers must follow when engaging in each class of regulated work. States that administer their own federally approved state OSHA programs may require other precautions.

The State of Texas has established the Texas Environmental Lead Reduction Rules

(TELRR) to establish the means to control and minimize public exposure to lead by regulating lead-based paint activities in target housing and child-occupied facilities. The

TELRR contains procedures and requirements for the accreditation of lead training providers, procedures and requirements for the certification of individuals and firms engaged in lead-based paint activities and standards for performing such activities in target housing and child-occupied facilities. The TELRR also requires that all lead-based paint activities in target housing and child-occupied facilities be performed by certified individuals.

As a point of reference, regulatory agencies (HUD, TDSHS) have defined LBP as a paint or other surface coating that contain >5,000 parts per million (ppm) of lead or more than

0.5% of lead by weight for buildings that meet the definition of target housing. OSHA, however, defines LBP as a paint which contains lead, regardless of the concentration.

The OSHA Lead Standard for Construction (29 CFR 1926.62) applies to construction work where an employee may be occupationally exposed to lead. All work related to

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 7 construction, alteration, or repair (including painting and decorating) is included. The lead-in-construction standard applies to any detectable concentration of lead in paint. OSHA considers paint containing any level of lead above the analytical method detection limit a potential hazard which should be communicated to any employees or contractors who may disturb the materials in the course of their assigned work.

5.0 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the results of the laboratory analyses, asbestos was confirmed in the following materials:

ASBESTOS

◼ Vinyl floor tile (blue with white streaks) with mastic

◼ Tank insulation

◼ Roof caulk (brown/black)

The identified ACM were assessed to be nonfriable and in good condition on the day of the survey. Terracon understands Building 1604 is for demolition. Therefore, the identified

ACM must be abated prior to demolition activities.

LEAD-BASED PAINT

A total of thirty-nine (39) paint chip samples were collected and nine (9) samples were determined to contain detectible concentrations of lead. A summary of the components tested, location of the measurement, and results are provided in Appendix B.

The following paint chip samples were determined to contain concentrations of lead above the laboratory limit of detection, but below the threshold considered as LBP (5,000 ppm), with the exception of the yellow paint on the handrails located at building 1631 highlighted in red below:

• Light brown paint on metal roof vent pipes on Building 1604

• White paint on metal HVAC duct in Utility Room 1001 in Building 1604

• White paint on metal panel doors in Utility Room 1001 in Building 1604

• Beige paint on the exterior metal walls/siding of Building 1608

• White paint on the exterior metal bay doors of Building 1608

• Red paint on the metal support columns in Building 1606

• Yellow paint on handrails in Tank Yard 1631

Responsive ■ Resourceful ■ Reliable 8

• Black paint on metal pipes in Tank Yard 1631

• Beige paint on the exterior metal walls/siding of Building 1626

Any demolition activities conducted in the Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and the structures associated with area 1632 would be subject to OSHA regulations (29 CFR

1926.62 – Lead Exposure in Construction). The OSHA regulation defines specific training requirements, engineering controls and working practices for construction personnel subject to this standard. There are also federal and state regulations, which require characterization of demolition debris to determine the proper disposal procedures.

It is unlikely component removal would present a lead hazard to personnel, however, it is recommended that contracting personnel who may disturb the paint as part of the demolition activities should be made aware of the lead content in the materials so that they may exercise proper OSHA procedures for personnel protection or possibly employ protective procedures when working with the materials.

Compliance with applicable OSHA lead regulations is the responsibility of the contractor performing the work and it is recommended that they be required to communicate potential lead hazards to their workforce and utilize lead-safe work practices such as outlined in the

EPA Renovation, Repair, and Painting Final Rule (40 CFR 745) or applicable portions of the Structural Steel Painting Council (SSPC) Guidelines. It is further recommended that activities such as flame/torch dismantling, dry sanding and/or dry grinding of any components with lead-containing materials applied should be prohibited as part of any repair, renovation or demolition activity.

6.0 GENERAL COMMENTS

The asbestos survey and LBP sampling was conducted in a manner consistent with the level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of the profession currently practicing under similar conditions in the same locale. The results, findings, conclusions and recommendations expressed in this report are based on conditions observed during our survey of the buildings scheduled for demolition. The information contained in this report is relevant to the date on which this survey was performed, and should not be relied upon to represent conditions at a later date. This report has been prepared on behalf of and exclusively for use by The Johnson-McAdams Firm for specific application to their project as discussed. This report is not a bidding document. Contractors or consultants reviewing this report must draw their own conclusions regarding further investigation or remediation deemed necessary. Terracon does not warrant the work of regulatory agencies, laboratories or other third parties supplying information which may have been used in the preparation of this report. No warranty, express or implied is made.

APPENDIX A

ASBESTOS-CONTAINING MATERIALS

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Sample No.

Material Location (Area)

NESHAP

Classification Assessed Condition

Estimated Quantity

Building 1604

60, 61, 62 12” x 12” Vinyl Floor Tile (blue with white streaks) with Mastic

Meeting Hall 1014 Category I

Nonfriable Good

620 square feet

78, 79, 80 Tank Insulation Mechanical Room 1001 Category II

Nonfriable Good

8 square feet

118, 119, Roof Caulk (brown/black) Central Roof Penetrations above Restrooms

Category II

Nonfriable Good

5 square feet

APPENDIX B

ASBESTOS SURVEY SAMPLE SUMMARY

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Material Asbestos Containing Sample Numbers

2’ x 2’ Ceiling Tile (white, pinholes and fissures)

No 1, 2, 3

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down)

No 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10

Cove Base Mastic (tan) No 11, 12, 13

Carpet Mastic (yellow) No 14, 15, 16

Interior Door Caulk (white) No 17, 18, 19

12” x 12” Ceramic Floor Tile (tan) with Grout (beige) and Thinset

No 20, 21, 22

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (cream, crow’s foot)

No 23, 24, 25

Finished Gypsum Wall System (cream, crow’s foot)

No 26, 27, 28

4” x 4” Ceramic Wall Tile (beige, speckled) with Grout (white)

No 29, 30, 31

Interior Building Caulk (white) associated with Plumbing

No 32, 33, 34

1” x 1” Ceramic Floor Tile (brown/beige) with Grout (brown) and Thinset

No 35, 36, 37

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn)

No 38, 39, 40, 41, 42

2’ x 2’ Ceiling Tile (white, pinholes and indentions)

No 43, 44, 45

Residual Wall Mastic (white) No 46, 47, 48

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, smooth)

No 49, 50, 51, 52, 53

Ceiling Texture (white, splatter drag) on Drywall

No 54, 55, 56

Wall Texture (white, crow’s foot) on Drywall

No 57, 58, 59

12” x 12” Vinyl Floor Tile (blue with white streaks) with Mastic

Yes 60, 61, 62

Interior Window Caulk (white) No 63, 64, 65

Interior Building Caulk (white) No 66, 67, 68

Interior Door Caulk (tan) No 69, 70, 71

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, smooth)

No 72, 73, 74

12” x 12” Spline Ceiling Tile (white) with Mastic (brown)

No 75, 76, 77

Tank Insulation Yes 78, 79, 80

Thermal System Pipe Insulation Mastic (white)

No 81, 82, 83

Duct Mastic (gray) No 84, 85, 86

Duct Mastic (white) No 87, 88, 89

HVAC Mastic (gray) No 90, 91, 92

Finished Gypsum Wall and Ceiling System (white, smooth)

No 93, 94, 95

CMU Wall Texture (white) No 96, 97, 98

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough)

No 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105

Exterior Building Caulk (tan) associated with Doors, Vent, and Soffit

No 106, 107, 108

Exterior Window Caulk (dark brown) No 109, 110, 111

Exterior Soffit Siding (brown, wood pattern)

No 112 ,113, 114

Roof Shingle (tan/red) No 115, 116, 117

Roof Caulk (brown/black) Yes 118, 119, 120

Roof Caulk (red) associated with Mechanical Room Vent

No 121, 122, 123

Roof Caulk (gray) No 124, 125, 126

Roof Caulk (white) No 127, 128, 129

Roof Mastic (black) No 130, 131, 132

Roof Caulk (brown/gray) No 133, 134, 135

Building 1606

2’ x 4’ Ceiling Tile (white, pinholes and indentions)

No 1, 2, 3

2’ x 4’ Ceiling Tile (white, pinholes and fissures)

No 4, 5, 6

Finished Drywall Wall System (white, sandy)

No 7, 8, 9

Cove Base Mastic (cream) No 10, 11, 12

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Fiberglass Reinforced Panel Mastic (yellow)

No 13, 14, 15

Finished Drywall Ceiling System (white, semi-smooth)

No 16, 17, 18

Finished Drywall Wall System (white, drag)

No 19, 20, 21, 22, 23

Interior Building Caulk (white) associated with Restroom Sink

No 24, 25, 26

12” x 12” Vinyl Floor Tile (light blue with blue flakes) with Mastic

No 27, 28, 29

Residual Floor Mastic (yellow) No 30, 31, 32

Interior Door Caulk (white) No 33, 34, 35

Exterior Window Caulk (brown) No 36, 37, 38

Exterior Building Caulk (brown) No 39, 40, 41

Residual Button Mastic (tan) No 42, 43, 44

Roof Caulk (white) No 45, 46, 47

Roof Caulk (black) No 48, 49, 50

Roof Penetration Caulk (silver) No 51, 52, 53

Roof Seam Caulk (black) No 54, 55, 56

Building 1608

Finished Gypsum Wall/Ceiling System (white, semi-smooth)

No 1, 2, 3

Vinyl Cove Base Mastic (tan) No 4, 5, 6

Interior Building Caulk (white) No 7, 8, 9

Foundation Caulk (gray) No 10, 11, 12

Exterior Building Caulk (white) No 13, 14, 15

Roof Caulk (white) No 16, 17, 18

Roof Caulk (gray) No 19, 20, 21

Building 1626

Exterior Building Caulk (white) No 1, 2, 3

Exterior Building Caulk (gray) No 4, 5, 6

Exterior Building Caulk (white, chalky) No 7, 8, 9

Area 1632

Foundation Caulk (black) No 1, 2, 3

Foundation Caulk (gray) No 4, 5, 6

Tank Coating (white) No 7, 8, 9

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Interior Building Caulk (white) No 10, 11, 12

Exterior Building Caulk (gray) No 13, 14, 15

Exterior Building Caulk (gray) No 16, 17, 18

Interior Window Caulk (white) No 19, 20, 21

APPENDIX C

Lead Based Paint Sample Results

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Number

Sample Location

Component Lead

Concentration1

(ppm)

Building 1604, Room 1014 Beige paint on metal door <100

Building 1604, Room 1014 White paint on gypsum board wall <49

Building 1604, Room 1014 Beige paint on wood baseboard <67

Building 1604, Room 1014 White paint on metal supply-air register <69

Building 1604, Exterior Brown paint on metal door <48

Building 1604, Exterior Brown paint on metal support column <200

Building 1604, Hall 1008 Gray paint on metal door panic bar <130

Building 1604, Restroom 1009

Beige on black paint on wood door <59

Building 1604, Exterior White paint on metal pole <75

Building 1604, Roof Light brown paint on vent pipe 560

Building 1604, Exterior Brown paint on wood door casing <47

Building 1604, Utility 1001 White paint on metal HVAC duct 570

Building 1604, Utility 1001 White paint on metal panel door 160

Building 1604, Utility 1001 White paint on masonry block wall <46

Building 1608, Warehouse Blue paint on metal shelving <98

Building 1608, Warehouse Red Paint on metal support column <49

Building 1608, Restroom White paint on gypsum board wall <47

Building 1608, Warehouse White paint on metal door casing <38

Building 1608, Exterior Beige paint on metal wall/siding 2,200

Building 1608, Exterior White paint on metal bay door 150

Building 1606, Room 1003 Blue paint on metal door casing <64

APPENDIX C

Lead Based Paint Sample Results

Naval Air Station Joint Reserve Base (NASJRB)

Buildings 1604, 1606, 1608, 1626, and Structures Associated with Area 1632

1510 Chennault Avenue

Number

Sample Location

Component Lead

Concentration1

(ppm)

Building 1606, Room 1003 Red paint on metal support column 46

Building 1606, Room 1003 Gray paint on metal bay door casing <48

Building 1606, Room 1002 White paint on gypsum board wall <73

Building 1606, Room 1003 White paint on wood door <50

Building 1606, Room 1001 White paint on gypsum board wall <50

Building 1606, Room 1004 Blue paint on wood door casing <45

Building 1606, Exterior Beige paint on metal wall/siding <49

Fuel Island

1632B Yellow paint on eyewash pipe <46

Fuel Island

1632B White paint on fuel canopy support column <42

Fuel Island

1632B White paint on metal fuel dispenser <50

Building 1632A, Interior Gray paint on metal door <45

Building 1632A, Exterior Yellow paint on metal bollards <39

Building 1632A, Exterior Gray paint on metal gutter <68

35 Tank Yard 1631 Yellow paint on metal handrails 10,000

36 Tank Yard 1631 White paint on metal tank walls <48

37 Tank Yard 1631 Black paint on metal pipe 66

38 Tank Yard 1631 Gray paint on metal light pole <160

Building 1626, Exterior Beige paint on metal wall/siding 1,900

APPENDIX D

ASBESTOS LABORATORY ANALYTICAL REPORTS

PLM REPORT SUMMARY

Cates Laboratories NVLAP Lab No. 200569-0

1339 Motor Circle TDSHS License No. 30-0287

Dallas, Texas 75207 (214) 920-5006

Client: Terracon Lab Job No.: PLM-22019

Project: NASJRB Buildings 1604; 1510 Chennault Ave., Fort Worth, TX Set No.: 32377

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 1 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Lab

Sample No.

