Attachment 16 - CDC Playground Technical Factors.pdf
PDF 144 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Child Development Center Playgrounds
- Solicitation number
- FA301027Q0002
About this file
DOCUMENT TYPE: This is an Evaluation Factors for Award document for a federal construction contract to refresh the Child Development Center (CDC) Outdoor Play Environments at Keesler Air Force Base.
PROJECT AND CONTRACTING DETAILS: The project reference is MAHG225001 CDC Playground Refresh, prepared for Keesler AFB Procurement Office, with a final document date of 05 November 2026. This evaluation framework establishes the technical criteria for assessing proposals for the design and construction of age-segregated outdoor play facilities serving infants (6 weeks to 24 months), toddlers (24 to 36 months), and preschoolers (3 to 5 years).
KEY TECHNICAL REQUIREMENTS: Offerors must submit a comprehensive Technical Approach addressing eight mandatory subsections: (A) Progress Schedule with CDC Phasing and Security protocols requiring minimum 6-foot temporary chain-link fencing with dust screening, work-hour coordination around mandatory nap times (12:00 PM – 2:00 PM), and haul route controls; (B) Playground Equipment Compliance with IPEMA certifications, age-segregated layout, and adherence to UFC Table 2-14 platform height limits (maximum 36 inches for pre-toddlers, 48 inches for toddlers/preschoolers), excluding prohibited items such as animal swings and trampolines; (C) Impact Surfacing with independent ASTM F1292/F355 laboratory certifications validating Critical Fall Height attenuation, specifying recycled SBR substrate and UV-stabilized EPDM wear courses with solar reflectance mitigation; (D) Perimeter Child Safety Fencing with 6-foot vinyl-coated chain-link, 3-inch embedment into 12-inch PCC curbs, and gate latches positioned between 48 and 54 inches with child-proof mechanisms; (E) Non-Toxic Landscaping Plan prepared by licensed Professional Landscape Architect with certified botanical schedules and engineered shade canopies providing 15 square feet per child or 10% of play area; (F) Civil Grading and Drainage Plan with positive 1.5% to 2% slope, subsurface French drains, and stormwater protection; (G) Quality Control and Safety Acceptance Audit Plan incorporating mandatory post-installation inspection by independent CPSI (Certified Playground Safety Inspector); and (H) Site Restoration Plan including demobilization, turf rehabilitation, and magnetic sweep protocols.
PERSONNEL CREDENTIALS AND CERTIFICATIONS: Offerors must provide documented evidence of: (1) independent third-party CPSI certification from the National Recreation and Park Association (NRPA) with minimum three years of experience on commercial or military childcare installations and no affiliation with equipment manufacturers; (2) manufacturer-issued factory-certification for the lead protective surfacing installer with documentation of five successful playground projects of similar scope within three years; (3) signed commitment certifying all on-site personnel will clear Defense Biometric Identification System (DBIDS) registration and Department of Air Force child-care background vetting (Tier 1 CNACI); (4) current Professional Landscape Architect registration with toxicological screening experience for Gulf Coast botanical species; and (5) factory-trained certified playground equipment installation supervisor with documentation of three commercial or military modular installations within three years. The evaluation emphasizes that combining the independent CPSI safety audit role with the installation contractor is not permissible.
REGULATORY COMPLIANCE FRAMEWORK: All proposals must strictly adhere to DAFI 34-144 (Child and Youth Programs), UFC 4-740-14 (Child Development Centers), ASTM F1487, ASTM F1292, and CPSC Publication 325. Submissions that merely paraphrase government specifications without providing site-specific operational details, validated safety certifications, and realistic scheduling will be rated Unacceptable. The evaluation identifies eight critical pitfalls including failure to reference DAFI 34-144, submission of boilerplate municipal park equipment with prohibited items, missing Critical Fall Height matching to specific equipment, toxic or invasive plant selections, shallow-water table drainage neglect, unmitigated noise during CDC nap windows, and inadequate site restoration plans. The Government will evaluate proposals on a Pass/Fail (Acceptable/Unacceptable) basis for Lowest Price Technically Acceptable (LPTA) solicitations or on a Confidence/Technical Rating scale for Best Value Tradeoff (BVTO) selections.
View the file
Other files
Show all 20
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Evaluation Factors for Award | B308
EVALUATION FACTORS FOR AWARD
Document Status: Final
Prepared For: Keesler AFB Procurement Office
Date: 05 November 2026
Project Reference: MAHG225001 CDC Playground Refresh
1. Factor 1: Technical Approach
1.1 Purpose & Scope
The Government will evaluate the Offeror’s Technical Approach to assess their technical understanding of the unique child safety mandates, age-segregated spatial organization, certified impact surfacing requirements, and active-facility coordination necessary to execute the Child Development Center
(CDC) Outdoor Play Environments project at Keesler AFB.
Child Development Centers serve highly vulnerable populations (infants aged 6 weeks through preschool-age children). Consequently, standard commercial landscaping or playground practices are insufficient. Proposals must strictly adhere to the policies, child welfare safeguards, and design criteria established by DAFI 34-144 (Child and Youth Programs), UFC 4-740-14 (Child Development Centers), and the Government's technical specifications (Unified Facilities Guide Specifications - UFGS). A submission that merely repeats, paraphrases, or summarizes the requirements of the Government’s specifications
(Attachment F: UFGS Sections) and Unified Facilities Criteria (Attachment G: UFC 4-740-14) without providing site-specific operational details, validated safety certifications, and realistic scheduling will be evaluated as Unacceptable.
Note on Terminology & Execution Planning: Where solicitation instructions or contractor checklists reference a "Construction Approach" or "Execution Plan," offerors must submit these details within the integrated Technical Approach narrative outlined below, structured in accordance with Sub-Sections A through H.
1.2 Submission Requirements
Offerors shall submit a written Technical Approach narrative that addresses the following specific components in detail:
Evaluation Sub- Section
Specific Submission Requirements Technical Specs / Drawings Reference
A. Progress Schedule, Active
Submit a detailed, logical progress schedule (e.g., Gantt Chart) detailing sequential execution, critical
UFC 4-740-14,
Sections 2-8.16 & 3-
Evaluation Sub- Section
Specific Submission Requirements Technical Specs / Drawings Reference
CDC Phasing & Security path milestones, and duration estimates. Because Keesler AFB CDC remains fully operational during construction, the proposal must explicitly detail:
1. Physical separation of active CDC occupants from construction operations (minimum 6-ft high temporary chain-link construction security fence with wind/dust fabric screening).
2. Work-hour coordination accounting for mandatory CDC quiet hours (daily nap time restrictions, typically 12:00 PM – 2:00 PM, during which heavy machinery, pneumatic compaction, demolition hammer operations, and loud noise generating tasks are strictly prohibited).
3. Haul route controls, material staging, and delivery vehicle escorts that eliminate conflict with parent drop-off/pick-up traffic patterns.
17.8;
UFGS 01 11 00
(Summary of Work / Phasing);
UFGS 02 41 00
(Demolition)
B. Playground Equipment Compliance & Age Segregation
Submit complete manufacturer catalog cuts, specifications, structural layout drawings, and independent third-party IPEMA (International Play Equipment Manufacturers Association) certifications for all proposed modular play units, swings, slides, and sensory structures. The submission must demonstrate:
1. Absolute compliance with DAFI 34-144 and UFC age-group segregation criteria: strictly separate, dedicated play spaces for Infants/Pre-toddlers (6 weeks to 24 months), Toddlers (24 to 36 months), and Preschoolers (3 to 5 years).
2. Adherence to platform heights, guardrails, and barrier rules per UFC Table 2-14 and UFGS 11 68 13 (e.g., max 36-in platform height for pre-toddlers; max 48-in for toddlers/preschoolers).
3. Complete omission of prohibited equipment (e.g., animal swings, hard-seat swings, trampolines, metal
DAFI 34-144,
Attachment 4;
UFC 4-740-14,
Section 5-3 & Section 5-4;
UFGS 11 68 13
(Playground Equipment), SD-02, SD-03, SD-07
Evaluation Sub- Section
Specific Submission Requirements Technical Specs / Drawings Reference slide beds, rotating whirls/merry-go-rounds, free-fall ropes).
C. Impact Surfacing & Critical Fall Height Attenuation
Submit independent laboratory test reports and third-party certifications (ASTM F1292 / ASTM F355) validating that the proposed playground protective surfacing system meets or exceeds the Critical Fall Height (CFH) of the highest designated play event across each zone.
1. For Poured-in-Place (PIP) rubber or synthetic turf systems, specify substrate thickness (minimum 100% recycled SBR base cushion) and wear course formulation (UV-stabilized EPDM granules with aliphatic polyurethane binder).
2. Provide subbase preparation and concrete/aggregate containment curb detailing per
UFGS 32 18 16.13.
3. Provide solar reflectance / surface heat mitigation strategy (light/medium color blending; dark colors exceeding 10% black are strictly unacceptable due to child contact-burn hazards).
UFC 4-740-14,
Sections 5-3.21 & 5- 3.22;
UFGS 32 18 16.13
(Playground Protective Surfacing), SD-03, SD-06, SD-07
D. Perimeter Child- Safety Fencing & Gate Hardware
Submit shop drawings, product data, and hardware schedules for perimeter fencing and interior zone-dividing fences. The submission must verify:
1. Air Force specific minimum 6-ft high perimeter security fencing (vinyl-coated chain link, fabric selvage knuckled top and bottom to eliminate puncture points).
2. Posts and fabric embedded 3 inches into a 12-inch-wide flush PCC curb along the perimeter to preclude animal burrowing and child escape under the fence.
3. Subdividing interior fences (3 ft to 5 ft height) separating age groups.
UFC 4-740-14,
Section 5-3.10;
DAFI 34-144, Section 6;
UFGS 32 31 13
(Chain Link Fences and Gates), SD-02, SD-03, SD-08
Evaluation Sub- Section
Specific Submission Requirements Technical Specs / Drawings Reference
4. Gate latch mechanisms located precisely between 48 in. and 54 in. above grade, equipped with magnetic or self-latching hardware precluding operation by a child or unauthorized reach-over from the exterior.
E. Non-Toxic Landscaping & Shade Structure Integration
Submit a detailed Planting and Shade Plan prepared by a licensed Professional Landscape Architect (PLA).
The submittal must include:
1. A certified botanical schedule affirming that 100% of proposed sod, shrubs, and trees are non-toxic (free from poisonous berries, seeds, sap, foliage, or irritants), non-thorny, and non-attracting to aggressive stinging insects, conforming to Armed Forces Pest Management Board directives and UFC 3- 19.1.
2. Engineered shade canopy details providing at least 15 sq. ft. per child or 10% of the play area (whichever is greater), engineered for local wind loading (minimum 10-year UV degradation fabric warranty, 91% UV block), and maintaining a minimum 3-ft to 5-ft fire separation from the CDC facility wall.
UFC 4-740-14,
Sections 3-19 & 5- 3.11–5-3.13;
DAFI 34-144,
Attachment 4;
UFGS 32 92 23
(Sodding);
UFGS 32 93 00
(Exterior Plants), SD-
03, SD-06
F. Civil Grading, Drainage & Subbase Management
Submit an engineered Site Grading, Drainage, and Subsurface Water Control Plan. The plan must detail:
1. Positive surface slope grading (minimum 1.5% to 2% away from play areas and structures) to guarantee zero water ponding or muddy conditions within use zones.
2. Integrated subsurface French drains, perforated collectors, and drainage mats beneath synthetic turf and PIP surfacing connecting directly to the installation stormwater system.
3. Protection of low-elevation zones from coastal backwater or localized storm runoff.
UFC 4-740-14,
Sections 2-8.8, 3- 17.1, 5-2.5;
UFGS 31 23 00.00 20
(Excavation and Fill);
UFGS 33 40 00
(Stormwater Utilities)
Evaluation Sub- Section
Specific Submission Requirements Technical Specs / Drawings Reference
G. Quality Control & Safety Acceptance Audit Plan
Submit a Project-Specific Quality Control Plan detailing inspection, verification, and field-testing protocols from site preparation through project closeout. The plan must explicitly incorporate the mandatory Post-Installation Child Safety & Accessibility Audit executed by a non-affiliated, certified third-party Certified Playground Safety Inspector (CPSI) prior to final Government acceptance.
UFGS 01 45 00.00 10
(Quality Control);
DAFI 34-144, Section 6;
UFGS 11 68 13,
Section 3.4;
UFGS 32 18 16.13,
Section 3.5
H. Site Restoration, Turf Recovery & Final Clean-Up
Submit a comprehensive Site Restoration and Demobilization Plan outlining procedures to return all construction, laydown, access corridor, and adjacent grounds to pristine operational condition.
The submittal must include:
1. Demobilization schedule including removal of temporary fencing, barricades, signage, and construction debris.
2. Turf rehabilitation, soil aerating, and sod replacement protocols (bermudagrass or approved turf per UFGS 32 92 23) for all ground compacted or disturbed during staging or transit.
3. Magnet sweeps and fine debris removal protocols across all fall zones, synthetic turf, and surrounding grounds to guarantee zero metal shards, nails, screws, staples, or foreign matter remain in child-accessible spaces.
UFGS 01 74 00
(Cleaning and Waste Management);
UFGS 01 78 00
(Closeout Submittals);
UFGS 32 92 23
(Sodding);
DAFI 34-144, Section
1.3 Key Personnel & Specialty Certifications & Subcontractor Vetting
The Offeror must provide documented evidence of qualifications, active licenses, and specialty certifications. Distinct technical credentials are required for safety inspection versus surfacing/equipment installation; combining these disparate functions under a single uncertified entity is not permissible.
1.3.1 Independent Third-Party Certified Playground Safety Inspector (CPSI):
1.3.1.1 Provide proof of current, valid CPSI certification issued by the National Recreation and
Park Association (NRPA) for the designated safety auditor.
1.3.1.2 The certified inspector must possess a minimum of three (3) years of documented inspection experience on commercial or military childcare installations and must not be an employee of the playground equipment manufacturer or installer.
1.3.2 Certified Protective Surfacing Installer:
1.3.2.1 Provide manufacturer-issued training certificates confirming that the lead installation technician is factory-certified for the specific Poured-in-Place (PIP) rubber or synthetic turf system being installed.
1.3.2.2 Submit documentation demonstrating successful installation of at least five (5) playground projects of similar scope and magnitude within the past three (3) years.
1.3.3 Air Force Installation Access & Child Care Background Clearances:
1.3.3.1 Offerors must submit a complete roster of all proposed trade subcontractors (e.g., earthwork, concrete, fencing, surfacing, planting, electrical/utility).
1.3.3.2 Submit a signed commitment and compliance statement certifying that all on-site supervisory personnel, field technicians, and subcontractor laborers will undergo and clear mandatory installation access requirements, including Defense Biometric
Identification System (DBIDS) registration and Department of the Air Force child-care background vetting protocols (Tier 1 / Child Care National Agency Check with Inquiries
[CNACI], where applicable per DAFI 34-144).
1.3.4 Landscape Architect of Record:
1.3.4.1 Provide proof of current Professional Landscape Architect (PLA) registration with experience in toxicological screening of southern coastal botanical species suitable for
Keesler AFB / Gulf Coast soil and climate conditions.
1.3.5 Certified Playground Equipment Installer:
1.3.5.1 Provide documentation verifying that the installation supervisor is factory-trained and certified by the specific modular playground equipment manufacturer proposed for this project.
1.3.5.2 Evidence of successful completion of at least three (3) commercial or military modular play installations within the past three (3) years.
1.4 Evaluation Criteria & Risk Assessment
The Government will evaluate the Technical Approach on a Pass/Fail (Acceptable/Unacceptable) basis for LPTA solicitations, or on a comparative Confidence / Technical Rating scale for Best Value Tradeoff
(BVTO) selections.
To receive an Acceptable (or High Confidence) rating, the proposal must demonstrate:
1.4.1 Comprehensive Regulatory Compliance: Proposed equipment, layout, use zones, and protective surfacing conform strictly to DAFI 34-144, UFC 4-740-14, ASTM F1487, ASTM
F1292, and CPSC Publication 325.
1.4.2 Rigorous Age Segregation: Clear spatial isolation between infants, toddlers, and older preschool groups with zero overlapping fall zones or blind spots in caregiver sightlines.
1.4.3 Operational Risk Mitigation: A realistic, well-phased construction sequence that isolates active CDC classrooms from noise, vibration, airborne particulates, and vehicle traffic while protecting daily nap periods (12:00 – 14:00).
1.4.4 Verified Technical Credentials: Complete and unexpired CPSI (third-party independent), certified equipment and surfacing installer, and professional engineering/landscape architecture credentials submitted with the initial proposal package.
1.4.5 Site Restoration Guarantee: A structured closeout plan guaranteeing full turf recovery, sodding, and magnetic sweep verification to eliminate child hazards.
1.5 Common Pitfalls during Evaluation
Technical evaluators must closely examine proposals for the following deficiencies and high-risk oversights:
1.5.1 Failure to Reference DAFI 34-144: Proposing standard commercial childcare setups without citing or adhering to the specific requirements of Department of the Air Force Instruction
34-144.
1.5.2 Boilerplate / Generic Equipment Cuts: Offerors submitting standard municipal park equipment that includes items prohibited in Air Force CDCs (e.g., chain balance beams, fulcrum teeter-totters, metal slide chutes, or enclosed crawl tubes lacking visual inspection slots).
1.5.3 Missing Fall Height Matching: Surfacing submittals providing generic ASTM F1292 test certificates without demonstrating that the tested thickness provides a certified Critical Fall
Height rating exceeding the specific maximum fall height of the proposed play towers.
1.5.4 Uncertified Labor on Play Equipment / Conflated Credentials: Attempting to combine the independent CPSI safety audit role with the installation contractor, or using general field laborers to erect complex modular play events. Non-certified assembly frequently results in non-compliant head/neck entrapment gaps (between 3.5 in. and 9 in.) and finger-pinch hazards, voiding manufacturer structural warranties.
1.5.5 Toxic or Invasive Plant Selections: Failure of the landscaping schedule to cross-reference plant species against toxicological guidelines. Introducing oleander, lantana, Carolina jessamine, pyracantha (thorny), or plants that heavily attract stinging insects violates UFC 4-
740-14 Section 3-19.1.
1.5.6 Shallow-Water Table Drainage Neglect: Submitting flat grading plans without subsurface drainage under synthetic turf or PIP systems. In coastal Mississippi conditions, subbase saturation causes rapid polyurethane binder breakdown, bubbling wear surfaces, and standing water vectors for mosquitoes.
1.5.7 Unmitigated Noise during CDC Nap Windows: Failure to program high-noise excavation, pneumatic fastening, or concrete demolition around mandatory infant/toddler sleep schedules, resulting in operational work stoppages by the CDC Director.
1.5.8 Inadequate Site Clean-Up and Restoration Plans: Treating site restoration as incidental without providing concrete submittals for magnetic sweeps, sodding, soil decompaction, and perimeter repair.
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .