RFP 00002527 Scoring Detail and Summary.pdf
PDF 148 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- 00002527
- Issued by
- Oregon
About this file
This document is a Phase I evaluation scoring summary for RFP 00002527, an Oregon energy retrofit project for unregulated multifamily and multidwelling housing. The RFP evaluates four proposers across multiple criteria categories: Proposer Capabilities (30 points maximum), Project Team (10 points), Project Approach (30 points), Cost or Other factors (5 points), State Certification (4 points), MWESB Contracting (8 points), Workforce Diversity and Community Involvement (8 points), and Sustainable Business Practices (5 points), for a total of 100 points available. Five independent evaluators scored each proposal, with results compiled into individual and summary scoring tables.
The four competing proposers and their Phase I total scores are as follows: TRC Environmental Corporation (427.1 points), Energy Infrastructure Partners (424.5 points), Oregon Energy Fund (336.0 points), and ResourceSmart (293.0 points). TRC Environmental Corporation achieved the highest cumulative score across all five evaluators, followed closely by Energy Infrastructure Partners. Oregon Energy Fund and ResourceSmart scored significantly lower, with ResourceSmart receiving the lowest evaluation overall. The scoring reflects particular emphasis on proposer capabilities and project approach, with evaluators assessing each firm's technical competence, team qualifications, and strategic methodology for executing the multifamily housing energy retrofit initiative.
View the file
Other files
Show all 11
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Individual Summary of Scores Page 1 of 2
PROPOSER
CAPABILITIES
PROJECT
TEAM
PROJECT
APPROACH COST
OR State Certification
MWESB
Contracting
Workforce Diversity & Community Involvement
Sustainable Business Practices
30 10 30 5 4 8 8 5 Evaluator 1 25 9 25 4 4 6.301 5 4 82.3 Evaluator 2 25 9 28 5 4 6.3 6 4 87.3 Evaluator 3 25 10 28 2 4 6.3 6 4 85.3 Evaluator 4 25 9 25 4 4 6.3 5 4 82.3 Evaluator 5 23 9 27 5 4 6.3 8 5 87.3
Total: 123 46 133 20 20 31.5 30 21 424.5
PROPOSER
CAPABILITIES
PROJECT
TEAM
PROJECT
APPROACH COST
OR State Certification
MWESB
Contracting
Workforce Diversity & Community Involvement
Sustainable Business Practices
30 10 30 5 4 8 8 5 Evaluator 1 22 7 22 3 0 8.0 3 3 68.0 Evaluator 2 22 8 19 3 0 8.0 6 4 70.0 Evaluator 3 20 8 15 3 0 8.0 7 4 65.0 Evaluator 4 24 7 18 3 0 8.0 4 4 68.0 Evaluator 5 20 9 15 4 0 8.0 6 3 65.0
Total: 108 39 89 16 0 40.0 26 18 336.0
PROPOSER
CAPABILITIES
PROJECT
TEAM
PROJECT
APPROACH COST
OR State Certification
MWESB
Contracting
Workforce Diversity & Community Involvement
Sustainable Business Practices
30 10 30 5 4 8 8 5 Evaluator 1 16 5 16 2 0 0.0 4 3 46.0 Evaluator 2 22 8 19 2 0 0.0 5 4 60.0 Evaluator 3 20 6 13 2 0 0.0 5 4 50.0 Evaluator 4 20 7 19 4 0 0.0 7 4 61.0 Evaluator 5 24 9 25 5 0 0.0 8 5 76.0
Total: 102 35 92 15 0 0.0 29 20 293.0
PROPOSER
CAPABILITIES
PROJECT
TEAM
PROJECT
APPROACH COST
OR State Certification
MWESB
Contracting
Workforce Diversity & Community Involvement
Sustainable Business Practices
30 10 30 5 4 8 8 5 Evaluator 1 28 9 27 4 0 5.4 5 3 81.4 Evaluator 2 27 9 27 4 0 5.4 6 4 82.4 Evaluator 3 29 10 29 5 0 5.4 7 4 89.4 Evaluator 4 26 9 26 5 0 5.4 7 5 83.4 Evaluator 5 30 10 29 5 0 5.4 6 5 90.4
Total: 140 47 138 23 0 27.1 31 21 427.1
Proposer
Criteria Max pts avail.
Ev al ua to r Ev al ua to r
Ev al ua to r
Max pts avail.
Ev al ua to r
Proposer
Criteria Max pts avail.
Proposer
Criteria Max pts avail.
Proposer
Criteria
TRC ENVIRONMENTAL CORPORATION
Total Score
ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE PARTNERS
Total Score
Total Score
OREGON ENERGY FUND
RESOURCESMART
Total Score
Summary of Scores Page 2 of 2
Evaluator 1 82.3 68.0 46.0 81.4 Evaluator 2 87.3 70.0 60.0 82.4 Evaluator 3 85.3 65.0 50.0 89.4 Evaluator 4 82.3 68.0 61.0 83.4 Evaluator 5 87.3 65.0 76.0 90.4
Total: 424.5 336.0 293.0 427.1
Ev al ua to r
Phase I Evalaution Results
ENERGY
INFRASTRUCTURE
PARTNERS
OREGON
ENERGY
FUND
RESOURCESMART
TRC
ENVIRONMENTAL
CORPORATION
424.5
336.0 293.0
427.1
0.0
50.0
100.0
150.0
200.0
250.0
300.0
350.0
400.0
450.0
ENERGY
INFRASTRUCTURE
PARTNERS
OREGON ENERGY
FUND
RESOURCESMART TRC
ENVIRONMENTAL
CORPORATION
PHASE I
Phase I
| Phase I Detail |
| Summary |
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .