RFP_Selection_Committee_Consolidated_Scoresheet.pdf

This document is a Selection Committee Consolidated Evaluation Scoresheet for Brevard County's Group Dental Insurance Plan (RFP-1-25-18), detailing the scoring and selection process for dental insurance providers. The evaluation meeting was held on June 20, 2025, with a posting period from June 20 through June 27, 2025, and involved scoring four dental insurance providers: CIGNA, Humana, Metropolitan Life, and The Standard. The committee members (Ron Forknall, Greg Pelham, and Jerry Visco) individually scored each provider, with CIGNA ultimately receiving the highest total points of 3 and being ranked first. A motion was made by Greg Pelham and seconded by Jerry Visco to award the contract to CIGNA, which passed unanimously.

The scoresheet reveals the detailed point allocation for each provider across committee members, with CIGNA receiving the most favorable evaluation. The document includes contact information for Mary Bowers at (321) 617-7390 X59334 for any questions regarding the selection process. Brevard County's approach emphasizes a fair and transparent evaluation method, with a statement encouraging prompt handling of complaints and disputes in accordance with established bid document procedures. The selection process appears designed to ensure a comprehensive and objective assessment of potential dental insurance providers for the county's group plan.