Attachment A - WHV Asbestos Report_compressed - Part 2 of 2.pdf

File No. 472/16085.JNS; Index No. 18350

REPORT OF

ASBESTOS BUILDING MATERIALS SURVEY

For

Heating Plant Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan 48197

Prepared For:

Mr. Judson N. Sorensen, P.E.

Michigan Department of Technology, Management and Budget Design and Construction Division

P.O. Box 30026 Lansing, Michigan 48909

MTC Project No. 151664

April 28, 2016

Prepared By:

Materials Testing Consultants, Inc.

693 Plymouth, NE

Grand Rapids, Michigan 49505 Phone: (616) 456-5469 Fax: (616) 456-5784

REPORT OF ASBESTOS BUILDING MATERIALS SURVEY

SIGNATURE PAGE

SECTION 1.0 ...................................................................................................................... INTRODUCTION

SECTION 2.0 ...................................................................................................... BUILDING DESCRIPTION

SECTION 3.0 .............................................................................................................................INSPECTION

Section 3.1 ......................................................................................................................Inspection Procedures Section 3.2 ................................................................................................................................ Function Areas Section 3.3 ...................................................................................................... Homogeneous Materials Report Section 3.4 ............................................................................................................................ Inspection Report

SECTION 4.0 ..................................................................................... BULK SAMPLING AND ANALYSIS

Section 4.1 ....................................................................................................................... Sampling Procedures Section 4.2 ............................................................................................................ Sample Locations Summary Section 4.3 ................................................................................... Lab Procedures / Accreditation Information Section 4.4 .............................................................................................................................. Analysis Results

SECTION 5.0 ..................................................................... ASSESSMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Section 5.1 ............................................................................................... Assessments and Recommendations

APPENDIX A - MATERIALS TESTING CONSULTANTS, INC. EMPLOYEE CREDENTIALS

Date(s) of Inspection: March 14 and 15, 2016 Building Inspector(s): Christopher J. Kestner, C.I.E.

Christopher J. Kestner Asbestos Inspector Course: Tillotson Env. Occ. Con.

Expiration Date: June 5, 2016 Certificate No. BIMPR15060502 State of Michigan Accreditation No. A10977 Asbestos Inspector Expiration Date: August 11, 2016 Asbestos Management Planner Course: Tillotson Env. Occ. Con.

Expiration Date: June 5, 2016 Certificate No. BIMPR15060502 State of Michigan Accreditation No. A10977 Asbestos Management Planner Expiration Date: October 18, 2016 Asbestos Project Designer Course: Tillotson Env. Occ. Con.

Expiration Date: October 13, 2016 Certificate No. PDR15101301 State of Michigan Accreditation No. A10977 Asbestos Project Designer Expiration Date: December 7, 2016

Report Prepared by: Date: April 28, 2016 Christopher J. Kestner, C.I.E., Sr. Project Environmental Professional

Reviewed by: Date: April 28, 2016 Allan G. Howland, Project Environmental Professional

Training Certificates and State of Michigan Accreditations are provided following Appendix A

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Materials Testing Consultants, Inc. (MTC) was retained by State of Michigan, Department of Technology, Management and Budget to provide asbestos-related services to the following twenty buildings: West Administration Building, Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, Field House, former Food Services, Academic/Vocational Building, Maintenance Building, Heating Plant, WHV Recreation Building, MSI Building, East Administration Building, Building H, Gladwin Hall, Fillmore Hall, Building E, Building J and Building K within the Woman’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility located at 3201 Bemis Road in Ypsilanti, Michigan. These services included inspection, sampling, and analysis of suspected asbestos containing building materials, with a report of findings for use in future decisions regarding each building.

The adverse health effects associated with asbestos exposure have been extensively studied for many years. Results of these studies and epidemiological investigations have demonstrated that inhalation of asbestos fibers may lead to increased risk of developing one or more diseases. Those diseases typically associated with asbestos fiber inhalation include asbestosis (a scar tissue buildup in the lungs caused by overexposure to asbestos), mesothelioma (a cancer of the lining of the lungs or abdomen which is almost always caused by exposure to asbestos), and lung cancer (a malignant growth in the lung tissue). Exactly why some people develop these diseases and others do not remain a mystery. It is important to recognize that the majority of people who have been inflicted and died as a result of asbestos exposure were asbestos workers. These workers were frequently exposed to high concentrations of asbestos fibers each working day with little or no protection.

The scope of this inspection and survey does not include inspection results concerning the potential presence of other hazardous materials. These hazardous materials may include lead-based paints, PCB containing oils in fluorescent light ballasts and other transformers, and mercury vapor in fluorescent lights. The potential presence of these materials in the facility represents areas of concern for building occupants and construction workers.

Lead has been targeted as a major health concern especially for young children in their developmental years.

Permissible exposure levels for people have recently been lowered and removal of lead-based paints has been regulated much like asbestos in many areas of the country. Prior to demolition or renovation activities, MTC recommends that sampling and laboratory analyses of all painted surfaces be conducted.

Concerning light ballasts and transformers, MTC recommends that prior to any electrical upgrade which would affect light ballasts or transformers, a detailed inspection be completed to determine their likelihood of containing PCB's. If disposal of PCB containing light ballasts or transformers is necessary, the Owner may dispose of intact ballasts in limited quantities as regular sanitary waste. If during electrical upgrades, building renovations or demolitions, the Owner or selected contractor is required to remove transformers or large quantities of light ballasts, it is recommended that these transformers or ballasts be maintained by the Owner for future use or that the Owner contract with a licensed facility for disposal. If ballasts or transformers are leaking, they must be considered as hazardous waste and disposed of at a licensed facility.

The bulbs associated with fluorescent lighting often contain hazardous mercury vapor. If disposal of fluorescent bulbs is necessary, MTC recommends that caution should be maintained to prevent breakage and that, for large quantities of bulbs, a licensed facility is contracted for proper disposal.

2.0 BUILDING DESCRIPTION

The Heating Plant Building is located in the Woman’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility complex at 3201 Bemis Road in Ypsilanti, Michigan. The building was originally built in 1978 and is approximately 10,000 square feet.

The building currently contains three Cleaver Brooks boilers, two Trane absorption chillers (not in use), two Federal Pacific diesel power generators, a control room, a water quality analysis laboratory, storage rooms, a restroom with showers and areas associated with the generation of heat for the Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility (WHVCF). The Heating Plant Building is a single-story structure with a partial basement. It is constructed of concrete and cinder block with a metal roof system. The interior construction typically consists of concrete cinder block walls. The building is currently used as the main heat generation plant for WHVCF.

SECTION 3.0 - INSPECTION

SECTION 3.1

INSPECTION PROCEDURES

Inspection of the Heating Plant Building within the Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility took place on March 14 and 15, 2016. Once on site, the Materials Testing Consultants, Inc. inspectors assigned Function Area numbers to individual rooms and continuous spaces and inspected each function area for quantity, location and condition of suspect friable and non-friable asbestos containing building materials. Function areas which could not be accessed are listed in the Building Survey Summary and noted on the Function Area Maps. See Section 3.2 of this report for maps of Function Area locations and numbering sequences representing the Heating Plant Building.

Individual types of building materials encountered during the inspection were assigned homogenous material numbers. Materials Testing Consultants, Inc. considered materials to be homogeneous only if they were similar in appearance, was located within the same building, and represented construction and/or renovation events which were completed over a set time or duration and which were likely completed by the same contractor.

Each suspect material was treated as a homogeneous material with the exception of floor tile and mastic which, when encountered, were combined as a single homogeneous material. Fire doors were assumed to be asbestos containing and were treated as a separate homogeneous material within the final report. For a listing of homogeneous materials, see the "Homogeneous Material Report", provided within Section 3.3, for the Heating Plant Building. The Homogeneous Material Report also provides a quick summary of the presence and type of asbestos for each homogeneous material and total quantities of each material. This information can be of value when assessing asbestos abatement costs associated with renovation and/or demolition activities.

The inspection performed quantified and assessed the condition of all suspect materials within each Function Area of the Heating Plant Building. As each function area was inspected, each suspect asbestos containing material was classified as friable or non-friable, assigned a type designation (surfacing, thermal system insulation or miscellaneous). Finally, quantity of material was determined in square feet, linear feet, cubic feet or unit. If needed, the inspector also provided written remarks describing damage or potential hazards, which may exist.

Inspection information has been provided within the report entitled "Building Survey Summary" for the Heating Plant Building. You will find that the Building Survey Summary report will be especially valuable when trying to assess the potential for impacting asbestos containing materials when performing building maintenance activities.

This report will provide interested parties with a quick reference of all materials considered to be suspect during the inspection, and when used in conjunction with the summary of analytical results, can indicate the presence of asbestos in each of these suspect materials.

Certain materials such as fiberglass pipe insulation were assumed as non-asbestos and were not sampled. Where appropriate, these materials were inspected to assure that other suspect materials were not being covered.

SECTION 3.2 - FUNCTION AREAS

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Figure No. 1 - Power Plant

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Rectangle

Christopher Kestner Rectangle

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Function Area Map

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Typewritten Text

Rectangle

Christopher Kestner Rectangle

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Main Floor - Power Plant

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Shed

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Mezzanine

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Line

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Cooling Tower

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text Funtion Area Map

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Christopher Kestner Typewritten Text

Rectangle

SECTION 3.3 - HOMOGENEOUS AREAS REPORT

Homogeneous Material Report

Friable/ Non-Friable

Classifi-cation

Asbestos Type Percentage

Homogeneous Material NumberHomogeneous Material (HM)

Asbestos Presence Quantity

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping

1 F ND T None Detected -- Each125

Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping

2 F ND T None Detected -- Each45

Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping

3 F ND T None Detected -- Each86

Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping

4 F ND T None Detected -- Each36

Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

5 F ND T None Detected -- Each145

Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

6 F ND T None Detected -- Each78

Wrapped Duct Insulation on Condensate Tank 7 F ND T None Detected -- Sq. Ft.99

Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping 8 F ND T None Detected -- Each68

Mud Compound Insulation on Boiler Feed Piping

9 F ND T None Detected -- Each3

Mud Compound Insulation on Blow Down Piping

10 F ND T None Detected -- Each9

K = known to contain asbestos A = assumed to contain asbestos ND = asbestos not detected by laboratory analysis NA = material identified as non-asbestos by inspector BRL = below regulated limit

T = thermal system insulation S = surfacing material M = miscellaneous material O = other hazardous material

Legend: Friable/Non-Friable F = Friable NF = Non-Friable

Asbestos Presence Classification Quantity NQ = Not Quantified

Non-Friable

Classifi-cation

Asbestos Type Percentage

Homogeneous Material NumberHomogeneous Material (HM)

Asbestos Presence Quantity

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

Wrapped Duct Insulation on Heat Exchangers 11 F ND T None Detected -- Sq. Ft.106

Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black 12 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.52

Electrical Switches 13 NF A M Assumed -- Each74

Fire Doors 14 NF A M Assumed -- Each5

Transite Window Panels 15 NF A M Assumed -- Sq. Ft.108

Window Caulk, Gray 16 NF BRL M Chrysotile <1% Sq. Ft.4

Cleaver Brooks Boilers 17 NF A T Assumed -- Each3

Boiler Stack Insulation 18 F ND T None Detected -- Sq. Ft.516

1" x 1" Ceramic Tile Grout 19 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.261

4" x 6" Ceramic Tile Grout 20 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.45

K = known to contain asbestos A = assumed to contain asbestos ND = asbestos not detected by laboratory analysis NA = material identified as non-asbestos by inspector BRL = below regulated limit

T = thermal system insulation S = surfacing material M = miscellaneous material O = other hazardous material

Legend: Friable/Non-Friable F = Friable NF = Non-Friable

Non-Friable

Classifi-cation

Asbestos Type Percentage

Homogeneous Material NumberHomogeneous Material (HM)

Asbestos Presence Quantity

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

2" x 2" Ceramic Tile Grout 21 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.25

2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes

22 F ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.407

Generator Vent Stack 23 F K T Chrysotile Amosite

5% - 60% ND to 45%

Sq. Ft.400

12" x 12" Floor Tile, Off-white with Light and Dark Splotches

24 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.246

4" Vinyl Cove Base, Gray 25 NF ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.21

2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes

26 F ND M None Detected -- Sq. Ft.203

Transite Panels on Cooling Tower 27 NF K M Chrysotile 20% Sq. Ft.240

Drywall 28 NF ND M None Detected -- NQ

K = known to contain asbestos A = assumed to contain asbestos ND = asbestos not detected by laboratory analysis NA = material identified as non-asbestos by inspector BRL = below regulated limit

T = thermal system insulation S = surfacing material M = miscellaneous material O = other hazardous material

Legend: Friable/Non-Friable F = Friable NF = Non-Friable

SECTION 3.4 - INSPECTION REPORT

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage Loc.(L) Gen.(G)

% Damage

0-1 ND

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

Function Area No.

HA

No.

Description

Asbestos Type

Asbestos Percent

F T -- -- 10 Each West Section of Basement - Concrete floor, walls and ceiling

3/14/2016001 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 7 Each3/14/2016001 2 Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 10 Each3/14/2016001 3 Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 30 Each3/14/2016001 4 Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 17 Each3/14/2016001 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 14 Each3/14/2016001 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 99 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016001 7 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Condensate Tank

None Detected --

F T -- -- 108 Each Main Section of Basement - Concrete, floor, walls and ceiling

3/14/2016002 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 38 Each3/14/2016002 2 Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 76 Each3/14/2016002 3 Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping

None Detected --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

F T -- -- 6 Each3/14/2016002 4 Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 112 Each3/14/2016002 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 52 Each3/14/2016002 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 68 Each3/14/2016002 8 Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 3 Each3/14/2016002 9 Mud Compound Insulation on Boiler Feed Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 9 Each3/14/2016002 10 Mud Compound Insulation on Blow Down Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 106 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016002 11 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Heat Exchangers

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 6 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016002 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black None Detected --

NF M G ND 18 Each3/14/2016002 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

NF M G ND 2 Each Chiller Section of Main Floor - Concrete floor, cinder block walls and metal deck

3/14/2016101 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

NF M G ND 3 Each3/14/2016101 14 Fire Doors Assumed --

NF M G ND 36 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016101 15 Transite Window Panels Assumed --

NF M -- -- 1 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016101 16 Window Caulk, Gray Chrysotile <1%

F T -- -- 6 Each3/14/2016102 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 12 Sq. Ft. Boiler Section of Main Floor - Concrete floor, cinder block walls and metal deck

3/14/2016102 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black None Detected --

NF M G ND 35 Each3/14/2016102 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

NF M G ND 54 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016102 15 Transite Window Panels Assumed --

NF M -- -- 2 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016102 16 Window Caulk, Gray Chrysotile <1%

NF T G ND 3 Each3/14/2016102 17 Cleaver Brooks Boilers Assumed --

F T -- -- 516 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016102 18 Boiler Stack Insulation None Detected --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

F T -- -- 12 Each Bathroom/Locker Room - Ceramic tile floor, cinder block walls, concrete deck above ceiling tile

3/14/2016103 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 8 Each3/14/2016103 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 4 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016103 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black None Detected --

NF M -- -- 261 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016103 19 1" x 1" Ceramic Tile Grout None Detected --

NF M -- -- 45 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016103 20 4" x 6" Ceramic Tile Grout None Detected --

NF M -- -- 25 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016103 21 2" x 2" Ceramic Tile Grout None Detected --

F M -- -- 236 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016103 22 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes

None Detected --

F T -- -- 1 Each Electrical Room - Concrete floor, cinder block walls, metal deck

3/14/2016104 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 24 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016104 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black None Detected --

NF M G ND 13 Each3/14/2016104 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

F T G ND 400 Sq. Ft.3/14/2016104 23 Generator Vent Stack Chrysotile Amosite

5% - 60% ND to 45%

NF M G ND 18 Sq. Ft. Engineer's Office - Concrete under floor tile, cinderblock walls, metal deck above ceiling tile

3/15/2016105 15 Transite Window Panels Assumed --

NF M -- -- 1 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016105 16 Window Caulk, Gray Chrysotile <1%

F M -- -- 123 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016105 22 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 246 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016105 24 12" x 12" Floor Tile, Off-white with Light and Dark Splotches

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 21 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016105 25 4" Vinyl Cove Base, Gray None Detected --

F M -- -- 123 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016105 26 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes

None Detected --

F T -- -- 2 Each Chemical Testing Laboratory - Concrete floor, cinder block walls, metal deck above ceiling tile

3/15/2016106 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 2 Each3/15/2016106 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

None Detected --

NF M G ND 1 Each3/15/2016106 14 Fire Doors Assumed --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

F M -- -- 48 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016106 22 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes

None Detected --

F M -- -- 48 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016106 26 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes

None Detected --

NF M -- -- 6 Sq. Ft. Tool Storage - Concrete floor, cinder block walls, metal deck

3/15/2016107 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black None Detected --

F M -- -- 32 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016107 26 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes

None Detected --

F T -- -- 2 Each Custodial Closet - Concrete floor, cinder block walls, metal deck

3/15/2016108 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping

None Detected --

F T -- -- 2 Each3/15/2016108 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping

None Detected --

-- -- -- -- -- Mezzanine - Concrete walls, cinder block walls, metal deck

3/15/2016201 0 No Asbestos Detected -- --

NF M G ND 5 Each Cooling Tower Area - Gravel floor, concrete walls

3/15/2016301 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

NF M G ND 240 Sq. Ft.3/15/2016301 27 Transite Panels on Cooling Tower Chrysotile 20%

NF M G ND 1 Each Attached Storage Area - Concrete floor, concrete, metal and drywall walls, wood deck

3/15/2016401 13 Electrical Switches Assumed --

Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant

Building Survey Summary

Friable/ Non-fri-able

Type Therm.(T) Surf.(S) Misc.(M)

Damage

1-10 D(G) 1-25 D(L)

>10 SD(G)

>25 SD(L)

Approx.

Quantity Remarks

27-Apr-16Date:

Inspection Date

NF M G ND 1 Each3/15/2016401 14 Fire Doors Assumed --

NF M -- -- NQ3/15/2016401 28 Drywall None Detected --

SECTION 4.0 – BULK SAMPLING AND ANALYSIS

SECTION 4.1

SAMPLING PROCEDURE

Samples were selected at random. Minimum sampling requirements have met requirements of OSHA Regulations for Construction, Subpart D - Occupational Health and Environmental Controls, 29 CFR 1926.1101 - Asbestos.

These OSHA regulations require in order for a material to be considered non asbestos-containing, that analysis of thermal system insulations and surfacing materials consist of a minimum three bulk samples being analyzed by a laboratory which participates in a nationally recognized testing program such as the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP) of the National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST).

This inspection, including all sampling was conducted by State of Michigan accredited Asbestos Building Inspectors. Copies of the Inspector's current Training Certificates and State Accreditations are attached to this report.

When at all possible, sampling was performed in a non-destructive manner. Where possible, samples were obtained in unobtrusive areas. Holes from core samples of thermal system insulation were repaired. The inspector performing the sampling had respiratory protection as required and performed the work in a professional and safe manner using wet methods and decontamination procedures as necessary to guard against localized building contamination.

The following report entitled "Sample Locations Summary" provides the site locations of each of the samples taken.

The homogeneous material that the sample is taken from is represented in the sample number. The first one or two digits of the sample number represent the homogeneous material in which the sample was found. For example:

Sample #101 was the first sample taken for Homogeneous Material #1. Sample #1104 was the fourth sample taken from Homogeneous Material #11.

SECTION 4.2 - SAMPLE LOCATIONS SUMMARY

Sample Location Summary

Material Description

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

101 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping 1.5' south and 15' west of the northeast corner, 5.5' up001

102 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping 6.5' north and 30' east of the southwest corner, 10' up002

103 1 Mud Compound Insulation on Low Pressure Steam Piping 0.5' south and 26' east of the northwest corner, 2.5' up002

201 2 Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping 5' north and 1.5' east of the southwest corner, 4.5' up001

202 2 Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping 1.5' south and 44' west of the northeast corner, 6' up002

203 2 Mud Compound Insulation on High Pressure Steam Piping 7.5' south and 38' east of the northwest corner, 7' up on end cap002

301 3 Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping 4.5' north and 0.5' east of the southwest corner, 3' up001

302 3 Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping 4.5' north and 30' east of the southwest corner, 8.5' up002

303 3 Mud Compound Insulation on Condensate Piping 1' south and 19.5' east of the northwest corner, 1.5' up in hanger002

401 4 Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping 10.5' north and 21.5' east of the southwest corner, 7' up001

402 4 Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping 7' south and 35.5' west of the northeast corner, 8' up002

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

403 4 Mud Compound Insulation on Chilled Water Piping 23' north and 1.5' east of the south west corner, 8' up002

501 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping 6' north and 0.5' east of the southwest corner, 6' up001

502 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping 2' north and 26.5' west of the southeast corner, 6' up002

503 5 Mud Compound Insulation on Cold Water Piping 3' north and 18.5' east of the southwest corner002

601 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping 9' south and 9' east of the northwest corner, 3.5' up002

602 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping 4.5' north and 7' east of the southwest corner, 9.5' up002

603 6 Mud Compound Insulation on Hot Water Piping 11.5' south and 9.5' east of the northwest corner, 10.5' up002

701 7 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Condensate Tank 3.5' south and 14.5' east of the northwest corner, 4' up001

702 7 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Condensate Tank 3' south and 20' east of the northwest corner, 4.5' up001

703 7 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Condensate Tank 2' south and 14.5' east of the northwest corner, 6' up001

801 8 Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping 30.5' south and 3' east of the northwest corner, 10.5' up002

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

802 8 Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping 12' south and 7.5' east of the northwest corner, 4' up002

803 8 Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping 32' south and 58' west of the northeast corner, 1' up102

804 8 Mud Compound Insulation on Fuel Oil Piping 20' south and 1' east of the northwest corner, 5.5' up002

901 9 Mud Compound Insulation on Boiler Feed Piping 13' south and 31' east of the northwest corner, 8.5' up002

902 9 Mud Compound Insulation on Boiler Feed Piping 13' south and 32.5' east of the northwest corner, 7' up002

903 9 Mud Compound Insulation on Boiler Feed Piping 13' south and 42.5' east of the northwest corner, 7' up002

1001 10 Mud Compound Insulation on Blow Down Piping 12' south and 28.5' east of the northwest corner, 10' up002

1002 10 Mud Compound Insulation on Blow Down Piping 13.5' south and 31.5' west of the northeast corner, 9' up002

1003 10 Mud Compound Insulation on Blow Down Piping 4' south and 26' west of the northeast corner, 6.5' up002

1101 11 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Heat Exchangers 3' south and 5' east of the northwest corner, 6.5' up002

1102 11 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Heat Exchangers 3' south and 3' east of the of the northwest corner, 6.5' up002

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

1103 11 Wrapped Duct Insulation on Heat Exchangers 4' south and 9' east of the northwest corner, 6' up002

1201 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black 1' south and 6' east of the northwest corner, 7' up in access panel103

1202 12 Vibration Dampening Cloth, Black 6' south and 12.5' west of the northeast corner, 7' up002

1601 16 Window Caulk, Gray 15' west of the northeast corner, 5' up102

1602 16 Window Caulk, Gray 6' east of the northwest corner, 5.5' up102

1801 18 Boiler Stack Insulation Boiler No. 2102

1802 18 Boiler Stack Insulation Boiler No. 1102

1803 18 Boiler Stack Insulation Boiler No. 3102

1901 19 1" x 1" Ceramic Tile Grout 5' south and 0.5' east of the northwest corner103

1902 19 1" x 1" Ceramic Tile Grout 8.5' south and 4.5' east of the northwest corner103

1903 19 1" x 1" Ceramic Tile Grout 5.5' south and 4.5' east of the northwest corner103

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

2001 20 4" x 6" Ceramic Tile Grout 8.5' south and 4.5' east of the northwest corner103

2002 20 4" x 6" Ceramic Tile Grout 5.5' south and 4.5' east of the northwest corner103

2003 20 4" x 6" Ceramic Tile Grout 5' south and 1' east of the northwest corner103

2101 23 Generator Vent Stack 4' south of the northwest corner, 1.5' up103

2102 23 Generator Vent Stack At the northwest corner, 1.5' up103

2103 23 Generator Vent Stack 4.5' south and 4.5' east of the northwest corner, 1.5' up103

2201 22 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes 2' south and 2' west of the northeast corner, 8' up106

2202 22 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Lateral Grooves and Pinholes At the northeast corner, 8' up103

2301 23 Generator Vent Stack Generator Vent # 2104

2302 23 Generator Vent Stack Generator Vent # 1104

2303 23 Generator Vent Stack Vent material on ground adjacent to Generator # 1104

Field Sample Number Sample Location

Homogeneous Material Number

Function Area Number

Job No.: 151664 Building No.: 1 Facility: Women's Huron Valley Correctional Facility

3201 Bemis Road Ypsilanti, Michigan

Building: Heating Plant 27-Apr-16Date:

2401 24 12" x 12" Floor Tile, Off-white with Light and Dark Splotches 1.5' north and 1' west of the southeast corner105

2402 24 12" x 12" Floor Tile, Off-white with Light and Dark Splotches 11' west of the southeast corner105

2501 25 4" Vinyl Cove Base, Gray 1' west of the southeast corner105

2502 25 4" Vinyl Cove Base, Gray 12' west of the southeast corner105

2601 26 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes 6' south and 9' west of the northeast corner, 8' up105

2602 26 2' x 4' Ceiling Tile, White with Random Pits and Pinholes 4' north and 2' west of the southeast corner, 8' up106

2701 27 Transite Panels on Cooling Tower 5' north of the southeast corner of the cooling tower, 6.5' up adjacent to ladder

2801 28 Drywall 9.5' south and 1' east of the northwest corner, 11.5' up401

2802 28 Drywall 23' east of the northwest corner, 1' up401

2803 28 Drywall 9.5' south and 12.5' east of the northwest corner, 11.5' up401

SECTION 4.3

LABORATORY PROCEDURES

All suspect asbestos containing materials were properly packaged and sent by Federal Express to EMSL Analytical, Inc. in Indianapolis, Indiana for analysis. EMSL Analytical, Inc. preparation and analysis of bulk samples was completed using a Stereoscopic Reflected Light Microscope and Polarized Light Microscope with dispersion staining capabilities to comply with EPA/600/R-93/116, July 1993, "Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Building Materials". The EMSL Analytical, Inc. results and Chain of Custody are included following this section. The results have been summarized in the Homogeneous Material Report and the Building Survey Summary.

SECTION 4.4 - ANALYSIS RESULTS

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

2001 East 52nd St. Indianapolis, IN 46205

Tel/Fax: (317) 803-2997 / (317) 803-3047 http://www.EMSL.com / indianapolislab@emsl.com

161604595EMSL Order:

Customer ID: MATE53

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Attention: Phone:Chris Kestner (616) 456-5469

Fax:Materials Testing Consultants (616) 456-5784

Received Date:693 Plymouth N.E. 03/16/2016 9:40 AM

Analysis Date:Grand Rapids, MI 49505 03/23/2016

Collected Date:

Project: WHVCF POWER PLANT 151664

Test Report: Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Materials via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method using Polarized

Light Microscopy

Sample Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous

Non-Asbestos Asbestos

% Type

161604595-0001

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI low pressure steam

5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0002

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI low pressure steam

5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0003

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI low pressure steam

5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0004

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI high pressure steam

5%

20%

10%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

Glass

65% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0005

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI high pressure steam

5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0006

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI high pressure steam

5%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

65% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0007

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI condensate 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0008

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI condensate 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0009

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI condensate 5%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

65% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0010

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI chilled water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0011

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI chilled water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0012

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI chilled water 20%

20%

20%

Cellulose

Synthetic

Min. Wool

40% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0013

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI cold water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0014

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI cold water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0015

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI cold water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0016

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI hot water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

Initial Report From: 03/23/2016 12:44:29

Page 1 of 4PLM - 1.67 Printed: 3/23/2016 12:44 PM

Tel/Fax: (317) 803-2997 / (317) 803-3047 http://www.EMSL.com / indianapolislab@emsl.com

161604595EMSL Order:

Customer ID: MATE53

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Test Report: Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Materials via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method using Polarized

Light Microscopy

Sample Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous

Non-Asbestos Asbestos

% Type

161604595-0017

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI hot water 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0018

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI hot water 5%

40%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

55% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0019

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedCondensate tank wrap

5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0020

Gray/Yellow

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedCondensate tank wrap

20%

40%

Min. Wool

Glass

40% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0021

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedCondensate tank wrap

5%

60%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

35% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0022

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI boiler feed 5%

20%

Cellulose

Glass

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0023

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI boiler feed 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0024

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI boiler feed 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0025

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI blow down 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0026

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI blow down 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0027

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedMCI blow down 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0028

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedHeat exch tank wrap 5%

20%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

75% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0029

Gray/Yellow

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedHeat exch tank wrap 20%

20%

Min. Wool

Glass

60% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0030

Gray/Yellow

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedHeat exch tank wrap 20%

20%

Min. Wool

Glass

60% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0031

White/Black

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedVibration dampening cloth

60% Glass 40% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0032

White/Black

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedVibration dampening cloth

60% Glass 40% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0033

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

Window caulk 100% Non-fibrous (Other) <1% Chrysotile

161604595-0034

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

Window caulk 100% Non-fibrous (Other) <1% Chrysotile

161604595-0035

White

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedBoiler stack insulation 5%

5%

Synthetic

Glass

90% Non-fibrous (Other)

Page 2 of 4PLM - 1.67 Printed: 3/23/2016 12:44 PM

Tel/Fax: (317) 803-2997 / (317) 803-3047 http://www.EMSL.com / indianapolislab@emsl.com

161604595EMSL Order:

Customer ID: MATE53

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Test Report: Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Materials via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method using Polarized

Light Microscopy

Sample Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous

Non-Asbestos Asbestos

% Type

161604595-0036

White

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedBoiler stack insulation 5%

5%

Synthetic

Glass

90% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0037

White

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None DetectedBoiler stack insulation 5%

5%

Synthetic

Glass

90% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0038

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected1"x1" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0039

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected1"x1" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0040

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected1"x1" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0041

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4"x6" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0042

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4"x6" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0043

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4"x6" ceramic tile grout

20%

80%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0044

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2"x2" ceramic tile grout

10%

90%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0045

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2"x2" ceramic tile grout

10%

90%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0046

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2"x2" ceramic tile grout

10%

90%

Quartz

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0047

White/Beige

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2"x4" ceiling tile 50%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

15%

5%

Perlite

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0048

White/Beige

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2"x4" ceiling tile 50%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

15%

5%

Perlite

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0049

White

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected12"x12" floor tile 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0050

White

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected12"x12" floor tile 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

2501-Cove Base

161604595-0051

Beige

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4" vinyl cove base 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

2501-Mastic

161604595-0051A

Yellow

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4" vinyl cove base 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

2502-Cove Base

161604595-0052

Gray

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4" vinyl cove base 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

2502-Mastic

161604595-0052A

Yellow

Non-Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected4" vinyl cove base 100% Non-fibrous (Other)

Page 3 of 4PLM - 1.67 Printed: 3/23/2016 12:44 PM

Tel/Fax: (317) 803-2997 / (317) 803-3047 http://www.EMSL.com / indianapolislab@emsl.com

161604595EMSL Order:

Customer ID: MATE53

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Test Report: Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Materials via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method using Polarized

Light Microscopy

Sample Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous

Non-Asbestos Asbestos

% Type

161604595-0053

Gray/White

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2'x4' ceiling tile 50%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

15%

5%

Perlite

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0054

Gray/White

Fibrous

Homogeneous

None Detected2'x4' ceiling tile 50%

30%

Cellulose

Min. Wool

15%

5%

Perlite

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0055

Gray

Fibrous

Homogeneous transite louvers on cooling tower

80% Non-fibrous (Other) 20% Chrysotile

161604595-0056

Brown/White

Fibrous

Heterogeneous

None Detecteddrywall 20%

2%

Cellulose

Glass

70%

8%

Gypsum

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0057

Brown/White

Fibrous

Heterogeneous

None Detecteddrywall 20%

2%

Cellulose

Glass

70%

8%

Gypsum

Non-fibrous (Other)

161604595-0058

Brown/White

Fibrous

Heterogeneous

None Detecteddrywall 35%

2%

Cellulose

Glass

60%

3%

Gypsum

Non-fibrous (Other)

Analyst(s)

Jadda Moffett (38)

Ross Matlock (22)

Richard Harding, Laboratory Manager or Other Approved Signatory

EMSL maintains liability limited to cost of analysis . This report relates only to the samples reported and may not be reproduced, except in full, without written approval by EMSL. EMSL bears no responsibility for sample collection activities or analytical method limitations. Interpretation and use of test results are the responsibility of the client. This report must not be used by the client to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST or any agency of the federal government . Non-friable organically bound materials present a problem matrix and therefore EMSL recommends gravimetric reduction prior to analysis. Samples received in good condition unless otherwise noted. Estimated accuracy, precision and uncertainty data available upon request. Unless requested by the client, building materials manufactured with multiple layers (i.e. linoleum, wallboard, etc.) are reported as a single sample. Reporting limit is 1%

Samples analyzed by EMSL Analytical, Inc. Indianapolis, IN NVLAP Lab Code 200188-0, AZ0939, CA 2575, CO AL-15132, TX 300262

Page 4 of 4PLM - 1.67 Printed: 3/23/2016 12:44 PM

OrderID: 161604595

Page 1 Of

Page 2 Of

Page 3 Of

Page 4 Of

SECTION 5.0 - ASSESSMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

SECTION 5.1

ASSESSMENTS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Inspection of the Heating Plant Building identified twenty-eight (28) separate suspect asbestos containing materials.

Of these twenty-eight (28) materials, twenty-two (22) were identified through laboratory analysis not to contain asbestos or to contain asbestos below the regulated limit of 1%, four (4) were not sampled but assumed to contain asbestos, two (2) were identified through laboratory analysis to positively contain asbestos. Materials known or assumed to contain asbestos are summarized as follows:

Homogeneous Area Number

Homogeneous Area Name

Asbestos Type and Percent

Quantity

13 Electrical Switches Assumed 74 Each 14 Fire Doors Assumed 5 Each 15 Transite Window Panels Assumed 108 Sq. Ft.

17 Cleaver Brooks Boilers Assumed 3 Each 23 Generator Vent Stack Chrysotile 5% - 60%

Amosite – ND – 45% 15 Sq. Ft.

27 Transite Panels on Cooling Tower

Chrysotile 20% 240 Sq. Ft.

Electrical Switches (HA-13) which are assumed to contain asbestos should be maintained in their current undamaged condition. All of these materials are located throughout the Heating Plant Building. Electrical switches could potentially have asbestos containing transite panels behind electrical connections. Upon de-energizing these fixtures, a trained person should assess the fixture before removal.

Fire Doors (HA-14) which are assumed to contain asbestos should be maintained in their current undamaged condition. The doors are located throughout the building. Fire doors could potentially have asbestos containing material within the door. Activities such as the cutting or drilling through the outer metal jacket and into the door's core materials could potentially result in a release of asbestos containing materials and should be avoided.

Transite Window Panels (HA-15) which are assumed to contain asbestos should be maintained in their current undamaged condition. Activities such as the cutting or drilling could potentially result in a release of asbestos containing materials and should be avoided.

Cleaver Brooks Boilers (HA-17) which are assumed to contain asbestos should be maintained in their current undamaged condition. All boilers were operational, so not interior samples could be taken. Activities such as the cutting or drilling could potentially result in a release of asbestos containing materials and should be avoided.

Generator Vent Stack (HA-23) was observed in the generator room and generally found to be in an undamaged condition. It is understood that the generators will be replace in the near future. MTC recommends that these materials be removed by State of Michigan licensed abatement contractor using trained and accredited workers and supervisors.

Transite Panels on Cooling Tower (HA-27) were observed in fair to good condition.