EPA_WED_PH1A_Substitution_Requests_20150721.pdf

E N G IN E E R S | A R C H IT E C T S | S U R V E Y O R S | S C IE N T IS T S

4755 Fo rge Road, Su i te 150

Colo rado Spr ings , CO 80907 p 719.590.9194 f 719.590. 9111 www. f -w.com | www.g reennav igat ion .com

Substitution Requests Response

Project: PHASE 1A LABORATORY MODERNIZATION

AT THE ORD-NHEERL, WESTERN ECOLOGY DIVISION, CORVALLIS, OR

Project Number: 0130523.03

Date: JULY 21, 2015

This review is only for general conformance with the design concept and the information given in the

Construction Documents. Approvals are based upon the opinion, knowledge, information, and belief of design team at time of issuance of this Addendum and reliance upon data submitted. Approvals are therefore interim in nature and subject to reconsideration as additional data, materials, workmanship, and coordination with other work are observed and reviewed. In proposing items allowed by this Addendum, Bidder assumes all risks, costs, and responsibilities for items final acceptance, integration into Work, and performance.

Item (with

EPA

Contracting

Officer label)

Spec

Section

Proposed

Manufacturer

Manufacturer Representative Name Approved or Disapproved

Permeable

Interlocking

Concrete

Pavers

Pavestone

(Willamette

Graystone

Division)

Gale Schroeder

Willamette Graystone (Division of

Pavestone)

2405 NE 244th Ave

Wood Village OR 97060 ph 971-241-0312 gale@willamettegraystone.com

Approved.

Metal Wall

Panels

074213 Metal Sales Stacey Henderson

Metal Sales Manufacturing

2727 E. Trent

Spokane, WA 99202

P: (509) 828-4757

Approved.

Chemical

Fume Hood

115300 BMC Metal-

ARC

Brian Johnston

Laboratory Design & Construction

PO Box 728

Wauna, WA 98395

P: (253) 858-7835 brian@laboratorydesign.net

Disapproved. Fume hood performance does not match the basis of design.

Contracting

Officer label)

Spec

Section

Proposed

Manufacturer

Manufacturer Representative Name Approved or Disapproved

Chemical

Fume Hood

115300 Labconco Brian Johnston

Laboratory Design & Construction

PO Box 728

Wauna, WA 98395

Disapproved. Specification

Section 11 53 00 requires:

2.00.D. The selected manufacturer for the

Chemical Fume Hood will also be selected for the

Laboratory Casework

(Section 12 33 60) to assure compatibility of the products.

Laboratory

Casework

123360 BMC Metal-

ARC

Brian Johnston

Laboratory Design & Construction

PO Box 728

Wauna, WA 98395

Disapproved. Does not meet

EPA AE Guidelines.

Temp

Controls

(EPA #4)

230900 Distech

Controls

Scott Conley or Becky Moon

Office Manager

Essential Building Technologies, LLC

600 SE Maritime Avenue, Ste. 240

Vancouver, WA 98661

P: (360) 573-3200 x101

F: (360) 573-3201 beckym@essentialbuildings.com

Approved

Temp

Controls

(EPA #3)

230900 Reliable

Controls

Scott Conley or Becky Moon

Office Manager

Essential Building Technologies, LLC

600 SE Maritime Avenue, Ste. 240

Vancouver, WA 98661

P: (360) 573-3200 x101

F: (360) 573-3201 beckym@essentialbuildings.com

Balancing

Valves (EPA

#12)

232113 NuTech

AB/MB

Greg Oberle

Oregon Air Reps

Ph 503-620-4300 grego@oregonairreps.com

Contracting

Officer label)

Spec

Section

Proposed

Manufacturer

Manufacturer Representative Name Approved or Disapproved

Duct

Silencers

(EPA # 11)

233300 Price model

RH

Johnson Air Products

2220 SE Ninth Ave

Portland, OR 97214

Eric Danielson

Engineering Sales Manager

971-244-5236 Direct edanielson@johnsonair.com

Approved

Air Duct

Accessories

233300 Pottorff Cory Hayes

Norman S. Wright - Northwest

OFFICE: 503.563.6033

FAX: 503.563.6031

MOBILE: 503.475.2000

Approved for duct silencers and dampers.

Exhaust Fans for lab exhaust

233423 Twin City Fans Greg Oberle

Oregon Air Reps

Ph 503-620-4300 grego@oregonairreps.com

Approved for lab exhaust fans. Approved for inline fans.

Single Duct

Air Terminal

Units

233600 Krueger LMHS Cory Hayes

Norman S. Wright - Northwest

OFFICE: 503.563.6033

FAX: 503.563.6031

MOBILE: 503.475.2000

Approved

Venturi

Valves and

Lab Controls

(EPA #14)

233605 Price Critical

Controls

Johnson Air Products

2220 SE Ninth Ave

Portland, OR 97214

Eric Danielson

Engineering Sales Manager

971-244-5236 Direct edanielson@johnsonair.com

Approved.

No major differences.

Engineer has no experience with this product.

Air Handling

Units

(EPA #10)

237313 TEAM Air

Conditioning

Equipment

Dave Havelick

TraneOregon

7257 SW Kable Lane

Portland, OR 97224

Approved.

Air Handling

Units

(EPA #9)

237313 Haakon

Industries

Dave Havelick

TraneOregon

7257 SW Kable Lane

Portland, OR 97224

Approved.

Contracting

Officer label)

Spec

Section

Proposed

Manufacturer

Manufacturer Representative Name Approved or Disapproved

Air Handling

Units

237313 BASX Cory Hayes

Norman S. Wright - Northwest

OFFICE: 503.563.6033

FAX: 503.563.6031

MOBILE: 503.475.2000

Disapproved. Too little data available on products from

BASX.

Air Handling

Units

237313 Unitech

WhisperAir

Greg Oberle

Oregon Air Reps

Ph 503-620-4300 grego@oregonairreps.com

Approved.

Appears acceptable.

Engineer has no prior experience with this manufacturer.

Air Handling

Units (EPA

#1)

237313 Engineered Air Nathan Ralphe

Engineered Air

3443 S Galena St, Suite 102

Denver, CO 80231

Approved.

Appears acceptable.

Engineer has minimal prior experience with this manufacturer.

Water

Source Heat

Pumps

238143 Enertech

Global

Cory Hayes

Norman S. Wright - Northwest

OFFICE: 503.563.6033

FAX: 503.563.6031

MOBILE: 503.475.2000

Disapproved.

Not enough demonstrated service.

Water

Source Heat

Pumps

238146 Daikin Greg Oberle

Oregon Air Reps

Ph 503-620-4300 grego@oregonairreps.com

Disapproved.

Heat pump data is insufficient to determine capacity. No data for units of comparable size.

Hot Water

Convector

238233 Sterling FSG-A Greg Oberle

Oregon Air Reps

Ph 503-620-4300 grego@oregonairreps.com

Approved.

Propeller

Unit Heaters

(EPA #13)

238239 Modine model

HC

Johnson Air Products

2220 SE Ninth Ave

Portland, OR 97214

Eric Danielson

Engineering Sales Manager

971-244-5236 Direct edanielson@johnsonair.com

Approved.

Contracting

Officer label)

Spec

Section

Proposed

Manufacturer

Manufacturer Representative Name Approved or Disapproved

Engine

Generators

263213 MTU Onsite

Energy

Jake Austin

Power Generation Sales

7215 South 228th St.

Kent, WA 98032

Approved.

Appears to be acceptable.

Engineer does not have experience with this brand.

Subject to space limitations and requirements of specifications and drawings.