Attach__No__1B_-_Patrick_AFB_AEI.pdf

PATRICK AIR FORCE BASE

2014 ANNUAL AIR EMISSION INVENTORY

CRITERIA, HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANT AND GREENHOUSE GAS

EMISSIONS FOR STATIONARY AND MOBILE SOURCES

FINAL REPORT

Contract # 8961/TO 002

BPA #: W912BV-12-A-0012

Call Order Number: CALL-002

PR&C #: W44XGQ32494660

22 January 2015

2014 Air Emission Inventory Final Report

Patrick Air Force Base

Criteria Pollutant, Hazardous Air Pollutant and Greenhouse Gas Emissions for Stationary and Mobile Sources

Prepared for

Contract # 8961/TO 002

BPA #: W912BV-12-A-0012

Call Order Number: CALL-002

PR&C #: W44XGQ32494660

January 22, 2015

Prepared by Cardno

2014 Air Emission Inventory Final Report

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno i

Executive Summary

Criteria pollutant, hazardous air pollutant (HAP) and greenhouse gas (GHG) annual air emission inventories (AEI) for stationary and mobile sources were performed for Patrick Air Force Base (AFB) for the calendar year of 2014. The criteria pollutants consist of particulate matter less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter (PM10), particulate matter less than 2.5 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter (PM2.5), oxides of sulfur (SOx), oxides of nitrogen (NOx), carbon monoxide (CO), lead and volatile organic compounds (VOC). GHG emissions were calculated in carbon dioxide equivalents (CO2e). The AEI was prepared using the Air Force’s Air Program Information Management System (APIMS) with data provided by base points of contact (POCs) and gathered during an on-site field survey conducted 6 through 10 Apr 15 along with material information from the Enterprise Environmental, Safety and Occupational Health – Management Information System (EESOH-MIS). The AEI was prepared in accordance with guidance, methodologies and emission factors (EF) from the Air Force Civil Engineer Center (AFCEC) Air Emissions Factor Guide for Air Force Stationary Sources (Oct 14) and Air Emissions Guide for Air Force Mobile Sources (Oct 14).

Figure 1 presents the 2014 total annual criteria and HAP emissions for Patrick AFB stationary sources in tons per year. Further details of emission results are provided in Section 1.3.1 of this report. Details of the emissions, emission calculation methodologies and information entered into APIMS are presented in Section 2 of this report with complete emission results by process located in Appendix A.

Figure 1 Patrick AFB 2014 Stationary Source Annual Emissions. Figure 1 presents the 2014 calculated stationary source criteria and total HAP emissions in tons per year for Patrick AFB. Lead is a criteria pollutant and also a HAP. Lead emissions are included in the ‘Total HAPs’ value.

Figure 2 presents the 2014 total annual criteria and HAP emissions for Patrick AFB mobile sources in tons per year. Further details of emission results are provided in Section 1.3.2 of this report. Details of the emissions, emission calculation methodologies and information entered into APIMS are presented in Section 3 of this report with complete emission results by process located in Appendix C.

.2

.4

0.

5.

2.

.5

1.

E -0

5 2.

PM10 PM2.5 SOX NOX CO VOC Lead Total HAPs

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

Pollutant

2014 Patrick AFB Total Stationary Source Emissions

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno ii

Figure 2 Patrick AFB 2014 Mobile Source Annual Emissions. Figure 2 presents the 2014 calculated mobile source criteria and total HAP emissions in tons per year for Patrick AFB.

7.

5.

80 10

.4

7 15

.9

0 1.

PM10 PM2.5 SOX NOX CO VOC Lead Total HAPs

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

Pollutant

2014 Patrick AFB Total Mobile Source Emissions

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno iii

Acronyms

Table 1 Acronyms

Acronym Term

45 SW 45th Space Wing

ABCL Abrasive cleaning

AEI Air emission inventory

AFB Air Force Base

AFCEC Air Force Civil Engineer Center

AFI Air Force Instruction

AGE Aerospace ground equipment

AOPS Aircraft operations

AP-42 EPA’s Compilation of Air Pollutant Emission Factors, Volume 1: Stationary Point and Area Sources

API Application program interface

APIMS Air Program Information Management System

AST Aboveground storage tank

Btu British thermal unit

CAS Chemical Abstract Service

CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act

CHEM Miscellaneous chemical use

CO Carbon monoxide

CO2e Carbon dioxide equivalents

COOL Cooling towers

CP Criteria pollutant

CY Calendar year

Deg Degree

DEGR Degreasing / solvent cleaning

DEP Department of Environmental Protection

DoD Department of Defense

EAOR Electronic Annual Operating Report

ECOM External combustion

EESOH-MIS Enterprise Environmental, Safety and Occupational Health – Management Information System

EF Emission factor

EPA Environmental Protection Agency

EU Emission unit

EVR Enhanced vapor recovery

°F Degrees Fahrenheit

FDSP Fuel dispensing

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno iv

Acronym Term

FIRE Fire training

FLD Fuel loading racks gal Gallon

GHG Greenhouse gas

GOV Government owned vehicle

GVWR Gross vehicle weight rating

HAP Hazardous air pollutant

HDGV Heavy-duty gasoline vehicle

HDDV Heavy-duty diesel vehicle

HEV Hybrid electric vehicle

HP Horsepower hr Hour

HVAC Heating, ventilating and air conditioning

IC Internal combustion

ICOM Internal combustion

ID Identification

JP-8 Jet-propulsion fuel grade 8

L liter lb(s) Pound(s)

LDGV Light-duty gasoline vehicle

LDDV Light-duty diesel vehicle

LDGT Light-duty gasoline truck

LDDT Light-duty diesel truck

LFB Low flyby

LTO Landing and take off

MC Motorcycle

Min Minute(s)

MM 1,000,000

Mv Vapor molecular weight

NA Not applicable

NASA National Aeronautics Space Agency

NEPA National Environmental Policy Act

NOx Oxides of nitrogen

NRDE Non-road engine

ODC Ozone depleting chemical

PEST Herbicide / pesticide application

PM Particulate matter

PM10 Particulate matter less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno v

Acronym Term

PM2.5 Particulate matter less than 2.5 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter

POC Point of contact

POL Petroleum, oil and lubricants

POV Privately owned vehicle ppm Parts per million psia Pounds per square inch absolute scf Standard cubic foot

SOx Oxides of sulfur

SPRL Spills / Releases

SURF Surface coating

T Temperature

TGO Touch and go

TVOP Title V Operating Permit

UID Unique identification

UST Underground storage tank

VEHE Vehicle emissions

VMT Vehicle miles traveled

VOC Volatile organic compound

VP Vapor pressure

WELD Welding/soldering

WOOD Woodworking operations

WWT Waste water treatment yr Year

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno vi

Table of Contents

Executive Summary i

Acronyms iii

1 Introduction 1

1.1 Background 1

1.2 Work Approach 1

1.3 Summary of Results 12

1.3.1 Stationary Sources 12

1.3.2 Mobile Sources 19

1.4 Recommendations 24

1.5 Points of Contact 25

1.6 References 25

2 Stationary Sources - Calculation Methodologies and Assumptions 27

2.1 Abrasive Cleaning 27

2.1.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 27

2.2 Cooling Towers 27

2.2.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 28

2.3 Degreasing/Solvent Cleaning 29

2.3.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 29

2.4 External Combustion 30

2.4.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 31

2.5 Fire Training 33

2.5.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 33

2.6 Fuel Dispensing 34

2.6.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 34

2.7 Fuel Loading 35

2.7.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 35

2.8 Fuel Storage Tanks 36

2.8.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 36

2.9 Herbicide/Pesticide Application 37

2.9.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 37

2.10 Internal Combustion – Stationary Units 37

2.10.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 38

2.11 Miscellaneous Chemical Use 39

2.11.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 39

2.12 Ozone Depleting Chemicals 40

2.12.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 40

2.13 Spills / Releases 40

2.13.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 40

2.14 Surface Coating 41

2.14.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 41

2.15 Welding/Soldering/Cutting 42

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno vii

2.15.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 42

2.16 Woodworking 43

2.16.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 43

3 Mobile Sources - Calculation Methodologies and Assumptions 44

3.1 Aerospace Ground Equipment 44

3.1.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 44

3.2 Aircraft Operations 47

3.2.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 47

3.3 Internal Combustion – Portable Units 52

3.3.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 52

3.4 Non-Road Engines 53

3.4.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 53

3.5 Vehicle Emissions 54

3.5.1 Emissions Calculation Methodology 54

Appendices

Appendix A 2014 Emission Results – Stationary Sources

Appendix B 2014 Throughput Data – Stationary Sources

Appendix C 2014 Emission Results – Mobile Sources

Appendix D 2014 Throughput Data – Mobile Sources 0

Appendix E Process Flow Diagrams 1

Appendix F APIMS Discoverer Queries 0

Tables Table 1 Acronyms iii

Table 1-1 2014 Site-Validated Processes 2

Table 1-2 2014 Patrick AFB Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 13

Table 1-3 2014 Patrick AFB Stationary Source Speciated HAP Emissions 13

Table 1-4 2014 Patrick AFB Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 19

Table 1-5 2014 Patrick AFB Mobile Source Speciated HAP Emissions 20

Table 1-6 Patrick AFB POCs 25

Table 2-1 Abrasive Cleaning Emission Factors 27

Table 2-2 Cooling Tower Process Parameters 28

Table 2-3 External Combustion Emission Factors 32

Table 2-4 Fire Training Emission Factors 34

Table 2-5 Fuel Dispensing Emission Factors 34

Table 2-6 Fuel Loading Emission Factors 35

Table 2-7 Internal Combustion Emission Factors 38

Table 2-8 Spills/Release Emission Factors 41

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno viii

Table 2-9 Welding Emission Factors 43

Table 3-1 Aerospace Ground Equipment Emission Factors 45

Table 3-2 Aerospace Ground Equipment Emission Factors – Continued 46

Table 3-3 Aircraft Operations Profiles 47

Table 3-4 Aircraft Operations Emission Factors 48

Table 3-5 Aircraft Operations Emission Factors – Continued 49

Table 3-6 Aircraft Operations Emission Factors – Continued 49

Table 3-7 Aircraft Operations Emission Factors – Continued 50

Table 3-8 Internal Combustion Emission Factors 52

Table 3-9 Non-Road Engines Emission Factors 54

Table 3-10 Vehicle Emissions Emission Factors 56

Figures

Figure 1 Patrick AFB 2014 Stationary Source Annual Emissions i

Figure 2 Patrick AFB 2014 Mobile Source Annual Emissions ii

Patrick AFB 2014 PM10 Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 15 Figure 1-1

Patrick AFB 2014 PM2.5 Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 15 Figure 1-2

Patrick AFB 2014 SOX Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 16 Figure 1-3

Patrick AFB 2014 NOX Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 16 Figure 1-4

Patrick AFB 2014 CO Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 17 Figure 1-5

Patrick AFB 2014 VOC Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 17 Figure 1-6

Patrick AFB 2014 Lead Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 18 Figure 1-7

Patrick AFB 2014 Total HAP Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 18 Figure 1-8

Patrick AFB 2014 CO2e Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category 19 Figure 1-9

Patrick AFB 2014 PM10 Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 20 Figure 1-10

Patrick AFB 2014 PM2.5 Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 21 Figure 1-11

Patrick AFB 2014 SOX Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 21 Figure 1-12

Patrick AFB 2014 NOX Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 22 Figure 1-13

Patrick AFB 2014 CO Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 22 Figure 1-14

Patrick AFB 2014 VOC Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 23 Figure 1-15

Patrick AFB 2014 Total HAP Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 23 Figure 1-16

Patrick AFB 2014 CO2e Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category 24 Figure 1-17

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 1

1 Introduction

1.1 Background

This report contains the 2014 comprehensive stationary and mobile source AEIs for Patrick AFB for criteria pollutant, HAP and GHG emissions. The AEIs were prepared as required by Chapter 4.2 of the Air Force Instruction (AFI) 32-7040 Air Quality Compliance and Resource Management. The AFI requires a comprehensive AEI to be completed at least every three years unless required to be completed more frequently by federal, state or local regulations. The AEIs were prepared in accordance with the AFCEC Air Emissions Factor Guide for Air Force Stationary Sources, AFCEC Air Emissions Factor Guide for Air Force Mobile Sources and the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) AP-42. Emission calculations were conducted utilizing APIMS with data gathered during an on-site field survey conducted 6 – 10 Apr 15, material usage and material properties from the EESOH-MIS to APIMS interface and supplemental data provided by Patrick AFB.

Patrick AFB is located between Satellite Beach and Cocoa Beach in Brevard County, Florida. The 45th Space Wing (45 SW) is the host unit at Patrick AFB. The 45 SW manages all launches of unmanned rockets at Cape Canaveral Air Force Station, located approximately 12 miles to the north of Patrick AFB. The rockets include satellites for the United States military, the National Security Agency, the National Reconnaissance Office, as well as scientific payload launches in support of the National Aeronautics Space Agency (NASA), weather satellite launches in support of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and payloads in support of international customers such as the European Space Agency.

The 45 SW hosts and supports more than 30 major mission partners and tenants at Patrick AFB including:

> Air Force Technical Applications Center – the sole Department of Defense (DoD) agency operating and maintaining a global network of nuclear event detection sensors.

> 920th Rescue Wing – the only rescue wing in the Air Force Reserve, headquartered at Patrick AFB and is the installation’s only military flying unit operating the HC-130P/N ‘King’ variant of the C-130 Hercules and the HH-60G Pave Hawk helicopter, ready for worldwide deployment.

> NASA Flight Operations Facility – provides support for NASA’s permanently based UH-1H helicopters supporting Kennedy Space Center and transient NASA fixed-wing aircraft such as the T-38 talon.

> US State Department’s Bureau for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs Air Wing – helps foreign countries combat drugs and narcotics criminals and operates a fleet of aircraft at Patrick AFB.

> US Navy’s Military Sealift Command – the leading provider of ocean transportation for the Navy and the rest of the DoD.

Air quality emission sources at Patrick AFB are permitted by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) under Title V Operating Permit (TVOP) #0090021-013-AV, issued 22 Sep 14. The TVOP lists seventeen significant/permitted emission units (EUs) consisting of approximately 68 processes in Subsection B ‘Summary of Emission Units’. Additionally, Condition FW11 in Section II of the TVOP lists various insignificant emission units located at Patrick AFB. An Electronic Annual Operating Report (EAOR) listing 2014 actual emissions for permitted sources was submitted by Patrick AFB to Florida DEP by the 1 Apr due date as required by Condition FW8 of the TVOP.

1.2 Work Approach

The existing Patrick AFB air emission equipment/process information in APIMS along with the current TVOP and EAOR were reviewed and used to: establish a baseline list of air quality equipment/processes located at Patrick AFB; determine additional data needed for completion of the emission inventory (i.e., process throughput – hours of operation and quantity of fuel used); and select the data/processes to be site-validated during the on-site field survey. A data request specifying the information required to prepare the AEI was submitted to Patrick

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 2

AFB on 1 Apr 15. The purpose of this data request was to help prepare Patrick AFB for the site visit, allow for identification of subject matter experts and base POCs and gather information needed for completion of the AEI.

For quality assurance purposes, the Blanket Purchase Agreement contract requires a minimum of 5% of the stationary sources be field surveyed to validate acquired information. The process data in APIMS was reviewed to determine appropriate processes for on-site field survey. Processes were selected in order to:

> validate air pollution control device information

> determine if an air pollution control device is associated to the process

> identify building/location of a process

> determine if low NOX technology is used for a process/equipment

> identify correct data for a process where no APIMS data or conflicting APIMS data existed

> determine the current status (i.e., active, inactive, demolished) of a process

During the on-site field survey, data for 69 processes (approximately 28% of the stationary sources) was validated. The processes covered 14 of the 17 stationary source categories at Patrick AFB. For the processes included in the on-site field survey, there were a variety of APIMS data elements that needed to be updated (process status, authorized materials, rating, control efficiency, etc.). Many of these data elements impact air emissions results. Table 1-1 provides details of the processes surveyed and the data validated during the site visit. Where appropriate, APIMS was updated to reflect the information gathered during the site visit.

Table 1-1 2014 Site-Validated Processes

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

ABCL 751

AIRCRAFT CLEANING /

DEGREASING

873 NA

> Validated this process was for an abrasive blast unit and not a degreaser unit.

> Unit is no longer in use (shutdown by Bio Environmental with no plans to put back in service). Changed process status in APIMS from active to permanently shutdown.

ABCL 313

ABCL - VACUUM

BLASTBOOTH - BLDG

313-1 - CONTRACTOR

868 055

> POC validated this process is operated by the contractor in the building. Added information in the process description in APIMS to include contractor info.

ABCL 313

ABCL - ENCLSD GLOVE

BX - BLDG 313-1 -

CONTRACTOR

1377 NA

> POC validated this process is operated by the contractor in the building. Added information in the process description in APIMS to include contractor info.

> POC provided information on the materials used in this glove box. Added materials to the APIMS authorized list for the process. Added 2014 throughput in APIMS.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 3

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

ABCL 313

ALUMINUM SANDING

WET & DRY -

CONTRACTOR

666498 NA

> POC validated this process is really the sanding of aluminum parts and is not an abrasive blast unit.

> Contacted Northrop Grumman and requested the source category be changed from ABCL to GRND (changing the source category of a process cannot be done through the front-end of APIMS nor through the API).

AST 912

HORIZONTAL FIXED

ROOF - CONVAULT -

500 GAL

659603 NA

> Validated tank is no longer active. Changed process status in APIMS from active to inactive.

AST 691

AST - HFR - CNVLT -

TANK 691-4 - DIESEL -

500 GAL

1397 NA

> Validated contents of tank (process name indicated ‘diesel’ but process description indicated ‘propane’). Updated process description field in

APIMS.

> Validated tank is no longer active. Changed process status in APIMS from active to inactive.

AST 806

AST - HRF - CNVLT -

TANK 806 - DIESEL -

500 GAL

1399 NA

> Validated contents of tank (process name indicated ‘diesel’ but process description indicated ‘propane’). Updated process description field in

APIMS.

AST 810

AST - HFR - CNVLT -

TANK 810-2 - DIESEL -

500 GAL

1400 NA

> Validated contents of tank (process name indicated ‘diesel’ but process description indicated ‘propane’). Updated process description field in

APIMS.

> Validated tank is no longer active. Changed process status in APIMS from active to inactive.

CHEM BASEWIDE

BASEWIDE

MISCELLANEOUS

CHEMICAL USE

947 NA

> Verified all materials are issued through EESOH-MIS.

COOL 350

FACILITY 350 BAC

COOLING TOWER

660715 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 4

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

COOL 352

FACILITY 352 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660716 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 415

FACILITY 415 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660717 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 431

FACILITY 431 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660757 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 432

FACILITY 432 CERAMIC

COOLING TOWER

660758 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 514

FACILITY 514 DORMS

CERAMIC COOLING

TOWER

660759 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 550

FACILITY 550 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER #2

660760 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 5

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

COOL 550

FACILITY 550 MARLEY

CHILLER PLANT

660762 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

> Validated process information and added info to APIMS in process name field (changed process name from ‘550’ to

‘FACILITY 550 MARLEY

CHILLER PLANT’).

COOL 710

FACILITY 710 TRI

THERMAL COOLING

TOWER

660763 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 750

FACILITY 750 REYMSA

COOLING TOWER

660764 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

> Correct location for unit is building 750 (instead of 751).

Updated APIMS appropriately.

COOL 820

FACILITY 820 BAC

COOLING TOWER

660767 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 821

FACILITY 821 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660768 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 925

FACILITY 925 BAC

COOLING TOWER (2)

660769 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 6

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

COOL 967

FACILITY 967 COOLING

TOWER

660770

NA

> Validated with POC unit has been removed in 2010 and replaced by new unit. Updated status in APIMS from active to removed.

> Validated process information and added info to APIMS in process name field (changed process name from ‘967’ to

‘FACILITY 967 COOLING

TOWER’).

COOL 967

FACILITY 967 BAC

COOLING TOWER

660771 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 985

FACILITY 985 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660819 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 989

FACILITY 989 C

SECTION CERAMIC

COOLING TOWER

660820 NA

> POC confirmed process was inactive in 2014. Updated status in APIMS from active to inactive.

COOL 989

FACILITY 989 A

SECTION CERAMIC

COOLING TOWER

660821 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 991

FACILITY 991 BAC

COOLING TOWER

660822 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 996

FACILITY 996 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660823 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 7

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

COOL 1364

FACILITY 1364 MARLEY

COOLING TOWER

660824 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 3655

FACILITY 3655 PROTEC

COOLING TOWER

660825 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 3656

FACILITY 3656 BAC

COOLING TOWER

660826 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 3659

FACILITY 3659 TRI

THERMAL COOLING

TOWER

660827 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

COOL 10989

FACILITY 10989

MARLEY TOWERS (3)

660829 NA

> Collected updated total dissolved solids data for the unit. Updated in APIMS (process parameter field).

> Validated water flow rate and total drift factor data in APIMS is correct for the unit.

DEGR 313

DEGR - BLDG 313-1 -

CONTRACTOR

OPERATED

957 NA

> POC provided 2014 throughput data (data not tracked in

EESOH-MIS).

> Added contractor contact information in process description in APIMS.

DEGR 313

DEGR - BLDG 313-1 -

CONTRACTOR

OPERATED

958 NA

> POC provided 2014 throughput data (data not tracked in

EESOH-MIS).

> Added contractor contact information in process description in APIMS.

ECOM 984

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

NATURAL GAS - 1.675

MMBTU/HR

895 NA

> POC confirmed the unit has been shutdown. Status updated in APIMS from active to permanently shutdown.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 8

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

ECOM 989

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

NATURAL GAS - 1.339

MMBTU/HR

901 NA

> POC confirmed the unit has been demolished. Status updated in APIMS from active to demolished.

ECOM 989

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

NATURAL GAS - 1.339

MMBTU/HR

902 NA

> POC confirmed the unit has been demolished. Status updated in APIMS from active to demolished.

ECOM 989

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

NATURAL GAS - 2.009

MMBTU/HR

903 NA

> POC confirmed the unit has been demolished. Status updated in APIMS from active to demolished.

ECOM 691

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

FUEL OIL - 0.95

MMBTU/HR

916 058

> POC confirmed the unit was shut down in 2013. Status updated in APIMS from active to inactive (unit was demolished in 2015 and APIMS status updated to reflect this).

ECOM 1316

EXTERNAL COMBUST -

FUEL OIL - 0.09

MMBTU/HR

921 NA

> POC confirmed the unit has been removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

FIRE NA

FIRE TRAINING AT

PATRICK AFB

1650 NA

> Collected 2014 throughput data.

> Verified only propane was used for this activity.

ICOM 1316

INTERNAL COMBUST

ACTIVITIES -

GENERATOR - 80 KW

976 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM 407

INTERNAL COMBUST

ACTIVITIES -

GENERATOR - 8 KW

987 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL COMBUST

ACTIVITIES -

GENERATOR - 8 KW

989 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL COMBUST

ACTIVITIES -

GENERATOR - 8 KW

990 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM 659

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION

ACTIVITIES - 454KW -

BLDG 659

1228 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-100KW

1429 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-20KW

1437 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 9

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-6KW

1443 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-6KW

1449 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-6KW

1450 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM UNKNOWN

RECIPROCATING -

DIESEL FUEL - 48 HP

666497 NA

> POC confirmed the unit was removed. Status updated in APIMS from active to removed.

ICOM MALABAR

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-175KW

1426 NA

> Unit does not belong to Patrick AFB, but belongs to a geographically separated unit (GSU). Environmental POC deleted process from APIMS.

ICOM MALABAR

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-500KW

159016 NA

> Unit does not belong to Patrick AFB, but belongs to a GSU.

Environmental POC deleted process from APIMS.

ICOM MALABAR

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-500KW

159017 NA

> Unit does not belong to Patrick AFB, but belongs to a GSU.

Environmental POC deleted process from APIMS.

ICOM MALABAR

INTERNAL

COMBUSTION -

EMERGENCY

GENERATOR-500KW

159020 NA

> Unit does not belong to Patrick AFB, but belongs to a GSU.

Environmental POC deleted process from APIMS.

ODC BASEWIDE

BASEWIDE

REFRIGERANT

PROCESSES

660830 NA > Verified all refrigerants (service records for HVAC units) are tracked in the APIMS Refrigerant Module. ODC BASEWIDE

HVAC - SERVICING

AND REPAIR

163005 NA

PEST BASEWIDE

BASEWIDE PESTICIDE

APPLICATION

686347 NA

> Verified all materials are issued through EESOH-MIS.

> Created new process in APIMS to account for all basewide pesticide usage.

SURF 511

SURFACE COATING -

PAINT BOOTH 511-1 -

BLDG 511

991 036

> Verified process was shutdown in 2013. Status updated in APIMS from active to permanently shut down.

SURF 511

SURFACE COATING -

PAINT BOOTH 511-2 -

BLDG 511

992 037

> Verified process was shutdown in 2013. Status updated in APIMS from active to permanently shut down.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 10

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

SURF 630

SURFACE COATING -

PAINT BOOTH - BLDG

993 039

> Verified process was shutdown in 2013. Status is currently active in APIMS as process was reactivated in April of 2015. Verified no usage in 2014 (paint booth inactivated in 2013, but reactivated in 2015).

UST 1360

UNDERGROUND

STORAGE TANK -

MOGAS - TANK 1360-2

1029 NA

> This process is a duplicate of process UID 659423. There is no corresponding tank record for this process in STAR.

Changed status from active to removed in APIMS. Included note that process is a duplicate of UID 659423.

UST 1360

UNDERGROUND

STORAGE TANK -

MOGAS - TANK 1360-3

1030 NA

> This process is a duplicate of process UID 659426. There is no corresponding tank record for this process in STAR.

Changed status from active to removed in APIMS. Included note that process is a duplicate of UID 659426.

WELD BASEWIDE BASEWIDE WELDING 686346 NA

> Verified all materials are issued through EESOH-MIS.

> Created new process in APIMS to account for all basewide pesticide usage.

WOOD 552

WOODWORKING

ACTIVITIES - BLDG 522

997 NA

> Collected 2014 throughput data.

> Verified dust collector control efficiency (added control efficiency for particulate matter (PM), PM10 and PM2.5 to the equipment record for accurate calculations).

> The organization plans on replacing the current control device manufactured by Camfil by the end of 2015 with an equivalent unit manufactured by Imperial System with a higher CFM rating.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 11

Source Category 1

Building Process Name Process

UID 2

Permit

EU ID 3

Validation Item(s)

WWT --

SWIMMING POOL

WATER TREATMENT

646209 NA

> Verified this activity/process is the addition of chemicals to the swimming pool.

> The WWT source category is for the treatment of industrial or sanitary waste water. Added text to the process description field in APIMS to clarify this is not a WWT process.

> Contacted Northrop Grumman and requested the source category be changed from WWT to CHEM (changing the source category of a process cannot be done through the front-end of APIMS nor through the API).

> There are not any material issue records (for any year) associated to this process in the APIMS consumption table.

Associated the process to the basewide chemical usage process (UID 947) to account for any future material issue records added to the consumption table for this process.

1 ABCL = abrasive cleaning, AST = aboveground storage tank, CHEM = miscellaneous chemical use, COOL = cooling tower, DEGR = degreasing/solvent cleaning, ECOM = external combustion, FIRE = fire training, ICOM = internal combustion, ODC = ozone depleting chemicals, PEST = herbicide/pesticide application, SURF = surface coating, UST = underground storage tank, WELD = welding/soldering, WOOD = woodworking, WWT = waste water treatment.

2 UID = unique identification

3 EU ID = emission unit unique identification

AFCEC issued new guidance in the October 2014 Air Emissions Guide for Air Force Stationary Sources in regards to source categories to be considered as ‘transitory’. From page 2 of the guide:

“Transitory sources are non-routine and/or seasonal sources (may be stationary, mobile or neither) that are short-term in nature. While historically transitory sources have been erroneously included as stationary or mobile sources in AEIs, transitory source emissions should generally only be accounted for in evaluating potential air quality impacts of proposed action under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA); National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), General Conformity, etc.”

Previously, the following source categories had been included in APIMS emission calculations but were not included in the 2014 AEI due to the new AFCEC guidance to consider them as transitory sources:

> Asphalt Operations (UID 656707)

> Construction Operations (UID 1537)

> Fuel Cell Maintenance (UIDs 928, 929, 930, 1594)

The following source category, although considered transitory, was included in the 2014 AEI because it is listed in Condition FW11 of the Patrick AFB TVOP:

> Spills/Releases - fuel or organic solvents (UIDs 1583, 1649, 160104)

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 12

The algorithms and EF sets associated with the existing processes were reviewed to validate consistency with the current AFCEC Air Emissions Guide for Air Force Stationary Sources, AFCEC Air Emissions Guide for Air Force Mobile Sources and EPA’s AP-42. Existing APIMS process data were updated as necessary and consumption data and information for newly identified air emission equipment/processes were entered into APIMS using the application program interface (API) and other appropriate methods. Three facilities (Patrick AFB, Ascension Island and Antigua) are associated with the Patrick AFB installation in APIMS. Only processes linked to the ‘Patrick AFB’ facility were included in this AEI.

The following emission calculations were created in APIMS for the 2014 AEI with a start date of 1/01/2014 and an end date of 12/31/2014:

> Monthly Stationary Calculation

> Monthly EESOH Calculation

> Mobile Calculation

> 2014 Tank Emission Calculation (a new tank calculation was not created; the existing 2014 calculation was utilized)

Additionally, the following emission inventory submittals were created and staged in APIMS:

> 2014 AEI – includes calculations:

- Monthly Stationary Calculation

- Monthly EESOH Calculation

- 2014 Tank Emission Calculation 2014

> 2014 GHG – includes calculations:

- Monthly Stationary Calculation

- Monthly EESOH Calculation

> 2014 MOB – includes calculations:

- Mobile Calculation

A summary of emissions by source category is provided in Section 1.3.1 and Section 1.3.2 for stationary and mobile sources, respectively; full details of the calculations are provided in Section 2 and Section 3. For stationary sources, emission results by process are included in Appendix A and the 2014 throughput data is included in Appendix B. For mobile sources, emission results by process are included in Appendix C and the 2014 throughput data is included in Appendix D. Process flow diagrams for each process category are provided in Appendix E and details of the Patrick AFB APIMS Discoverer queries are provided in Appendix F.

1.3 Summary of Results

Stationary source emission results are provided in Section 1.3.1. Mobile source emission results are provided in Section 1.3.2. The results and discussion of emission results include only the Patrick AFB facility processes and emissions.

1.3.1 Stationary Sources

The 2014 emissions are summarized by source category in Table 1-2. Speciated HAP emissions are presented in Table1-3. PM10, PM2.5, SOX, NOX, CO, VOC, lead, total HAP and CO2e emissions are presented by source category in Figure 1-1 through Figure 1-9.

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 13

Table 1-2 2014 Patrick AFB Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category

Source Category

Pollutant Emissions (tons/year)

PM10 PM2.5 SOX NOX CO VOC Lead 1 Total

HAPs 1 CO2e 2

Abrasive Cleaning

(ABCL)

5.57E-04 7.29E-04 -- -- -- -- -- -- --

Cooling Towers (COOL) 16.91 10.15 -- -- -- -- -- -- --

Degreasing / Solvent Cleaning (DEGR)

-- -- -- -- -- 0.33 -- -- --

External Combustion

(ECOM)

0.17 0.17 0.01 2.20 1.85 0.12 9.00E-06 2.82E-03 2,402

Fire Training (FIRE) 7.59E-03 7.59E-03 1.20E-05 0.04 0.01 0.02 -- 5.63E-04 --

Fuel Dispensing (FDSP) -- -- -- -- -- 0.12 -- 0.01 --

Fuel Loading Racks(FLD)

-- -- -- -- -- 0.03 -- 0.01 --

Fuel Storage – Aboveground Tanks

(AST)

-- -- -- -- -- 1.89 -- 0.08 --

Fuel Storage – Underground Tanks

(UST)

-- -- -- -- -- 8.39 -- 0.18 --

Herbicide / Pesticide Application (PEST)

-- -- -- -- -- 0.01 -- 2.19E-04 --

Internal Combustion – Stationary Sources

(ICOM)

0.12 0.12 0.03 3.09 0.80 0.11 -- 1.51E-03 120

Miscellaneous Chemical Use (CHEM)

-- -- -- -- -- 2.21 -- 2.66 --

Ozone Depleting Chemicals (ODC)

-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- 342

Spills/ Releases (SPRL) -- -- -- -- -- 0.12 -- 9.27E-04 --

Surface Coating (SURF) 0.04 0.04 -- -- -- 0.16 -- 0.03 --

Welding / Soldering

(WELD)

2.15E-03 2.15E-03 -- -- -- -- 4.00E-6 -- --

Woodworking (WOOD) 5.80E-04 4.37E-04 -- -- -- -- -- -- --

TOTAL 17.25 10.48 0.05 5.34 2.66 13.50 1.30E-05 2.98 2,864

1 Lead is both a criteria pollutant and a HAP. Lead emissions are included in the ‘Total HAPs’ emissions.

2 CO2e emissions are presented in metric tonnes.

Table 1-3 2014 Patrick AFB Stationary Source Speciated HAP Emissions

CAS Pollutant Emissions

(lb/yr) (ton/yr)

68-12-2 Dimethylformamide 0.01 5.00E-06

75-09-2 Methylene Chloride 2.92 1.46E-03

79-01-6 Trichloroethylene 19.94 9.97E-03

100-41-4 Ethylbenzene 31.27 0.02

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 14

CAS Pollutant Emissions

(lb/yr) (ton/yr)

100-42-5 Styrene 0.84 4.22E-04

106-46-7 1,4-Dichlorobenzene 0.03 1.70E-05

107-02-8 Acrolein 0.15 7.30E-05

107-21-1 Ethylene Glycol 548 0.27

108-10-1 Methyl Isobutyl Ketone 45.48 0.02

108-88-3 Toluene 245 0.12

108-95-2 Phenol 1.61 8.03E-04

110-54-3 Hexane 147 0.07

111-42-2 Diethanolamine 0.02 8.00E-06

127-18-4 Tetrachloroethylene 3.54 1.77E-03

132-64-9 Dibenzofuran 0.05 2.30E-05

1330-20-7 Xylene (Mixed) 129 0.06

1634-04-4 Methyl tert butyl ether 2,302 1.15

50-00-0 Formaldehyde 4.85 2.42E-03

540-84-1 2,2,4-Trimethylpentane 1.46 7.28E-04

67-56-1 Methanol 62.71 0.03

71-43-2 Benzene 157 0.08

75-07-0 Acetaldehyde 0.31 1.54E-04

75-56-9 Propylene Oxide 0.80 4.01E-04

7647-01-0 Hydrochloric Acid 2,051 1.03

7664-39-3 Hydrogen Fluoride 5.39 2.69E-03

7782-50-5 Chlorine 2,250 1.13

80-62-6 Methyl Methacrylate 0.05 2.50E-05

822-06-0 Hexamethylene-1,6-Diisocyanate 0.12 5.90E-05

84-74-2 Dibutyl Phthalate 0.38 1.88E-04

91-20-3 Naphthalene 1.34 6.72E-04

95-48-7 o-Cresol 6.00E-03 3.00E-06

98-82-8 Cumene 4.80 2.40E-03

-- Lead Compounds 0.03 1.30E-05

-- Cadmium Compounds 0.03 1.30E-05

-- Nickel Compounds 0.16 8.20E-05

-- Chromium Compounds 0.28 1.38E-04

-- Polycyclic Organic Matter 0.29 1.46E-04

-- Manganese Compounds 1.23 6.14E-04

-- Glycol Ethers 262 0.13

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 15

Patrick AFB 2014 PM10 Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-1 presents Figure 1-1 the 2014 PM10 emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 PM2.5 Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-2 presents Figure 1-2 the 2014 PM2.5 emissions in tons per year by source category.

5.

E -0

0 0

.9

0 0.

7.

E -0

0 0 0.

0 0 0 0.

0 2.

E -0

5.

E -0

P M

E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB PM10 Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

7.

E -0

0 0

.1

0 0.

7.

E -0

0 0 0.

0 0 0 0.

0 2.

E -0

4.

E -0

P M

2.

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB PM2.5 Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 16

Patrick AFB 2014 SOX Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-3 presents Figure 1-3 the 2014 SOX emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 NOX Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-4 presents Figure 1-4 the 2014 NOX emissions in tons per year by source category.

0 0 0 0 0

0.

1.

E -0

0 0

0.

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0.00

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04 S

O X

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB SOX Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

0 0 0 0 0

2.

0.

0 0

3.

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

N O

X E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB NOX Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 17

Patrick AFB 2014 CO Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-5 presents Figure 1-5 the 2014 CO emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 VOC Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-6 presents Figure 1-6 the 2014 VOC emissions in tons per year by source category. Gasoline USTs are equipped with EVR.

However, the APIMS TANKS module does not currently include functionality to account for EVR.

0 0 0 0 0

1.

0.

0 0

0.

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

C

O E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB CO Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

1.

89 2.

0.

0.

0.

0.

0.

0.

0 0.

01 0.

0.

8.

0 0

V O

C E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB VOC Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 18

Patrick AFB 2014 Lead Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-7 presents Figure 1-7 the 2014 lead emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 Total HAP Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-8 Figure 1-8 presents the 2014 total HAPs emissions in tons per year by source category. Gasoline USTs are equipped with EVR. However, the APIMS TANKS module does not currently include functionality to account for EVR.

0 0 0 0 0 9.

E -0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4.

E -0

0.00

0.25

0.50

L ea d E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB Lead Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

0 0.

2.

0 0 2.

E -0

5.

E -0

0.

0.

1.

E -0

0 2.

E -0

9.

E -0

0.

03 0.

0 0

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

T o ta l

H A

P E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB Total HAP Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 19

Patrick AFB 2014 CO2e Stationary Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-9 Figure 1-9 presents the 2014 CO2e emissions in metric tonnes per year by source category.

1.3.2 Mobile Sources

The 2014 mobile source emissions are summarized by source category in Table 1-4. Speciated HAP emissions are presented in Table1-5. PM10, PM2.5, SOX, NOX, CO, VOC, total HAP and CO2e emissions are presented by source category in Figure 1-10 through Figure 1-17.

Table 1-4 2014 Patrick AFB Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category

Source Category Pollutant Emissions (tons/year)

PM10 PM2.5 SOX NOX CO VOC Lead 1 Total HAPs CO2e 2

Aerospace Ground Equipment (AGE)

0.13 0.12 0.04 0.68 0.73 0.19 -- -- 39.28

Aircraft Operations

(AOPS)

7.15 5.24 10.07 139.02 113.30 15.76 -- 0.95 28,060

Internal Combustion – Portable Units (ICOM)

0.27 0.27 0.25 3.87 0.84 0.32 -- 3.36E-03 115

Non-road Engines

(NRDE)

0.11 0.11 0.05 0.75 10.26 0.67 -- 0.21 73.65

Vehicle Emissions

(VEHE)

0.12 0.06 0.03 2.39 30.71 3.01 -- -- 1,710

TOTAL 7.78 5.80 10.44 146.71 155.84 19.95 0 1.17 29,998

1 Lead is both a criteria pollutant and a HAP.

2 CO2e emissions are presented in metric tonnes.

0 0 0 0 0

2, 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

1,000

1,500

2,000

2,500

3,000

C O

2e

E m is si o n s (m et ri c to n n es /y r)

2014 Patrick AFB CO2e Stationary Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 20

Table 1-5 2014 Patrick AFB Mobile Source Speciated HAP Emissions

CAS Pollutant Emissions

(lb/yr) (ton/yr)

100-41-4 Ethylbenzene 29.40 0.01

100-42-5 Styrene 85.41 0.04

106-99-0 1,3-Butadiene 29.12 0.01

107-02-8 Acrolein 137 0.07

108-88-3 Toluene 125 0.06

108-95-2 Phenol 36.95 0.02

110-54-3 Hexane 9.96 4.98E-03

123-38-6 Propionaldehyde 40.04 0.02

1330-20-7 Xylene (Mixed) 108 0.05

50-00-0 Formaldehyde 1,185 0.59

71-43-2 Benzene 184 0.09

75-07-0 Acetaldehyde 271 0.14

91-20-3 Naphthalene 87.29 0.04

95-47-6 o-Xylene 12.31 6.16E-03

Polycyclic Organic Matter 0.14 7.10E-05

Patrick AFB 2014 PM10 Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-10 presents Figure 1-10 the 2014 PM10 emissions in tons per year by source category.

0.

7.

0.

0.

0.

P M

E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB PM10 Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 21

Patrick AFB 2014 PM2.5 Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-11 presents Figure 1-11 the 2014 PM2.5 emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 SOX Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-12 presents the Figure 1-12 2014 SOX emissions in tons per year by source category.

0.

5.

0.

0.

0.

P

M 2.

E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB PM2.5 Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

0.

.0

0.

0.

0.

S O

X E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB SOX Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 22

Patrick AFB 2014 NOX Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-13 presents Figure 1-13 the 2014 NOX emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 CO Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-14 presents the Figure 1-14 2014 CO emissions in tons per year by source category.

0.

3.

0.

2.

N

O X

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB NOX Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

0.

0.

.2

.7

C O

E m is si o n s (t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB CO Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 23

Patrick AFB 2014 VOC Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-15 presents Figure 1-15 the 2014 VOC emissions in tons per year by source category.

Patrick AFB 2014 Total HAP Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-16 Figure 1-16 presents the 2014 total HAPs emissions in tons per year by source category.

0.

.7

0.

32 0.

3.

V O

C E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

Process Category

2014 Patrick AFB VOC Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

0.

3.

E -0

3 0.

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

T o ta l

H A

P E m is si o n s

(t o n s/ yr

2014 Patrick AFB Total HAP Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 24

Patrick AFB 2014 CO2e Mobile Source Emissions by Source Category. Figure 1-17 presents Figure 1-17 the 2014 CO2e emissions in metric tonnes per year by source category.

1.4 Recommendations

The following recommendations are presented for consideration for future emission inventories as well as for the management of APIMS process data to demonstrate compliance with the TVOP requirements:

> The status of each process should be kept current.

> When a process/piece of equipment is removed from the base, the status of the process should be updated to reflect the change instead of the process record being deleted from APIMS.

> Record usage of ICOM processes in the IC Engine Log instead of the Consumption table.

> The CE heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) shop should continue using the Refrigerant Compliance module in APIMS to track the amount of refrigerant added and recovered for each piece of equipment.

> EESOH-MIS should be utilized to track hazardous materials usage in all shops on base whether contractor or government operated. This will provide accurate data for future AEIs, demonstrate compliance with TVOP requirements, as well as maintain compliance with AFI 32-7086 Hazardous Materials Management, 4 Feb 15, Chapter 3.2.

.2

,0

.6

1, 5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

35,000

40,000

C O

2e

E m is si o n s (m et ri c to n n es /y r)

2014 Patrick AFB CO2e Mobile Source Emissions by Process Category

8961/TO 002 January 22, 2015 Cardno 25

1.5 Points of Contact

Table 1-5 presents the Patrick AFB POCs who provided support for the 2014 AEI.

Table 1-6 Patrick AFB POCs

POC

Organization

Email Address Phone

Number Source Category

Jose Badillo 45 CES/CEOHS jose.badillo.2@us.af.mil 854-4355 WOOD

Michael Coyle 45 OSS/OSA michael.coyle.9@us.af.mil 854-9345 AOPS

Rick Davis CEOFP rickey.davis.1@us.af.mil 854-3962 ICOM

Jonathan Fair MXMG jonathan.fair.2@us.af.mil 854-4777 AGE

Laurie Fisher CEIE laurie.fisher@us.af.mil 854-7288 Overall support

Robert Freche CEOIH robert.freche@us.af.mil 854-4775 PEST

SSgt Jordan Hocker CEOIH jordan.hocker@us.af.mil 854-2625 PEST

David Jacobs CZOE david.jacobs.9.ctr@us.af.mil 854-1798 Overall support

Dennis Julian LGRV…