RFP 123350 O3 Foresensic Evaluation Scoresheet Send to DAS Final.xlsx

This is an evaluator scoresheet for RFP 123350 O3 Forensic Accounting for the State of Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services, Division of Children and Family Services, Adult Protective Services program. The solicitation seeks a qualified vendor to provide investigatory and forensic accounting services, including case analysis, document review, financial investigations, and report preparation for approximately 60 cases annually over a four-year contract term. Five vendors submitted proposals: Clifton Larson Allen LLP, CRI Advisors LLC, Deloitte Financial Advisory Services LLP, Eide Bailly LLP, and Myers and Stauffer LC. The evaluation process included assessment of corporate overview and technical response sections, each worth 45 points, with three evaluators scoring each vendor's qualifications and program approach.

CRI Advisors LLC submitted the lowest cost proposal at $492,000 for the four-year contract term and received the maximum 10 cost points, while Eide Bailly LLP submitted the highest cost at $1,530,000 and received only 3.22 cost points. Per-case pricing ranged from $1,900 to $6,000 in year one across the five vendors. The final overall scores combining corporate overview, technical response, and cost evaluation were: Myers and Stauffer LC (89.99 points), Deloitte (83.09 points), Clifton Larson Allen (80.29 points), Eide Bailly (74.40 points), and CRI Advisors (64.68 points). Despite CRI Advisors offering the lowest cost, Myers and Stauffer LC achieved the highest cumulative evaluation score, indicating that technical qualifications and corporate experience were weighted substantially in the selection process.