00011524 EvaluationScoreMatrix for release.xlsx

This evaluation score matrix from ODOT and Benton County details the proposal scoring for the Corvallis to Albany Shared Use Path project between NE Merloy Ave and NW Rainwater Ln. Four firms were evaluated: Alta Planning + Design, David Evans and Associates, Harper Houf Peterson Righellis, and Parametrix. Each proposal was scored by three evaluators across six criteria: Design Philosophy and Approach (15 points), Project Management (10 points), Project Team and Qualifications (20 points), Project Samples (40 points), Interested Parties Support & Construction Readiness (10 points), and Clarity of Proposal (5 points).

Parametrix received the highest combined average score of 96.00, followed by David Evans and Associates with 94.67, Harper Houf Peterson Righellis with 88.33, and Alta Planning + Design with 84.67. The scoring matrix also includes unused sections for interview scores and reference checks, suggesting these components were either not completed or not required for this evaluation process. No scoring deduction points were applied to any of the proposals.