Event 2120271004.pdf

PDF 235 KB Posted

Attached to
Architectural and Engineering Services for MacFarlane Greenhouse - Growth Chamber Expansion
Solicitation number
2120271004
Issued by
New Hampshire

About this file

This Request for Qualifications/Proposal is issued by the University System of New Hampshire (USNH), representing the University of New Hampshire (UNH), for architectural and engineering services related to the MacFarlane Greenhouse Growth Chamber Expansion project located at 13 Botanical Lane, Durham, New Hampshire. The project scope includes design services through Schematic Design, Design Development, Construction Documents, and Construction Administration phases, with services to commence in January 2027 and conclude by October 2027. The expansion involves demolishing most existing greenhouses while retaining the newest structure, constructing a new 3,400-square-foot greenhouse on the east side of the site, developing a new head-end structure to the south, and providing new unconditioned storage sheds. The design must incorporate MEP/FP modernization, including BAS integration, electrical distribution upgrades, plumbing replacements, site improvements, hazardous materials coordination, and compliance with New Hampshire State Building Codes and the NH State Fire Marshal's requirements. The selection process includes a qualifications submission phase, shortlisting, a pre-proposal informational meeting, and potential oral presentations before final selection. Qualifications submissions must include a cover letter, business information, completed Statement of Qualifications forms, three to five project data forms with images, key personnel identification, and firm capacity information, all submitted as a single PDF attachment not exceeding 50 MB.

The anticipated construction budget is $9,000,000, with $3,000,000 in federal funding (30%) consisting of a 1:1 grant match of federal and other agency funds, and $6,000,000 (70%) financed by non-federal sources. The project will be delivered using a Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR) method, with the CM engaging at the completion of Schematic Design. The A/E team must provide cost estimating services through Schematic Design and coordinate with the CM thereafter, maintaining strict design-to-budget requirements aligned with USNH's modified ConsensusDocs 240 agreement. Minority and women-owned firms and enterprises are encouraged to participate. The contract requires compliance with USNH health, safety, and environmental protocols, and all contractors and design professionals must meet minimum insurance coverage requirements before work commences. This is a quality-based selection process where fee submissions are evaluated only after the selection decision is made and are subject to review and negotiation. The evaluation criteria emphasize team qualifications, comparable project experience, design-to-budget performance, integrated A/E delivery, key personnel relevant experience, design integration approach, risk management methodology, management systems and value, experience with agricultural research facilities, cost management and controls, client service capabilities, demonstrated project understanding, and team fit with the owner community.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Rev. 02/11/2020 1

University System of New Hampshire Event #2120271004

REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS/PROPOSAL

for

Architectural and Engineering Services for MacFarlane Greenhouse - Growth Chamber Expansion

PART 1 – GENERAL

Project Information

Project: Architectural and Engineering Services for MacFarlane Greenhouse - Growth Chamber Expansion, 2020-0099 University of New Hampshire Durham, New Hampshire

Project Site: MacFarlane Research Greenhouse

13 Botanical Lane Durham, New Hampshire

Owner: University of New Hampshire of the University System of New Hampshire

Owner's Agent: Karen Sayers, Category Specialist USNH Procurement Services

Farnum Hall 28 College Drive Concord, NH 03301

Telephone: 603-862-6187 Email: karen.sayers@usnh.edu

Owner’s Rep.: Matthew Mancini, Senior Project Manager

UNH Facilities Project Management

Health, Safety & Environmental Protocols All contractors, sub-contractors, design professionals, and other personnel performing work on USNH property shall comply with current USNH health, safety, and environmental protocols, as well as all applicable federal and State of New Hampshire requirements in effect at the time of performance. Campus-specific procedures (e.g., site access requirements, screening, PPE, or jobsite practices) will be communicated by the respective campus (UNH, PSU, or KSC) and must be followed for the duration of the work.

Project Schedule

Project Design phase January 2027 – October 2027.

The Owner anticipates that construction activities will commence following completion of the design phase (October 2027).

A detailed construction schedule, including sequencing and duration of work, will be developed collaboratively with the selected Architectural/Engineering team and the Construction Manager during the design phase. This approach will ensure alignment with project requirements, campus operations, and the integrated project delivery process.

Rev. 02/11/2020 2

Solicitation Intent

The University System of New Hampshire, representing the University of New Hampshire (UNH) is seeking qualified, professional firms to provide design services outlined herein specific to the MacFarlane Greenhouse Growth Chamber Expansion at UNH. This solicitation is open to all qualified firms eligible to do business in the State of New Hampshire.

Minority and women-owned firms and enterprises are encouraged to participate in this solicitation process.

Existing Facilities and Conditions

UNH maintains an extensive collection of record drawings and documentation for the MacFarlane greenhouse complex, including original construction documents and subsequent renovation/as-built drawings. These materials will be made available upon request to shortlisted firms. The selected A/E team will be expected to verify existing conditions during Schematic Design and recommend any additional investigations as needed.

Project Funding & Delivery

The anticipated construction budget (Cost of the Work) for the renovation of the MacFarlane Greenhouse Growth Chamber Expansion is $9,000,000.

The project will be delivered using a Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR) method, with the CM onboard at the end of Schematic Design.

For purposes of compliance with Section 511 of P.L. 101-166 (the "Stevens Amendment"), firms are advised that the UNH MacFarlane Greenhouse Growth Chamber Expansion project is federally funded with $3,000,000, which is a combination of a 1:1 grant match of federal and other Agency funds (30%).

Additionally, 70% ($6,000,000) is financed by non-federal sources.

PART 2 – PROJECT DESCRIPTION

Project Overview

The project will expand and modernize the MacFarlane Greenhouse facility by demolishing the existing greenhouses, except for the newest greenhouse, which will remain, and by providing a new greenhouse of similar size and function. The existing head-end house will be substantially demolished, with portions retained only where deemed reasonably suitable for renovation and necessary to support facility operations during and after construction. The western portion contains most of the existing utilities serving the facility and will require careful evaluation and coordination to maintain critical services to the remaining greenhouse.

A new greenhouse of approximately 3,400 SF is proposed on the east side of the site, along with a new head-end structure to the south that will connect the existing and new greenhouses and create an interior service yard. The project will also include new open, unconditioned, 3-sided storage sheds. The final quantity, size, configuration, and arrangement of the storage sheds, as well as the extent of the existing head-end house to be retained and renovated, will be determined during design. The design must provide a clear phasing and utility strategy to maintain operation of the existing greenhouse and support ongoing research throughout construction.

Scope of Services Sought

The selected A/E team, under the direction of a designated owner design manager will provide integrated architectural and engineering services for the renovation of MacFarlane Greenhouse in accordance with the USNH modified ConsensusDocs 240 (including Exhibits F and G) and UNH standards. Services will be delivered through Schematic Design, Design Development, Construction Documents, and Construction Administration, in collaboration with UNH and the CM-at-Risk.

Project‑specific emphases (to be developed with UNH and the CM):

Rev. 02/11/2020 3

• Greenhouse design criteria will be developed collaboratively with stakeholders to define performance requirements, operational functionality, space planning, and the ultimate size and scope of the research greenhouse facility.

• MEP/FP modernization (including BAS integration, electrical distribution upgrades (panels/feeders, emergency lighting, generator/ATS, and plumbing replacements (domestic/sanitary, heaters/pumps).

• Site improvements serving the greenhouse complex; adjacent walks, ramps, and flatwork.

• Hazardous‑materials coordination in design.

• Code, life‑safety, and permitting with the NH State Fire Marshal (UNH is subject to state authority and exempt from local).

Provide pre-design, design and construction administration services as delineated in the USNH Standard Form of Agreement for Professional Planning and Design Services and all related appendices.

Provide individuals whose work experience is directly related to buildings and programs of this type.

Provide truly integrated architectural and engineering design services to develop a building envelope and non-proprietary electrical, mechanical, HVAC and fire protection systems that are as efficient and simple to maintain/operate as possible.

Architectural design is to provide spaces that are efficient and easy to maintain. When required by the project/scope of work, the design team is expected to use energy modeling and other contemporary tools throughout the design process.

Provide all documentation required for State of New Hampshire permits. The owner is accountable to state authority (ies) and is exempt from local authority.

Ensure that the design stays within the construction budget, working with owner representatives to identify cost efficiencies and bid alternates that do not compromise the long-term functionality of the building.

Incorporate owner construction standards into all specifications.

Provide illustrations and working models (computer or physical) that clearly communicate the design character and elements at both the schematic and design development levels.

Prepare at the end of construction a set of record drawings from construction drawings marked up by the general contractor and their subcontractors.

The level of cost estimating support required from the A/E will vary depending on project delivery method and timing of CM engagement.

Cost Control & Design-to-Budget Requirements

The A/E shall meet all cost management obligations established in USNH CD240 and Exhibits F and G — including cost estimating, design-to-budget, phase approvals, alternates, and redesign — and shall actively manage scope, systems, and materials at every phase to keep the design aligned with the Owner's approved construction budget.

Budget Alignment & Phase Gates Progression from SD to DD, and from DD to CD, requires Owner approval confirming that the design remains aligned with the approved Cost of the Work based on the estimate required for the applicable phase. If an estimate exceeds the approved Cost of the Work, the A/E shall identify recommended corrective actions and revise the design as authorized before proceeding.

Cost Monitoring & Compliance At each required design milestone, the party identified in the Cost Estimating Responsibilities section shall prepare and submit the applicable estimate of the Cost of the Work. The A/E shall participate in the review and reconciliation of such estimate and shall provide design-related input regarding scope, constructability, alternates, value-engineering opportunities, and other measures affecting project cost.

The party responsible for preparing the estimate shall also prepare the budget reconciliation report comparing the estimate to the Owner’s approved Cost of the Work. The report shall identify material variances, assumptions, escalation factors, Rev. 02/11/2020 4 allowances, contingencies, alternates, and recommended corrective actions necessary to maintain compliance with the approved project budget.

If the applicable estimate indicates that the design exceeds the approved Cost of the Work, the estimating party shall lead development of a corrective action plan, in collaboration with the A/E and Owner. The corrective action plan shall identify recommended scope adjustments, design modifications, value-engineering opportunities, procurement strategies, alternates, or other measures necessary to restore alignment with the approved budget.

The A/E shall timely evaluate and document the design implications of proposed corrective actions and shall revise the design as authorized by the Owner. Failure by either the estimating party or the A/E to perform its respective responsibilities under this section may be considered noncompliance with the contract requirements.

Alternates Strategy The A/E shall develop and maintain a structured list of bid alternates throughout the design process to maintain cost control without compromising core project objectives.

No Unapproved Betterments The A/E shall not incorporate enhancements beyond those explicitly authorized by the Owner. Any proposed enhancements must be identified as alternates with associated cost and schedule impacts.

Cost Estimating Responsibilities The A/E shall provide cost estimating as a Basic Service through the completion of Schematic Design, as identified in Exhibit F. The A/E's estimating obligation includes a planning-level cost opinion at the outset of design and a Schematic Design phase estimate of the Cost of the Work, both of which shall be reconciled against the Owner's approved construction budget of $9,000,000.

Following engagement of the Construction Manager at Risk (anticipated at the completion of Schematic Design), primary responsibility for preparation of estimates of the Cost of the Work shall transition to the CM. Thereafter, the A/E shall coordinate with the CM, provide timely design and technical information necessary to support the CM's estimating efforts, and participate in estimate review, budget reconciliation, and value-management activities at Design Development and Construction Document submissions. The A/E shall consider and respond to estimate findings and shall incorporate Owner-authorized design revisions necessary to support budget objectives.

Regardless of which party prepares an estimate, the A/E shall remain responsible for designing the Project in accordance with the approved scope, program requirements, and budget objectives. If an estimate indicates that the projected Cost of the Work exceeds the approved construction budget, the party responsible for preparing the estimate shall identify the sources of the variance and lead development of a corrective action plan. The A/E shall assist in evaluating design-related cost reduction measures, alternates, value-engineering opportunities, and other authorized revisions necessary to restore alignment with the approved budget.

These project-specific requirements supplement the A/E's responsibilities under USNH CD240 and the applicable exhibits.

Scope Authorization The A/E shall proceed only with scope elements explicitly authorized by the Owner in writing. Stakeholder feedback, programming discussions, or exploratory design concepts shall not constitute authorization to expand scope, increase program area, or elevate system performance beyond approved direction.

Pertinent Information and Special Conditions

Terms: The terms “must”, “shall” and “will” are used interchangeably in this document. All have the same meaning—they are denoting a basic requirement which the A&E firm must provide or perform, or they are denoting an action the owner or designated third party will perform.

Authority Having Jurisdiction: University of New Hampshire is accountable to state authority(ies) and is exempt from local authority. The NH State Fire Marshal will approve any construction documents prior to their being issued.

• State Building Codes and Permits: University of New Hampshire, as a part of the University System of New Hampshire, falls under the jurisdiction of the statewide building code (see:

Rev. 02/11/2020 5 http://www.nh.gov/safety/divisions/firesafety/legal/codebuilding.html). The AE firm shall comply therewith and shall cooperate with the Owner and with NH authorities having jurisdiction (and/or their agents) with regard to necessary reviews.

• Local Building Codes and Permits: In general, the University of New Hampshire does not fall under local jurisdiction. However, the Owner is subject to local water/sewer connection permitting requirements, road cut/closure permitting requirements, and noise ordinances.

USNH and the campus reserve the right to request, from time to time, information relating to AE firm’s employees, agents, or other employed by or associated with the AE firm, including employees and agents of sub-consultants and sub-sub-consultants, who have access to the campus, as required by the campus to comply with the provisions of the Jeanne Clery Act, as amended, 20 U.S.C. Section 1092(f) and to ensure that no such personnel represent a safety or security risk to the campus, its employees, agents, students or guests. The campus reserves the right to deny entry to the campus, at its sole discretion, to any consultant, sub-consultant, sub-sub-consultant, contractor, sub-contractor and sub-sub-contractor personnel who the campus believes represents a safety or security risk to the campus, its employees, agents, students or guests.

Form of Contract

The University System of New Hampshire (USNH) uses a modified form of ConsensusDocs 240 Standard Agreement Between Owner and Design Professional. This document is available on the web in the Buyer Attachments section of this Event. It is expected that all short-listed teams will fully review this document and take the requirements into consideration when preparing proposals.

Insurance

Awarded firm will be expected to meet the minimum coverage requirements of the insurance requirements noted in Section

7.2 of the USNH CD240. No work will begin until Owner’s Agent is in receipt of the certificate of insurance.

PART 3 – SELECTION PROCESS

Evaluation Committee

A committee will evaluate all qualification submissions. The committee consists of at least the following:

Karen Sayers, Sourcing and Contract Specialist, USNH Procurement Matt Mancini, Senior Project Manager, UNH Facilities Project Management Anton Bekkerman, Associate Dean for Research, COLSA, and Director of the Agricultural Experiment Station Laurie Westover, Facilities and Operations Manager, COLSA Matt Biondi, Greenhouse Manager • Agricultural Experiment Station Mike Mason, Director, Capital Planning and Management

Selection Schedule

The selection committee intends to adhere to the Event Timeline in undertaking this solicitation/selection process. Dates and times are subject to change as the process progresses.

Evaluation Process and Criteria

Based upon the information presented in the qualifications submission, the committee will develop a shortlist of the most highly qualified candidates. Short-listed firms will then provide formal proposals and fee submissions and may be invited to individual interviews/oral presentations, following which the committee will identify the successful firm as that which can provide the greatest overall benefit to the owner. However, the Owner reserves the right to make its decision without benefit of oral presentations/interviews. Respondents’ submissions will be evaluated based on the following broad criteria:

Qualifications Criteria:

1. Team Qualifications. Relevant credentials, qualifications and expertise of firm including the proposed consultant team.

http://www.nh.gov/safety/divisions/firesafety/legal/codebuilding.html

Rev. 02/11/2020 6

2. Comparable Project Experience. Relevant and recent experience on projects of similar scale, complexity, and type, demonstrated through successful project outcomes. Relevant and recent experience by the prime and key consultants; include at least three and no more than five successfully completed projects on Appendix “A” Project Data Forms.

3. Design-to-Budget & Schedule Performance. Demonstrated ability to deliver projects within established construction budgets and schedules, including effective use of cost control measures such as value engineering, alternates, and scope alignment.

4. Project-Type & Technical Experience. Demonstrated experience with project types, systems, or renovation scopes relevant to this project.

5. Integrated A/E Delivery. Ability and experience of the entire design team to provide coordinated, efficient, and integrated architectural and engineering services aligned with project goals and institutional standards.

Formal Proposal Criteria:

1. Key Personnel. Relevant experience of all key personnel proposed for this project and their time commitments.

2. Design Integration & Approach. Perceived team ability to integrate architectural and engineering design to achieve project objectives, and the team’s overall design approach for this specific project.

3. Methodology & Risk Management. Coherent methodology to address the project’s challenges and opportunities

(e.g., phasing, abatement coordination, schedule constraints).

4. Management Systems & Value. Adequacy of the firm’s management practices, QA/QC systems, staffing, proposed tools, and design methodology; overall value and benefit of the services in relation to fee (fee to be evaluated after selection).

5. Experience in the design of agricultural research and experimentation facilities, including demonstrated success with utility infrastructure renewal while maintaining ongoing building operations and research activities.

6. Cost Management Plan & Controls. Clarity, rigor, and practicality of the team’s cost‑management plan: (1) internal QA/QC to prevent scope inflation; (2) real‑time estimating cadence; (3) development and tracking of alternates; (4) method to ensure final CDs remain within the fixed Cost of the Work (CD240 §3.2.5).

7. Client service. Candor, inclusiveness, ability to listen, and spirit of collaboration; degree to which the team meets or exceed the university’s/college’s expectations for functionality, enduring quality, ease of maintenance, and efficiency of operations at a competitive initial cost.

8. Understanding of Objectives. Demonstrated depth of knowledge and understanding of the project objectives, challenges, and opportunities, including the identification of key design issues and proposed handling.

9. Project Approach Evidence. Ability to articulate a coherent, plausible approach to this project and its critical elements, with relevant examples.

10. Team Fit. Ability of key personnel to work successfully with the owner community as perceived by the selection committee.

This is a quality-based selection process. The fee submission will be evaluated after the selection is made. Proposed fee structure may be subject to review and negotiation.

Informational Meeting

Finalists will be invited to attend a pre-proposal meeting. See the Event Timeline for date/time and location.

The purpose of this meeting is to provide finalists an opportunity to learn and develop questions for submission to the board about the selection process, clarify and/or receive additional information and details about the intent of this project, its scope, delivery process, and contractual framework, meet key players for the Owner, and visit the site.

Oral Presentations/Interviews

Short-listed firms may be invited to the owner to make an oral presentation and to be interviewed by the evaluation committee. However, the owner reserves the right to make its decision without benefit of oral presentations/interviews.

If interviews/presentations are held, each short-listed firm will be forwarded additional information about their oral session following the announcement of the short-list and sufficiently prior to the oral session to permit advance preparation, including time and location information as well as the availability of any audio-visual support. This is the opportunity to demonstrate the depth of knowledge and understanding about this specific design effort and provide compelling evidence of the attributes that set your team apart from the other finalists.

Rev. 02/11/2020 7

Three areas to be addressed in the presentations:

• It is expected that the primary design architect and the architect’s day-to-day point of contact be present and describe their specific experience that is directly relevant to this project. Other key team members may also describe their roles and the specific benefits they bring to this project.

• Describe specific techniques, processes, and/or commitments your design team will apply on this project to create a truly integrated design. Identify what commitment(s) the Owner needs to make to this design effort to achieve a truly integrated design.

• Describe your team’s design approach and insights to this specific project using any combination of illustrations of your previous projects, observations about the university’s/college’s intentions, the site, and the construction budget.

PART 4 – SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS

General Requirements

All documents will be submitted in the eSource tool as a single attachment in PDF format under Supplier Attachments.

Attachments must not exceed 50 MB/each. The submission PDF document should be in the prescribed order in the Format requirements below. The information presented under each heading should conform strictly to the information and/or issues requested.

Qualifications Submission

Cover Letter – Provide a cover letter indicating the name of the firm(s) making the submission indicating why you’re interested in being selected for the project. Include a description of why your firm is well suited for and can meet the needs of this project. Acknowledge receiving any addenda that may have been issued for this RFQ/P. The letter should be signed by the individual(s) authorized to bind the respondent or group to any statements or representations made therein and to represent the information presented as authentic.

Business Information – Provide a brief description of the firm’s history, focus and vision.

Relevant and recent experience – Submit completed Document 00420 – Statement of Qualifications (attached separately).

Submit Appendix A- Project Data Form for at least three, but no more than five, projects completed by the submitting firm(s) within the past five years. Please emphasize successfully completed projects that are most similar to the proposed project (e.g., successful budget development; integration of building with site selected; integrated instructional and studio space;

inspiring teaching and experiential environment which fosters interaction among students and faculty) and/or having significant sustainable design features). Provide images of interior and exterior for each project submitted.

Respondent’s Team - Identify Respondent’s key personnel—briefly note relevant experience (e.g., with this facility type and/or collegiate projects). It is important to indicate if the experience was with the current firm or a past firm (please identify the past firm as appropriate). Identify all major sub-consultant disciplines proposed for project team. Provide firm names if known.

Respondent’s Capacity – Provide the following information about the firm(s) named above:

• Number of current projects and total anticipated construction value of present workload.

• For any key personnel and any major sub-consultants identified in Respondent’s Team, list the total number of projects, percent of completion and the total dollar value thereof for any Project Manager (defined as the person responsible for day-to-day production of the work of the project) available for assignment to this project

• Location of primary office from which the services would be provided and number of employees (licensed professionals, interns, technical support) at that location

Finalist Proposal Submission: (Short-listed firms only)

Additional specific information concerning the content and format requirements for the proposal may be forwarded to the finalists selected to submit proposals. At minimum, the formal proposal shall contain the following:

Executive summary - Acknowledge receiving any addenda that may have been issued for this RFQ/P. The executive summary should be signed by the responsible principal of the firm.

Rev. 02/11/2020 8

Relevant Credentials, Qualifications and Experience - Provide resumes for all employees who will be assigned to this project; expand upon the information provided in Document 00420 – Statement of Qualifications, which was submitted with your qualifications package. Describe prior project experience that is most relevant to this specific project. List what projects these employees are currently working on and in what capacity. Note when their current responsibilities end. List any subconsultant firms to be engaged and provide similar information for their key personnel. Note each individual’s recent (five years) experience on higher education projects.

Approach to this Project – Provide a brief narrative outlining the significant challenges and/or opportunities of this project. Reference your experience on previous projects and how that experience fits this one. Identify the critical elements that need to be skillfully addressed in order to deliver a successful project; include any options worthy of exploration. This section can be seen as an opportunity for the respondent to illustrate that they understand the requirements, scope and intent of the project. While a graphic submission is not required for the proposal, if the respondent feels that drawings, sketches, or other illustrations can best demonstrate its vision and understanding of the project, they are free to support their narrative in such a fashion. This may be considered as an opportunity for the respondent to articulate its understanding of the project’s requirements in a conceptual solution, upon which its proposal has been based, and demonstrate the level of design skills they can provide toward meeting those requirements.

Project Schedule – Outline the key tasks overall. Include recommended durations for each; note approximate start/complete dates for the services requested in Section 2.3. Provide a schedule that will allow for the successful completion of the project that meets the university’s/college’s programmatic needs and quality expectations.

Cost Management and Estimating Approach – Describe the team’s approach to designing to the approved Cost of the Work, including scope control, required estimating services, coordination with any CM or Owner-retained estimator, estimate reconciliation, alternates development, value analysis, and corrective action when estimates exceed budget.

Identify the personnel or subconsultants responsible for any A/E-provided estimating services.

Deliverables – Stipulate the specific deliverables your firm will provide to meet the needs of this project and the terms of USNH’s standard agreement.

Fees

The proposed fee submission should not be included in the proposal pdf. The fee proposal is to be a separate PDF document.

END OF DOCUMENT

REQUEST FOR QUALIFICATIONS/PROPOSAL
PART 2 – PROJECT DESCRIPTION
1. Team Qualifications. Relevant credentials, qualifications and expertise of firm including the proposed consultant team.
2. Comparable Project Experience. Relevant and recent experience on projects of similar scale, complexity, and type, demonstrated through successful project outcomes. Relevant and recent experience by the prime and key consultants; include at least t...
3. Design-to-Budget & Schedule Performance. Demonstrated ability to deliver projects within established construction budgets and schedules, including effective use of cost control measures such as value engineering, alternates, and scope alignment.
4. Project-Type & Technical Experience. Demonstrated experience with project types, systems, or renovation scopes relevant to this project.
5. Integrated A/E Delivery. Ability and experience of the entire design team to provide coordinated, efficient, and integrated architectural and engineering services aligned with project goals and institutional standards.
1. Key Personnel. Relevant experience of all key personnel proposed for this project and their time commitments.
2. Design Integration & Approach. Perceived team ability to integrate architectural and engineering design to achieve project objectives, and the team’s overall design approach for this specific project.
3. Methodology & Risk Management. Coherent methodology to address the project’s challenges and opportunities (e.g., phasing, abatement coordination, schedule constraints).
4. Management Systems & Value. Adequacy of the firm’s management practices, QA/QC systems, staffing, proposed tools, and design methodology; overall value and benefit of the services in relation to fee (fee to be evaluated after selection).
5. Experience in the design of agricultural research and experimentation facilities, including demonstrated success with utility infrastructure renewal while maintaining ongoing building operations and research activities.
6. Cost Management Plan & Controls. Clarity, rigor, and practicality of the team’s cost‑management plan: (1) internal QA/QC to prevent scope inflation; (2) real‑time estimating cadence; (3) development and tracking of alternates; (4) method to ensure ...
7. Client service. Candor, inclusiveness, ability to listen, and spirit of collaboration; degree to which the team meets or exceed the university’s/college’s expectations for functionality, enduring quality, ease of maintenance, and efficiency of ope...
8. Understanding of Objectives. Demonstrated depth of knowledge and understanding of the project objectives, challenges, and opportunities, including the identification of key design issues and proposed handling.
9. Project Approach Evidence. Ability to articulate a coherent, plausible approach to this project and its critical elements, with relevant examples.
10. Team Fit. Ability of key personnel to work successfully with the owner community as perceived by the selection committee.
This is a quality-based selection process. The fee submission will be evaluated after the selection is made. Proposed fee structure may be subject to review and negotiation.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .