44F2C847-DCDE-D822-A4337D82DBDE228F.xlsx

XLSX spreadsheet 34 KB Posted

Attached to
Air Compressor System for Toxicology
Solicitation number
ITB 2026-49-11
Issued by
Franklin County, Ohio

About this file

This file is a Benefit Program Comparison Variances document for Franklin County Cooperative's RFP 2025-06-09, detailing the differences between current and proposed health insurance benefit plans across multiple employee categories. The document outlines comparison matrices for six distinct employee groups: Hourly HMO, New Hire Hourly HMO, Salaried HMO, Salaried PPO HDHP, Salaried Student PPO, and Student HMO. Each section presents a structured format identifying specific benefit categories where variances exist between the current plan and proposed plan alternatives, with space for client decision documentation. The document notes that additional variances may emerge during the implementation review process and acknowledges that if Summary Plan Descriptions were not provided during the proposal process, the document may not capture all benefit variances.

The identified variances include critical differences in pharmacy coverage, mental health services, and substance abuse treatment. For the Hourly HMO groups, the proposed plan limits preferred specialty drugs to 30-day supplies with maximum 15-day limits on some drugs, compared to the current plan's 34-day and 60-90-day supplies. Additionally, the proposed plan cannot accommodate the current mental health and substance abuse benefit structure, specifically the tiered outpatient visit copay process (100% for visits 1-20, $20 copay thereafter) and the inpatient deductible waiver for visits 1-45. The proposed carrier has flagged potential non-compliance with Mental Health Parity requirements. The document also includes a separate Scope of Work Deviations section for Disability and Voluntary Programs, providing vendors space to identify any modifications to the county's current scope of work requirements.

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
F13E338C-C030-4C55-2FE32EE64813CA9E.docx DOCX document
0D016D70-E47F-20E8-0F04921174A75D50.pdf PDF
E99102BF-B146-146D-35DFAF9763C1170B.pdf PDF
9AEA49E5-D258-E830-CAAB03DD9BBE7883.pdf PDF
4ADB9154-92D0-FA39-8C51818579A9E699.pdf PDF
A468A6C0-ADFF-A361-D0B6A6D23BE37251.pdf PDF
471F0983-EB69-959C-3B62A289547CA11E.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
4491B391-0B2C-57F1-169E865F334A5FAD.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
56D200B6-A79A-5846-53B374D48289713F.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
441C7CE8-FE79-FFAD-86876E5C9E330E9F.pdf PDF
D1C75C4E-ACBE-A700-94A3260C246A50BF.pdf PDF
600AF88E-C800-4399-20BE9FDE4A50714B.docx DOCX document
7D243EA3-FAAD-CF0C-AFFD3FFE55D5912C.pdf PDF
48FFA356-A619-FDBE-4B4D833D8E7B2589.pdf PDF
44F28715-E1AF-A884-828CBEAF47CBA5D7.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
47A070EA-AA3B-485A-6C240303241C99D2.pdf PDF
47649CE8-A0E3-2433-AC9846884D7DA4C4.pdf PDF
E990A518-E8F3-4318-3125803AC770B0DD.pdf PDF
4ADC3DEA-9D5B-9827-C369A2B1FCFC62A9.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
C0135AC1-FF9D-F3AC-BDB7FB4697056E65.pdf PDF
471F2B18-FADB-16E3-6A13A124C82D15B3.pdf PDF
47B899A6-E73C-31FA-C552C2E2911070DF.pdf PDF
BCCA0BAC-C5BA-CDB6-49D2EFF559EDAF11.pdf PDF
8BE169B1-0EA5-67F3-FE8D32CD74B2BC3C.pdf PDF
E920A267-FB29-7597-A525F8234B855C09.pdf PDF
BEA8591A-F056-8D68-013C92A00C2DA843.pdf PDF
8B0111A9-AB26-EF6C-1377B5BEC77C1480.pdf PDF
260F9701-94BA-EFEA-FCAED968AC730EE0.docx DOCX document
A468D9BE-C742-A53B-A0E51044FC47530E.pdf PDF
8B00ECA9-D368-AD09-80DA20EDC1915543.pdf PDF
48FFE6B8-C249-DC8C-BA6A621BAD5FF49F.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
9705A9CE-B76B-3514-2AB6D46F5013FD96.pdf PDF
1FF70774-E56E-EAC8-88A7694DAF5EB82C.pdf PDF
56D1E25C-D6F7-A070-782594700401C348.docx DOCX document
1FF7F5A5-B656-F561-D618C609C0908F61.pdf PDF
1FF79148-03D3-7B1B-77CF64FD687ECA4C.pdf PDF
9EDCD8B0-B36E-8610-B9A1060DE4F7BDD1.pdf PDF
4703BAFF-A637-A4BC-D31224A6D85981B6.pdf PDF
1FF6D412-D5CF-E3DA-42373990EB63A4DE.docx DOCX document
4ADC54F2-C74F-3F02-B4900398FFBEE5A5.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
BEA8B132-08B9-5848-83E1018BFD8D09C5.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
47647B12-EF69-CBAE-3877E615229CE346.pdf PDF
98B00E89-F3C2-2215-1B6B7A585EA6B903.pdf PDF
4ADC0CC3-B76B-A18D-C62DDED0F769FB5E.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
44A3FAEC-97F9-FAD6-B54F90D5CEDD52DA.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
1FF8629C-E097-4138-B3B7BE56C0FCD3F5.pdf PDF
4ADBF0DE-FA15-F6CB-0B2B1FFF2D166DEF.pdf PDF
A46910BC-E967-DD22-10B71BADEA153824.docx DOCX document
1FF7330C-CAC3-999B-9E6EF28469A04621.pdf PDF
98C3F6F7-A2E4-2584-EE8EB79AF1AA8052.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
Show 40 more

Latest 50 of 142 listed here. See the rest on GovTribe.

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Hourly HMO

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1Preferred Specialty DrugsAllow 34 day supply some 60 - 90 day supplyLimited to 30 day supply, with 15 limit max on some specialty drugs
2Mental Health & Substance Abuse Outpatient ServicesVisits 1-20 process at 100%, Visits 21 and greater apply $20 copayCannot accommodate. Based on Payment Policy and group may not be Mental Health Parity Compliant.
3Mental Health & Substance Abuse Inpatient ServicesDeductible does not apply for first 1-45 visits, Ded & Coin applies visits 46 and greaterCannot accommodate. Based on Payment Policy and group may not be Mental Health Parity Compliant.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Scope of Work Deviations

Franklin County Cooperative - RFP 2025-06-09 Disability and Voluntary Programs RFP
Scope of Work Deviations
Please note any deviations from the County’s current Scope of Work.

All deviations from the Scope of Work must be identified and confirmed. If awarded the contract, vendor will be required to provide all programs, services and insurance lines that currently are provided unless identified in the following plan deviations document.

Current Scope of Work Element Proposed Scope of Work Modification

Samplee.g. Produce electronic W-2s at the agency level at no coste.g. Can only provide W-2s at an agency level for an additional cost
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30

New Hire Hourly HMO

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1Preferred Specialty DrugsAllow 34 day supply some 60 - 90 day supplyLimited to 30 day supply, with 15 limit max on some specialty drugs
2Mental Health & Substance Abuse Outpatient ServicesVisits 1-20 process at 100%, Visits 21 and greater apply $20 copayCannot accommodate. Based on Payment Policy and group may not be Mental Health Parity Compliant.
3Mental Health & Substance Abuse Inpatient ServicesDeductible does not apply for first 1-45 visits, Ded & Coin applies visits 46 and greaterCannot accommodate. Based on Payment Policy and group may not be Mental Health Parity Compliant.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Salaried HMO

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Salaried PPO HDHP

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Salaried Student PPO

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Student HMO

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

Sheet7

BENEFIT PROGRAM COMPARISON VARIANCES
RFP Request
Following is an outline of the variances/alternatives between the current and proposed benefit programs for -
GROUP NAME

Please note: Additional variances may become evident during the implementation review process. If the current carrier documents (Summary Plan Descriptions) were not provided during the proposal process, this document may not encompass all benefit variances.

Benefit Current Plan Proposed Plan Client Decision

Medical Policy variations are not included in the scope of this document. Medical Policy information is proprietary, not shared among carriers and it is not included in this aspect of benefit administration comparisons.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .