111765 Z6 EVALUATION SPREADSHEET 2.22.23.pdf

This document is a Proposal Evaluation Worksheet for Request for Quotation (RFQ) Number 111765 Z6, involving two organizations: Possible Points and Carla Vista, with a potential third entity, the Mental Health Association. The RFQ pertains to two types of Transitional Living Housing services: one without programming and another with mental health programming specifically for parole clients. The evaluation worksheet breaks down the proposal scoring across three key areas: Corporate Overview (25 possible points), Technical Approach (60 possible points), and Cost Proposal (15 possible points), with a total possible score of 100 points.

The scoring reveals performance variations between the two providers. For the Transitional Living Housing without programming, Carla Vista scored 78.7 out of 100 points, with notable weakness in the Technical Approach section where they earned 40.3 out of 60 possible points. In the version with mental health programming, Carla Vista improved slightly, scoring 86.7 total points, with the Technical Approach section showing improvement to 48.3 points. The Cost Proposal section remained consistent at 15.0 points for both service types. The worksheet suggests a competitive evaluation process focusing on comprehensive service delivery for transitional housing and rehabilitation services for parolees.