Attachment 5_WNYC Ph 1C - CxDwgReviewLog_08282022.pdf

C = Critical CO = Coordinate S = Suggestion I = Information

Cx-001 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

01 81 13 / 01 91 00

01 81 13: 1.2 01 91 00: 1.4 General

Request verification of LEED scope. Current draft of 01 81 13 references section 01 81 13.02 for LEEDv4. This section is not currently included in the Pre-Final RFP package.

This also needs to be aligned with 01 91 00 Section 1.4 which references commissioning for LEED in general as well as the Measurement and Verification credit.

Cx-002 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

01 81 13 1.5-G-5 & 3.1-A-4 General

Recommend confirming if the Indoor Air Quality flush-out is to be a requirement for this project.

While technically achievable, the duration of flush-out can be extensive (e.g. multiple months between end of construction and occupancy) without the aid of supplemental ventilation. The ability to use supplemental ventilation is also limited by the requirement to maintain indoor temperature and humidity levels.

For reference, this section aligns with Paths 1 and 2 of LEEDv4 Indoor Air Quality Assessment Option 1 which is an optional credit under that

Cx-003 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

01 45 29 General General This specification was in generally unedited draft form when received. Will track to verify finalization of this specification.

Cx-004 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Drawings GI002 General

The Sheet Index called Sheet GI002 or G-001 includes drawings not currently in the progress set (e.g. GI101, GI102, MEP sheets, etc.) and does not include certain drawings found in the progress set (e.g. V-101 thru V-103; B-102 and B-103).

Will track to verify finalization of Sheet Index and review additional drawings produced for the DB-RFP package.

Cx-005 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - Chapter 1 1.1 General

This section refers to the Pole Barn as approximately 2,500 sq. ft. Sheet A104 shows approximately 2,400 sq. ft. The discrepancy appears to be the length dimension referenced.

Cx-006 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - ESR MS General General

The Material Storage Bins building ESR sheets are still in progress. Will track to verify finalization of these documents.

Cx-007 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - Maintenance

Building General General

Maintenance Building ESR documents have not been not received for review. Will track to verify finalization of these documents.

Cx-008 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 ESR - Honor Guard General General

The ESR documents received for the Honor Guard are work in progress. Will track to verify finalization of these documents.

Cx-009 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General GIS

Request clarification of GIS scope for this project. The 1/4/2022 Concept Design Workshop (CDW) Meeting Minutes indicate "GIS system cost will be included in estimate".

Did not find specific references to this scope in Pre-Final draft documents.

8/23/2022 Per the Architect, "GIS is not in our scope."

Cx-010 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Architectural

The 1/4/2022 Meeting Minutes reference provision of an air curtain above door for Honor Guard building. Did not identify any requirements for this in the CDW Report or progress Pre-Final documents. Request verification if required and referenced in RFP package, if applicable.

DisciplineSection

National Cemetary Administration Western New York National Cemetery

Genesee County, New York

StatusCommissioning Agent Comment Response

Date Comment

Design Team Response

Backcheck Date

Comment

Commissioning Backcheck Comment Number

Comment Date

Reference

Rev. Document

Page 1 of 5 Commissioning Design Review Comment Log

S = Suggestion I = Information

DisciplineSection

National Cemetary Administration Western New York National Cemetery

Genesee County, New York

StatusCommissioning Agent Comment Response

Date Comment

Design Team Response

Backcheck Date

Comment

Commissioning Backcheck Comment Number

Comment Date

Reference

Rev. Document

Cx-011 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Architectural

The 4/19/2022 CDW Meeting Minutes indicate 8-10 ft CMU wall separating Maintenance Building Vehicle Bay and Wash Bay with stud wall above. Sheet A101 indicates CMU wall to 12 ft with stud wall above. Request verification this meets the intent of the referenced workshop discussion.

Cx-012 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Architectural

The 1/4/2022 Meeting Minutes indicate for AEW to provide cut sheets for welding hood if required by OSHA. The hood is referenced in Section 8.1 of the CDW Report but a cut sheet is not included. Request clarification of this requirement is to be incorporated into the DB- RFP package.

Cx-013 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Architectural

The 4/19/2022 Meeting Minutes indicate that recessed mats will be specified at all man door entrances. Did not find specification of this in the CDW Report or architecutral drawings. Sheet A101 references these as "Walk Off Mats".

Recommend clarifying in the DB-RFP package.

Cx-014 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Fire Protection

Fire protection references in the draft documents are most explicitly related to Fire Alarm Systems and exterior Fire Hydrants. Request clarification if any sprinkler systems will be required for the Maintenance Building or Honor Guard.

8/23/2022 Per the Architect: "The buildings are unsprinklered"

Cx-015 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D20_HG D202003 Plumbing

Section D202003 refers to ESR G30 for domestic water metering requirements. ESR G30 is not included in the review documents -requirement needs to be verified.

Cx-016 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D302001 Mechanical

Boilers are described as condensing with multi-wall boiler stack. Request verification from Mechanical designer if multi-wall vents are required for these condensing boilers.

Cx-017 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D302001 Mechanical

Recommend making reference to condensate neutralization (kit) and drainage requirements for the condensing boilers.

Cx-018 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D3020 Mechanical

Heating hot water distribution is indicated to be variable primary. Request clarification if Variable Frequency Drives will be required, if hot water coil valves to be two-way or three-way and whether a minimum flow control bypass will be required. This request applies also to the Maintenance Building heating hot water system.

Cx-019 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D304005 Mechanical

D304005 and D304006 reference glycol distribution systems (chilled water). CxA assumes these sections are not applicable.

Request verification.

Cx-020 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D306001 Mechanical

Section D306001 HVAC Controls section is not complete. Request verification of the extent of HVAC control / DDC requirements for this facility (and Maintenance Complex) and whether this system would be integrated into an existing Building Automation System. Section D302001 references BACnet communications protocol for Boilers.

8/23/2022

Per the Architect: "Our scope of work did not include the intent to design a complete centralized HVAC control (DDC) system for the maintenance building or honor guard. The idea was that the equipment that we included in the RFP document would have individual controls that would tie into the building's BAS system to be monitored only."

Cx-021 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D309001 Mechanical

Section D309001 references Force Protection Criteria. Request verification if applicable to this facility.

Cx-022 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D30_HG D301001 Mechanical

Section D301001 describes an oil supply system for oil fired generator. Request verification if this section is applicable to this facility.

Page 2 of 5 Commissioning Design Review

S = Suggestion I = Information

DisciplineSection

National Cemetary Administration Western New York National Cemetery

Genesee County, New York

StatusCommissioning Agent Comment Response

Date Comment

Design Team Response

Backcheck Date

Comment

Commissioning Backcheck Comment Number

Comment Date

Reference

Rev. Document

Cx-023 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

01 00 00 Section 1.4 Mechanical

The 1/4/2022 CDW Meeting Minutes reference an Add Alternate for radiant heat in sidewalk from Honor Guard building to the road. Section

11.1 of the CDW report indicates in-slab radiant heating for 1/3 of the sidewalk from the entrance.

Request clarification if this is to be flagged as an Add Alternate.

Cx-024 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Mechanical

The 4/19/2022 CDW Meeting Minutes indicate that vehicle exhaust pipe through doors (two pipes) is to be provided. The specifics of this requirement does not appear to be addressed in the CDW report or current Pre-Final draft documents. Recommend clarification in the scope narratives and/or drawings.

Cx-025 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_G40_PB G401006 Electrical

G4010 indicates Pole Barn to be powered off circuits from panelboard in Maintenance Building. G401006 references underground 600V service. This section is generally applicable but the Design Team should verify the anticipated service and correct or eliminate reference to 600V if not applicable to Pole Barn.

See references also to 600V service in Material Storage and Honor Guard G40 documents.

Cx-026 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

F-101 Pole Barn Room

Requirements F-101 Electrical

Section D5020 "Power Equipment" references general purpose GFI outlets. Request clarification if block heaters will plug into these GFI outlets or if additional clarification is needed to identify power requirements for block heaters.

Cx-027 CO = Coordinate 8/22/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D50_PB D502002 Electrical

Section D502002 references lighting control via switches and occupancy sensors. F-101 references control via ceiling-mounted occupancy sensors. Request verification if both switches and occupancy sensors are required. If required, we recommend a more explicit requirement to ensure incorporation into the final design (e.g. light switch required for manual shut off of ceiling-occupancy sensor controlled lighting).

Cx-028 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Part 3 - 6 ESR_D50_MS D502002 Electrical

Section D502002 references lighting control for interior via switches and occupancy sensors. E- 101 thru E-103 reference control via ceiling-mounted occupancy sensors. Request verification if both switches and occupancy sensors are required. If required, we recommend a more explicit requirement to ensure incorporation into the final design (e.g. light switch required for manual shut off of ceiling-occupancy sensor controlled lighting).

Cx-029 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Electrical

Request clarification of power requirements for Outsourced Area. 1/4/2022 CDW Meeting Minutes indicate to be 100 amp, not necessarily three-phase. Have not identified requirements in draft Pre-Final narratives or drawings.

Cx-030 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

Chapter 3_Site Analysis G205007 Irrigation

Request clarification of irrigation scope for Maintenance Complex and Honor Guard.

Section G205007 still appears to be work in progress (e.g. referencing burial sections).

Irrigation LI sheets not yet received for review.

Page 3 of 5 Commissioning Design Review

S = Suggestion I = Information

DisciplineSection

National Cemetary Administration Western New York National Cemetery

Genesee County, New York

StatusCommissioning Agent Comment Response

Date Comment

Design Team Response

Backcheck Date

Comment

Commissioning Backcheck Comment Number

Comment Date

Reference

Rev. Document

Cx-031 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General - Site Civil General Site Utilities

Recommend clarification of scope of required heat tracing for site utilities in Chapter 3 and/or Part 3 documents. Heat tracing is referenced on Detail 3 / GC502.

Cx-032 CO = Coordinate 8/23/2022 Pre- Final Draft

General General Site Utilities

The Cost Estimate references Concrete over HDPE stormwater drainage apparently due to HDPE availability concerns. The CDW Report and draft Pre-Final site plans generally show HDPE. Request clarification if concrete it to be referenced as an approved alternate or would otherwise require RFI to substitute.

Page 4 of 5 Commissioning Design Review