01_EBDG-26075-062-0_Repower-Conceptual-Study_RevP0.pdf
PDF 857 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- Not on record
- Issued by
- Alaska
About this file
This is a conceptual engineering study prepared by Elliott Bay Design Group for the Alaska Department of Fish and Game regarding the repowering of the research vessel R/V MEDEIA. The study evaluates the feasibility of replacing the vessel's existing twin Detroit Diesel 16V-92N main propulsion engines (625 HP each) with Caterpillar C18 engines (636 HP at Heavy Duty rating). The R/V MEDEIA is a 110-foot-9-inch steel research vessel built in 1982 by Universal Iron Works in Houma, Louisiana. The study is preliminary and conceptual in nature, intended solely to support the owner's decision-making process for future detailed design and engineering work. No physical ship inspection or scan has been conducted at this time, and the study does not constitute approval for construction or procurement activities.
The analysis concludes that the proposed repowering is technically feasible and identifies several favorable attributes of the CAT C18 engine, including improved fuel consumption (approximately 33.6 gallons per hour versus 40 gallons per hour), reduced weight, lower cooling requirements, and better emissions performance with US EPA Tier 3 compliance. Key areas requiring further detailed engineering include exhaust backpressure calculations, cooling system configuration options, engine foundation redesign, engine room ventilation requirements, electrical system integration for 24 VDC control and monitoring, and a complete stability analysis to assess the impact of machinery weight reduction on the vessel's vertical center of gravity. The study recommends replacing the existing channel coolers with new keel coolers and suggests consulting with original equipment manufacturers regarding reduction gear compatibility, torsional vibration analysis, and propeller performance verification before proceeding with implementation.
View the file
Other files
Show all 48
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Repowering Conceptual Study
R/V MEDEIA
Prepared for: Alaska Department of Fish and Game
Prepared by: Nick Hunter, PE
Reference: 26075-062-0
Rev. P0 Date: 7/27/2026
1. Purpose The Alaska Department of Fish and Game has engaged Elliott Bay Design Group (EBDG) to perform a concept-level repower assessment for the research vessel R/V MEDEIA. The primary objective is to support machinery selection and define the scope of any future detailed engineering effort. This study will focus on identifying major technical constraints, integration challenges, and anticipated downstream engineering requirements. This evaluation is conceptual and preliminary in nature and is not intended for construction, procurement, installation, regulatory approval, or other detailed implementation purposes. As such, no ship check or Matterport scan has been done at this time. The study is solely intended to support the owner's decision-making process and development of a future detail design and plan approval package. The R/V MEDEIA is not subject to USCG inspections or oversight, however, 46 CFR Subchapter T regulations are observed for guidance.
2. Vessel Identification Vessel Name: R/V MEDIA
Type: Research Vessel Owner: Alaska Department of Fish and Game
O.N.: 653322 IMO No.: N/A
Builder: Universal Iron Works, Houma, LA Hull No.: 192
Construction Date: 1982 Hull Material: Steel
Length Overall: 110' – 9" Length, Between Perps: 108' – 0"
Beam, molded: 26' – 0" Depth, molded: 12' – 0" Depth, to keel: 2"
26075-062-0 Rev. P0
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
3. Analysis
3.1 General Considerations
The MEDEIA is a twin screw, diesel-mechanical propulsion configuration with equipment that was delivered in the mid-1980s. The vessel currently has two Detroit Diesels installed as main propulsion engines. Each engine is nominally rated at 625 HP at 1800 RPM. A suitable replacement engine, selected for the purposes of this conceptual study, would be a CAT C18. The C18 is an 18.1 liter, inline-6 industrial diesel engine built by Caterpillar. It has ratings between 469 HP and 775 HP and is widely used in marine propulsion applications. For the purposes of this study, a C18 with a Heavy Duty rating was evaluated as the replacement engine. Table 1 highlights the differences between the CAT engine ratings, for reference.
Rating Description
A Rating (Unrestricted Continuous)
For vessels operating at rated load and rated speed up to 100% of the time without interruption or load cycling (80% to 100% load factor).
Typical operation ranges from 5000 to 8000 hours per year.
B Rating (Heavy Duty)
For vessels operating at rated load and rated speed up to 80% of the time with some load cycling (40% to 80% load factor).
Typical operation ranges from 3000 to 5000 hours per year.
C Rating (Maximum Continuous)
For vessels operating at rated load and rated speed up to 50% of the time with cyclical load and speed (20% to 80% load factor).
Typical operation ranges from 2000 to 4000 hours per year.
D Rating (Intermittent Duty)
For vessels operating at rated load and rated speed up to 16% of the time (up to 50% load factor).
Typical operating ranges from 1000 to 3000 hours per year.
E Rating (High Performance)
For vessels operating at rated load and rated speed up to 8% of the time (up to 30% load factor).
Typical operation ranges from 250 to 1000 hours per year.
Table 1: CAT Engine Rating Guide
3.2 Engine Room Arrangement
A repowered drivetrain will likely require less space in the engine room than the current configuration.
When comparing the proposed CAT C18 engine to the existing Detroit Diesel 16V-92N, less physical space is required in the engine room in nearly every dimension as illustrated in Figure 1 and Figure 2.
Existing components are hatched and proposed new components are drawn in red.
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
Figure 1: Engine Room Profile at Approx 6'-0" Off Center
Figure 2: Looking Forward at Frame 40
3.3 Main Engine
The existing Detroit Diesel main engines and proposed CAT C18s share some similarities, but several differences are impactful on the repowering design. Table 2 shows a comparison of the two units' technical details and specifications.
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
Existing New Manufacturer Detroit Diesel CAT Model V16 Series 92 C18 B bHP 625 HP @ 1700 RPM 636 HP @ 1700 RPM
RPM 1450-2100 1800-2100
sFC Appx. 40 gal/h Appx. 33.6 gal/h Torque 1500 ft-lbs @ 1400 RPM 1750 ft-lbs @ 1800 RPM Emissions Standard No Tier Rating US EPA Tier 3 Air Consumption est. 2,370 SCFM 1,275 SCFM Heat Rejection to Atm Unknown 82,233 Btu/h Cooling Load to Coolers Appx 1,380,000 Btu/h 1,081,649 Btu/h Weight (dry) (no gear) 5,200 lbs 4,000 lbs Aspiration Naturally Aspirated Turbocharged Max Back Pressure on Exhaust Manifold
44.21 inH2O (11 kPa)
27 inH2O (6.7 kPa)
Air Intake Restriction 10.0 inH2O (2.5 kPa)
15-25 inH2O (3.7 - 6.2 kPa)
Exhaust Routing 4 x 4" combined to 8" NPS 1 x 6" routed at 8" NPS Table 2: Main Engine Specification Comparison
Evaluating the technical differences between the two engine models highlights some of the biggest differences: the exhaust requirements and the heat rejection.
Exhaust
The existing engine has a higher allowable exhaust backpressure than the proposed engine. If the exhaust routing results in a backpressure on the engine that is suitable for the existing engine but excessive for the new engine, the system may need overhauling.
However, upon closer inspection, the difference in allowable backpressure may not be a significant concern. The exhaust piping between the silencer and the engine will need to be completely redesigned to suit the new exhaust connection on the C18. The C18 has one exhaust connection whereas the existing Detroit Diesel has four. The piping at the engine, therefore, will need to be reworked to accommodate this difference. Exhaust for the C18 is typically routed through 6" or 8" piping. The existing silencers appear to be suitable for an 8" NPS connection. A detailed backpressure calculation still needs to be carried out to ensure proper system function. From a notional perspective, though, the existing exhaust piping from the silencer to the stack would likely be suitable for reuse.
Engine Cooling
Heat rejection data for the existing main engines is not readily available for review. The MEDEIA has four courses of C12x20.7 channel coolers, each 54'-0" long, installed on each side. A detailed analysis will be required to determine whether this is sufficient cooling capacity to meet the cooling requirements for the reduction gear and main engine. The coolers' capacity can be determined practically by evaluating the cooling water's inlet and outlet temperatures. Alternatively, and it is EBDG's recommendation, the vintage channel coolers can be replaced with keel coolers. A 62"x12" two-pass keel cooler would likely satisfy the C18's jacket water requirements while a 55"x8" single-pass keel cooler would likely satisfy the
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
C18's aftercooler and reduction gear requirements. Final calculations are needed to verify these selections, but a high-level estimate has been provided to illustrate the difference in required footprint between the existing channel coolers and updated keel coolers.
Figure 3: Conceptual Keel Cooler Layout (Existing Channel Coolers Shown Overlaid)
Removing the existing channel coolers will not only improve the cooling efficiency of the system, but it will also reduce the overall weight and maintainability of the vessel.
If the channel coolers were retained, the cooling capacity of would need to be established and compared to the proposed engine's requirements. Additionally, the piping system between the coolers and the engine would need to be modified. The proposed engines typically have separate cooling circuits.
Typically one circuit is dedicated for the jacket water and one for the aftercooler and reduction gear. If the channels were retained, the interconnection piping would need to be modified to suit this arrangement.
Engine Room Air Requirements
As shown in Table 2 the new engines will require about 1,275 SCFM for combustion and reject about 82,000 BTU/h each. Using a CAT engine room ventilation formula, assuming an allowable rise in engine room temperature to be 25°F the engine room fans should supply a total of approximately 11,000 CFM.
This is a rough estimate that will require exact measurement of the existing ventilation layout and further calculations to confirm.
Foundations
To maintain shaft alignment the proposed CAT C18 will sit higher than the existing engine as shown in Figure 2. In addition, the bolt patterns for the foundations are also different between the existing and proposed engines. This will require the design and construction of new engine footings. The C18 does have a smaller footprint so it is likely that this redesign will fit within the existing engine space, but further design work is required to confirm this.
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
Fuel System
Both the existing Detroit Diesel engine and proposed C18 are equipped with fuel returns routed back to the fuel supply tank. Detailed calculations will need to be carried out to confirm that the fuel supply and return piping systems are suitable for the engine-driven fuel pump mounted on the proposed engine.
Across the speed regime evaluated, the proposed CAT C18 has a lower fuel consumption compared to the available data of the Detroit Diesel. Below is a figure showing the C18 and existing Detroit Diesel fuel consumptions.
Figure 3: Fuel Consumption of existing Detroit Diesel and proposed C18 compared
Controls/Electrical
It is likely given the R/V MEDEIA is an older unclassed vessel with an electrical system insufficient to support the C18s electrical control and monitoring system. If this is the case a 24 VDC electrical system will need to be installed in the engine room to meet this need. A CAT console is typically delivered with the C18s and should be installed in the engine room for control and monitoring. EBDG also recommends a secondary monitoring screen to be installed in the pilothouse for engine monitoring.
Engine Starting
The current engine utilizes an air starter. The proposed CAT C18s can be pneumatically started requiring a minimum cranking speed of 100 RPM. Further calculations would be required to determine if the old system is compatible with the proposed engine's requirements. However, considering that a 24 VDC system will be installed already for control and monitoring purposes, installing an electric starter may be a better option regardless. Elliot Bay Design Group has had success with using the electric starter for multiple C18 installations previously and recommends this configuration.
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Co ns um pt io n
(g /h r)
Speed (RPM)
Fuel Consumption
Detriot Diesel
C18 "B" Rating
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026
3.4 Reduction Gear
At the client's request, EBDG has considered the option to retain and re-use the reduction gears. While this option has been evaluated here, it is not a scenario EBDG encounters often. Typically, vessel owners elect to replace the engines and reduction gears together, so that the lifecycle of the critical propulsion components is reset to the same time. This also covers both the engine and reduction gear with a manufacturer's warranty (typically one year), in case there are some unknown break-in issues.
There is a Twin Disc MG-530 reduction gear currently installed on the port and starboard side. The existing reduction gear ratio is 4.04:1. Outreach to Twin Disc has resulted in the original manufacturer's ratings and technical data sheets being made available for review.
MG-530 (existing) Gear Ratio 4.04:1 SAE Housing 0 Rated HP at 1200 RPM 625 HP Rated HP at 1600 RPM 775 HP Rated HP at 1800 RPM 840 HP Maximum Speed 2400 RPM
Table 3: Existing Reduction Gear Ratings
Comparing the allowable input power to the proposed CAT C18 power delivered at these speeds, the C18 with a "B" rating (Heavy Duty) would not exceed these power ratings. Below is a figure comparing the reduction gear allowable input power to the existing, and proposed, engines' delivered power.
Figure 4: Reduction Gear Allowable Power Compared to Engines' Delivered Power
The connection between the existing reduction gear and the proposed C18 engine would need to be further evaluated. The existing reduction gear is equipped with an SAE 0 connection flange. The C18
1000 1300 1600 1900 2200
Po w er (H
P)
Speed (RPM)
Allowable and Delivered Power
Detroit Diesel
Reduction Gear MG-530
C18 "B" Rating
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026 does have factory delivery options for both SAE 0 and 1 type flywheels, so it is likely the current gear will interface correctly with the proposed engine. This should be confirmed through engagement with Caterpillar, and a torsional vibration analysis (TVA) would also be requested of the OEM. Proper rotation needs to be evaluated between the gears and the new engines as wel.
Currently, it appears the cooling of the gear is accomplished through the main engine jacket water cooling circuit. Depending on the final decision regarding the future cooling methods (channel cooler versus new keel coolers), the cooling capacity would need to consider the reduction gear's cooling requirements. If new keel coolers were installed, the reduction gear would be included in the engine's aftercooler's keel cooler circuit. If the channel coolers were retained, the cooling capacity would may not be sufficient for the reduction gear in series with the proposed engine.
3.5 Shafting
Considering the proposed C18 with a Heavy Duty rating would be delivering less power than the existing Detroit Diesel, the existing shaft arrangement is suitable. Reference drawings indicate the vessel's 5" shaft is an Aquamet material but does not specify the grade of Aquamet. If a conservative Aquamet tensile strength and a 96% reduction gear efficiency is assumed, the existing shaft is likely suitable for the proposed engine when evaluated against ABS Marine Vessel Rules.
Given that the shaft is likely sufficient and the new engines run at similar RPM and power, the existing propeller is likely to be compatible with the proposed equipment. Further calculations should be made to confirm satisfactory propeller performance before proceeding.
3.6 Stability
Replacing the Detroit Diesel engines with CAT C18s will likely reduce the overall machinery weight.
Because the engines are so low in the vessel, this will raise the vessel's overall vertical center of gravity (VCG). Based on the 1993 stability data, assuming the reduction gear remains unchanged and the engines, coolers and cooling fluid are the majority of the weight changes, the vessel's VCG may raise by 0.5" to 3.6" depending on the scope of the repowering.
Weight (lbs)
VCG
(ft ABL)
V-mom (ft-lbs)
1993 Lightship Characteristics 548,800 11.75 6,448,400
Weight Change (Engines) -2,875 4.5 -12937.5 Weight Change (Coolers) -8,943 1.25 -11178.8 Weight Change (Liquid) -4,493 1.25 -5616.16
Weight Change (Keel Coolers) +413 1.25 516.25 Estimated Characteristics 532,902 12.05 6,419,184 Table 4: Conceptual Lightship Characteristics and Net Change
With this change in vertical center of gravity, a loss of stability will occur. There is no existing digital geometry file for the vessel available, so at this time, the impact of these stability changes cannot be evaluated. EBDG would require a complete stability analysis in the next phase of the project to ensure the vessel's safe operation. The next step would be developing a model and creating a new stability
By | Nick Hunter
Alaska Department of Fish and Game R/V MEDEIA July 27, 2026 booklet based on finalized designs for the repower to confirm what ballasting adjustments may be required to maintain the vessel's stability.
4. Conclusions The conceptual repower assessment indicates that replacing the existing Detroit Diesel main engines with CAT C18 engines is a promising and practical path forward for the R/V MEDEIA. The proposed engines appear generally compatible with the vessel’s available machinery space, existing reduction gears, shafting arrangement, and propeller operating range, while offering potential benefits in fuel consumption, emissions performance, maintenance, and overall machinery weight.
Several areas require detailed follow-on engineering, including exhaust backpressure, cooling system configuration, engine foundations, ventilation, controls and electrical integration, starting arrangements, and stability impacts. In particular, replacing the existing channel coolers with new keel coolers is a favorable option from both performance and maintainability perspectives. Further discussions should also address whether to retain or replace the reduction gears considering their age, maintainability, and remaining operational lifespan. Overall, no major conceptual obstacles were identified that would preclude the repower, and the project is well positioned to advance into a more detailed design, OEM coordination, ship-check verification, and stability analysis.
| Repowering Conceptual Study |
| 1. Purpose |
| 2. Vessel Identification |
| 3. Analysis |
| 3.1 General Considerations |
| 3.2 Engine Room Arrangement |
| 3.3 Main Engine |
| Exhaust |
| Engine Cooling |
| Engine Room Air Requirements |
| Foundations |
| Fuel System |
| Controls/Electrical |
| Engine Starting |
| 3.4 Reduction Gear |
| 3.5 Shafting |
| 3.6 Stability |
4. Conclusions
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .