Attch 7 Hazmat AFRL Bldg 3 022924.pdf

443 Electronics Parkway, Liverpool, NY 13088 · Office: 315-457-5200 · Fax: 315-451-0052 · BartonandLoguidice.com

1122.009.001 AFRL Bldg 3 022924.docx

February 29, 2024

Mr. Travis Richards Towne Engineering, PC 18 South Street Utica, New York 13501

Re: Targeted Investigation for Asbestos, PCB Containing

Materials and Lead-Based Paint Characterization HVAC System Upgrade Project – Building 3 Rome Research Site, Rome, New York

File: 1122.009.001

Dear Mr. Richards

This letter and attachments represent Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.’s (B&L’s) report for the referenced project.

Introduction

B&L was retained by Towne Engineering, PC to conduct a targeted pre-renovation asbestos survey and lead-based paint characterization at building 3 located at the Rome Research Site in Rome, New York.

These results are presented in the following asbestos sample table. Potential PCB containing exterior caulk materials impacted by the current scope were also sampled. The survey was performed to accommodate planned renovations in Bays: A,B,C and D.

The survey investigation was conducted by Michael Goff, Jeffrey Brandon and Benjamin Sprague of B&L between January 22, 2024 and February 8, 2024. Mr. Goff, Mr. Brandon and Mr. Sprague are New York State Department of Labor (DOL) certified asbestos inspectors. A copy of each inspector’s certification and B&L’s company license are provided in Attachment A.

Survey Methods

Representative sampling was conducted based upon the planned renovations noted in the project drawings provided. Friable samples were collected in triplicate and submitted for analysis by polarized light microscopy (PLM) with dispersion staining. Non-friable organically bound (NOB) materials were analyzed in accordance with New York State Department of Health requirements. NOBs are first subjected to an ashing and acid washing procedure to properly break down the material. The sample is then analyzed by PLM for asbestos content. If asbestos is found, the analysis is complete. However, a negative result must be confirmed by using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). All asbestos samples were analyzed by AmeriSci Laboratories of New York.

Lu Engineers conducted an asbestos survey of Building 3 in 2020. Lu Engineer’s survey report was used for reference in B&L’s investigation and is provided as an attachment to this report.

Discussion and Results

Asbestos Sampling Results

The survey included the collection of triplicate sets of friable material samples and NOB duplicate sample sets not previously identified in previous surveys, throughout the affected building areas. Items found to be asbestos containing and listed as presumed in our survey table. Laboratory reports, sample chain-of-custody forms, and laboratory certifications are included in Attachment B. Material sample results are summarized in the tables below:

AFRL – Asbestos Results

Sample ID Material Sampled Lab Results

(% Asbestos) Material Location

Building #3

PFIT-AAA Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation Presumed – Based on Previous

Sampling Data

On fiberglass insulated lines

PI-AAA Magnesia and Aircell Type Pipe Insulation & Associated Pipe Fitting Insulation

Older pipe insulation

DUCT-AAA White Cloth Duct Vibration Collars Older air handling units

JC-AAA Sheetrock Joint Compound Select areas

CLLI-1-1,2 2’x4’ Long Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel NAD Various spaces throughout

DUCT-2-1,2 Brown Duct Pin Mastic NAD Older foil covered fiberglass duct insulation

DUCT-3-1,2 Black Duct Seam Sealant 5.4% Chrysotile Between sections of AHU’s, tape-like material

TAR-4-1,2 Black Duct Tar Seam Sealant 2.1% Chrysotile Noted between sections of older AHU’s

BEAM-5-1,2,3 Beam Plaster NAD On expanded metal lathe, around ceiling beams

PFIT-6-1,2,3 Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation NAD On larger fiberglass lines in B Bay Mech Room

JC-7-1,2,3 Joint Compound NAD B Bay Mech Room renovations, on WLSH-14

WLSH-8-1,2,3 Sheetrock – blue paper backer NAD New B Bay mezzanine, no joint compound

CAULK-9-1,2 White Caulk NAD B Bay Mech room wall penetrations

PFIT-10-1,2,3 Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation NAD Larger corridor valves – corridor H

CLLI-11-1,2 2’x2’ Textured w/ Recessed Edge Ceiling Panel

NAD Corridor I

GLUE-12-1,2 Yellow Duct Glue NAD Under fiberglass duct insulation – C Bay Mech Room at top of B Bay Mech stairs

DUCT-13-1,2 Tan Duct Seam Sealant NAD C Bay center AHU’s #6 & 7 – new material

WLSH-14-1,2,3 Sheetrock NAD B Bay Mech Room renovations

AFRL – Asbestos Results

Sample ID Material Sampled Lab Results

(% Asbestos) Material Location

DUCT-15-1,2,3 White Air Handling Unit Sealant 7.9% Chrysotile D Bay perimeter mechanical room –J6-J

PFIT-16-1,2,3 Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation NAD D Bay perimeter mechanical room – J6-J, on fiberglass lines to AHU

CAULK-17-1,2 Grey Louver/Expansion Joint Caulk NAD Building exterior

CAULK-18-1,2 Brown Louver Caulk NAD Sampled roof level, G Bay louvers

CAULK-19-1,2 White over Grey Louver Caulk NAD B Bay louvers

PFIT-20-1,2,3 Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation NAD AHU 6 & 7, over B Bay

NAD: No Asbestos Detected Trace - <1% non ACM as per NYS regulation

Building #3 Of the samples collected, black tar and sealants on air handling units are asbestos containing materials per laboratory analysis. White sealant on air handling units is also asbestos containing. Mud pipe fitting insulation, old magnesia and aircell pipe insulation, white duct vibration collars and some sheetrock joint compound are presumed asbestos containing based on previous sampling data. These materials will be addressed during our abatement design work, for incorporation into your construction documents.

Lead Based-Paint Sampling

The lead-based paint survey of the building was completed by a certified lead inspector. A thorough review of the building components impacted by this project for suspect LBP is first completed by the inspector. These included, but were not limited to: walls, ceilings, mechanical equipment, structural members, and exterior finishes. The LBP sampling was conducted utilizing a SciAps Model X-550 X-ray fluorescence analyzer (XRF). This instrument provides direct reading identifying a lead concentration.

The data collected during the survey was compiled in tabular form for reporting.

The attached XRF report (Attachment D) includes a summary of the reviewed materials, materials sampled, and sample location information. A summary of components/tested surfaces that are considered to have a lead containing finish according to HUD/EPA levels is provided in the table below.

To summarize, the structural steel components and steel catwalk systems are coated with LBP.

B&L’s lead-based paint characterization also included the collection of 12 bulk paint chip confirmatory samples and was comprised of all layers. The lead-based paint laboratory report is included in Appendix B and the paint sample results are summarized in the table below. Samples were analyzed by Phoenix Environmental Laboratories located in Manchester, Connecticut. This sampling did confirm the LBP found by XRF testing, namely the structural steel and catwalk components.

AFRL Building #3 - Lead-Based Paint Sample Results

Sample Number

Painted Component

Component Substrate Color Condition Location

Result (% lead)

P-1 Wall Block Blue Good Corridor 4 0.0215

P-2 Wall Sheetrock White Good Offices B5-A <0.0026

P-3 Wall Block Purple Good Corridor 5 <0.0045

P-4 Wall Block Green Good Corridor A 0.0169

P-5 AHU Metal Grey Fair Mech A6-A 0.0964

P-6 Pipe Insulation Fiberglass Grey Fair Mech C8-C 0.276

P-7 Wall Block Off-White Good Corridor 8 0.0155

P-8 Wall Sheetrock Off-White Good Offices

B6-A <0.0021

P-9 Wall Block Grey Fair Exterior <0.0031

P-10 Wall Black Red Fair Exterior <0.0040

P-11 Catwalk Steel Orange Good Ceiling Space 18.9

P-12 Bar Joist Steel Brown Fair Ceiling Space 0.540

Two samples listed above, highlighted in bold, are considered covered with lead-based paint by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA – HUD) definition (greater than 0.5 % by weight). The

Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) considers paint with any concentration of lead to fall under the OSHA Construction Standard for lead. Contractors disturbing lead-based or lead-containing paint must comply with this Standard cited in - 29 CFR 1926.62. Contractors must also comply with lead-based paint collection and disposal as required by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). The DEC requires that loose and peeling paint to be containerized and disposed of based on the results of a Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) test.

Collected paint chips cannot be disposed of directly as C&D waste.

PCB Caulk Sampling Results

As noted above, exterior caulking samples were analyzed for PCB content. PCB caulk samples were analyzed by Phoenix Environmental laboratories, Inc. located in Manchester, Connecticut.

PCB Sample Results

Sample ID Material Description Results

(PCB ppm)

AFRL Building #3

CAULK-17 Grey Louver/Expansion Joint Caulk - building exterior < 0.890 mg/kg

CAULK-18 Brown Louver Caulk - sampled roof level, G Bay louvers <0.710 mg/kg

CAULK-19 White over Grey Louver Caulk - B Bay louvers <0.960 mg/kg mg/kg = part per million (ppm)

If PCBs are found in caulking at concentrations greater than 50 ppm at the time of disposal, then this material would be considered a PCB Bulk Product Waste and therefore regulated under TSCA. The results from the samples collected indicate the caulk materials are not considered PCB regulated waste.

If you have any questions, please call me at (315) 457-5200. It was a pleasure working with you on this project and I hope we can be of service in the future.

Sincerely, BARTON & LOGUIDICE, D.P.C.

Michael D. Goff John E. Rigge Staff Industrial Hygienist Vice President

Attachments

Asbestos Containing Material Location Plans

ASBESTOS SURVEY LEGEND

ACM MAG TYPE PIPE INSULATION

ACM TRANSITE ROOF DRAIN PIPE

ACM PIPE FITTING INSULATION ON FG LINES

ACM PIPE INSULATION DEBRIS

ACM TRANSITE ROOF DRAIN PIPE

ACM JOINT COMPOUND ON GWB IN ROOM

D8-H 3.11

HVP-C8-1/HVSB-D8-2

D8-H 3.11

HVP-C8-1/HVSB-D8-2

ASBESTOS SURVEY LEGEND

ACM MAG TYPE PIPE INSULATION

ACM AIR HANDLING UNIT SEAM SEALANT

LVP-A6-1/HVSB-D8-2

MCC-A6-1/

HVSB-D8-2

LVP-A7-1/

HVSB-D8-2

D8-H 3.16

D8-H 3.19

F1-E 1.3

F1-E 1.3

F1-E 1.3

DS-TA6A1

T-GS

(T-A6A-1)

CB-LGS

(CB-ELVPGS1)

LVP-A6-1/HVSB-D8-2

MCC-A6-1/

HVSB-D8-2

LVP-A7-1/

HVSB-D8-2

D8-H 3.16

D8-H 3.19

T-GS (T-A6A-1)

CB-LGS (CB-ELVPGS1)

DS-TA6A1

F1-E 1.3

F1-E 1.3

F1-E 1.3

ACM AIR HANDLING UNIT SEAM SEALANT

D8-H 2

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-2/HVSB-D8-1

FIRE PUMP D.S.

D8-H 3

ASBESTOS SURVEY LEGEND

ACM JOINT COMPOUND ON GWB IN ROOM

LVDP-D8-2/HVDP-D8-1

LVDP-D8-1/HVDP-D8-1

LVP-D8-1/HVDP-D8-1

T-LVSBD81

LVSB-D8-1/HVSB-D8-1

D8-H 1

D8-H 2

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 2.5

T-LVDPD81

HVDP-D8-1/

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-2/HVSB-D8-1

FIRE PUMP D.S.

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 3

ASBESTOS SURVEY LEGEND

ACM MAG TYPE PIPE INSULATION

ACM AIR HANDLER UNIT SEAM SEALANT

ACM JOINT COMPOUND ON GWB IN THIS ROOM

XXXX

ACM AIR HANDLER UNIT SEAM SEALANT

ACM DUCTWORK FLEX JOINT

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXX

XXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXX

XXXXXX XXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXX

ACM JOINT COMPOUND ON GWB IN THIS ROOM

ACM SEAM SEALANT ON AIR HANDLING UNIT

XXXXXX ACM DUCT FLEX CONNECTOR

XXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXX

XXXXXXX

ACM DUCT FLEX CONNECTORXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXX

XXXXXX

ACM DUCT FLEX CONNECTORXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXX ACM DUCT FLEX CONNECTOR

ACM MAG TYPE PIPE INSULATION

XXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

ACM TRANSITE ROOF DRAIN PIPE

Attachment A

Certifications

DIVISION OF SAFETY & HEALTH LICENSE AND CERTIFICATE UNIT, STATE OFFICE CAMPUS, BLDG. 12, ALBANY, NY 12226 ASBESTOS HANDLING LICENSE Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway, Liverpool, NY, 13088

This license has been issued in accordance with applicable provisions of Article 30 of the Labor Law of New York State and of the New York State Codes, Rules and Regulations (12 NYCRR Part 56). It is subject to suspension or revocation for a (1) serious violation of state, federal or local laws with regard to the conduct of an asbestos project, or (2) demonstrated lack of responsibility in the conduct of any job involving asbestos or asbestos material.

This license is valid only for the contractor named above and this license or a photocopy must be prominently displayed at the asbestos project worksite. This license verifies that all persons employed by the licensee on an asbestos project in New York State have been issued an Asbestos Certificate, appropriate for the type of work they perform, by the New York State Department of Labor.

Amy Phillips, Director For the Commissioner of Labor

SH 432 (12/21)

License Number:

License Class:

Date of Issue:

Expiration Date:

Duly Authorized Representative:

29267

RESTRICTED

02/01/2024 02/28/2025 Jeffrey Reed

John Rigge Stamp

Attachment B

Laboratory Reports & Sample Chain of Custody Documentation visit our web site - www.amerisci.com

John E. Rigge Marwan A. Alahiri Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C. 224012587

(315) 451-0052 ELAP-PLM/TEM 3 day Results

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3

- Rome, NYjrigge@bartonandloguidice.com, mgoff@bartonandloguidice.com, rthorp@bartonandloguidice.com

Saturday, January 27, 2024 09:08:21

Please Reply To:

Number of Pages:

Client Project:

Fax #:

Time:

From:

Date:

Certified Analysis Service 24 Hours A Day • 7 Days A Week Competitive Prices

LABORATORY ELECTRONIC TRANSMITTAL

Comments:

NOTE: Attached report is to be considered preliminary until final review with accompanying analysis summary letter is issued.

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: Unless otherwise indicated, the information contained in this communication is confidential information intended for use of the individual named above. If the reader of this communication is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender by telephone and return the original message to the above address via the US Postal Service at our expense.

Samples are disposed of in 60 days or unless otherwise instructed by the protocol or special instructions in writing. Thank you.

To:

Subject:

(including cover sheet)

Boston • Los Angeles • New York • Richmond

Email:

AmeriSci Job #:

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

01/25/24 AmeriSci Job # 224012587 01/26/24

ELAP # 11480 1 3

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3 - Rome, NY

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Date Received Date Examined

RE:

ofPage

P.O. # Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Attn: John E. Rigge

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-1-1 224012587-01 NAD Bulk Material1

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 44.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-1-2 224012587-02 NAD Bulk Material1

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 45.9%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoDUCT-2-1 224012587-03 NAD Bulk Material2

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 1.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoDUCT-2-2 224012587-04 NAD Bulk Material2

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 0.6%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

YesDUCT-3-1 224012587-05 5.4% Bulk Material3

Black, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material Chrysotile 5.4 % Non-fibrous 21.4%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

See Reporting notes on last page

AmeriSci Job #: 224012587 Page 2 of 3

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3 - Rome, NY

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

DUCT-3-2 224012587-06 NA/PS

Bulk Material3

Bulk Material

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

YesTAR-4-1 224012587-07 2.1% Bulk Material4

Black, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material Chrysotile 2.1 % Non-fibrous 6.1%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

TAR-4-2 224012587-08 NA/PS

Bulk Material4

Bulk Material

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoBEAM-5-1 224012587-09 NAD Bulk Material5

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoBEAM-5-2 224012587-10 NAD Bulk Material5

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoBEAM-5-3 224012587-11 NAD Bulk Material5

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

AmeriSci Job #: 224012587 Page 3 of 3

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3 - Rome, NY

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-6-1 224012587-12 NAD Bulk Material6

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-6-2 224012587-13 NAD Bulk Material6

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-6-3 224012587-14 NAD Bulk Material6

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/26/24

Reporting Notes:

*NAD/NSD =no asbestos detected; NA =not analyzed; NA/PS=not analyzed/positive stop, (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite;

(SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; PLM Bulk Asbestos Analysis using Motic, Model BA310 Pol Scope, Microscope, Serial #: 1190000538, by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 quantified by either CVES or 400 pt ct as noted for each analysis (NVLAP 200546-0), ELAP PLM Method 198.1 for NY friable samples, which includes the identification and quantitation of vermiculite, or ELAP 198.6 for NOB samples, or EPA 400 pt ct by EPA 600- M4-82-020 (NY ELAP Lab 11480); Note:PLM is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor coverings and similar non-friable organically bound materials. NAD or Trace results by PLM are inconclusive, TEM is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non asbestos-containing in NY State (also see EPA Advisory for floor tile, FR 59,146,38970,8/1/94) National Institute of Standards and Technology Accreditation requirements mandate that this report must not be reproduced except in full without the approval of the lab.This PLM report relates ONLY to the items tested. RI Cert AAL-094, CT Cert PH-0186, Mass Cert AA000054, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

____________END OF REPORT___________

Analyzed by: Bo Sun Date: 1/26/2024

Reviewed by: Marwan A. Alahiri

Client Name:

224012587

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3 - Rome, NY

AmeriSci Job #: Page 1 of 2

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

01 CLLI-1-1 1 0.147 28.7 27.1 44.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

02 CLLI-1-2 1 0.174 26.7 27.4 45.9 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

03 DUCT-2-1 2 0.189 82.9 15.9 1.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

04 DUCT-2-2 2 0.161 84.2 15.1 0.6 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

05 DUCT-3-1 3 0.174 67.6 5.5 21.4 Chrysotile 5.4 NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

06 DUCT-3-2 3 0.250 68.5 5.5 26.0 NA/PS NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

07 TAR-4-1 4 0.329 87.8 4.0 6.2 Chrysotile 2.1 NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

08 TAR-4-2 4 0.215 89.1 3.9 7.0 NA/PS NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

09 BEAM-5-1 5 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

10 BEAM-5-2 5 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

11 BEAM-5-3 5 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

12 PFIT-6-1 6 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

13 PFIT-6-2 6 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

14 PFIT-6-3 6 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

224012587

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.009.001; AFRL; Building 3 - Rome, NY

AmeriSci Job #: Page 2 of 2

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

**Quantitative Analysis (Semi/Full); Bulk Asbestos Analysis - PLM by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 or NYSDOH ELAP 198.1 for New York friable samples or NYSDOH ELAP 198.6 for New York NOB samples;

TEM (Semi/Full) by EPA 600/R-93/116 (or NYSDOH ELAP 198.4; for New York samples). Analysis using Hitachi, Model H7000-Noran 7 System, Microscope, Serial #: 747-05-06. NAD = no asbestos detected during a quantitative analysis; NA = not analyzed; Trace = <1%; (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite; (SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; Quantitation for beginning weights of <0.1 grams should be considered as qualitative only; Qualitative Analysis: Asbestos analysis results of "Present" or "NVA = No Visible Asbestos" represents results for Qualitative PLM or TEM Analysis only (no accreditation coverage available from any regulatory agency for qualitative analyses): NVLAP (PLM) 200546-0, NYSDOH ELAP Lab 11480, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

Warning Note: PLM limitation, only TEM will resolve fibers <0.25 micrometers in diameter. TEM bulk analysis is representative of the fine grained matrix material and may not be representative of non-uniformly dispersed debris for which PLM evaluation is recommended (i.e. soils and other heterogenous materials).

Analyzed by: Marwan A. Alahiri Date: 1/27/2024

Reviewed by: Marwan A. Alahiri visit our web site - www.amerisci.com

John E. Rigge Bo Sun Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C. 224012883

(315) 451-0052 ELAP-PLM/TEM 3 day Results

1122.009.001; Towne Engineering; AFRL Bldg. 3, Rome, New York jrigge@bartonandloguidice.com, mgoff@bartonandloguidice.com, dmorse@bartonandloguidice.com

Thursday, February 1, 2024 03:41:44

Please Reply To:

Number of Pages:

Client Project:

Fax #:

Time:

From:

Date:

Certified Analysis Service 24 Hours A Day • 7 Days A Week Competitive Prices

LABORATORY ELECTRONIC TRANSMITTAL

Comments:

NOTE: Attached report is to be considered preliminary until final review with accompanying analysis summary letter is issued.

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: Unless otherwise indicated, the information contained in this communication is confidential information intended for use of the individual named above. If the reader of this communication is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender by telephone and return the original message to the above address via the US Postal Service at our expense.

Samples are disposed of in 60 days or unless otherwise instructed by the protocol or special instructions in writing. Thank you.

To:

Subject:

(including cover sheet)

Boston • Los Angeles • New York • Richmond

Email:

AmeriSci Job #:

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

01/29/24 AmeriSci Job # 224012883 01/31/24

ELAP # 11480 1 5

1122.009.001; Towne Engineering; AFRL Bldg. 3, Rome, New York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Date Received Date Examined

RE:

ofPage

P.O. # Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Attn: John E. Rigge

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoJC-7-1 224012883-01 NAD Joint Compound7

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoJC-7-2 224012883-02 NAD Joint Compound7

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoJC-7-3 224012883-03 NAD Joint Compound7

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-8-1 224012883-04 NAD Sheetrock8

Brown/White, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-8-2 224012883-05 NAD Sheetrock8

Brown/White, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

AmeriSci Job #: 224012883 Page 2 of 5

1122.009.001; Towne Engineering; AFRL Bldg. 3, Rome, New York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-8-3 224012883-06 NAD Sheetrock8

Brown/White, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCAULK-9-1 224012883-07 NAD White Caulk9

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 3.3%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCAULK-9-2 224012883-08 NAD White Caulk9

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 2.7%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-10-1 224012883-09 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation10

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-10-2 224012883-10 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation10

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-10-3 224012883-11 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation10

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun

AmeriSci Job #: 224012883 Page 3 of 5

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-11-1 224012883-12 NAD 2'x2' Swirl Textured W/Recessed Edge Ceiling Panel11

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 3%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-11-2 224012883-13 NAD 2'x2' Swirl Textured W/Recessed Edge Ceiling Panel11

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 2.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoGLUE-12-1 224012883-14 NAD Yellow Duct Glue12

Yellow, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 15.6%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoGLUE-12-2 224012883-15 NAD Yellow Duct Glue12

Yellow, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 10.7%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoDUCT-13-1 224012883-16 NAD Tan Duct Seam Seal13

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 18.9%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoDUCT-13-2 224012883-17 NAD Tan Duct Seam Seal13

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 18%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun

AmeriSci Job #: 224012883 Page 4 of 5

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-1 224012883-18 NAD Sheetrock14

Brown/White, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-2 224012883-19 NAD Sheetrock14

Brown/Gray, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-3 224012883-20 NAD Sheetrock14

Brown/White, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

YesDUCT-15-1 224012883-21 7.9% White AHU Sealant15

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material Chrysotile 7.9 % Non-fibrous 23.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

DUCT-15-2 224012883-22 NA/PS

White AHU Sealant15

Bulk Material

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-16-1 224012883-23 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation16

Gray, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 10%, Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 80%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun

AmeriSci Job #: 224012883 Page 5 of 5

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-16-2 224012883-24 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation16

Gray, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 10%, Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 80%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPFIT-16-3 224012883-25 NAD Mud Pipe Fitting Insulation16

Gray, Homogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 5%, Fibrous glass 10%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Bo Sun on 01/31/24

Reporting Notes:

*NAD/NSD =no asbestos detected; NA =not analyzed; NA/PS=not analyzed/positive stop, (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite;

(SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; PLM Bulk Asbestos Analysis using Motic, Model BA310 Pol Scope, Microscope, Serial #: 1190000538, by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 quantified by either CVES or 400 pt ct as noted for each analysis (NVLAP 200546-0), ELAP PLM Method 198.1 for NY friable samples, which includes the identification and quantitation of vermiculite, or ELAP 198.6 for NOB samples, or EPA 400 pt ct by EPA 600- M4-82-020 (NY ELAP Lab 11480); Note:PLM is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor coverings and similar non-friable organically bound materials. NAD or Trace results by PLM are inconclusive, TEM is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non asbestos-containing in NY State (also see EPA Advisory for floor tile, FR 59,146,38970,8/1/94) National Institute of Standards and Technology Accreditation requirements mandate that this report must not be reproduced except in full without the approval of the lab.This PLM report relates ONLY to the items tested. RI Cert AAL-094, CT Cert PH-0186, Mass Cert AA000054, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

____________END OF REPORT___________

Analyzed by: Bo Sun Date: 1/31/2024

Reviewed by: Khaalid W. Perine

224012883

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.009.001; Towne Engineering; AFRL Bldg. 3, Rome, New York

AmeriSci Job #: Page 1 of 2

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

01 JC-7-1 7 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Joint CompoundLocation:

02 JC-7-2 7 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Joint CompoundLocation:

03 JC-7-3 7 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Joint CompoundLocation:

04 WLSH-8-1 8 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

05 WLSH-8-2 8 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

06 WLSH-8-3 8 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

07 CAULK-9-1 9 0.221 33.7 63.0 3.3 NAD NAD

White CaulkLocation:

08 CAULK-9-2 9 0.260 33.4 63.9 2.7 NAD NAD

White CaulkLocation:

09 PFIT-10-1 10 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

10 PFIT-10-2 10 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

11 PFIT-10-3 10 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

12 CLLI-11-1 11 0.250 25.1 71.9 3.0 NAD NAD

2'x2' Swirl Textured W/Recessed Edge Ceiling PanelLocation:

13 CLLI-11-2 11 0.250 14.9 82.4 2.8 NAD NAD

2'x2' Swirl Textured W/Recessed Edge Ceiling PanelLocation:

14 GLUE-12-1 12 0.159 79.3 5.0 15.6 NAD NAD

Yellow Duct GlueLocation:

15 GLUE-12-2 12 0.107 77.4 11.9 10.7 NAD NAD

Yellow Duct GlueLocation:

16 DUCT-13-1 13 0.309 29.9 51.2 18.9 NAD NAD

Tan Duct Seam SealLocation:

224012883

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.009.001; Towne Engineering; AFRL Bldg. 3, Rome, New York

AmeriSci Job #: Page 2 of 2

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

17 DUCT-13-2 13 0.242 29.6 52.4 18.0 NAD NAD

Tan Duct Seam SealLocation:

18 WLSH-14-1 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

19 WLSH-14-2 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

20 WLSH-14-3 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

SheetrockLocation:

21 DUCT-15-1 15 0.233 43.1 25.2 23.8 Chrysotile 7.9 NA

White AHU SealantLocation:

22 DUCT-15-2 15 0.277 44.5 25.7 29.8 NA/PS NA

White AHU SealantLocation:

23 PFIT-16-1 16 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

24 PFIT-16-2 16 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

25 PFIT-16-3 16 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Mud Pipe Fitting InsulationLocation:

**Quantitative Analysis (Semi/Full); Bulk Asbestos Analysis - PLM by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 or NYSDOH ELAP 198.1 for New York friable samples or NYSDOH ELAP 198.6 for New York NOB samples;

TEM (Semi/Full) by EPA 600/R-93/116 (or NYSDOH ELAP 198.4; for New York samples). Analysis using Hitachi, Model H7000-Noran 7 System, Microscope, Serial #: 747-05-06. NAD = no asbestos detected during a quantitative analysis; NA = not analyzed; Trace = <1%; (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite; (SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; Quantitation for beginning weights of <0.1 grams should be considered as qualitative only; Qualitative Analysis: Asbestos analysis results of "Present" or "NVA = No Visible Asbestos" represents results for Qualitative PLM or TEM Analysis only (no accreditation coverage available from any regulatory agency for qualitative analyses): NVLAP (PLM) 200546-0, NYSDOH ELAP Lab 11480, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

Warning Note: PLM limitation, only TEM will resolve fibers <0.25 micrometers in diameter. TEM bulk analysis is representative of the fine grained matrix material and may not be representative of non-uniformly dispersed debris for which PLM evaluation is recommended (i.e. soils and other heterogenous materials).

Analyzed by: Khaalid W. Perine Date: 2/1/2024

Reviewed by: Khaalid W. Perine

Attachment C

2020 Lu Engineers Asbestos Survey Report

Attachment D

Eco-Testing

Lead Based Paint Inspection Report

Conducted by:

LBP-R-121052-2

Project:

Rome Research Site-Building 3

Rome, NY 13441

Lead-Based Paint XRF Testing Report

Prepared For:

Barton & Loguidice

443 Electronics Parkway Liverpool, NY 13088

Eco-Testing Services, LLC.

213 Sydney Terrace Newfield, NY 14867

2/13/2024

Daryl Heffron

2/13/2024

To:

David Morse Barton & Loguidice 443 Electronics Parkway Liverpool, NY 13088

RE: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

Dear David:

On February 8, 2024, Eco-Testing Services conducted XRF testing for the presence of lead-based paint, as directed by Barton & Loguidice, at the above captioned location.

The instruments were operated with the guidance from the Performance Characteristics Sheets published by the US Department of HUD and the results classified as positive or negative based the HUD action level of 1.00 mg/cm². Results less than 1.00 mg/cm² are considered negative and results greater than 1.00 mg/cm² are considered positive. For renovation purposes, as well as OSHA implications, it should be noted the lead present in levels less than 1.00 mg/cm² could generate dust that exceeds acceptable levels depending on the renovation or demolition being performed. For OSHA purposes, there are no accepted standards other than “zero” for lead content in surfaces that are affected so as to release lead in the form of dust. XRF readings at the lower end of the range (close to zero) are less likely to create toxic situations. XRF readings with negative prefixes correlate to very low lead levels in that particular surface. For conclusive, task-oriented results, contractors should follow all applicable OSHA requirements found in regulation 1926.62.

The walls in each space oriented in a clockwise fashion, with wall #1 oriented to the front of the building. Please refer to the building plans for clarification. An “NA” indicates that the room was not accessible during testing, and “NP” indicates that there were no painted surfaces within that space. During the testing procedures, Eco- Testing personnel were able to gain access to all of the designated spaces and tested the rooms that were requested.

Summary of Positive Findings LOCATION ADDRESS: Rome Research Site-Building 3, Rome NY 13441

Positive test results for the presence of lead-based paint in concentrations equal to or greater than 1.00 mg/cm² are:

Positive components by substrate:

Building 1 Metal: Support Post (2) Catwalk (2)

If you have any questions regarding this report, please feel free to give us a call at any time.

Sincerely Yours, Daryl Heffron Eco-Testing Services, LLC

Floor Plans

D8-H 2

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-2/HVSB-D8-1

FIRE PUMP D.S.

D8-H 314

LVDP-D8-2/HVDP-D8-1

LVDP-D8-1/HVDP-D8-1

LVP-D8-1/HVDP-D8-1

T-LVSBD81

LVSB-D8-1/HVSB-D8-1

D8-H 1

D8-H 2

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 2.5

T-LVDPD81

HVDP-D8-1/

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-1

HVSB-D8-2/HVSB-D8-1

FIRE PUMP D.S.

D8-H 2.5

D8-H 3

Ext 19

Daily Calibrations

Eco-Testing Services, LLC 213 Sydney Terrace, Newfield, NY 14867

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

# Date / Time Type Pass / Fail mg/cm2 1 2/8/2024 9:46 Calibration Pass 0.9 2 2/8/2024 9:46 Calibration Pass 0.9 3 2/8/2024 9:46 Calibration Pass 1 4 2/8/2024 9:46 Calibration Pass 0.9

131 2/8/2024 14:27 Calibration Pass 0.9 132 2/8/2024 14:27 Calibration Pass 1 133 2/8/2024 14:27 Calibration Pass 1 134 2/8/2024 14:27 Calibration Pass 0.9

Calibrations

Summary

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

# Component # Tested Negative % Negative # Tested Positive % Positive Total Tested Total %

1 AHU 39 100.00% 0 0.00% 39 100.00%

2 Bar Joist 5 100.00% 0 0.00% 5 100.00% 3 Ceiling 1 100.00% 0 0.00% 1 100.00% 4 Ceiling Grid 2 100.00% 0 0.00% 2 100.00% 5 Ceiling I-Beam 2 100.00% 0 0.00% 2 100.00% 6 Duct 18 100.00% 0 0.00% 18 100.00% 7 Floor 2 100.00% 0 0.00% 2 100.00% 8 Grate/Cover 1 100.00% 0 0.00% 1 100.00% 9 Hand Rail 3 60.00% 2 40.00% 5 100.00%

10 Structural Steel 4 100.00% 0 0.00% 4 100.00% 11 Pipe 4 100.00% 0 0.00% 4 100.00% 12 Radiator 1 100.00% 0 0.00% 1 100.00% 13 Support Post 3 60.00% 2 40.00% 5 100.00% 14 Wall 37 100.00% 0 0.00% 37 100.00%

Summary Analysis

Confirmed Positives

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

Reading # Room Tested # Wall Component Substrate Color Results mg/cm2 63 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Brown Positive 3.3 64 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Brown Positive 3.2

108 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Catwalk Metal Orange Positive 2.5 109 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Catwalk Metal Orange Positive 4.8

Confirmed Positives

XRF Results

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

Reading # Room # Wall Component Substrate Condition Results mg/cm2 5 Cor-4 1 Wall 2 Wall Masonry White Negative 0.1 6 Cor-4 1 Wall 2 Wall Masonry Blue Negative 0.1 7 Cor-4 1 Wall 2 Ceiling Grid Metal White Negative 0 8 Cor-4 1 Wall 4 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 9 Cor-4 1 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 10 Cor-4 1 Wall 4 Wall Masonry White Negative 0 11 Cor-5 2 Wall 1 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 12 Cor-6 2 Wall 2 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 13 Cor-7 2 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 14 Cor-8 2 Wall 4 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 15 A4-A 3 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Blue Negative 0 16 4 Wall 1 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Blue Negative 0 17 4 Wall 2 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Blue Negative 0 18 4 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Blue Negative 0 19 4 Wall 4 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Blue Negative 0 20 4 Wall 4 Grate/Cover Metal White Negative 0 21 4 Wall 4 Ceiling Grid Metal White Negative 0 22 Cor-5 5 Wall 4 Wall Masonry White Negative 0 23 Cor-5 5 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Purple Negative 0 24 Cor-5 5 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Green Negative 0 25 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.3 26 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.3 27 A6-A 6 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 28 A6-A 6 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 29 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2 30 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2 31 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.3 32 A6-A 6 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2 33 A6-A 6 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 34 A6-A 6 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 35 A7-A 7 Wall 1 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 36 A7-A 7 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 37 A7-A 7 Wall 3 Radiator Metal Brown Negative 0 38 B8-A 8 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 39 Cor-7 9 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 40 Cor-7 9 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 41 Cor-7 9 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 42 C8-C 10 Wall 4 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2 43 C8-C 10 Wall 4 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 44 C8-C 10 Wall 4 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 45 C8-C 10 Wall 4 Pipe Metal Brown Negative 0.1 46 Cor-8 11 Wall 4 Wall Masonry Yellow Negative 0 47 Cor-C 12 Wall 1 Wall Masonry Green Negative 0 48 C8-A 13 Wall 1 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 49 C8-A 13 Wall 3 Support Post Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0

XRF & Labs

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

Reading # Room # Wall Component Substrate Condition Results mg/cm2 XRF & Labs

50 Cor-D 14 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Red Negative 0 51 Cor-D 14 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum White Negative 0 52 E8-A 15 Wall 3 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Gray Negative 0 53 E6-A 16 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 54 E6-A 16 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 55 E6-A 16 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 56 E6-A 16 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 57 F8-J 17 Wall 1 Wall Plaster-Gypsum Green Negative 0 58 F8-J 17 Wall 1 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 59 F8-J 17 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 60 F8-J 17 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 61 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Pipe Metal Red Negative 0 62 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Pipe Metal Black Negative 0 63 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Brown Positive 3.3 64 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Brown Positive 3.2 65 F8-J 17 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 66 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Structural Steel Metal Brown Negative 0 67 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Structural Steel Metal Brown Negative 0 68 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Structural Steel Metal Brown Negative 0 69 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Gray Negative 0 70 F8-J 17 Wall 3 Support Post Metal Gray Negative 0 71 Cor-4.5 18 Wall 3 Wall Masonry Orange Negative 0 72 Exterior 19 Wall 2 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 73 Exterior 19 Wall 2 Wall Masonry Gray Negative 0 74 17-B 20 Wall 1 Wall Masonry White Negative 0 75 17-B 20 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 76 17-B 20 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 77 17-B 20 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 78 17-B 20 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 79 17-B 20 Wall 3 Floor Masonry Gray Negative 0.1 80 J6-H 21 Wall 1 Floor Masonry Gray Negative 0 81 J6-H 21 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 82 J6-H 21 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.5 83 J6-H 21 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 84 J6-H 21 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 85 J6-H 21 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 86 J6-H 21 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 87 J6-H 21 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 88 J6-H 21 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 89 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 90 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 91 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Ceiling Masonry Gray Negative 0 92 J6-C 22 Wall 3 CatWalk Metal Gray Negative 0 93 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 94 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0

Client:

Barton Loguidice

Project: Rome Research Site-Building 3 Rome, NY 13441

Reading # Room # Wall Component Substrate Condition Results mg/cm2 XRF & Labs

95 J6-C 22 Wall 3 Pipe Metal Brown Negative 0 96 Exterior 19 Wall 1 Wall Masonry Red Negative 0 97 Exterior 19 Wall 1 Wall Masonry Red Negative 0 98 AHU-4C 23 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 99 AHU-4C 23 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2

100 AHU-4C 23 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 101 AHU-4C 23 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 102 AHU-5B 24 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.2 103 AHU-5B 24 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 104 AHU-5B 24 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 105 AHU-5B 24 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 106 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 107 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 108 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 CatWalk Metal Orange Positive 2.5 109 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 CatWalk Metal Orange Positive 4.8 110 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Bar Joist Metal Brown Negative 0 111 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Bar Joist Metal Brown Negative 0 112 AHU-5B 24 Wall 3 Bar Joist Metal Brown Negative 0 113 AHU-5C 25 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 114 AHU-5C 25 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 115 AHU-5C 25 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 116 AHU-5C 25 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 117 AHU-5C 25 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 118 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 Duct Metal Gray Negative 0 119 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 120 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 121 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0 122 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 123 AHU-7C 26 Wall 1 AHU Metal Gray Negative 0.1 124 C-Bay 27 Wall 1 Structural Steel Metal Brown Negative 0 125 B-Bay 28 Wall 1 Bar Joist Metal Brown Negative 0 126 B-Bay 28 Wall 1 Bar Joist Metal Brown Negative 0 127 New Catwalk 29 Wall 1 CatWalk Metal Gray Negative 0 128 New Catwalk 29 Wall 1 CatWalk Metal Gray Negative 0 129 New Catwalk 29 Wall 1 Ceiling I-Beam Metal Gray Negative 0 130 New Catwalk 29 Wall 1 Ceiling I-Beam Metal Gray Negative 0

Daryl Heffron, Risk Assessor

The Individual listed below completed XRF testing at the Rome Research Site Building 3:

Signature Page

E co-T esting S ervices, LLC has fulfilled the requirem ents of the T oxic S ubstances C ontrol A ct (T

S C

A ) S ection 402, and has received certification to conduct lead-based paint activities pursuant to 40 C

F R

P art 745.226

A ll E

P A

A dm inistered Lead-based P aint A ctivities P rogram

S tates, T ribes and T erritories

T his certification is valid from the date of issuance and expires S eptem ber 30, 2024

C ertification #

LB

P

-F 229091-1

Issued O n

S eptem ber 16, 2021

M ichelle P rice, C hief

Lead, H eavy M etals, and Inorganics B ranch

D aryl R

H effron has fulfilled the requirem ents of the T oxic S ubstances C ontrol A ct (T

S C

A ) S ection 402, and has received certification to conduct lead-based paint activities pursuant to 40 C

F R

P art 745.226 as:

A ll E

P A

A dm inistered Lead-based P aint A ctivities P rogram

S tates, T ribes and T erritories

T his certification is valid from the date of issuance and expires M arch 30, 2024

C ertification #

LB

P

-R -121052-2

Issued O n

F ebruary 08, 2021

B en C onetta, C hief

C hem icals and M ultim edia P rogram s B ranch

R isk A ssessor

SciAps X-550 PCS February 2022 Action Level: 1.0 mg/cm2

Performance Characteristic Sheet

EFFECTIVE DATE: February 1, 2022

MANUFACTURER AND MODEL:

Make: SciAps

Models: Model X-550

X-Ray Source: Rhodium (Rh) or Gold (Au) Anode

FIELD OPERATION GUIDANCE

ACTION LEVEL SETTING:

1.0 mg/cm2

OPERATING PARAMETERS:

Timed mode: fixed 10-second reading.

Quick mode: variable-time reading (approximately 2-6 seconds).

XRF CALIBRATION CHECK LIMITS:

0.8 to 1.2 mg/cm2 (inclusive) on NIST SRM 2579 (1.02 mg/cm2)/NIST SRM 2573, or equivalent

SUBSTRATE CORRECTION:

Not applicable

INCONCLUSIVE RANGE OR THRESHOLD:

Au Anode (quick)

READING DESCRIPTION

SUBSTRATE THRESHOLD (mg/cm2)

Results not corrected for substrate bias on any substrate

Brick 1.0 Concrete 1.0 Drywall 1.0 Metal 1.0

Plaster 1.0 Wood 1.0

Rh Anode (Timed or Quick), Au Anode (Timed)

READING DESCRIPTION

SUBSTRATE THRESHOLD (mg/cm2)

Results not corrected for substrate bias on any substrate

Brick 0.9 Concrete 0.9 Drywall 0.9 Metal 0.9

Plaster 0.9 Wood 0.9

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

EVALUATION DATA SOURCE AND DATE:

This sheet is supplemental information to be used in conjunction with Chapter 7 of the HUD Guidelines for the

Evaluation and Control of Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Housing, 2012 Edition ("HUD Guidelines"). Performance parameters shown on this sheet are calculated using test results on building components in the HUD archive.

Testing was conducted on 146 test samples in February 2022, with two separate instruments of each Anode type, operated in both Timed and Quick modes.

OPERATING PARAMETERS

Performance parameters shown in this sheet are applicable only when properly operating the instrument using the manufacturer's instructions and procedures described in Chapter 7 of the HUD Guidelines.

XRF CALIBRATION…