Attch 4 B2 Haz Mat Report.pdf

443 Electronics Parkway, Liverpool, NY 13088 · Office: 315‐457‐5200 · Fax: 315‐451‐0052 · BartonandLoguidice.com

1122.005.001 DFAS Bldg 2 Investigation 092321.docx

September 23, 2021

Christopher D. Krecidlo, P.E.

Towne Engineering, PC 18 South Street Utica, New York 13501

Re: Limited Pre‐Renovation Asbestos Survey and Lead‐Based Paint Characterization

Boiler Replacement and HW to Stream Conversion – DFAS Building 2 Rome Research Site, Rome, New York

File: 1122.005.001

Dear Mr. Krecidlo:

This letter and attachments represent Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.’s (B&L’s) report for the referenced project.

Introduction

B&L was retained by Towne Engineering, PC to conduct a targeted pre‐renovation asbestos survey and lead‐based paint characterization at the above referenced building located at the Rome Research Site in Rome, New York. The survey was performed to accommodate planned renovations.

The survey investigation was conducted by Michael Goff of B&L on September 8 and 9, 2021.

Mr. Goff is a New York State Department of Labor (DOL) certified asbestos inspector. A copy of the inspector’s certification and B&L’s company license are provided in Attachment A.

Survey Methods

Representative sampling was conducted based upon the planned renovations noted in the project scope provided. Friable samples were collected in triplicate and submitted for analysis by polarized light microscopy (PLM) with dispersion staining. Non‐friable organically bound (NOB) materials were analyzed in accordance with New York State Department of Health requirements. NOBs are first subjected to an ashing and acid washing procedure to properly break down the material. The sample is then analyzed by PLM for asbestos content. If asbestos is found, the analysis is complete. However, a negative result must be confirmed by using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). All asbestos samples were analyzed by AmeriSci Laboratories of New York.

Discussion and Results

Asbestos Sampling Results

The survey included the collection of triplicate sets of friable material samples and NOB duplicate sample sets throughout. Laboratory reports, sample chain‐of‐custody forms, and laboratory certifications are included in Attachment B. Material sample results are summarized in the table below:

Rome Research Site – Asbestos Results

Sample

ID

Material Sampled

Lab Results (% Asbestos)

Material Location

Building #2

PFIT‐AAA Pipe Fitting Insulation Presumed Asbestos

RIOC Office and Engineer Shops

TRANS‐AAA Transite Wall Panel Presumed Asbestos

Custodial Office/Storage

WLSH‐1‐1,2,3 Typical Sheetrock NAD Walls

FRSTP‐2‐1,2 Red Firestop Material NAD Wall penetrations

CLLI‐3‐1,2 2’x2’ Rough Texture Ceiling Panel NAD North Break Room & Restrooms

CLLI‐4‐1,2 2’x4’ Long Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel

NAD Corridor B

CLLI‐5‐1,2 2’x4’ Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel NAD Corridor B ‐ outside entrance

CLLI‐6‐1,2 2’x4’ Dimple & Pinhole Ceiling Panel NAD Office area B

CLLI‐7‐1,2 2’x2’ Smooth Ceiling Panel NAD Mailroom

CLLI‐8‐1,2 2’x2’ Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel NAD South Restrooms

MAS‐9‐1,2 Tan Duct Mastic NAD Metal ducts above ceiling – South Restrooms

SEALANT‐

10‐1,2

White Fiberglass Pipe Insulation Sealant

NAD Painted on ends of newer fiberglass insulation throughout

SEALANT‐

11‐1,2

Grey Duct Sealant NAD Painted on seams of metal ductwork – North

MAS‐12‐1,2 Tan Duct Mastic NAD Painted on interior seams of Garage Bay ductwork

SEALANT‐

13‐1,2

White Duct Seam Sealant NAD Between sections of Garage Bay ductwork – noted on interior

Rome Research Site – Asbestos Results

Sample

ID

Material Sampled

Lab Results (% Asbestos)

Material Location

WLSH‐14‐

1,2,3

Sheetrock Wall Panel w/ Canvas Cover

NAD Custodial Office/Storage

PIN‐15‐1,2 Brown Duct Pin Mastic NAD Fiberglass insulation pins – Garage Bay ductwork

NAD: No Asbestos Detected Trace ‐ <1% non ACM as per NYS regulation

Building #2

None of the samples collected at this time, none were found to contain asbestos as per laboratory analysis. Pipe fitting insulation on older fiberglass lines was noted above the RIOC Office and Engineer Shop. These fittings should are assumed asbestos containing due to age and inaccessibility. Transite wall panels surrounding the upper portion of the Custodial Area are assumed asbestos containing. These materials will be addressed during our abatement design work, for incorporation into your construction documents.

Lead Based‐Paint Sampling

The lead‐based paint characterization included the collection of 6 paint chip samples and was comprised of all layers. The lead‐based paint laboratory report is included in Attachment B and the paint sample results are summarized in the table below.

Rome Research Site – Lead Paint Sample Results

Sample Number

Painted Component

Component Substrate

Color Condition Location Result (% lead)

Building #2

PAINT‐1 Beams Metal Yellow Fair Verticals‐ floor level 9.11

PAINT‐2 Beams Metal Tan Fair Throughout 29.9

PAINT‐3 Walls Sheetrock White Good Offices 0.0024

PAINT‐4 Beams Metal Grey Fair Throughout 19.3

PAINT‐5 Wall Sheetrock Grey Fair North offices 0.0099

PAINT‐6 Wall Sheetrock/

Block

Off‐ White/ Mauve Good

South Restrooms 8.34

In the table above, the samples collected have been listed along with the location, component, substrate, color, condition and laboratory result. Sample locations are illustrated attached figures. Of the samples collected, those in highlighted in bold are considered lead‐based paint by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA – HUD) definition (greater than 0.5 % by weight). The Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) considers paint with any concentration of lead to fall under the OSHA Construction Standard for lead. Contractors disturbing lead‐based or lead‐containing paint must comply with this Standard cited in ‐ 29 CFR

1926.62. Contractors must also comply with lead‐based paint collection and disposal as required by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). The DEC requires that loose and peeling paint to be containerized and disposed of based on the results of a Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure (TCLP) test. Collected paint chips cannot be disposed of directly as C&D waste.

If you have any questions, please call me at (315) 457‐5200. It was a pleasure working with you on this project and I hope we can be of service in the future.

Sincerely, BARTON & LOGUIDICE, D.P.C.

Michael D. Goff John E. Rigge Staff Industrial Hygienist Vice President

MDG/JER/jms

Attachments

Sample Location Drawings

PAINT-5

SEALANT-10-2

SEALANT-11-1,2

WLSH-1-3

WLSH-1-2

PAINT-3

CLLI-3-1,2

CLLI-4-1,2

CLLI-5-1,2CLLI-6-1,2

FRSTP-2-1,2

WLSH-1-1

PRESUMED ASBESTOS

PIPE FITTING

INSULATION ABOVE

DROP-CEILING

PAINT-1

PAINT-2

PAINT-4

WLSH-14-1,2,3

PRESUMED

ASBESTOS TRANSITE

WALL PANELS

CLLI-7-1,2

PRESUMED ASBESTOS

PIPE FITTING

INSULATION

CLLI-8-1,2

MAS-9-1,2

PAINT-6

SEALANT-10-1

MAS-12-1,2

SEALANT-13-1,2

PIN-15-1,2

Attachment A

Certifications

New York State – Department of Labor Division of Safety and Health License and Certificate Unit State Campus, Building 12

Albany, NY 12240

ASBESTOS HANDLING LICENSE

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

FILE NUMBER: 99-0130

LICENSE NUMBER: 29267

LICENSE CLASS: RESTRICTED

DATE OF ISSUE: 01/26/2021

EXPIRATION DATE: 02/28/2022

Duly Authorized Representative – Scott D Nostrand:

This license has been issued in accordance with applicable provisions of Article 30 of the Labor Law of New York State and of the New York State Codes, Rules and Regulations (12 NYCRR Part 56). It is subject to suspension or revocation for a (1) serious violation of state, federal or local laws with regard to the conduct of an asbestos project, or (2) demonstrated lack of responsibility in the conduct of any job involving asbestos or asbestos material.

This license is valid only for the contractor named above and this license or a photocopy must be prominently displayed at the asbestos project worksite. This license verifies that all persons employed by the licensee on an asbestos project in New York State have been issued an Asbestos Certificate, appropriate for the type of work they perform, by the New York State Department of Labor.

Eileen M. Franko, Director SH 432 (8/12) For the Commissioner of Labor

Attachment B

Laboratory Reports & Sample Chain‐of‐Custody Documentation visit our web site - www.amerisci.com

John E. Rigge Jared C. Clarke Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C. 221091930

ELAP-PLM/TEM 3 day Results 1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York jrigge@bartonandloguidice.com, mgoff@bartonandloguidice.com, dmorse@bartonandloguidice.com

Tuesday, September 14, 2021 12:25:45

Please Reply To:

Number of Pages:

Client Project:

Fax #:

Time:

From:

Date:

Certified Analysis Service 24 Hours A Day • 7 Days A Week Competitive Prices

LABORATORY ELECTRONIC TRANSMITTAL

Comments:

NOTE: Attached report is to be considered preliminary until final review with accompanying analysis summary letter is issued.

CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: Unless otherwise indicated, the information contained in this communication is confidential information intended for use of the individual named above. If the reader of this communication is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify the sender by telephone and return the original message to the above address via the US Postal Service at our expense.

Samples are disposed of in 60 days or unless otherwise instructed by the protocol or special instructions in writing. Thank you.

To:

Subject:

(including cover sheet)

Boston • Los Angeles • New York • Richmond

Email:

AmeriSci Job #:

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

AmeriSci New York

117 EAST 30TH ST.

NEW YORK, NY 10016

TEL: (212) 679-8600 • FAX: (212) 679-3114

09/11/21 AmeriSci Job # 221091930 09/14/21

ELAP # 11480 1 6

1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Date Received Date Examined

RE:

ofPage

P.O. # Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Attn: John E. Rigge

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-1-1 221091930-01 NAD Bulk Material1

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 12%, Fibrous glass Trace, Non-fibrous 88%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-1-2 221091930-02 NAD Bulk Material1

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 10%, Fibrous glass Trace, Non-fibrous 90%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-1-3 221091930-03 NAD Bulk Material1

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 25%, Fibrous glass Trace, Non-fibrous 75%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoFRSTP-2-1 221091930-04 NAD Bulk Material2

Red, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 16.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoFRSTP-2-2 221091930-05 NAD Bulk Material2

Red, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 16.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

See Reporting notes on last page

AmeriSci Job #: 221091930 Page 2 of 6

1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-3-1 221091930-06 NAD Bulk Material3

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 2.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-3-2 221091930-07 NAD Bulk Material3

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 4.5%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-4-1 221091930-08 NAD Bulk Material4

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 52.3%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-4-2 221091930-09 NAD Bulk Material4

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 52.6%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-5-1 221091930-10 NAD Bulk Material5

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 29.7%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-5-2 221091930-11 NAD Bulk Material5

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 31.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke

AmeriSci Job #: 221091930 Page 3 of 6

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-6-1 221091930-12 NAD Bulk Material6

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 47.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-6-2 221091930-13 NAD Bulk Material6

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 47.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-7-1 221091930-14 NAD Bulk Material7

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 23.7%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-7-2 221091930-15 NAD Bulk Material7

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 27.1%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-8-1 221091930-16 NAD Bulk Material8

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 31%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoCLLI-8-2 221091930-17 NAD Bulk Material8

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 25.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke

AmeriSci Job #: 221091930 Page 4 of 6

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoMAS-9-1 221091930-18 NAD Bulk Material9

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 17.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoMAS-9-2 221091930-19 NAD Bulk Material9

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 16.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-10-1 221091930-20 NAD Bulk Material10

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 18.4%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-10-2 221091930-21 NAD Bulk Material10

White, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 17.6%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-11-1 221091930-22 NAD Bulk Material11

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 9%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-11-2 221091930-23 NAD Bulk Material11

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 9.1%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke

AmeriSci Job #: 221091930 Page 5 of 6

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoMAS-12-1 221091930-24 NAD Bulk Material12

Black, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 9.7%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoMAS-12-2 221091930-25 NAD Bulk Material12

Black, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 13.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-13-1 221091930-26 NAD Bulk Material13

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 4.6%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoSEALANT-13-2 221091930-27 NAD Bulk Material13

Gray, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 5.8%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-1 221091930-28 NAD Bulk Material14

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 40%, Non-fibrous 60%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-2 221091930-29 NAD Bulk Material14

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 30%, Non-fibrous 70%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke

AmeriSci Job #: 221091930 Page 6 of 6

York

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoWLSH-14-3 221091930-30 NAD Bulk Material14

Gray/Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPIN-15-1 221091930-31 NAD Bulk Material15

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 9.2%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

NoPIN-15-2 221091930-32 NAD Bulk Material15

Brown, Homogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 9.5%

(by NYS ELAP 198.6) by Jared C. Clarke on 09/14/21

Reporting Notes:

*NAD/NSD =no asbestos detected; NA =not analyzed; NA/PS=not analyzed/positive stop, (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite;

(SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; PLM Bulk Asbestos Analysis using Motic, Model BA310 Pol Scope, Microscope, Serial #: 1190000326, by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 quantified by either CVES or 400 pt ct as noted for each analysis (NVLAP 200546-0), ELAP PLM Method 198.1 for NY friable samples, which includes the identification and quantitation of vermiculite, or ELAP 198.6 for NOB samples, or EPA 400 pt ct by EPA 600- M4-82-020 (NY ELAP Lab 11480); Note:PLM is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor coverings and similar non-friable organically bound materials. NAD or Trace results by PLM are inconclusive, TEM is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non asbestos-containing in NY State (also see EPA Advisory for floor tile, FR 59,146,38970,8/1/94) National Institute of Standards and Technology Accreditation requirements mandate that this report must not be reproduced except in full without the approval of the lab.This PLM report relates ONLY to the items tested. RI Cert AAL-094, CT Cert PH-0186, Mass Cert AA000054, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

____________END OF REPORT___________

Analyzed by: Jared C. Clarke Date: 9/14/2021

Reviewed by: Marik Peysakhov

Client Name:

221091930

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York

AmeriSci Job #: Page 1 of 3

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

01 WLSH-1-1 1 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

02 WLSH-1-2 1 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

03 WLSH-1-3 1 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

04 FRSTP-2-1 2 0.425 57.5 25.7 16.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

05 FRSTP-2-2 2 0.414 59.9 23.9 16.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

06 CLLI-3-1 3 0.316 13.8 83.5 2.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

07 CLLI-3-2 3 0.263 13.0 82.4 4.5 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

08 CLLI-4-1 4 0.251 24.2 23.4 52.3 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

09 CLLI-4-2 4 0.306 25.8 21.6 52.6 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

10 CLLI-5-1 5 0.406 14.6 55.7 29.7 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

11 CLLI-5-2 5 0.262 15.4 53.4 31.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

12 CLLI-6-1 6 0.188 24.2 28.6 47.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

13 CLLI-6-2 6 0.211 24.2 28.0 47.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

14 CLLI-7-1 7 0.195 10.5 65.8 23.7 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

15 CLLI-7-2 7 0.315 10.4 62.5 27.1 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

16 CLLI-8-1 8 0.340 15.1 54.0 31.0 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York

AmeriSci Job #: Page 2 of 3

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

17 CLLI-8-2 8 0.385 16.1 58.7 25.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

18 MAS-9-1 9 0.179 59.7 22.5 17.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

19 MAS-9-2 9 0.143 61.6 21.6 16.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

20 SEALANT-10-1 10 0.360 40.3 41.3 18.4 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

21 SEALANT-10-2 10 0.357 38.3 44.1 17.6 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

22 SEALANT-11-1 11 0.295 50.5 40.5 9.0 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

23 SEALANT-11-2 11 0.230 49.1 41.8 9.1 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

24 MAS-12-1 12 0.136 47.3 43.0 9.7 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

25 MAS-12-2 12 0.100 47.5 39.3 13.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

26 SEALANT-13-1 13 0.279 26.5 68.9 4.6 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

27 SEALANT-13-2 13 0.227 27.8 66.4 5.8 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

28 WLSH-14-1 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

29 WLSH-14-2 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

30 WLSH-14-3 14 ---- ---- ---- ---- NAD NA

Bulk MaterialLocation:

31 PIN-15-1 15 0.122 62.5 28.4 9.2 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

32 PIN-15-2 15 0.191 62.8 27.8 9.5 NAD NAD

Bulk MaterialLocation:

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

1122.005.001; Towne Engineering; DFAS Bldg. 2, Rome, New York

AmeriSci Job #: Page 3 of 3

Table I Summary of Bulk Asbestos Analysis Results

Client Sample#

Sample Weight (gram)

Heat Sensitive

Organic %

Acid Soluble

Inorganic %

Insoluble Non-Asbestos

Inorganic %

HG

Area ** Asbestos % by

PLM/DS

** Asbestos % by

TEM

AmeriSci Sample #

**Quantitative Analysis (Semi/Full); Bulk Asbestos Analysis - PLM by Appd E to Subpt E, 40 CFR 763 or NYSDOH ELAP 198.1 for New York friable samples or NYSDOH ELAP 198.6 for New York NOB samples;

TEM (Semi/Full) by EPA 600/R-93/116 (or NYSDOH ELAP 198.4; for New York samples). Analysis using Hitachi, Model H7000-Noran 7 System, Microscope, Serial #: 747-05-06. NAD = no asbestos detected during a quantitative analysis; NA = not analyzed; Trace = <1%; (SOF-V) = Sprayed On Fireproofing containing Vermiculite; (SM-V) = Surfacing Material containing Vermiculite; Quantitation for beginning weights of <0.1 grams should be considered as qualitative only; Qualitative Analysis: Asbestos analysis results of "Present" or "NVA = No Visible Asbestos" represents results for Qualitative PLM or TEM Analysis only (no accreditation coverage available from any regulatory agency for qualitative analyses): NVLAP (PLM) 200546-0, NYSDOH ELAP Lab 11480, NJ Lab ID #NY031.

Warning Note: PLM limitation, only TEM will resolve fibers <0.25 micrometers in diameter. TEM bulk analysis is representative of the fine grained matrix material and may not be representative of non-uniformly dispersed debris for which PLM evaluation is recommended (i.e. soils and other heterogenous materials).

Analyzed by: Marik Peysakhov Date: 9/14/2021

Reviewed by: Marik Peysakhov fBnrtqrrt etgmu*di*e

Client: Towne Engineering

Location. DFAS Blds.2

Bulk Sample Chain-of-Custody 11 Centre Park

Suite 203

Rochester, NY 14614

585-325-7190 Fax: 31 5-325-4856 te2210 I 1 I 5 0

1122.005.O01

9t9t2021

MDG

Comments:

New York

Sample ldentification: Description wLSH-1-1,2,3 Typical Sheetrock

FRSTP-2-1,2 Red Firestop Material cLLl-3-1,2 2'x2' Rough Texture Ceiling Panel cLLt4-1,2 2'x4' Long Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling

Panel cLLt-5-1,2 2'x4'Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel cLLt-6-1,2 2'x4' Dimple & Pinhole Ceiling Panel cLu-7-1,2 2'x2'Smooth Celliry Palet_ _ cLLt-8-1,2 2'x2' Fissure & Pinhole Ceiling Panel

MAS-g-1,2 Tan Duct Mastic

SEALANT.I O-1,2 il/hite Fiberglass Pipe Sealant

SEALANT-11-1,2 Grey Duct Sealant

Sheetrock Wall Panel w/ Canvas Cover

Analysis Required: Comments:

Polarized Light Microscopyl X lstop at first positive (> than 1olo asbestos) in each sample series.

PLM - NOBI X lAdvance to TEM if PLM result is 1% asbestos or less

Email: Mike Goff

Email: Dave Morse

By: 72hrs TAT

7a'* eage I of J r4/ ./Z->e

CJ26626 - CJ26631

Friday, September 17, 2021

Sample ID#s:

Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Sincerely yours, Laboratory Director

Phyllis Shiller

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200. The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

NELAC - #NY11301

CT Lab Registration #PH-0618

MA Lab Registration #M-CT007

ME Lab Registration #CT-007

NH Lab Registration #213693-A,B

NJ Lab Registration #CT-003

NY Lab Registration #11301

PA Lab Registration #68-03530

RI Lab Registration #63

UT Lab Registration #CT00007

VT Lab Registration #VT11301

This laboratory is in compliance with the NELAC requirements of procedures used except where indicated.

This report contains results for the parameters tested, under the sampling conditions described on the Chain Of Custody, as received by the laboratory. This report is incomplete unless all pages indicated in the pagination at the bottom of the page are included.

A scanned version of the COC form accompanies the analytical report and is an exact duplicate of the original.

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O. Box 370, Manchester, CT 06040

Telephone (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Sample Id Cross Reference September 17, 2021

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045 Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

SDG I.D.: GCJ26626

Client Id Lab Id Matrix

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

PAINT-1 CJ26626 SOLID

PAINT-2 CJ26627 SOLID

PAINT-3 CJ26628 SOLID

PAINT-4 CJ26629 SOLID

PAINT-5 CJ26630 SOLID

PAINT-6 CJ26631 SOLID

Sample Information Custody Information

Matrix:

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-1

Phoenix ID: CJ26626

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

9.11Lead 0.18 09/15/21 EK SW6010D% 100

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

Ver 1

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-2

Phoenix ID: CJ26627

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

29.9Lead 2.5 09/15/21 TH SW6010D% 1000

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-3

Phoenix ID: CJ26628

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

0.0024Lead 0.0022 09/14/21 EK SW6010D% 1

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-4

Phoenix ID: CJ26629

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

19.3Lead 0.20 09/15/21 EK SW6010D% 100

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-5

Phoenix ID: CJ26630

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

0.0099Lead 0.0038 09/14/21 TH SW6010D% 1

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

Location Code:

Rush Request:

P.O.#:

Collected by:

Received by:

Analyzed by:

SOLID

BARTLOG

Standard

1122.005.001

09/09/21

LB

see "By" below

MDG

Laboratory Data

PAINT-6

Phoenix ID: CJ26631

09/13/21 12:07

Parameter Result

RL/

PQL Units Date/Time By Reference

FOR: Attn: Mr. Mike Goff

Barton & Loguidice, D.P.C.

443 Electronics Parkway

Liverpool, NY 13088

Analysis Report September 17, 2021

Date Time

SDG ID: GCJ26626

Client ID:

Project ID: TOWNE ENGINEERING

Dilution

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045

Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

8.34Lead 0.21 09/14/21 TH SW6010D% 100

CompletedTotal Metals Digest 09/13/21 M/AG SW3050B

Comments:

Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

September 17, 2021

If you are the client above and have any questions concerning this testing, please do not hesitate to contact Phoenix Client Services at ext.200.

The contents of this report cannot be discussed with anyone other than the client listed above without their written consent.

Reviewed and Released by: Rashmi Makol, Project Manager

RL/PQL=Reporting/Practical Quantitation Level (Equivalent to NELAC LOQ, Limit of Quantitation) ND=Not Detected at RL/PQL BRL=Below Reporting Level L=Biased Low

QA/QC Data

Parameter Blk Blank RL

MS

MSD

MS

RPD

QA/QC Report September 17, 2021

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045 Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

SDG I.D.: GCJ26626

LCS

Dup

RPD

LCSD

LCS

RPD

Rec

Limits

RPD

Limits Sample Result

Dup Result

QA/QC Batch 591689 (mg/kg), QC Sample No: CJ26115 (CJ26626, CJ26627, CJ26628, CJ26629)

ICP Metals - Soil Lead 104BRL 1217.40 113 6.8 75 - 125 353.65 3.390.33

Additional Criteria: LCS acceptance range is 80-120% MS acceptance range 75-125%.

Comment:

QA/QC Batch 591715 (mg/kg), QC Sample No: CJ26916 (CJ26630, CJ26631)

ICP Metals - Soil Lead 100BRL 1184.00 116 1.7 75 - 125 3554.1 56.30.33

Additional Criteria: LCS acceptance range is 80-120% MS acceptance range 75-125%.

Comment:

MS - Matrix Spike Phyllis Shiller, Laboratory Director

If there are any questions regarding this data, please call Phoenix Client Services at extension 200.

September 17, 2021 MS Dup - Matrix Spike Duplicate

RPD - Relative Percent Difference LCS - Laboratory Control Sample LCSD - Laboratory Control Sample Duplicate

NC - No Criteria Intf - Interference

Sample Criteria Exceedances ReportFriday, September 17, 2021

Acode Phoenix Analyte CriteriaResult RLSampNo Analysis

UnitsCriteria

GCJ26626 - BARTLOG

Criteria: None

RL

Criteria

State: NY

#Type!*** No Data to Display ***

Phoenix Laboratories does not assume responsibility for the data contained in this exceedance report. It is provided as an additional tool to identify requested criteria exceedences. All efforts are made to ensure the accuracy of the data (obtained from appropriate agencies). A lack of exceedence information does not necessarily suggest conformance to the criteria. It is ultimately the site professional's responsibility to determine appropriate compliance.

Analysis Comments

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045 Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

SDG I.D.: GCJ26626

The following analysis comments are made regarding exceptions to criteria not already noted in the Analysis Report or QA/QC Report: None.

NY Temperature Narration

587 East Middle Turnpike, P.O.Box 370, Manchester, CT 06045 Tel. (860) 645-1102 Fax (860) 645-0823

Environmental Laboratories, Inc.

SDG I.D.: GCJ26626

The samples in this delivery group were received at 21.6°C.

(Note acceptance criteria for relevant matrices is above freezing up to 6°C)