Client

Field I.D.

Sample Description/Location Asbestos Content

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced except in full.

CL782807

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & fissure) - Conference Room 1011, North

None Detected

CL782808

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & fissure) - Corridor 1008, East

CL782809

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & fissure) - Corridor 1008, West

CL782810

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Room 1012, Southwest Corner

None Detected - Paint Texture

None Detected - Joint Tape

None Detected - Joint Compound

None Detected - Paper

None Detected - Wallboard Material

CL782811

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Conference Room

1011, Northwest corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782812

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Corridor 1008, East Wall

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782813

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Corridor 1008, West Wall

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782814

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Lobby 1001, Northeast Corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 2 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782815

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Lobby 1001, Southwest Corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782816

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, knock-down) - Office 1005, None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782817

Cove Base Mastic (tan) - Room 1012, Southwest Corner

None Detected - Cove Base

None Detected - Tan Mastic

CL782818

Cove Base Mastic (tan) - Corridor 1008, East Wall

CL782819

Cove Base Mastic (tan) - Office 1005, Northeast Corner

CL782820

Carpet Mastic (yellow) - Room 1012, Southwest

CL782821

Carpet Mastic (yellow) - Conference Room 1011, Southwest

CL782822

Carpet Mastic (yellow) - Office 1006, North

CL782823

Interior Door Caulk (white) - Conference Room 1011, South Entry Door

CL782824

CL782825

CL782826

12" X 12" Ceramic Floor Tile (tan)/Grout (beige) & Thinset - Corridor

1008, West

None Detected - Ceramic Tile

None Detected - Grout

None Detected - Thinset

CL782827

1008, Center

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 3 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782828

1008, Center

CL782829

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1009, South

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782830

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1009, None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782831

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1010, None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782832

Finished Gypsum Wall System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1009, Southeast Corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782833

Finished Gypsum Wall System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1010, None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782834

Finished Gypsum Wall System (cream, crow's foot) - Restroom 1010, None Detected - Joint Compound

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 4 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782835

4" X 4" Ceramic Wall Tile (beige, speckled)/Grout (white) - Restroom

1010, West

None Detected - Yellow Mastic

CL782836

CL782837

CL782838

Interior Building Caulk (white) associated w/Plumbing - Restroom 1009, West

CL782839

Interior Building Caulk (white) associated w/Plumbing - Restroom 1009, CL782840

Interior Building Caulk (white) associated w/Plumbing - Restroom 1010, CL782841

1' X 1' Ceramic Floor Tile (brown/beige, mosaic)/Grout (brown) &

Thinset - Restroom 1010, South Wall

CL782842

CL782843

CL782844

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn) - Office 1005

None Detected - Spray-Applied Tx

None Detected - Joint Compound

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 5 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782845

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn) - Office 1002

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782846

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn) - Office 1003

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782847

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn) - Lobby 1001

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782848

Finished Gypsum Ceiling System (white, popcorn) - Corridor adjacent to

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782849

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & indent) - Corridor 1008, Center

CL782850

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & indent) - Corridor 1008, Center

CL782851

2' X 2' Ceiling Tile (white, pinhole & indent) - Corridor 1008, West

CL782852

Residual Wall Mastic (white) - Conference Room 1011, West Wall

CL782853

CL782854

CL782855

Finished Drywall Ceiling System (white, smooth) above Ceiling Tile -

Room 1012, East

None Detected - Paint Layer

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 6 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782856

Room 1012, Center

CL782857

Conference Room 1011, North

CL782858

Corridor 1008, East

CL782859

Corridor 1008, CL782860

Ceiling Texture (white, splatter drag) on Drywall - Meeting Hall 1014, Southeast

CL782861

Southwest

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782862

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782863

Wall Texture (white, crow's foot) on Drywall - Meeting Hall 1014, None Detected - Joint Compound

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 7 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782864

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782865

Northwest Corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782866

12" X 12" Vinyl Floor Tile (blue w/white streaks) w/Mastic -Meeting

Hall 1014, North

None Detected - Floor Tile 1

3% Chrysotile - Floor Tile 2

None Detected - Black Mastic

CL782867

Hall 1014, West

3% Chrysotile - Floor Tile 2

None Detected - Black Mastic

10% Chrysotile - Floor Tile 3

3% Chrysotile - Black Mastic

CL782868

Hall 1014, East

3% Chrysotile - Floor Tile 2

None Detected - Black Mastic

10% Chrysotile - Floor Tile 3

3% Chrysotile - Black Mastic

CL782869

Interior Window Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, North Window

CL782870

Interior Window Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, North Window

CL782871

Interior Window Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, West Window

CL782872

Interior Building Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, East Wall

CL782873

Interior Building Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, East Wall

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 8 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782874

Interior Building Caulk (white) - Meeting Hall 1014, West Wall

CL782875

Interior Door Caulk (tan) - Meeting Hall 1014, North Entry Door

CL782876

Interior Door Caulk (tan) - Meeting Hall 1014, West Door

CL782877

Interior Door Caulk (tan) - Meeting Hall 1014, South Entry Door

CL782878

Finished Gypsum Wall System (white, smooth) - Meeting Hall 1014, West Alcove

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782879

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782880

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782881

Spline Ceiling Tile (12" X 12" white) w/Mastic - Office 1013, Center

None Detected - Ceiling Tile

None Detected - Brown Mastic

CL782882

Spline Ceiling Tile (12" X 12" white) w/Mastic - Office 1013, Center

CL782883

Spline Ceiling Tile (12" X 12" white) w/Mastic - Office 1013, North

CL782884

Tank Insulation - Mechanical Room 1001, East

20% Chrysotile - White Mastic

None Detected - Wrap

None Detected - Insulation

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 9 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782885

CL782886

CL782887

Thermal System Pipe Insulation Mastic (white) - Mechanical Room 1001, None Detected - White Mastic

CL782888

East

CL782889

CL782890

Duct Mastic (grey) - Mechanical Room 1001, North

CL782891

CL782892

CL782893

Duct Mastic (white) - Mechanical Room 1001, South

CL782894

CL782895

CL782896

HVAC Mastic (grey) - Mechanical Room 1001, Southeast

CL782897

CL782898

CL782899

Finished Gypsum Wall & Ceiling System (white, smooth) - Mechanical

Room 1001, Northwest Corner

None Detected - Joint Compound

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 10 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782900

Room 1001, North Wall

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782901

Room 1001, North Wall

None Detected - Joint Compound

CL782902

CMU Wall Texture (white) - Mechanical Room 1001, Southeast Corner

CL782903

CL782904

CL782905

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - North Exterior Wall, Northeast

None Detected - Stucco

CL782906

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - East Exterior Wall, Southeast

CL782907

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - South Exterior Wall, CL782908

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - South Exterior Wall, CL782909

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - West Exterior Wall, CL782910

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - West Exterior Wall, North

CL782911

Exterior Finished Insulation System (tan, rough) - North Exterior Wall, CL782912

Exterior Building Caulk (tan) associated w/Doors, Vent & Soffit -

Northeast Entry Door

Project No: 95197819 Report Date: 12/18/2019

Identification: Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis Sample Date: 12/10-11/2019

Test Method: Polarized Light Microscopy/Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600/R-93/116 Page 11 of 13

On 12/16/2019, one-hundred, thirty-five (135) bulk samples were submitted by Mr. Chad Champagne of Terracon for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

Copies of the lab data sheets are attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Client

These samples were analyzed by layers. The overall percent asbestos for the sample is reported when relevant. The EPA considers a material to be asbestos containing only if it contains greater than one percent asbestos by Calibrated Visual Area Estimation (CVAE). EPA regulations also indicate that Regulated Asbestos Containing

Materials (RACM) – materials that are friable or may become friable – be further analyzed by point counting when the results indicate less than ten percent asbestos by

CVAE. CatesLab utilizes CVAE on a routine basis and does not include point counting unless specifically requested by the client. The results may not be reproduced

CL782913

Exterior Building Caulk (tan) associated w/Doors, Vent & Soffit -

Northwest Entry Door

CL782914

Exterior Building Caulk (tan) associated w/Doors, Vent & Soffit - North

Central Entry Door

CL782915

Exterior Window Caulk (dark brown) - Northeast Window Exterior

CL782916

Exterior Window Caulk (dark brown) - Southeast Window Exterior

CL782917

Exterior Window Caulk (dark brown) - North Window Exterior

CL782918

Exterior Soffit Siding (brown, wood pattern) - adjacent to Northeast Entry

None Detected - Cement Board

CL782919

Exterior Soffit Siding (brown, wood pattern) - adjacent to South Entry

CL782920

Exterior Soffit Siding (brown, wood pattern) - adjacent to North Entry

CL782921

Roof Shingles (tan/red) - North Roof

None Detected - Roofing Shingle

None Detected - Roofing Felt

CL782922

Ro…