Attachment 05 - Lead Based Paint Inspection Report.pdf

IIHHII

E N V I R O N M E N T A L

LEAD BASED PAINT INSPECTION

Bob Stump Veterans Affairs Medical Center Building 111 – Boiler Plant

500 North Highway 89

Prescott, Arizona

Order Number VA649-C10326

April 11, 2012

Prepared for:

Richard Trevino Northern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care System

500 North Highway 89 Prescott, Arizona 86313

Prepared by: Reviewed by:

Mr. Oulono Folau EPA Lead Inspector

Joseph K. Palermo, REA, LEED® AP Regional Manager

Project #11P-A3138

4527 NORTH 16TH STREET, #105 PHOENIX AZ 85016 TELEPHONE: 602.776.0300 FAX: 602.776.0301 E-MAIL: PHOENIX@IHI-ENV.COM

SALT LAKE CITY SAN FRANCISCO PHOENIX DENVER SEATTLE

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 Executive Summary IHI Environmental LBP Inspection Project #11P-A3138

IIHHII

E N V I R O N M E N T A L

Executive Summary As requested by the Northern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care System (NAVAHCS), IHI Environmental (IHI) conducted a Lead-based Paint (LBP) Inspection at the Building 111

– Boiler Plant facility located at the Bob Stump Veterans Affairs Medical Center, 500 North Highway 89, Prescott, Arizona.

The Lead-based Paint Inspection was performed to identify and locate lead-based paint at the facility. This inspection included a Paint Condition Inspection to identify Lead Hazards.

The following table summarizes the results.

XRF Samples 226 Positive for Lead (>1 mg/cm2) 84

Components in Poor Condition 1

Based on the results of the survey, lead-based paint was identified on several exterior and interior building components. The paint on all of the components was considered to be in either intact or fair condition, with one exception. One component containing lead-based paint was considered to be in poor condition. Based on HUD guidelines, all painted components that are considered LBP (>1.0 mg/cm2) and identified as being in poor condition, represent potential lead hazards.

Estimated costs for the abatement of lead-based painted components in poor condition range from $32 to $80. Details of the estimated costs are provided in Section 6 and Appendix D.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Scope of Work

2.0 METHODOLOGY

2.1 Lead-paint Inspection

2.2 Paint Condition Inspection

3.0 RESULTS

3.1 Summary of LBP Inspection and Condition Results

4.0 LEAD HAZARD CONTROLS DISCUSSION

4.1 Lead Hazard Controls for LBP Hazards

5.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

5.1 Lead-paint Hazards

6.0 COST ESTIMATES FOR ABATEMENT

7.0 REFERENCES

8.0 PROJECT LIMITATIONS

APPENDICES

Appendix A Floor Plans Appendix B LBP Summary Sheet Appendix C XRF Data Appendix D Cost Estimates for Abatement Appendix E IHI Certification

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 TOC-1 IHI Environmental

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 TOC-2 IHI Environmental

Abbreviations and Definitions

ADEQ Arizona Department of Environmental Quality

DEUR ADEQ’s Waste Programs – Remediation and Declaration of Environmental Use Restriction

AWP ADEQ’s Waste Programs

EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

EPCRA Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act

Hazardous substance

A substance defined as a hazardous substance (Section 101(14) of CERCLA). In accordance with ASTM Standard E 1527, this definition includes petroleum products.

HUD U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development

HUD

guidelines

HUD Guidelines for the Evaluation and Control of Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Housing, June 1995, US Department of Housing and Urban Development, (http://www.hud.gov/offices/lead/lbp/hudguidelines)

LBP Lead-based Paint. HUD considers paint to be lead-based paint (LBP) if the concentration is 1.0 milligram of lead per square centimeter (1.0 mg/cm2) or greater, or if the lead concentration is greater than 5,000 parts per million (ppm) or 0.5% by weight.

LBP Hazard A lead-based paint “hazard” is any condition that causes exposure to lead from lead-contaminated dust, lead-contaminated soil, or lead-contaminated paint that is deteriorated or is present in accessible surfaces, friction surfaces, or impact surfaces that would result in adverse human health effects.

OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration

RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act. The regulations which govern the identification, management, transportation, and disposal of hazardous wastes from “cradle to grave.”

VRP ADEQ’s Voluntary Remediation Program.

1.0 INTRODUCTION

The Northern Arizona Veterans Affairs Health Care System NAVAHCS retained IHI

Environmental (IHI) to conduct a Lead-based Paint Inspection of the Bob Stump Veterans

Affairs Medical Center facility, located at 500 North Highway 89, Prescott, Arizona.

1.1 Scope of Work

IHI was retained by NAVAHCS to conduct a Lead-based Paint Inspection (LBP) Inspection using methodology outlined in the HUD guidelines (HUD, 1995). Each painted space was analyzed using an X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectrometer to determine the presence of lead-based paint. A sufficient number of samples were collected to meet HUD guidelines. This inspection included a Paint Condition Inspection to identify Lead Hazards.

The results, conclusions, and recommendations in this report are based on information identified during the performance of this inspection. If greater certainty or detail is needed to understand the risks associated with the presence of lead at the site, additional evaluation may be required. Floor plans of the building are presented in Appendix A.

2.0 METHODOLOGY

2.1 Lead-paint Inspection

The LBP Inspection was conducted by Mr. Oulono Folau, a Environmental Protection Agency

(EPA)-accredited Lead Risk Assessor (PB-1056) on January 15, 2012.

Measurements for lead in paint were made using a RMD LPA-1 Lead Paint Analyzer (Serial

Number 1195). The RMD non-destructively measures lead concentrations in painted surfaces, regardless of the number of paint layers present. Results are reported in mg/cm2.

Quality control procedures included checking the internal calibration of the XRF before and after the testing was completed by taking three consecutive measurements on a National

Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) standard with a known concentration of lead.

2.2 Paint Condition Inspection

IHI inspected the condition of each painted material at the site. The condition of painted surfaces was determined based on the criteria found in Table 1.

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 1 IHI Environmental

Table 1 Paint Conditions (as defined by HUD)

Total Area of Deteriorated Paint on Each Component Type of Building

Component1 Intact Fair2 Poor3 Exterior components with large surface areas

Entire surface is intact

Less than or equal to 10 square feet

More than 10 square feet

Interior components with large surface areas (walls, ceilings, floors, doors)

Entire surface is intact

Less than or equal to 2 square feet

More than 2 square feet

Interior and exterior components with small surface areas (window sills, baseboards, soffits, trim)

Entire surface is intact

Less than or equal to 10 percent of the total surface area of the component

More than 10 percent of the total surface area of the component

Notes

1. Building component in this table refers to each individual component or side of building, not the combined surface area of all similar components in a room (e.g., a wall with 1 square foot of deteriorated paint is in “fair” condition, even if the other three walls in a room are intact).

2. Surfaces in “fair” condition should be repaired and/or monitored, but are not considered to be “lead-based paint hazards” as defined in by HUD guidelines.

3. Surfaces in “poor” condition are considered to be “lead-based paint hazards” as defined in HUD guidelines and should be addressed through abatement or interim controls.

3.0 RESULTS

In accordance with federal law, this Lead-Paint Inspection was conducted by Mr. Oulono

Folau. A copy of his current EPA certificate for conducting lead based paint activities is presented in Appendix E.

3.1 Summary of LBP Inspection and Condition Results

A summary of the samples which tested positive as LBP (Appendix B, Summary Report) show 84 components tested positive for LBP, and two (2) components were identified as both LBP and in poor condition. Based on the HUD guidelines, the components in poor condition represent a lead hazard at the site. A complete set of the XRF data is presented in

Appendix C.

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 2 IHI Environmental

4.0 LEAD HAZARD CONTROLS DISCUSSION

As outlined in the HUD guidelines there are two different types of control options for lead hazards. These are interim (temporary) controls or permanent abatement. Interim controls are less expensive initially, but may be more expensive than abatement in the long run since they need to be re-evaluated and maintained more frequently. If all lead-based paint surfaces are abated or replaced, no re-evaluation is needed.

4.1 Lead Hazard Controls for LBP Hazards

As a measure of controlling LBP hazards at this site, there are several interim controls that can be utilized; however, these methods will require ongoing monitoring to assure that the existing hazard has not returned or new hazards developed. A listing of these controls is as follows:

• Paint film stabilization: This interim control involves repair or restoration of existing substrate, removal of the loose or deteriorated paint, and applying a new protective coating, such as a sealant or a new coat of non lead-based paint.

• Lead dust reduction: This interim control involves the ongoing cleaning of potential lead dust-impacted surfaces through the use of a HEPA vacuum in addition to wet washing the impacted components.

• Impact surface elimination or reduction: This interim control involves the reconfiguration of the building components to eliminate impact surfaces. This can include lining window tracks with vinyl guides or the narrowing of doors or windows to eliminate impact surfaces.

As a measure of permanent elimination of the LBP hazard at the site, there are several abatement options that can be selected. These options will eliminate the source of the lead hazard and do not require ongoing monitoring. A listing of permanent abatement measures are as follows:

• Lead-based paint removal: This method involves the removal of the lead-based paint from the building components, using approved methods, such as approved low temperature heat guns, wet sanding or scraping, in addition to a HEPA vacuuming, and/or the use of approved chemical strippers. These methods should only be performed by trained lead abatement contractors.

• Component replacement: This method involves the removal and complete replacement of impacted building components with non lead-based painted materials.

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 3 IHI Environmental

5.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

5.1 Lead-paint Hazards

Based on HUD guidelines, all painted components that are considered LBP (>1.0 mg/cm2) and were identified as being in poor condition, represent lead hazards. IHI identified one component that represents a lead hazard at the facility. Recommended Controls for the abatement of components include either lead-based paint removal or component replacement.

6.0 COST ESTIMATES FOR ABATEMENT

Cost Estimates for the abatement of lead-based painted components in poor condition are presented in Appendix D. The cost estimates for the abatement of LBP hazards were derived by use of the RS Means Cost Guide and through IHI’s experience in the local and regional markets. The cost estimate provided is for use in long-term budgeting and planning only and does not have a level of accuracy sufficient to be used as construction design cost estimates.

The actual cost of LBP abatement is highly dependent on a number of factors such as the size of the job (single room or window, or an entire floor or building); the required time frame for removal; the time of year the job is conducted; and travel time and distance to the job for the contractor. Therefore, actual removal costs could vary significantly from these estimates.

Materials replacement and consultant abatement management costs are not included in these estimates and can add 15 - 50% to the project costs.

7.0 REFERENCES

HUD, 1995. Guidelines for the Evaluation and Control of Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Housing, June 1995, US Department of Housing and Urban Development, (http://www.hud.gov/offices/lead/lbp/hudguidelines).

8.0 PROJECT LIMITATIONS

This project was performed using, as a minimum, practices consistent with standards acceptable within the industry at this time, and a level of diligence typically exercised by

EH&S consultants performing similar services.

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 4 IHI Environmental

NAVAHCS Bob Stump VAMC Bldg. 111 5 IHI Environmental

The procedures used attempt to establish a balance between the competing goals of limiting investigative and reporting costs and time, and reducing the uncertainty about unknown conditions. Therefore, because the findings of this report were derived from the scope, costs, time and other limitations, the conclusions should not be construed as a guarantee that all universal, toxic and/or hazardous wastes have been identified and fully evaluated.

Furthermore, IHI assumes no responsibility for omissions or errors resulting from inaccurate information, or data, provided by sources outside of IHI or from omissions or errors in public records.

It is emphasized that the final decision on how much risk to accept always remains with the client since IHI is not in a position to fully understand all of the client's needs. Clients with a greater aversion to risk may want to take additional actions while others, with less aversion to risk, may want to take no further action.

Appendix A

Floor Plans

V

Pr oj ec ts

\V A

M C

\1 1P

-A

V

A M

C P re sc ot t A sb -L

B P

In sp ii\ D ra w in gs

\S R

_V A

As be st os

S ur ve y

C A

D \2

4\

P-

A

-2

-1 8-

\1

1P -A

-B ld g

1.

dw g, A llF lrs

_P b, /2

0/

0:

:1

AM

, m ik eb

PROJECT No:

SHEET:

DRAWN BY:

REVIEWED BY:

Le ad

S am pl in g W al l R ef er en ce

K ey

DATE:

DATE:

DATE:

REVISED BY:

0 8' 16'

11P-A3138 1_Pb

MBradley 2-18-12

D ep ar tm en t o f V et er an s Af fa irs

N or th er n Ar iz on a Ve te ra ns A ffa irs

H ea lth C ar e

S ys te m

(N

AV

AH

C

S) B oi le r P la nt

Bu ild in g

P re sc ot t, A riz on a

Side A

Side C

S id e B

S ide D

Lead Sampling Wall Reference Key for Typical Room

Appendix B

LBP Summary Sheet

Building 111 - Boiler Plant Summary.TXT SUMMARY REPORT OF LEAD PAINT INSPECTION FOR: Building 111 - Boiler Plant

Inspection Date: 01/15/12 IHI Environmental #11P-A3138 Report Date: 1/24/2012 NAVAHCS Prescott, Arizona Abatement Level: 1.0 Report No. 01/15/12 15:11 Total Readings: 226 Actionable: 84 Job Started: 01/15/12 15:11 Job Finished: 01/16/12 11:40

Read Paint Paint Lead No. Wall Structure Location Member Cond Substrate Color (mg/cm²) Mode Exterior Room 001 Number Only 189 A ladder Ctr I Metal Brown 1.8 QM 187 A Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Green 2.1 QM 188 A Window Rgt Sash I Metal Green 2.9 QM 198 A Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Wood Green 1.5 QM 197 A Door Ctr U Lft I Wood Green >9.9 QM 204 B Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green 4.5 QM 205 B Window Ctr Lft jamb I Metal Green 4.8 QM 211 C Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Green >9.9 QM 218 C Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Green >9.9 QM 212 C Window Lft Sash I Metal Green 8.1 QM 207 C Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Green 4.7 QM 206 C Window Rgt Sash I Metal Green 3.7 QM 209 C Door Lft Header I Metal Green 7.6 QM 210 C Door Lft Lft casing I Metal Green >9.9 QM 216 C Door Lft U Rgt I Metal Green >9.9 QM 219 D Window Lft Sash I Metal Green 8.0 QM 217 D Door Lft Rgt casing I Metal Green >9.9 QM Interior Room 001 201 020 A Pipe Lft I Metal Yellow 4.9 QM 014 B ladder Rgt I Metal Brown 2.7 QM 015 B Crown Mldg Rgt I Wood Brown 2.4 QM 021 B Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 7.4 QM 022 B Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 2.9 QM 023 B I-beam Rgt I Metal Yellow 3.9 QM 007 B Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 2.4 QM 008 B Window Lft Sash I Metal Brown 2.1 QM 030 C Pipe Ctr I Metal Blue 1.0 QM 026 C I-beam Rgt I Metal Yellow 5.6 QM 027 C Truss Rgt I Metal Yellow 8.7 QM 028 C ladder Rgt I Metal Gray 2.5 QM 013 C Wall L Lft gate I Metal Beige 7.4 QM 017 D Railing Rgt Balusters I Metal Beige 2.9 QM 016 D Railing Rgt Railing I Metal Beige 2.3 QM Interior Room 002 202 031 B Ceiling Ctr I Plaster White 1.0 QM 035 D Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 1.8 QM 034 D Door Ctr U Rgt I Wood Brown 3.2 QM Interior Room 003 202a 039 B Pipe Ctr I Metal White 3.1 QM 043 B Radiator Ctr I Metal White 1.4 QM 036 B Ceiling Ctr I Plaster White 2.0 QM 037 B Window Ctr Header I Metal Brown >9.9 QM 038 B Window Ctr Sash I Metal Brown 2.4 QM

041 C Window Ctr Header I Metal Brown 8.1 QM 040 C Window Ctr Sash I Metal Brown 3.2 QM Interior Room 004 203 045 C Window Ctr Rgt jamb P Plaster Brown 2.3 QM 044 C Window Ctr Sill I Wood Brown 3.6 QM 046 D Window Ctr Rgt casing I Metal Brown 3.8 QM Interior Room 005 stair 2 &cw 063 A Window Ctr Frame I Metal Green 6.3 QM 050 A Railing Ctr Railing I Metal Beige 1.8 QM 057 D vert column Lft I Metal Beige 1.7 QM 058 D hrzntl beam Lft I Metal Beige 2.9 QM 053 D Railing Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.2 QM Interior Room 006 stair 1 065 B Stairs Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.0 QM 064 B Stairs Ctr Railing cap I Metal Beige 1.7 QM 067 D Stairs Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.2 QM 066 D Stairs Ctr Railing cap I Metal Beige 2.4 QM Interior Room 007 101 082 A Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 3.5 QM 083 A pump Rgt pan I Metal Yellow 4.7 QM 120 A boiler 2 Rgt column I Metal Beige 3.5 QM 075 A Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green 2.4 QM 076 A Window Ctr Lft jamb I Metal Green 1.8 QM 074 A Door Rgt Lft casing I Metal Green 3.7 QM 078 A Column Ctr I Metal Beige 4.0 QM 131 B Floor Rgt gutter I Metal Brown 2.0 QM 089 C Pipe Lft I Metal Gray >9.9 QM 128 C boiler 3 Rgt pipe I Metal silver 1.0 QM 129 C boiler 3 Rgt pipe I Metal Yellow 2.7 QM 095 C Floor Ctr gutter I Metal Brown 1.0 QM 091 C Door Ctr Lft casing I Metal Green 2.8 QM 090 C Door Ctr L Lft I Metal Green 1.0 QM 103 D Pipe Ctr I Metal Yellow >9.9 QM on boiler 1 100 D Window Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Green 1.0 QM 099 D Door Lft Lft casing I Metal Green 1.6 QM 098 D Door Lft L Ctr I Metal Green 1.0 QM 104 D Column Ctr I Metal Beige 4.5 QM Interior Room 008 102 138 B Pipe Ctr I Metal silver 4.2 QM 142 C Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 2.2 QM 143 C Window Rgt Sash I Metal Brown 2.8 QM 147 D Window Rgt Sash I Metal Brown 2.5 QM 146 D Window Rgt Lft jamb I Concrete Brown 3.5 QM 149 D Door Ctr Rgt casing I Wood Brown 2.8 QM Interior Room 011 stair 3 168 D Stairs Rgt Balusters I Metal Beige 3.4 QM 167 D Stairs Rgt Railing cap I Metal Beige 3.1 QM Interior Room 012 001 178 B Column Ctr I Metal Beige 5.4 QM 183 C Pipe Rgt I Metal Green 3.5 QM Interior Room 013 steam tnl 186 C Floor Ctr I Metal Green 2.3 QM Calibration Readings

---- End of Readings ----

Paint Condition I = Intact F = Fair P = Poor

Appendix C

XRF Data

Building 111 - Boiler Plant Detailed.TXT DETAILED REPORT OF LEAD PAINT INSPECTION FOR: Building 111 - Boiler Plant

Inspection Date: 01/15/12 IHI Environmental #11P-A3138 Report Date: 1/24/2012 NAVAHCS Prescott, Arizona Abatement Level: 1.0 Report No. 01/15/12 15:11 Total Readings: 226 Job Started: 01/15/12 15:11 Job Finished: 01/16/12 11:40

Read Paint Paint Lead No. Wall Structure Location Member Cond Substrate Color (mg/cm²) Mode Exterior Room 001 Number Only 189 A ladder Ctr I Metal Brown 1.8 QM 190 A vent Ctr rail I Metal Green 0.0 QM 192 A vent Ctr I Metal Green -0.1 QM 193 A vent Ctr I Metal Green -0.3 QM 194 A vent Ctr casing I Metal Green 0.2 QM 195 A vent Ctr floor I Metal Green 0.4 QM 196 A Pipe Ctr I Metal Gray 0.1 QM 201 A Pipe Ctr I Metal Red 0.1 QM 187 A Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Green 2.1 QM 188 A Window Rgt Sash I Metal Green 2.9 QM 200 A Door Ctr threshold I Concrete Yellow 0.0 QM 198 A Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Wood Green 1.5 QM 199 A Door Ctr Lft casing I Wood Green 0.4 QM 197 A Door Ctr U Lft I Wood Green >9.9 QM 191 A Railing Ctr Balusters I Metal Green 0.5 QM 204 B Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green 4.5 QM 205 B Window Ctr Lft jamb I Metal Green 4.8 QM 203 B Door Rgt Rgt casing I Metal Green 0.3 QM 202 B Door Rgt U Lft I Metal Green 0.5 QM 213 C bollard Lft I Metal Yellow -0.2 QM 214 C Pipe Lft I Metal Yellow 0.0 QM 215 C Pipe Lft I Metal Yellow 0.2 QM 208 C bollard Rgt I Metal Red 0.1 QM 211 C Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Green >9.9 QM 218 C Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Green >9.9 QM 212 C Window Lft Sash I Metal Green 8.1 QM 207 C Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Green 4.7 QM 206 C Window Rgt Sash I Metal Green 3.7 QM 209 C Door Lft Header I Metal Green 7.6 QM 210 C Door Lft Lft casing I Metal Green >9.9 QM 216 C Door Lft U Rgt I Metal Green >9.9 QM 220 D Floor Lft threshold I Concrete Yellow -0.1 QM 219 D Window Lft Sash I Metal Green 8.0 QM 217 D Door Lft Rgt casing I Metal Green >9.9 QM Interior Room 001 201 020 A Pipe Lft I Metal Yellow 4.9 QM 014 B ladder Rgt I Metal Brown 2.7 QM 015 B Crown Mldg Rgt I Wood Brown 2.4 QM 021 B Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 7.4 QM 022 B Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 2.9 QM 023 B I-beam Rgt I Metal Yellow 3.9 QM 007 B Window Lft Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 2.4 QM 008 B Window Lft Sash I Metal Brown 2.1 QM 025 B Railing Rgt Balusters I Metal Gray 0.7 QM 024 B Railing Rgt Railing I Metal Gray 0.1 QM

010 C cabinet Lft I Wood Brown -0.1 QM 011 C cabinet Lft door I Wood Brown 0.1 QM 012 C cabinet Lft shelf I Wood Brown 0.2 QM 029 C Pipe Ctr I Metal silver 0.3 QM 030 C Pipe Ctr I Metal Blue 1.0 QM 026 C I-beam Rgt I Metal Yellow 5.6 QM 027 C Truss Rgt I Metal Yellow 8.7 QM 028 C ladder Rgt I Metal Gray 2.5 QM 009 C Wall L Lft I Brick Brown -0.1 QM 013 C Wall L Lft gate I Metal Beige 7.4 QM 018 D Stairs Rgt threshold I Concrete Yellow 0.1 QM 019 D Stairs Rgt threshold I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 017 D Railing Rgt Balusters I Metal Beige 2.9 QM 016 D Railing Rgt Railing I Metal Beige 2.3 QM Interior Room 002 202 032 B Baseboard Ctr I Wood Brown 0.3 QM 031 B Ceiling Ctr I Plaster White 1.0 QM 033 D Baseboard Ctr I Wood Brown -0.1 QM 035 D Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 1.8 QM 034 D Door Ctr U Rgt I Wood Brown 3.2 QM Interior Room 003 202a 039 B Pipe Ctr I Metal White 3.1 QM 043 B Radiator Ctr I Metal White 1.4 QM 036 B Ceiling Ctr I Plaster White 2.0 QM 037 B Window Ctr Header I Metal Brown >9.9 QM 038 B Window Ctr Sash I Metal Brown 2.4 QM 042 C Baseboard Ctr I Metal Brown 0.2 QM 041 C Window Ctr Header I Metal Brown 8.1 QM 040 C Window Ctr Sash I Metal Brown 3.2 QM Interior Room 004 203 049 A Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 0.1 QM 048 A Door Ctr U Rgt I Wood Brown 0.0 QM 045 C Window Ctr Rgt jamb P Plaster Brown 2.3 QM 044 C Window Ctr Sill I Wood Brown 3.6 QM 047 D Baseboard Ctr I Wood White 0.0 QM 046 D Window Ctr Rgt casing I Metal Brown 3.8 QM Interior Room 005 stair 2 &cw 061 A tank Lft I Metal silver -0.1 QM 062 A tank Lft pipe I Metal silver -0.1 QM 063 A Window Ctr Frame I Metal Green 6.3 QM 051 A Railing Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige -0.1 QM 050 A Railing Ctr Railing I Metal Beige 1.8 QM 056 D ladder Lft I Metal Brown 0.2 QM 057 D vert column Lft I Metal Beige 1.7 QM 058 D hrzntl beam Lft I Metal Beige 2.9 QM 059 D ladder Ctr I Metal Brown -0.1 QM 060 D ladder Rgt I Metal Brown -0.2 QM 055 D Stairs Ctr Stringers I Metal Beige -0.1 QM 054 D Stairs Ctr Treads I Metal Beige 0.6 QM 053 D Railing Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.2 QM 052 D Railing Ctr Railing I Metal Beige 0.3 QM Interior Room 006 stair 1 072 B Stairs Ctr Stringers I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 065 B Stairs Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.0 QM 064 B Stairs Ctr Railing cap I Metal Beige 1.7 QM 068 D Stairs Ctr Treads I Metal Beige 0.0 QM 071 D Stairs Ctr Treads I Metal Brown 0.7 QM 069 D Stairs Ctr Risers I Metal Beige 0.2 QM

070 D Stairs Ctr Risers I Metal Brown 0.2 QM 067 D Stairs Ctr Balusters I Metal Beige 5.2 QM 066 D Stairs Ctr Railing cap I Metal Beige 2.4 QM Interior Room 007 101 080 A I-beam Rgt pipe suppor I Metal Beige 0.0 QM 081 A Pipe Rgt Sprinkler I Metal Red 0.4 QM 082 A Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 3.5 QM 083 A pump Rgt pan I Metal Yellow 4.7 QM 084 A pump Rgt footer I Concrete Beige -0.2 QM 085 A equipment Rgt I Metal Green 0.0 QM 113 A boiler 2 Rgt I Metal Green -0.2 QM 118 A boiler 2 Rgt valve I Metal Blue 0.6 QM 119 A boiler 2 Rgt valve I Metal silver -0.2 QM 120 A boiler 2 Rgt column I Metal Beige 3.5 QM 122 A boiler 2 Rgt valve I Metal silver -0.1 QM 077 A Baseboard Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.3 QM 117 A Floor Rgt gutter I Metal Brown 0.4 QM 075 A Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green 2.4 QM 076 A Window Ctr Lft jamb I Metal Green 1.8 QM 073 A Door Rgt Header I Wood Green 0.6 QM 074 A Door Rgt Lft casing I Metal Green 3.7 QM 078 A Column Ctr I Metal Beige 4.0 QM 079 A Column Ctr footer I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 121 A Column Rgt footer I Concrete Beige 0.3 QM 088 B tank Lft I Metal Gray 0.2 QM 114 B boiler 2 Rgt I Metal Green 0.4 QM 115 B boiler 2 Rgt Frame I Metal Green 0.0 QM 116 B boiler 2 Rgt footer I Concrete Beige 0.0 QM 086 B Floor Lft I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 087 B Floor Lft footer I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 131 B Floor Rgt gutter I Metal Brown 2.0 QM 089 C Pipe Lft I Metal Gray >9.9 QM 096 C sw board Ctr I Metal Black -0.1 QM 097 C Pipe Rgt I Metal Yellow 0.3 QM 123 C boiler 3 Rgt I Metal Green 0.2 QM 125 C boiler 3 Rgt Frame I Metal Green 0.2 QM 126 C boiler 3 Rgt footer I Concrete Beige 0.4 QM 127 C boiler 3 Rgt valve I Metal silver 0.0 QM 128 C boiler 3 Rgt pipe I Metal silver 1.0 QM 129 C boiler 3 Rgt pipe I Metal Yellow 2.7 QM 130 C boiler 3 Rgt column I Metal Beige 0.1 QM 094 C Baseboard Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.3 QM 095 C Floor Ctr gutter I Metal Brown 1.0 QM 092 C Window Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Green 0.1 QM 093 C Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green 0.0 QM 091 C Door Ctr Lft casing I Metal Green 2.8 QM 090 C Door Ctr L Lft I Metal Green 1.0 QM 103 D Pipe Ctr I Metal Yellow >9.9 QM on boiler 1 105 D boiler Ctr footer I Concrete Beige 0.1 QM 106 D boiler Ctr Frame I Metal Green -0.1 QM 107 D boiler 1 Ctr I Metal Green 0.2 QM 108 D boiler 1 Rgt I Metal Green 0.0 QM 109 D boiler 1 Rgt I Metal silver 0.2 QM 110 D boiler 1 Rgt pipe I Metal silver -0.3 QM 111 D boiler 1 Rgt valve I Metal Blue 0.3 QM 112 D boiler 1 Rgt ladder I Metal Brown 0.4 QM 124 D boiler 3 Rgt I Metal Green 0.5 QM 102 D Baseboard Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.5 QM 100 D Window Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Green 1.0 QM 101 D Window Ctr Sash I Metal Green -0.1 QM 099 D Door Lft Lft casing I Metal Green 1.6 QM

098 D Door Lft L Ctr I Metal Green 1.0 QM 104 D Column Ctr I Metal Beige 4.5 QM Interior Room 008 102 134 A Baseboard Lft I Brick Brown 0.0 QM 133 A Door Lft Rgt casing I Metal Beige -0.1 QM 132 A Door Lft U Lft I Metal Beige -0.1 QM 138 B Pipe Ctr I Metal silver 4.2 QM 135 B Baseboard Lft I Concrete Beige 0.5 QM 137 B Window Lft Sash I Metal Beige 0.2 QM 136 B Window Lft Sill I Concrete Beige 0.3 QM 152 C bench Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.0 QM 153 C bench Ctr top I Wood Brown -0.3 QM 139 C Wall L Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 140 C Wall L Rgt I Concrete Beige 0.5 QM 150 C Floor Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 142 C Window Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 2.2 QM 143 C Window Rgt Sash I Metal Brown 2.8 QM 141 C Window Rgt Sill I Concrete Beige 0.2 QM 151 C Column Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.5 QM 144 D Wall L Ctr I Concrete Beige 0.1 QM 147 D Window Rgt Sash I Metal Brown 2.5 QM 145 D Window Rgt Sill I Concrete Beige 0.3 QM 146 D Window Rgt Lft jamb I Concrete Brown 3.5 QM 148 D Door Ctr Header I Wood Brown 0.5 QM 149 D Door Ctr Rgt casing I Wood Brown 2.8 QM Interior Room 009 103 154 A Floor Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 157 A Door Ctr threshold I Concrete Beige -0.2 QM 158 A Door Ctr threshold I Concrete Yellow 0.4 QM 156 A Door Ctr Lft casing I Metal Green 0.2 QM 155 A Door Ctr U Lft I Metal Green -0.1 QM Comment: no paint on walls & ceiling Interior Room 010 104 160 A generator Ctr footer I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 159 A Floor Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.3 QM 163 B Door Ctr Rgt jamb I Metal Brown 0.0 QM 162 B Door Ctr U Rgt I Metal Brown -0.1 QM 161 B Door Ctr U Lft I Metal Brown -0.2 QM 165 C Door Rgt Rgt jamb I Metal Brown -0.1 QM 166 C Door Rgt Lft casing I Wood Brown 0.0 QM 164 C Door Rgt U Rgt I Metal Brown -0.1 QM Comment: no paint on walls & ceiling Interior Room 011 stair 3 173 D Stairs Rgt Stringers I Concrete Beige 0.5 QM 172 D Stairs Rgt Baseboard I Concrete Beige 0.2 QM 169 D Stairs Rgt Treads I Concrete Brown 0.6 QM 170 D Stairs Rgt Treads I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 171 D Stairs Rgt Risers I Concrete Beige 0.2 QM 168 D Stairs Rgt Balusters I Metal Beige 3.4 QM 167 D Stairs Rgt Railing cap I Metal Beige 3.1 QM Interior Room 012 001 176 A pump Ctr footer I Concrete Beige 0.7 QM 181 A pump Ctr I Metal silver 0.0 QM 175 A Baseboard Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 177 B pump Ctr footer I Concrete Beige 0.1 QM 178 B Column Ctr I Metal Beige 5.4 QM 183 C Pipe Rgt I Metal Green 3.5 QM 184 C Floor Lft grate I Metal Red -0.2 QM

179 D post Lft I Metal Beige -0.1 QM 182 D pump Ctr I Metal Gray -0.2 QM 180 D ladder Rgt I Metal Brown 0.2 QM 174 D Floor Ctr I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM Interior Room 013 steam tnl 185 A Floor Lft I Concrete Beige -0.1 QM 186 C Floor Ctr I Metal Green 2.3 QM Calibration Readings 001 -0.1 Std 002 -0.2 Std 003 -0.2 Std 004 1.0 Std 005 1.0 Std 006 0.8 Std 221 -0.1 Std 222 -0.1 Std 223 -0.1 Std 224 1.0 Std 225 1.0 Std 226 0.9 Std ---- End of Readings ----

Paint Condition I = Intact F = Fair P = Poor

Appendix D

Cost Estimates

NAVAHCS Building 111 - Boiler Plant

Lead-Based Paint Abatement Cost

Estimates

Components in Poor Condition

Chemical Removal Component Removal

Room Number Building Component Quantity (sf) Unit

Cost Total* Unit Cost Total*

Interior – Rm 203 Wall C Window Jam 6 $13.31 $79.86 $5.32 $31.92

Total $79.86 $31.92

Appendix E

IHI Certifications