Attachment 3 Livorno EMS FCAR 2020.pdf

“identification only”

II. SCHOOL PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION

The summary below provides a physical description of the school. When multiple systems or materials are present, the predominant system or material observed during the facility condition assessment is shown.

a. STRUCTURAL/EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE: The building exterior is an exterior insulation and finish system (E.I.F.S). Roof coverings are built-up. Exterior doors are pre-finished aluminum with glazing. Window systems are pre-finished aluminum with double-glazing.

b. INTERIORS: Floor finishes used include ceramic tile and wood. Walls are painted hard surfaces. Ceilings are acoustical lay-in tiles.

c. MECHANICAL: Campus facilities have heating, which is provided by boilers. All campus facilities have air conditioning, which is provided by chilled water. The campus has no elevators.

d. ELECTRICAL: Major electrical upgrades have been completed to support the additions to Building 201, but mot wiring appears to be original. Lighting is typically lay-in fixtures with fluorescent lamps. Ground-fault circuit interrupter (GFCI) receptacles appear to be present, but are not properly labeled. The campus has an intercom system. There is a security system, and security cameras are present.

e. PLUMBING: Plumbing fixtures and piping have been partially upgraded. Domestic hot water is provided by indirect water heaters.

f. SITE: The school has parking for approximately 32 privately owned vehicles. In addition, the school has two playgrounds.

g. LIFE SAFETY: Fire safety inspection reports were not available for review.

"identification only"

III. OBSERVATIONS

The following observations were made: Exterior door security was observed and reported to be a problem.

The exterior doors were weathered with some corrosion observed and sample tested hardware was difficult to operate and secure in some cases. The skylights in Building 201, above the entry hall/corridor, were deteriorated and appeared broken beyond repair. Further, in Building 201, the joint sealants at the exterior wall expansion joints have lost flexibility with cracks observed; this may potentially allow water infiltration of the facility. Exterior windows in Building 201 were also weathering and wall-to-window sealants were failing with wall spalling noted in some locations, however, windows were observed and reported to operate correctly. All interior finishes are aging as expected and the walls appear to have been painted within the last two years.

It appears that outside air is being introduced into the HVAC system. The make-up air units and exhaust fans appear to be in poor condition and are showing signs of rust and possibly biological growth. Additionally, the chiller at Building 201 had no data plate and appeared to be weathered, discolored, and deteriorated. The roof covering at Building 201 had potentially damaging organic growth observed encroaching and this growth was also observed around the mechanical units at the Kitchen. The plumbing fixtures, enclosed circuit breakers, and electrical distribution panels appeared to be in good condition and were showing minimal signs of deterioration.

The Facility Utilization Survey (FUS) drawings were updated to reflect the assessment findings, including room-use and room number changes observed throughout the campus. No buildings were added or removed from the site since the time of the previous assessment. Building 201 is a partial-use facility and is shared between Livorno Elementary/Middle School and the Child and Youth Services (CYS). Livorno Elementary/Middle School utilizes approximately 97% of Building 201 (41,915 SF), and CYS utilizes approximately 3% of Building 201, specifically Room C06 (1,471 SF) for a GSF total of 43,386 SF. As DoDEA is the predominant user (>90% occupant), 100% of the square footage for Building 201 is being reported. A portion of Playground 1 was demolished, and the construction of a new playground was observed during the assessment. Further, there were areas around Building 201 where the pavers are beginning to sink, causing a potential tripping hazard.

Building 200 remained a Q-1.

Building 201 improved from a Q-3 to a Q-2. Since the time of the previous assessment, ALPHA updated the algorithm to estimate quantities of the plumbing concealed systems; Domestic Water Distribution System, and Sanitary Waste System, which resulted in a reduction of the costs for these work items.

Appendix A

Site Plan

Appendix B

Overview of Sustainment Management System (SMS) and

BUILDER™ Engineered Management System (EMS)

Overview of Sustainment Management System (SMS) and BUILDER™ Engineered Management System (EMS)

Sustainment Management System (SMS)

The Sustainment Management System (SMS) is a suite of web-based software applications developed by the

United States Army Corps of Engineers - Engineer Research Development Center - Construction Engineering

Research Laboratory (USACE-ERDC-CERL) to help facility engineers, technicians, and managers decide when, where, and how to best maintain the built environment. The SMS modules include BUILDER™ and

ROOFER™ for assessing building conditions, PAVER™ for pavements, and RAILER™ for railroad infrastructure.

Because real property assets are so vast and diverse, a "knowledge-based" philosophy drives the SMS process. The process starts with the automated download of real property data, and then more detailed system inventory is modeled and/or collected which identifies components and their key life cycle attributes such as the age and material.

From this inventory, Condition Index (CI) measures for each component are predicted based on its expected stage in the life cycle. Objective and repeatable inspections can then be performed on various components to verify their condition with respect to the expected life cycle deterioration. The level of detail and frequency of these inspections are not fixed like other processes; they are dependent on knowledge of component criticality, the expected and measured condition and rate of deterioration, and remaining maintenance and service life. This "knowledge-based" inspection focuses attention to the most critical components at the time.

In addition to these condition assessments, functionality assessments can be performed to evaluate user requirement changes, compliance and obsolescence issues. This provides a comprehensive picture of the overall performance of real property assets and their key components.

BUILDER Engineered Management System (EMS)

In September 2013, the Under Secretary of Defense, Frank Kendall, issued a memo indicating the Department of Defense requires a standardized process for facility condition assessments to ensure consistent and reliable data necessary for sound strategic investment decisions in managing the Department's built environment.

Establishing a DoD-wide facility condition assessment process will contribute to a more credible DoD asset management program and will support better buying power by allowing Department leadership to better target fiscal resources to those facilities most in need of investment. Further, adopting a standard process will help ensure that condition data will be audit-ready in accordance with the Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller)'s "Financial Improvement and Readiness Guidance" issued in March 2013.

The facility condition assessment process used to generate this report is based on BUILDER Engineered Management System (EMS) Version 3. BUILDER EMS was developed by the Engineer Research and Development Center.

The facility condition assessment process addresses the requirements necessary for routine building facility management activities, including long range budgeting and sustainment/restoration/modernization (SRM) planning. This assessment approach provides an objective and generalized framework to help to identify problem areas that will require more investigation through detailed or specialized assessments. There may be times when detailed engineering assessments may be required to diagnose specific problems.

BUILDER is a software application for building asset life cycle management. The primary focus of BUILDER is work plan development. BUILDER stores real property building information and more detailed system inventory is modeled and/or collected which identifies building components and their key life cycle attributes such as the age, material and capacity. Inspections are then performed on the various components to determine an objective and repeatable Condition Index (CI) measure, which relates the general physical health of the asset.

With information about condition and remaining service life, BUILDER guides the development of short- and long-range work plans based on sound investment strategies, prioritization criteria, and budget constraints.

BUILDER consolidates a variety of building-related management issues into a single decision-support package.

The system gives functional managers and decision-makers instant access to building inventory, current building condition indices, and probabilities condition prediction models. It also employs a patented knowledge-based inspection scheduling process. BUILDER improves the allocation process and return of building life cycle investments by directing resources to the most condition critical components to avoid costly repair penalty costs, as well as, the most mission critical components to manage risks of failure.

BUILDER Facility Condition Assessment Process

Facility Condition Assessment (FCA) is one of the primary processes of a facility life cycle asset management program. The FCA process results in a better understanding of the physical condition and readiness of an organization's buildings along with the reliability of its systems and components. It also facilitates the identification of work candidates for facility SRM repair projects. It is a critical aspect of the shift towards a proactive versus reactive facility management strategy. Instead of keeping facilities operational by relying primarily on corrective repairs (after a system or component has failed due to significant loss of function), it focuses on condition-based repairs which can be planned prior to failure. A condition-based approach can result in higher performing facilities at lower life cycle costs.

Prior to an assessment, knowledge of the building systems and components present is necessary, since assessments are done against these components, not against the building as a whole. This information about the systems and components that make up a building is called the BUILDER Inventory. BUILDER has a vast library of predefined components which an assessor will select from, and the inventory collection process involves identifying the type, quantity, and year installed for all pertinent components. These components are also organized into systems and sub-systems according to the UNIFORMAT classification hierarchy. When a specific instance of a component is recorded, this is called a component-section in BUILDER, and represents a single component assembly or collection of like components to be managed as a single unit. The BUILDER facility condition assessment process directly supports the computation of a condition index for building component-sections, known as the Component-Section Condition Index (CSCI), which is the fundamental metric used in BUILDER. The CSCI is aggregated to compute a condition index metric at the system (SCI), building (BCI), and site/organizational levels.

A condition-based facility repair strategy requires condition information be collected at a component level, and that this condition information relate to loss of component function. Every component of a building has a primary function that it performs. This function is the reason that the component was constructed or installed in the building. It may also serve a number of secondary or tertiary functions. For example, for a door component, the primary function is to provide safe entry/egress of authorized movements while limiting unwanted movements of people (security), or other objects (water or moisture). The secondary functions would relate to aesthetics and thermal and air control, among others.

The condition assessment process in BUILDER uses the Direct Rating method.

1. The Direct Rating method uses a single qualitative rating for each component based on condition observations. This also results in a condition index metric, which relates to the level of deterioration and the loss of function. This abbreviated Direct Rating approach is often better suited to initial baseline assessments where the components are inventoried, and data is initially loaded into BUILDER.

BUILDER Report Overview

Outlined below is a summary and description of the reports that are included.

Appendix C - Facility Summary Report – Provides a summation of FCA results. A Building Summary Report is included for each building that is considered permanent or semi-permanent construction and receives a Q-Rating. The purpose of this report is to provide a general overview of the building including key performance indicators. This report was generated using DoDEA's calculated Replacement Cost overwriting the data populated from real property records. This provides a more accurate Replacement Cost due to the inconsistencies with real property reconciliation between DoDEA and the Services. The DoD Facility Pricing Guide and DoDEA measurements for building square footage were used to calculate the Replacement Cost.

Appendix D - System Summary Report – Provides an overview of inspected systems and their condition index rating. A Building System Condition Index (SCI) By System Report is included for each building that is considered permanent or semi-permanent construction and receives a Q-Rating.

Appendix E - Work Items By Building – Provides a list of work items requiring repair or replacement of system/components, including budgets, for project planning purposes. A Work Plan Detail by Year Report is included for each building that is considered permanent or semi-permanent construction and receives a Q- Rating.

Appendix F - Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report – Provides a detailed overview of systems/components, including descriptions, and their respective age, remaining service life and remaining paint life.

Appendix G - Direct Condition Rating Inspection By Section Report – Provides a summary of direct condition ratings for each component-section collected within each facility.

Appendix H - System Inventory Report – Provides a list of details for each component-section collected within each facility.

Appendix I - Fire Inspection Safety Report – This appendix is only applicable when a Fire Inspection Safety Report is provided at the time of the assessment for inclusion in the Facility Condition Assessment Report.

The report provides a summary of the recent Fire Inspection to include any deficiencies.

Note: All reports are generated from the DoDEA BUILDER database. In the event line items within a report are compressed and difficult to read, this is a result of how BUILDER generates the report. It is our understanding that CERL is working to update the report format.

Appendix C

Facility Summary Report

Appendix D

System Summary Report

Appendix E

Work Items By Building

B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE2017

2002 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE CIP Concrete

1,040 (SF) Paint 0.00B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS

-- Paint B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE CIP Concrete

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)200 - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 200

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 1 of 10April 30, 2020

C30 INTERIOR FINISHES2015

1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS Other

2,868 (SF) Replace 0.00C3010 WALL FINISHES

-- Replace C3010 WALL FINISHES 1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS General

D20 PLUMBING2015

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

6,391 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,033 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS Unknown

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

521 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

16 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

D30 HVAC2015

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS Chiller 1 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,000 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Hot Water Dist D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 2 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

150 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Chilled Water Dist D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

1954 D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

43 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS Fan Coils D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

C30 INTERIOR FINISHES2016

1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS Other

2,868 (SF) Replace 0.00C3010 WALL FINISHES

-- Replace C3010 WALL FINISHES 1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS General

D20 PLUMBING2016

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

6,391 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,033 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS Unknown

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

521 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

16 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

D30 HVAC2016

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 3 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS Chiller 1 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,000 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Hot Water Dist D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

150 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Chilled Water Dist D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

1954 D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

43 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS Fan Coils D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE2017

1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Cement Boards / Panels

1,334 (SF) Paint 0.00B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS

-- Paint B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Cementitous Boards / Panels

1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE E.I.F.S.

26,576 (SF) Paint 0.00B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS

-- Paint B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE E.I.F.S.

1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General

11,435 (SF) Paint 0.00B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS

-- Paint B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General

C10 INTERIOR CONSTRUCTION2017

1954 C101001 FIXED PARTITIONS Wall - Concrete Block

37,747 (SF) Paint 0.00C1010 PARTITIONS

-- Paint C1010 PARTITIONS 1954 C101001 FIXED PARTITIONS General

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 4 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 C103002 TOILET & BATH ACCESSORIES General

19 (EA) Replace 0.00C1030 SPECIALTIES

-- Replace C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103002 TOILET & BATH ACCESSORIES General

C30 INTERIOR FINISHES2017

1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS Other

2,868 (SF) Replace 0.00C3010 WALL FINISHES

-- Replace C3010 WALL FINISHES 1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS General

1954 C302004 RESILIENT FLOOR FINISHES Composition Sheet

4,400 (SF) Replace 0.00C3020 FLOOR FINISHES

-- Replace C3020 FLOOR FINISHES 1954 C302004 RESILIENT FLOOR FINISHES Composition Sheet

1954 C303003 PLASTER CEILING FINISHES General

2,392 (SF) Paint 0.00C3030 CEILING FINISHES

-- Paint C3030 CEILING FINISHES 1954 C303003 PLASTER CEILING FINISHES General

D20 PLUMBING2017

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

6,391 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,033 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS Unknown

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

521 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

16 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 5 of 10April 30, 2020

D30 HVAC2017

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS Chiller 1 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,000 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Hot Water Dist D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

150 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Chilled Water Dist D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Unknown

1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS MUA-1 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit

1954 D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

43 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS Fan Coils D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton

D40 FIRE PROTECTION2017

1954 D401001 FIRE ALARM DISTRIBUTION Other

11 (SF) Repair 0.00D4010 FIRE ALARM AND DETECTION SYSTEMS

-- Repair D4010 FIRE ALARM AND DETECTION SYSTEMS D401001 FIRE ALARM DISTRIBUTION Fire detection systems, 50 detectors

B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE2018

1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General

11,435 (SF) Paint 0.00B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS

-- Paint B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General

D20 PLUMBING2018

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 6 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

12,681 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION 1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

13,110 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,542 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

D30 HVAC2018

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,085 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

108 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

10 (EA) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

D50 ELECTRICAL2018

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 7 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY

-- Replace D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY 1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

D20 PLUMBING2019

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

12,681 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION 1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

13,110 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,542 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

D30 HVAC2019

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,085 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

108 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

10 (EA) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 8 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

D50 ELECTRICAL2019

1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY

-- Replace D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY 1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

1954 D503007 CLOCK & PROGRAM SYSTEMS General

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY

-- Replace D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY 1954 D503007 CLOCK & PROGRAM SYSTEMS General

D20 PLUMBING2020

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

10,995 (LF) Replace 0.00D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION

-- Replace D2020 DOMESTIC WATER DISTRIBUTION 1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General

1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

5,498 (LF) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General

1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

1,337 (EA) Replace 0.00D2030 SANITARY WASTE

-- Replace D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General

D30 HVAC2020

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3030 COOLING GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air Cooled Screw Liquid Chiller

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 9 of 10April 30, 2020

1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1,085 (MBH) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

108 (TON) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General

1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

10 (EA) Replace 0.00D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS

-- Replace D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM

1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS

-- Replace D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, includes standard controls

D50 ELECTRICAL2020

1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY

-- Replace D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY 1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets

1954 D503007 CLOCK & PROGRAM SYSTEMS General

1 (EA) Replace 0.00D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY

-- Replace D5030 COMMUNICATIONS & SECURITY 1954 D503007 CLOCK & PROGRAM SYSTEMS General

Camp Darby

Year System

Completion Date

Qty (UM) CostActivity

Section Description

Component Status

-- Description

ScoreProject

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Cost Book: Reference

Work Items by Building Report

Page 10 of 10April 30, 2020

Appendix F

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 2002 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE CIP Concrete 18 39 15

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 2002 B201010 EXTERIOR JOINT SEALANT General 18 8

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 2002 B203001 SOLID DOORS Steel 18 8

B30 ROOFING B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 2002 B301002 LOW SLOPE ROOF SYSTEMS Built-Up 18 4

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 2002 B301005 GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS Downspouts 18 8

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 2002 B301005 GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS Gutters 18 8

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)200 - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 200

Section Description Age (yrs) RSL (yrs) RPL (yrs)ComponentSystem

Camp Darby

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

Page 1 of 5April 30, 2020

B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Cement Boards / Panels 40 12 Unknown

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE E.I.F.S. 40 20 Unknown

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Wall Louver 40 12 20

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201004 PARAPETS General 15 10

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201006 BALCONY WALLS & HANDRAILS Ladder 31 6

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General 13 8 Unknown

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1954 B201010 EXTERIOR JOINT SEALANT General 31 4

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 1954 B202001 WINDOWS Aluminum Windows 31 31

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 1954 B202002 STOREFRONTS General 21 8

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 1954 B202090 OTHER EXTERIOR WINDOWS General 31 34

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 1954 B203001 SOLID DOORS Aluminum 21 8

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 1954 B203001 SOLID DOORS Wood 21 6

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 1954 B203090 OTHER EXTERIOR SPECIALTY DOORS Emergency Egress D

21 6

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 1954 A B203001 SOLID DOORS Aluminum 6 8

B30 ROOFING B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301002 LOW SLOPE ROOF SYSTEMS Built-Up 15 4

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301003 ROOF INSULATION & FILL General 15 5

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Apron 15 10

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Base 15 10

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Cap 6 7

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Embedded Edge Metal 15 10

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301005 GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS Downspouts 15 8

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301005 GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS Gutters 15 8

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301006 ROOF OPENINGS AND SUPPORTS Gravity Ventilator - 6" Diameter

66 8

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301006 ROOF OPENINGS AND SUPPORTS Skylights 20 7

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1954 B301090 OTHER ROOFING General 15 4

C10 INTERIOR

CONSTRUCTION

C1010 PARTITIONS 1954 C101001 FIXED PARTITIONS Wall - Concrete Block 66 39 26

C1010 PARTITIONS 1954 C101005 INTERIOR WINDOWS Interior Windows 30 20

C1010 PARTITIONS 1954 C101005 INTERIOR WINDOWS Metal Rollup / Coiling Grille 30 8

C1020 INTERIOR DOORS 1954 C102001 STANDARD INTERIOR DOORS Wood Door/Wood Frame 21 12

C1020 INTERIOR DOORS 1954 C102002 GLAZED INTERIOR DOORS General 21 16

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Section Description Age (yrs) RSL (yrs) RPL (yrs)ComponentSystem

Camp Darby

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103001 COMPARTMENTS, CUBICLES & TOILET PARTITIONS Toilet P titi

30 6

Page 2 of 5April 30, 2020

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103001 COMPARTMENTS, CUBICLES & TOILET PARTITIONS Urinal S

30 6

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103002 TOILET & BATH ACCESSORIES General 27 6

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103003 MARKER BOARDS & TACK BOARDS General 12 8

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103008 COUNTERS Laminated Plastic 27 9

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103008 COUNTERS Stone 10 15

C1030 SPECIALTIES 1954 C103009 CABINETS Other 27 6

C20 STAIRS C2010 STAIR CONSTRUCTION 1954 C201001 INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR STAIRS Interior Steps 31 8

C2010 STAIR CONSTRUCTION 1954 C201001 INTERIOR AND EXTERIOR STAIRS Interior Steps - Concrete 31 8

C2010 STAIR CONSTRUCTION 1954 C201090 STAIR HANDRAILS, GUARDRAILS AND ACCESSORIES General

31 8

C30 INTERIOR FINISHES C3010 WALL FINISHES 1954 C301004 TILE & TERRAZZO WALL FINISHES Tile 13 39

C3010 WALL FINISHES 1954 C301005 WALL COVERINGS Other 13 3

C3020 FLOOR FINISHES 1954 C302001 TILE FLOOR FINISHES Ceramic Tile 2 39

C3020 FLOOR FINISHES 1954 C302003 WOOD FLOORING General 31 12

C3020 FLOOR FINISHES 1954 C302004 RESILIENT FLOOR FINISHES Composition Sheet 31 5

C3030 CEILING FINISHES 1954 C303001 ACOUSTICAL CEILING TILES & PANELS General 27 21

C3030 CEILING FINISHES 1954 C303003 PLASTER CEILING FINISHES General 27 65 25

C3030 CEILING FINISHES 1954 C303005 SUSPENSION SYSTEMS General 27 6

C3030 CEILING FINISHES 1954 C303006 METAL STRIP CEILINGS General 27 12

D20 PLUMBING D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201001 WATERCLOSETS General 31 10

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201002 URINALS General 31 10

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201003 LAVATORIES General 31 10

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201004 SINKS Kitchen Sink 31 18

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201004 SINKS Service Sink 31 10

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201006 DRINKING FOUNTAINS AND COOLERS Water Cooler 3 10

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201090 OTHER PLUMBING FIXTURES Emergency Eye Wash 31 13

D2010 PLUMBING FIXTURES 1954 D201090 OTHER PLUMBING FIXTURES Emergency Shower 31 13

D2020 DOMESTIC WATER

DISTRIBUTION

1954 D202001 PIPES & FITTINGS General 66 0

D2020 DOMESTIC WATER

DISTRIBUTION

1954 D202003 DOMESTIC WATER EQUIPMENT Water Heaters, Residential, Electric

6 10

D2020 DOMESTIC WATER

DISTRIBUTION

1954 M101 D202003 DOMESTIC WATER EQUIPMENT Storage Tank - Glass lined PE 80 gallon 20" diameter 64" L O A

9 9

D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203001 WASTE PIPE & FITTINGS General 66 0

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Section Description Age (yrs) RSL (yrs) RPL (yrs)ComponentSystem

Camp Darby

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203002 VENT PIPE & FITTINGS General 66 0

Page 3 of 5April 30, 2020

D2030 SANITARY WASTE 1954 D203003 FLOOR DRAINS General 66 8

D30 HVAC D3010 ENERGY SUPPLY 1954 D301002 GAS SUPPLY SYSTEM Fuel Storage Tank - Fuel Storage Tank, 2500 G L

66 15

D3020 HEAT GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 M101 D302004 AUXILIARY EQUIPMENT Expansion Tank - 30 gal 10 15

D3020 HEAT GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 M101 D302004 AUXILIARY EQUIPMENT Expansion Tank - 60 gal 10 15

D3020 HEAT GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 M101 B1 D302001 BOILERS Gas, Hot Water - 650-900 MBH 11 15

D3020 HEAT GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 M101 B2 D302001 BOILERS Gas, Hot Water - 650-900 MBH 11 15

D3020 HEAT GENERATING SYSTEMS 1954 M101 B3 D302001 BOILERS Gas, Hot Water - 650-900 MBH 11 15

D3030 COOLING GENERATING

SYSTEMS

1954 D303001 CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS Chiller, Rotary Screw - 180 TN, Air C l S Li i Chill

24 0

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General 31 0

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Circulating Pump, E S ti 3" i 5 HP t 225 GPM

10 10

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304006 CHILLED WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS General 24 0

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 D304007 EXHAUST SYSTEMS Fan System, Roof Exhaust - 800 CFM 40 0

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 M101 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Circulating Pump, End Suction 3" size 5 HP to 225 GPM

10 10

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 M101 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Circulating Pump, E S ti 4" i 7 1/2 HP t 350 GPM

11 10

D3040 DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS 1954 M101 D304003 HOT WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS Heat Exchanger, Plate Type 1200 GPM

24 8

D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305001 UNIT VENTILATORS Make-Up Air Unit - 14,000 CFM, 1180 MBH, i l t t l

31 0

D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305002 UNIT HEATERS Hydronic - 200 MBH 20 9

D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 D305003 FAN COIL UNITS Cab Mount, Two Pipe - 1-1/2 ton 31 8

D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 A D305006 PACKAGE UNITS A/C Unit, Split Systems w/ Air Cooled Condenser 2 TN

4 10

D3050 TERMINAL & PACKAGE UNITS 1954 B D305006 PACKAGE UNITS A/C Unit, Split Systems w/ Air Cooled

C 2 TN

15 2

D40 FIRE PROTECTION D4010 FIRE ALARM AND DETECTION

SYSTEMS

1954 D401001 FIRE ALARM DISTRIBUTION Other 18 2

D4030 STANDPIPE SYSTEMS 1954 D403001 STANDPIPE EQUIPMENT & PIPING Riser - 4" diam 6 10

D4090 OTHER FIRE PROTECTION

SYSTEMS

1954 D409004 HOOD & DUCT FIRE PROTECTION General 16 10

D50 ELECTRICAL D5010 ELECTRICAL SERVICE &

DISTRIBUTION

1954 D501004 PANELBOARDS Main lugs, 400 amp 20 8

D5010 ELECTRICAL SERVICE &

DISTRIBUTION

1954 D501004 PANELBOARDS Safety Switch, < 30 Amp 31 15

D5010 ELECTRICAL SERVICE &

DISTRIBUTION

1954 D501006 MOTOR CONTROL CENTERS Motor Control Center - Size 3, 50 HP 24" high

31 21

D5020 LIGHTING & BRANCH WIRING 1954 D502001 BRANCH WIRING General 31 29

D5020 LIGHTING & BRANCH WIRING 1954 D502002 LIGHTING EQUIPMENT General 11 10

D5030 COMMUNICATIONS &

SECURITY

1954 D503002 PUBLIC ADDRESS SYSTEMS 30 outlets 25 0

D5030 COMMUNICATIONS &

SECURITY

1954 D503003 INTERCOMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS 25 stations 25 8

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Section Description Age (yrs) RSL (yrs) RPL (yrs)ComponentSystem

Camp Darby

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

D5030 COMMUNICATIONS &

SECURITY

1954 D503005 SECURITY SYSTEMS General 18 10

Page 4 of 5April 30, 2020

D5030 COMMUNICATIONS &

SECURITY

1954 D503007 CLOCK & PROGRAM SYSTEMS General 25 0

D5090 OTHER ELECTRICAL

SERVICES

1954 D509003 GROUNDING SYSTEMS General 6 44

E10 EQUIPMENT E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *CONVECTION OVEN SINGLE A E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General

6 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *CONVECTION OVEN SINGLE B E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT

G l

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *DEEP FRYER E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General 11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *DISH WASHER E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General 6 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *RANGE GAS E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General 11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR A E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT G l

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR B E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT General

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR C E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT G l

6 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR D E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT General

6 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *SERVING LINE COOLER E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General 6 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN A E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT General

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN B E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT G l

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN C E109002 FOOD SERVICE

EQUIPMENT General

11 13

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT *STEAMER 2 DOOR E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General 11 13

Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201*

Section Description Age (yrs) RSL (yrs) RPL (yrs)ComponentSystem

Camp Darby

Remaining Service Life (RSL) Detail Report

Page 5 of 5April 30, 2020

Appendix G

Direct Condition Rating Inspection By Section Report

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*CONVECTION OVEN SINGLE A E109002 FOOD SERVICE

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*CONVECTION OVEN SINGLE B E109002 FOOD SERVICE

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*DEEP FRYER E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*DISH WASHER E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*RANGE GAS E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR A E109002 FOOD

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR B E109002 FOOD

201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201* Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)

Camp Darby

ComponentSection Description Quantity (UM)System

Direct Condition Rating Inspection Report by Section

Page 2 of 18April 30, 2020

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR C E109002 FOOD

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*REFRIGERATOR REACH IN 2 DOOR D E109002 FOOD

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*SERVING LINE COOLER E109002 FOOD SERVICE

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN A E109002 FOOD

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN B E109002 FOOD

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*STEAM COUNTER ELECTRIC MULTI BASIN C E109002 FOOD

201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201* Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)

Camp Darby

ComponentSection Description Quantity (UM)System

Direct Condition Rating Inspection Report by Section

Page 3 of 18April 30, 2020

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

E1090 OTHER EQUIPMENT 1 (EA)E10 EQUIPMENT*STEAMER 2 DOOR E109002 FOOD SERVICE EQUIPMENT

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

A+ InspectionPaint Rating:

Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1,334 (SF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Cement Boards / Panels

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

A+ InspectionPaint Rating:

Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 26,576 (SF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE E.I.F.S.

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

A+ InspectionPaint Rating:

Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 248 (SF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201001 EXTERIOR CLOSURE Wall Louver

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G-

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 1,009 (LF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201004 PARAPETS General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 23 (LF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201006 BALCONY WALLS & HANDRAILS Ladder

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 11,435 (SF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201007 EXTERIOR SOFFITS General

201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201* Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)

Camp Darby

ComponentSection Description Quantity (UM)System

Direct Condition Rating Inspection Report by Section

Page 4 of 18April 30, 2020

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

A+ InspectionPaint Rating:

Inspection Comments:

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A-

Inspection

The joint sealants are cracking and shrinking, potentially allowing water infiltration.Inspection Comments:

B2010 EXTERIOR WALLS 2,343 (LF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B201010 EXTERIOR JOINT SEALANT General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

The windows are generally in operable condition although the exterior finishes are deteriorating.Inspection Comments:

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 77 (EA)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B202001 WINDOWS Aluminum Windows

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 432 (SF)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B202002 STOREFRONTS General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

G-

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B2020 EXTERIOR WINDOWS 71 (EA)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B202090 OTHER EXTERIOR WINDOWS General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 14 (EA)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B203001 SOLID DOORS Aluminum

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A

Inspection

The door finish is cracked and deteriorated.Inspection Comments:

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 2 (EA)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B203001 SOLID DOORS Wood

201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201* Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)

Camp Darby

ComponentSection Description Quantity (UM)System

Direct Condition Rating Inspection Report by Section

Page 5 of 18April 30, 2020

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A

Inspection

The doors are difficult to secure properly and finishes are weathered.Inspection Comments:

B2030 EXTERIOR DOORS 34 (EA)B20 EXTERIOR ENCLOSURE1954 B203090 OTHER EXTERIOR SPECIALTY DOORS

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 45,386 (SF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301002 LOW SLOPE ROOF SYSTEMS Built-Up

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

01-Jan-2005 No

Inspection Source:

G+

InstallDate

Original InspectionInspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 45,386 (SF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301003 ROOF INSULATION & FILL General

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1,147 (LF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Apron

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1,147 (LF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Base

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A

Inspection

The flashing and roof detailing are showing deterioration.Inspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 1,502 (LF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Cap

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 5,497 (LF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301004 FLASHINGS & TRIM Flashings - Embedded

201* - Livorno ES/MS Bldg 201* Livorno ES/MS (HE5408)

Camp Darby

ComponentSection Description Quantity (UM)System

Direct Condition Rating Inspection Report by Section

Page 6 of 18April 30, 2020

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

Last Inspection Date: Condition Rating: Used Sampling?

Inspector:

07-Jan-2020 No

Inspection Source:

A+

Inspection

Inspection Comments:

B3010 ROOF COVERINGS 671 (LF)B30 ROOFING1954 B301005 GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS Downspouts

La…