20110209_ACM_Survey_BV.pdf

APPENDIX B-113

Asbestos Survey Summary for

Building 860 Vandenberg AFB, California

Bureau Veritas Project # 25009-009558.00

Surveyed by: Mr. Jeremy MacMann, CSST (Certification No. 05-3830)

Dates of Survey: February 9, 2011

Number of Samples collected: Thirty-seven (37)

Number of Samples Analyzed by PLM: thirty-five (35)

Number of Samples Analyzed by TEM: Two (2)

Number of Samples Analyzed by PLM Point Count: None

Photos of Sample Locations: Refer to Appendix C (separated per building), for Photos of Sample Locations on Compact Disc (CD).

Building Description:

Building 860 at Vandenberg AFB, California is a two story, CMU structure constructed in 1959 that comprises approximately 7,741 square feet of floor space.

The interior spaces of Building 860 included classrooms, a conference room, telecom rooms, simulator room, training room, offices, restrooms, a day room, kitchen, physical fitness room, locker room, supply room, and tool room. The interior walls were finished with painted gypsum board with texture. The interior ceilings were finished with drop ceiling. Interior floor finishes included glued on carpet, ceramic tile, and vinyl floor tile. Additional interior finishes included vinyl cove base. The heating, ventilating, and air conditioning (HVAC) system supplied air to each room via un-insulated duct work. The piping was also insulated. The building’s roof consisted of built up tar and gravel. Note that due to the non-destructive nature of this assessment, the aforementioned ceramic floor tile mortar bed was not sampled.

Survey Results

Three (3) of the building materials sampled were found to contain asbestos greater than one percent and four (4) inaccessible material was assumed to contain asbestos greater than one percent. The following table presents a summary of our findings by homogenous sampling area (HA). Sample and asbestos location drawings are attached at the end of Appendix B-113. The laboratory results and the field chain of custodies are also attached at the end of Appendix B-113.

Building 860 (continued)

Table 2: Asbestos Assessment Results

Vandenberg AFB, California

Material (Classification) Location of Material

Condition

Friable Yes/No

Quantity

(NESHAP

Category)

Asbestos Content

HA-1: 4“’ O.D. mudded elbows, fittings and associated white cloth wrap

(TSI)

Throughout Good Yes 20 s.f.

(RACM)

Wrap: ND Insulation: 10% chrysotile

HA-2: 4” O.D. white insulation pipe run (TSI) Throughout Good Yes 150 l.f.

(NA) Insulation: ND

HA-3: White texture on gypsum wallboard and associated mineral mixture(S)

Throughout Good Yes 20,000 s.f.

(NA)

Texture: ND Mineral mixture: ND

HA-4: 2’ x 2’ textured lay-in ceiling tiles (M) Throughout Good Yes 10,000 s.f.

(NA) ND

HA-5: 4” brown cove base with associated white mastic and white mineral mixture

Throughout rooms Good No 20,000 l.f.

(NA)

Cove base: ND Mastic: ND

Mineral mixture: ND

HA-6: 12” x 12” gray vinyl floor tile with associated black, tan and yellow mastics and gray mineral mixture (M)

Room 106 Good No 50 s.f.

(Cat. I)

Floor tile: ND1 Black mastic: 2% chrysotile Tan mastic: ND

Yellow mastic: ND Mineral mixture: ND

HA-7: Gypsum wallboard with associated joint compound (M) Throughout Good Yes 20,000 s.f.

(NA)

Gypsum board: ND Paint/joint compound: ND Tape/joint compound: ND

HA-8: Yellow/black carpet mastics and associated mineral mixture (M)

Class room’s Good No 7,000 s.f.

(Cat. I)

Mastic: 2% chrysotile Mineral mixture: ND

HA-9: Black/white and brown/black vapor barrier and associated gray mineral mixture (M)

Perimeter walls Good Yes 20,000 s.f.

(NA)

Black/white Barrier: ND Brown/black barrier: ND

Mineral mixture: ND

HA-10: 4” gray cove base and associated white mastic and white mineral mixture (M)

Room 111 Good No 100 l.f.

(NA)

Cove base: ND Mastic: ND

Mineral mixture: ND HA-11: Built up tar and gravel and associated black, brown, and yellow insulations (M)

Room 111 Good No 100 l.f.

(NA) All layers: ND1

HA-12: Cementitious panels(TransiteR) (M) Below windows Good No 1,120 s.f.

(Cat. II) Assumed to contain asbestos greater than one (1) percent

HA-13 Gaskets (M) Piping systems throughout Good No NQ

(Cat. I) Assumed to contain asbestos greater than one (1) percent

Table 2: Asbestos Assessment Results

Vandenberg AFB, California

Material (Classification) Location of Material

Condition

Friable Yes/No

Quantity

(NESHAP

Category)

Asbestos Content

HA-14: Grout associated with 12”x12” tan ceramic floor tile (M)

Lobby, men’s and women’s restrooms, kitchen, and room

Good No 360 s.f.

(Cat. II)

Assumed to contain asbestos greater than one (1) percent

HA-15: Adhesive associated with 12”x12” tan ceramic floor tile (M)

Lobby, men’s and women’s restrooms, kitchen, and room

Good No 360 s.f.

(Cat. I)

Assumed to contain asbestos greater than one (1) percent s.f. = Square Feet, l.f. = Linear Feet, ND = Non Detect, S = Surfacing material, M = Miscellaneous, TSI = Thermal system insulation, O.D. = Outside Diameter, RACM = Regulated asbestos containing material, Cat. I = Category I Non-friable Asbestos Containing Material, Cat. II = Category II Non-Friable Asbestos Containing Material, 1 = Verified by TEM Analysis, NQ = Not Quantified, and NA = Not Applicable, Prepared by: Reviewed by:

Timothy J. Coe, CAC Michael-Ray Boyden, CAC Certified Asbestos Consultant (05-3838) Certified Asbestos Consultant (93-0985) Health, Safety and Environmental Services Health, Safety and Environmental Services

Attachments:

• Laboratory Report and Field Chain of Custody Forms

• Figure 1 – Sample Location Drawing

• Figure 2 – Asbestos Location Drawing

LABORATORY REPORT AND FIELD CHAIN OF CUSTODY FORMS

Bureau Veritas North America, Inc.

Health, Safety, and Environmental Services 3380 Chastain Meadows Parkway, Suite 300 Kennesaw, GA 30144

Main: (770) 499-7500 Fax: (770) 499-7511 www.us.bureauveritas.com

February 26, 2011

BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Michael-Ray Boyden

Dear Michael-Ray Boyden:

Reference: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/25009-009558.00.300

Bureau Veritas Work Order No. A1102183

2430 Camino Ramon

San Ramon, CA 94583- Suite 122

Bureau Veritas North America, Inc. received 34 samples on 2/15/2011 1:18:04 PM and reported on 2/26/2011 1:50:48 PM for the analyses presented in the following report.

The results apply only to the samples analyzed in this project. Please note that any unused portion of the samples will be discarded after a thirty-day holding period, unless you have requested otherwise.

We appreciate the opportunity to assist you. If you have any questions concerning the report, please contact the analyst whose name appears on the report or myself at (770) 499-7701.

Sincerely, Alan M. Segrave, P.G.

Director, Laboratory Services http://www.us.bureauveritas.com

Work Order No.: A1102183

Client Reference: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/25009-009558.00.300

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

9%

Sample Morphology

001A 860-1A (P)

Total

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 10 Homogeneous Off-White Cloth None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

(2) 90 Homogeneous Off-White Insulation Chrysotile Glass Wool Binder/Filler3%10%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

002A 860-1B (P)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous Off-White Cloth None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

003A 860-1C (P)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous Off-White Cloth None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

004A 860-2A (P)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

005A 860-2B (P)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95% Mineral wool Glue1%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

006A 860-2C (P)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95% Mineral wool Glue1%

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

007A 860-3A (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 95 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

(2) 5 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Gypsum

Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

008A 860-3B (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

009A 860-3C (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

010A 860-4A (C)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Ceiling Tile None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler30% Glass Wool Perlite10%

Glass Slag Paint

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

011A 860-4B (C)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Ceiling Tile None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler30% Glass Wool Perlite10%

Glass Slag Paint

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

012A 860-4C (C)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 100 Homogeneous White Ceiling Tile None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler30% Glass Wool Perlite10%

Glass Slag Paint

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

013A 860-5A (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 70 Homogeneous Brown Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber

(2) 20 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 10 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

014A 860-5B (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 70 Homogeneous Brown Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber Paint

(2) 20 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 10 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

015A 860-5C (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 97 Homogeneous Brown Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber Paint

(2) 3 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

<1%

Sample Morphology

016A 860-6A (F)

Total

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 95 Homogeneous Gray Floor Tile None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 3 Homogeneous Tan Mastic None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler1%

(3) 1 Homogeneous Black Mastic Chrysotile Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler1%2%

(4) 1 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

017A 860-6B (F)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 96 Homogeneous Gray Floor Tile None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 2 Homogeneous Yellow Mastic None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler1%

(3) 2 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

018A 860-6C (F)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 98 Homogeneous Gray Floor Tile None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 1 Homogeneous Yellow Mastic None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler1%

(3) 1 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

019A 860-7A (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 30 Homogeneous White Paint/Joint Compound

None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 10 Homogeneous White Joint Compound/Tape

None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 60 Homogeneous White Wall Board None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Tape

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

020A 860-7B (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 40 Homogeneous White Paint/Joint Compound

None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 60 Homogeneous White Wall Board None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

021A 860-7C (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 40 Homogeneous White Paint/Joint Compound

None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(2) 60 Homogeneous White Wall Board None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1%

02/18/2011VK

2%

Sample Morphology

022A 860-8A (F)

Total

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1)

Layer Comment: Layers inseparable.

100 Homogeneous Black/Yellow Mastic, Mineral Mixture

Chrysotile Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler1%2%

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

023A 860-8B (F)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

Sample not analyzed per client request.

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

024A 860-8C (F)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

Sample not analyzed per client request.

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

025A 860-9A (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 48 Homogeneous Black/White Vapor Barrier

None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler60% Tar

(2) 2 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 50 Homogeneous Brown/Black Vapor

Barrier None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler60%

Tar

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

026A 860-9B (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 48 Homogeneous Black/White Vapor Barrier

None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler60% Tar

(2) 2 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 50 Homogeneous Brown/Black Vapor

Barrier None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler60%

Tar

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

027A 860-9C (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 48 Homogeneous White Vapor Barrier None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

(2) 2 Homogeneous Gray Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 50 Homogeneous Brown/Black Vapor

Barrier None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler60%

Tar

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

028A 860-10A (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 87 Homogeneous Gray Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber

(2) 10 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 3 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Paint Tape

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

029A 860-10B (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 87 Homogeneous Gray Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber

(2) 10 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 3 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

030A 860-10C (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 87 Homogeneous Gray Cove Base None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Rubber

(2) 10 Homogeneous White Mastic None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

(3) 3 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Paint Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

031A 860-3D (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 95 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint Tape

(2) 5 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Gypsum

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

032A 860-3E (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 70 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

(2) 30 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Gypsum

Tape

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 2/15/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 26-Feb-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 26-Feb-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

033A 860-3F (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 80 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

(2) 20 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Gypsum

Tape

02/18/2011VK

Sample Morphology

034A 860-3G (W)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

02/10/2011

(1) 80 Homogeneous White Textured Coating None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler Paint

(2) 20 Homogeneous White Mineral Mixture None Detected Fibrous glass Binder/Filler1% Gypsum

Tape

Laboratory Limits

Range R Limit

Laboratory

Quartile Limit 0.1-1 100 +/- 1.482

10-100 100 +/- 22.23 1-10 100 +/- 7.41 Trace 100 +/- 1.482

Range R Limit

Vera Khorosh ( VK)

Quartile Limit 0.1-1 100 +/- 1.482

10-100 100 +/- 26.676 1-10 100 +/- 5.928 Trace 100 +/- 1.482

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 2/26/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Date Received: 2/15/2011 1:18:04 PM Report Date: 2/26/2011 1:50:48 PMSample Type: Bulk

Analytical Method: TEM Full-Quant Analysis EPA/600/R-93/116

Grid Box Identification: 02-23-11H-1

Lab Sample No.

Client Sample Identification

Date Sampled

Analysis Date Analyst

Reporting Limit (% by Weight): 0.1

Sample Description (Morphology)

Asbestos Total Asbestos (%)**(%)*Identification

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Client: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/25009-009558.00.300Client Reference No.:

Work Order No.: A1102183 Date: 26-Feb-11

A1102183-016A 860-6A (F) 02/10/11 @12:00 am

02/26/11 @1:42 pm

NG Gray Floor Tile None Detected -- < 0.1

Instrument *Magnification Calibration Date

TEM Microscope Documentation Accelerating

Voltage

TEM 2/D686 14998x 2/11/2011100 KeV

*Magnification = Calibrated screen magnification at 15,000X. For ISO Method 10312 the calibrated screen magnification is at 20,000X

Analyst(s) Name/Date:

Result is less than the indicated limit of detection.<:

2/26/2011

--: Present but below the detection limit The visual area estimation of asbestos content in the final residue.*:

**: The calculated total percent asbestos in the sample as received.

Bureau Veritas North America, Inc.

Health, Safety, and Environmental Services 3380 Chastain Meadows Parkway, Suite 300 Kennesaw, GA 30144

Main: (770) 499-7701 Fax: (770) 499-7511 www.us.bureauveritas.com

March 28, 2011

BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Michael-Ray Boyden

Dear Michael-Ray Boyden:

Reference: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/ 25009-009558.00.300

Bureau Veritas Work Order No. A1103227

2430 Camino Ramon

San Ramon, CA 94583- Suite 122

Bureau Veritas North America, Inc. received 3 samples on March 18, 2011 for the analyses presented in the following report.

The results apply only to the samples analyzed in this project. Please note that any unused portion of the samples will be discarded after a thirty-day holding period, unless you have requested otherwise.

We appreciate the opportunity to assist you. If you have any questions concerning the report, please contact the analyst whose name appears on the report or myself at (770) 499-7701.

Sincerely, Alan M. Segrave, P.G.

Director, Laboratory Services Electronic signature authorized through password protection

Tim Coecc:

http://www.us.bureauveritas.com

28-Mar-11Date:CASE NARRATIVE

Project: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/ 25009-009558.00.300

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Work Order No A1103227

ANALYTICAL METHOD FOR ASBESTOS IN BULK SAMPLES USING POLARIZED

LIGHT MICROSCOPY (PLM)

The results of this report relate only to the samples listed in the body of this report.

Unless otherwise noted below, the following statements apply: 1) all samples were received in acceptable condition, 2) all quality control results associated with this sample set were within acceptable limits and/or do not adversely affect the reported results, and 3) the industrial hygiene results have not been blank corrected unless otherwise noted.

Use of EPA/600/R-93/116 satisfies applicable requirements of the USEPA's "Interim Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Insulation Sample", EPA-600/M4-82-020, December 1982, published as Appendix E to Subpart E of 40CFR763. Bulk samples analyzed by New York State methods follow stratified point counting methods (198.1) or Method 198.6 for PLM non-friable organically bound materials (NYSDOH Lab Code –11645). Percentages are visual estimations of asbestos >10:1 aspect ratio. The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples for which asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

NESHAP requires point counting of a bulk sample when the result is <10% by a method other than point counting. EPA, however states that if 3 mounts of the sample are analyzed and the asbestos percentage is <10% by visual estimation, the client may elect to assume the amount to be greater than 1% or require verification by point counting. If the result by point counting is different than the result obtained by visual estimation, the point count result will be used. Sample friability or non-friability noted on the report is a requirement for the State of California and refers only to the condition of the sample under macroscopic examination. It does not imply friability or non-friability for the sample as collected or observed in the field as determined by the person collecting the sample. The Kennesaw, Georgia lab is accredited by NVLAP –Lab Code 101125-0.

(a)Polarized- light microscopy is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor coverings and similar non-friable organically bound materials. Quantitative electron microscopy is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non-asbestos containing. When analysis of such materials by PLM yields results negative for the presence of asbestos, Bureau Veritas recommends utilizing quantitative transmission electron microscopy (TEM). For more information, contact the laboratory.

References

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Work Order No A1103227

McCrone, Walter C. 1980. The Asbestos Particle Atlas. Ann Arbor, MI: Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Inc.

United States Environmental Protection Agency. Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory.

1982. Interim Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Insulation Samples. EPA-600/M4-82-

020. Washington: GPO, December.

United States Environmental Protection Agency. Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Building Materials. EPA-600/R-93/116, July 1993 (PLM)

Fed. Reg. Vol. 55, No.224, 11/20/90, p.48415 (NESHAP) EPA Memorandum 5/8/1991 –NESHAP Clarifications

NYSDOH Methods 198.1/198.6

QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS OF BULK SAMPLES FOR ASBESTOS USING TRANSMISSION

ELECTRON MICROSCOPY (TEM)

Upon receipt in the laboratory, samples are ground until homogeneous. Each sample is weighed in a tared silica crucible. The sample is placed in a muffle furnace at a temperature of 480C for at least 3 hours or until the weight has stabilized. The sample is allowed to cool to room temperature and immediately weighed to calculate percent organic loss.

Approximately 1 ml of nondiluted HCL acid is slowly added to remove calcite and dolomite from the ashed sample. After evolution of CO2 gas has ceased, the sample is immediately diluted with ultra-pure water. The sample is then dispersed in 50 ml of ultra-pure water and filtered onto a pre-weighed 47 mm,

0.45 um pore size, MCE filter. The filter is dried on a slide warmer and weighed once again.

A 1 cm2 portion of the filter is cut and placed in a clean silica crucible. Approximately 250 ul of both 20 ppm methyl cellulose solution and isopropyl alcohol are added and ultra-sonicated for 1 minute to remove the deposited sample into suspension. Approximately 3 ul of the suspension is pipetted onto a carbon-coated copper TEM grid and allowed to dry.

Grids are examined in the TEM at 15,000X magnification. Asbestos is identified using morphology, selected area electron diffraction, and energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy. From TEM examination, a visual area estimation is made of asbestos in the final residue. Percent asbestos in the final residue is then extrapolated using gravimetric records to percent asbestos in the total sample.

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Work Order No A1103227

The Kennesaw, Georgia lab is accredited by NVLAP –Lab Code 101125-0.

References

Chatfield Method for Quantitative Analysis of Bulk Samples for Asbestos Using Transmission Electron Microscopy (unpublished).

United States Environmental Protection Agency. Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Building Materials. EPA-600/R-93/116, July 1993 (PLM)

NOTE: Some of the samples may have contained inseparable layers which were combined during preparation.

Work Order No.: A1103227

Client Reference: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/ 25009-009558.00.300

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 3/18/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 28-Mar-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 28-Mar-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

03/22/2011CF

Sample Morphology

001A 860-11A (R)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

03/15/2011

(1) 30 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Fibrous glass Tar10% Cellulose fiber Granular Minerals5%

Binder/Filler

(2) 15 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Fibrous glass Tar20%

Binder/Filler

(3) 20 Homogeneous Brown Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

(4) 5 Homogeneous Black Tar None Detected Non-Detected Tar

Binder/Filler

(5) 30 Homogeneous Yellow Insulation None Detected Non-Detected Foam

03/22/2011CF

Sample Morphology

002A 860-11B (R)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

03/15/2011

(1) 25 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Cellulose fiber Tar15% Fibrous glass Granular Minerals5%

Binder/Filler

(2) 5 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Fibrous glass Tar5%

Binder/Filler

(3) 50 Homogeneous Brown Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

(4) 5 Homogeneous Black Tar None Detected Cellulose fiber Tar10%

Fibrous glass Binder/Filler5%

(5) 15 Homogeneous Yellow Insulation None Detected Non-Detected Foam

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 3/28/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples for w asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Work Order No.: A1103227

Client Reference: VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/ 25009-009558.00.300

Method Reference: EPA-600/M4-82-020/EPA/600/R-93/116/NYELAP 198.1

Sample Type: Bulk

Date Received: 3/18/2011

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Report Date: 28-Mar-11

CLIENT: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

Date: 28-Mar-11

Lab ID Client Sample ID Analyst Date AnalyzedDate Sampled

03/22/2011CF

Sample Morphology

003A 860-11C (R)

Layer POB Asbestos % Other Fibers % Particulate

03/15/2011

(1) 25 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Fibrous glass Tar10% Cellulose fiber Granular Minerals5%

Binder/Filler

(2) 10 Homogeneous Black Roofing Material None Detected Fibrous glass Tar15%

Binder/Filler

(3) 40 Homogeneous Brown Insulation None Detected Cellulose fiber Binder/Filler95%

(4) 10 Homogeneous Black Tar None Detected Cellulose fiber Tar5%

Fibrous glass Binder/Filler5%

(5) 15 Homogeneous Yellow Insulation None Detected Non-Detected Binder/Filler

Laboratory Limits

Range R Limit

Carol Findlay ( CF)

Quartile Limit 0.1-1 100 +/- 1.482

10-100 100 +/- 26.676 1-10 100 +/- 5.928 Trace 100 +/- 1.482

Range R Limit

Laboratory

Quartile Limit 0.1-1 100 +/- 1.482

10-100 100 +/- 22.23 1-10 100 +/- 7.41 Trace 100 +/- 1.482

Analyst(s) Name/Date: 3/28/2011

The reliable limit of quantitation of the method is 1%, although asbestos may be qualitatively detected at concentrations less than 1%. Samples for w asbestos is detected at <1% are reported as trace, "<1%". "None Detected" indicates that no asbestos fibers were observed.

Date Received: 3/18/2011 3:16:30 PM Report Date: 3/28/2011 3:24:41 PMSample Type: Bulk

Analytical Method: TEM Full-Quant Analysis EPA/600/R-93/116

Grid Box Identification: 03-25-11A-1

Lab Sample No.

Client Sample Identification

Date Sampled

Analysis Date Analyst

Reporting Limit (% by Weight): 0.1

Sample Description (Morphology)

Asbestos Total Asbestos (%)**(%)*Identification

ANALYTICAL RESULTS

Client: BUREAU VERITAS - PLEASANTON

VANDENBERG AFB BLDG 860/ 25009-009558.00.300Client Reference No.:

Work Order No.: A1103227 Date: 28-Mar-11

A1103227-001A 860-11A (R) 03/15/11 @12:00 am

03/28/11 @3:15 pm

KRP Black Roofing None Detected -- < 0.1

Composite layers were analyzed.

Instrument *Magnification Calibration Date

TEM Microscope Documentation Accelerating

Voltage

TEM 1/D675 14530x 3/4/2010100 KeV

*Magnification = Calibrated screen magnification at 15,000X. For ISO Method 10312 the calibrated screen magnification is at 20,000X

Analyst(s) Name/Date:

Result is less than the indicated limit of detection.<:

3/28/2011

--: Present but below the detection limit The visual area estimation of asbestos content in the final residue.*:

**: The calculated total percent asbestos in the sample as received.

SAMPLE AND ASBESTOS LOCATION DRAWINGS

LEGEND BUILDING 860 FIGURE

Vandenberg Air Force Base 1515 Iceland Avenue Vandenberg AFB, California 93437 Vandenberg AFB Project No. XUMU091669E Bureau Veritas Project No. 25009-009558.00

Sample Location

Tool Return

Supply Room

Locker Room

Physical Fitness Room

110 - Dayroom

860-3E(W)

860-1A(P) 860-2A(F) 860-4A(C)

860-1A(P) 860-2A(F) 860-4A(C)

860-8B(F)

860-3A(W)

860-9A(W)

860-3G(W)

860-6A-C(F)

860-7A(W)

860-5A(W)

860-3A(W)

860-10A-C(W)

860-1B(P)

860-3B(W) 860-4B(C) 860-5B(W) 860-7B(W) 860-8A(F) 860-9B(W)

860-3B(W) 860-4B(C) 860-5B(W) 860-7B(W) 860-8A(F) 860-9B(W)

860-3F(W) 860-5C(W) 860-7C(W) 860-8C(F) 860-9C(W)

860-3F(W) 860-5C(W) 860-7C(W) 860-8C(F) 860-9C(W)

860-2B(F)

860-1C(P) 860-2C(F) 860-3C(W)

860-1C(P) 860-2C(F) 860-3C(W)

860-3D(W) 860-4C(C) 860-3D(W) 860-4C(C)

108 - Crew Office

Men’s Restroom

101 - Training 102 Simulator Room

Classroom 1

Classroom 2

Conference Room

Lobby

Women’s Restroom

108a Supt’s Office

NOT TO SCALE

N

Bldg. No. - HA Sample No. - Component (ie: floor, wall) Example: 860-1A(F)

C = Ceiling W = Wall P = Plumbing M = Miscellaneous R = Roof D = Door I = Insulation

SAMPLE NO. PROTOCOL:

F = Floor

Kitchen

LEGEND BUILDING 860 - ROOF FIGURE

Vandenberg Air Force Base 1515 Iceland Avenue Vandenberg AFB, California 93437 Vandenberg AFB Project No. XUMU091669E Bureau Veritas Project No. 25009-009558.00

Sample Location

860-11A(R)

860-11C(R)

860-11B(R)

NOT TO SCALE

N

Bldg. No. - HA Sample No. - Component (ie: floor, wall) Example: 860-1A(F)

C = Ceiling W = Wall P = Plumbing M = Miscellaneous R = Roof D = Door I = Insulation

SAMPLE NO. PROTOCOL:

F = Floor

BUILDING 860 FIGURE

Vandenberg Air Force Base 1515 Iceland Avenue Vandenberg AFB, California 93437 Vandenberg AFB Project No. XUMU091669E Bureau Veritas Project No. 25009-009558.00

Tool Return

Supply Room

Locker Room

Physical Fitness Room

110 - Dayroom

108 - Crew Office

Men’s Restroom

101 - Training 102 Simulator Room

Classroom 1

Classroom 2

Conference Room

Lobby

Women’s Restroom

108a Supt’s Office

NOT TO SCALE

N

Kitchen

LEGEND:

HA-1:

= HA-6:

HA-8

= HA-12

= HA-14 and 15

Note

4” O.D. Mudded Elbows and Fittings (Note located at various locations throughout building)

Black Mastic Associated with 12” x 12” Gray Vinyl Floor Tile

= : Yellow/Black Mastic Associated with Carpet

: Cementitious (Transite ) Panels

: Grout and Adhesive Associated with 12” x 12” Tan Ceramic Tile

: All Gaskets Assumed to Contain Asbestos Greater than 1%

Assumed to Contain Asbestos Greater than 1%)

Assumed to Contain Asbestos Greater than 1%