Thule Air Base Energy Management and Control Systems Upgrades _ BOD_RTA.pdf

Thule Air Base Energy Management and Control Systems Upgrades

Design Analysis Handbook

June 15, 2022

New York District, USACE

Design Analysis Handbook

New York District, USACE

Basis of Design i

Contents

1. Project Summary

1.1 Purpose

1.2 Authorization

1.3 Acquisition Strategy

1.4 Project Description and Scope Validation

2. Existing Conditions

2.1 Base-Wide EMCS

2.2 EMCS Network

2.3 Existing Controls

3. Proposed Improvements

3.1 Facility-Related Control Systems Cybersecurity

Appendix A. DD1391

Appendix B. Product Data

Appendix C. FRCS Cybersecurity Control Correlation Identifiers

1. Project Summary

1.1 Purpose

This report provides a basis of design and summary of design analyses for the upgrade of the energy management and control system (EMCS) of 62 buildings at Thule Air Base, Greenland. The project is intended to upgrade existing control systems to control and monitor the existing HVAC and other building systems, which will improve energy savings and efficiency, and also provide provision for future connection and integration into the existing base-wide EMCS.

1.2 Authorization

This Design Analysis Handbook has been authorized by the Air Force Civil Engineer Center as the proponent agency for Thule Air Base, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New York District.

• Date of Issuance – 29 September 2021

• Program Year – FY22 Design, FY22-23 Construction

• Programmed Amount (per DD1391 dated 31 August 2017) - $6,000,000

1.3 Acquisition Strategy

This project will be bid as Design Bid Build and will be funded by the Energy Resilience and Conservation

Investment Program (ERCIP) funds. Construction will be solicited from Danish contractors. Wage rates will be estimated using New York and New Jersey wage rates as these have historically matched Danish rates within an acceptable level.

1.4 Project Description and Scope Validation

The US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) has initiated efforts to upgrade the EMCS at 62 buildings at Thule Air

Base. Phase 1 of this project, completed prior to 2017, installed a fiber backbone and monitoring to a limited number of buildings. Phase 1 did not provide controls for a majority of dormitories or smaller administrative buildings on Thule Air Base. The base cannot monitor or control the temperatures in buildings that were not included in Phase 1. The base uses excessive energy to overheating unoccupied buildings and spaces, and this also incurs expensive repair costs if a facility freezes during storm conditions. The HVAC systems in these buildings are not currently controlled and/or monitored by centralized EMCS system, which leads to energy waste from overheating or expensive repairs in the event of a facility freezing during storm conditions. By providing DDC controls including controllers, sensors, actuators, and interface devices connected to the EMCS for the 62 buildings included in this Phase, Thule Air Base will be able to control and monitor the equipment status and operating conditions in the facilities and avoid the costs associated with heating unoccupied buildings and frozen systems during storm events.

This project scope is limited to the addition of controls to the existing buildings, and supplementary electrical work as required to power DDC controllers, actuators, sensors, and interface devices. No additional building systems are provided as part of this project.

2. Existing Conditions

2.1 Base-Wide EMCS

The site has a base-wide EMCS installed throughout the base to control and monitor the HVAC equipment and other building systems. The majority of EMCS components were installed under the Phase 1 EMCS upgrade project, which included the installation and integration of EMCS for more than 100 buildings. The base-wide

EMCS is based on the Trend Controls system and the HMI/workstation loaded with Trend Controls 963

Supervisor front-end software is currently located in Building 1411.

2.2 EMCS Network

The existing EMCS utilizes the base-wide fiber-optic network backbone to facilitate the communication between the server and local systems in the buildings that is also being used for other building systems, such as Public

Announce System (PAS), Fire Alarm System (FAS), and TV/Cable Services. The buildings with the existing EMCS are connected to the base-wide fiber-optic network using the Ethernet connection via a fiber-optic termination/switch box in each building.

The existing fiber-optic network is outdated and the bandwidth for use of EMCS is limited to a low speed at 3

Mbps. The base is currently working on a project to upgrade the base-wide fiber-optic infrastructure that will provide the new fiber-optic cables and termination/switch boxes throughout the entire base and also increase the network speed up to 1 Gbps.

The DDC system provided under this project will be local, stand-alone system with necessary components for future connection and integration into the base-wide EMCS. Once the new fiber-optic network infrastructure is provided, the local DDC system provided under this project will be connected to and fully integrated into the base-wide EMCS for remote control and monitoring capability in the future.

2.3 Existing Controls

Some of the buildings included in this project have the existing EMCS installed under the Phase 1 EMCS project however the controls associated with some mechanical equipment and components were not upgraded and they are currently not being controlled and/or monitored by the EMCS. The hot water system including heat exchangers and pumps are controlled by self-contained, electric controls. The radiators and unit heaters serving most of occupied spaces are controlled by either unit or wall mounted thermostats or thermostatic control valves. The air handling units are controlled by the self-contained, packaged controls however run status, operating conditions and other parameters are not monitored by the EMCS.

Although local, self-contained controls for most equipment are operational, some control and field devices including thermostats were damaged or not fully operational, so the associated equipment was placed in manual operation.

The buildings with the existing EMCS have legacy Trend Controls controllers, IQ3 series, and these controllers had been discontinued by the manufacturer and the replacement part is no longer available.

3. Proposed Improvements

New local DDC system will be provided and connected to the base-wide EMCS to control and monitor the HVAC equipment and other components. The new system will utilize a BACnet as a communication protocol. Trend's proprietary sub-network communication may be used where the existing equipment needs to be integrated into the existing base-wide EMCS however they must be fully compatible with the existing Trend Controls EMCS.

The operation of all mechanical and other building systems controlled and monitored by the EMCS, including new local DDC system provided under this project, will operate as a whole and make no distinction between existing and new equipment. For the buildings with the existing EMCS, the existing EMCS server and front-end software will be modified to incorporate the new local DDC system added under this project and the settings, level of details, graphical displays and system functionalities will be maintained as they are currently configured.

For the buildings where a stand-alone, local DDC system will be provided but not connected to the base-wide

EMCS, a local display panel (LDP) will be provided. The LDP will server as a primary access point for local DDC system where the operator can adjust the schedule, set points and other settings.

All existing IQ3 series controllers in the buildings will be replaced with the current generation of Trend controllers, IQ4 series. All existing I/O points will be re-connected, and the sequence of operation and associated programming will be re-loaded/re-configured for the new controllers. The removed IQ3 series controllers will be turned over to the base so they can be used as spare parts.

This project will provide new EMCS to control and/or monitor the HVAC equipment and other components for the buildings listed below.

Buildings 106, 115, 116, 127, 134, 136, 142, 143, 144, 145, 151, 212, 214, 216, 231, 233, 243, 244, 246, 252, 254, 255, 256 and 367 (Typical): These buildings are on the EMCS however the hot water system, air handling unit, and/or heat trace are not controlled or monitored by the EMCS. The existing controls associated with the hot water system and air handling unit will be replaced with new DDC controls and incorporated into the existing

EMCS. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace will be added to the existing EMCS. The existing IQ3 controllers will be replaced with IQ4 series controllers.

Building 200: This building is on the EMCS however compressors for air handling units and space temperature in food storage are not monitored by the EMCS. This project will add food storage temperature monitoring and alarm, and also add the status and alarm monitoring of compressors associated with air handling units to the existing EMCS.

Building 211: This building is on the EMCS however the radiators, unit heaters, and heat trace are not controlled or monitored by the EMCS. The existing controls associated with the radiators and unit heaters will be replaced with new DDC controls and incorporated into the existing EMCS. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace will be added to the existing EMCS. The existing IQ3 controllers will be replaced with IQ4 series controllers.

Buildings 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 331, 333, 334, 335, 336, 342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 351, 352, 353, 354 and

355 (Typical): The existing controls associated with the hot water system, air handling unit and/or radiators will be replaced with new DDC controls. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace will be added to the new DDC controls.

Buildings 562, 564 and 577 (Typical): The hot water system in Building 562 serves Buildings 564 and 577. The existing controls associated with the hot water system, air handling units and radiators in these buildings will be replaced with new DDC controls. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace will be added to the new DDC controls.

Buildings 614, 615, 616 and 617 (Typical): These buildings house fuel pumps and electrical switchgears that are critical to base operation, served by electric unit heaters however the space conditions are not monitored by the

EMCS. The existing controls associated with the electric radiators and unit heaters will be replaced with new DDC controls. Also, the status and alarm monitoring of engine generators and the status electrical emergency shutdown switch will be added to the new DDC controls.

Building 935: The existing controls associated with the hot water system, ventilation units, radiators and unit heaters will be replaced with new DDC controls. The status and alarm monitoring of steam boilers and fuel oil tank will be added to the new DDC controls.

Bid Options:

Option 1

- Electric Domestic Water Heaters in Buildings 145, 214, 321, 324, 336, 346, 352, 353, 354, and 355

(Typical): Provide new DDC controls for electric domestic water heaters including domestic water temperature sensors, control relays and/or control valves.

Option 2

- Buildings 703, 705, and 707 (Typical): The existing controls associated with the electric radiators and domestic water heaters will be replaced with new DDC controls. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace will be added to the new DDC controls.

Option 3

- Buildings 104, 114 and 245 (Typical): These buildings are on the EMCS however the radiators are not controlled or monitored by the EMCS. The existing controls associated with the radiators will be replaced with new DDC controls and incorporated into the existing EMCS.

Option 4

- Building 287: This building is on the EMCS however the status and alarm points associated with the engine generator for the building is not monitored by the EMCS. This project will provide necessary field/control devices and add the status and alarm monitoring of engine generator to the existing EMCS.

- Building 1401: The existing controls associated with the unit heaters will be replaced with new DDC controls. The status and alarm monitoring of heat trace and boilers will be added to the new DDC controls.

3.1 Facility-Related Control Systems Cybersecurity

A. INTRODUCTION AND DESIGN CRITERIA

This section describes the cybersecurity design requirements for Facility-Related Control Systems (FRCS) for the

EMCS Upgrade Project at Thule AB, Greenland. UFC 04-010-06 & UFGS Division 25 are required for FRCS

Cybersecurity design compliance.

Following are additional references for informational purposes:

• Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) 4-010-06 Cybersecurity of Facility-Related Control Systems, Change 01, 18 January 2017

• Unified Facilities Guide Specifications (UFGS) Division 25, Integrated Automation, Cybersecurity for

Facility-Related Control Systems, November 2017

• Committee on National Security Systems Instruction (CNSSI) 1253, Security Categorization and Control

Selection for National Security Systems, March 2014

• Department of Defense Advanced Cyber Industrial Control System Tactics, Techniques and Procedures

(ACI TTP) for Department of Defense (DOD) Industrial Control Systems (ICS) Revision 2, March 2018

• Department of Defense Directive 8140.01 Cyberspace Workforce Management, July 2017

• Department of Defense Instruction 8500.01, Cybersecurity, March 2014

• Department of Defense Instruction 8510.01, Risk Management Framework (RMF) for DoD Information

Technology (IT), March 2014

• Department of Defense Instruction 8530.01 Cybersecurity Activities Support for DoD Information

Network Operations, July 2017

• Department of Defense Handbook for Self-Assessing Security Vulnerabilities & Risks of Industrial Control

Systems on DoD Installations, December 2012

• Federal Information Processing Standard (FIPS) 200 Minimum Security Requirements for Federal

Information and Information Systems, March 2006

• Federal Information Processing Standard (FIPS) 201-2 Personal Identity Verification (PIV) of Federal

Employees and Contractors, August 2013

• National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication (NIST SP) 800-37, Revision 2, Risk

Management Framework for Information Systems and Organizations: A System Life Cycle Approach for

Security and Privacy, December 2018

• National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication (NIST SP) 800-53 Revision 5 Security and Privacy Controls for Information Systems and Organizations, September 2020

• National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication (NIST SP) 800-82 Revision 2 Guide to Industrial Control Systems (ICS) Security, May 2015

• National Institute of Standards and Technology Special Publication SP (NIST SP) 800-115 Technical

Guide to Information Security Testing and Assessment, September 2008

• Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) 1-200-02 High Performance and Sustainable Building Requirements, 01

December 2020

• Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) 3-410-02 Direct Digital Control for HVAC and Other Building Control

Systems, 18 July 2018

• Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC) 3-470-01 Utility Monitoring and Control System (UMCS) Front End and

Integration, 12 January 2018

B. FACILITY-RELATED CONTROL SYSTEMS CYBERSECURITY DESCRIPTION

Information below was obtained from RFI submitted to Thule AB stakeholders for a parallel project effort onsite.

RFI responses provided by Michael Lobo, 21st CES/CENP Site Support Engineer and incorporated below. Civil

Engineering Community of Interest Network Enclave (CE COINE) has not yet been implemented on base.

The following contact information regarding FRCS for this project was obtained from Thule AB Project

Stakeholders:

For FRCS, COINE, RMF, eMASS support please email:

AFCEC.COMI.ICSHELPDESK@us.af.mil or Call (850) 775-3200

SMITH, PARRISH W GS-12 USAF AFCEC AFCEC/COOI parrish.smith.2@us.af.mil

CE COINE System Manager / COR

Facility Related Control Systems (FRCS) Branch

Air Force Civil Engineer Center

Comm (850) 775-3183

ISSM for Thule AB is Mr. Frank Serrano, 21st CES/CEOI, franklin.serrano@spaceforce.mil

ISO for Thule AB is Mr Jeff Robertson, 21st CES/CD, william.robertson.13@spaceforce.mil

Site Support Engineer is Michael Lobo, 21st CES/CENP, michael.lobo@spaceforce.mil

This project will provide EMCS upgrade for 62 buildings as described in the above sections. The EMCS in each building will remain localized and not be connected to the existing HMI Front-End in Building 1411 at Thule AB via base fiber optic backbone at this time. The existing EMCS server and front-end software will be modified to incorporate the new local DDC system added under this project and the settings, levels of details, graphical displays and system functionalities will be maintained as they are currently configured. There are no existing

CJ&A justifications for this project. There are existing Authority To Operate (ATO) with eMASS ID’s as noted below.

All EMCS equipment will be Contractor Furnished and Installed.

UFGS, Division 25, Section 25 05 11, Cybersecurity of FRCS Guide Specification has been included in the submittals as it outlines deliverables based on UFC 4-010-06, Cybersecurity for FRCS, which delineates design requirements per design phase. UFGS Division 25 does not provide general requirements for a control system, nor are the requirements in UFGS Division 25 sufficient to procure a control system. UFGS Division 25 must be used in conjunction with other controls system specifications; For example, for HVAC controls within a project, UFGS Division 25 should be used in conjunction with Section 23 09 00 and all related sections.

Control Correlation Identifiers (CCIs) have been attached to this design analysis.

FRCS Type

Authorizing

Official

(AO)

System

Owner (SO)

Transport

Protocol

Installation

Authority

To

Operate

(ATO)

CJ&A? C-I-A Impact

Level

Energy

Management

Control

System –

EMCS – local building installation only at this time

HQ

AFCEC/CA

821st Air

Base Group

Civil

Engineering

BACNET

(but

LOCAL

BAS only at this time)

All EMCS equipment to be

Contractor

Furnished

Contractor

Installed

(CFCI)

Yes

EMCS

eMASS

ID# 8057

UMCS

eMASS

ID# 8158

No CJ&A exists for

EMCS at Thule AB

L-L-L

Appendix A. DD1391

DD FORM 1391, DEC 99 Previous editions are obsolete. Page No.

1. COMPONENT

AIR FORCE

FY 2019 MILITARY CONSTRUCTION PROJECT DATA

(computer generated)

2. DATE

31 Aug 17

3. INSTALLATION, SITE AND LOCATION 4. PROJECT TITLE

THULE AIR BASE INSTALL ENERGY MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEM,

THULE AIR BASE SITE # 1 PHASE 2

GREENLAND

5. PROGRAM ELEMENT

14494

6. CATEGORY CODE

218-868

7. RPSUID/PROJECT NUMBER

3339/WWCX173002

8. PROJECT COST ($000)

6,000

9. COST ESTIMATES

ITEM U/M QUANTITY UNIT

COST

($000)

PRIMARY FACILITIES 4,690

EMCS SM 67 70,000 (4,690)

SUPPORTING FACILITIES 10

UTILITIES LS (5)

SITE IMPROVEMENTS LS (5)

SUBTOTAL 4,700

CONTINGENCY (5%) 235

TOTAL CONTRACT COST 4,935

SUPERVISION, INSPECTION AND OVERHEAD (6.5%) 306

DESIGN (6%) 282

TOTAL REQUEST 5,523

TOTAL REQUEST (ROUNDED) 6,000

10. Description of Proposed Construction: Install Phase 2 of Energy Management and Control System (EMCS) in 67 buildings and above ground utility systems that were not included in the WWCX 03-1004A. System will include sensors, actuators, and interface devices within buildings and limited fiber optic communications to interconnect buildings. System will be compatible with existing system installed by WWCX 03-1004A and with planned changes to central heating utility. Control action will be limited to facilities identified as end state and will not be installed in facilities to be abandoned or demolished as a result of Thule Consolidation projects. System will control heating and lighting per occupancy schedules and limit the range of temperatures selectable by the user to prevent overheating areas or allowing areas to freeze.

11. Requirement: Adequate: Substandard:

PROJECT: Install Phase 2 of Energy Management and Control System (EMCS) to interface with heating and ventilation systems, lighting systems and above-ground utility systems on base.

REQUIREMENT: Install Energy Management and Control System conforming to UFC 3-410- 02 in selected buildings and utilities to provide control of facility energy use and thus produce energy savings and reductions in operations and maintenance costs.

CURRENT SITUATION: Phase 1 of EMCS provided fiber backbone and monitoring to a limited number of buildings. Additionally, some control connectivity was installed. The initial phase did not reach the majority of the dormitories or smaller administrative buildings at Thule Air Base. This impedes the base in monitoring and controlling the temperatures the buildings not included in phase 1 and leads to energy waste from overheating or expensive repairs in the event of a facility freezing during storm conditions.

IMPACT IF NOT PROVIDED:

Energy savings advantages of building automation system will not be realized.

ADDITIONAL: An economic analysis has been performed on this project. The proposed replacement is based on the least cost alternative. The Savings to Investment Ratio (SIR) is 2.49 and simple payback is 5.7 years. The annual savings are calculated to be 45,187 MBTU per year and $977,395 per year. Option D (whole building metering) is the measurement and verification plan for this ERCIP project.

Metering is a part of this project.

Base Civil Engineer: Lt Col D. Landon Phillips, Commercial (719) 556-7633

I have reviewed this document and certify it is complete and accurate. I have validated the project's primary and supporting costs and work classification. It has been coordinated with the user and other appropriate agencies and approved by the Installation Commander.

D. LANDON PHILLIPS, Lt Col, USAF

Commander, 21st Civil Engineer Squadron

FY 2019 MILITARY CONSTRUCTION PROJECT DATA

(computer generated)

2. DATE

31 Aug 17

3. INSTALLATION, SITE AND LOCATION

THULE AIR BASE

THULE AIR BASE SITE # 1

GREENLAND

4. PROJECT TITLE

INSTALL ENERGY MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEM,

PHASE 2

5. PROGRAM ELEMENT

14494

6. CATEGORY CODE

218-868

7. RPSUID/PROJECT NUMBER

3339/WWCX173002

8. PROJECT COST ($000)

6,000

This project will demonstrate a short payback period and savings to investment ration that will qualify the project for the funding from the Energy Resilience & Conservation Investment Program.

This is the second phase of the EMCS project and will extend control to 181 systems in and around 67 buildings. This will enable automated control of building temperatures, wet utilities temperatures, ventilation and lighting based on the occupancy, outdoor air temperatures, wind conditions and use of the area. This system will allow the base to save an estimated 45,187 MMBTU per year (approximately 325,815 gallons of JP8 fuel) with cost savings of approximately $977,400 per year.

CURRENT SITUATION: The installation of EMCS at Thule Air Base is only half complete. There are 67 buildings that do not benefit from available modern technology for monitoring and control. There are 21 multi-unit dormitory buildings that have only local (i.e. occupant) control over heat and lighting leading to excessive energy use when occupants heat to high levels or leave energy consuming items on when the area is unoccupied. In some cases, excessive repair costs are incurred when buildings freeze when unoccupied due to a heating system failure or when water or sewage line freeze due to failed heat tracing. Heating, lighting and ventilation systems are sometimes left on when spaces are unoccupied resulting in wasted energy. Much of the waste occurs from overheated buildings due to deficient temperature controls

IMPACT IF NOT PROVIDED: If not provided, Thule Air Base will continue to waste energy and spend excessive operations and maintenance dollars on recurring repairs due to freezing. The USAF will also forego anticipated savings of $977.4K per year.

ADDITIONAL: A life cycle cost analysis for the project has been conducted resulting in a simple payback of 5.7 years and savings to investment ratio of 2.49.

11C. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS SECTION: Maintain status quo vs. completion of EMCS project

11D. ECONOMIC JUSTIFICATION SUMMARY:

Life-cycle cost analysis

1. Investment costs were developed in-house based on costs experienced in first phase.

2. Live-Cycle costs were calculated using the National Institute of Standards and Technology Energy Price Indices and Discount Factors for Life-Cycle cost analysis.

a. Total investment cost with SIOH = $5,523,872

b. Energy Savings Summary (all JP8):

Cost/MMBTU Savings MMBTU/Yr $/Yr Discount factor Discounted Savings

$21.63 45,187 977,395 14.101 $13,782,362

c. Non-energy savings: $0

d. First year dollar savings: $977,395

e. Simple Payback Period (Years): 5.7

f. Total Net Discounted Savings: $13,782,362

g. Savings to Investment Ratio: 2.49

3. Energy Savings Calculations: Energy savings are the reduction in fuel to create heating steam and to generate electricity for lighting. This project will allow automated control of lighting and heating in 67 buildings which currently only have local manual control.

4. Savings Verification Plan: The savings that will be realized as a result of this project will be verified by:

a. Comparing fuel consumption at the central Combined Heat/Power plant in before and after project conditions

b. Individual building metering.

5. Closure Statement: This base is not being considered for closure or realignment.

FY 2019 MILITARY CONSTRUCTION PROJECT DATA

(computer generated)

2. DATE

31 Aug 17

3. INSTALLATION AND LOCATION

THULE AIR BASE

THULE AIR BASE SITE # 1

GREENLAND

4. PROJECT TITLE

INSTALL ENERGY MANAGEMENT CONTROL

SYSTEM, PHASE 2

5. PROGRAM ELEMENT

14494

6. CATEGORY CODE

218-868

7. PROJECT NUMBER

3339/WWCX173002

8. PROJECT COST ($000)

6,000

12. SUPPLEMENTAL DATA:

a. Estimated Design Data:

(1) Status:

(a) Date Design Started NA

(b) Parametric Cost Estimates used to develop costs YES

* (c) Percent Complete as of 01 JAN 2018 0%

* (d) Date 35% Designed

(e) Date Design Complete

(f) Energy Study/Life-Cycle analysis was/will be performed NO

(2) Basis:

(a) Standard or Definitive Design - NO

(b) Where Design Was Most Recently Used -

(3) Total Cost (c) = (a) + (b) or (d) + (e): ($000)

(a) Production of Plans and Specifications 0

(b) All Other Design Costs 0

(c) Total 0

(d) Contract 0

(e) In-house 0

(4) Construction Contract Award

(5) Construction Start

(6) Construction Completion

* Indicates completion of Project Definition with Parametric Cost Estimate which is comparable to traditional 35% design to ensure valid scope, cost and executability.

b. Equipment associated with this project provided from other appropriations: N/A

NIST BLCC 5.3-15: ECIP Report Consistent with Federal Life Cycle Cost Methodology and Procedures, 10 CFR, Part 436, Subpart A The LCC calculations are based on the FEMP discount rates and energy price escalation rates updated on April 1, 2015.

Location: Alaska Discount Rate: 3%

Project Title:

WWCX173002, EMCS Phase 2, Thule Air Base Analyst: W.J. Bayles PE

Base Date: August 1, 2019 Preparation Date:

Fri Jun 23 12:49:50 MDT

BOD: August 1, 2019 Economic Life: 15 years 0 months

File Name:

C:\BLCC 5\projects\WWCX 173002 EMCS Phase

2.xml

1. Investment

Construction Cost $4,943,826

SIOH $306,046

Design Cost $282,504

Total Cost $5,532,376

Salvage Value of Existing Equipment $0

Public Utility Company $0

Total Investment $5,532,376

2. Energy and Water Savings (+) or Cost (-) Base Date Savings, unit costs, & discounted savings

Item Unit Cost Usage Savings Annual Savings Discount Factor Discounted Savings

Distillate Fuel Oil (#1, #2) $21.63000 45,187.0 MBtu $977,395 14.101 $13,782,362

Energy Subtotal 45,187.0 MBtu $977,395 $13,782,362

Water Subtotal 0.0 Mgal $0 $0

Total $977,395 $13,782,362

3. Non-Energy Savings (+) or Cost (-)

Item Savings/Cost Occurrence Discount Factor Discounted Savings/Cost

Non-Annually Recurring

Non-Annually Recurring Subtotal $0 $0

Total $0 $0

4. First year savings $977,395

5. Simple Payback Period (in years) 5.66 (total investment/first-year savings)

6. Total Discounted Operational Savings

$13,782,362

7. Savings to Investment Ratio

(SIR)

2.49 (total discounted operational savings/total investment)

8. Adjusted Internal Rate of Return (AIRR)

9.46% (1+d)*SIR^(1/n)-1; d=discount rate, n=years in study period

Appendix B. Product Data

DOC-0002595 www.onicon.com Rev.C

F-3200

INLINE

ELECTROMAGNETIC

FLOW METER

ONICON

Flow and Energy Measurement

ONICON’s F-3000 Series is a family of inline flow meters that provide accurate, reliable flow measurement for a variety of applications.

• Chilled Water • Hot Water • Domestic Water • Condenser Water •

727.447.6140 Page 2 onicon.com

ONICON

Flow and Energy Measurement

F-3200

INLINE ELECTROMAGNETIC FLOW METER

DESCRIPTION

ONICON F-3000 Series Inline Electromagnetic Flow Meters are suitable for measuring electrically conductive liquids in a wide variety of applications. The F-3200 can be configured to provide analog outputs for flow rate, programmable pulse outputs for flow totalization, and serial communications via an RS485 network.

APPLICATIONS

• HVAC hydronic applications including chilled water, heating hot water and condenser water

• Bi-directional flow for primary/secondary bypass and thermal storage applications

• Domestic cold and hot water applications

• Clean process flow applications with conductivities greater than 5 µS/cm

Faraday’s Law states that a voltage will be induced in a conductor (the conductive fluid) when it passes through a magnetic field (generated by the meter), and that voltage will be directly proportional to the velocity of the conductor (the fluid). This voltage is measured by electrodes on opposite sides of the flow tube and used to calculate the flow velocity.

For energy measurement applications, the F-3200 flow meter can be specified together with an ONICON BTU Meter, forming a complete energy measurement system.

CALIBRATION

Every ONICON F-3000 series flow meter is wet calibrated in a flow laboratory against standards that are directly traceable to international standards. A certificate of calibration accompanies every meter.

FEATURES

Exceptional Performance & Accuracy – F-3000 series inline meters deliver unmatched accuracy in installations with just three diameters of straight pipe upstream of the meter!

Easy to Install and Use - Every ONICON meter is individually wet calibrated and programmed for the application - saving start-up and commissioning time!

Excellent Long Term Reliability - ONICON electromagnetic flow meters have no moving parts and employ state-of-the-art electronics, ensuring years of accurate, trouble-free performance.

Redundant Outputs – The F-3000 series inline meters can be ordered with an additional redundant analog output. This optional feature can provide a cost-effective alternative in Mission Critical applications which require redundant flow measurements.

727.447.6140 Page 3 onicon.com

Flow and Energy Measurement

F-3200

INLINE ELECTROMAGNETIC FLOW METER

* SPECIFICATIONS subject to change without notice.

** See model codification for additional information regarding option selections.

*** Selection based on application.

F-3200 TRANSMITTER

PERFORMANCE ACCURACY ± 0.2% of reading from 1.6 to 33 ft/s ± 0.0033 ft/s at flow rates < 1.6 ft/s

MINIMUM CONDUCTIVITY 5 µS/cm INPUT POWER** AVAILABLE OPTIONS • Low Power, 24 VAC/DC, 50/60 Hz, 12 VA

• High Power, 110 - 240 VAC, 50/60 Hz, 12 VA I/O SIGNALS** AVAILABLE OPTIONS • Two (2) digital outputs, one (1) digital input and one (1) analog output

• Four (4) digital outputs, one (1) digital input and two (2) analog outputs

• MODBUS RTU (RS485)

ELECTRONICS

ENCLOSURE**

IP67 (NEMA 4X) enclosure with display AVAILABLE OPTIONS • Integral mount

• Remote (wall) mount with kit, up to 325 ft in fluids with conductivity ≥ 200 µS/cm

DISPLAY 16-character, 8 - line, 128x64 graphic LCD with back light AMBIENT CONDITIONS Transmitter: -4 °F to 140 °F

PROGRAMMING Menu driven user interface via three (3) programming keys

ELECTRICAL

CONNECTIONS

INPUT POWER Removable terminal blocks for use with 14 - 22 gauge wire I/O SIGNALS Removable terminal blocks for use with 18 - 24 gauge wire COIL & ELECTRODES Removable terminal blocks for use with sensor cable provided

APPROVALS CE 2014/30/EU EMC Directive 2014/35/EU LVD Directive

F-3000 SERIES FLOW SENSOR

PERFORMANCE SENSING METHOD Electromagnetic sensing (no moving parts)

OPERATING

CONDITIONS

FLUID TEMPERATURE RANGE See Liner Selection Table on back page FLUID PRESSURE RANGE See Liner Selection Table on back page

FLOW SENSOR

DESIGN**

FLOW TUBE 304 SS

ELECTRODES Qty: Three (3), round, 316 SS

FLOW BODY** AVAILABLE OPTIONS*** • Carbon Steel

• Polypropylene

• Stainless Steel

FLOW LINER** AVAILABLE OPTIONS*** • PTFE

• Ebonite

• Polypropylene

PROCESS

CONNECTIONS**

AVAILABLE OPTIONS • Flanged connections ANSI Class 150 or ANSI Class 300

• Wafer mount

APPROVALS NSF/ANSI

CE

E97/23/CE PED Directive

SPECIFICATIONS*

727.447.6140 Page 4 onicon.com

Flow and Energy Measurement

F-3200

INLINE ELECTROMAGNETIC FLOW METER

TYPICAL INSTALLATION

Flow direction

TYPICAL INSTALLATION IN STEEL

(CONDUCTIVE) PIPE

2 DIA

MINIMUM

DOWNSTREAM

STRAIGHT PIPE RUN

3 DIA

MINIMUM UPSTREAM

STRAIGHT PIPE RUN

EARTH GROUND

CONNECTION

REQUIRED

EARTH GROUND

CONNECTION

REQUIRED

FLANGED AND WAFER MODELS OPERATING RANGE

PIPE SIZE (Inches) FLOW RATE (GPM)

(0.1 ft/sec - 33 ft/sec) PIPE SIZE (Inches) FLOW RATE (GPM)

(0.1 ft/sec - 33 ft/sec) PIPE SIZE (Inches) FLOW RATE (GPM)

(0.1 ft/sec - 33 ft/sec)

1 0.2 - 79 5 5.9 - 1,981 16 61 - 20,288 1½ 0.6 - 203 6 8.5 - 2,853 18 77 - 25,678 2 0.9 - 317 8 15 - 5,072 20 95 - 31,701

2½ 1.6 - 536 10 24 - 7,925 24 137 - 45,649 3 2.4 - 812 12 34 - 11,412 42 417 - 139,800 4 3.8 - 1,268 14 47 - 15,533 48 547 - 182,596

11451 Belcher Road South • Largo, FL 33773 • USA • (P) 727.447.6140 • (F) 727.442.5699 • onicon.com

Flow and Energy Measurement

METER ORDERING INFORMATION

Meter Model Number Coding = F-32BB-CDEF(-SPC)

BB = Meter Size 01 = 1” 04 = 4” 15 = 1.5” 05 = 5” 02 = 2” 06 = 6” 25 = 2.5” 08 = 8” 03 = 3” 10 = 10” nn = meter size, 12” - 48”

C = Body Material, Liner and Electrode Configuration 1 = Carbon Steel, PTFE Liner and 3 SS Electrodes 2 = Carbon Steel, Polypropylene Liner, 3 SS

Electrodes and Viton O-rings 3 = Carbon Steel, Ebonite Liner and 3 SS Electrodes

D = Process Connection 0 = Wafer Connection 1 = ANSI 150 Flanges 3 = ANSI 300 Flanges

E = Input Power 1 = Low Power, 24 VAC/DC 2 = High Power, 120 - 240 VAC

F = Electronics Enclosure Mounting Configuration 4 = Integral IP67 enclosure 5 = Remote IP67 enclosure

SPC = Special Configuration 101 = Aux outputs, redundant analog and pulse signals 102 = MODBUS RTU (RS485) serial communication

F-32BB = Inline Electromagnetic Flow Meter

LINER SELECTION TABLE

Material Line Size Flanged and Wafer Grade Color Temperature

Range Pressure Range Based on Liner

Abrasion Resistance (Carbon Steel = 100)

Ebonite 8 - 48” Food Amber 32°F - 175°F 580 psi ¹ 90 - 118 Polypropylene 1 - 6” Food Gray 32°F - 140°F 232 psi 122

PTFE 1 - 48” Food White 0 - 266°F ³ 580 psi ¹ ² 78 Notes Description

1 Flanged meter pressure rating is the lesser of 580 psi or the flange rating.

2 Wafer style meters above 6” are limited to 232 psi.

3 Remote mount electronics option required for application temperature above 212°F.

11451 Belcher Road South, Largo, FL 33773 • USA • Tel +1 (727) 447-6140 • Fax +1 (727) 442-5699 www.onicon.com • sales@onicon.com 05-192079-2

• F-3500 SERIES •

INSERTION ELECTROMAGNETIC

FLOW METER

FEATURES

Simple Installation and Commissioning - Factory programmed and ready for use upon delivery.

Exceptional Performance & Value - Cost-eff ective insertion style design provides accuracy and reliability normally only found in more expensive full bore devices.

Excellent Long Term Reliability - Low maintenance, no-moving-parts fl ow sensing technology works well in diffi cult fl ow measurement applications such as open loop condenser water fl ow.

Highly Accurate Over a Wide Flow Range - Highly effi cient sensor design and continuous auto-zero function improve accuracy and sensitivity, particularly at low fl ow rates.

Simplifi ed Hot Tap Insertion Design - Standard on every insertion fl ow meter, this feature allows for insertion and removal by hand without a system shutdown.

Ideal Solution for Retrofi ts - The innovative hot tap adapter design allows for wet tapping pipes without interrupting fl ow.

DESCRIPTION

ONICON Incorporated’s F-3500 series insertion electromagnetic fl ow meters are suitable for measuring electrically conductive liquids in a wide variety of applications. Each F-3500 provides a single analog output for fl ow rate, a high resolution frequency output to drive peripheral devices, a scalable pulse output for totalization, and an empty pipe alarm signal.

Two versions of the F-3500 are now available. The standard confi guration F-3500 is suitable for pipe sizes ranging from 3” to 72” in diameter. The small pipe confi guration F-3500 is suitable for pipes ranging in size from 1¼” to 2½” in diameter.

Optional remote displays and BTU measurement systems are also available for both versions.

APPLICATIONS

• Accurate, reliable fl ow measurement for HVAC applications

• Ideal for monitoring open loop condenser water fl ow

• Hot tap design simplifi es domestic water retrofi t installations

• Cost-eff ective way to monitor fl ow in larger pipe sizes

• Suitable for use in water and water/glycol systems

CALIBRATION

Every ONICON fl ow meter is wet calibrated in a fl ow laboratory against standards that are directly traceable to NIST*. A certifi cate of calibration accompanies every meter.

Standard Confi guration

Small Pipe Confi guration

ONICON’s F-3500 Insertion Electromagnetic Flow Meter combined with the System-20 BTU Meter forms an energy measurement system with unsurpassed accuracy and reliability.

*National Institute of Standards and Technology

OPERATING RANGE FOR

COMMON PIPE SIZES

0.1 to 20 ft/s Pipe Size (inches) Flow Rate (GPM)

1 ¼ 0.4 - 95

1 ½ 0.6 - 130

2 1.0 - 200

2 ½ 1.1 - 230

3 2.4 - 460

4 4 - 800

6 9 - 1,800

8 16 - 3,100

10 24 - 4,900

12 35 - 7,050

14 42 - 8,600

16 55 - 11,400

18 70 - 14,600

20 86 - 18,100

24 125 - 26,500

30 223 - 41,900

36 304 - 60,900

NOTE: Specifi cations are subject to change without notice.

ELECTROMAGNETIC INSERTION FLOW METER

NSF/ANSI 61 <MH60590>

ALSO CLASSIFIED

IN ACCORDANCE WITH

NSF/ANSI 372

GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS

ACCURACY

± 1.0% of reading from 2 - 20 ft/s ± 0.02 ft/s below 2 ft/s

FLOW RANGE

0.1 ft/s to 20 ft/s (200:1 turndown)

SENSING METHOD

Electromagnetic sensing (no moving parts)

PIPE SIZE RANGE

Standard Confi guration: 3 - 72” nominal diameter Small Pipe Confi guration: 1¼ - 2½” nominal diameter

INPUT POWER

20 - 28 VDC, 250 mA at 24 VDC 20 - 28 VAC, 60 Hz, 6 VA

LIQUID TEMPERATURE RANGE

15°F to 250°F

AMBIENT TEMPERATURE RANGE

-20°F to 150°F

OPERATING PRESSURE

400 psi maximum

PRESSURE DROP

Standard Confi guration: 0.1 psi at 12 ft/s in 3” pipe, decreasing as line size increases Small Pipe Confi guration: 0.33 psi at 8 ft/s in 1.25” pipe, decreasing as the line size increases

OUTPUT SIGNALS PROVIDED

Analog Output (Isolated) Selectable: 4-20 mA, 0-10 V or 0-5 V Frequency Output 0-15 V peak pulse, 0-500 Hz Scalable Pulse Output Isolated solid state dry contact Contact rating: 50 VDC, 100 mA maximum Pulse Duration: 0.5, 1, 2 or 6 seconds

MATERIAL

Wetted metal components: 316 Stainless Steel Sensor head: XAREC Optional: NSF/ANSI 61/372 version

ELECTRONICS ENCLOSURE

Weathertight NEMA 4 aluminum enclosure

ELECTRICAL CONNECTIONS

10’ of PVC jacketed cable with ½” NPT conduit connection Dedicated earth wire required 4-wire minimum for power and analog output Additional wires required for pulse, frequency and alarm outputs

STRAIGHT RUN INFORMATION Minimum Installation Recommendation Table Meters Upstream (Y) Downstream (X)

Uni-Directional 80% or 10 Dia. 20% or 5 Dia.

Bi-Directional 50% or 10 Dia. 50% or 10 Dia.

APPROVALS

FLOW

X% Y% UpstreamDownstream

Available Straight Run

F-3500 Series 30 - 40" depending on pipe size

CLEARANCE

REQUIRED FOR

INSTALLATION FLO

W

X% Y%

U pstream

D ow nstream Available Straight R un

Vertical Pipe

Position

For Horizontal Pipe Position Meter

Anywhere in Upper 240º (All Meters)

FLOW

½" FNPT

conduit connection

Insertion depth gage provided with each meter

FLOW

Connect factory wires to field wires in appropriate junction box.

Output signal(s) to control system

ONICON

Display or BTU Meter (Optional)

Allow enough slack in the flexible conduit to permit the meter to be removed from the valve.

Typically 30" - 36" depending on pipe size and height of valve assembly.

CLEARANCE

REQUIRED

FOR INSTALLATION

Standard Installation Kit for Steel Pipe

1" Full port ball valve 1" Close nipple 1" Branch outlet

1¼" for hot tap

Minimum Hole Size = 1" Must be centered

• Install in vertical or horizontal pipe

• For horizontal pipe position meter anywhere in upper 240

TYPICAL METER INSTALLATION

(New construction or scheduled shutdown)

NOTE: Installation kits vary based on pipe material and application.

For installations in pressurized (live) systems, use “Hot Tap Installation Kit” and drill hole using a 1” wet tap drill.

METER ORDERING INFORMATION

Meter Model Number Coding = F-35AA-BB-CC-DEFG(-SPC)

F-35AA = Insertion Electromagnetic Flow Meter D = Process Connection

00 = Insertion electromagnetic fl ow meter 1 = 1” NPT adapter. ⅜” stem

BB = Outputs E = Wetted Material

11 = Frequency, isolated analog, scaled pulse and alarm (dry contacts)

12 = Frequency, isolated analog, bi-directional, scaled pulse and alarm (dry contacts)*

1 = 316 SS, XAREC, Viton, Temp < 150°F

2 = 316 SS, XAREC, FKM, Temp ≤ 250°F

3 = 316 SS, XAREC, EPDM, NSF rated for domestic water

CC = Pipe Size Range and Meter Length F = Electronics Enclosure

A1 = 1.25 - 2.5” (F-3500 Small Pipe) 1 = NEMA 4 weathertight enclosure

C3 = 3.0 - 10.0” G = Wiring Connection

D4 = 3.0 - 16.0” 1 = 10’ PVC jacketed cable, pig tail with ½” conduit adapter

E5 = 3.0 - 22.0”

F6 = 3.0 - 72” SPC = Special Confi guration

*For 3” and larger pipes

Room Controller VT7200 Communicating and Net-work Ready Controllers Technical Cut Sheet

Smart energy management has never been easier than with the VT7200 series. Designed for new construction or retrofit projects, the controllers dramatically decrease total costs by reducing installation time, configuration and commissioning time. The VT7200 series provides the advanced features and monitoring functions required by modern building automation systems without the use of software and commissioning tools.

NOTICE

IMPORTANT NOTICE RELATED TO PRODUCT PART NUMBERS

For the latest model and part numbers, please refer to ”VT8000 and VT7000 Series Room Controllers Catalog, version 10” (028-6100-10), which can be found on http://www.viconics.com/.

This document contains information on active and retired products. The latter are no longer sold by Viconics Technologies or its partners.

For additional information on 7000 Series Room Controllers and a list of replacement part numbers, please visit http://www.viconics.com/.

Failure to follow these instructions can result in confusion or order delays.

028-8040-01_SDS-VT7200_A4-EN www.viconics.com January 2020

Introduction Smart energy management has never been easier than with the VT7200 series. Designed for new construction or retrofit projects, the controllers dramatically decrease total installed costs by reducing installation, configuration and commissioning time. The VT7200 series provides the advanced features and monitoring functions required by modern building automation systems without the use of software and commissioning tools.

The VT7200 series zone controllers are specifically designed to control on-off, floating or 0 to 10 Vdc heating or cooling terminal equipment such as pressure dependent VAV’s, valves or other devices.

Open protocol design provides network compatibility to BACnet® MS/ TP, LonWorks® and Wireless ZigBee® Pro network systems. Our Network Ready “stand-alone” versions can be upgraded with optional communication modules which enable the controllers to be integrated into most building automation systems as building requirements change.

All models can be customized with PIR motion sensor functionality via an optional PIR accessory cover. The cover can be installed in the field or ordered as a factory installed option. This provides advanced occupancy routines and automatic energy savings during occupied periods without sacrificing occupant comfort.

VT7200 zoning controllers offer a cost-competitive product that increases occupant comfort while reducing customer energy costs and accelerating return on investment.

Product Highlights

• Open protocol allows for easy integration into most network systems

• Network Ready models can be retrofit with optional communication modules

• One simple wall mounted device to install, wire and commission

• Intuitive “thermostat like” interface

• Application specific controllers can be configured to meet most applications

• No special software required for configuration

• Fully embedded local configuration utility

• Advanced occupancy and monitoring functions through factory or field installed PIR cover

VT7200 Room Controller Features

AT A GLANCE

Custom design

• Advanced occupancy functions

• Equipt for optional PIR cover

• 3 configurable inputs

• Pre-configured sequences of operation

• Unique configuration setup utility

• Lockable keypad

• Available for 24 Vac On/Off, Floating or Analog control

• Auxiliary output

• Discharge air sensor

• Intuitive menu-driven programming

Options and accessories

• Available with various open industry standards communication adapters

Common Applications

• Cooling only VVT zone with reheat

• Fin-tube radiators

• Cabinet heaters

• Radiant panel heaters

• Electric re-heat zones

• Pressure dependent VAV system

• Terminal reheat

OVERRIDE

SIMPLIFIED HMI

VT7200 Room Controller Applications

TYPICAL APPLICATION

Supply Air

BACnet MS/TP Wired communication protocol

ZigBee® Pro Optional wireless communication

To diffusser H

C

OVERRIDE

VT7200

PIR options:

-50 = PIR ready but PIR cover not included -55 = Factory assembled with PIR cover

Communication options:

-B = BACnet® MS/TP -E = LonWorks®

-P = ZigBee Pro wireless -W = ZigBee® wireless

- = Network ready

Control output type:

-C = Floating or on/off digital control outputs -F = Analogue 0 - 10 VDC control outputs

Example:

VT7200F5000W

• Zone Control

• Analogue 0 - 10 VDC outputs

• PIR ready

• ZigBee wireless

* Some part number configurations may not be available.

Dimensions 12.5cm/4.9in (H) x 8.6cm/3.38in (W) x 2.9cm/1in (D) Power Requirements 19-30Vac, 50/60 Hz; 2 VA (RC & C) Class 2 Operating Conditions 0 °C - 50 °C ( 32 °F - 122 °F ) 0% - 95% R.H. non-condensing Storage Conditions -30 °C - 50 °C ( -22 °F - 122 °F ) 0% - 95% R.H. non-condensing Temperature Sensor Local 10 K NTC thermistor Temperature Sensor Resolution ± 0.1 °C ( ± 0.2 °F ) Temperature Control Accuracy ±0.5 ° C ( ± 0.9 °F ) @ 21 °C ( 70 °F ) typical calibrated Occ, Stand-by and Unocc Cooling Setpoint Range

12.0 - 37.5 °C ( 54 - 100 °F ) Occ, Stand-by Unocc Heating Setpoint Range

4.5 °C - 32 °C ( 40 °F - 90 °F ) Room and Outdoor Air Temperature Display Range -40 °C - 50 °C ( -40 °F - 122 °F )

Proportional Band for Room Temperature control Cooling & Heating: 1.8°C ( 3.2°F ) Binary Inputs Dry contact across terminal BI1, BI2 & UI3 to Scom Contact Output Rating Triac output: 30 Vac, 1 Amp. Maximum, 3 Amp. in-rush Analog: 0 to 10 Vdc into 2KΩ resistance min.

Wire Gauge 18 gauge maximum, 22 gauge recommended Approximate Shipping Weight

0.75 lb (0.34 kg) Agency Approvals All Models UL: UL 873 (US) and CSA C22.2 No. 24 (Canada), File E27734 with CCN XAPX (US) and XAPX7 (Canada) Industry Canada: ICES-003 (Canada) FCC: Compliant to CFR 47, Part 15, Subpart B, Class A (US) CE: EMC Directive 89/336/EEC (Europe Union) C-Tick: AS/NZS CISPR 22 Compliant (Australia / New Zealand) Supplier Code Number N10696

Agency Approvals Wireless Models FCC: Compliant to: Part 15, Subpart C

THIS DEVICE COMPLIES WITH PART 15 OF THE FCC

RULES. OPERATION IS SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING

TWO CONDITIONS: (1) THIS DEVICE MAY NOT CAUSE

HARMFUL INTERFERENCE, AND (2) THIS DEVICE

MUST ACCEPT ANY INTERFERENCE RECEIVED,

INCLUDING INTERFERENCE THAT MAY CAUSE UNDE-

SIRED OPERATION.

Specifications

Check with your local government for instruction on disposal of these products.

Ordering information

VT7200 Room Controller Specifications

Branding:

-00 = Viconics -31 = No logo

0 0

Appendix C. FRCS Cybersecurity Control Correlation Identifiers

ENERGY MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEM

LOW-LOW-LOW

This attachment includes the cybersecurity control set that will be used by the Government for RMF purposes to comply with the requirements as defined by UFC 4-010-06. Cybersecurity controls are part of the Risk Management Framework as defined in DoD 8510.01. These controls have been selected based on the C-I-A impact that was assigned.

These controls have been tailored by the Designer to fit the control system being configured. The list of controls is taken from Table H-1 for LOW-LOW-LOW controls.

The following explains the columns used in the table below:

CCI Number – this number is taken from UFC 4-010-06 Table H-1. It is mapped to a control element in

NIST SP 800-53r4.

NIST SP 800-53/800-82 Control Text Indicator - NIST SP 800-53 breaks individual controls (i.e., single

Control IDs) down into multiple elements and enhancements, where an enhancement is a more stringent requirement than the base control. The Control Text Indicator uniquely identifies each of these elements and enhancements. A letter indicates an element within a control, a number is an enhancement. For example, “AC-17 (4)(b)” is the second element of the fourth enhancement to AC-17.

CCI Definition – This provides the definition of the control as it is written in NIST SP 800-53r4.

Designer Implementation – The information in this column is meant to provide supplemental guidance by the Designer for the Contractor to understand how the control applies to this specific control system.

Classification – This column was completed by the Designer. The Designer reviewed each control in this

CCI control set and determined which were APPLICABLE to this specific control system. The following classifications have been defined:

• APPLICABLE – These are actionable controls. These have been identified by the Designer as controls that the control system should be able to accept.

• N/A – These are non-actionable controls. These controls either do not apply or they are policy based and will be implemented by the…