2._Combined_Technical_Evaluation_Form.docx

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 1 of 9

Project Name: SABER IDIQ, Seed Project 1, Seed Project 2

TECHNICAL EVALUATION FORM

Notice to Contractor

The Contractor shall be evaluated on the criteria and sub-criteria as defined in this form as stated in Section M.

Based upon adherence to the requirements of the Scope of Work (SOW), Request for Proposal (RFP) and technical capabilities across all criteria, the contractor shall be given a single Evaluation Rating of either 'Acceptable' or 'Unacceptable' as described in Section L and Section M of the RFP.

The Contractor shall use this form as a checklist to satisfy the requirements of the RFP.

Overall Evaluation Rating Acceptable Unacceptable Contract Number Project Number Proposer Number Date Reviewed Reviewed By 14-0031, 17-0093

Project Name SABER IDIQ, Seed Project 1 (Repair Pool, 14-0031), Seed Project 2 (Bird Netting, 17-0093)

Project Description

FA5702-18-R-0016, SABER

Seed Project 1: Design/Build project to Repair CC Pool Pump House as described in the RFP. This project is to include the design, engineering, consultant coordination, logistical planning and construction required to allow the GOVERNMENT to maintain a complete CC Pool Pump House.

Seed Project 2: Design/Build project to Install Bird Control devices at multiple locations as described in the RFP (B3279, B3976, B3979, B3993, and B6671 Sunshades). This project is to include the design, engineering, consultant coordination, logistical planning and construction.

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 2 of 9

General Requirements

1. Does the technical proposal include the Contractor's Commercial License with the Qatar Ministry of Economy and Commerce or a plan to obtain one within 30 days of contract award?

2. Does the technical proposal include the Contractor's membership with the Qatar Chamber of Commerce and Industry or a plan to obtain one within 30 days of contract award?

3. Does the technical proposal include the Contractor's and/or Sub- contractor's KAHRAA MAA certificate or a plan to obtain one within 30 days of contract award?

4. Does the technical proposal include the Contractor's Annual Contractor's All Risk Insurance or Indemnity Letter with guarantee of policy for specific project, and plan to obtain Defense Base Act insurance?

5. Did the Contractor include a Design Narrative that demonstrates an understanding of the project scope for each seed project?

[Type here] [Type here] [Type here]

Project Name: SABER IDIQ, Seed Project 1, Seed Project 2

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 3 of 9

Management Experience

1. Does the technical proposal demonstrate that the contractor plans to employ a Project Manager with minimum ten years of experience in multi-discipline/multi-project management comparable to SABER or JOC and is capable of reading, writing and conversing fluently in the English language for this contract? (SABER IDIQ)

2. Does the technical proposal demonstrate that the contractor plans to employ a Technical Support Staff with minimum five years of experience in the following functions for this contract: project planning/design, estimating, quality control, drafting, and clerical? (SABER IDIQ)

3. Does the technical proposal demonstrate that the contractor plans to employ a Quality Control Manager with minimum five years of relevant experience for this contract? (SABER IDIQ)

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 4 of 9

Design Experience

1. Does the technical proposal demonstrate that electrical engineering design work will be performed by an Electrical Engineer who is enrolled in the Register of Engineers? (Seed Project 1)

2. Does the technical proposal demonstrate that mechanical engineering design work will be performed by a Mechanical Engineer who is enrolled in the Register of Engineers? (Seed Project 1)

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 5 of 9

Schedule

1. Does the technical proposal include a Project Schedule including administrative activities, design, submittals, sequence of events and durations and identify items with lead times longer than 30 days for each seed project?

2. Does the technical proposal include the Contractor's Starting, adjusting, Commissioning and Close-out submittal procedures, including As-built documents, O&M Manuals and warranty for each seed project?

3. Did the contractor identify appropriate construction milestones for each seed project?

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 6 of 9

Design Elements

Acceptable

1. Does the technical proposal adequately address Site / Civil design elements Division 31 Earthworks and the appropriate Sub- sections? (Seed Project 1)

2. Does the technical proposal adequately address Site / Civil design elements Division 32 Exterior Improvements and the appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

3. Does the technical proposal adequately address Site / Civil design elements Division 33 Utilities and the appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

4. Does the technical proposal adequately address Structural design elements Division 03 Concrete and appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

5. Does the technical proposal adequately address Structural design elements Division 04 Masonry and the appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

6. Does the technical proposal adequately address Architectural design elements Division 01 General Requirements and the appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

7. Does the technical proposal adequately address Architectural design elements Division 02 Existing Conditions and the appropriate Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 7 of 9

8. Does the technical proposal adequately address Architectural design elements Division 08 Openings and Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

9. Does the technical proposal adequately address Architectural design elements Division 09 Finishes and Sub- sections? (Seed Project 1)

10. Does the technical proposal adequately address Architectural design elements Division 10 Specialties and Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

11. Does the technical proposal adequately address Mechanical design elements Division 23 Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) and Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

12. Does the technical proposal adequately address Electrical design elements Division 26 Electrical and Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

13. Does the technical proposal address how the bird control devices will be attached to the existing facilities? (Seed Project 2)

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 8 of 9

Design Communications

1. Does the technical proposal Acceptable Not Acceptable Comment

1. Does the technical proposal adequately address Division 27 Communications and Sub-sections? (Seed Project 1)

2. Does the technical proposal adequately address Division 28 Electronic Safety and Security and Sub- sections? (Seed Project 1)

FA5702-18-R-0016 Attachment 2 Page 9 of 9

Management of Multiple Concurrent Projects

1. Does the technical proposal include the contractor’s approach to managing multiple concurrent projects? Is the approach reasonable? (SABER IDIQ)

2. If the contractor intends to subcontract any work, does the technical proposal include the contractor’s approach to managing subcontractors? (SABER IDIQ)

Use of RS Means

1. Does the technical proposal explain the contractors experience with RS Means and plan to ensure competency in providing proposals through the life of the contract? Is the approach reasonable? (SABER IDIQ)

2. Did the contractor propose reasonable quantities and types of labor and materials for each proposed seed project?

image4.png image5.png image6.png image7.png image8.png image9.png image10.png image11.png image12.png image13.png image14.png image15.png image16.png image17.png image18.png image19.png image20.png image21.png image22.png image23.png image24.png image1.png image2.png image3.png