CLDC Final RFP Questions and Answers.pdf
PDF 579 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- 80JSC027R0004
About this file
This document is a Questions and Answers (Q&A) compilation for the Commercial Low-Earth Orbit Development Program (CLDC) Final Request for Proposals (RFP) dated November 9, 2026. The Q&A contains 203 questions and answers organized into 11 thematic categories addressing clarifications on transportation, pricing, technical requirements, work planning, capabilities, insurance, data rights, and solicitation clauses.
Key procurement details include: NASA is acquiring end-to-end commercial low-earth orbit destination services through an Indefinite Delivery/Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) contract with multiple contract line items (CLINs). CLIN 1 covers initial development with a firm-fixed-price and 15-18 month completion target. CLIN 2 addresses development and certification with multiple milestones, while CLIN 3 provides mission services with task order pricing. The contract includes options for CLIN 4 additional services and CLIN 5 special studies. Proposal due date is December 14, 2026, with Government Technical Assistance (GTA) requests due December 1, 2026. Critical requirements include: use of previously certified crew and cargo transportation vehicles (SpaceX Dragon, Boeing Starliner, Northrop Grumman Cygnus) for the first four missions; U.S. domestic sourcing compliance per 51 U.S.C. §50131 and §30703; Government Furnished Transportation Services (GFTSS) guaranteeing 2 crew and 4 cargo missions annually for the first four missions at normalized pricing; third mission requirement to achieve continuously crewed capability; compliance with CLDP-REQ-1130 technical requirements; and adherence to specified standards and specifications in CLDP-STD documents. Offerors must submit comprehensive proposals in five volumes including technical approach, pricing, past performance, and responsibility information, with specific page limits and formatting requirements detailed throughout the RFP.
View the file
Other files
Show all 22
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
CLDC Final RFP Questions and Answers November 9, 2026
P a g e 1 | 77
1. Contents Theme 1: Transportation (Launch Vehicle, Crew and Cargo)
Theme 2: GFTSS (Technical and Pricing Related Questions)
Theme 3: Pricing
Theme 4: Technical Questions, Specs, Standards
Theme 5: Work Plan /Cert Plan Clarification
Theme 6: Capability, Ordering & Mission Type Clarifications
Theme 7: Insurance, Informed Consent. Jurisdiction and Data Rights
Theme 8: DRDs
Theme 9: IP & Habitable Modules
Theme 10: Proposal Submittal Instructions, Small Business, Responsibility
Theme 11: Solicitation Clauses
P a g e 2 | 77
Theme 1: Transportation (Launch Vehicle, Crew and Cargo)
1. [In reference to Statement of Work 3.4.1] Table 3.4.1-1 NASA First Right of Refusal
Allocated Cargo Per Mission states: "2 crew = 50%; 4 crew = 65%; 4 crew = 75% of cargo." Section 2.14 states: "For any crew or cargo mission, the Contractor shall ensure NASA has first right of refusal of no less than 70% of the available late load and early destow volume capability. The exact volume will be documented at the CLIN 3 RFTOP award based on the Contractor proposed vehicle traffic plan." Please clarify if late load cargo is handled differently in terms of NASA allocation compared to nominal cargo.
Yes, the late load cargo requirements identified in SOW 2.14 Mission Integration are handled differently than the NASA First Right of Refusal Allocated Cargo percentages in SOW 3.4.1 Additional Services for nominal cargo. For late load and early destow capability, NASA is requiring first rights of refusal of 70% of any crew and cargo vehicles.
2. RFP Section L, L.17.3.1 MS SUBFACTOR 1 – TECHNICAL APPROACH (TA) - Please clarify the launch vehicle requirements for cargo missions to CLDs. Section L.17.3.1.TA.1 of the RFP specifies NLS 2+, while SOW 2.17.5 specifies "three (3) or more previous successful flights of a similar launch vehicle configuration."
Section L.17.3.1.TA.1 in Paragraph (5)(B)(2) identifies that offerors should describe their launch vehicles and how they meet requirements in SOW.2.17.5. for crew, cargo and element launch. Launch vehicles of cargo do not require an NLS level but only require "three (3) or more previous successful flights of a similar launch vehicle configuration."
SOW 2.17.5, Launch Vehicle Maturity establishes the applicable mission assurance standards, requiring Category 3 launch vehicles for element launches, with Category 2 use allowed only with NASA approval and added risk/insurance conditions. The reference to “three (3) or more previous successful flights of a similar launch vehicle configuration" is associated with the requirement for launch of cargo.
3. RFP Section H, H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE
CRITERIA - Are there percentage domestic sourcing requirements for cargo and crew vehicles, only for the rocket on which they launch, or for the integrated stack?
Clarification has been made in Amendment 1, H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA provides clarity on the requirements.
See response to #4 for additional details.
4. RFP Section H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC. SOURCE CRITERIA and SOW 2.17.6 Crew Launch & Return - The U.S.-commercial-provider /
P a g e 3 | 77 domestic-source requirement is stated explicitly for crew launch (SOW 2.17.6), but its applicability to cargo transportation and to element launch is less clear. Does the U.S.
commercial provider / domestic source requirement in Clause H.8 and Attachment L- 10 apply to (a) crew transportation only, (b) crew and cargo transportation, and/or (c) launch of CLDS elements? Please confirm which transportation services must be provided by a U.S. domestic source.
The requirements in Amendment 1, Clause H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA, have been updated to clarify. Clause H.8 paragraph a) applies to the CLD Provider, launch vehicle provider, and crew and cargo transportation providers if providing NASA service which includes launch/return of NASA crew, NASA cargo, crew accommodations, CLD vehicle accommodations including spares and other equipment required to provide the service and CLD modules/elements required in the performance of the service.
The requirements in Amendment 1, Clause H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA, have been updated to clarify. Clause H.8 paragraph b) applies to the launch vehicle provider, crew and cargo transportation providers if launching or returning NASA payloads or cargo to the CLD.
NASA has additional requirements in SOW 2.15.6 USG Payload or Payload Facility Delay, requiring the contractor to develop processes and procedures to accommodate late payloads including options for “Moving the payload or payload facility to a future flight assignment” and first rights of refusal for crew and cargo vehicles as outlined in SOW Section 2.14 and 3.4.1. Utilizing a mixed fleet of US owned/US manufactured with foreign owned/foreign manufactured might impede Contractor’s ability to meet these requirements and provide appropriate manifest flexibility.
5. RFP Section H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA and SOW 2.17 Transportation - It is unclear whether the domestic-source obligation attaches to the end-to-end service NASA purchases or to all transportation to the Destination regardless of payload sponsor. Does the U.S.-provider requirement apply to the full scope of transportation to and from the Destination, or only to the portion carrying USG crew, NASA cargo, and NASA payloads? Specifically, may the Contractor use a non-U.S. cargo transportation vehicle for non-NASA (commercial or sovereign) cargo while using a U.S. vehicle for NASA cargo?
See answer to Question 4.
P a g e 4 | 77
6. RFP Section H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA and SOW 2.17.6 Crew Launch & Return - Q2 distinguishes transportation carrying USG crew from other transportation. More broadly, it is unclear whether the mere presence of USG (NASA) crew aboard the CLD causes an activity or increment to be categorized as a 'NASA mission,' which could in turn trigger domestic-source and other NASA-mission requirements. Does NASA consider the presence of USG crew on the CLD to constitute a 'NASA mission'? That is, if NASA crew are present on the CLD, will the activity always be treated as a NASA mission (with the attendant requirements), or can NASA crew be present during non-NASA (commercial or sovereign) missions without the activity being categorized as a NASA mission?
Yes, the presence of USG Crew on the Destination does designate the increment as a NASA Mission which does trigger mission requirements. For specific applicability for domestic source requirements see answer to Question 4.
7. SOW 2.17.1 Transportation Certification - SOW states that "The Contractor shall utilize previously certified crew and cargo transportation vehicles for the first four (4) Mission Service Order increments. Previously certified crew and cargo transportation systems are defined as currently certified or in work to be certified to ISS under the CRS or CCtCap contracts as of October 1, 2026." Is NASA willing to extend that SOW language to include “CRS, CCtCap, or ESA LCRS contracts?
No, NASA does not plan to update the RFP to allow additional vehicles to qualify for the first four missions. Transportation must be obtained for the first four missions utilizing currently certified or in work to be certified to ISS under the CRS or CCtCap contracts as of October 1, 2026.
8. RFP Section L.17.3.1 MS SUBFACTOR 1 – TECHNICAL APPROACH (TA), TA.1 System
Architecture(5)(B)(2) - "The LOI should provide information on the planned launch vehicle and NLS Category designator. If launch vehicle has not reached Category 2 or 3 at time of LOI, provide plan for completing prior to first mission." Does this Category 2 or 3 requirement apply to the launch vehicle only (rocket) or the cargo/crew vehicle also?
The Category 2 or 3 designation applies to launch vehicles when launching elements.
Launch vehicle requirements for the launch of cargo are outlined as no less than 3 successful launches. Launch vehicle requirements for crew are in CLDP-REQ-1130, Requirements and Standards for the Commercial Low-Earth Orbit Development Program. This NLS classification only applies to launch vehicles and does not apply to cargo and crew vehicles. These requirements can be found in SOW 2.17.5 Launch Vehicle Maturity.
P a g e 5 | 77
9. SOW 1.5 NASA Utilization Capability Needs in LEO - When must the return requirements for a mission type (Category 1-3) be met. How long after the mission can the return take place?
All requirements including the return requirements are expected to be met based on mission type. The return requirements outlined in SOW 1.5 are required to coincide with a period of time as defined by the Category 1, 2, 3 and represent the total transportation vehicle return requirements for that period. Nominal and early destow time requirements are found in CLDP-REQ-1130.
However, NASA recognizes that the actual transportation capabilities available for CLDs may not accommodate the NASA Category requirements. In the case that the overall transportation capability is less than Category 1-3, NASA expects to receive the minimums outlined in SOW, Section 3.4.1 of at least 50% of the total capability available for return for 2 crew members, 65% of the total capability for return for 3 crew members and 75% of the total capability for return for 4 crew members. NASA has clarified this in the Amendment 1.
10. SOW 2.17.1 Transportation Certification - Some vehicles hold a NASA-recognized ISS visiting-vehicle certification obtained through the ISS international-partnership / Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) framework (e.g., JAXA's HTV-X) rather than under a NASA CRS or CCtCap contract. Does a vehicle that is certified as an ISS visiting vehicle under the IGA / international-partner process, but not under the CRS or CCtCap contracts, satisfy the SOW 2.17.1 definition of "previously certified"? If not, please confirm that the first four Mission Service Order increments (the "Minimum Buy") are limited exclusively to vehicles certified under the CRS or CCtCap contracts.
Correct, the first four Mission Service Order increments (the "Minimum Buy") are limited exclusively to vehicles certified under the CRS or CCtCap contracts as of October 1, 2026.
11. SOW 2.17.1 Transportation Certification and 2.17.5 Launch Vehicle Maturity - SOW
2.17.1 governs the first four increments by contract-based certification, while SOW
2.17.5 separately gates cargo launch vehicles on flight heritage ("three (3) or more previous successful flights of a similar launch vehicle configuration"). For increments after the first four, does a non-U.S. cargo vehicle with demonstrated ISS flight heritage certified under the IGA / international-partner process (e.g., IGA-certified vehicles such as JAXA's HTV-X or ESA's LCRS - Low-Earth-Orbit Cargo Return Service) need only
P a g e 6 | 77 satisfy the SOW 2.17.5 maturity criteria, or does it also remain subject to the domestic-source requirement (Q1/Q2) and a 51 U.S.C. 50131(b) exception? Please clarify how
2.17.1 and 2.17.5 interact for a previously flown, IGA-certified, non-CRS/CCtCap cargo vehicle such as JAXA's HTV-X or ESA LCRS.
Vehicles outside of the CRS or CCtCaP contract can be considered after the first four missions as long as they meet all US domestic sourcing, launch or manufacturing requirements in accordance with clause H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA in performance of meeting the requirements of this contract. JAXA's HTV-X or ESA LCRS vehicles do not meet the domestic source requirements in clause H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA at this time. If credible plans to meet the US Domestic Source Criteria are provided by the time of CLIN 2 RFTOP, the Offeror may propose use of these vehicles for missions after the first four mission increments.
12. RFP Section H.34 CONTRACTOR USE OF EXCESS NASA CAPACITY and SOW 2.17
Transportation - NASA purchases a defined share of cargo (first-right-of-refusal, SOW 3.4.1), but the Destination also carries non-NASA commercial and sovereign cargo/payloads. Does the requirement to use a U.S. launch vehicle apply only to the transportation of NASA cargo and NASA payloads, or to all cargo and payloads delivered to the Destination? If the Contractor delivers commercial or sovereign payloads to the destination on a non-U.S. cargo vehicle (including under H.34 excess-capacity or the Contractor's own commercial missions), does that implicate the domestic-source requirement, provided NASA cargo and payloads are flown on a U.S.
vehicle?
See answer to Question 4. Additionally, the H.34 Excess capacity clause pertains to NASA’s excess capacity released back to the Contractor. As this capacity would have already been required to be offered under a domestic source requirement it is unclear how this could be realistically considered for a Non-US vehicle.
13. RFP L.17.5 RESPONSIBILITY CONSIDERATIONS – VOLUME IV and SOW 2.17.1
Transportation Certification - The Final RFP permits an optional request for a NASA exception to 51 U.S.C. 50131(b), and defers new/non-baseline transportation decisions to the CLIN 2 RFTOP. May a 51 U.S.C. 50131(b) exception be requested for cargo transportation specifically, and may it be submitted or revisited post-award at the CLIN 2 RFTOP rather than only with the initial proposal?
L.17.5 RESPONSIBILITY CONSIDERATIONS allows offerors to submit information for NASA to consider an exception leading into the CLIN 2 RFTOP. Additional information
P a g e 7 | 77 may also be submitted post CLIN 1 award. CLIN 2 RFTOP decisions on transportation will be based on information provided prior to CLIN 2 RFTOP. Once CLIN 2 RFTOP is released, Offeror’s proposals must meet requirements as laid out in the CLIN 2 RFTOP which may or may not include exceptions. Post-CLIN 2 RFTOP award if transportation capabilities change, additional requests may be considered.
14. RFP Section L.17.5 RESPONSIBILITY CONSIDERATIONS – VOLUME IV - Where an
Offeror requests that NASA consider an exception to 51 U.S.C. 50131, the Offeror is required to provide information on market research, schedule impacts, availability timelines, cost comparisons, and technical gaps preventing use of U.S. providers. As a premise, the addressee of this statute is the Federal Government. Specifically, on what basis does NASA impose this restriction on the CLD procurement, and through what process does NASA intend to make exceptions to this restriction possible?
NASA is acquiring space transportation services through the CLDC contract and, depending on the prime contractor’s approach and capabilities, the prime contractor may subcontract for the space transportation services. Since NASA is acquiring services, the service provider (prime or subcontractor) is required to meet the definition of United States Commercial Provider in accordance with H.8.(a). This approach is consistent with the approach for the US-manufactured vehicle requirement in accordance with H.8.(b), which applies regardless of whether a prime or subcontractor is launching or transporting a US Government payload.
(a) There are multiple exceptions under 51 U.S.C. 50131(b), and some of the exceptions that may be considered do not require all of the information listed above.
Accordingly, depending on the exception to be considered, could NASA be flexible in its consideration of the information listed above?
This is an optional proposal supplement which would be considered post-award.
The supplemental information does not have to be submitted and, if it is, Offerors have discretion as to the information to provide.
(b) Specifically, when will NASA make its determination using this information? In addition, may a request be submitted even after CLIN 1 award?
L.17.5 RESPONSIBILITY CONSIDERATIONS allows offerors to submit information for NASA to consider an exception leading into the CLIN 2 RFTOP. Additional information may also be submitted post CLIN 1 award. CLIN 2 RFTOP decisions on transportation will be based on information provided prior to CLIN 2 RFTOP. Once CLIN 2 RFTOP is released, Offeror’s proposals must meet requirements as laid out
P a g e 8 | 77 in the CLIN 2 RFTOP which may or may not include exceptions. Post-CLIN 2 RFTOP award, if transportation capabilities change, additional requests may be considered.
15. The restrictions in H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC
SOURCE CRITERIA are based not only on 51 U.S.C. 50131 but also on 51 U.S.C. 30703.
Accordingly, we consider that exceptions should also be considered with respect to 51 U.S.C. 30703. Will such a determination be made based on the information provided under L.17.5 RESPONSIBILITY CONSIDERATIONS – VOLUME IV?
NASA will use all information provided under L.17.5(c)(2), in addition to other data available to NASA, to assess whether an exception to or request for a waiver from each of the requirements in H.8, United States Commercial Provider and Domestic Source Criteria, is in the best interest of the Government.
16. In Q&A Part 1, Question 157, as quoted below, NASA stated that it would update the
Final RFP to clarify the scope of application of H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA. However, the language in the Final RFP is unchanged from the Draft RFP. As noted in that question, the statute governs procurement by the Federal Government but does not impose restrictions on the CLD Provider, and it remains unclear what restrictions this clause imposes on the CLD Provider's own procurement plan. Please clarify this point to the extent possible.
(a) (QA excerpt)(Question) “Under Section H Clause, UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE CRITERIA, paragraph (a) requires the Contractor to comply with 51 U.S.C. §50131 "in performance of this contract by acquiring space transportation services from United States commercial providers," without defining scope. Clarify whether this applies to all launches — crew, cargo, and CLDS element launches — or only to transportation acquired for NASA-procured services. Paragraph (b) of the same clause is properly scoped to U.S.-manufactured vehicles "to launch a NASA payload"; CLDS elements are Contractor-owned property, not NASA payloads, and 51 U.S.C. §50131 governs Federal Government acquisition of space transportation. As written, paragraph (a) could preclude the Contractor from launching its own elements on internationally operated vehicles, including under sovereign customer barter arrangements, limiting commercial viability without a statutory basis. Recommend paragraph (a) be scoped to space transportation services acquired for the performance of NASA-procured missions and NASA payloads, consistent with paragraph (b), with the Contractor's element launches and non-NASA commercial activity outside the restriction.”
P a g e 9 | 77
(Answer) “NASA plans to update the final RFP to clarify the application for crew, cargo and element launches. Commercial crew or cargo mission not including USG crew or USG payloads are not within the scope of this contract and are not envisioned to be covered by this requirement. See also NASA response to Question 145.”
NASA has made clarifications in the Amendment 1 to H.8 Domestic Source Criteria.
Additionally see NASA response to Question #4.
17. Please clarify what new-vehicle development, certification planning, risk-reduction, and evidence generation should be included and priced before the CLIN 2 RFTOP, given that NASA states the formal certification decision will not occur until that RFTOP.
As outlined in L.17.3.1 TA.1(5)(B), Offerors should include the stated evidence, and any other evidence necessary to explain new transportation development, certification and operations in their proposal and throughout their LOIs, but Offerors should not include any cost related to the certification of new transportation vehicles in their proposal. If new transportation vehicles are proposed to be used after the first 4 missions, the offeror can include the operational cost associated with new transportation, but not the certification costs which will be handled through a separate contract mechanism.
18. For Table L-08.2.1, given the statement "The Contractor Cargo allocation shall be 50% of the total capacity", does this mean that the other 50% of the vehicle capabilities could be sold to other commercial or government customers to further reduce mission costs?
Yes, and NASA has clarified this requirement in Amendment 1 and the Round 1 Q&A.
The Offeror should determine the total amount of cargo required to support CLD operations, USG utilization and non-USG utilization needs. The remaining cargo space is being made available to the Contractor for sale to non-USG customers. An equitable adjustment of the total cargo space utilized by the Contractor is expected as part of the CLIN 3 Mission Service task order when NASA is providing GFTSS.
19. Please confirm that SOW 2.17.1, Clause H.8, and L.17.2(g)(3) apply to transportation services provided by the contractor to NASA under this contract and confirm they do not restrict crew/cargo vehicles the contractor may use for non-USG missions (e.g., missions flown during a USG increment and subject to the Destination-side
P a g e 10 | 77 requirements of CLDP-REQ-1130 and the CLDP-STD-3102 safety review process for any vehicle approaching the Destination while USG crew are aboard).
20. If NASA may use international, government-supported transportation to satisfy GFTSS, how will NASA ensure that GFTSS implementation preserves U.S. domestic transportation capability and does not displace the domestic providers needed for a sustainable U.S. commercial LEO ecosystem?
NASA recognizes that a robust U.S. commercial LEO economy requires a healthy and competitive domestic transportation market. While NASA reserves the right to utilize international or government-supported transportation assets when appropriate to satisfy GFTSS requirements, the purpose of GFTSS is to ensure continuity of access to LEO and reduce transition risk during the development of commercial destinations, not to replace or displace U.S. commercial transportation providers.
GFTSS is designed as an enabling and transitional capability, providing assured access to LEO while commercial destination providers and transportation providers mature their business models and customer bases. NASA has also stated that it does not intend to rely on GFTSS as a long-term solution and will consider transition approaches proposed by industry.
21. For the Transportation Return Capability section for Category 3, 50 CTBE is listed for both disposal and for return. Usually, disposal capability is a larger number than return capability. Should one of these numbers be adjusted?
The 50 CTBE represents NASA’s utilization needs only for disposal and return and does not include the vehicle or crew disposal needs associated with the increment.
22. RFP Section H.8 UNITED STATES COMMERCIAL PROVIDER AND DOMESTIC SOURCE
CRITERIA - "The Contractor shall...comply with 51 U.S.C. §50131 in performance of this contract by acquiring space transportation services from United States commercial providers." Please clarify what transportation services are considered "in performance of this contract" vs commercial.
23. If a launch or transportation vehicle is not currently U.S. owned can it be proposed if the vehicle will be U.S. owned after the first 4 missions? Does the vehicle have to be U.S.
owned for the entire 15 year PoP?
P a g e 11 | 77
Transportation providers need to meet the domestic source criteria for all CLDC service missions. Offerors may propose new transportation providers that are on the path to US manufacture and ownership by CLIN 2 RFTOP for services after the first four missions.
Offerors’ Letters of Intent should include their plans for ensuring their proposed transportation and launch vehicles will comply with all applicable restrictions (including 51 U.S.C. §§ 50131 and 30703, 42 U.S.C. § 18311, and the National Space Transportation Policy of 2026) by CLIN 2 RFTOP if the transportation provider does not meet it at the time of proposal. NASA will consider offerors to be compliant if they submit a credible plan and verifiable information from the subject launch vehicle or transportation provider that they are on the path to meet the US statutes by CLIN 2
RFTOP.
24. What existing CRS/ISS certification, verification, safety, qualification, and flight evidence will NASA accept without regeneration for a previously certified CaTS, and what specific CLDP evidence must be recreated or reformatted under CLDP-PLN-2000, CLDP-REQ-1130, CLDP-STD-3102, and the CLDC DRDs?
All requirements need to be assessed and verified. The Contractor is responsible for delta certification and based on their architecture needs to determine the impact to the previous certification based on changes to the interface, environment, operations or other factors. Previously delivered verification evidence may be acceptable if it can be shown it is still applicable and does not require updates.
25. During the Pre-proposal Conference, A. Hart indicated that if GFTSS is requested/provided, then NASA will conduct the delta certification of transportation vehicles and offeror should not include those costs in their pricing. Does that mean that NASA plans to fund those delta certifications efforts under a GFTSS offering?
NASA has clarified this in the Amendment 1 in SOW, Section 12.7.3.1. For GFTSS, NASA will be responsible for the transportation costs associated with delta certification and the contractor shall remain responsible for the destination costs associated with transportation delta certification when NASA utilizes previously certified vehicles defined in SOW 2.17.1.
26. [In reference to SoW 2.17.1 Transportation Certification] First paragraph states
"Previously certified crew and cargo transportation systems are defined as currently
P a g e 12 | 77 certified or in work to be certified to ISS under the CRS or CCtCap contracts as of October 1, 2026." Please provide a list of vehicles which fall under this definition.
Listing of vehicles was provided under the Round 1 Q&A and includes SpaceX Dragon crew and cargo, Boeing Starliner, and Northrop Grumman Cygnus vehicles.
27. Under the final-RFP schedule, GTA requests are due October 31, 2026. Is there an opportunity to extend this deadline while transportation providers continue to evaluate the final RFP, work to understand delta-cert vs. new cert and absorb the significant changes to transportation (and GFTSS) inherent in the final RFP? Goal here is to make sure CLDPs are armed with more complete data which will increase proposal credibility.
NASA has updated the final RFP to extend the proposal due date to December 14, 2026, but will still return GTAs to the Offerors no later than December 1, 2026 (which was the original date NASA would return GTAs prior to this extension). This extension now gives Offerors 14 days to review GTAs and integrate them into their proposal.
28. For purposes of clarification: Are Letters of Intent required for the launch vehicles proposed to launch CLD elements?
Yes, LOIs should be included for all transportation vehicles and launch vehicles.
29. Please confirm that all LOI information are non-binding and will be used for planning estimates only?
Yes, LOI information is non-binding and will be used to validate Basis of Estimate and proposal. The proposed cost by the Destination prime will be binding as part of the contract and the proposal shall describe why if pricing proposed is not in line with the transportation LOIs.
30. Are Letters of Intent required for anticipated GFTSS vehicles (if services provided by NASA as opposed to those same services being procured by the Contractor)?
No, LOIs are not required for use of vehicles during the GFTSS guaranteed missions.
However, all transportation vehicles and launch vehicles after the first four missions planned to be utilized should be included in LOIs.
31. SOW 2.17.1 (p.38): “New transportation development and certification may be proposed but decision on certification will not be formalized until the CLIN 2 RFTOP.” It also says that after the first four increments “the Contractor may use new crew and cargo transportation systems,” and that “Final determination related to new system
P a g e 13 | 77 development and certification will be defined at CLIN 2 RFTOP.” RFP p.308: NASA will not determine “new transportation vehicle certification until the CLIN 2 RFTOP.”
H.2(d)(2) (pp.36-37): The CLIN 2 RFTOP is where contractors may propose “major changes (increase or decrease) to the transportation cost” and “additional enhancements/capabilities.” Conference slide 59: “New transportation development and certification may be proposed after the first four (4) missions.” To clarify these statements of use of future vehicles and the development and certification will be done on a different contract?
Offerors may propose and price new transportation after the first four missions, but development and certification for new transportation vehicles will be done under a different contract mechanism. The provision stated in clause H.2 is to allow the offeror to update their transportation approach or pricing (with justification) when they compete on the CLIN 2 RFTOP, but is not anticipated to cover development or certification costs. Conference slide #59 was to clarify a general requirement that offerors shall use previously certified transportation for the first four missions but may propose new transportation vehicles after the first four missions. If new Transportation is proposed in that scenario; NASA will be responsible for development and certification on new transportation vehicles under a separate contract or agreement which will be determined at a future time. NASA will address continued GFTSS and new transportation approvals at CLIN 2 RFTOP.
32. Recommend that the Lettes of intent for Crew and Cargo Transportation be moved outside the 300-page Mission Suitability Factor page count, and instead submitted as part of the Mission Suitability Factor Attachments, and that all content for Mission Suitability Factor outside of the 300-page count be provided as a separate Word or PDF document. Between the 300-page Mission Suitability Factor and the page unlimited DRD CLDC-001, Integrated Master Schedule; 100-page limited Attachment L-07, Business Case Analysis; 200-page limited DRD CLDC-002, Commercialization Plan (which also requires letters of commitment from investors and copies of teaming arrangements that would needed to be converted from PDFs to images and inserted in the Volume II Word document) there is a concern the file sizes would become unwieldy for both proposers and NASA evaluators.
NASA has clarified in the Amendment 1 and Final RFP Round 1 Q&A that LOIs have been removed from the page count.
33. Our understanding is that the Government does not intend to provide funding for new transportation vehicle development through the CLDC contract. However, the Offeror
P a g e 14 | 77 may propose new transportation vehicle milestones as non-payment milestones for purposes of alignment and informing NASA's decision about new transportation vehicle certification at the CLIN 2 RFTOP. Is this the correct understanding?
Yes, unfunded milestones related to planned new transportation may be proposed to provide NASA insight but do not constitute an agreement by NASA for future new transportation certification.
34. Does development and certification of new transportation vehicles fall within the scope of this contract?
No, development and certification of new transportation vehicles is not within the scope of the CLDC. NASA will be responsible for new transportation certification which will be covered under a different agreement/contract mechanism in the future.
35. Are offerors required to provide a Letter of Intent (LOI) for new transportation vehicles?
What if the offeror cannot get LOIs from any transportation providers?
Offerors shall seek LOIs from previously certified transportation partners, as well as any new transportation vehicles they wish to propose (after the first four (4) missions). If the offeror cannot obtain any or all the information required to be in the LOI, the offeror shall include estimates in line with their approach and proposed costs as requested in L.17.3.1 MS Subfactor 1 – Technical Approach TA.1 System Architecture.
36. Clarify the pre-certified transportation providers that the Offerors can propose for the first four missions, and what transportation vehicles the Offerors need to accommodate under GFTSS.
Offerors can propose the following previously certified Transportation for the first four missions: SpaceX Dragon (Crew & Cargo variant); Boeing Starliner; Northrop Grumman Cygnus Vehicle.
For GFTSS, the Offeror shall assume NASA will use the same suite of transportation vehicles listed above and should ensure Destination compatibility. But, as stated in Attachment L-08, NASA may also choose to fulfill this obligation by on-ramping new certified vehicles or utilizing vehicles provided by international partners for transportation missions. If transportation vehicles are planned to be used outside of the previously certified listing above, NASA will be responsible for the transportation and destination delta certification.
P a g e 15 | 77
Theme 2: GFTSS (Technical and Pricing Related Questions)
37. RFP Attachment L-01 Price Template and L-08 GFTSS Pricing Instructions - NASA has provided Government Furnished Transportation Services (GFTSS) rates for bidders to use. No milestone payment percentages and associated timeframes are provided for each of the launches. Each launch provider will have a unique milestone payment schedule. Milestone payment schedules inform cash flow and the business case, which drive Attachment L-07. Please provide a milestone payment schedule inclusive of the timing and percentage for each type of launch. Without such data, the bidders cannot develop a business case, especially considering uncertainty relating to which company will be providing launch services.
For GFTSS, NASA will negotiate directly with transportation providers which will include the associated launch vehicle service for actual timeline for payments for GFTSS.
Offerors are not responsible for the launch vehicle or transportation vehicle costs associated with GFTSS. Offeror should assume similar milestones and phasing will be utilized as outlined in J-12 Mission Service Workplan.
38. SOW Section 2.17.3 Government Furnished Transportation and Support Services
(GFTSS) - At what point will NASA determine the transportation vehicles to be provided as GFTSS, and when will NASA notify the CLD Provider?
The overall fleet will be determined at the CLIN 2 RFTOP with the specific mission complements being defined NLT CLIN 3 task order negotiations.
39. For GFTSS, how is pricing assessed for missions beyond those guaranteed per year? Is the assumption that after the guaranteed missions allocated by NASA, that any additional missions will need to be procured commercially?
GFTSS may be requested for missions beyond the first 4 missions, but it is not guaranteed. Decisions on future GFTSS will be addressed at CLIN 2 RFTOP. For this proposal, Offeror’s are to assume GFTSS is not available after the first four mission guarantee, and they need to propose commercially procured options.
40. Are the GFTSS missions NASA guaranteed prices, or only prices used for proposal submission estimating purposes? Is the intent that if commercial pricing exceeds the value in the GFTSS table that NASA subsidizes the value of the transportation services beyond those prices listed in the table?
NASA has developed a normalized pricing for GFTSS for proposal purposes in order to protect specific Commercial Provider pricing and does not necessarily constitute the actual prices NASA will negotiate in the future, which the CLD provider is not
P a g e 16 | 77 responsible for. This includes the full transportation service including launch, transportation and the services outlined in SOW, Section 2.17.3.1. NASA recognizes future transportation capabilities may differ from this table and actual GFTSS offering may be different. Differences will be negotiated post award during CLIN 3 Mission services discussions when the actual vehicles and their capabilities are committed.
41. Does the pricing table for GFTSS include/assume certification costs of any kind? If not, how will those costs be handled?
Details associated with certification are addressed in the RFP and SOW 2.17.1 and SOW 2.17.3. For GFTSS, NASA Is responsible the visiting vehicle delta-certification costs but did not include that cost in the GFTSS pricing in Table L-08.1.1 as it will be covered under a separate contract. The CLD Provider is responsible for their Destination costs for delta certification for previously certified vehicles. Offeror should not include any launch or transportation vehicle delta certification costs in their pricing if GFTSS is requested.
42. SOW 2.17.1 (Attachment J-01, p. 38) makes the Contractor responsible for identifying and performing delta certification, and L.17.3.1 TA.2(4) asks offerors to include estimated delta certification costs in their end-to-end pricing. For GFTSS missions, however, NASA acquires the transportation service through its own contracts (CLDP- PLN-2000 Rev A §6.1, p. 52), and L.17.2(d)(4) excludes GFTSS costs from Section B.
Some vehicle-side deltas come from CLDP requirements that apply to the visiting vehicle regardless of Destination. One example is [R.CLDS.778] (CLDP-REQ-1130 Rev D, p. 88), which requires the CVV and CaVV to meet CLDP-STD-1170 (C3DL). For a previously certified vehicle provided under GFTSS, please confirm whether the offeror should include the cost of vehicle-side modification and delta certification needed to meet such common requirements in its CLIN 2 pricing (Attachment L-07, "Delta Certification - Crew/Cargo Vehicle"), or whether NASA will address that cost through its transportation contracts.
If GFTSS is requested for the first four missions, NASA is responsible for the delta certification costs of the visiting vehicle provider for those vehicles utilized as part of GFTSS. The Contractor always remains responsible for any delta certification costs associated with work for the Destination.
43. Will NASA please provide additional clarification about how GFTSS delta certification scope and pricing is to be handled in the proposal? Our understanding is that proposals should include explanation and pricing for GFTSS delta-certification activities given the
P a g e 17 | 77
SOW requirement "For missions which utilizes GFTSS, the Contractor shall develop and complete an integration and test campaign with concurrence of NASA and Transportation provider required to support verification of mission specific requirements and/or delta-certification.” However, we also note Q&A Round #3 question #158 states: “NOTE: If GFTSS is utilized during the first four missions, NASA will be responsible for delta certification of those flights." What are the bounds for NASA scope versus Contractor scope for GFTSS delta-certification? And is our interpretation correct that the Contractor responsibility for delta-certification should be explained and priced into our proposal?
NASA is responsible for working with the transportation partner on the visiting vehicle delta certification costs associated with GFTSS but the Contractor is still responsible for certification requirements on the Destination side and should price costs related to work needed on the Destination side.
44. For the guaranteed Cargo and Crew GFTSS associated with the first four Mission
Service Order increments, what provider-level contracting instrument will NASA use, when will NASA select the Cargo and Crew provider, and how far in advance of the first required launch does NASA expect to authorize vehicle production, launch procurement, CLD-specific modifications, and delta certification?
NASA will determine outside of this procurement the appropriate mechanism for GFTSS and will work with current providers to determine appropriate timelines, schedules, and delta certification assumptions. NASA will have adequate data (interfaces, timelines, assumptions, etc.) from the Destination prime contractor to ensure there is compatibility with the GFTSS selection.
45. For Table L-08.1.1, is the Launch vehicle cost included? Do costs in the table assume GFE NASA launches with bulk buys of launch vehicles, or does it assume a fully commercial procurement on the other side of the GF Transportation cost. i.e. can you provide insight into how that table was created and the assumptions. If not, would NASA consider a bulk buy of launch vehicles and/or assessing assumptions on which launch vehicle?
We recommend launch assumptions being provided for the table (i.e. are launch vehicle costs included?). We also recommend that NASA consider a bulk buy of launch vehicles to reduce transportation costs and improve launch vehicle availability.
NASA has developed a normalized pricing for GFTSS in order to protect specific Commercial Provider pricing and does not necessarily constitute the actual prices
P a g e 18 | 77
NASA will negotiate in the future. This includes the full transportation service including launch, transportation and the services outlined in SOW, Section 2.17.3.1. NASA recognizes future transportation capabilities may differ from this table and actual GFTSS offering may be different. Differences will be negotiated post award during CLIN 3 Mission services discussions when the actual vehicles and their capabilities are committed.
46. For Attachment L-08, given that the same pricing is provided for either Type 1 or Type 2 cargo, how is pricing assessed for vehicles that can provide both Type 1 and Type 2 capability (i.e. Up, Return, and Trash cargo) within a single launch?
We recommend adding a line to Table L-08.1.1 for a mission that provides both Type 1 and Type 2 cargo.
NASA recognizes future transportation capabilities may differ from this table and actual GFTSS offering may be different. Offerors should assume the capabilities as defined in L-08 and determine the number and types of vehicles needed accordingly. Differences will be negotiated post award during CLIN 3 Mission services discussions when the actual vehicles and their capabilities are committed.
47. For Table L-08.2.1, given the statement "The Contractor Cargo allocation shall be 50% of the total capacity", does this mean the pricing in Table L-08.1.1 assumes only half of the capabilities in Table L-08.2.1? i.e. For Type 1 cargo, does Table L-08.1.1 assume capability for 8 or 4 powered lockers?
NASA has clarified this requirement in Amendment 1. The pricing in table L-08.1.1 represents the total price of the vehicle. The capabilities in L-08.2.1 represent the vehicles’ total capabilities.
In accordance with SOW Section 3.4.1, NASA would expect to utilize a minimum of 50% of the powered locker locations for 2 USG Crew (4 powered locker locations), 65% if there are 3 USG Crew (5 powered locker locations) and 75% if there are 4 USG Crew (6 powered locker locations).
48. GFTSS pricing table has costs for transportation missions in CY28 and CY29, is that based on transportation mission ILC and not when mission is ordered? What cargo Type 2 options can be available in CY28?
All Mission Service prices are based on the year flown. All Vehicles can be requested starting in CY28.
P a g e 19 | 77
49. NASA provided GFTSS has a guarantee to provide 2 crew transportation mission and 4 cargo transportation missions per year for the first 4 ordered increment missions. This guarantee is important for investor confidence in closing a business case if a transportation provider knows these are procurements of US based transportation providers. Will NASA confirm that these guaranteed missions are new procurements of US based vehicles? Or is it possible that NASA might fulfill part of this guarantee with an International Partner based vehicle via an interagency barter arrangement?
NASA reserves the right to utilize new procurements of previously certified vehicles or International Partner vehicles available to NASA.
50. What are the associated milestones after GFTSS delta-DCR for CLDS? It is understood that these milestones will be owned / facilitated by NASA and the GFTSS provider but it is expected that the CLD Contractor would participate in most if not all of them. What is the breakout of roles and responsibilities for the CTS mission workplan milestones (VBR, MIR, MCR, etc.) between NASA, the CLD, and the transportation provider when GFTSS is provided? This is important for CLDs to plan associated scope for ensuring GFTSS mission integration with the CLD.
Milestones after any DCR lead into the Mission Integration milestones (i.e. ORR, FRR, LRR, etc.). NASA expects the CLDC contractor to participate in GFTSS NASA led transportation milestones including the CTS mission workplan milestones (VBR, MIR, MCR, etc.) to facilitate the integration of the transportation vehicle with the Destination.
The CLDC contractor will be responsible for Attachment J-01 Statement of Work items defined in Section 2.17 Transportation.
51. Should Dragon be accounted for in station designs as a potential GFTSS provided crew or Type 2 cargo transportation service?
Yes, Dragon should still be considered as a potential GFTSS option both for crew and cargo.
52. "SOW 2.17.3.1 Support Services delineates a significant amount of scope for which the Contractor is responsible when GFTSS is used for transportation (support services during pre-launch, post-launch, and crew rescue). We have the following questions:
(a) Is the Contractor responsible for these support services for all GFTSS missions, including the first four guaranteed by NASA?
P a g e 20 | 77
Yes, the Contractor is responsible for the support services identified as “the Contractor shall provide” when NASA is providing GFTSS, including the GFTSS is provided for the first four missions.
(b) Is the Offeror expected to include the cost for these support services in its pricing to NASA, in addition to the GFTSS per-flight price provided by NASA in Attachment L-01 and Attachment L-08?
Yes, NASA has identified what services will still be the Contractors responsibilities under GFTSS. The Contractor should include the cost of providing those services when pricing its Mission Service pricing.
(c) Many of the identified Contractor support services are currently provided by the transportation service company in the CRS and CCtCap models. Is it NASA's intention that the Contractor will be responsible for providing these support services either by itself or by negotiating with the GFTSS transportation company separately from NASA?
For services that remain the Contractor’s responsibility under GFTSS, the Contractor can determine the best way to provide these services either through subcontracting with the GFTSS provider or through internal means.
(d) To simplify the scope and ensure equivalent assumptions among Offerors, will NASA consider including the pricing for support services in the overall GFTSS per-flight price, at least for the first four GFTSS missions?"
No, NASA did not update this requirement in the Amendment 1. The support services remaining under the Contractor responsibility have been specifically identified, and they may require knowledge and/or significant integration with each CLD provider’s processes, therefore standardized pricing may not be applicable.
53. Please identify the cost scope included in the Cargo Type 2 value in Table L-08.1.1:
vehicle production, launch service, launch integration, mission operations, cargo processing/integration, CLD interface modifications, delta certification, powered-cargo accommodations, disposal operations, and post-flight products. Which of these costs are separately funded or provided by the CLDP?
The scope NASA plans to contract for with GFTSS providers represents the current CCtCap and CRS contract scope to perform standard transportation services and includes support services as outlined in SOW Section 2.17.3.1
P a g e 21 | 77
54. RFP Section L.17.3.2 MS SUBFACTOR 2 – MANAGEMENT APPROACH (MA), TA.2 Certification & Engineering Approach states: "The Offeror shall describe their approach for certification of visiting vehicles and operations." Please confirm that the Offeror will be responsible for certifying visiting vehicles, including those on which NASA payloads and/or crew may be flying.
The Offeror is responsible for delta certification of previously certified visiting vehicles unless provided under GFTSS. If GFTSS is provided on the first four missions, NASA will be responsible for the delta certification of the visiting vehicle side of the interface and visiting vehicle costs. The Contractor will remain responsible for visiting vehicle certification work associated with the destination side of the interface.
55. RFP Attachment J-15 Government Furnished Transportation and Support Services - Under what conditions does NASA envision electing to provide such support? How will price of such services be evaluated vs commercial alternatives?
The conditions for NASA providing the GFTSS are outlined in Attachment L-08, Government Furnished Transportation and Support Services (GFTSS). NASA has offered to provide GFTSS with guaranteed GFTSS for the first four missions if requested.
Transportation pricing that is offered lowered than the GFTSS pricing will also be evaluated in Section M, TA.1 System Architecture.
56. RFP Attachment L-08 GFTSS Pricing Instructions, Table L-08.2.1 Crew and Cargo Vehicle Capabilities description - “When…
This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .