Asbestos Lead Survey_Bldg-1006_20150326.pdf

March 26, 2015

Mr. Aaron Williams USACE, Tulsa District 1645 South 101st East Avenue Tulsa, OK 74128 Phone: (918) 669-4915

RE: Submittal of Hazardous Building Material Surveys Contract No. W912BV-10-D-2011, Task Order 0002 Ft. Bliss Bldg. # 1006

Dear Mr. Williams, This document summarizes the Asbestos Survey and/or Lead Paint Survey Reports for the subject building. The below listed information was utilized to complete the Scope of Work Tasks:

Bldg. No. 1006 POC: Jesse Moncada Phone No: 915-568-1838 Building Square Footage (SF) Reported: 47,649 Technical Summary:

1. LEAD PAINT. ENCON performed a total of two-hundred and sixty-two (262) XRF analyses, which included two-hundred and thirty-four (234) building component measurements and twenty-eight (28) calibration checks. Ninety-two (92) of the building readings tested positive for lead paint. Refer to the attachments for more details.

2. ASBESTOS. A total of eighty-four (84) bulk samples were collected for lab analysis. The attached analytical results indicated that asbestos containing materials were present in the subject building. Contact Ft. Bliss, DPW regarding the current overall status of any asbestos or lead paint materials, and any additional related reports that may become available.

SUMMARY TABLE (with Action Level) Previously Surveyed by others

Were Found

Were Not Found

Actions Required Yes / No

1. Lead Containing Paint Materials (≥0.3 mg/cm2) X Yes

2. Asbestos Containing Materials (>1 %) X Yes

Please contact me with any technical questions, or follow-up needs that you may have.

Sincerely, David Epperly, Ph.D., P.E.

Project Manager – ALL Consulting

CC: Jesse Moncada (Ft Bliss DPW) Barry Vercoe (CESFW-PEC-TM)

ATTACHMENTS

1. Lead Paint Survey Report

2. Asbestos Survey Report

ATTACHMENT 1

Lead Paint Survey Report

COMPREHENSIVE LEAD PAINT SURVEY

BUILDING 1006

FORT BLISS, TEXAS 79916

Prepared for:

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Tulsa District

Prepared by:

ALL CONSULTING TEAM

ENCON International, Inc.

7307 Remcon Circle, #103

El Paso, TX 79912 and

ALL Consulting, LLC 1718 S. Cheyenne Ave.

Tulsa, OK 74119

Inspection Start Date:

February 2, 2015

LEAD PAINT SURVEY REPORT

Ft. Bliss, Texas ─ Building 1006

PURPOSE

The ALL Consulting Team was contracted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), Tulsa

District, to perform comprehensive Hazardous Building Materials Surveys to identify the presence of any asbestos or lead paint at a number of facilities at Ft. Bliss, Texas. This project also included the development and population of a database to store the survey reports for access by the Ft. Bliss

Directorate of Public Works (DPW), and others. The facilities that are included within this contract scope of work includes buildings within the New Mexico installations of McGregor Range and Dona Ana Range, in addition to the Ft. Bliss facilities in Texas.

BACKGROUND

Ft. Bliss has a large number of buildings constructed before 1990 when the use of asbestos and lead paint was prevalent in the construction of buildings. Because the presence of these materials still exists in these facilities, Ft. Bliss is required to identify the extent of the lead paint remaining at these buildings, as well as their condition. Lead in paint is a hazard that is regulated by the

Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) under 29 CFR 1926.62 for worker exposure. In addition to the dangers of occupational exposure to construction and maintenance workers, as well as building occupants, lead particles and lead dust may be inadvertently carried home on clothes and shoes to expose their families. Identifying components containing lead paint will not only protect the workers and their families, but will help to indemnify Ft. Bliss by preemptively identifying the location of these potential hazardous materials.

INTRODUCTION

In accordance with OSHA Lead Regulation 29 CFR 1926.62, and the OSHA Hazard

Communication standard (29 CFR 1910.1200), where lead exists workers must be notified and steps must be taken to protect them from the inherent hazards. By identifying the lead containing components in these facilities, and, when appropriate, removing the hazards or potential hazards, Ft. Bliss avoids the liability of workers becoming exposed. Lead paint was banned for use in residential dwellings starting in January of 1978, but lead paint is still available for non-residential applications.

FACILITY DESCRIPTION

The Facility known as Building 1006 was constructed in 1956, and was occupied at the time of inspection. Its previous use was listed as “barracks.” A description of this facility is presented in

Table 1 below.

TABLE 1 – BUILDING DESCRIPTION

Building Items Description Area of building 47,649 square feet Date of Construction 1956 Number of floors Three (3) floors and basement Exterior wall materials CMU, concrete Roof type Flat Roof material Asphalt roll roofing

Interior walls 1st, 2nd & 3rd floor: CMU, ceramic tiles Basement: concrete

Interior floors Concrete

Interior floor coverings 1st, 2nd & 3rd floor: carpet, 12x12 vinyl tiles, ceramic tiles Basement: Rubber mats (workout room only) Hammerhead Area: ceramic tiles, 12x12 vinyl

Ceilings

1st floor: 2x4 ceiling tiles, drywall 2nd & 3rd floor: drywall Basement: concrete Hammerhead Area: drywall, 2x2 ceiling tiles

Notes:

UNIQUE PAINTING HISTORY

Lead can be found in paint, varnish, shellac, and stain, so any coated surface other than a factory coating is suspect for lead paint. A Lead Paint Survey is based upon coated components which are grouped into similar components with a similar (unique) painting history. This would include components with the same substrate, built or installed at the same time, with a common painting history. Items such as window components (sash and mullions), window frame (trim, header, sill, and apron), doors, and door frame materials, should be considered to have a possible separate painting history, and could have had different coatings applied throughout the years.

REGULATORY STANDARDS

Lead-based paint in residential structures, or Child Occupied Facilities (day care facilities, etc.), is regulated by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) under 24 CFR 35, and also by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) under 40 CFR 745. Only a few of these types of facilities have been identified in the buildings included in this contract. For all facilities included in this category, both HUD and EPA regulations will apply. All other buildings identified in this project would be regulated under the OSHA standards pertaining to worker protection from hazards (29 CFR 1926.62).

Sampling protocols have already been thoroughly established by the HUD and the EPA for residential housing units. For non-residential structures, there is no specified lead paint sampling protocol, but HUD / EPA protocols were generally followed. These comprehensive lead paint surveys include thorough inspections to identify all lead painted components.

SAMPLING METHODOLOGY

The building materials survey tasks were performed in accordance with the Final Hazardous

Building Materials Surveys, Sampling Plan, Fort Bliss, Texas, December 2014, prepared by ALL

Consulting and ENCON International, Inc. A visual inspection of the Facility was conducted to develop a sampling strategy. This included identifying component groups with similar painting histories. Each component group was sampled throughout the facility to establish whether or not the building contained lead at the prescribed action level for this project, at the time of the survey.

This Lead Paint Inspection was performed on February 2-3, 2015 and February 5, 2015 using an x-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyzer, to identify if any lead amounts in the paint were at or above

0.3 mg/cm2. A total of two-hundred and sixty-two (262) XRF analyses were performed, which included two-hundred and thirty-four (234) building component measurements and twenty-eight (28) calibration checks. Drawings that illustrate the locations of all building measurements have been provided in Appendix A of this Report.

XRF RESULTS

The XRF analyzer indicated that lead-containing paint was identified in the building component types listed in Table 2 below. The table also provides additional details regarding building component types, and if the tested components were located at the exterior or interior of the subject building.

TABLE 2 - LEAD CONTAINING COMPONENT TYPES

Component Substrate Condition Color

Exterior Building Components

WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN

BEAM CONCRETE FAIR TAN

RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN

DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN

BEAM CONCRETE POOR TAN

WALL CONCRETE POOR TAN

RAIL METAL POOR BROWN

DOOR METAL POOR TAN

WINDOW CASING METAL FAIR TAN

WINDOW METAL POOR TAN

COLUMN CONCRETE POOR TAN

DOOR CASING METAL POOR BROWN

Interior: Mechanical Room

DOOR CASING WOOD FAIR BROWN

Interior: First Floor

CEILING CONCRETE FAIR WHITE

COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR WHITE

WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE

WINDOW SILL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE

DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN

ELECTRIC PANEL METAL FAIR WHITE

WALL CMU FAIR WHITE

WALL CMU FAIR GREY

WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY

SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY

STRINGER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN

WINDOW METAL POOR TAN

WALL CMU POOR TAN

COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN

RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN

WINDOW SILL CMU FAIR WHITE

WALL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE

Interior: Second Floor

DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN

WINDOW SILL

(EXTERIOR) CMU FAIR TAN

Component Substrate Condition Color

WINDOW SILL

(INTERIOR) CMU FAIR WHITE

COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN

WALL CMU FAIR TAN

WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY

WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE

WALL CMU FAIR WHITE

Interior: Third Floor

FLOOR CONCRETE POOR BROWN

DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN

WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE

WALL CMU FAIR TAN

WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY

SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY

COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN

WALL CMU FAIR WHITE

Interior: Basement

WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN

COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR BROWN

Interior: Hammerhead Area

CEILING PLASTER FAIR TAN

DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN

WINDOW CASING METAL FAIR TAN

WALL CMU FAIR TAN

THRESHOLD CONCRETE POOR BLACK

WALL BRICK FAIR TAN

WALL PLASTER FAIR TAN

WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN

WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN

CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN

Table 3 below indicates that a total of ninety-two (92) of the building measurements tested positive, which confirmed the presence of lead at or above 0.3 mg/cm2. The complete XRF lead paint data, including negative measurements and calibration readings, have been provided in

Appendix B of this Report. Note that the XRF analyzer makes a final determination regarding if a building component is positive or negative for lead in paint. This analytical determination is based upon the standard (≥0.3 mg/cm2), the measurement obtained, and the analytical range of the margin of error for the XRF analyzer. On occasion, a measurement obtained using this test method (EPA method # 6200) that is below the standard may effectively result in a positive determination, due to the analyzer’s margin of error. Any measurements that are determined to be positive for lead paint by the XRF analyzer, will be accepted as such, during this Survey. Any results that apply to this will be noted with an asterisk (*) below.

TABLE 3 - POSITIVE XRF LEAD PAINT MEASUREMENTS

No Component Substrate Condition Color Measurement Location Action Level

(mg/cm2) PbC

(mg/cm2)

Exterior Building

7 WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL 0.3 5.1

10 BEAM CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL 0.3 1.2

13 RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR

ENTRYWAY 0.3 1.3

15 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; 1st FLOOR

ENTRYWAY 0.3 5.7

20 WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL 0.3 5.5

21 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT

ENTRYWAY 0.3 3.3

26 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; 1st FLOOR

ENTRYWAY 0.3 3.3

29 BEAM CONCRETE POOR TAN N WALL 0.3 0.8

30 WALL CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; WINDOW AREA

WELL 0.3 4

31 RAIL METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT

ENTRYWAY 0.3 0.5

32 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT

ENTRYWAY 0.3 4

36 DOOR METAL POOR TAN E WALL 0.3 6

40 WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL 0.3 6

43 WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL 0.3 3.1

49 RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR

ENTRYWAY 0.3 0.3

60 WINDOW

CASING METAL FAIR TAN W WALL; HAMMER HEAD 0.3 3.6

61 WINDOW METAL POOR TAN W WALL; HAMMER HEAD 0.3 3.9

67 COLUMN CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; HAMMER HEAD 0.3 10

72 DOOR CASING METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT

ENTRYWAY 0.3 3.2

77 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN E WALL; MECHANICAL

ROOM 0.3 2.5

Interior: Mechanical Room

79 DOOR CASING WOOD FAIR BROWN S WALL; MECHANICAL

ROOM 0.3 0.6

Interior: First Floor

88 CEILING CONCRETE FAIR WHITE BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.8

89 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR WHITE BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 1

92 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 *0.28

93 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.8

95 WINDOW SILL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 1.3

99 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.5

Action Level

(mg/cm2) PbC

(mg/cm2)

102 ELECTRIC

PANEL METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; ELEC. DOOR;

CORRIDOR 0.3 *0.29

103 WALL CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 2.3

104 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY;

CORRIDOR 0.3 1.4

109 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.120;

CORRIDOR 0.3 2.8

110 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 2.2

112 WALL CMU FAIR GREY W WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 0.7

113 WALL CERAMIC

BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 1.8

115 SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY E WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 0.6

116 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY;

CORRIDOR 0.3 1.9

117 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY AREA 0.3 1.8

118 STRINGER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN E WALL; STAIRWAY AREA 0.3 0.7

123 WINDOW METAL POOR TAN N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 0.8

124 WALL CMU POOR TAN S WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 0.8

125 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN SW CORNER; LAUNDRY

ROOM 0.3 1

129 RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN E SIDE; STAIRWAY AREA 0.3 0.9

209 WALL CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; RM.119 0.3 0.5

212 WINDOW SILL CMU FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.121 0.3 1.1

213 WALL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.121 0.3 0.5

Interior: Second Floor

131 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR 0.3 0.6

133 WINDOW SILL

(EXTERIOR) CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM 0.3 0.7

134 WINDOW SILL

(INTERIOR) CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM 0.3 0.9

135 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN SW CORNER; LAUNDRY

ROOM 0.3 1

141 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 2.3

142 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.8

143 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.216;

CORRIDOR 0.3 2.4

145 WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.1

146 WALL CERAMIC

BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 0.9

147 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM; CORRIDOR 0.3 2

150 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 0.4

Level

(mg/cm2) PbC

(mg/cm2)

151 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR 0.3 2

215 WALL CMU FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.211 0.3 1.4

216 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.211 0.3 0.5

Interior: Third Floor

161 FLOOR CONCRETE POOR BROWN S STAIRWAY LANDING 0.3 0.6

162 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR 0.3 1

168 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM; CORRIDOR 0.3 2.8

170 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 1.6

171 WALL CMU FAIR TAN W WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 0.7

172 WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.4

173 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.9

175 WALL CERAMIC

BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 1.4

176 SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY W WALL; JANITOR'S

CLOSET 0.3 1.5

177 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.8

178 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.319;

CORRIDOR 0.3 1.4

179 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S

RESTROOM; CORRIDOR 0.3 1.9

182 WALL CMU FAIR WHITE W WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM 0.3 0.7

217 WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.301 0.3 0.5

218 WALL CMU FAIR WHITE W WALL; RM.301 0.3 0.6

Interior: Basement

196 WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL; BASEMENT 0.3 0.4

205 COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR BROWN W WALL; BASEMENT 0.3 0.4

Interior: Hammerhead Area

227 CEILING PLASTER FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR 0.3 1

228 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR; STORE

ROOM C 0.3 0.5

229 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR; N EXIT

DOOR 0.3 2.3

230 WINDOW

CASING METAL FAIR TAN CORRIDOR; N WALL;

STORE ROOM C 0.3 0.6

236 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN E WALL; SERVING AREA 0.3 1

237 WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; ENTRYWAY 0.3 0.9

238 THRESHOLD CONCRETE POOR BLACK W WALL; ENTRYWAY 0.3 14.4

239 WALL BRICK FAIR TAN S WALL; ENTRYWAY 0.3 1

240 WALL PLASTER FAIR TAN E WALL; ENTRYWAY 0.3 0.7

243 WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.9

249 WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.7

250 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM 0.3 0.4

251 WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN E WALL; DINING ROOM 0.3 0.7

252 DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; DINING ROOM 0.3 0.5

Level

(mg/cm2) PbC

(mg/cm2)

256 WALL CMU FAIR TAN E WALL; WOMEN'S

RESTROOM 0.3 0.9

258 CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN WOMEN'S RESTROOM 0.3 0.5

QUALIFICATIONS

This Comprehensive Lead Paint Survey was performed by an Inspector that was qualified to perform work in Texas and New Mexico, per the Texas Department of State Health Services

(DSHS), and New Mexico per USEPA certification credentials. This individual has received training under the HUD / EPA training criteria for the required Lead Paint Inspector and/or Risk

Assessor courses and has received the refresher training within the prescribed period for each jurisdiction. Company and individual licenses and credentials have been provided and are available for review in the project sampling plan documents, which have been submitted to the

USACE.

LIMITATIONS

The overall purpose of this Comprehensive Lead Paint Survey was to identify if lead-containing components were present, within the qualifications and limitations summarized below. Reliance on this Report is specifically limited to gathering initial information regarding the presence of lead in paint. Any time that lead-based paint may be identified during the performance of a lead inspection, the owner of the building is responsible to the occupants and to the public to properly manage these materials, per Local, State and Federal regulations. Prior to the abatement or removal of any lead containing materials, a Lead Project Design should be properly performed, by a qualified Lead Firm, to 1) ensure that materials will be properly managed, and 2) to prepare a more accurate estimate of actual materials to be addressed. This Survey Report was specifically prepared for ALL Consulting’s Client (USACE and Ft. Bliss), and the extent of liability incurred, is limited to the amount of the Report Fee paid by its Client. The USACE agrees that the ALL

Consulting Team cannot be held responsible for any liability based on reliance of this Report by any third party.

CONCLUSIONS

1. Specific Conclusions. Lead-containing paint was found on components either inside and / or outside of this building.

• Lead paint should not be disturbed without proper procedures in place. Should the lead paint need to be disturbed, personnel should be evacuated in advance, and only properly trained persons with adequate PPE should be allowed to disturb the lead paint material.

• Lead painted components in poor condition should be stabilized with interim controls or abatement procedures by properly trained personnel.

• Lead hazard air monitoring should be performed during abatement activities.

• Following abatement activities, clearance wipe samples should be collected and sent to an approved laboratory for lead paint analysis.

• The OSHA Hazard Communication Standard and the Lead Paint Standard both require anyone working in such areas to be informed of lead paint hazards and methods to avoid the hazards.

2. General Conclusions. Proper notification should be made to the appropriate authorities prior to disturbance of any lead-containing materials, including abatement activity, renovations, or operations and maintenance (O&M) activities, or demolition of any facilities or public buildings.

Other personnel working in the area must be alerted by signage and the appropriate regulated area designations. OSHA specifies worker protection and engineering controls, as well as work practices to ensure the safety of workers and anyone who will be in the area after the conclusion of the work.

Contact the personnel listed below with any clarifications that may be needed.

Inspected by: Reviewed by: Approved by:

Tim Jones, RPIH Alex Woelper, P.E., RPIH David Epperly, Ph.D., P.E.

Lead Inspector Environmental Consultant Project Manager License # 2070306

APPENDICES:

A. Lead Paint Sample Location Drawing(s) B. XRF Lead Paint Data

APPENDIX A

Lead Paint Sample Location Drawing(s)

Project: # 139-14

Hazardous Materials Surveys

Draw by: JC Location:

Building # 1006 Fort Bliss, TX 7307 Remcon Cir, Ste 103

El Paso, Texas, 79912 915.833.3740

Sheet

ENV-1

Date:

02-17-2015

ENCON INTERNATIONAL, INC

NOT TO SCALE

LEAD PAINT Sample Location Drawing - Basement

Lead Sample Locations

Positive Lead Sample Locations##

N

Hazardous Materials Surveys

Draw by: JC Location:

Building # 1006 Fort Bliss, TX 7307 Remcon Cir, Ste 103

El Paso, Texas, 79912 915.833.3740

Sheet

ENV-2

Date:

02-17-2015

ENCON INTERNATIONAL, INC

NOT TO SCALE

LEAD PAINT Sample Location Drawing - 1st Floor

Positive Lead Sample Locations##

N

118212

10399

29 30

228227

256 258

240236

Hazardous Materials Surveys

Draw by: JC Location:

Building # 1006 Fort Bliss, TX 7307 Remcon Cir, Ste 103

El Paso, Texas, 79912 915.833.3740

Sheet

ENV-3

Date:

02-17-2014

ENCON INTERNATIONAL, INC

NOT TO SCALE

LEAD PAINT Sample Location Drawing - 2nd Floor

Lead Sample Locations

Positive Lead Sample Locations##

N

151 147

145 143 141 131

Hazardous Materials Surveys

Draw by: JC Location:

Building # 1006 Fort Bliss, TX 7307 Remcon Cir, Ste 103

El Paso, Texas, 79912 915.833.3740

Sheet

ENV-4

Date:

02-17-2014

ENCON INTERNATIONAL, INC

NOT TO SCALE

LEAD PAINT Sample Location Drawing - 3rd Floor

Lead Sample Locations

Positive Lead Sample Locations##

N

178 179177172161

APPENDIX B

XRF Lead Paint Data

Note that the XRF analyzer makes a final determination regarding if a building component is positive or negative for lead in paint. This analytical determination is based upon the standard (≥0.3 mg/cm2), the measurement obtained, and the analytical range of the margin of error for the XRF analyzer. On occasion, a measurement obtained using this test method (EPA method # 6200) that is below the standard may effectively result in a positive determination, due to the analyzer’s margin of error. Any measurements that are determined to be positive for lead paint by the XRF analyzer, will be accepted as such, for this Survey. Any results that apply to this will be noted with an asterisk (*) in the table to follow.

Fort Bliss, Texas XRF Lead Paint Data Bldg.1006

No Type Component Substrate Condition Color Measurement Location Results Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

1 SHUTTER_CAL 7.32

2 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

3 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.2

4 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

5 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL Negative 0.3 0.09 6 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL Negative 0.3 0 7 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL Positive 0.3 5.1 8 PAINT WINDOW SILL EXT CMU FAIR TAN N WALL Null 0.3 0.4 9 PAINT WINDOW SILL EXT CMU FAIR TAN N WALL Negative 0.3 0.18

10 PAINT BEAM CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL Positive 0.3 1.2 11 PAINT WINDOW SILL EXT CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL Negative 0.3 0.02 12 PAINT RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.1 13 PAINT RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 1.3 14 PAINT CEILING CONCRETE FAIR TAN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.09 15 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 5.7 16 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.07 17 PAINT CEILING CONCRETE FAIR TAN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 18 PAINT RAIL METAL FAIR TAN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Null 0.3 0.11 19 PAINT RAIL METAL FAIR TAN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.09 20 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL Positive 0.3 5.5 21 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 3.3 22 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 23 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.11 24 PAINT RISER CONCRETE POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.02 25 PAINT TREAD CONCRETE POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.04 26 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 3.3 27 PAINT RAIL METAL FAIR BROWN N SIDE; 1st FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.16 28 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL Negative 0.3 0.01 29 PAINT BEAM CONCRETE POOR TAN N WALL Positive 0.3 0.8 30 PAINT WALL CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; WINDOW AREA WELL Positive 0.3 4

EXTERIOR BUILDING

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 1

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

31 PAINT RAIL METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 0.5 32 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 4 33 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 34 PAINT RISER METAL POOR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.03 35 PAINT WALL CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.1 36 PAINT DOOR METAL POOR TAN E WALL Positive 0.3 6 37 PAINT BEAM CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL Null 0.3 0 38 PAINT BEAM CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL Negative 0.3 0 39 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL Negative 0.3 0.01 40 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL Positive 0.3 6 41 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN S WALL Negative 0.3 0 42 PAINT WINDOW SILL EXT CMU FAIR TAN S WALL Negative 0.3 0.05 43 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL Positive 0.3 3.1 44 PAINT CEILING METAL FAIR TAN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Null 0.3 0.01 45 PAINT CEILING METAL FAIR TAN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 46 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Null 0.3 0.12 47 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.12 48 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.04 49 PAINT RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 0.3 50 PAINT RAIL METAL FAIR BROWN S SIDE; 1ST FLOOR ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 51 PAINT WINDOW WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN S WALL Negative 0.3 0.03 52 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.01 53 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN E WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.07 54 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.01 55 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN S WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.02 56 PAINT FLOOR CONCRETE POOR BROWN S SIDE; HAMMER HEAD ENTRYWAY Null 0.3 0.02 57 PAINT FLOOR CONCRETE POOR BROWN S SIDE; HAMMER HEAD ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.02 58 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; HAMMER HEAD ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.09 59 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN W WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.04 60 PAINT WINDOW CASING METAL FAIR TAN W WALL; HAMMER HEAD Positive 0.3 3.6 61 PAINT WINDOW METAL POOR TAN W WALL; HAMMER HEAD Positive 0.3 3.9

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 2

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

62 PAINT A/C WALL STUCCO FAIR TAN W OF B.1006 Negative 0.3 0 63 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.25 64 PAINT FLOOR CONCRETE FAIR BROWN N SIDE; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.03 65 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0 66 PAINT PANEL METAL FAIR TAN N SIDE; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0 67 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; HAMMER HEAD Positive 0.3 10 68 PAINT BUMPER METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.1 69 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE POOR TAN E WALL; HAMMER HEAD Negative 0.3 0.16 70 PAINT RISER CONCRETE POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.03 71 PAINT WALL CONCRETE POOR TAN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.18 72 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 3.2 73 PAINT DOOR METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.09 74 PAINT RAIL METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Null 0.3 0.22 75 PAINT RAIL METAL POOR BROWN N SIDE; BASEMENT ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 -0.16 76 PAINT THRESHOLD CONCRETE POOR BROWN W WALL; MECHANICAL ROOM Negative 0.3 0.02 77 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN E WALL; MECHANICAL ROOM Positive 0.3 2.5 78 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN W WALL; MECHANICAL ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01

79 PAINT DOOR CASING WOOD FAIR BROWN S WALL Positive 0.3 0.6

80 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

81 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

82 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

83 SHUTTER_CALCALIBRATE 8.29

84 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

85 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

86 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

87 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR WHITE BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 88 PAINT CEILING CONCRETE FAIR WHITE BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.8

INTERIOR: MECHANICAL ROOM

INTERIOR: FIRST FLOOR

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 3

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

89 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR WHITE BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 1 90 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 91 PAINT DOOR CASING WOOD FAIR BROWN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 92 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 *0.28 93 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.8 94 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 95 PAINT WINDOW SILL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 1.3 96 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; ELEV. SHAFT; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 97 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; ELEV. SHAFT; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 98 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 99 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.5

100 PAINT ELECTTRIC PANEL METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; ELEC. DOOR; CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0.22 101 PAINT ELECTTRIC PANEL METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; ELEC. DOOR; CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0.29 102 PAINT ELECTRIC PANEL METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; ELEC. DOOR; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 *0.29 103 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.3 104 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.4 105 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN E WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.03 106 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 107 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 108 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.119; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.05 109 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.120; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.8 110 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.2 111 PAINT HEATER METAL FAIR BROWN E WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 112 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR GREY W WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 0.7 113 PAINT WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 1.8 114 PAINT SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY E WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Null 0.3 0.11 115 PAINT SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY E WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 0.6 116 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.9 117 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; STAIRWAY AREA Positive 0.3 1.8 118 PAINT STRINGER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN E WALL; STAIRWAY AREA Positive 0.3 0.7 119 PAINT RAIL METAL POOR BROWN E SIDE; STAIRWAY AREA Null 0.3 0

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 4

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

120 PAINT RAIL METAL POOR BROWN E SIDE; STAIRWAY AREA Negative 0.3 0 121 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 122 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN MEN'S RESTROOM Negative 0.3 0.02 123 PAINT WINDOW METAL POOR TAN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.8 124 PAINT WALL CMU POOR TAN S WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.8 125 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN SW CORNER; LAUNDRY ROOM Positive 0.3 1 126 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.130; CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0.04 127 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.128; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.01 128 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN E WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 129 PAINT RISER CONCRETE FAIR BROWN E SIDE; STAIRWAY AREA Positive 0.3 0.9 207 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR WHITE RM.119 Negative 0.3 0.01 208 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; RM.119 Null 0.3 0.5 209 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; RM.119 Positive 0.3 0.5 210 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.119 Negative 0.3 0.15 211 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.121 Negative 0.3 0.16 212 PAINT WINDOW SILL CMU FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.121 Positive 0.3 1.1 213 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.121 Positive 0.3 0.5

130 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; STAIRWAY AREA Negative 0.3 0.04 131 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 0.6 132 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM Negative 0.3 0.12 133 PAINT WINDOW SILL EXT CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM Positive 0.3 0.7 134 PAINT WINDOW SILL INT CMU FAIR WHITE N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM Positive 0.3 0.9 135 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN SW CORNER; LAUNDRY ROOM Positive 0.3 1 136 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.230; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.04 137 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.233; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 138 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.229; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 139 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.221; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0

INTERIOR: SECOND FLOOR

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 5

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

140 PAINT

FIRE EXTINGUISHER

BOX

METAL FAIR RED S WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.07

141 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.3 142 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.8 143 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.216; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.4 144 PAINT SCUTTLE DOOR METAL FAIR TAN CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 145 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.1 146 PAINT WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 0.9 147 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2 148 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Null 0.3 0.26 149 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Negative 0.3 0.19 150 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.4 151 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2 152 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.207; CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0.04 153 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.206; CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0.02 154 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.206; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.04 155 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.201; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.04 214 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR WHITE RM.211 Negative 0.3 0.06 215 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.211 Positive 0.3 1.4 216 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.211 Positive 0.3 0.5

156 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; S STAIRWAY Negative 0.3 0.16 157 PAINT WINDOW LINTEL METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; S STAIRWAY Negative 0.3 0.17 158 PAINT LADDER METAL FAIR BLACK W WALL; S STAIRWAY Negative 0.3 0.04 159 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; S STAIRWAY Negative 0.3 0.3 160 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; S STAIRWAY Negative 0.3 0 161 PAINT FLOOR CONCRETE POOR BROWN S STAIRWAY LANDING Positive 0.3 0.6 162 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1 163 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.311; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.03

INTERIOR: THIRD FLOOR

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 6

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

164 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.306; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 -0.02 165 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; RM.304; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 166 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.303; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 167 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN W WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 168 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 2.8 169 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 170 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 1.6 171 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN W WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.7 172 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.4 173 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.9 174 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 175 PAINT WALL CERAMIC BRICK FAIR GREY N WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 1.4 176 PAINT SHELF WOOD FAIR GREY W WALL; JANITOR'S CLOSET Positive 0.3 1.5 177 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.8 178 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.319; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.4 179 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; MEN'S RESTROOM; CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1.9 180 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; S STAIRWAY; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.02 181 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE N WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM Negative 0.3 0 182 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE W WALL; LAUNDRY ROOM Positive 0.3 0.7 183 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR WHITE E WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.01 184 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR WHITE CORRIDOR Null 0.3 0 185 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR WHITE CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 186 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; RM.325; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0 187 PAINT ELECTRIC PANEL METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; CORRIDOR Negative 0.3 0.02

188 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

189 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

190 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

217 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.301 Positive 0.3 0.5 218 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR WHITE W WALL; RM.301 Positive 0.3 0.6 219 PAINT HEATER METAL FAIR WHITE S WALL; RM.301 Negative 0.3 0

220 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 7

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

221 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

222 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

191 SHUTTER_CAL 8.56

192 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

193 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1

194 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

195 PAINT CEILING CONCRETE FAIR TAN BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.02 196 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN E WALL; BASEMENT Positive 0.3 0.4 197 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN N WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0 198 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0 199 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR BROWN N WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.02 200 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR BROWN W WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.01 201 PAINT FLOOR CONCRETE FAIR GREY BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.26 202 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; BASEMENT Null 0.3 0.23 203 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR BROWN S WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.1 204 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR BROWN NW EXIT DOOR; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0.02 205 PAINT COLUMN CONCRETE FAIR BROWN W WALL; BASEMENT Positive 0.3 0.4 206 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR BROWN W WALL; BASEMENT Negative 0.3 0

223 SHUTTER_CAL 9.41

224 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

225 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

226 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

227 PAINT CEILING PLASTER FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR Positive 0.3 1 228 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR; STORE ROOM C Positive 0.3 0.5 229 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W CORRIDOR; N EXIT DOOR Positive 0.3 2.3 230 PAINT WINDOW CASING METAL FAIR TAN CORRIDOR; N WALL; STORE ROOM C Positive 0.3 0.6 231 PAINT DUCT METAL FAIR TAN KITCHEN Negative 0.3 0

INTERIOR: HAMMERHEAD AREA

INTERIOR: BASEMENT

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 8

Action Level (mg/cm2)

PbC (mg/cm2)

232 PAINT VENT HOOD METAL FAIR TAN KITCHEN Negative 0.3 0.28 233 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL; KITCHEN Negative 0.3 0.13 234 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN N WALL; KITCHEN Negative 0.3 0.15 235 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; KITCHEN Negative 0.3 0.11 236 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN E WALL; SERVING AREA Positive 0.3 1 237 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN N WALL; ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 0.9 238 PAINT THRESHOLD CONCRETE POOR BLACK W WALL; ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 14.4 239 PAINT WALL BRICK FAIR TAN S WALL; ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 1 240 PAINT WALL PLASTER FAIR TAN E WALL; ENTRYWAY Positive 0.3 0.7 241 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0 242 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR TAN E WALL; ENTRYWAY Negative 0.3 0.01 243 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN N WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.9 244 PAINT WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 245 PAINT FURR DOWN DRYWALL FAIR TAN CEILING; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 246 PAINT DOOR WOOD FAIR BROWN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 247 PAINT DOOR CASING WOOD FAIR BROWN E WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 248 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.12 249 PAINT WALL CONCRETE FAIR TAN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.7 250 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN W WALL; BRIEFING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.4 251 PAINT WINDOW METAL FAIR TAN E WALL; DINING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.7 252 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; DINING ROOM Positive 0.3 0.5 253 PAINT DOOR METAL FAIR TAN S WALL; DINING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 254 PAINT LOWER WALL DRYWALL FAIR TAN W WALL; DINING ROOM Negative 0.3 0 255 PAINT DOOR CASING METAL FAIR TAN N WALL; DINING ROOM Negative 0.3 0.01 256 PAINT WALL CMU FAIR TAN E WALL; WOMEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.9 257 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN WOMEN'S RESTROOM Null 0.3 0.03 258 PAINT CEILING DRYWALL FAIR TAN WOMEN'S RESTROOM Positive 0.3 0.5 259 PAINT VENT CASING METAL FAIR TAN WOMEN'S RESTROOM Negative 0.3 0

260 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 0.9

261 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

262 PAINT CALIBRATE N/A 0.3 1.1

02/02/2015 ALL CONSULTING TEAM 9

ATTACHMENT 2

Asbestos Survey Report

COMPREHENSIVE ASBESTOS SURVEY

BUILDING 1006

FORT BLISS, TEXAS 79916

Prepared for:

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Tulsa District

Prepared by:

ALL Consulting, LLC 1718 S. Cheyenne Ave.

Tulsa, OK 74119

Inspection Start Date:

February 2, 2015

ENCON International, Inc.

7307 Remcon Circle, #103

El Paso, TX 79912

L&P Scientific Consulting, LLC 6400 Airport Rd., Bldg. B, #J

El Paso, TX 79925

COMPREHENSIVE ASBESTOS SURVEY

Ft. Bliss, Bldg. 1006

PURPOSE

The ALL Consulting Team was contracted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), Tulsa

District, to perform comprehensive Hazardous Building Materials Surveys to identify the presence of any asbestos or lead paint at a number of facilities at Ft. Bliss, Texas. This project also included the development and population of a database to store the survey reports for access by the Ft. Bliss

Directorate of Public Works (DPW), and others. The facilities that are included within this contract scope of work include buildings within the New Mexico installations of McGregor Range and Dona Ana Range, in addition to the Ft. Bliss facilities in Texas.

BACKGROUND

Ft. Bliss has a large number of buildings constructed before 1990 when the use of asbestos and lead paint was prevalent in construction of buildings. Because these materials may still exist within these facilities, Ft. Bliss is required to identify (asbestos or lead containing materials), assess the condition (stable or deteriorating), determine the nature of building materials (i.e., drywall or floor tile), and the extent of these hazardous substances. In accordance with the Clean Air Act (40 CFR

61 subpart M, Asbestos), any renovation, remodeling or demolition of any structure, (i.e., buildings, facilities, etc.), shall be surveyed for asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) and properly abated prior to any disturbance of the material.

INTRODUCTION

The facilities selected for this project were provided to the ALL Consulting Team by USACE, Tulsa District. The selected facilities were located in four geographic areas: Ft. Bliss main post, Biggs Field (now known as East Bliss), McGregor Range, NM, and Doña Ana Range, NM.

Records were available for some of these buildings where previous partial or complete inspections had been performed. When available, prior asbestos reports were referenced to enhance the thoroughness of the asbestos inspection performed for this facility. The goal of this project was to provide a comprehensive inspection of the designated facilities, but destructive sampling was not authorized. Therefore, on rare occasion some asbestos materials may be hidden behind walls, under subfloors, or located in other areas that were inaccessible to the inspector. If or when any building is to undergo demolition, an additional investigation should be undertaken in which destructive sampling is authorized.

REGULATORY STANDARDS

Asbestos in building materials is regulated on the federal level by the Environmental Protection

Agency (EPA), and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). On the state level, Texas also has regulations pertaining to sampling and abatement of asbestos in buildings.

The inspection was conducted to ensure compliance with National Emission Standards for

Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) – 40 CFR Part 61, Subpart M, which states that “prior to the commencement of the demolition or renovation, thoroughly inspect the affected facility or part of the facility where the demolition or renovation operation(s) will occur for the presence of asbestos, including Category I and Category II non-friable ACM.” Asbestos Inspectors for both Texas and

New Mexico facilities were trained under the EPA AHERA (40 CFR 763) standards. For facilities in the State of Texas, the Texas Asbestos Health Protection Rules (TAHPR) were complied with, which specify inspector licensure and a minimum of three (3) samples for each homogeneous area.

In New Mexico, facilities were sampled under the applicable regulations from the EPA, 40 CFR

61.

FACILITY DESCRIPTION

The facility known as Building 1006 was occupied and had been used as a barracks on Fort Bliss, Texas. Description of this facility is presented in Table 1 below:

TABLE 1 – BUILDING DESCRIPTION

Building Items Description Area of building 47,649 square feet Date of Construction 1956 Number of floors Three (3) floors and basement Exterior wall materials CMU, concrete Roof type Flat Roof material Asphalt roll roofing

Interior walls 1st, 2nd & 3rd floor: CMU, ceramic tiles Basement: concrete

Interior floors Concrete

Interior floor coverings 1st, 2nd & 3rd floor: carpet, 12x12 vinyl tiles, ceramic tiles Basement: Rubber mats (workout room only) Hammerhead Area: ceramic tiles, 12x12 vinyl

Ceilings

1st floor: 2x4 ceiling tiles, drywall;

2nd & 3rd floor: drywall Basement: concrete Hammerhead Area: drywall, 2x2 ceiling tiles

FUNCTIONAL AREAS

Functional areas were areas (or groups of areas), within a structure or facility that were constructed to have the same use or purpose, constructed of the same materials, and were relatively the same age. A general administrative area, or several identical buildings within a facility, could typically be considered a single functional area.

The functional area(s), or purpose, of this facility was identified as follows:

“Barracks”

HOMOGENEOUS AREAS

Within Functional Areas, Homogeneous Areas were determined. Homogeneous Areas are areas of surfacing material, thermal system insulation (TSI), or miscellaneous materials that were uniform in color, texture, substrate, and were relatively of the same age. Table 2 below lists the homogeneous areas and the general locations where they were identified.

TABLE 2 - Homogeneous Areas and Locations Identified

# Homogeneous Areas (Suspect Materials) Location

1 Beige texture drywall materials Basement east end 2 12” tan floor tile and mastic Basement east end 3 Brown texture drywall materials Basement west end 4 Cove base mastic Basement west end 5 Wall plaster Basement B002 southeast room 6 Pipe insulation wrap Basement B005 7 Metal jacket mastic Mechanical room 8 End pipe white sealant Mechanical room 9 Vinyl flooring mastic 1st floor hallway, 2nd floor hallway, 3rd floor hallway 10 Black floor tile and mastic under green vinyl flooring 1st floor hallway

11 12” light blue floor tile and mastic Room 128, room 211, room 311 12 Floor tile and mastic under black floor tile, under vinyl flooring, and under light blue floor tile

1st floor hallway, 2nd floor hallway, 3rd floor room 311

13 Smooth texture drywall materials 1st floor ceiling, 2nd floor ceiling, 3rd floor ceiling

14 Beige texture drywall materials 1st floor large west room, 2nd floor room 211, 3rd floor room 311

15 Rubber mat mastic Southeast stairs, south-center stairs, north-center stairs

16 2’ x 2’ ceiling tiles West large room, hammerhead 17 12” off-white with blue streaks floor tile and mastic Hammerhead

18 Tan ceiling plaster Hammerhead 19 Wall caulking Hammerhead 20 Texture drywall materials Hammerhead 21 Tan cove base mastic Hammerhead 22 Perimeter door caulking South door to hammer head, north door to basement, south door to hammerhead 23 Exterior CMU paint wall materials East side, north side, south side 24 Exterior window glazing North side, south side 25 Exterior expansion joint caulking South side, north side 26 Air duct sealant Evaporative cooler unit on north side 27 Roofing materials Top roof and hammerhead roof 28 Roof penetration sealant Top roof and hammerhead roof

SAMPLING METHODOLOGY

The building materials survey tasks were performed in accordance with the Final Hazardous

Building Materials Surveys, Sampling Plan, Fort Bliss, Texas, December 2014, prepared by ALL

Consulting and ENCON International, Inc. A visual inspection of the Facility was conducted to develop a sampling strategy. This task included determining both functional areas and homogeneous areas / materials, as well as sample collection locations. Friability was assessed by manually manipulating the suspect asbestos materials utilizing hand pressure to determine if the materials, when dry, could be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder. Twenty-eight (28) homogeneous areas were established and at least three (3) samples were collected from each area to adequately identify accessible asbestos in the facility. Portions of the subject building that had suspect asbestos-containing surfacing, thermal system insulation, or miscellaneous materials were divided into homogeneous areas for sampling. These samples were each uniquely and individually identified and logged into a chain of custody document and prepared for shipment to a third-party, independent laboratory for analysis. Building materials that were not considered suspect ACM included the following; concrete, metal, glass, asphalt, plastic, and wood. Destructive sampling was not authorized or performed to locate hidden or inaccessible materials.

Eighty-four (84) samples were collected and submitted for laboratory analysis. Bulk sample analyses were conducted utilizing polarized light microscopy (PLM), as per EPA Test Method

600/R-93/116. This method separates the sample material into various layers based on their morphology, and then identifies the presence of the different asbestos fibers in each of these layers when detected. The analysis was performed by Crisp Analytical Laboratories, LLC, located in

Carrollton, TX. The term…