Exhibit T, Oral Presentation Consensus Scoring Rubric.pdf
PDF 149 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Eligibility Support Services
- Solicitation number
- HHS0017117
- Issued by
- Hockley County, Arlington City, Texas
About this file
This document is an Oral Presentation Consensus Scoring Rubric for Solicitation #HHS0017117, an Eligibility Support Services Request for Proposals issued by a state health and human services agency. The rubric establishes the evaluation framework for oral presentations that will contribute to the final scoring of respondent proposals. Oral presentations will add a maximum of 12 points to each respondent's Final Written Response Score, which comprises the Total Score. The oral presentation evaluation encompasses three criteria: Staffing Levels (4 points available), Quality Management (3 points available), and Maintaining Service Levels (5 points available). Each criterion is scored on a raw scale of 0-10, with the awarded points calculated as a percentage of the raw score applied to the available points for that criterion.
The scoring guide defines five performance levels for evaluation: Excellent (raw score 10), Acceptable (raw score 7-9), Marginal (raw score 4-6), Unacceptable (raw score 1-3), and Nonresponsive (raw score 0). Evaluators assess respondent presentations based on the level of detail provided, direct relevance to criterion needs, and the evaluation team's confidence in the respondent's ability to fulfill requirements. The rubric includes designated spaces for scenario-specific discussions related to each of the three criteria, though the specific scenarios are not detailed in this document version (PCS 543 Version 1.30, effective review/revision date 01/12/2026).
View the file
Other files
Show all 33
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
EXHIBIT T, ORAL PRESENTATION CONSENSUS SCORING RUBRIC
SOLICITATION #: HHS0017117 ESS
SOLICITATION TITLE: Eligibility Support Services Request for Proposals
RESPONDENT:
DATE:
PCS 543 Version 1.30 Page 1 of 3
Review/Revision Date 01/12/2026
ORAL PRESENTATIONS
SCORING SUMMARY
ORAL PRESENTATIONS will add up to 12 additional points to the Respondent’s Final Written Response Score, the calculation of which will be the Total Score as defined by the Solicitation.
Each criterion can receive a raw score of 0-10. The points awarded will be calculated based on the raw score and the number of points available for each criterion. For example, if a criterion has 2 points available and the Respondent receives a raw score of 8/10 (80%) the Respondent would get 80% of the points for that criterion, or 1.6 points (0.8 x 2
= 1.6)
Raw Score:
Excellent= 10 Acceptable= 7-9 Marginal= 4-6 Unacceptable= 1-3 Nonresponsive= 0
ID Criterion Raw
Score
(out of
10)
Number of
Available
Points
Points
Awarded
Justification
1. Staffing Levels 4
2. Quality Management 3
3. Maintaining Service Levels 5
Oral Presentation Score
Final Written Response Score:
Total Score = Final Written Response
Score + Oral Presentation Score.
SOLICITATION TITLE: Eligibility Support Services Request for Proposals
PCS 543 Version 1.30 Page 2 of 3
Specific Scenarios
No. Criteria Scenario Discussion
1. Staffing Levels
2. Quality Management
3. Maintaining Service
Levels
SOLICITATION TITLE: Eligibility Support Services Request for Proposals
PCS 543 Version 1.30 Page 3 of 3
ORAL PRESENTATIONS SCORING GUIDE
Excellent Respondent’s presentation addresses the criterion in a high level of detail. The presentation relates directly to the needs of this criterion/scenario. The Evaluation Team has a high degree of confidence in Respondent’s ability to fulfill the requirements of this criterion.
Raw Score
Acceptable Respondent’s presentation addresses the criterion in a moderate level of detail. Respondent’s presentation relates generally to the needs of this criterion. The Respondent does not address minor considerations.
The Evaluation Team has a medium degree of confidence in Respondent’s ability to fulfill the requirements of this criterion.
Raw Score 7 – 9
Marginal Respondent’s presentation addresses the criterion in general terms.
The Respondent’s presentation may address some major considerations; however, responses may not address specific needs of this criterion/scenario. The Evaluation Team has a somewhat low degree of confidence in Respondent’s ability to fulfill the requirements of this criterion.
Raw Score 4 – 6
Unacceptable Respondent’s presentation addresses the criterion in general terms.
The Respondent’s presentation does not address major considerations or responses do not address specific needs of this criterion/scenario.
The Evaluation Team has a very low degree of confidence in Respondent’s ability to fulfill the requirements of this criterion.
Raw Score 1 – 3
Nonresponsive Respondent’s presentation does not address the criterion/scenario.
The Evaluation Team has no confidence in Respondent’s ability to fulfill the requirements of this criterion.
Raw Score
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .