SSP Attachment 5 - Section M.docx

DOCX document 30 KB Posted

Attached to
Air Combat Training System (ACTS)
Solicitation number
FA3002-10-R-0009
Issued by

About this file

Draft Section M Basis for Award

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
CHANGE TO Q A —
AFI 13-212 Luke Sup 1.pdf PDF
CHANGE TO Q A —
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS —
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS —
Appendix 7 Rev 24 May 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 4 Rev 24 May 10.docx DOCX document
RFP Amendment 002.doc DOC document
Appendix 5 Rev 25 May 10.docx DOCX document
Amend 001 Attach 3 - Attachment 8 to RFP - Gila Bend CBA —
Amend 001 Attach 1 - Page 1 and 34 of RFP Replacement.pdf PDF
Amend 001.doc DOC document
Amend 001 Attach 2 - Appendix 4 —
Appendix 4 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 7 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Attachment 5.3 —
Appendix 6 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Attachment 5.4 WD 2005-3007 Rev 9.txt TXT text file
Appendix 1 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 8 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Attachment 5.2 WD 2005-2023 Rev11 —
Appendix 5 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Attachment 4 - Small Business Subcontracting Checklist.docx DOCX document
Appendix 9 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
ACTS PWS —
RFP —
Attachment 5.1 Luke CBA —
Attachment 6 - DD 254.pdf PDF
Attachment 3 - Past and Present Performance Questionnaire.docx DOCX document
Attachment 7 - Site Visit Security Form.pdf PDF
Appendix 2 26 Apr 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 3 8 Mar 10.docx DOCX document
Attachment 2 - Past Performance Info Sheet.doc DOC document
Attachment 5.3 —
Draft Schedule B.doc DOC document
SSP Attachment 4 - Section L.docx DOCX document
ACTS Industry Q A.docx DOCX document
Industry Question Format.doc DOC document
Appendix 6 28 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 9 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 5 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 4 25 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
ACTS PWS 28 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 2 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 1 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 8 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 3 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Appendix 7 26 Jan 10.docx DOCX document
Show all 48

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Section M – Evaluation Factors for Award

Clauses Incorporated by Reference

52.217-5 Evaluation of Options Jul 1990

BASIS FOR CONTRACT AWARD: This is a competitive best value source selection in which competing offerors' past performance history will be evaluated on a basis significantly more important than cost or price considerations. However, cost/price will contribute substantially to the selection decision.

By submission of its offer, the offeror accedes to all solicitation requirements, including terms and conditions, representations and certifications, and technical requirements, in addition to those identified as evaluation factors or subfactors.

The evaluation process shall proceed as follows:

A. The Government will evaluate the technical proposals and assign ratings of Acceptable, Reasonably Susceptible of Being Made Acceptable, or Unacceptable.

(1) The offeror’s proposal shall, at a minimum, address each of the subfactors in (3) below, as they apply to the PWS. Detailed instructions are included in the proposal preparation instructions section of this solicitation. During evaluation of each proposal, the Government will assign each subfactor a rating as shown in (2) below. A rating of unacceptable in one or more technical subfactors will constitute an overall rating of unacceptable for the technical evaluation.

(2) The ratings consist of:

RATING
DEFINITION
Acceptable
Meets specified minimum performance or capability requirements necessary for acceptable contract performance.

Reasonably Susceptible of Being Made Acceptable An approach which, as proposed, does not meet specified minimum performance/capability requirements necessary for performance due to error(s), omissions(s) or deficiency(ies) which, in the view of the Government, may be corrected through discussions without significant revision of the proposal.

Unacceptable
Does not meet specified minimum performance or capability requirements necessary for acceptable contract performance without a major rewrite or significant revision of the proposal.

(3) Description of Subfactors:

(a) Subfactor 1: Quality Control

Description of Subfactor: This subfactor evaluates the offeror’s ability to develop and implement the Quality Control Process that would be employed in this effort. The plan must explain the process your company will use to develop and evaluate the quality of operation and maintenance, identify, document and immediately correct deficiencies in the short term and identify and document trends resulting in corrective action and continual process improvement in terms of quality, workmanship, and customer support. The standard is met when:

i. The proposal demonstrates a proposed sufficient QC organization, including lines of authority that will successfully evaluate compliance, find and document problems and monitor corrective actions ensuring successful and timely problem resolution and explains how recurring problems will be prevented.

ii. The proposal describes a process that is sufficient for recording, computing and assessing performance measurement data and monitoring corrective actions to ensure successful and timely problem resolution and compliance with the PWS.

iii. The offeror describes a process that results in continuous process improvement and innovation in terms of quality, price/cost, and timeliness.

iv. The plan sufficiently explains how negative trends will be identified, corrective actions will be implemented and recurrent trends will be prevented by site and contract wide.

v. The plan describes the documents and records that your company will develop, keep and use as part of the quality plan.

vi. The proposal adequately describes procedures for making changes and updates to the plan.

vii. The plan describes the method for gathering information, evaluating performance based on the requirements of the PWS, and reporting the results to the Government Quality Assurance Personnel (QAP).

(b) Subfactor 2: Workforce and Organizational Structure

Description of Subfactor: This subfactor evaluates the adequacy of the offeror’s proposed staffing by shift and skill classification for the basic contract period and all option years. The proposal must demonstrate an organizational structure that the company will employ while performing this effort. It must address lines of authority, details of onsite personnel by skill mix, function and numbers. The proposal must address roles, responsibilities, and relationships for each organizational element. The proposal must provide rationale used to develop the organizational structure. The standard has been met when:

i. The proposal demonstrates a staffing/manpower matrix that is consistent with proposed methodology and that provides Full or Part Time Equivalents sufficient to accomplish the projected workload provided in the PWS detailed to the “shop/function” level.

ii. The proposal provides sufficient full or part time equivalents to accomplish the workload provided in the PWS in addition to the rationale for the proposed number of employees and the calculations used to arrive at this number. Additionally, the offeror must adequately explain any efficiency that would be employed if the number of FTEs proposed appears to be lower than typically required to achieve the workload projections and PWS requirements.

iii. The proposal provides detailed job qualifications to include experience, education, and supervisory responsibility for key personnel (branch level or equal and above) positions at each place of performance.

iv. The proposal provides the staff years programmed to be in the workforce for the basic performance period and each following contract period.

v. The proposal provides a description of the teaming arrangements with any subcontractors or joint ventures including the organizational relationship and the responsibilities between the prime and subcontract employees.

vi. The proposal provides plans for personnel certification in critical areas.

vii. The proposal identifies one-deep positions on the organizational chart and explains the plan for backing up these positions.

(c) Subfactor 3: Understanding the Requirement

Description of Subfactor: This subfactor evaluates the company’s overall approach and methodology for accomplishing work requirements identified in the PWS with the appropriate skills, equipment and materials. The plan should convey the ability to have trained personnel in sufficient number at the right place and at the right time. Additionally, the offeror must provide detailed approach to include sound innovations and efficiencies that enhance contract performance and achieve reduction in both contract and Government O&M costs.

i. The offeror describes an approach for scheduling work so that sufficient skills are available to meet ACTS O&M and mission support requirements provided in the PWS.

ii. Describes sufficient procedures/plans for operations/maintenance scheduling, tracking and completing special inspections, scheduled and unscheduled maintenance while continually meeting equipment availability standards.

iii. The offeror’s proposal adequately describes an approach that results in maintenance data input and forms that are required in the PWS are accomplished and that the status indicated on forms and in data systems is accurate.

(d) Subfactor 4 - Service Provider Training Program

Description of Subfactor - This subfactor evaluates the offeror’s method for developing a robust formal training program for operation, maintenance and logistics personnel. The submittal must address both remedial and on-going training. The standard is met when:

i. The offeror provides a training plan that adequately addresses procedures for training, qualifying, certifying and maintaining currency of employees prior to assuming a position and throughout the life of the contract.

ii. The offeror identifies a position responsible for the overall contractor training program and describes the role and responsibilities of the position.

(e) Subfactor 5 – Contractor Transition Plan

Description of Subfactor – This subfactor evaluates the offeror’s transition approach and ability to be prepared to achieve full performance on the first day of contract operations. The standard will be met when the proposal:

i. The offeror provides a detailed description that adequately addresses recruiting, training, certifying, and qualifying personnel during the 30-day Phase-In period that results in sufficient numbers of fully qualified employees by contract start date.

ii. The proposal shows a graphical time-line schedule that addresses start and completion of each event (e.g., interviewing, hiring, human resource actions, training, and start work dates). The time-line shall address inventory for transfer of Government equipment and facilities, assumption of work, materials, GSA leased vehicles and work procedures.

iii. The proposal shows a plan to provide sufficient number and type of GSA leased vehicles to be used in performance of this contract and the timeline for acquiring them.

(f) Small Business Subcontracting Plan (Separate Volume, Not included against page count)

Description of Evaluation Factor - This factor is not considered as a subfactor within the Technical Volume. However, large business offeror’s small business subcontracting plan must be compliant with FAR 52.219-9 and must be accepted by the PCO prior to contract award. Offerors shall provide a plan to maximize participation of small businesses (SB), veteran-owned small business (VOSB), service-disabled veteran-owned small business (SDVOSB), historically underutilized business zone (HUBZone), small disadvantaged business (SDB) and woman-owned small businesses (WOSB) and historically black colleges and universities (HBCU) and minority institutions (MI). The current Government-wide goals for small business participation are provided in the Section L. The offeror provides an acceptable plan when:

i. The proposal provides a clear, detailed, logical and realistic plan for maximizing participation of SB, VOSB, SDVOSB, HUBZone, SDB, WOSB and HBCU/Mis

ii. The plan sufficiently addresses all requirements listed in the AETC Small Business subcontracting checklist provided in Section J, Attachment 4.

B. The Government will evaluate the price proposals, and any other relevant proposal data submitted, to determine if proposed prices are reasonable and balanced based on the offeror (s) proposed approach.

(1) Each offeror’s Total Evaluated Price (TEP) will be calculated as the sum of the all firm fixed price CLINs for the basic period and all option periods. All proposed prices for all contract periods will be evaluated for reasonableness, which may be determined based on prices submitted by the competition, historical pricing, current market conditions, comparison to the Independent Government Estimate, and/or other proposal analysis techniques as described in FAR 15.404-1. Evaluation of option years will not obligate the Government to exercise options.

(2) The Government may require submission of information other than cost or pricing data to the extent necessary to evaluate price reasonableness. A contract will not be awarded to an offeror whose proposed price is not determined reasonable.

(3) Proposed contract line item prices will be evaluated for unbalanced pricing (FAR 15.404-1(g)). Unbalanced pricing exists when, despite an acceptable total evaluated price, the price of one or more contract line items or sub line items appears to be significantly overstated or understated as indicated by the application of price analysis techniques. An offeror’s proposal may be rejected if the Contracting Officer determines that the lack of balance poses an unacceptable risk to the Government.

(4) As discussed in Section L, Part II Price Proposal, Paragraph (g) Financial Responsibility, the standard has been met when the offeror demonstrates financially responsible. To assist the Government in determining financial responsibility, the Government will take into consideration offeror’s proposed funding and financial resources as outlined in Section L. An offeror not determined to be responsible will be ineligible for contract award IAW FAR 9.103(b).

(5) As discussed in Section L, Part II Price Proposal, Paragraph (h) Accounting System, the standard has been met when the offeror’s accounting system has been determined adequate by the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) for accumulating and reporting allowable contractor incurred costs.

C. The Government will evaluate past performance to assess how well the performed work is relevant to the type of effort and type of requirement described in the solicitation as an indicator of an offeror’s ability to perform the contract successfully. The Government will use the following procedures in evaluating past performance:

(1) The Government will accomplish the past performance evaluation, assigning a performance confidence assessment rating to the offeror’s proposal based on performance ratings of recent and relevant efforts.

(2) The Government will seek relevant performance information from: (i) past and present efforts provided by the offeror (using questionnaires, which are forwarded by the contracting officer to the contractor’s selected sources) and (ii) data independently obtained from other Government and commercial sources. The past performance evaluation will take into account past performance information regarding predecessor companies, key personnel, or subcontractors that will perform major or critical aspects of the requirement when such information is relevant to the instant acquisition. The past performance evaluation may also consider the past performance of affiliated companies or operating divisions within the parent company or joint ventures of the parent company when it is reasonable to attribute the experience of these past efforts to the proposed effort and when the clearly demonstrates the resources (e.g. financial resources, overall oversight and management or other resources) of the parent or affiliated division will meaningfully affect performance of the instant acquisition. The past performance of teaming partners or subcontractors who are proposed to perform less than 20% of the work and are not proposed to perform critical aspects will not be evaluated

(a) Recency is defined as performance occurring within the last three (3) years of the date of this solicitation, except that ongoing programs must have begun no less than three (3) months from issuance of the RFP.

(b) Relevant performance includes performance of efforts involving requirements that are similar or greater in scope, magnitude, and complexity than the effort described in this solicitation. Relevancy will be assigned ratings of Very Relevant, Relevant, Somewhat Relevant, and Not Relevant. The Government will give greater consideration to performance on those contracts deemed more relevant to the effort described in this RFP. In determining relevancy for individual contracts, consideration will be given to the effort, or portion of the effort, being proposed by the offeror, teaming partner, or subcontractor.

The following table provides relevancy definitions that will be used:

RELEVANCY DEFINITIONS
RATING
DEFINITION
Very Relevant
Present/past performance effort involved essentially the same magnitude of effort and complexities this solicitation requires.
Relevant
Present/past performance effort involved much of the magnitude of effort and complexities this solicitation requires.
Somewhat Relevant
Present/past performance effort involved some of the magnitude of effort and complexities this solicitation requires.
Not Relevant
Present/past performance effort did not involve any of the magnitude of effort and complexities this solicitation requires.

(c) Performance information may be obtained from the references on each project submitted. The Government may also obtain performance data from other sources.

(i) In addition to evaluating the extent to which the offeror’s performance meets basic contract PWS and technical requirements, the assessment will consider things such as the offeror’s history of forecasting and controlling costs (if applicable,) adhering to schedules, (including the administrative aspects of performance), reasonable and cooperative behavior and commitment to customer satisfaction.

(ii) Where a relevant performance record indicates performance problems, the Government will consider the number and severity of the problems and the appropriateness and effectiveness of any corrective actions taken (not just planned or promised). The Government may review more recent projects or performance evaluations to ensure corrective actions have been implemented and evaluate their effectiveness.

(iii) The following performance definitions will be used in the assessment of performance.

PERFORMANCE DEFINITIONS

PERFORMANCE

RATING

DEFINITION

Exceptional

Performance meets contractual requirements and exceeds many requirements to the Government’s benefit. The contractual performance of the element being assessed was accomplished with few minor problems for which corrective actions taken by the contractor were highly effective.

Very Good

Performance meets contractual requirements and exceeds some requirements to the Government’s benefit. The contractual performance of the element being assessed was accomplished with some minor problems for which corrective actions taken by the contractor were effective.

Satisfactory

Performance meets contractual requirements. The contractual performance of the element being assessed contained some minor problems for which corrective actions taken by the contractor appear or were satisfactory.

Marginal

Performance does not meet some contractual requirements. The contractual performance of the element being assessed reflects a serious problem for which the contractor has not yet identified corrective actions or the contractor’s actions appear only marginally effective or were not fully implemented.

Unsatisfactory

Performance does not meet most contractual requirements and recovery is not likely in a timely manner. The contractual performance of the element being assessed contains serious problem(s) for which the contractor’s corrective actions appear or were ineffective.

Not Applicable
Unable to provide a score. Performance in this area is not applicable to the effort assessed.

(3) The Government will integrate the recency, relevancy and performance on all the efforts evaluated for the offeror; the integration will result in a performance confidence assessment of Substantial Confidence, Satisfactory Confidence, Limited Confidence, No Confidence, or Unknown Confidence as defined below for the offeror. Offerors with no relevant past or present performance history or whose performance record is so limited that no confidence assessment rating can be reasonably assigned shall receive the rating of “Unknown Confidence”, meaning the rating is treated neither favorably nor unfavorably.

PERFORMANCE CONFIDENCE ASSESSMENT DEFINITIONS
Rating
Definition
Substantial Confidence
Based on the offeror’s performance record, the Government has a high expectation that the offeror will successfully perform the required effort.
Satisfactory Confidence
Based on the offeror’s performance record, the Government has an expectation that the offeror will successfully perform the required effort.
Limited Confidence
Based on the offeror’s performance record, the Government has a low expectation that the offeror will successfully perform the required effort.
No Confidence
Based on the offeror’s performance record, the Government has no expectation that the offeror will be able to successfully perform the required effort.
Unknown Confidence
No performance record is identifiable or the offeror’s performance record is so sparse that no confidence assessment rating can be reasonably assigned.

D. After initial evaluation of each offeror’s technical and price proposals, and assessment of each offeror’s past performance, if the lowest reasonably priced technically acceptable offer (by TEP) is determined responsible in accordance with FAR 9.104, and has a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating, award will be made to that offeror without entering into discussions as this represents the best value to the Government.

E. If the lowest reasonably priced offer (by TEP) does not have a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating, the next lowest reasonably priced, technically acceptable, and responsible offeror will be considered and the process will continue (in order by TEP) until the Government reaches an offer with a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating or until all offers are considered, whichever occurs first. The Source Selection Authority will then make an integrated assessment best value award decision unless it is in the Government’s best interest to conduct discussions.

F. The Government intends to award a contract without discussions with respective offerors. Offerors shall submit sufficient information and in the format specified in Proposal Preparation Instructions. Offeror’s may be asked to clarify certain aspects of their proposal (e.g., the relevance of past performance information) or respond to adverse past performance information to which the offeror has not previously had an opportunity to respond. Adverse past performance is defined as past performance information that supports a less than satisfactory rating on any evaluation element or any unfavorable comments received from sources without a formal rating system. Exchanges conducted with regard to adverse past performance or to resolve minor or clerical errors will not constitute discussions, and the contracting officer reserves the right to award a contract without the opportunity for proposal revision.

G. However, the Government reserves the right to conduct discussions if deemed in its best interest. If the Government elects to hold discussions, a competitive range will be established based on FAR 15.306(c) procedures and this solicitation. The Government reserves the right to further limit the number of proposals in the competitive range to the greatest number that will permit an efficient competition among the most highly rated proposals. If the contracting officer determines that an offeror’s proposal should no longer be included in the competitive range, the proposal will be eliminated from consideration for award. Written notice of this decision shall be provided to unsuccessful offerors in accordance with FAR 15.503. Offerors excluded or otherwise eliminated from the competitive range may request a debriefing in accordance with FAR 15.505 or 15.506.

H. After conclusion of discussions and receipt of final proposal revisions, the Government will rank all offers by TEP. If the lowest reasonably priced technically acceptable offer (by TEP), is determined responsible in accordance with FAR 9.104, and has a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating, award will be made to that offeror as this represents the best value to the Government. If the lowest reasonably priced offer (by TEP) does not have a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating, the next lowest reasonably priced, technically acceptable, and responsible offeror will be considered, and the process will continue (in order by TEP) until the Government reaches an offer with a Substantial Confidence performance confidence assessment rating or until all offers are considered, whichever occurs first. The Source Selection Authority will then make an integrated assessment best value award decision.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .