1._Limited_Asbestos_Survey_B110.pdf

Binghamton ♦ Canton ♦ Elmira ♦ Plattsburgh ♦ Poughkeepsie ♦ Rochester ♦ Syracuse ♦ Utica ♦ Watertown

Albany 22 Corporate Drive Clifton Park, NY 12065 518-383-9144 (T) atlantictesting.com

ATLANTIC TESTING LABORATORIES

WBE certified company

March 14, 2019

QPK Design 450 South Salina Street, Room 500 Syracuse, New York 13201

Attn: Mr. David McNeil, AIA

Re: Limited Asbestos Survey The Big Gun Shop Building 110- Watervliet Arsenal Watervliet, New York ATL Report No. AT5536AI-01-03-19

Ladies/Gentlemen:

Enclosed is a copy of the Limited Asbestos Survey report prepared for the referenced site. This project was completed in accordance with the scope of work outlined in our contract (ATL No.

AT5998-044-01-19), dated January 22, 2019, and authorized by David McNeil on January 24, 2019.

Please contact our office should you have any questions, or if we may be of further assistance.

Sincerely, ATLANTIC TESTING LABORATORIES, Limited

Tina M. Prouty Project Manager

TMP/JDG/tg

WBE certified company

LIMITED ASBESTOS SURVEY

THE BIG GUN SHOP BUILDING 110 - WATERVLIET ARSENAL

WATERVLIET, NEW YORK

ATL REPORT NO. AT5336AI-01-03-19

PREPARED BY:

ATLANTIC TESTING LABORATORIES, LIMITED

22 Corporate Drive

Clifton Park, New York 12065

PREPARED FOR:

QPK Design, LLP 450 South Salina Street, Room 500

Syracuse, New York 13201

ATL REPORT NO. AT5536AI-01-03-19

March 14, 2019

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Purpose

1.2 Project Team and Certifications

2.0 SCOPE OF WORK

2.1 Project Description

2.2 Inaccessible Areas

2.3 Document Review

2.4 Limitations

3.0 ASBESTOS

3.1 Methodology

3.2 Regulatory Compliance

3.3 Summary of Findings

4.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

4.1 General

4.2 Asbestos-Containing Materials

APPENDICES

Licenses and Certifications ........................................................................................................ A Sample Location Plans .............................................................................................................. B Laboratory Reports and Custody Documentation ....................................................................... C Summary Tables ........................................................................................................................ D Arcadis US, Inc. Documentation ............................................................................................ E

The Big Gun Shop Building 110 – Watervliet Arsenal, Watervliet, New York March 14, 2019 ATL Report No. AT5536AI-01-03-19

1.0 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Purpose

Atlantic Testing Laboratories, Limited (ATL) was retained by QPK Design, LLP, to perform a limited asbestos survey of designated areas within The Big Gun Shop Building 110 at the Watervliet Arsenal, located at 1 Buffington Street, Watervliet, New York. The limited survey was performed on February 8 through February 19, 2019. The purpose of the limited asbestos survey was to identify asbestos-containing materials (ACM) that are present on exposed surfaces within the subject areas, and may have a significant impact on planned renovation activities. The limited asbestos survey procedures and report format that follow are in general compliance with applicable local, state, and federal rules and regulations.

1.2 Project Team and Certifications

Members of the ATL project team included Tina Prouty, Project Manager; Tina Ganter, Environmental Technician; and Brian Babcock, Environmental Specialist. Certifications of ATL's field survey team members and a copy of applicable company licenses maintained by ATL are included in Appendix A.

2.0 SCOPE OF WORK

2.1 Project Description

The project site is located at 1 Buffington Street, Watervliet, Albany County, New York.

The intent of the limited asbestos survey was to identify suspect ACM that are located within designated areas of the subject building and may be impacted during a proposed renovation project. The limited asbestos survey was conducted for the subject areas, as directed by David McNeil, representing QPK Design, LLP. The roof system, external brick masonry, and east and west window systems were not included in this survey event as directed by representatives of QPK Design. The subject areas were occupied and operational at the time of the sampling event.

2.2 Inaccessible Areas

The extent of inaccessible areas is dependent upon the building type, construction materials, history of renovations and repairs, and project scope. Concealed materials may exist in areas that are not readily exposed to view. Although this limited asbestos survey was performed to identify ACM within the subject areas, potential ACM may have escaped detection that could be encountered during future building demolition and/or renovation activities. Wall, ceiling, floor, and/or other component systems may contain concealed suspect ACM. If any suspect ACM is encountered during demolition and/or renovation activities, the activities disturbing the suspect ACM must stop and the material must be sampled and laboratory analyzed in accordance with applicable regulations.

2.3 Document Review

Documents that were provided to ATL for review during the limited asbestos survey included documentation of previous ACM and Lead Based Paint analysis, dated December 6, 2018, provided by Arcadis US, Inc.

2.4 Limitations

This report has been prepared in accordance with the scope of work outlined in ATL’s contract (ATL No. AT5998-044-01-19), dated January 22, 2019, and should not be used as abatement specifications or design documents. The findings, conclusions, and recommendations presented in this report are based on the field observations made by representatives of ATL and the information provided by representatives of QPK Design, LLP.

Quantities and locations of sampled materials are approximate, and should be verified by the abatement contractor(s) prior to providing actual cost quotations and/or initiating abatement activities. Variations in reported quantities and locations for sampled materials, in addition to the discovery of suspect materials not identified in this report, is possible due to the presence of inaccessible areas, as described in Section 2.2 of this report.

The findings and opinions are relevant to the dates of our site work and should not be relied on to represent conditions at substantially later dates.

3.0 ASBESTOS

3.1 Methodology

A visual examination of the subject areas was conducted by an Asbestos Building Inspector to identify suspect ACM. Functional spaces were identified to assist while locating suspect ACM.

A functional space is defined as a spatially distinct area within a building that contains identifiable populations of building occupants. A functional space may include a room, a group of rooms, or other defined area, and several functional spaces may comprise a single homogeneous sampling area. A homogeneous sampling area is defined as an area that is uniform by color, texture, construction/application, and general appearance. Each identified functional space was visually examined to determine the locations of suspect ACM. These materials were then delineated into homogeneous sampling areas.

Samples of each accessible homogeneous area were collected and placed in clean, labeled containers. The appropriate custody documentation was completed and the suspect ACM samples were submitted to AmeriSci New York (AmeriSci), located in New York, New York.

The samples were laboratory analyzed by polarized light microscopy (PLM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) methodologies, as applicable. AmeriSci is a New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) certified laboratory for PLM and TEM analysis under Environmental Laboratory Approval Program (ELAP) No. 11480. AmeriSci is also accredited by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), under the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP).

3.2 Regulatory Compliance

In New York State, there are multiple regulatory agencies that have jurisdiction over ACM in buildings. Asbestos survey requirements are primarily regulated or specified by the New York State Department of Labor (NYSDOL), the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH), the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

The NYSDOL established Part 56 of The Official Compilation of Codes, Rules, and Regulations (cited as 12 NYCRR, Part 56) to address the proper identification, handling, removal, and disposal of ACM in buildings. Asbestos survey requirements are specified in Subpart 56-5.1 “Asbestos Survey Requirements for Building/Structure Demolition, Renovation, Remodeling and Repair.” The NYSDOL also works in conjunction with the NYSDOH to establish and maintain asbestos safety training program requirements, and enforce personnel certifications and licensing protocol for asbestos contractors.

The OSHA defines requirements for asbestos surveys and identification of ACM and presumed asbestos-containing materials (PACM) in 29 CFR 1926.1101 (k) “Communication of Hazards.”

Under this regulation, OSHA makes reference to conducting inspections according to

1926.1101 (k)(5)(ii)(B) and 1926.1101 (k)(5)(iii) or pursuant to the requirements of the Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA) 40 CFR Part 763, Subpart E “Asbestos-Containing Materials in Schools.” The AHERA is regulated by the EPA, and applies to primary and secondary schools only; however, the procedures mandated under AHERA are generally considered the industry standards for surveys, as these are typically the most stringent.

3.3 Summary of Findings

A total of 106 homogeneous areas of suspect ACM were identified during the visual examination, from which 104 bulk samples were collected and subsequently submitted to a NYSDOH approved laboratory for analysis. Approximate sample locations are depicted on the Sample Location Plans, contained in Appendix B. A copy of laboratory reports and sample custody documentation are contained in Appendix C. Table D-I, contained in Appendix D, provides a summary of the identified suspect ACM and associated analytical results.

The EPA, NYSDOL, and other regulatory agencies define ACM as any material containing greater than 1% of asbestos. Materials listed in bold font in Table D-I of Appendix D were determined or assumed to be ACM.

Materials containing trace asbestos (i.e., less than 1%) are not considered ACM; however, OSHA recognizes materials that contain trace amounts of asbestos, and requires these materials be handled in accordance with their standard interpretation letter titled “Requirements for demolition operations involving material containing <1% asbestos “, dated August 13, 1999.

As shown in Table D-I of Appendix D, 4 materials were determined to contain trace amounts of asbestos.

Other materials that were observed, but are not considered suspect ACM, include the following;

• Glass • Nylon-Coated Wire Jacket

• Wood • Metal

• Ceramic Tile • Wooden Doors

4.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

The following conclusions and recommendations are prepared from ATL’s understanding that the subject building may be subject to renovation projects. Should the management of the building areas change, it is recommended that the findings be revisited to reflect appropriate operations and management practices for hazardous materials containing items.

4.1 General

1. Concealed regulated hazardous materials may exist at the site that could be encountered during future building renovation activities. Wall, ceiling, floor, roofing, and/or other component systems may contain concealed suspect hazardous materials. If any suspect hazardous materials or hazardous materials-containing items are encountered during demolition and/or renovation activities, the activities disturbing the suspect material must stop and the material must be sampled and laboratory analyzed or otherwise managed pursuant to in accordance with applicable regulations.

4.2 Asbestos-Containing Materials

1. The materials listed in bold in Table D-I of Appendix D were determined or assumed to be

ACM. The referenced table also shows materials that contain trace concentrations of asbestos and are regulated under OSHA.

2. Subpart 56-5(h) of 12 NYCRR Part 56 requires that no demolition, renovation, remodeling, or repair work be commenced by any owner or the owner’s agent prior to the completion of asbestos abatement. Asbestos abatement must be performed by an asbestos abatement contractor that maintains a current asbestos handling license, and employs NYSDOL certified asbestos handlers and supervisors. It is recommended that a 12 NYCRR 56 certified Project Monitor oversee abatement activities.

3. Subpart 56-5(g) of 12 NYCRR Part 56 specifies requirements for transmittal of asbestos survey information by the owner or owner’s agent. One copy of the asbestos survey report shall be sent to the local government entity charged with issuing a permit for such demolition, renovation, remodeling, or repair work under applicable State or local laws. If controlled demolition or pre-demolition activities will be performed, one copy of the asbestos survey report shall be submitted to the appropriate Asbestos Control Bureau district office.

One copy of the asbestos survey report must be kept on the construction site throughout the duration of the asbestos project and any associated demolition, renovation, remodeling, or repair project.

A

APPENDIX A

LICENSES AND CERTIFICATIONS

Asbestos Certificate Code Classifications The following letter codes shown on the enclosed asbestos certificates represent the corresponding asbestos classifications:

A - Asbestos Handler F - Operations & Maintenance B - Allied Trades G - Asbestos Supervisor C - Air Sampling Technician H - Asbestos Project Monitor D - Building Inspector I - Asbestos Project Designer E - Management Planner

New York State – Department of Labor Division of Safety and Health License and Certificate Unit State Campus, Building 12

Albany, NY 12240

ASBESTOS HANDLING LICENSE

Atlantic Testing Laboratories, Limited

P.O. Box 29

Canton, NY 13617

FILE NUMBER: 99-0911

LICENSE NUMBER: 29276

LICENSE CLASS: RESTRICTED

DATE OF ISSUE: 10/31/2018

EXPIRATION DATE: 10/31/2019

Duly Authorized Representative – Marijean B Remington:

This license has been issued in accordance with applicable provisions of Article 30 of the Labor Law of New York State and of the New York State Codes, Rules and Regulations (12 NYCRR Part 56). It is subject to suspension or revocation for a (1) serious violation of state, federal or local laws with regard to the conduct of an asbestos project, or (2) demonstrated lack of responsibility in the conduct of any job involving asbestos or asbestos material.

This license is valid only for the contractor named above and this license or a photocopy must be prominently displayed at the asbestos project worksite. This license verifies that all persons employed by the licensee on an asbestos project in New York State have been issued an Asbestos Certificate, appropriate for the type of work they perform, by the New York State Department of Labor.

Eileen M. Franko, Director SH 432 (8/12) For the Commissioner of Labor

B

APPENDIX B

SAMPLE LOCATION PLANS

ASBESTOS KEY NOTES :

Light Gray Window Glazing

Partial First Floor Sample Location Plan - South

Scale: NTS

Drawing: Project No.: Date :

Albany, NY

Plattsburgh, NY

Canton, NY

Watertown, NY

Poughkeepsie, NY

Syracuse, NY

Elmira, NY

Utica, NY

Binghamton, NY

Rochester, NY

Drawn By:

March 2019

SAMPLE LOCATION PLAN

__ of __

Watervliet Arsenal

The Big Gun Shop Building 110

Watervliet, New York www.AtlanticTesting.com

Scale:

As Noted1 4

WBE Certified Company

JDF AT5536

Tan 1-Inch and 2-Inch TSI Pipe Jacket

AT5536AI97A

AT5536AI97B

AT5536AI98A

AT5536AI98B

AT5536AI99A

AT5536AI99B

AT5536AI13A

AT5536AI13B

AT5536AI08A

AT5536AI08B

AT5536AI08C

AT5536AI44A

AT5536AI45A

AT5536AI46A

AT5536AI47A

AT5536AI48A

AT5536AI48B

AT5536AI49A

AT5536AI49B

AT5536AI52A

AT5536AI52B

AT5536AI52C

AT5536AI53A

AT5536AI53B

AT5536AI53C

AT5536AI56A

AT5536AI57A

AT5536AI58A

AT5536AI58B

AT5536AI07A

AT5536AI07B

AT5536AI56B

AT5536AI57B

AT5536AI39B

AT5536AI15C

AT5536AI42A

AT5536AI42B

AT5536AI17A

AT5536AI17B

AT5536AI17C

AT5536AI18A

AT5536AI18B

AT5536AI18C

LEGEND :

Suspect Asbestos Sample ID and Approximate Location

AT5536AI01A

ATL Room Designation for Labeling Purposes

A

White Pipe TSI associated with Tan 1-Inch and 2-Inch

TSI Pipe Jacket

White Window Overlap Caulk

Off-White Interior Window Glazing

Gray Door Frame Caulk

Partial First Floor Sample Location Plan - Center

Scale: NTS

Drawing: Project No.: Date :

Albany, NY

Plattsburgh, NY

Canton, NY

Watertown, NY

Poughkeepsie, NY

Syracuse, NY

Elmira, NY

Utica, NY

Binghamton, NY

Rochester, NY

Drawn By:

March 2019

SAMPLE LOCATION PLAN

__ of __

Watervliet Arsenal

The Big Gun Shop Building 110

Watervliet, New York www.AtlanticTesting.com

Scale:

As Noted2 4

WBE Certified Company

JDF AT5536

Dark Red and Black Checker Pattern 12- by 12-Inch Floor

Tile

AT5536AI12A

AT5536AI54A

AT5536AI61A

AT5536AI61B

AT5536AI62A

AT5536AI62B

AT5536AI63A

AT5536AI63B

AT5536AI64A

AT5536AI64B

AT5536AI67A

AT5536AI39A

AT5536AI54B

AT5536AI65A

AT5536AI66A

AT5536AI67B

AT5536AI104A

AT5536AI104B

AT5536AI41A

AT5536AI41B

AT5536AI41C

AT5536AI40A

AT5536AI40B

AT5536AI38A

AT5536AI38B

AT5536AI95A

AT5536AI95B

AT5536AI65B

AT5536AI66B

AT5536AI70A

AT5536AI70B

AT5536AI71A

AT5536AI71B

AT5536AI72A

AT5536AI72B

AT5536AI73A

AT5536AI73B

AT5536AI105A

AT5536AI105B

AT5536AI12B

AT5536AI68A

AT5536AI69A

AT5536AI87A

AT5536AI106A

AT5536AI106B

AT5536AI76A

AT5536AI77A

AT5536AI44B

AT5536AI45B

AT5536AI46B

AT5536AI47B

AT5536AI75A

AT5536AI75B

AT5536AI107A

AT5536AI107B

AT5536AI108A

AT5536AI108B

AT5536AI76B

AT5536AI77B

AT5536AI90A

AT5536AI90B

AT5536AI91A

AT5536AI91B

AT5536AI74A

AT5536AI74B

AT5536AI109A

AT5536AI109B

AT5536AI78B

AT5536AI85B

AT5536AI68B

AT5536AI69B

AT5536AI81B

AT5536AI87A

AT5536AI78A

AT5536AI79A

AT5536AI79B

AT5536AI80A

AT5536AI80B

LEGEND :

Suspect Asbestos Sample ID and Approximate Location

AT5536AI01A

ATL Room Designation for Labeling Purposes

A

Note: Closet 114C was homogeneous to Room 114 and sampled accordingly.

Black Mastic Associated with Dark Red and Black

Checker Pattern 12- by 12-Inch Floor Tile

Dark Red 9- by 9-Inch Marbled Floor Tile

Yellow 9- by 9-Inch Sub-Floor Tile

Tan with Orange Streaks 9- by 9-Inch Floor Tile

Gray Window Perimeter Caulk

White 12- by 12-Inch Mottle Floor Tile

Black Mastic Associated with White 12- by 12-Inch Mottle

Floor Tile

14 15

Black Floor Filler Associated with Black with Light Gray

Mottled 12- by 12-Inch Floor Tile

Partial First Floor Sample Location Plan - North

Scale: NTS

Drawing: Project No.: Date :

Albany, NY

Plattsburgh, NY

Canton, NY

Watertown, NY

Poughkeepsie, NY

Syracuse, NY

Elmira, NY

Utica, NY

Binghamton, NY

Rochester, NY

Drawn By:

March 2019

SAMPLE LOCATION PLAN

__ of __

Watervliet Arsenal

The Big Gun Shop Building 110

Watervliet, New York www.AtlanticTesting.com

Scale:

As Noted3 4

WBE Certified Company

JDF AT5536

AT5536AI25A

AT5536AI25B

AT5536AI92A

AT5536AI92B

AT5536AI110A

AT5536AI110B

AT5536AI20A

AT5536AI81A

AT5536AI94B

AT5536AI20B

AT5536AI24A

AT5536AI24B

AT5536AI22A

AT5536AI22B

AT5536AI22C

AT5536AI23A

AT5536AI23B

AT5536AI23C

AT5536AI20C

AT5536AI24C

AT5536AI26A

AT5536AI27A

AT5536AI29A

AT5536AI29B

AT5536AI29C

AT5536AI30A

AT5536AI30B

AT5536AI27B

AT5536AI35A

AT5536AI35B

AT5536AI96A

AT5536AI96B

AT5536AI94A

AT5536AI31A

AT5536AI31B

AT5536AI100A

AT5536AI100B

AT5536AI101A

AT5536AI101B

AT5536AI102A

AT5536AI102B

AT5536AI103A

AT5536AI103B

AT5536AI32A

AT5536AI32B

AT5536AI15A

AT5536AI15B

AT5536AI26B

AT5536AI33A

AT5536AI33B

AT5536AI34A

AT5536AI34B

LEGEND :

Suspect Asbestos Sample ID and Approximate Location

AT5536AI01A

ATL Room Designation for Labeling Purposes

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

Second Floor Sample Location Plan

Scale: NTS

Drawing: Project No.: Date :

Albany, NY

Plattsburgh, NY

Canton, NY

Watertown, NY

Poughkeepsie, NY

Syracuse, NY

Elmira, NY

Utica, NY

Binghamton, NY

Rochester, NY

Drawn By:

March 2019

SAMPLE LOCATION PLAN

__ of __

Watervliet Arsenal

The Big Gun Shop Building 110

Watervliet, New York www.AtlanticTesting.com

Scale:

As Noted4 4

WBE Certified Company

JDF AT5536

LEGEND :

Suspect Asbestos Sample ID and Approximate Location

AT5536AI01A

ATL Room Designation for Labeling Purposes

A

AT5536AI83A

AT5536AI83B

AT5536AI85A

AT5536AI86A

AT5536AI86B

C

APPENDIX C

LABORATORY REPORTS AND CUSTODY DOCUMENTATION

AuenrScr

Atlantic Testing Laboratories, Attn: Tina Prouty

6431 US Higway 11

Canton, NY 13617

AmeriSci New York

1 17 EAST 3OTH ST.

NEWYORK, NY 10016

lEL: (212) 679-8600 . F M: (212) 679-3114

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Limited Date Received

Date Examined

ELAP #

RE: 4T5536; Big

03109119 AmeriSci Job # 219031960 03t10t19 P.O. # 19025 11480 Page 1 of 1

Green Shop Bldg. 110; Bldg. 110

Glient No. / HGA Lab No. Asbestos Present Total % Asbestos

4T5536AT12A

21 9031 960-01 Location: Rm 112- Tan Seam Tape

Tan/Brown, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 96 %, Non-fibrous 4 %

A/o NAD 7

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 03/10/19

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

AT5536AT128

21 9031 960-02 Location: Rm 114 - Tan Seam Tape

Tan/Brown, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 95 %, Non-fibrous 5 7o

IVo NAD (by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 03/10/19

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

Reporting Notes:

(l) This job was - Analygg:d usilg Motic BA3l0 Pol Scope S,4.1 1190000538

Analyzed by: Bo Sun ;[>C .\ .-'- "NAD/NSD =no asbestos det5cted; NA =not analyzed: NfuPS=not analyzed/positive stop, (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite;

(SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; PLM Bulk Asbestos Analysis by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 (NVLAP 200546-0), ELAP PLM Method 198.1 for NY friable samples, which includes the identification and quantitation of vermiculite or 198.6 for NOB samples or EPA 400 pt ct by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 (NY ELAP Lab 1 1480); Note:PLM is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor coverings and similar non-friable organically bound materials. NAD or Trace results by PLM are inconclusive, TEM is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non asbestos-containing in NY State (also see EPA Advisory for floor tile, FR 59,146,38970,8/1/94) National lnstitute of Standards and Technology Accreditation requirements mandate that this report must not be reproduced except in full without the approval of the lab.This PLM report relates ONLY to the items tested. AIHA-LAP, LLC Lab lD 102843, Rl Cert AAL-094, CT Cert PH-0186, Mass Cert A4000054.

Reviewed By: END OF REPORT

<v H8 urA io ooo

IE

Eo o fo{I

.E !o o E.

E6a t(5 dI tno o (Doo s att FEo

TL

(D iI (0 co E g c u.l o Eo

LL

id

E

.e, B E ar .U -F

*st\ ob(Do EEg E#q IJL.E e<i

=e!9v

= o'!5>o- H -9

I "9o io0&EnE;gtr (n q=o.:

Jr dr tr

@rt

F

.E+ d tr

N tr oz E trlF o N dt z J!.

o ooI z

I oD q, o o& ir,) c!\5 iO c-

S, t-gg

,=crlErlCil; -;;

Elfrf;$ slZ EsF

;ri B

3; e.

$a:$E sli ?r r

.* .s >;

g

Es^^ O H;E::E fl.:alIO al8 899o EF;;

IJJ O

E.

,,-g$ee El e>i*g;2{q elrgx;

91 r^fidtr3 fiIE?Ee sEEE

}G F-5ctlle^ 913> E E Et'! z j.;

dli EEt st gEcc ElEriI -El+ i .i "iI{E EF!:

;i hFl&

>oo s;;

,Er6 6 o6^^dkr

2fr9 d;d s

.gl,E Clls iDl E

-glt fx 8.,IF

OIJ

Etd d aAv t'{a Q t tr'l o

Iz l+{t*t U rq Fl& r=(a a M c)

FA

ac H0 E] FEa rtl t{ trIgI tF t)

Ea

N tr S

FI

tr oq *i U

F

FI

Ea

Nt\ t)!\!\ k !.1!\

D

APPENDIX D

SUMMARY TABLES

D

KEY FOR SUMMARY TABLES

Acronyms for the Known or Assumed ACM:

CFT = Ceramic Floor Tile CWT = Ceramic Wall Tile EPDM = Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer

HVAC = Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning TSI = Thermal System Insulation

Abbreviations for Friable/ACM Type:

Y = Yes N= No M = Miscellaneous S = Surfacing T = Thermal System Insulation

Descriptions for Conditions:

The listed conditions of Good, Fair, and Poor generally correspond with the AHERA descriptions of Good, Damaged, and Significantly Damaged for different types of materials. The following summarizes additional details relative to the listed conditions.

Surfacing (Surf.) and Miscellaneous (Misc.) Materials

• Good: Material with no visible damage or deterioration, or showing only very limited damage or deterioration

• Fair: Material with characteristics of surface crumbling, blistered, water-stained, gouged, marred, or otherwise abraded over less than one tenth of the surface if the damage is evenly distributed or one quarter if the damage is localized.

• Poor: Material with one or more of the following characteristics:

- Surface crumbling or blistering is present over at least one tenth of the surface, if the damage is evenly distributed or one quarter if the damage is localized.

- One tenth (or one quarter, if localized) of material hanging from the surface, deteriorated, or showing adhesive failure.

- Water stains, gouges, or mars over at least one tenth of the surface if the damage is evenly distributed or one quarter if the damage is localized.

Thermal System Insulation (TSI) Materials

• Good: Material with no visible damage or deterioration, or showing only very limited damage or deterioration

• Fair: Material with one or more of the following characteristics:

- A few water stains or less than one tenth of insulation with missing jackets.

- Crushed insulation or water stains, gouges, punctures, or mars on up to one tenth of the insulation if the damage is evenly distributed or up to one quarter if the damage is localized.

• Poor: Material with one or more of the following characteristics:

- Missing jackets on at least one tenth of the piping or equipment.

- Crushed or heavily gouged or punctured insulation on at least one tenth of the component (pipe runs/risers, boiler, tank, duct, etc.) if the damage is evenly distributed or one quarter if the damage is localized.

Notes:

1 Sample Location Plan(s) are enclosed in Appendix B.

2a NAD = No Asbestos Detected/ 2b ND = Not detected above the laboratory method detection limit.

3 Quantities and locations are approximate and must be verified by asbestos abatement contractors prior to providing actual cost quotations and/or initiating abatement activities.

4 NA = Not Applicable

5 Material is determined to be ACM due to being comingled with asbestos-containing mastic

6 Material is assumed (ACM) based on inaccessibility

7 Reference data in Arcadis US, Inc. sample analysis report.

Table D-I Summary of Suspect ACM and Analytical Results

D1

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

White Newer Pipe TSI Jacket

West Center Side, West South Side, and South Center;

Room Nos. 102, 104, 112, 113b, 114, 114a, 135, and 241

Y/T Non-Detect Fair A00497

A00507

A00517

N/A

White Pipe TSI End Sealant

West End, South West, South Center, and North Wall;

Adjacent to Column Nos. A32 and A57

Y/T Non-Detect Fair A00467

A00477

A00487

N/A

Brown Window and Door

Perimeter Caulk

West of Columns G48 and F64;

Adjacent to Column Nos. A22, B23, A32, A37, A62, A67;

Column C68 adjacent to main door

N/M Non-Detect Fair A00197

A00207 N/A

Off-White Cloth Pipe TSI Jacket

South West, Center West, and South

Areas; North Wall;

Column Nos. G48 and C22; Room No.

Y/T Non-Detect Fair A00017

A00027

A00037

N/A

White Pipe TSI

South West, Center West, and South

Areas; North Wall;

Room No. 220

Y/T Non-Detect Fair A00497

A00507

A00517

N/A

Off-White Mudded Pipe TSI Fitting Associated with Off-White Pipe TSI Jacket

South West, Center West, and South

Areas; North Wall;

Room No. 220

Y/T Non-Detect Fair

A00047

A00057

A00067

A00077

A00087

A00097

N/A

Summary of Suspect ACM and Analytical Results Continued

D2

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Black Vibration Dampening Cloth

West Side LP 174 Unit and West Side near G55 Column

N/M NAD Good

AT5536AI07A

AT5536AI07B

N/A

Tan Paper TSI Pipe Jacket

Adjacent to Column No. F59

Y/ T NAD Fair

AT5536AI08A

AT5536AI08B

AT5536AI08C

N/A

Off-White Mudded Pipe TSI

Fitting

Adjacent to Column No. F59

Y/T Assumed6 Fair AT5536AI09 6 Linear Feet

White Gypsum Board

Room Nos. 100, 131, 132, 112, 112 2nd floor, 113, 113 2nd floor, 113a, and 114;

Column Nos. C21, C18, C17, C16 and

C15

Y/M Non-Detect Fair

A00307

A00317

A00427

A00427

N/A

White Joint Compound

Associated with White Gypsum

Board

Room Nos. 100, 131, 132, 112, 112 2nd floor, 113, 113 2nd floor, 113a, and 114;

Column Nos. C21, C18, C17, C16, and

C15

N/M Non-Detect Fair A00507

A00517 N/A

White Seam Tape Associated with

Off-White Gypsum Wall Board

Room Nos. 100, 114, 131, 132, 112 and

112 2nd floor Column Nos. C21, C18, C17, C16 and

C15

N/M NAD Fair

AT5536AI12A

AT5536AI12B

N/A

Light Gray Window Glazing

South End N/ M 1.4 Poor

AT5536AI13A

AT5536AI13B

275 Square Feet

Off-White Lag Cloth Patch TSI

Column Nos. G68, E20, E67, C19, and A22; Adjacent to Walls South West and North

Y/T Non-Detect Fair A00167

A00177

A00187

D3

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Silver HVAC TSI Jacket

Adjacent to column Nos. D68, B5, and

A57 Y / T NAD Fair

AT5536AI15A

AT5536AI15B

AT5536AI15C

N/A

Tan 1-Inch and 2- Inch TSI Pipe

Jacket

Adjacent to column No. C52 1/2

Y/ T 1.5 Fair

AT5536AI17A

AT5536AI17B

AT5536AI17C

80 Linear Feet

White Pipe TSI Associated with

Tan 1-Inch and 2- Inch TSI Pipe

Jacket

Adjacent to column No. C52 1/2

Y / T 26.7 Fair

AT5536AI18A

AT5536AI18B

AT5536AI18C

80 Linear Feet

Off-White Mudded Pipe TSI Fitting Associated with Tan 1- Inch and 2- Inch TSI

Pipe Jacket

Adjacent to column No. C52 1/2

Y / T Assumed6 Fair AT5536AI19 6 Square Feet

Gray Insulation Backing Paper

Associated with Pink Fiberglass

Adjacent to column Nos. C31 1/2, C22, C18, E20, and E5;

Walls North, and East; Room Nos.

135, 143, 144, and

Y / T NAD Poor

AT5536AI20A

AT5536AI20B

AT5536AI20C

N/A

Off-White Interior Window Glazing

Center Interior Wood Windows, North Interior Wood Windows; Room

Nos. 134, 220, and 220A

N/M 3.4 Fair A00777

A00787 163 Square

Feet

Gray Skim Coat Wall Plaster

Adjacent to column No. C21

Y / S NAD Fair

AT5536AI22A

AT5536AI22B

AT5536AI22C

D4

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Gray Base Coat Wall Plaster

Adjacent to column No. C21

Y / S NAD Fair

AT5536AI23A

AT5536AI23B

AT5536AI23C

N/A

Off-White Mudded Pipe TSI Fitting Associated with Gray Insulation Backing Paper Associated with Pink Fiberglass

Adjacent to column No. C18, E20, and E5; Walls East and

North

Y / T NAD Fair

AT5536AI24A

AT5536AI24B

AT5536AI24C

N/A

White Caulk Associated with

Door Frame Room No. 144 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI25A

AT5536AI25B

N/A

Brown Floor Expansion Board

Adjacent to column Nos. C18, C17, C16, C15, B4, B5, and A6

East Side, Center East, and South East of Building

N/ M NAD Fair

AT5536AI26A

AT5536AI26B

N/A

Brown 4-Inch Cove Base

Adjacent to column Nos. C18, C17, C16, and C15 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI27A

AT5536AI27B

N/A

White Adhesive Associated with

Brown 4-Inch Cove Base

Adjacent to Column Nos. C18, C17, C16, and C15 N/ M Non-Detect Fair

A00677

A00687 N/A

Silver Pipe TSI Jacket

Adjacent to column No. C18

N / T NAD Fair

AT5536AI29A

AT5536AI29B

AT5536AI29C

N/A

Gray Expansion Joint Caulk

Throughout Building N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI30A

AT5536AI30B

D5

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

White Gypsum Associated with

Beige Wall Board Textured Panels

Center of Building Y/M NAD Good

AT5536AI31A

AT5536AI31B

N/A

Brown Expansion Joint Caulk

Adjacent to column Nos. A1 and C1

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI32A

AT5536AI32B

N/A

Brown Vibration Dampening Cloth

Adjacent to column No. B5

N / M NAD Good

AT5536AI33A

AT5536AI33B

N/A

Gray Floor Filler Patch

Adjacent to column No. B5

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI34A

AT5536AI34B

N/A

Off-White Window Glazing

Adjacent to column No. A16

Interior Windows Room Nos. 141 and

141 2nd Floor

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI35A

AT5536AI35B

N/A

Orange Pipe TSI Jacket

Adjacent to column Nos. A16 and A22;

Center East Wall

Y / T Assumed6 Fair AT5536AI36 133 Square

Feet

Off-White Mudded Pipe TSI Fitting Associated with Orange Pipe

TSI Jacket

Adjacent to column Nos. A16 and A22

N / T Assumed6 Fair AT5536AI37 2 Square Feet

Orange Gasket Adjacent to column

No. B29 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI38A

AT5536AI38B

N/A

Black Tar Expansion Joint

Patch

Center and South East of Building

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI39A

AT5536AI39B

N/A

Gray Door Frame Caulk

Adjacent to column No. B31

N / M 2.4 Fair

AT5536AI40A

AT5536AI40B

4 Square Feet

D6

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Older White Pipe TSI Jacket

Adjacent to column No. A32

Y / T NAD Fair

AT5536AI41A

AT5536AI41B

AT5536AI41C

N/A

White Interface Caulk

Adjacent to column No. A56

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI42A

AT5536AI42B

N/A

White 2-by 2-Foot Fissured and

Pinholed Ceiling Tile

Room Nos. 102 and

Y/M Non-Detect Fair A00387

A00397 N/A

Gray Grout Associated with

Large Tan Rectangular CWT

Room Nos. 102, 137, and 136

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI44A

AT5536AI44B

N/A

Off-White Mortar Associated with

Large Tan Rectangular CWT

Room Nos. 102, 137, and 136

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI45A

AT5536AI45B

N/A

Gray Grout Associated with 1-

Inch and 2- Inch Tan and Beige CFT

Room Nos. 102, 137, and 136

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI46A

AT5536AI46B

N/A

Gray Mortar Associated with 1-

Inch and 2- Inch Tan and Beige CFT

Room Nos. 102, 137, and 136

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI47A

AT5536AI47B

N/A

Gray Grout Associated with 1-by 1- Inch CFT Patch

Room No. 102 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI48A

AT5536AI48B

N/A

Gray Pattern Mortar Associated with 1- by 1- Inch

CFT Patch

Room No. 102 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI49A

AT5536AI49B

D7

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

White Skim Coat Wall Plaster

Room Nos. 103, 134, 135, and 144

Y/S Non-Detect Poor A00607

A00617

A00627

N/A

Gray Base Coat Wall Plaster

Room Nos. 103, 134, 135, and 144

Y/S Non-Detect Poor A00647

A00657

A00667

N/A

White Skim Coat Ceiling Plaster

Room Nos. 103, 104, and 134

Y / S NAD Fair

AT5536AI52A

AT5536AI52B

AT5536AI52C

N/A

Gray Base Coat Ceiling Plaster

Room Nos. 103, 104, and 134

Y / S NAD Fair

AT5536AI53A

AT5536AI53B

AT5536AI53C

N/A

Black 4-Inch Cove Base

Room Nos. 103, 112, 112 2nd Floor, 113, 113 2nd Floor, 114, 114A, and 138

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI54A

AT5536AI54B

N/A

Black Adhesive Associated with

Black 4-Inch Cove Base

Room Nos. 103, 112, 112 2nd Floor, 113, 113 2nd Floor, 114, 114A, and 138

N/M Non-Detect Fair A00717

A00727 N/A

Red Fire Stop Room Nos. 104 and

Adjacent to 104 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI56A

AT5536AI56B

N/A

Brown Fire Stop Room Nos. 104 and

Adjacent to 104 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI57A

AT5536AI57B

N/A

Black Residual Mastic Associated with Painted Floor

Room No. 104 (under floor paint)

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI58A

AT5536AI58B

N/A

White 12- by 12- Inch Mottled

Floor Tile

Room Nos. 112, 112- 2nd Floor, 113, and

113B Y/M Non-Detect5 Fair

A00737

A00747 985 Square

Feet

D8

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Black Mastic Associated with White 12- by 12-

Inch Mottled Floor Tile

Room Nos. 112, 112- 2nd Floor, 113, and

113B N/M 2.5 Fair

A00757

A00767 985 Square

Feet

Off-White Grout Associated with 4-by 4- Inch Tan Speckled CWT

Room No. 112 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI61A

AT5536AI61B

N/A

White Adhesive Associated with 4-by 4- Inch Tan Speckled CWT

Room No. 112 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI62A

AT5536AI62B

N/A

Black Grout Associted with 1-by 1- Inch Tan CFT

Room No. 112 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI63A

AT5536AI63B

N/A

Gray Mortar Associted with 1-by 1- Inch Tan CFT

Room No. 112 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI64A

AT5536AI64B

N/A

White Grout Associated with 4-by 4- Inch White

Speckled CWT

Room Nos. 113 and 114B

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI65A

AT5536AI65B

N/A

White Adhesive Associated with 4-by 4- Inch White

Speckled CWT

Room Nos. 113 and 114B

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI66A

AT5536AI66B

N/A

White Fixture Caulk

Room Nos. 112, 113, and 114B

N/M NAD Fair

AT5536AI67A

AT5536AI67B

D9

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

White 2- by 4-Foot Rough Fissured

Ceiling Tile

Room Nos. 114 and 138A

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI68A

AT5536AI68B

N/A

Light Gray 12- by 12-Inch Mottled

Floor Tile

Room Nos. 114, 138A, 238J, and

238G N/M NAD Fair

AT5536AI69A

AT5536AI69B

N/A

Dark Gray Pattern Grout Associated with 1- by 1- Inch Yellow and White

Patterned CFT

Room No. 114B Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI70A

AT5536AI70B

N/A

Gray Mortar Associated with 1-by 1- Inch Yellow and White Patterned CFT

Room No. 114B Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI71A

AT5536AI71B

N/A

White 2- by 2-Foot Pitted Ceiling Tile

Room No. 114A Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI72A

AT5536AI72B

N/A

Gray and Tan Marbled Linoleum

Room No. 114A N / M NAD Good

AT5536AI73A

AT5536AI73B

N/A

Gray Fire Stop Room No. 135 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI74A

AT5536AI74B

N/A

White Terrazzo Associated with

Shower Pan Room No. 137 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI75A

AT5536AI75B

N/A

Dark Red and Black Checker

Pattern 12- by 12- Inch Floor Tile

Room Nos. 134, 133, 143, and 141

N / M 4.3 Fair

AT5536AI76A-114L1

AT5536AI76B-115L1

3,105 Square Feet

Dark Red and Black Checker

Pattern 12- by 12- Inch Floor Tile

Room Nos. 134, 133, 143, and 141

N / M 3.1 Fair

AT5536AI76A-114L2

AT5536AI76B-115L2

3,105 Square

D10

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Black Mastic Associated with

Dark Red and Black Checker

Pattern Floor Tile

Room Nos. 134, 133, 143, and 141

N / M 2.1 Fair

AT5536AI77A

AT5536AI77B

3,105 Square Feet

White 2- by 4-Foot Smooth Ceiling

Tile

Room Nos. 138, 139, 139A, and 139B

Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI78A

AT5536AI78B

N/A

Light Gray Pebble/ Crackle Pattern 12-by 12- Inch Floor

Tile

Room No. 138 N/M NAD Fair

AT5536AI79A

AT5536AI79B

N/A

Black Mastic Associated with

Light Gray 12- by 12-Inch Crackle

Pattern Floor Tile

Room No. 138 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI80A

AT5536AI80B

N/A

Tan 4-Inch Cove Base

Room Nos. 138, 138A, 150, 154, 153, and 152 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI81A

AT5536AI81B

N/A

Tan Adhesive Associated with Tan 4-Inch Cove

Base

Room Nos. 138, 138A, 150, 154, 153, and 152 N/M Non-Detect Fair

A00447

A00457 N/A

White 2- by 4-Foot Fissured and

Extremely Pinholed Ceiling

Tile

Room No. 238 Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI83A

AT5536AI83B

N/A

White 2- by 4-Foot Short-Fissured and

Pinholed Ceiling Tile

Room Nos. 238, 238A, 238C, 238D, 238E, 238F, 238H, 238i, 152, 153, and

Y/M Non-Detect Fair A00367

A00377 N/A

D11

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Black 4-Inch Cove Base

Room Nos. 238, 238A, 238C, 238D, 238E, 238F, 238G, 238H, 238i, 238J, 139, 139A, and 139B

N / M NAD Good

AT5536AI85A

AT5536AI85B

N/A

White Adhesive Associated with

Black 4-Inch Cove Base

Room Nos. 238, 238A, 238C, 238D, 238E, 238F, 238G, 238H, 238i, 238J, 139, 139A, and 139B

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI86A

AT5536AI86B

N/A

Black Mastic Associated with

Light Gray 12- by 12-Inch Mottled

Floor Tile

Room Nos. 114, 138A, 238J, and

238G N / M Trace Fair

AT5536AI87A

AT5536AI87B

1,481 Square Feet

Yellow Adhesive Associated with

Gray and Tan Mottled 2- by 2- Foot Carpet Tile

Room Nos. 139, 139A, and 139B

N/M Non-Detect Good A00697

A00707 N/A

Dark Red 9- by 9- Inch Marbled

Floor Tile Room No. 133 N / M 10.2 Fair

AT5536AI90A

AT5536AI90B

6 Square Feet

Black Mastic Associated with

Dark Red 9- by 9- Inch Marbled

Floor Tile

Room No. 133 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI91A

AT5536AI91B

N/A

Black and Light Gray 12- by 12-

Inch Mottled Floor Tile

Room No. 144 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI92A

AT5536AI92B

D12

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Yellow Mastic Comingled with

White Floor Leveler Associated with Black and Light Gray 12- by 12-Inch Mottled

Floor Tile

Room No. 144 N/M Non-Detect Fair A00347

A00357 N/A

Black Window Butyl

Room Nos. 150, 154, 153, and 152

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI94A

AT5536AI94B

N/A

White Window Glazing Patch on Wooden Window

Frames

Room Nos. 220 and 220A

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI95A

AT5536AI95B

N/A

Black Door Light Butyl

Room Nos. 154, 153 and 152

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI96A

AT5536AI96B

N/A

White Window Glazing Patch on Metal Window

Frames

South Facade Y / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI97A

AT5536AI97B

N/A

Light Gray Door Caulk

South Facade N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI98A

AT5536AI98B

N/A

White Window Overlap Caulk

South Façade N / M 1.7 Fair

AT5536AI99A

AT5536AI99B

3 Square Feet

Off-White Cementitious Seam Grout

North Façade N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI100A

AT5536AI100B

N/A

Pink Window Glazing

North Facade N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI101A

AT5536AI101B

D13

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

White Window Glazing Associated with Wooden Windows and

Mullions

North Facade N/M Trace Fair

AT5536AI102A

AT5536AI102B

1,000 Square Feet

Off-White Window Glazing Patch

Associated with Wooden Windows and Mullions

North Facade N / M Trace Fair

AT5536AI103A

AT5536AI103B

N/A

Brown Adhesive Associated with 4-by 4-Inch Speckled

CWT

Room Nos. 113 and

N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI104A

AT5536AI104B

N/A

Yellow 9- by 9- Inch Sub-Floor Tile

Room Nos. 114A and 114

N / M 6.9 Fair

AT5536AI105A-04L1

AT5536AI105B-04L1

1,396 Square Feet

Black Mastic Associated with

Yellow 9- by 9-Inch Sub-Floor Tile

Room Nos. 114A and

N/M Trace Fair

AT5536AI105A-04L2

AT5536AI105B-04L2

N/A

Clear Glue Associated with

Yellow 9- by 9-Inch Sub-Floor Tile

Room Nos. 114A and

N/M Trace Fair

AT5536AI105A-04L3

AT5536AI105B-04L3

N/A

Tan with Oranges Streaks 9- by 9- Inch Floor Tile

Room No. 114 N / M 2.8 Fair

AT5536AI106A

AT5536AI106B

1,300 Square Feet

Gray Floor Filler Room No. 141 N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI107A

AT5536AI107B

N/A

Gray Window Perimeter Caulk

Room No. 141 N / M 2.9 Fair

AT5536AI108A

AT5536AI108B

54 Square Feet

D14

Material General Location1 Friable / ACM Type % Asbestos2a,2b Condition Sample Numbers7 Estimated

Quantity3,4

Gray Putty Room No. 135 (Pipe

Penetrations) N / M NAD Fair

AT5536AI109A

AT5536AI109B

N/A

Black Floor Filler Associated with Black with Light

Gray Mottled 12-by 12-Inch Floor

Tile

Room No. 144 N / M 1.9 Fair

AT5536AI110A

AT5536AI110B

320 Square

E

APPENDIX E

ARCADIS US, INC. DOCUMENTATION

Analyzed Date Asbestos Fibrous Non-FibrousTest Color

Non Asbestos

Test Report:Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

200 Route 130 North, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077 Phone/Fax: (800) 220-3675 / (856) 786-5974 http://www.EMSL.com cinnasblab@EMSL.com

041835210 CustomerID: ACAD78BJ CustomerPO: 02118227.0000 ProjectID:

EMSL Order:

Attn: Joe Ashman ARCADIS U.S., Inc.

50 Fountain Plaza Suite 600 Buffalo, NY 14202

Received: 11/29/18 10:40 AM

02118227.0000 - Watervliet Arsenal - Building 10 - Watervliet, NY

Fax: (716) 667-0279 Phone: (716) 667-0900

Project:

12/5/2018Analysis Date:

11/27/2018Collected:

A001 041835210-0001

Description North End - A7 Wall - Cloth Jacketing a/w Fiberglass Pipe Insulation (FPI)

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Cellulose20.00% Glass5.00%

Non-fibrous (other)75.00%

A002 041835210-0002

Description North End - A19 Wall - Cloth Jacketing a/w Fiberglass Pipe Insulation (FPI)

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Cellulose20.00% Glass5.00%

Non-fibrous (other)75.00%

A003 041835210-0003

Description North End - A21 Wall - Cloth Jacketing a/w Fiberglass Pipe Insulation (FPI)

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Cellulose15.00% Glass10.00%

Non-fibrous (other)75.00%

A004 041835210-0004

Description North End - A7 Wall - Approximately 3" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool20.00% Non-fibrous (other)80.00%

A005 041835210-0005

Description North End - A7 Wall - Approximately 3" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool20.00% Non-fibrous (other)80.00%

Page 1Test Report 198VCM-7.30.0 Printed: 12/6/2018 7:34:04 PM

Initial Report From 12/06/2018 19:34:04 http://www.EMSL.com mailto:cinnasblab@EMSL.com

Asbestos Fibrous Non-FibrousTest Color Non Asbestos

Test Report:Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

200 Route 130 North, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077 Phone/Fax: (800) 220-3675 / (856) 786-5974 http://www.EMSL.com cinnasblab@EMSL.com

041835210 CustomerID: ACAD78BJ CustomerPO: 02118227.0000 ProjectID:

EMSL Order:

A006 041835210-0006

Description North End - E5 Wall - Approximately 3" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool20.00% Non-fibrous (other)80.00%

A007 041835210-0007

Description North End - A7 Wall - Approximately 6" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool30.00% Non-fibrous (other)70.00%

A008 041835210-0008

Description North End - A7 Wall - Approximately 6" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool30.00% Non-fibrous (other)70.00%

A009 041835210-0009

Description North End - A6 Wall - Approximately 6" Mudded Pipe Fitting a/w FPI

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/6/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool35.00% Non-fibrous (other)65.00%

A010 041835210-0010

Description North End - A19 Wall - Brick Mortar

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

A011 041835210-0011

Description North End - A7 Wall - Brick Mortar

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

Page 2Test Report 198VCM-7.30.0 Printed: 12/6/2018 7:34:04 PM

Initial Report From 12/06/2018 19:34:04

Test Report:Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

200 Route 130 North, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077 Phone/Fax: (800) 220-3675 / (856) 786-5974 http://www.EMSL.com cinnasblab@EMSL.com

041835210 CustomerID: ACAD78BJ CustomerPO: 02118227.0000 ProjectID:

EMSL Order:

A012 041835210-0012

Description North End - E7 Wall - Brick Mortar

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/6/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

A013 041835210-0013

Description North End - A7 Wall - Parging at Interior Window Sill

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

A014 041835210-0014

Description North End - A19 Wall - Parging at Interior Window Sill

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

A015 041835210-0015

Description Center - A32 Wall - Parging at Interior Window Sill

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/6/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Non-fibrous (other)100.00%

A016 041835210-0016

Description North End - A17 Wall - Lag Cloth Repaired Mudded Fitting

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool40.00% Non-fibrous (other)60.00%

A017 041835210-0017

Description North End - A19 Wall - Lag Cloth Repaired Mudded Fitting

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Min. Wool40.00% Non-fibrous (other)60.00%

Page 3Test Report 198VCM-7.30.0 Printed: 12/6/2018 7:34:04 PM

Initial Report From 12/06/2018 19:34:04

Test Report:Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

200 Route 130 North, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077 Phone/Fax: (800) 220-3675 / (856) 786-5974 http://www.EMSL.com cinnasblab@EMSL.com

041835210 CustomerID: ACAD78BJ CustomerPO: 02118227.0000 ProjectID:

EMSL Order:

A018 041835210-0018

Description North End - E7 Wall - Lag Cloth Repaired Mudded Fitting

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/6/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Glass10.00% Min. Wool35.00%

Non-fibrous (other)55.00%

A019 041835210-0019

Description North End - A22 Door - Interior Dark Brown Door Frame Caulk

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

12/5/2018

12/6/2018

Not Analyzed

Inconclusive: None Detected

None Detected

Brown

Brown

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

A020 041835210-0020

Description North End - A22 Door - Interior Dark Brown Door Frame Caulk

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

12/5/2018

12/6/2018

Not Analyzed

Inconclusive: None Detected

None Detected

Brown

Brown

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

A021 041835210-0021

Description North End - C Office - Single Coat Plaster

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Synthetic10.00% Non-fibrous (other)90.00%

A022 041835210-0022

Description North End - C Office - Single Coat Plaster

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/5/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Synthetic10.00% Non-fibrous (other)90.00%

A023 041835210-0023

Description North End - C Office - Single Coat Plaster

PLM NYS 198.1 Friable 12/6/2018

PLM NYS 198.6 NOB

TEM NYS 198.4 NOB

None Detected

Not Analyzed

Not Analyzed

Gray

Sample ID Homogeneity Homogeneous

PLM NYS 198.6 VCM Not Analyzed

Hair4.00% Non-fibrous (other)96.00%

Page 4Test Report 198VCM-7.30.0 Printed: 12/6/2018 7:34:04 PM

Initial Report From 12/06/2018 19:34:04

Test Report:Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

200 Route 130 North, Cinnaminson, NJ 08077 Phone/Fax: (800) 220-3675 / (856) 786-5974 http://www.EMSL.com cinnasblab@EMSL.com

041835210 CustomerID: ACAD78BJ CustomerPO: 02118227.0000 ProjectID:

EMSL Order:

A024 041835210-0024

Description North End - C Office - 12"x12"…