Evaluation packet.pdf
PDF 1 MB Posted
- Attached to
- Grazing lease for Ft Churchill
- Solicitation number
- 70CNR-S2979
- Issued by
- Humboldt County, Nevada
About this file
This evaluation packet contains scoring sheets from multiple evaluators for the Fort Churchill Grazing Lease Agreement (RFP 70CNR-2979) administered by the Nevada Division of State Parks. The evaluation forms show detailed scoring across four criteria categories: Experience, Expertise and Reliability (25 points), Proposal - Operations Plan (30 points), Rental Offer (25 points), and Other Criteria and Considerations (20 points). Three bidders were evaluated - Talbott, Mission, and S7 - with evaluations completed between November 27 and December 10, 2024.
The scoring results show Talbott receiving the highest average total score of 89.5 points, followed by Mission with 83.25 points, and S7 with 76.5 points. Talbott scored particularly well in Operations Plan (27.5 average) and Experience (23.25 average). The evaluation forms were completed by multiple evaluators including Jennifer Villenueva, Brad Larkin, and Cody Tingey, with each evaluator providing independent scores that were averaged for the final results. All evaluations used the standard form with the maximum 100-point scale spread across the four specified criteria categories.
View the file
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| RFP S2979 - Fort Churchill.docx | DOCX document | |
| S2979 Q&A.pdf | ||
| S2979 Fort Churchill - Scope of Work (2).pdf | ||
| Bid evaluation - recalculation packet.pdf | ||
| Quote Instructions.pdf | ||
| S2979 Fort Churchill - Pasture Management Plan.pdf |
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
#1 #2 #3 #4 Average Experience, Expertise and Reliability 25 18 25 25 23.25 Proposal - Operations Plan 30 22 28 30 27.5 Rental Offer 25 19 23 20 21.75 Other Criteria and Considerations 19 11 18 20 17
TOTALS 99 70 94 95 89.5
#1 #2 #3 #4 Average Experience, Expertise and Reliability 20 19 20 20 19.75 Proposal - Operations Plan 30 28 23 30 27.75 Rental Offer 25 15 20 25 21.25 Other Criteria and Considerations 18 13 12 15 14.5
TOTALS 93 75 75 90 83.25
#1 #2 #3 #4 Average Experience, Expertise and Reliability 25 16 15 15 17.75 Proposal - Operations Plan 30 19 20 15 21 Rental Offer 25 25 17 25 23 Other Criteria and Considerations 18 16 15 10 14.75
TOTALS 98 76 67 65 76.5
Talbott
Mission
S7
Talbott
Fort Churchill Grazing Lease Agreement RFP 70CNR-2979
PROPOSAL EVALUATION FORM
MAX. POINTS POINTS
III. Experience, Expertise and Reliability 25
IV. Proposal – Operations Plan 30 ____30_______
V. Rental Offer 25
VII. Other Criteria and Considerations 20
TOTAL POINTS:
(Maximum 100)
The award of the lease resulting from the Request for Proposal shall be based upon the Respondent judged to be most favorable to Nevada Division of State Parks in accordance with the above criteria.
Evaluator: ___________________________________ Date: _______________________
11/27/2024
12/10/2024
Mission
PROPOSAL EVALUATION FORM
MAX. POINTS POINTS
III. Experience, Expertise and Reliability 25
IV. Proposal – Operations Plan 30 ___30________
V. Rental Offer 25
VII. Other Criteria and Considerations 20
TOTAL POINTS:
(Maximum 100)
The award of the lease resulting from the Request for Proposal shall be based upon the Respondent judged to be most favorable to Nevada Division of State Parks in accordance with the above criteria.
Evaluator: ___________________________________ Date: _______________________
S7
PROPOSAL EVALUATION FORM
MAX. POINTS POINTS
III. Experience, Expertise and Reliability 25
IV. Proposal – Operations Plan 30 ____30_______
V. Rental Offer 25
VII. Other Criteria and Considerations 20
TOTAL POINTS:
(Maximum 100)
The award of the lease resulting from the Request for Proposal shall be based upon the Respondent judged to be most favorable to Nevada Division of State Parks in accordance with the above criteria.
Evaluator: ___________________________________ Date: _______________________
| Evaluation averages.pdf |
| TITLE |
| Talbott Bid Packet for Evaluation_JV.pdf |
| Evaluation page.pdf |
| Talbott Bid Packet for Evaluation_BL.pdf |
| Talbott Bid Packet for Evaluation_SE.pdf |
| Talbott Bid Packet for Evaluation_CT.pdf |
| TITLE.pdf |
| Mission Bid Packet for Evaluation_JV.pdf |
| Evaluation page.pdf |
| Mission Bid Packet for Evaluation_BL.pdf |
| Mission Bid Packet for Evaluation_SE.pdf |
| Mission Bid Packet for Evaluation_CT.pdf |
| TITLE |
| S7 Bid Packet for Evaluation_JV.pdf |
| Evaluation page.pdf |
| S7 Bid Packet for Evaluation_BL.pdf |
| S7 Bid Packet for Evaluation_SE.pdf |
| S7 Bid Packet for Evaluation_CT.pdf |
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .