Appendix B - Hazardous Material Report.pdf

Asbestos Survey VA Project: Upgrade Air Terminals

VA Project Number: 539-21-111 Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC)

3200 Vine Street, Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Prepared for:

FFE, Inc.

Cincinnati, OH 45246

Prepared by:

Terracon Consultants, Inc.

Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

Terracon Consul tants, Inc., 611 Lunken Park Dr ive, Cincinnat i , OH 45226 P (513) 321-5816 terracon.com

March 10, 2021

FFE, Inc.

110 Boggs Lane, Suite 170 Cincinnati, OH 45246

Attn: Mr. Clint Weekley, PE, CBCP, LEED AP President P: 513-519-5999 (cell) E: clint.weekley@ffe-serv.com

Re: Asbestos Survey Report VA Project: Upgrade Air Terminal Units VA Project No.: 539-21-111 Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC) 3200 Vine Street, Cincinnati, OH 45220 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Dear Mr. Weekley:

Terracon Consultants, Inc. (Terracon) is pleased to submit the attached report for the above-referenced renovation project to FFE, Inc. (Client). The purpose of this report is to present the results of an asbestos survey, which was performed at the Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC) on various days during the month of February of 2021, and in general accordance with our proposal number PN1207213, dated May 13, 2020. We understand that this survey was requested for the purpose of a planned renovation project pertaining to upgrading air terminal units and associated mechanical systems/components at the CVAMC.

Asbestos-containing materials (ACM) were identified as a result of this project-specific survey at the CVAMC. Please refer to the attached report for further detail.

Terracon appreciates the opportunity to provide this service to FFE, Inc. If you have any questions regarding this report, please contact the undersigned at 513-321-5816.

Sincerely, Terracon Consultants, Inc.

Josh Vogel Joseph A. Tussey, CHMM Project Manager Sr. Associate / Group Manager

OH AHES #35291 OH AHES #32388

Project: Upgrade Air Terminal Units CVAMC March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Project Objective

1.2 Reliance

2.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION

3.0 FIELD ACTIVITIES

3.1 Visual Assessment

3.2 Physical Assessment

3.3 Sample Collection

3.4 Sample Analysis

4.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW

5.0 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

6.0 LIMITATIONS/GENERAL COMMENTS

APPENDIX A IDENTIFIED ASBESTOS-CONTAINING MATERIALS BY HOMOGENEOUS AREA (HA)

APPENDIX B ASBESTOS SURVEY SAMPLE & RESULTS SUMMARY

APPENDIX C ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL LABORATORY REPORT

APPENDIX D LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS

APPENDIX E SAMPLE & ACM LOCATION DRAWINGS

APPENDIX F PHOTO LOG

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 1

ASBESTOS SURVEY

VA Project: Upgrade Air Terminal Units

VA Project No.: 539-21-111 Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC)

3200 Vine Street, Cincinnati, Ohio 45220 Terracon Project No. N1207213

March 10, 2021

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Terracon Consultants, Inc. (Terracon) conducted an asbestos survey specifically limited to within the boundaries and intent of the planned renovation project entitled “Upgrade Air Terminals Units” at the Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC). The survey was performed on various days during the month of February of 2021 by United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA)-accredited asbestos inspectors who were also certified by the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) as Asbestos Hazard Evaluation Specialists (AHES). Based on Client-provided renovation drawings, accessible building components and areas intended to be impacted by the renovation project were surveyed. Homogeneous areas of suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACM) were visually identified and documented. Although reasonable effort was made to survey accessible suspect materials, additional suspect but un-sampled materials could be located in walls, in voids, or in other concealed areas. Suspect ACM samples were collected in general accordance with the sampling protocols outlined in USEPA 40 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 763, Subpart E, known as the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA).

Samples were delivered to an accredited laboratory for analysis by Polarized Light Microscopy

(PLM).

1.1 Project Objective

Terracon understand the renovation project pertains to various upgrades of air terminal units and associated mechanical systems/components throughout the CVAMC. Please note that asbestos surveys are required prior to renovation and demolition projects to satisfy requirements of the USEPA 40 CFR Part 61, Subpart M, the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) regulation (as well as the state NESHAP equivalent).

1.2 Reliance

This report is for the exclusive use of FFE, Inc (Client) for the project being discussed. Reliance by any other party on this report is prohibited without written authorization of Terracon and the Client. Reliance on this report by the Client and all authorized parties will be subject to the terms, conditions, and limitations stated in the proposal and the agreement between Terracon and the Client

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 2

2.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION

Terracon understood the renovation project pertains to various mechanical systems/components including upgrades on air terminal units at the CVAMC. Client-provided renovation drawings were used as a “road-map” for this project-specific survey.

3.0 FIELD ACTIVITIES

The survey was conducted by Mr. Lemuel Weyer and Mr. Tyler Stenten, USEPA-accredited asbestos inspectors and OEPA-certified AHES. Copies of their Ohio AHES credentials are attached as Appendix D. The survey was conducted in general accordance with the sample collection protocols established in USEPA 40 CFR Part 763, Subpart E, Section 763.86, AHERA.

A summary of survey activities is provided below.

3.1 Visual Assessment

Based on a review of Client-provided drawings, survey activities were initiated with visual observation of project-specific accessible areas and accessible building components to be impacted by the renovation project to identify homogeneous areas of suspect ACM. A homogeneous area (HA) consists of building materials that appear similar throughout in terms of color and texture with consideration given to the date of application.

3.2 Physical Assessment

A physical assessment of each HA of suspect ACM was conducted to assess the friability and condition of the materials. A friable material is defined by the USEPA as a material which can be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure when dry. Friability was assessed by physically touching suspect materials.

3.3 Sample Collection

Based on results of the visual observation, bulk samples of suspect ACM were collected in general accordance with USEPA AHERA sampling protocols. Samples of suspect materials were collected from randomly selected locations in each homogeneous area. Bulk samples were collected using wet methods as applicable to reduce the potential for fiber release. Samples were placed in sealable containers and labeled with unique sample numbers using an indelible marker.

The selection of sample locations and frequency of sampling were based on Terracon’s observations and the assumption that like materials in the same area are homogeneous in content.

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 3

Terracon collected a total of 200 bulk samples from 59 homogeneous areas of suspect ACM. A summary of suspect ACM samples collected during the survey is included as Appendix B.

3.4 Sample Analysis

Bulk samples were submitted under chain of custody to EMSL Analytical, Inc. (EMSL) of Indianapolis, Indiana for analysis PLM with dispersion staining techniques per USEPA methodology 600/R-93/116. The percentage of asbestos, where applicable, was determined by microscopic visual estimation. When applicable for friable material samples determined by PLM to have a low asbestos content (<10%), the additional point count (PC) method was utilized.

EMSL is accredited under the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP), accreditation number 200188-0.

The laboratory analytical report is included in Appendix C.

4.0 REGULATORY OVERVIEW

The asbestos NESHAP (40 CFR Part 61, Subpart M) regulates asbestos fiber emissions and asbestos waste disposal practices. The asbestos NESHAP regulation also requires the identification and classification of existing ACM according to friability prior to demolition or renovation activity. Friable ACM is a material containing more than 1% asbestos that, when dry, can be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure. All friable ACM is considered regulated asbestos containing material (RACM).

The asbestos NESHAP regulation classifies material subject to demolition or renovation as either RACM, Category I non-friable ACM, or Category II non-friable ACM. RACM includes all friable ACM (pre-disturbance), along with Category I non-friable ACM that becomes friable (during disturbance), and Category I non-friable ACM subject to sanding, grinding, cutting, or abrading, or Category II non-friable ACM with a high probability of becoming crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by forces expected to act on the material during disturbance. Category I non-friable ACM are exclusively asbestos-containing packings, gaskets, resilient floor coverings, and asphalt roofing products that contain more than 1% asbestos. Category II non-friable ACM are all other non-friable materials (other than Category I non-friable ACM) that contain more than 1% asbestos. Category II non-friable ACM generally includes (but is not limited to) cementitious material such as: cement pipes, cement siding (Transite™), cement panels, glazing, mortar, and grouts.

The Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (OEPA) adopted Chapter 3745-20 of the Ohio Administrative Code and implements the Asbestos NESHAP. The owner or operator must provide the OEPA district office or local air agency with written notification at least 10 business days prior to the commencement demolition projects and prior to removal of friable ACMs in quantities greater than 50 linear or 50 square feet. The OEPA also regulates friable asbestos abatement activities, asbestos personnel training, and issuance of asbestos professional certifications under

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 4

OAC 3745-22. OEPA audits asbestos abatement projects and responds to public health emergencies where friable ACMs has been released. Please note that per OEPA regulations, non-friable floor tile if broken into pieces four (4) square inches or smaller are considered friable, and thus as a RACM.

The United States Occupational Safety and Health Administration (USOSHA) asbestos standard for construction (29 CFR 1926.1101) regulates workplace exposure to asbestos. The USOSHA standard requires that employee exposure to airborne asbestos must not exceed 0.1 fibers per cubic centimeter of air (0.1 f/cc) as an eight-hour time weighted average (TWA) and not exceed

1.0 fibers per cubic centimeter of air (1.0 f/cc) over a 30-minute time period known as an excursion limit (EL). The TWA and EL are known as USOSHA’s asbestos permissible exposure limits (PELs). The USOSHA standard classifies construction and maintenance activities which could disturb ACM and specifies work practices and precautions which employers must follow when engaging in each class of regulated work.

5.0 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Specific to the subject renovation project areas and components to be impacted based on Client-provided renovation drawings, asbestos was identified by laboratory analysis in samples collected from the following materials:

ACM Description Material Location % and Type Asbestos Condition Estimated

Quantity*

White Mudded Fittings Associated with

Fiberglass Pipe Lines in Northwest Hallway in

Area A of the Basement

1.50% Chrysotile by Point Count

(PC)

Good/Non- Friable ~6 LF or 6 Fittings

White Mudded Fittings Associated with

Fiberglass Pipe Line in Hallway to East Entrance to Basement Room B022

0.50% Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable ~1 LF or 1 Fitting

Tan Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work in Chapel and West Hallway of Area A on the

1st Floor

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~150 SF of Duct Mastic

Gray-Brown Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work in Room A144 and Area C of 1st Floor (Under

Fiberglass Insulation)

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~200 SF of Duct Mastic

Tan Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work in Area C and Main Hallway on the 1st Floor

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~100 SF of Duct Mastic

Tan Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work in Main Hallway of Area B on the 2nd Floor

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~150 SF of Duct Mastic

Tan Duct Mastic

Associated with Duct Work in Area C and

Room A246 on the 2nd

Floor 2% Chrysotile Good/Non-

Friable ~75 SF of Duct

Mastic

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 5

ACM Description Material Location % and Type Asbestos Condition Estimated

Quantity*

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Pipe Lines throughout Area B and Main Elevator Lobby on the 3rd Floor

0.25% Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable

~52 LF or 52 Fittings

White Preformed Black Pipe Insulation and Fittings

Associated with Steam Lines in PACU Area and

North Walkway of the Central Hallway on the 3rd

Floor

30% Amosite, 15% Chrysotile

Good/Non- Friable ~90 LF

Tan Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work in South Hallway and Adjacent Rooms of Area C of the 3rd Floor

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~100 SF of Duct Mastic

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Pipe Lines in 4th Floor Elevator Lobby and Adjacent Rooms

0.25% Chrysotile by

PC, 0.25%

Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable

~18 LF or 18 Fittings

Tan Duct Mastic Associated with Duct

Work throughout Area B of the 4th Floor

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~125 SF of Duct Mastic

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Pipe Lines throughout Area B of the 4th Floor

0.25% Amosite by PC, 0.25% Chrysotile by

PC

Good/Non- Friable

~16 LF or 16 Fittings

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Water Lines throughout Area B of the 6th Floor

0.75% Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable

~14 LF or 14 Fittings

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Water Lines in Main Elevator Lobby of the 7th Floor

<0.25% Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable

~12 LF or 12 Fittings

White Mudded Fittings

Associated with Fiberglass Water Lines in Main Elevator Lobby of the 8th Floor

0.50% Amosite by PC

Good/Non- Friable ~ 6 LF or 6 Fittings

Tan Duct Mastic

Associated with Large Duct Work in the

Crawlspace of Area C of the Basement (Under Fiberglass Insulation)

2% Chrysotile Good/Non- Friable

~ 200 SF of Duct Mastic

Corrugated Paper Pipe Insulation and Mudded

Fittings

Associated with Lines to Heater Units in Rooms

B501, B503, B504, B539, B540, A539, A540, A541 and A542

Assumed (Based on Prior Knowledge of Past Surveys)

Good/Friable ~140 LF

*Estimated quantities listed above are based on a cursory field evaluation, and actual quantities may vary significantly, especially if ACMs are present outside of the renovation areas, and in hidden and/or inaccessible areas not evaluated as part of this survey. This is not a bidding document and contractors would be responsible for drawing their own conclusions on quantities present. Please note that the quantities listed for duct mastic are Terracon’s opinion of asbestos-containing duct mastic present on ductwork to be impacted by the project, and the quantities listed are not meant to refer to actual square footage of duct surfaces or runs of duct work in linear feet. Additionally, please note that duct mastic is on hard metal ductwork, and in some instances, it may be located under non-asbestos-containing fiberglass insulation.

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable 6

A sample and results summary table is included in Appendix B, the laboratory analytical report is included in Appendix C, drawings indicating sample and ACM locations are included in Appendix E, and example photos of the identified materials are included in Appendix F.

If the identified ACMs will be impacted by the renovation project, such materials will first need to be properly removed, handled, and disposed by a state-licensed abatement contractor in accordance with applicable federal and state EPA asbestos regulations, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) asbestos regulations, and per VA abatement project specifications.

It should be noted that inaccessible/concealed suspect materials, other than those identified during this survey, may exist. This survey did not include disassembling equipment or electrical wiring/electrical components as the building was fully active/operational and inspecting/sampling such equipment/materials would representative a safety hazard to the inspector. Should additional suspect materials be uncovered prior to or during renovation activities, those materials must be assumed asbestos-containing until sampled by a state-licensed asbestos inspector and analysis refutes the positive assumption.

6.0 LIMITATIONS/GENERAL COMMENTS

The survey was project-specific and limited to the HVAC/building components indicated on Client-provided drawings to be impacted and within the boundaries of the areas to be renovated. This survey is not meant to be a comprehensive survey of the entire facilities. In addition, Terracon did not perform sampling which required demolition or destructive activities such as knocking large holes in walls, dismantling of equipment or removal of protective coverings. Reasonable efforts to access suspect materials within known areas of restricted access (e.g., crawl spaces) were made; however, confined spaces or areas/equipment which may pose a health or safety risk to Terracon personnel were not sampled (inspecting/opening energizing equipment, inspecting/sampling electrical wiring and similar components). Sampling did not include suspect materials which could not be safely reached with available ladders/man-lifts.

This asbestos survey was conducted in a manner consistent with the level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of the profession currently practicing under similar conditions in the same locale. The results, findings, conclusions, and recommendations expressed in this report are based on conditions observed during our survey of the building. The information contained in this report is relevant to the date on which this survey was performed and should not be relied upon to represent conditions at a later date. This report has been prepared on behalf of and exclusively for use by FFE, Inc. for specific application to their project as discussed. This report is not a bidding document. Contractors or consultants reviewing this report must draw their own conclusions regarding quantities, further investigation or remediation deemed necessary. Terracon does not warrant the work of regulatory agencies, laboratories, or other third-parties supplying information which may have been used in the preparation of this report. No warranty, express or implied is made.

Re sp on si ve Re so ur ce fu l Re lia bl e

AP

PE

N D

IX

A

VA

Pr oj ec t:

U pg ra de Ai rT er m in al U ni ts

VA

Pr oj ec tN o.

:5

-2 1-

C in ci nn at iV

A M ed ic al C en te r( C

VA

M

C

Vi ne

St re et ,C in ci nn at i, O

H

ID

EN

TI

FI

ED

AS

B

ES

TO

S-

C O

NT

AI

N

IN

G M

AT

ER

IA

LS

B Y

HO

M

O G

EN

EO

US

AR

EA

(H

A) HA No

’s

AC

M

De sc rip tio n M at er ia lL oc at io n an d Ty pe As be st os

EP

A

NE

SH

AP

Cl as si fic at io n Co nd iti on

Fr ia bi lit y Es tim at ed Q ua nt ity

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

Pi pe

Li ne s in

N or th w es tH al lw ay in

Ar ea

A of th e

Ba se m en t

1.

C hr ys ot ile by Po in tC ou nt

(P C

R eg ul at ed As be st os

C on ta in in g

M at er ia l (R

AC

M

G oo d/

Fr ia bl e

~6 Li ne ar

Fe et

(L F) or

Fi tti ng s

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

Pi pe

Li ne in H al lw ay to

Ea st

En tra nc e to Ba se m en tR oo m

B0

0.

Am os ite by

PC

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A G oo d/

Fr ia bl e

~1

LF

or

Fi tti ng

Ta n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith D uc tW or k in C ha pe l an d W es tH al lw ay of

Ar ea

A on th e

1st

Fl oo r 2%

C hr ys ot ile C at eg or y

II

N on -F ria bl e G oo d/

N on

Fr ia bl e

~1

Sq ua re Fe et (S

F) of

D uc t M as tic

G ra y-

Br ow n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith D uc tW or k in R oo m

A1 an d

Ar ea

C of

1st Fl oo r(

U nd er Fi be rg la ss

In su la tio

n) 2%

C hr ys ot ile C at eg or y

II

N on -F ria bl e G oo d/

N on

Fr ia bl e ~2

SF

of D uc t

M as tic

Ta n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith D uc tW or k in Ar ea C an d

M ai n H al lw ay on th e

1st Fl oo r

2% C hr ys ot ile

C at eg or y

II

N on

-F ria bl e

G oo d/ N on

Fr ia bl e

~1

SF

of

D uc t M as tic

-1

Ta n

D uc tM as tic As so ci at ed w ith

D uc tW or k in

M ai n H al lw ay an d N or th

H al lw ay of Ar ea B on th e 2nd

Fl oo r 2%

C hr ys ot ile C at eg or y

II

N on -F ria bl e G oo d/

N on

Fr ia bl e ~1

SF

of D uc t

M as tic

-2

Ta n

D uc tM as tic As so ci at ed w ith

D uc tW or k in

Ar ea

C an d R oo m

A2 on th e 2nd

Fl oo r (U nd er

Fi be rg la ss In su la tio n)

2% C hr ys ot ile

C at eg or y

II

N on

-F ria bl e

G oo d/ N on

Fr ia bl e

~7

SF

of

D uc t M as tic

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

Pi pe

Li ne s th ro ug ho ut

Ar ea

B an d M ai n

El ev at or

Lo bb y on th e

3rd Fl oo r

0.

Am os ite by

PC

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~5

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

W hi te

Pr ef or m ed Bl ac k

Pi pe

In su la tio n an d Fi tti ng s As so ci at ed w ith

St ea m Li ne s in

PA

C U

Ar ea an d

N or th W al kw ay of th e

C en tra lH al lw ay on th e

3rd Fl oo r

Am os ite

C hr ys ot ile R

AC

M

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~9

LF

on si ve Re so ur ce fu l Re lia bl e

HA No ’s

AC

M De sc rip tio n

M at er ia lL oc at io n an d

Ty pe

As be st os

EP

A

NE

SH

AP

Cl as si fic at io n

Co nd iti on

Fr ia bi lit y

Es tim at ed

Q ua nt ity

Ta n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith D uc tW or k in So ut h

H al lw ay an d

Ad ja ce nt

R oo m s of Ar ea C of th e 3rd

Fl oo r 2%

C hr ys ot ile C at eg or y

II

N on -F ria bl e G oo d/

N on

Fr ia bl e ~1

SF

of D uc t

M as tic

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

Pi pe

Li ne s in

4th Fl oo rE le va to rL ob by an d

Ad ja ce nt

R oo m s

0.

C hr ys ot ile by

PC

,0 .2

5% Am os ite by

PC

(0 .5

To ta l)

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~1

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

Ta n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith D uc tW or k th ro ug ho ut Ar ea B of th e 4th

Fl oo r 2%

C hr ys ot ile C at eg or y

II

N on -F ria bl e G oo d/

N on

Fr ia bl e ~1

SF

of D uc t

M as tic

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

Pi pe

Li ne s th ro ug ho ut

Ar ea

B of th e

4th Fl oo r

0.

Am os ite by

PC

,0 .2

5% C hr ys ot ile by

PC

(0 .5

To ta l)

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A G oo d/

Fr ia bl e

~1

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

W at er Li ne s th ro ug ho ut Ar ea B of th e 6t h Fl oo r

0.

Am os ite by

PC

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A G oo d/

Fr ia bl e

~1

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

W at er Li ne s in M ai n

El ev at or

Lo bb y of th e

7th

Fl oo r

<0 .2

5% Am os ite by

PC

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~1

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

W hi te

M ud de d

Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Fi be rg la ss

W at er Li ne s in M ai n

El ev at or

Lo bb y of th e

8th

Fl oo r

0.

Am os ite by

PC

N ot

R eg ul at ed by

EP

A

1%

H ow ev er

R eg ul at ed by

O

SH

A

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~6

LF

or

Fi tti ng s

Ta n D uc tM as tic

As so ci at ed w ith La rg e

D uc tW or k in

C ra w ls pa ce of Ar ea C of th e Ba se m en t(

U nd er Fi be rg la ss

In su la tio n)

2% C hr ys ot ile

C at eg or y

II

N on

-F ria bl e

G oo d/ N on

Fr ia bl e

~2

SF

of

D uc t M as tic

C or ru ga te d Pa pe rP ip e

In su la tio n an d M ud de d Fi tti ng s

As so ci at ed w ith Li ne s to H ea te rU ni ts in

R oo m s

B5

,B

3, B5

,B

9, B5

,A

9, A

0, A

1, an d A5

As su m ed

(B as ed on

Pr io r Kn ow le dg e of Pa st Su rv ey

s) R

AC

M

G oo d/ Fr ia bl e ~1

LF

*E st im at ed qu an tit ie s lis te d ab ov e ar e ba se d on a cu rs or y fie ld ev al ua tio n, an d ac tu al qu an tit ie s m ay va ry si gn ific an tly ,e sp ec ia lly if

AC

M s ar e pr es en to ut si de of th e pl an ne d re no va tio n ar ea s, an d in hi dd en an d/ or in ac ce ss ib le ar ea s no te va lu at ed as pa rt of th is su rv ey .T hi s is no ta bi dd in g do cu m en ta nd co nt ra ct or s w ou ld be re sp on si bl e fo rd ra w in g th ei ro w n co nc lu si on s re ga rd in g qu an tit ie s pr es en t.

Pl ea se no te th at th e qu an tit ie s lis te d ar e Te rra co n’ s op in io n of as be st os -c on ta in in g du ct m as tic pr es en to n du ct w or k to be im pa ct ed by th e pr oj ec t, an d th e qu an tit ie s lis te d ar e no t m ea nt to re fe rt o ac tu al sq ua re fo ot ag e of du ct su rfa ce s or ru ns of du ct w or k in lin ea rf ee t.

Ad di tio na lly

,p le as e no te th at du ct m as tic is on ha rd m et al du ct w or k, an d in so m e in st an ce s, it m ay be lo ca te d un de rn on

-a sb es to s-co nt ai ni ng fib er gl as s in su la tio n.

on si ve Re so ur ce fu l Re lia bl e

Se e

Ap pe nd ix

B fo ra su m m ar y of sa m pl es co lle ct ed w ith re sp ec tiv e an al yt ic al re su lts

,A pp en di x C fo rt he la bo ra to ry an al yt ic al re po rt, Ap pe nd ix

E fo rs am pl e an d

AC

M lo ca tio n dr aw in gs an d Ap pe nd ix F fo rp ho to ex am pl es of th e ab ov e id en tif ie d m at er ia ls

It sh ou ld be no te d th at in ac ce ss ib le

/c on ce al ed su sp ec tm at er ia ls ,o th er th an th os e id en tif ie d du rin g th is su rv ey

,m ay ex is t.

Th is su rv ey di d no ti nc lu de di sa ss em bl in g eq ui pm en to re le ct ric al w iri ng /e le ct ric al co m po ne nt s as th e bu ild in g w as fu lly ac tiv e/ op er at io na la nd in sp ec tin g/ sa m pl in g su ch eq ui pm en t/m at er ia ls w ou ld re pr es en ta tiv e a sa fe ty ha za rd to th e in sp ec to r.

Sh ou ld ad di tio na ls us pe ct m at er ia ls be un co ve re d pr io rt o or du rin g re no va tio n ac tiv iti es

,t ho se m at er ia ls m us tb e as su m ed as be st os

-c on ta in in g un til sa m pl ed by a st at e-lic en se d as be st os in sp ec to r an d an al ys is re fu te s th e po si tiv e as su m pt io n.

If th e id en tif ie d

AC

M s w ill be im pa ct ed by th e re no va tio n, su ch m at er ia ls w ou ld ne ed to be pr op er ly re m ov ed

,h an dl ed

,a nd di sp os ed in ac co rd an ce w ith ap pl ic ab le fe de ra la nd st at e

EP

A re gu la tio ns

,O cc up at io na lS af et y an d

H ea lth Ad m in is tra tio n

(O S

H A) re gu la tio ns ,a nd pe rV A pr oj ec ts pe ci fic at io ns

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

APPENDIX B

VA Project: Upgrade Air Terminal Units VA Project No.: 539-21-111

Cincinnati VA Medical Center (CVAMC) 3200 Vine Street, Cincinnati, OH 45220

ASBESTOS SURVEY SAMPLE & RESULTS SUMMARY

Sample # Sample Material

Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

White Mudded Fittings

Hallway at Room A032

Northwest Hallway in Area A of Basement

1.25% Chrysotile by Point Count (PC)

02 Hallway at Room A031 1.50% Chrysotile by PC

03 Hallway at Room A031 0.75% Chrysotile by PC

White Pipe Encapsulant

At Doorway of A031a Associated with

Fiberglass Pipe Insulation throughout the Basement

None Detected (ND)

05 Center of A047 ND

Southwest Corner of C003 on Pump

System

ND

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Hallway at Room A018

Throughout Basement

ND

08 Hallway at Southwest Stairwell ND

09 South End of Southwest Hallway ND

Spray-on Fireproofing

Center of Room A047c

Room A047 and Adjacent Offices

ND

11 Center of Room A047a ND

12 Northeast Corner of

A047 ND

13 Northwest Corner of A047 ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

14 Center of A047 ND

15 Center of A047 ND

16 Northwest Corner of A047 ND

White Mudded Fittings

Near Entrance to Room B022

Near East Entrance to Room B022

0.25% Amosite by PC

18 Near Entrance to Room B022 <0.25% Amosite by PC

19 Near Entrance to Room B022 0.50% Amosite by PC

Tan Duct Mastic

Northwest Corner of Chapel Associated with

Chapel Duct Work, and West Hallway on 1st

Floor

2% Chrysotile

21 Hallway at Room B159 2% Chrysotile

22 Hallway at Room B159 2% Chrysotile

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Northwest Corner of Chapel

Throughout 1st

Floor

ND

24 South End of West Central Hallway ND

25 Doorway of Room

B144 ND

Spray-On Fireproofing

Northwest Corner of Chapel

Throughout Project Area on

1st Floor

ND

27 Southeast Corner of Chapel ND

28 Middle West Wall of

B163K ND

29 South End of East Central Hallway

ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

30 South End of East Central Hallway ND

31 Middle West Wall of

B163K ND

32 Southeast Corner of Chapel ND

Brown Duct Mastic over Fiberglass

Insulation

Hallway at Room B163

Associated with Insulated

Ductwork in East and East Central Hallways, B163 I-L Offices on 1st

Floor

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

34 Southwest Corner of B163L

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

35 Middle of East Central Hallway

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

2’x’4’White Ceiling Tile with Large

Fissures

Room 163K

B163 I-L Offices

ND

37 Room 163L ND

38 Room 163L ND

Gray Duct Mastic

Middle of East Central Hallway

East Central Hallway in Area B on 1st Floor

ND

40 Center of B159 ND

Southeast Corner of Lobby at Room

B141

ND

Tan Duct Mastic over Fiberglass Insulation

East Wall of Room A144 Associated with

Insulated Duct Work on 1st

Floor- Areas A and C

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

43 Center of Room A144

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

44 Hallway at Room C126

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND, Insulation: ND

13 45 Center of Room A144a

Throughout 1st

Floor ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

46 2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Center of Room

A144 ND

47 Entrance to Travel Room Area ND

White Duct Mastic over Fiberglass

Insulation

Center of A144a

Associated with Room A149 Duct

Work

Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND

49 Center of C137a Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND

50 Center of C137a Mastic: ND, Wrap: ND

Gray-Brown Duct Mastic

Center of A149a A144 and Area

C (Under fiberglass

Insulation) on 1st Floor

2% Chrysotile

52 Center of A144 2% Chrysotile

53 Northwest Corner of C128 2% Chrysotile

Tan Duct Mastic

Northeast Corner of A144a Associated with

Duct in 1st Floor Area C and

Main Hallway of 1st Floor

2% Chrysotile

55 Hallway at Room C126 2% Chrysotile

56 Hallway at Room C130 2% Chrysotile

Gray Duct Mastic

Middle North Wall

B162 (Travel Area)

ND

58 Center of B162 ND

59 Center of B162 ND

Tan Duct Mastic

Middle East Side of A217

Physical Therapy Rooms and

Offices, West Hallway, Elevator

Lobby

ND

61 Center of Hallway at A218

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

62 Northwest Corner of Elevator Lobby ND

19-1

63a

2’x’2 White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Middle East Side of A217

Throughout 2nd

Floor

ND

64a Hallway at A213 ND

65a Hallway at Room B203

ND

20-1

66a

Gray Duct Mastic

At Entrance to A217

Throughout 2nd

Floor North Area A Hallway and

Area B

ND

67a Hallway at Room

B213 ND

68a Hallway at Room

B203 ND

21-1

69a

Gray-Brown Duct Mastic

At Northwest Corner of Elevator

Lobby 2nd Floor

Elevator Lobby

ND

70a Hallway at Room

B218 ND

71a Hallway at Room

B216 ND

22-1

72a

Tan Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room B235

Area B- 2nd

Floor Main Hallway

ND

73a Hallway at Room

B203 ND

74a Room B218 Doorway 2% Chrysotile

19-2

63b

Gray Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room C236

Throughout Area C 2nd Floor

ND

64b Hallway at Room C229a ND

65b Hallway at Room C229a ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

20-2

66b

Tan Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room C229b

Throughout Area C and

Room A246 on 2nd Floor

2% Chrysotile

67b Southwest Corner of Room A246 ND

68b Southwest Corner of Room A246 2% Chrysotile

21-2

69b

Tan Duct Mastic

Hallway near B322

Throughout 3rd

Floor Area B

ND

70b Hallway Near Room B308a ND

71b Hallway at Room

B315 ND

22-2

72b

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Hallway near B322

Throughout 3rd

Floor

ND

73b North End of North Hallway in Area B ND

74b Southwest Corner of Room B322a ND

Red-Fire Stop Caulking

Double-Doors at West Side of Area

B Throughout 3rd

Floor

ND

76 North End of North Hallway in Area B ND

77 North End of North Hallway in Area B ND

White Mudded Fittings

Hallway at Entrance to B322 Associated with

Fiberglass Pipe Insulation in Area B and

Main Elevator Lobby of 3rd

Floor

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.25% Amosite by PC

Hallway at

Doorway to Room B315

Insulation: <0.25% Amosite by PC

Hallway at Room

B327- Main Elevator Lobby

Insulation: 0.25% Amosite by PC

25 81 Gray Duct Mastic Hallway at Room B314

Associated with Duct Work in ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

82 Hallway at Room B319d

Area B on 3rd

Floor ND

83 Hallway at Room B319d ND

Red Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room B311

Throughout 3rd

Floor Area B Hallways and

Learning Center

ND

85 Hallway at Room B308

ND

86 Middle East Side of B322a ND

Gray-Brown Duct Mastic

Hallway At Room B308

Throughout Area B on 3rd Floor

ND

88 At Entrance to Room B322 ND

89 At Entrance to Room B322 ND

White Preformed Pipe Insulation and

Fittings

Central Hallway- South of Elevator

Lobby Associated with 3rd Floor Steam Lines in PACU Area leading to

Floor Above

30% Amosite, 15% Chrysotile

Central Hallway- South of Elevator

Lobby

30% Amosite, 15% Chrysotile

Central Hallway- South of Elevator

Lobby

30% Amosite, 15% Chrysotile

Tan Duct Mastic

South End of Hallway at Room

C335 Associated with

Duct Work in Area C – South

Hallway and Adjacent

Offices on the 3rd Floor

2% Chrysotile

94 Hallway at Room C325 2% Chrysotile

95 Hallway at Room C319 2% Chrysotile

30 96 White Mudded

Fittings on Fiberglass Lines

Southwest Corner of Elevator Lobby

Associated with Fiberglass Pipes in 4th

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

<0.25% Amosite by PC, <0.25% Chrysotile by PC

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

97 Hallway at Room A439

Floor Elevator Lobby and Adjacent Rooms

Insulation: 0.25% Amosite by PC, <0.25% Chrysotile by PC

98 Hallway at Room A439

Insulation: 0.25% Amosite by PC, <0.25% Chrysotile by PC

Tan Duct Mastic

Southwest Corner of Elevator Lobby Associated with

Ducts in 4th Floor Elevator Lobby and Northwest

Adjacent Rooms

ND

100 Hallway at Room

B439 ND

101 Hallway at Room

B439 ND

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Hallway at Room B439

Throughout 4th

Floor

ND

103 Hallway at Room

B438 ND

104 Hallway at Toom

B421 ND

Tan Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room B438 Associated with

Duct Work throughout

Area B on the 4th Floor

2% Chrysotile

106 Hallway at Room B403a ND

107 At Entrance to B426a ND

Red Fire-Stop Caulking

Entrance to B403b

Throughout Area B on 4th Floor

ND

109 Entrance to B403b ND

110 Entrance to Respiratory Suite ND

111 White Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Lines

Hallway at Room B403a

Associated with Fiberglass

Pipes throughout

Area B on the 4th Floor

Insulation: <0.25% Amosite by PC, <0.25% Chrysotile by PC

112 Hallway at Room B426

Insulation: <0.25% Amosite by PC, 0.25% Chrysotile by

PC

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

113 Hallway at Room B427

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.25% Amosite by PC, <0.25% Chrysotile by PC

Gray-Brown Duct Mastic

Inside Entrance of B426

Rooms B426, Room B246a and Adjacent

Hallway

ND

115 End of Hallway Near B425 ND

116 End of Hallway Near B425 ND

White Encapsulant Over Fiberglass Lines

Center of Room B420

Throughout Area B of 4th Floor

Encapsulant: ND, Insulation: ND

118 Pipe Chase Closet in Room B420

Encapsulant: ND, Insulation: ND

119 Pipe Chase Closet in Room B420

Encapsulant: ND, Insulation: ND

White Encapsulant over Fiberglass Lines

Pipe Chase Closet in Room A549

Pipe Chase Closet within Room A549

Encapsulant: ND, Insulation: ND

121 Pipe Chase Closet in Room A549

Encapsulant: ND, Insulation: ND

122 Pipe Chase Closet in Room A549 Encapsulant: ND

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

In Northwest Corner of A549

Throughout Area A of 5th Floor

ND

124 East End of Elevator Lobby ND

125 East End of Elevator Lobby ND

2’x2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Center of Elevator Lobby

Throughout 6th

Floor

ND

127 Hallway at Room B606

ND

128 Hallway At room

B603 ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

Tan Duct Mastic

Hallway at Room B603

Associated with Duct Work in

Area B on the 6th

Floor

ND

South End of

Cardiology Suite Hallway

ND

North End of

Cardiology Suite Hallway

ND

White Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Lines

Hallway at Room B603

Associated with Water Lines in

Area B of the 6th

Floor

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.75% Amosite by PC

133 Hallway at Room B606

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.50% Amosite by PC

Hallway at

Double-Doors to East Suite

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.25% Amosite by PC

2’ x 2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Center of elevator lobby – 7th floor

Throughout 7th floor

ND

North end of east Elevator lobby- 7th floor

ND

137 East end of Area B Hallway – 7th floor ND

Tan Duct Mastic

Middle of South Side of Elevator

Lobby

7th floor - Main Elevator Lobby

ND

Middle of South Side of Elevator

Lobby

ND

Middle of South Side of Elevator

Lobby

ND

White Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Pipes

Hallway at room A730 Associated with

Water Lines in Main Elevator

Lobby on the 7th floor

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

<0.25% Amosite by PC

142 Pipe chase in Room A740

Insulation: 0.25% Amosite by PC

143 Pipe chase in Room A740

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

<0.25% Amosite by PC

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

Gray Duct Mastic

Middle north wall in A739a

Associated with Duct Work in

Rooms A739a and A728d

ND

145 Middle north wall in A739a ND

146 Middle north wall in A739a ND

White Pipe Encapsulant

South Side of Pipe Chase

Pipe Chase in Room A740

ND

148 South Side of Pipe Chase ND

149 South Side of Pipe Chase ND

Tan Duct Mastic

Center of Main Elevator lobby

Associated with Duct Work in Main Elevator

Lobby of 8th Floor

ND

151 Hallway Outside Room A845 ND

152 Hallway Outside Room A845 ND

2’ x 2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Fissures

Center of Main Elevator Lobby –

8th floor Throughout 8th floor

ND

154 West End of Elevator Lobby ND

155 South Side of Reception Area ND

White Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Lines

Center of Main Elevator Lobby Associated with

Water Lines in Main Elevator

Lobby on the 8th

Floor

Insulation: 0.50% Amosite by PC

157 Center of Main Elevator Lobby

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

<0.25% Amosite by PC

158 Center of Main Elevator Lobby

Wrap: ND, Insulation:

0.25% Amosite by PC

51 159 White Pipe Encapsulant

Pipe Chase Closet in Southwest Wing

9th Floor

Associated with Fiberglass Pipes within Pipe

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

Pipe Chase Closet in Southwest Wing

9th Floor

Chase Closet in Southwest Wing of the 9th floor

ND

Pipe Chase Closet in Southwest Wing

9th Floor

ND

2’ x 2’ White Ceiling Tile with Small

Pinholes

At Northwest Entrance

Area B of 8th floor

ND

163 Center of Lobby ND

164 Middle of North Wall ND

Tan Duct Mastic

Middle of Mail Room in Basement

Basement Mail Room (B022A)

ND

166 Middle of Mail Room in Basement ND

167 Middle of Mail Room in Basement ND

Tan Duct Mastic

East End of Duct Work

Associated with Large Ducts in Basement Area C Crawlspace

2% Chrysotile

169 At 45 Degree Turn 2% Chrysotile

170 West End of Duct Area 2% Chrysotile

Tan Duct Mastic

South Entrance to A235a

Associated with Ductwork in SPD on the 2nd Floor

ND

172 South Entrance to A235a ND

173 South Entrance to A235a ND

56 - Corrugated Paper

Pipe Insulation and Mudded Fittings

Associated with Lines to Heater Units in Rooms

B501, B503, B504 B539, Assumed (Based on Prior Knowledge of Past Surveys)

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. # B540, A540, A541 and A542

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

Plaster Walls: Base Coat and Finish Coat

Basement- At Entrance to Morgue

Area

Throughout Building

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

1st Floor- Main

Hallway at Room Women’s Restroom

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

03 2nd Floor- East Side Elevator Lobby

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

04 3rd Floor- At Double Doors to Area B

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

05 4th Floor- East Side of Elevator Lobby

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

5th Floor- Near

Entrance to Pharmacy Area

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

07 6th Floor- East Side of Elevator Lobby

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

08 7th Floor – Near Room A743

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

9th Floor- Northwest Corner of Elevator

Lobby

Base Coat: ND, Finish Coat:

ND

Drywall System:

Drywall and Joint

Compound

Basement- East Elevator Lobby

Throughout Building

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

1st Floor- Hallway at

Room A123 Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

12 2nd Floor- Northwest Corner of C201

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

3rd Floor- Near

Southeast Corner of Elevator Lobby

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

Sample # Sample Material Description Sample Location HA Location(s) Results (% / Type of

Asbestos)HA # SEQ. #

4th Floor- Area B- Doorway to North

Wing

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

5th Floor- South

Wall of East Elevator Lobby

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

6th Floor- South

Wall of Main Elevator South

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

17 7th Floor – At Entrance to Area B

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

8th Floor- Northeast Corner Service Elevator Lobby

Drywall: ND, Joint Compound: ND

Spray-On Fireproofing

Basement – East Elevator Lobby

Throughout Building

ND

20 1st Floor- Near Main Entrance Lobby ND

21 2nd Floor – Entrance to Dentistry Area

ND

22 3rd Floor- Center of Elevator Lobby ND

23 4th Floor – Center of Elevator Lobby ND

5th Floor- Near

Entrance to Pharmacy Area

ND

25 6th Floor- East Elevator Lobby

ND

7th Floor- West Side of Main Elevator Lobby

ND

9th Floor – East End of Hallway at Entrance to

Maintenance Area

ND

Inspector Signatures: ________________________ _____________________________ Lem Weyer, OH AHES #36337 Tyler Stenten, OH AHES #35931

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

APPENDIX C

ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL LABORATORY DATA

OrderID: 162103849

OrderID: 162103849

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

APPENDIX D

LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS

asbestoslicensing@epa.ohio.gov asbestoslicensing@epa.ohio.gov

Tyler.Stenten@terracon.com https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://www.epa.ohio.gov/dapc/atu/asbestos*179575185-resources__;Iw!!JrcuqBw_IQ!ye2zI16CE5GxLxa_plaztHHkGanxgHMAbkaX4nG16PVJ0YVxnt7 SeTKHfNDN2K-qnYU$ https://urldefense.com/v3/__http://ebiz.epa.ohio.gov__;!!JrcuqBw_IQ!ye2zI16CE5GxLxa_plaztH HkGanxgHMAbkaX4nG16PVJ0YVxnt7SeTKHfNDNIQIz_ek$ asbestoslicensing@epa.ohio.gov asbestoslicensing@epa.ohio.gov

Tyler.Stenten@terracon.com https://urldefense.com/v3/__https://www.epa.ohio.gov/dapc/atu/asbestos*179575185-resources__;Iw!!JrcuqBw_IQ!3Cm-JjG06KMBKt3mNSnGvB7z-vADrd5hMrbVybdDlldUSeZkZhnQWOgZV0fTMhpjKGY$ https://urldefense.com/v3/__http://ebiz.epa.ohio.gov__;!!JrcuqBw_IQ!3Cm- JjG06KMBKt3mNSnGvB7z-vADrd5hMrbVybdDlldUSeZkZhnQWOgZV0fTSca13T4$

March 10, 2021 Terracon Project No. N1207213

Responsive Resourceful Reliable

APPENDIX E

SAMPLE & ACM LOCATION DRAWINGS

Project No. N1207213

Consulting Engineers and Scientists

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

Basement- Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

1Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

11 08

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Pipes

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

Basement- Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

2Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fitting on

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

Basement- Area C Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

3Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Tan Duct Mastic

Asbestos-Containing White Preformed Block Pipe Insulation and Fittings

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

1st Floor - Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

4Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos- Containing Tan

Duct Mastic

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

1st Floor - Area C Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

5Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos- Containing

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

2nd Floor - Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

6Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

No Asbestos-Containing Materials associated with this Project found in this Area

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

2nd Floor - Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

7Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

71 74

Asbestos-Containing Tan

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

2nd Floor - Area C Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

8Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Tan Duct Mastic

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

3rd Floor- Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

9Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

81 70

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fittings on Fiberglass Pipes

Asbestos-Containing White Preformed Block Pipe Insulation and Fittings

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

3rd Floor- Area C Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

10Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

95 94 93

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

4th Floor – Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

11Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fittings on Fiberglass Pipes

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

4th Floor – Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

12Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fittings on

Fiberglass Pipes

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

5th Floor – Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

13Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Assumed Asbestos-Containing Corrugated Paper Pipe

Insulation

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

5th Floor – Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

14Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

No Samples Collected in this Area

Assumed Asbestos- Containing Corrugated Paper Pipe Insulation

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

6th Floor – Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

15Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

No Asbestos-Containing Material associated with this Project found in this

Area

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

6th Floor – Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

16Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Asbestos-Containing Mudded Fittings on Fiberglass Pipes

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

7th Floor – Area A Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

17Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

142 147 143 148 144 149

Asbestos-Containing

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH. (513) 321-05816

FAX (513) 321-0294

7th Floor – Area B Exhibit

Survey Date: February 2021 Cincinnati VA Medical Center Upgrade Air Terminal Units Project

3200 Vine Street Cincinnati, Ohio 45220

18Project Manager: Josh Vogel

APR: Joe Tussey

Assumed Asbestos- Containing Corrugated Paper Pipe Insulation (Within Wall

Pipe Chase)

611 Lunken Park Drive Cincinnati, Ohio 45226

PH.