RFP_Selection_Committee_Consolidated_Scoresheet.pdf

This document is a Selection Committee Consolidated Evaluation Scoresheet for a Group Dental Insurance Plan Request for Proposal (RFP-1-25-18) issued by Brevard County. The procurement process involved evaluating four dental insurance providers: CIGNA, Humana, Metropolitan Life, and The Standard, with a meeting scheduled for June 20, 2025 at 2:00 p.m. and a posting period from June 20, 2025 through June 27, 2025 at 5:00 p.m. Three committee members (Ron Forknall, Greg Pelham, and Jerry Visco) scored and ranked the providers, with CIGNA ultimately receiving the highest total points and being selected as the top-ranked firm.

The evaluation scoresheet shows a detailed point allocation across the four insurance providers, with CIGNA receiving 3 total points and ranking first, followed by Metropolitan Life with 6 points (ranking second), The Standard with 7 points (ranking third), and Humana with 8 points (ranking fourth). The committee voted unanimously to move forward with awarding the contract to CIGNA, as motioned by Greg Pelham and seconded by Jerry Visco. Any questions regarding the procurement process can be directed to Mary Bowers at (321) 617-7390 X59334. The document also includes a standard statement from Brevard County encouraging prompt and fair handling of complaints and disputes with the business community.