1-Attachment D Technical Evaluation Scoring Sheet.xlsx

This is a Technical Evaluation Scoring Sheet for the North Summit Fire District's Fire Station 23 Dorm Addition and Interior Remodel project located at 2000 S Hoytsville Rd., Wanship, UT 84017. The evaluation form is designed for a proposal evaluation panel to independently assess contractor proposals using a standardized scoring methodology. A mandatory pre-proposal site visit is scheduled for August 27, 2026, with questions due by September 2, 2026 at 2:00 PM Mountain Time, and proposal submissions due by September 4, 2026 at noon Mountain Time via the U3P platform. The file serves as the evaluation framework rather than the procurement announcement itself, establishing the criteria and scoring procedures for assessing competing bids.

The scoring sheet establishes six evaluation categories with a maximum total technical score of 105 points. Work Plan & Schedule comprises 30 points maximum and evaluates understanding of scope, construction sequencing, disruption minimization, schedule realism, and resource allocation. Contractor Qualifications & Experience accounts for 25 points and assesses relevant project experience, public safety facility experience, project team qualifications, and past performance. Project Management Approach contributes 20 points covering communication, quality control, safety, and risk management plans. Ability to Meet Timeline provides 15 points based on staffing capacity, contractor availability, and critical path identification. Added Value/Innovations offers 10 points for cost efficiency ideas, material innovations, and building performance enhancements. A bonus category of 5 points is available for prior successful North Summit Fire District experience, including communications, scheduling, and on-time completion. Each subfactor is scored on a 0-5 point scale with specific performance descriptors, and individual evaluator scores must be submitted for consensus determination.