Bronx VAMC Boiler Plant RBM Survey Report - Final.pdf

p

REGULATED BUILDING MATERIALS

SURVEY REPORT

Bronx VAMC Boiler Plant 130 W Kingsbridge Road Bronx, NY

A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers

Mabbett Project No. R2022071.000

January 13, 2023

Prepared For:

Miller-Remick, LLC 1010 Kings Highway South Cherry Hill, NH 08034

Mabbett & Associates, Inc. www.mabbett.com 105 Central Street, Suite 4100 Stoneham, MA 02180-1260 T. 781-275-6050 F: 781-954-5155 Massachusetts | Virginia | Rhode Island | New York

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

REGULATED BUILDING MATERIALS SURVEY REPORT

A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers | Bronx VAMC Boiler Plant | New York, NY

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page i January 13, 2023 Project No. R20220271.000 Bronx VAMC Boiler Plant RBM Survey Report - Final

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

This Regulated Building Materials Survey Report has been prepared by Mabbett & Associates, Inc. (Mabbett®) for the A/E Design Services to replace existing boilers at the James J. Peters DVA Medical Center located at 130 W Kingsbridge Road in the Bronx, New York. The information presented herein is based on the facts and information conveyed to or received by Mabbett during the preparation of this report. If any of the information provided to Mabbett that was used in preparing this report is incorrect, incomplete, or subject to change, Mabbett would wish to alter its opinion(s) accordingly. In addition, the professional opinions and information contained in this report are based solely on the requirements of the applicable regulations and technical data as known to Mabbett as of the date of this report and considered applicable to this report.

The attached Regulated Building Materials Survey Report was prepared by Mr. Kevin M. Donovan, Senior Environmental, Health & Safety Specialist of Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

This report has been reviewed and approved by:

Michael F. Delaney Director, Building Sciences Group

MFD/fmz

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page ii January 13, 2023 Project No. R2022071.000 Bronx VAMC Boiler Plant RBM Survey Report - Final

TABLE OF CONTENTS

SECTION PAGE

1.0 INTRODUCTION

2.0 ASBESTOS SURVEY

2.1 Sampling Methodology

2.2 Analytical Methodology

2.3 Summary of Asbestos Containing Materials Findings

3.0 LEAD CONTAINING PAINT SURVEY

3.1 Sampling Methodology

3.2 Analytical Methodology

3.3 LCP Results

4.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

4.1 Asbestos

4.2 Lead Containing Paint

5.0 LIMITATIONS

TABLES

Table 1 – Summary of Identified ACM Table 2 – Summary of Lead Paint Chip Analytical Results

FIGURES

RBM-1 - Regulated Building Materials Sample Locations Plan, Office Adjacent to Boiler Room

RBM-2 - Regulated Building Materials Sample Locations Plan, Mezzanine Level

APPENDICES

Appendix A – Summary of ACM Sampling Results Appendix B – Asbestos Laboratory Report and Chains of Custody Appendix C – Lead Paint Chip Laboratory Report and Chains of Custody Appendix D – Hazardous Materials Survey Report Dated December 23, 2016 - Revised June 26, 2017

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 1 January 13, 2023

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Mabbett and Associates, Inc. (Mabbett®) performed a survey for regulated building materials (RBM) as part of the A/E Services t o Replace Existing Boilers at the James J. Peters DVA Medical Center located at 130 W Kingsbridge Road, Bronx, New York. Site survey work was performed on December 13, 2022, by appropriately credentialed regulated building material inspectors and investigators, and consisted of the following activities:

A review of the existing facility regulated building reports and renovation history;

An Asbestos Containing Material (ACM) survey of suspect materials (Analysis by Polarized Light Microscopy

[PLM] and Transmission Electron Microscopy [TEM]); and Limited Lead Containing Paint (LCP) sampling (Analysis by atomic absorption [AA]).

The survey was limited to materials and areas impacted by the Replace Existing Boilers project and included the lower level, main level, mezzanine level, roof, and exteriors of the boiler plant. Areas surveyed were specific locations identified on field note drawings provided by the client. Areas and materials outside of this scope of work were not included in the survey and report.

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 2 January 13, 2023

2.0 ASBESTOS SURVEY

A visual screening inspection was conducted by New York City licensed asbestos investigator to identify locations of suspect ACM and conceptualize the sampling program. Only areas that were accessible during the field work phase were inspected. Reasonable efforts were made during the initial field survey to access areas as necessary to complete the asbestos survey and sampling program.

Prior to the execution of this RBM survey, existing building plans for the Replace Existing Boilers project locations were examined and engineering personnel interviewed to discern the age, location, and condition of existing materials, as well as the renovation history of the building areas being impacted.

2.1 Sampling Methodology

Site inspection work was performed on December 13, 2022, by New York City DEP Asbestos Control Program licensed Asbestos Investigator, Mr. Iyke Ohriala (#120484). Bulk asbestos samples were collected using EPA National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP), 40 CFR Part 763, and Asbestos Hazard Emergency Response Act (AHERA) protocols. The inspection was limited to areas that may be impacted by the proposed project. Bulk suspect ACM sampling was generally conducted according to the following sampling protocol:

Friable surfacing material:

• At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is 1,000 ft2 or less.

• At least five bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than 1,000 ft2 but less than or equal to 5,000 ft2.

• At least seven bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than 5,000 ft2.

Thermal system insulation:

• At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area of thermal system insulation.

• At least one bulk sample shall be collected from each homogeneous area of patched area of thermal system insulation.

• Sufficient samples shall be collected from elbows and fittings to determine if they contain ACM.

• Bulk samples shall not be collected from any homogeneous area where the state licensed asbestos inspector determined that the thermal system insulation is fiberglass, foam glass, rubber, or other non-ACM.

Miscellaneous material:

• At least two bulk sample shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is less than

100 ft2.

• At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than

100 ft2.

Areas that were inaccessible, or where the survey was limited to visual observation only, are identified below:

Within walls Within fire doors

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 3 January 13, 2023

Enclosed pipe/duct chases Inside mechanical equipment/ductwork Above fixed drywall or plaster ceilings Electrical equipment

2.2 Analytical Methodology

The collected bulk samples were submitted under chain of custody (COC) procedures to AmeriSci of Richmond, Virginia for PLM and TEM analysis as required by the New York State Environmental Laboratory Approval Program (ELAP). PLM analysis of friable materials was performed using NYS ELAP Method 198.1. Samples of Non-Friable Organically Bound (NOB) materials were analyzed by PLM (NYS ELAP Method 198.6) subsequent to matrix reduction. NOB samples that were identified as non-ACM by PLM methods were re-analyzed by TEM (NYS ELAP Method 198.4) for confirmation purposes. AmeriSci is accredited by the American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) and participates in the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP).

All bulk sample results from this inspection are summarized in Appendix B, Summary of ACM Building Survey Results. The EPA, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and Part 56 of Title 12 of the Official Compilation of Codes, Rules, and Regulations of the State of New York (12 NYCRR Part 56) defines any material that contains greater than one percent (>1%) asbestos as being an ACM. As such, the analytical laboratory identified bulk samples as positive for asbestos that met the regulatory criteria of greater than one percent (>1%) asbestos. Laboratory reports and COC documentation are provided in Appendix B of this report.

2.3 Summary of Asbestos Containing Materials Findings

Mabbett identified fifty-one (51) homogenous materials and collected fifty-seven (57) representative bulk ACM samples. Fifty-seven(57) samples were analyzed by PLM and forty-one (41) samples were analyzed by TEM. The laboratory-reported analytical data indicated that one of the materials sampled as part of this survey contained 1% or greater asbestos and is classified as ACM and one material contained less than 1% asbestos and is considered non-ACM. Historical survey data that was provided identified cementitious pipe insulation over high pressure steam supply/return pipes and 12” x 12” beige floor tile and associated mastic as asbestos containing materials.

The results of the ACM sampling are summarized in Table 1, with laboratory reports provided in Appendix A.

TABLE 1

Summary of Identified ACM

A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers Bronx VAMC, Bronx, NY

Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity

Amount Units

Boiler Control Room and Stairwell 12” x 12” Beige Floor Tile and Associated Mastic* Trace - 9.5% Chrysotile 925 Square Feet

Boilers #1, #2 and #3 Cementitious Pipe Insulation* 21% Chrysotile 1,100 Linear Feet

Notes: * = Previously Identified ACM

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 4 January 13, 2023

3.0 LEAD CONTAINING PAINT SURVEY

The limited LCP survey included the collection of paint chips from painted surfaces and systems in the areas surveyed that may be impacted by the Replace Existing Boilers project . Ten (10) samples of different homogenous areas of paint were collected during this survey. Paint chip samples were submitted under standard COC procedures to Scientific Analytical Institute, Inc. (SAI) in Greensboro, North Carolina. Analysis was conducted using AA EPA method SW-846 3050B/6010C/7000B.

3.1 Sampling Methodology

Paint chip samples are collected using a sharp hand tool to score and peel paint off a 1 square inch (or larger) area of the substrate. Different tools such as chisels, putty knives, and hammers may also be needed in the collection of paint chips. All tools are cleaned after each sample to prevent cross contamination. Collected paint chip samples are submitted under COC procedures to an accredited laboratory and analyzed via Flame Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry (AA).

3.2 Analytical Methodology

The regulations addressing LCP in non-residential buildings are focused on occupational exposures involved with paint-disturbing activities and related waste-disposal activities. Occupational exposure to lead is regulated by OSHA regulation 29 CFR 1926.62, Lead in Construction, as well as other applicable state and local regulations.

An LCP survey cannot determine a safe level of lead for the purpose of paint-disturbing/waste-disposal activities but is intended to provide guidance as to the locations of surfaces containing lead.

Contractors may use this information to better determine where worker exposures to airborne lead and other hazards may occur. They can then assess the potential magnitude of exposure to their employees and identify the controls necessary to limit health risks. This information can also be used for pre-characterization of demolition waste streams prior to toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) sampling in accordance with 40 CFR Part 261.

3.3 LCP Results

A concentration of lead greater than or equal to 0.5 mg/Kg percent by weight or 1.0 mg/cm² exceeds EPA and HUD residential standards and is considered an indicator of risk. The results of this LCP sampling survey identified one (1) sample that indicates risk.

The results of the limited LCP sampling are summarized in Table 2, with laboratory reports provided in Appendix C.

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 5 January 13, 2023

TABLE 2

Summary of Lead Paint Chip Analytical Results A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers

Bronx VAMC - Bronx, NY

Sample No. Location Substrate and Component Color Result

(% by weight) Pb-01 Boiler Room (NE) Concrete Block Wall White 0.0052 Pb-02 Boiler Room (NE) Metal Duct Silver 0.017 Pb-03 Boiler Room (East Side) Concrete Floor Gray <0.0042 Pb-04 Boiler Room, Boiler #2 Metal Boiler Gray 0.85 Pb-05 Men’s Room Gypsum Wall Tan <0.0066 Pb-06 Control Room Metal Door Blue 0.012 Pb-07 Control Room Concrete Column White 0.0035 Pb-08 Control Room Metal Door Frame Blue 0.17 Pb-09 Chiller Room Concrete Pad Gray 0.0053 Pb-10 Chiller Room Metal Pipe Green 0.070

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 6 January 13, 2023

4.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

4.1 Asbestos

Materials containing asbestos were identified in the areas surveyed. Any suspect materials encountered during demolition or renovation activities that were not identified in this report as being non-ACM, should be assumed to be ACM unless sample results prove otherwise. Suspect ACM that may be present within the walls, above inaccessible hard ceilings, or in other inaccessible locations, should be assumed to contain asbestos if discovered during any demolition or renovation process or until otherwise verified. If discovered, ACM must be abated and properly disposed of prior to disturbance by state licensed and properly trained contractors. All abatement must be performed in accordance with federal, state, and local requirements.

4.2 Lead Containing Paint

The purpose of the limited LCP survey was to identify similar areas of LCP. During the on-site survey, representative samples of similar areas of interior building coatings were collected and analyzed for lead content.

The regulations addressing LCP in non-residential buildings are focused on occupational exposures involved with paint-disturbing activities and related waste-disposal activities.

Occupational exposure to lead during construction is regulated by OSHA regulation 29 CFR 1926.62 “Lead in Construction,” as well as other applicable state and local regulations. These regulations involve air monitoring to determine worker exposure levels when disturbing paint containing measurable levels of lead. This LCP survey cannot determine a safe level of lead for the purpose of paint-disturbing activities. However, this report is intended to provide guidance as to the location of LCP so it can be controlled, abated, or disposed of properly during this project’s construction related activities. Information gathered during this LCP survey should be used to determine where worker exposures to airborne lead may occur. Additionally, this information should also be used to assess the potential for exposure to workers, and for determining appropriate controls necessary to limit his or her health risks during this project.

A concentration of lead greater than or equal to 0.5 mg/Kg percent by weight or 1.0 mg/cm2 exceeds EPA and HUD residential standards is considered an indicator of risk. Representative samples of LCP waste to be generated during building renovation, or following demolition but prior to disposal, should be collected and analyzed using toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) in accordance with 40 CFR Part 261. Management and disposal of lead containing waste must be done in accordance with all applicable local, state, and federal regulations.

OSHA regulations may require certain procedures for any paint that contains lead, even if it is below EPA and HUD levels. All LCP identified, regardless of the lead content, should either be sampled and analyzed by TCLP and then handled/disposed of accordingly, or segregated from other large-scale debris and then managed as hazardous waste in accordance with federal, state, and local hazardous waste disposal regulations.

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 7 January 13, 2023

5.0 LIMITATIONS

This survey report is the result of a diligent and thorough inspection for regulated building materials of the designated areas and materials that may be impacted by the Replace Existing Boilers project. Inaccessible areas were not included in this survey. Although a comprehensive inspection was performed, Mabbett does not claim to have identified all hazardous materials that could be present in the facility (for example, materials potentially located within the inaccessible areas). Mabbett has conducted this assessment with reasonable care and has performed this project in accordance with generally accepted industry standards. There can be no assurances, and Mabbett makes no assurances, that the information, research, and technology used to prepare this report may not change in the future, thus affecting the results reported herein.

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. FIGURES January 13, 2023

FIGURES

LEGEND

STOP POSITIVE SAMPLE FOR ASBESTOS

NO ASBESTOS DETECTED (NAD)

SAMPLE POSITIVE FOR ASBESTOS

APPROXIMATE SAMPLE LOCATION

01A*

01A**

01A

01A

LEAD PAINT SAMPLE LOCATIONPb-01

GENERAL SURVEY NOTES:GENERAL SURVEY NOTES:

1. DRAWINGS DO NOT CLAIM TO IDENTIFY ALL THE ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL (ACM)

PRESENT IN THE BUILDING AND SHOULD NOT BE THE SOLE BASIS FOR IDENTIFYING ACM FOR

FUTURE RENOVATION OR DEMOLITION PROJECTS, ABATEMENT SPECIFICATIONS, ETC. MABBETTS'S

SURVEY WAS PERFORMED WITH LIMITATIONS INHERENT TO NON-DESTRUCTIVE VISUAL

INSPECTIONS. ANY SUSPECT MATERIAL ENCOUNTERED DURING RENOVATION/DEMOLITION THAT

IS NOT IDENTIFIED AS BEING NON-ACM SHOULD BE ASSUMED TO BE ACM UNLESS SAMPLE

RESULTS PROVE OTHERWISE. BASE PLAN OBTAINED FROM MILLER REMICK, AND PREPARED BY

MILLER REMICK, RECEIVED DECEMBER 2022.

2. SURVEY COMPLETED ON 15 DECEMBER 2022 BY MABBETT & ASSOCIATES, INC..

Pb-06

Pb-07

Pb-08

50A,51A

09,10

11,12

20,22

SAMPLES 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 40, 41,

42, 43, 44 COLLECTED ON LOWER LEVEL

49A,49B

REGULATED BUILDINGS MATERIALS

SAMPLE LOCATIONS PLAN, OFFICE

ADJACENT TO BOILER ROOM

RBM-1

DJAMFD

Project Number

Building Number

Drawing Number

Project Title

Location

Issue Date Checked Drawn

Drawing Title

Approved:

VA FORM 08 - 6231

A

Office of Construction and Facilities Management

U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

B

C

D

E

F

A

B

C

D

E

F

21 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

PhaseENGINEER OF RECORDCONSULTANTS

321 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

REPLACE EXISTING BOILERS

PROJECT AT THE BRONX NY VAMC

MEDICAL CENTER

BRONX, NY VA MEDICAL CENTER

R2022017.001

Project Director

2022-12-21

NO. DESCRIPTION DATE

PRINTS OF THIS DRAWING SHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE

WHATSOEVER WITHOUT THE SEAL AND SIGNATURE OF THE

PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER

6" 6"

6" 6" on e ei gh th in ch o ne fo ot on e qu ar te r i nc h on e fo ot th re e ei gh th s in ch o ne fo ot on e ha lf in ch o ne fo ot th re e qu ar te rs in ch o ne fo ot on e in ch o ne fo ot on e an d on e ha lf in ch es o ne fo ot th re e in ch es o ne fo ot

KEYPLAN

AutoCAD SHX Text

SCALE:

AutoCAD SHX Text 1E

AutoCAD SHX Text

REGULATED BUILDING MATERIALS PLAN

AutoCAD SHX Text 1/4" = 1'-0"

LEGEND

STOP POSITIVE SAMPLE FOR ASBESTOS

NO ASBESTOS DETECTED (NAD)

SAMPLE POSITIVE FOR ASBESTOS

APPROXIMATE SAMPLE LOCATION

01A*

01A**

01A

01A

LEAD PAINT SAMPLE LOCATIONPb-01

GENERAL SURVEY NOTES:GENERAL SURVEY NOTES:

1. DRAWINGS DO NOT CLAIM TO IDENTIFY ALL THE ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL (ACM)

PRESENT IN THE BUILDING AND SHOULD NOT BE THE SOLE BASIS FOR IDENTIFYING ACM FOR

FUTURE RENOVATION OR DEMOLITION PROJECTS, ABATEMENT SPECIFICATIONS, ETC. MABBETTS'S

SURVEY WAS PERFORMED WITH LIMITATIONS INHERENT TO NON-DESTRUCTIVE VISUAL

INSPECTIONS. ANY SUSPECT MATERIAL ENCOUNTERED DURING RENOVATION/DEMOLITION THAT

IS NOT IDENTIFIED AS BEING NON-ACM SHOULD BE ASSUMED TO BE ACM UNLESS SAMPLE

RESULTS PROVE OTHERWISE. BASE PLAN OBTAINED FROM MILLER REMICK, AND PREPARED BY

MILLER REMICK, RECEIVED DECEMBER 2022.

2. SURVEY COMPLETED ON 15 DECEMBER 2022 BY MABBETT & ASSOCIATES, INC..

Pb-05

Pb-04

Pb-02

Pb-01

Pb-03

Pb-09 Pb-10

LOCATED IN ADJACENT CHILLER ROOM

48A,48B

50B,51B

47A,47B

23,26

38,39

46B

45,46A

SAMPLES 01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06, 07, 08

COLLECTED ON ROOF

28 24

REGULATED BUILDINGS MATERIALS

SAMPLE LOCATION PLAN,

MEZZANINE LEVEL

RBM-2

DJAMFD

Project Number

Building Number

Drawing Number

Project Title

Location

Issue Date Checked Drawn

Drawing Title

Approved:

VA FORM 08 - 6231

A

Office of Construction and Facilities Management

U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs

B

C

D

E

F

A

B

C

D

E

F

21 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

PhaseENGINEER OF RECORDCONSULTANTS

321 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

REPLACE EXISTING BOILERS

PROJECT AT THE BRONX NY VAMC

MEDICAL CENTER

BRONX, NY VA MEDICAL CENTER

R2022017.001

Project Director

2022-12-21

NO. DESCRIPTION DATE

PRINTS OF THIS DRAWING SHALL NOT BE USED FOR ANY PURPOSE

WHATSOEVER WITHOUT THE SEAL AND SIGNATURE OF THE

PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER

6" 6"

6" 6" on e ei gh th in ch o ne fo ot on e qu ar te r i nc h on e fo ot th re e ei gh th s in ch o ne fo ot on e ha lf in ch o ne fo ot th re e qu ar te rs in ch o ne fo ot on e in ch o ne fo ot on e an d on e ha lf in ch es o ne fo ot th re e in ch es o ne fo ot

KEYPLAN

AutoCAD SHX Text

SCALE:

AutoCAD SHX Text 1F

AutoCAD SHX Text

REGULATED BUILDING MATERIALS PLAN

AutoCAD SHX Text 1/4" = 1'-0"

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. APPENDIX A January 13, 2023

APPENDIX A

Summary of ACM Sampling Results

Appendix A

Summary of ACM Sampling Results A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers

Bronx VAMC - Bronx, NY

Sample No. Sample Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

01 Roof – Exhaust Vent Pipe (NE Area) Gray Caulk NAD 02 Roof – Aeration Tank Vent Pipe (North) Flashing Membrane/Mastic NAD 03 Roof – Exhaust Vent Pipe (Pitch Pocket) Black Mastic NAD 04 Roof – Exhaust Vent Joints (NE Corner) Black Caulk NAD 05 Roof – Exhaust Vent Base (NE Corner) Flashing Mastic NAD 06 Roof – Steam Silencer (North) Flashing Membrane/Mastic NAD 07 Roof – Exhaust Vent (NE Corner) White Caulk NAD 08 Roof – Steam Silencer (North) Black Flashing Mastic Patch NAD 09 Control Room Office 4” Blue Cove Base NAD 10 Control Room Office 4” Blue Cove Base Adhesive NAD 11 Control Room Office 12” x 12” Blue Floor Tile NAD

12 Control Room Office 12” x 12” Blue Floor Tile

Mastic NAD

13 Control Room 2’ x 2’ Small Pinhole Ceiling

Tile NAD 14 Boiler Room (South) Leveling Compound NAD

15 Control Room – Managers Office Canvas Material & Pipe

Insulation NAD

16 Above Control Room Blue/Gray Caulk (HVAC

Seams) NAD

17 Center of Boiler Room – Fuel Pump Flange Gasket Material

(Green) NAD 18 Compressor/Chiller Room Red Caulk NAD 19 MCC2A Cabinet – Separation Board White Arc Shield Material NAD

20 Boiler Feed Pump #2 Flange Gasket Material

(Green) NAD

21 Boiler Water Pump #1 Canvas/Mudded Joint

Packing NAD

22 Boiler Feed Pump #2 Canvas/Mudded joint

Packing (Gray) NAD 23 Boiler #1 – Access Hatch Gasket Material (White) NAD

24 Boiler #2 – Bottom Breeching Canvas/Cementitious

Material NAD 25 Boiler #1 – Double Wall (East Side) Brown Insulation Material NAD

26 Boiler #2 - Bottom Outer Jacket/Pipe

Insulation NAD

Appendix A Summary of ACM Sampling Results

A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers Bronx VAMC - Bronx, NY

Sample No. Sample Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

27 Boiler #1 – Gas Pipe Flanges Flange Gasket Material

(Green) NAD

28 Boiler #2 – Elbows, Drain Line Canvas Covering on Mudd

Joint NAD

29 Boiler #2 – Drain Piping Cementitious Material on

Mudd Joint NAD 30 Boiler Room – SE Corner by Boiler #3 Spray-on Fireproofing NAD 31 Deaeration Tank - Lower Canvas Jacket NAD

Deaeration Tank – Lower Tank (East

Side) Cementitious Material

(Gray) NAD

Deaeration Tank – Upper Tank (West

Side)

Covering Material/Cementitious

(Dark Gray) NAD

34 Deaeration Tank – Piping Flange Black Flange Gasket

Material NAD

35 Deaeration Tank – Piping Flange Brown Flange Gasket

Material NAD 36 Deaeration Tank – Piping Flange Red Flange Gasket Material NAD

37 Orange Condensate – Storage Tank Canvas/Cementitious

Material

NAD

38 Condensate Tank Piping Flange Green Flange Gasket

Material

NAD

39 Condensate Tank Piping Flange Red Flange Gasket Material NAD

40 Water Meter Room

Canvas Covering/Cementitious

Insulation (Gray)

NAD

41 Blow Down Tank - Bottom

Canvas Covering/Cementitious

Insulation (Gray)

NAD

42 East Wall – Lower Stairwell Light Gray Troweled-on Cementitious Sealant

NAD

43 East Wall Pink Cementitious

Insulation

NAD

44 West Wall Brick Mortar NAD 45 Boiler Room – Boiler #2 Breeching Insulation NAD

46A Boiler Room – Boiler #2 White Fiberglass End

Sealant

NAD

46B Chiller Room White Fiberglass End

Sealant

NAD

Appendix A Summary of ACM Sampling Results

A/E Design Services to Replace Existing Boilers Bronx VAMC - Bronx, NY

Sample No. Sample Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

47A Boiler Room - North Black Lab Top (Sink) NAD 47B Boiler Room - North Black Lab Top (Sink) NAD

48A Stairwell – Upper Level Rubber Stair Tread

Adhesive

NAD

48B Stairwell – Ground Level Rubber Stair Tread

Adhesive

NAD

49A Control Room – Managers Office 2’ x 2’ White Ceiling Tile

(Fissured)

NAD

49B Control Room – Managers Office 2’ x 2’ White Ceiling Tile

(Fissured)

NAD

50A Control Room - Office 12” x 12” Beige Floor Tile 2.1% Chrysotile 50B Stairwell – Ground Level 12” x 12” Beige Floor Tile NA/PS

51A Control Room - Office 12” x 12” Beige Floor Tile

Mastic Trace Chrysotile

51B Stairwell – Ground Level 12” x 12” Beige Floor Tile

Mastic Trace Chrysotile

Notes: NAD = No Asbestos Detected NA/PS = Not Analyzed/Positive Stop

© 2023, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. APPENDIX B January 13, 2023

APPENDIX B

Asbestos Laboratory Report and Chains of Custody

December 20, 2022

Dear Michael Delaney:

Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Attn: Michael Delaney 5 Alfred Circle Bedford, MA 1730

RE: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Job Number 122121509 P.O. #R2022071.000 R2022071.000; Bronx VMAC - Boiler Plant; Bronx, NY

AmeriSci Richmond

13635 GENITO ROAD

MIDLOTHIAN, VIRGINIA 23112

TEL: 8047631200 FAX: 8047631800

Enclosed are the results of Asbestos Analysis - Bulk Protocol of the following Mabbett & Associates, Inc. samples, received at AmeriSci on Friday, December 16, 2022, for a 3 day turnaround:

01, 02, 03, 04, 05, 06, 07, 08, 09, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46A, 46B, 47A, 47B, 48A, 48B, 49A, 49B, 50A, 50B, 51A, 51B

The 57 samples, placed in zip lock bag, were shipped to AmeriSci via UPS 1Z9A908E1395183673 955. Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

requested ELAP PLM/TEM analysis of these samples.

The results of the analyses which were performed under NYSDOH ELAP Lab Certification # 10984 following ELAP 198.4 TEM guidelines are presented within the Summary Table of this report. The presence of matrix reduction data in the Summary Table normally indicates an NOB sample. For NOB samples the individual matrix reduction and TEM analysis results are listed in Table I. Complete PLM results for individual samples analyzed by ELAP 198.1 (friable) and ELAP 198.6 (NOB) are presented in the PLM Bulk Asbestos Report. This combined report relates ONLY to sample analysis expressed as percent composition by weight and percent asbestos. This report must not be used to claim product endorsement or approval by these laboratories, NVLAP, ELAP or any other associated agency. The National Institute of Standards and Technology accreditation requirements, mandate that this report must not be reproduced, except in full without the written approval of the laboratory. This report may contain specific data not covered by NVLAP or ELAP accreditations respectively, if so identified in relevant footnotes.

Cory M. Parnell

Sincerely, Laboratory Director | Authorized Signatory

AmeriSci appreciates this opportunity to serve your organization. Please contact us for any further assistance or with any questions.

Boston - Los Angeles - New York - Richmond

AmeriSci Richmond

13635 GENITO ROAD

MIDLOTHIAN, VIRGINIA 23112

TEL: (804) 763-1200 • FAX: (804) 763-1800

12/16/22 AmeriSci Job # 122121509 12/20/22

ELAP # 10984 1 15

R2022071.000; Bronx VMAC - Boiler Plant; Bronx, NY

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Date Received Date Examined

RE:

ofPage

P.O. # Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

5 Alfred Circle

Bedford, MA 1730

Attn: Michael Delaney

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No01 122121509-01 NAD Roof - Exhaust Vent Pipe (NE Area); Gray Caulk1

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 20%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 27.9%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 51.6%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 20.5%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No02 122121509-02 NAD Roof - Aeration Tank Vent Pipe North; Flashing Membrane/Mastic2

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 16%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 75.0%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 8.3%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 16.7%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No03 122121509-03 NAD Roof - Exhaust Vent Pipe (Pitch Pocket); Black Mastic3

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 12%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 84.8%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 2.3%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 12.9%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No04 122121509-04 NAD Roof - NE Corner - Exhaust Vent Joints; Black Caulk4

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 7.7%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 77.5%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 14.8%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 7.7%

See Reporting notes on last page

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 2 of 15

R2022071.000; Bronx VMAC - Boiler Plant; Bronx, NY

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No05 122121509-05 NAD Roof - NE Corner - Exhaust Vent Base; Flashing Mastic5

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 3.5%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 69.6%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 26.9%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 3.5%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No06 122121509-06L1 NAD Roof - Steam Silencer (North); Flashing Membrane/Mastic6

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 2.3%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 77.0%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 20.6%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 2.3%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No06 122121509-06L2 NAD Roof - Steam Silencer (North); Flashing Membrane/Mastic6

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 62%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 32.9%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 4.4%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 62.7%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No07 122121509-07 NAD Roof - Exhaust Vent (NE Corner); White Caulk7

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 9.4%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 72.7%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 17.9%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 9.4%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No08 122121509-08 NAD Roof - Steam Silencer (North); Black Flashing Mastic Patch8

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 6.5%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 90.8%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 2.7%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 6.5%

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 3 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No09 122121509-09 NAD Boiler Room - Control Room Office; 4" Blue Cove Base9

Blue, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 2.1%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 55.8%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 42.1%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 2.1%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No10 122121509-10 NAD Boiler Room - Control Room Office; 4" Blue Cove Base Adhesive10

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 37%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 29.8%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 32.7%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 37.5%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No11 122121509-11 NAD Boiler Room - Control Room Office; 12x12 Blue Floor Tile11

Blue, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 57%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 24.6%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 18.3%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 57.1%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No12 122121509-12 NAD Boiler Room - Control Room Office; 12x12 Blue Floor Tile Mastic12

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 19%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 52.1%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 28.8%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 19.2%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No13 122121509-13 NAD Boiler Room - Control Room Office; 2'x2' Blue Small Pinhole Ceiling Tile13

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 41%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 18.6%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 40.2%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 41.3%

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 4 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No14 122121509-14 NAD Boiler Room - South Office; Leveling Compound14

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No15 122121509-15 NAD Control Room - Managers Office; Canvas Material 9' Pipe Insulation15

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 57%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 30.3%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 11.9%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 57.8%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No16 122121509-16 NAD Above Control Room; Blue/Gray Caulk (HVAC Seams)16

Blue, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 59%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 28.1%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 12.6%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 59.4%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No17 122121509-17 NAD Fuel Pump - Center Of Boiler Room; Flange Gasket Material (Green)17

Green, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 51%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 40.2%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 8.5%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 51.3%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No18 122121509-18 NAD Compressor/Chiller Room; Red Caulk18

Red, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 20%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 37.7%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 41.7%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 20.7%

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 5 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No19 122121509-19 NAD MCC2A Cabinet - Separation Board; White Arc Shield Material19

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 2.2%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 33.6%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 64.1%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 2.2%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No20 122121509-20 NAD Boiler Feed Pumps - Boiler #2; Flange Gasket Material (Green)20

Green, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 61%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 34.4%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 4.7%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 61.0%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No21 122121509-21L1 NAD Boiler Feed Water Pump #1; Canvas/Mudded Joint Packing21

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Canvas

Non-Asbestos 56%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 38.2%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 5.8%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 56.0%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No21 122121509-21L2 NAD Boiler Feed Water Pump #1; Canvas/Mudded Joint Packing21

Pink-Green-Gray, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Insulation

Fibrous glass 8.0%, Non-fibrous 92%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No22 122121509-22L1 NAD Boiler Feed Pump #2; Canvas/Mudded Joint Packing (Gray)22

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 36%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 48.9%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 14.5%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 36.7%

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 6 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No22 122121509-22L2 NAD Boiler Feed Pump #2; Canvas/Mudded Joint Packing (Gray)22

Green/Gray, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 15%, Non-fibrous 85%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No23 122121509-23 NAD Boiler #1 - Access Hatch; Gasket Material (White)23

White, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No24 122121509-24.1 NAD Boiler #2 - Bottom Breeching; Canvas/Cementitious Material24

Pale Pink-Gray, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Fibrous Material

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No24 122121509-24.2 NAD Boiler #2 - Bottom Breeching; Canvas/Cementitious Material24

Gray, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Cementitious, Insulation

Fibrous glass 5.0%, Non-fibrous 95%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No25 122121509-25 NAD Boiler #1 - Double Wall (East Side); Brown Insulation Material25

Brown, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No26 122121509-26.1 NAD Boiler #2 - Bottom; Outer Jacket/Pipe Insulation26

White/Brown/Silver, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Wrap

Cellulose 50%, Fibrous glass 5.0%, Non-fibrous 45%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 7 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No26 122121509-26.2 NAD Boiler #2 - Bottom; Outer Jacket/Pipe Insulation26

Pale Pink, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Insulation

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No27 122121509-27 NAD Boiler #1 - Gas Pipe Flanges; Flange Gasket Material (Green)27

Green, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 64%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 31.4%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 4.3%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 64.3%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No28 122121509-28L1 NAD Boiler #2 Elbows - Drain Pipe; Canvas Covering On Mudd Joint28

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Canvas

Non-Asbestos 58%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 15.2%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 26.2%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 58.7%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No28 122121509-28L2 NAD Boiler #2 Elbows - Drain Pipe; Canvas Covering On Mudd Joint28

Pink, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Insulation

Cellulose 5.0%, Fibrous glass 3.0%, Non-fibrous 92%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No29 122121509-29 NAD Boiler #2 - Drain Piping; Cementitious Material On Mudd Joint29

Green/Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 8 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No30 122121509-30 NAD Boiler Room - SE Corner By #3; Spray-On Fireproofing30

Gray, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Non-fibrous 75%, Vermiculite 10%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No31 122121509-31.1 NAD Dearation Tank - Lower; Canvas Jacket31

White, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Wrap

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No31 122121509-31.2 NAD Dearation Tank - Lower; Canvas Jacket31

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Insulation

Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No32 122121509-32.1 NAD Dearation Lower Tank (East Side); Cementitious Material Gray32

Off-White/Silver, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Wrap

Fibrous glass 5.0%, Non-fibrous 95%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No32 122121509-32.2 NAD Dearation Lower Tank (East Side); Cementitious Material Gray32

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Insulation

Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No33 122121509-33.1 NAD Dearation Upper Tank (West Side); Covering Material/Cementitious (Dark Gray)

White, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Wrap

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 9 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No33 122121509-33.2 NAD Dearation Upper Tank (West Side); Covering Material/Cementitious (Dark Gray)

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Insulation

Fibrous glass 5.0%, Non-fibrous 95%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No34 122121509-34 NAD Dearation Tank - Piping Flange; Black Flange Gasket Material34

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 49%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 27.1%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 23.4%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 49.5%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No35 122121509-35 NAD Dearation Tank Piping Flange; Brown Flange Gasket Material35

Brown, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 48%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 27.0%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 24.4%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 48.6%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No36 122121509-36 NAD Dearation Tank Piping Flange; Red Flange Gasket Material36

Red, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 31%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 33.9%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 35.0%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 31.1%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No37 122121509-37L1 NAD Orange Condensate Storage Tank; Canvas/Cementitious Insulation Material37

Yellow, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Canvas

Non-Asbestos 48%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 38.2%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 13.8%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 48.0%

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 10 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No37 122121509-37L2 NAD Orange Condensate Storage Tank; Canvas/Cementitious Insulation Material37

White, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Insulation

Cellulose 12%, Fibrous glass 4.0%, Non-fibrous 84%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No38 122121509-38 NAD Condensate Tank Piping Flange; Green Flange Gasket Material38

Blue, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 3.8%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 94.6%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 1.5%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 3.8%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No39 122121509-39 NAD Condensate Tank Piping Flange; Red Flange Gasket Material39

Red, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 17%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 75.2%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 7.3%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 17.4%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No40 122121509-40L1 NAD Water Meter Room - Lower Level; Canvas Covering/Cementitious Insulation40

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Canvas

Non-Asbestos 28%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 50.9%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 20.4%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 28.7%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No40 122121509-40L2 NAD Water Meter Room - Lower Level; Canvas Covering/Cementitious Insulation40

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Insulation

Cellulose Trace, Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 11 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No41 122121509-41L1 NAD Blow Down Tank - Bottom; Canvas Covering/Cementitious Insulation (Gray)41

Red, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Canvas

Non-Asbestos 18%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 52.0%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 29.2%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 18.8%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No41 122121509-41L2 NAD Blow Down Tank - Bottom; Canvas Covering/Cementitious Insulation (Gray)41

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Insulation

Cellulose Trace, Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No42 122121509-42 NAD East Wall - Lower Stairwell; Light Gray Toweled On Cementitious Sealant42

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No43 122121509-43 NAD East Wall; Pink Cementitious Insulation43

Pink, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Bulk Material

Cellulose 15%, Fibrous glass 2.0%, Non-fibrous 83%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No44 122121509-44 NAD West Wall; Brick Mortar44

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 12 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No45 122121509-45.1 NAD Boiler Room - Boiler #2; Breeching Insulation45

Yellow, Heterogeneous, Fibrous, Insulation

Fibrous glass 95%, Non-fibrous 5.0%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No45 122121509-45.2 NAD Boiler Room - Boiler #2; Breeching Insulation45

Gray, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Insulation

Fibrous glass 7.0%, Non-fibrous 93%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No46A 122121509-46 NAD Boiler Room - Boiler #2; White Fiberglass End Sealant46

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Perlite 55%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 42.8%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 1.4%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 55.8%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No46B 122121509-47 NAD Chiller Room; White Fiberglass End Sealant46

White, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Bulk Material

Non-Asbestos 56%

(NOB by NYS ELAP 198.6) by David W. Ralbovsky on 12/20/22

Comment: Heat Sensitive (organic): 42.7%; Acid Soluble (inorganic): 1.2%; Inert (Non-asbestos): 56.1%

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No47A 122121509-48 NAD Boiler Room - North; Black Lab Top (Sink)47

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS ELAP 198.1) by David W. Ralbovsky

AmeriSci Job #: 122121509 Page 13 of 15

PLM Bulk Asbestos Report Client Name: Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

Asbestos Present Total % AsbestosClient No. / HGA Lab No.

Location:

Analyst Description:

Asbestos Types:

Other Material:

No47B 122121509-49 NAD Boiler Room - North; Black Lab Top (Sink)47

Black, Heterogeneous, Non-Fibrous, Cementitious, Bulk Material

Non-fibrous 100%

(by NYS…