36C24119R0029-0002002.pdf

ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL

SURVEY REPORT

BUILDING 20

VA Contract No. VA241-15-D-0176 VA Order No. VA241-16-J-1315

VA Project No. 631-16-040

Northampton VA Medical Center 421 North Main Street

Leeds, Massachusetts 01053-9764

Mabbett Project No. 7062001.000 Task 001

9 June 2016

Mabbett & Associates, Inc.

5 Alfred Circle Bedford, MA 01730-2318 T. 781-275-6050 www.mabbett.com Massachusetts | Virginia | Rhode Island | New Jersey

ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL SURVEY REPORT / BUILDING 20

Northampton VA Medical Center | Leeds, MA

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc

VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page i

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This Asbestos Containing Materials (ACM) Building Survey Report was prepared for the Veterans Affairs (VA) Central Western Massachusetts HCS in accordance with an established scope of work as defined in VA Project Number 631-16-040 dated 25 March 2016. The information presented herein is based on the facts and information conveyed to or received by Mabbett & Associates, Inc. (Mabbett®) during the preparation of this report. If any of the information provided to Mabbett that was used in preparing this report is incorrect, incomplete, or subject to change, Mabbett would wish to alter its opinion(s) accordingly. In addition, the professional opinions and information contained in this report are based solely on the requirements of the applicable regulations and technical data as known to Mabbett as of the date of this report and considered applicable to this report.

This report was prepared by the following Mabbett & Associates, Inc. personnel:

Kevin Donovan Environmental, Health & Safety Specialist Massachusetts Asbestos Inspector AI002014 Massachusetts Asbestos Designer AD034039

This report has been reviewed and approved by:

MABBETT & ASSOCIATES, INC.

By:

David A. Nelson, RPIH Senior Industrial Hygienist/Senior Environmental Health and Safety Consultant

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc

©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Description Page

1.0 INTRODUCTION & EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

2.0 BUILDING DESCRIPTION

3.0 ASBESTOS SURVEY

3.1 Sampling Methodology

3.2 Analytical Methodology

3.3 Summary of Asbestos Containing Materials (ACM) Findings

3.3.1 Supplemental Site Survey – Mabbett - June 2016

3.3.2 Asbestos Inspection - Survey – ATC – April 2016

3.3.3 Asbestos Containing Materials Report - Mabbett - December 2010

3.3.4 CADD Drawings

4.0 LIMITATIONS

5.0 CLOSING REMARKS

Tables Table 1 Specific Inaccessible Areas Table 2 Mabbett 2016 Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Table 3 ATC 2016 Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Table 4 Mabbett 2010 Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Table 5 Summary of All Positive ACM Building Survey Results

Figures Figure 1 Asbestos Survey Summary Plan - Building 20, Basement Figure 2 Asbestos Survey Summary Plan - Building 20, Floor 1 Figure 3 Asbestos Survey Summary Plan - Building 20, Floor 2 Figure 4 Asbestos Survey Summary Plan - Building 20, Attic

Appendices Appendix A Laboratory Analytical Reports Appendix B Relevant Photographs of ACM – Mabbett 2010

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc

©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 1 of 5

1.0 INTRODUCTION & EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Mabbett and Associates, Inc. (Mabbett®), performed a follow-up and pre-abatement design survey for suspect asbestos containing building materials (ACM) of Building 20 at the Northampton VA Medical Center (VAMC) located at 421 North Main Street, Leeds, Massachusetts, under VA Contract Number VA241- 15-D-0176, and VA Project Number 631-16-040. The purpose of this survey was to review and confirm the results of the previously existing asbestos survey reports prepared by Mabbett in 2010 and ATC in 2016 and to collect supplemental bulk samples of previously unidentified suspect materials such that a Traditional Asbestos Abatement Plan per the VA Master Specifications dated 1 September 2015 could be prepared in preparation for the complete renovation of Building 20.

The supplemental site survey was performed 1 June 2016 by appropriately credentialed Mabbett personnel as required. Collected suspect ACM samples were submitted to a certified analytical laboratory for asbestos analysis by polarized light microscopy (PLM) using positive stop methodology where indicated. The survey effort involved the collection of the following samples, resulting in the following conclusions:

• 28 additional bulk samples for suspect ACM were collected from Building 20;

• Laboratory analysis of the additional suspect ACM samples collected revealed that none contained asbestos greater than or equal to 1%; and

• The sprinkler pipe thread sealant (throughout the building), contains trace asbestos

(greater than 0% but less than 1%).

This survey report consists of a summary of findings, floor plans indicating positive sample locations, detailed analytical findings for the specific surveyed building materials, and photos of the previously Mabbett identified ACM. Laboratory analytical reports for this building report are located in Appendix A.

2.0 BUILDING DESCRIPTION

According to information provided by the VAMC Office of Facilities Management and observations made by the Mabbett team at the time of the supplemental survey, Building 20 is a three-story vacant Administrative building built in 1923 and occupies approximately 20,784 square feet. The VA Plans to completely abate the ACM throughout the building prior to a full-scale renovation project.

3.0 ASBESTOS SURVEY

3.1 Sampling Methodology

A visual screening inspection was conducted by state licensed asbestos inspectors throughout the building to identify locations of suspect ACM. Only areas that were accessible during the field work phase were inspected. Every effort was made during the supplemental site survey work to access areas as necessary to complete the survey.

However, if any areas remained inaccessible to the survey team, they are indicated in Table 1 below.

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc

©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 2 of 5

Table 1 – Specific Inaccessible Areas

Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

Building Floor Room No. Reason Area was Inaccessible and Survey Impacts, if Applicable

20 Basement EL Door was locked and the room has an active electrical transformer.

Other general areas that were inaccessible or where the survey was limited to visual observation only are identified below:

• Within walls

• Enclosed pipe/duct chases

• Electrical wiring

• Above fixed drywall or plaster ceilings

• Inside mechanical equipment/ductwork

Bulk samples were collected of suspect ACM in accordance with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) Asbestos Hazard and Emergency Response Act (AHERA), the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP), and the VISN 1 approved Mabbett VISN 1 Survey Program Standard Operating Procedure (SOP).

Roofing materials were not sampled to maintain applicable warranties. Bulk suspect ACM sampling of previously identified suspect materials was conducted according to the following sampling plan:

(a) Surfacing material:

(1) At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is 1,000 ft2 or less;

(2) At least five bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than 1,000 ft2 but less than or equal to 5,000 ft2; and

(3) At least seven bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than 5,000 ft2.

(b) Thermal system insulation:

(1) At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area of thermal system insulation;

(2) At least one bulk sample shall be collected from each homogeneous area of patched area of thermal system insulation;

(3) Sufficient samples shall be collected from elbows and fittings to determine if it contains ACM;

and

(4) Bulk samples shall not be collected from any homogeneous area where the state licensed asbestos inspector determined that the thermal system insulation is fiberglass, foam glass, rubber, or other non-ACM.

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc

©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 3 of 5

(c) Miscellaneous material:

(1) At least one bulk sample shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is less than 100 ft2; and

(2) At least three bulk samples shall be collected from each homogeneous area that is greater than

100 ft2.

3.2 Analytical Methodology

The collected bulk samples were submitted under chain of custody procedures to ProScience Analytical Services, Inc. (ProScience - MA ID# AA000156) of Woburn, MA for Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) analysis of bulk materials via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method.

Sample results from the Mabbett 2010 survey that revealed trace concentrations of asbestos by PLM were re-analyzed using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis.

ProScience is accredited by the American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) and participates in the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP Lab Code 200090-0).

Bulk sample results are summarized in Tables 2, 3, and 4 – Summary of ACM Building Survey Results. The EPA and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and the Commonwealth of Massachusetts department of Labor Standards (MA DLS) define any material that contains greater than or equal to one percent (≥1%) asbestos as being an ACM. The Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MA DEP) defines any material that contains any amount of asbestos, less than one percent (<1%) trace asbestos as being an Asbestos Containing Waste Material (ACWM) and should be disposed of as ACWM. As such, the analytical laboratory identified bulk samples as positive for asbestos that met the regulatory criteria of equal to or greater than one percent (≥1%) asbestos and trace for asbestos that met the regulatory criteria of less than one percent (<1%) asbestos.

3.3 Summary of Asbestos Containing Materials (ACM) Findings

3.3.1 Supplemental Site Survey – Mabbett - June 2016

Mabbett Associates, Inc. inspectors Mr. Kevin Donovan and Mr. Darren Andrews, who are EPA certified and Massachusetts Department of Labor Standards (MA DLS) licensed asbestos inspectors (MA DLS # AI002014 and #AI000294, respectively), conducted a supplemental site survey on 1 June 2016. The purpose of this survey was to review and confirm the results of the previously existing asbestos survey reports prepared by Mabbett in 2010 and ATC in 2016 and to collect supplemental bulk samples of previously unidentified suspect materials. In addition Mabbett conducted a room by room inventory of all ACBMs and video taped the exterior and interior of the building. Mabbett collected a total of twenty eight (28) samples and delivered them to ProScience for PLM analysis via EPA 600/- 93/116 Method. Two (2) samples of sprinkler pipe thread sealant contained trace amounts (<1%) of chrysotile asbestos. This material is assumed present throughout the building in

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 4 of 5 various pipe chases and within walls.

A summary all positive ACM analytical results can be seen on Table 5 and the laboratory analytical reports can be seen in Appendix A.

3.3.2 Asbestos Inspection - Survey – ATC – April 2016

ATC Group Services LLC (ATC) inspector Mr. Edward Kolodziej, an EPA-trained and Massachusetts Certified Asbestos Inspector (MA DLS #AI073072), conducted an asbestos survey on 20 March 2016. ATC performed a limited pre-renovation survey to identify suspect asbestos-containing materials in building #20. The survey included a visual assessment of accessible suspect asbestos-containing materials and subsequent sampling and analysis. ATC collected forty three (43) samples and transported under chain of custody to EMSL Analytical, Inc. located in New York, NY for Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) analysis (EPA Method 600/R-93/116). Analytical results indicated that one (1) sample (B20-14A) of leveler/black mastic contained 4% chrysotile asbestos. This sample was collected from Room 125 and is assumed throughout the building.

A summary all positive ACM analytical results can be seen on Table 5 and the laboratory analytical reports can be seen in Appendix A.

3.3.3 Asbestos Containing Materials Report - Mabbett - December 2010

Mabbett MA DLS licensed asbestos inspectors conducted building surveys between May and June 2010; this included Building 20. The purpose of the survey was to identify locations, collect samples of accessible suspect materials, photograph suspect materials and conduct a lead based paint assessment. Mabbett collected a total of one hundred and sixty four (164) bulk samples and sent them to ProScience for PLM analysis and TEM analysis. Seventy five (75) samples contained asbestos. These materials included; floor tile and mastic, pipe insulation and pipe fitting insulation, and fire doors which are found throughout the building. One-foot by one-foot ceiling tiles with glue dabs are found in the basement stairwell and second floor hallway. Door frame/header caulking and window frame/header caulking, were are found on the exterior of the building.

A summary all positive ACM analytical results can be seen on Table 5 and the laboratory analytical reports can be seen in Appendix A.

3.3.4 CADD Drawings

The location of each collected bulk sample and its abridged sample ID is shown on the CADD drawings in the Figures Section of this report. The sample ID on the drawings have been abridged (by excluding the individual room number from the full sample ID) for aesthetic purposes. Each positive ACM sample location is colored red. Building areas containing ACM have been indicated with hatching to identify the location of the identified

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 S:\ADMINA\7062001 VISN1 AE Contract\TO1 Northampton\Asbestos Survey Report\Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20.doc VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Page 5 of 5

ACM. The CADD plans reflect the results from all three surveys; Mabbett 2016, ATC 2016, and Mabbett 2010.

4.0 LIMITATIONS

This inspection report is the result of a diligent search of Building 20 for ACM. Potential suspect ACM may exist in inaccessible areas of the building that could not be assessed during this survey as described in Section 3.1 above. Mabbett conducted this assessment with reasonable care and has performed this project within generally accepted industry standards. Mabbett recommends that abatement contractors provide unit pricing for typical materials in case unforeseen ACM is encountered during the abatement project. There can be no assurances, and Mabbett makes no assurances, that the information, research, and technology used to prepare this report may not change in the future, thus affecting the results provided.

5.0 CLOSING REMARKS

Upon completion of a review of readily available historical asbestos survey documents (Mabbett 2010 and ATC 2016) and upon completion of a supplemental asbestos survey Mabbett identified numerous ACMs throughout Building 20 located on the Northampton VA campus.

1. All ACMs located in Building 20 are required to be properly abated prior to any renovation activities in accordance with the U.S. EPA’s NESHAP, MA DEP, and MA DLS regulations.

2. All asbestos abatement work must be performed by a Commonwealth of Massachusetts licensed Asbestos Abatement Contractor and must be performed in accordance with all federal, state, and local regulations.

3. Any suspect ACM identified during the course of the abatement or renovation activities must be assumed to be ACM until additional bulk sampling is performed.

4. Mabbett will provide the Northampton VAMC with a Traditional Asbestos Abatement Specifications report written in accordance with the VA’s Master Specifications dated 1 September 2015.

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20 VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Tables

Tables

©2016, Mabbett Associates, Inc. Page 1 of 1 June 9, 2016

Table 2

Amount Units

01A Exterior Foundation Gray Foundation Skim-coat NAD - - - -

01B Exterior Foundation Gray Foundation Skim-coat NAD - - - -

01C Exterior Foundation Gray Foundation Skim-coat NAD - - - -

01D Exterior Foundation Gray Foundation Skim-coat NAD - - - -

01E Exterior Foundation Gray Foundation Skim-coat NAD - - - -

02A Exterior Foundation Black Foundation Coating NAD - - - -

02B Exterior Foundation Black Foundation Coating NAD - - - -

02C Exterior Foundation Black Foundation Coating NAD - - - -

02D Exterior Foundation Black Foundation Coating NAD - - - -

02E Exterior Foundation Black Foundation Coating NAD - - - -

03A Exterior - NW Foundation Tan Window Box Caulking NAD - - - -

03B Exterior - NW Foundation Tan Window Box Caulking NAD - - - -

03C Exterior - NW Foundation Tan Window Box Caulking NAD - - - -

04A Attic - South Throughout Building Sprinkler Pipe Thread Sealant NAD - - - -

04B Attic - Center Throughout Building Sprinkler Pipe Thread Sealant Trace Chrysotile EA Good 4 04C Attic - North Throughout Building Sprinkler Pipe Thread Sealant Trace Chrysotile EA Good 4 05A Bathroom 1st & 2nd Floors Marble Shower Wall NAD - - - -

05B Bathroom 1st & 2nd Floors Marble Shower Wall NAD - - - -

06A Bathroom 1st & 2nd Floors Metal Stall Wall Insulation NAD - - - -

06B Bathroom 1st & 2nd Floors Metal Stall Wall Insulation NAD - - - -

07A First Floor 1st & 2nd Floor Hall Black Chimney Riser Insulation NAD - - - -

07B First Floor 1st & 2nd Floor Hall Black Chimney Riser Insulation NAD - - - -

07C Basement 1st & 2nd Floor Hall Black Chimney Riser Insulation NAD - - - -

08A Exterior East Side of Building Gray Awning Flashing Caulk NAD - - - -

08B Exterior East Side of Building Gray Awning Flashing Caulk NAD - - - -

08C Exterior East Side of Building Gray Awning Flashing Caulk NAD - - - -

09A Exterior Front Porch 2' x 4' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - -

09B Exterior Front Porch 2' x 4' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - -

Notes:

NAD - No Asbestos Detected (PLM) EA - Each SF - Square Feet CF - Cubic Feet LF - Linear Feet

Condition

VISN 1

RISK

Hazard Category

1-4*

2,200

* - The VISN 1 hazard assessment scale 1 – 4 is a relative indicator of the risk and need for response/remediation. (1) represents the highest priority (e.g. removal or encapsulation) whereas a (4) represents the lowest priority (monitor as part of 6 month O&M program). The rating, assigned by an Asbestos Management Planner, takes into account the following criteria: condition, friable vs. non-friable, accessibility, occupancy (e.g. continuous, intermittent or occasional, patients/staff/visitors), potential for air erosion, potential for vibration damage, potential for disturbance/damage (e.g.

exposed and in an accessible location), and potential for water damage.

Table 2 - Mabbett 2016 Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

Sample No.

Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity

Table 3

Amount Units

B20-01A Room #107 Throughout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01B Room #217 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01B Room #217 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01C Room #232 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01C Room #232 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01D Basement - fire place Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01E Main stairwell Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01E Main stairwell Throughtout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01F 1st floor hall Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01F 1st floor hall Throughtout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01G Room #14 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (skimcoat) NAD - SF - -

B20-01G Room #14 Throughtout Plaster ceiling (rough coat) NAD - SF - -

B20-02A Room #16 Basement Black sink undercoat NAD - EA - -

B20-03A Basement Basement White sink undercoat NAD - EA - -

B20-04A Room #108 Throughout Black coating on brick NAD - SF - -

B20-04B Room #219 Throughout Black coating on brick NAD - SF - -

B20-05A Room #16 Basement 1' x 1' perforated ceiling tile NAD - SF - -

B20-05B Room #16 Basement 1' x 1' perforated ceiling tile NAD - SF - -

B20-06A Room #16 Basement Glue daub assoc. with 1' x 1' ceiling tile NAD - SF - -

B20-06B Room #16 Basement Glue daub assoc. with 1' x 1' ceiling tile NAD - SF - -

B20-07B Room #15 Basement Reinforced window glazing NAD - LF - -

B20-08A Room #235 Throughout Soft concrete floor NAD - SF - -

B20-08B 2nd floor hall Throughout Soft concrete floor NAD - SF - -

B20-09A Basement entry lobby Basement 1' x 1' tan ceramic floor tile thinset/adhesive NAD - SF - -

B20-10A Basement entry lobby Basement 1' x 1' tan ceramic floor tile grout NAD - SF - -

B20-11A Room #125 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic floor tile grout NAD - SF - -

B20-11B Room #214 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic floor tile grout NAD - SF - -

B20-12B Room #214 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic floor tile thinset/adhesive NAD - SF - -

B20-13A Room #233 Bathrooms throughout 12' x 12" floor tile mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-14A Room #125 Throughout Leveler/Black Mastic 4% Chrysotile 21,000 SF Good 4

B20-14A Room #125 Throughout Leveler/black mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-14B Room #15 Throughout Leveler/black mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-14B Room #15 Throughout Leveler/black mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-15A Room #208 Throughout Leveler/black mastic under carpet NAD - SF - -

B20-15A Room #208 Throughout Leveler/black mastic under carpet NAD - SF - -

B20-16A Room#103 Throughout Red leveler/black mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-16A Room#103 Throughout Red leveler/black mastic NAD - SF - -

B20-17A Room #212 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic wall tile adhesive NAD - SF - -

B20-17B Room #135 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic wall tile adhesive NAD - SF - -

B20-18A Room #212 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic wall tile grout NAD - SF - -

B20-18B Room #135 Bathrooms throughout Ceramic wall tile grout NAD - SF - -

B20-19A Attic Throughout Black tar on joist NAD - SF - -

B20-20B Basement Throuhout Chimney exhaust insulation NAD - SF - -

B20-20C Basement thoughout Chimney exhaust insulation NAD - SF - -

Notes:

NAD - No Asbestos Detected (PLM) SF - Square Feet EA - Each LF - Linear Feet CF - Cubic Feet

Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity Condition

VISN 1

RISK

Hazard Category

1-4*

* - The VISN 1 hazard assessment scale 1 – 4 is a relative indicator of the risk and need for response/remediation. (1) represents the highest priority (e.g. removal or encapsulation) whereas a (4) represents the lowest priority (monitor as part of 6 month O&M program). The rating, assigned by an Asbestos Management Planner, takes into account the following criteria: condition, friable vs. non-friable, accessibility, occupancy (e.g. continuous, intermittent or occasional, patients/staff/visitors), potential for air erosion, potential for vibration damage, potential for disturbance/damage (e.g. exposed and in an accessible location), and potential for water damage.

Table 3 - ATC 2016 - Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

Sample No. Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material

©2016, Mabbett Associates, Inc. Page 1 of 3

Table 4

Amount Units 01A Exterior Doors Door Caulk TR - - - - 01B Exterior Doors Door Caulk 2% Chrysotile 60 LF Damaged 3 01C Exterior Doors Door Caulk 02A Exterior Perimeter of Windows Window Caulk 3% Chrysotile 2,000 LF Good 4 02B Exterior Perimeter of Windows Window Caulk 02C Exterior Perimeter of Windows Window Caulk 03A 127 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 10,000 SF Good 4 03B 129 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile 03C 237 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile 04A 127 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile Mastic 5% Chrysotile 10,000 SF Good 4 04B 129 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile Mastic 04C 237 Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor 9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile Mastic 05A Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 300 SF Good 4 05B Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile 05C Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile 06A Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile 300 SF Good 4 06B Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile Mastic 06C Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Gray Floor Tile Mastic 07A Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 300 SF Good 4 07B Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile 07C Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile 08A Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile 300 SF Good 4 08B Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile Mastic 08C Hallway 1st & 2nd Floor Hall 9"x9" Tan Floor Tile Mastic 09A Hallway - Leveling Compound NAD - - - - 09B Hallway - Leveling Compound NAD - - - - 09C Hallway - Leveling Compound NAD - - - - 10A Stairwell North Stairs & Room 225 12"x12" White Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 100 SF Good 4 10B 225 North Stairs & Room 225 12"x12" White Floor Tile 10C 225 North Stairs & Room 225 12"x12" White Floor Tile 11A Stairwell - 12"x12" White Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 11B 225 - 12"x12" White Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 11C 225 - 12"x12" White Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 12A Stairwell Main Stair & 1st Floor Foyer 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile 5% Chrysotile 400 SF Good 4 12B Foyer Main Stair & 1st Floor Foyer 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile 12C Foyer Main Stair & 1st Floor Foyer 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile 13A Stairwell - 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 13B Foyer - 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 13C Foyer - 9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 14A 103 Room 103 & 125 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 300 SF Good 4 14B 103 Room 103 & 125 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile 14C 103 Room 103 & 125 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile 15A 103 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 15B 103 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 15C 103 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 16A 210 - Carpet Mastic NAD - - - - 16B 206 - Carpet Mastic NAD - - - - 16C Dining Area - Carpet Mastic NAD - - - - 17A 123 Rooms 123, 124, 133, 223, 224 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile 5% Chrysotile 400 SF Good 4 17B 133 Rooms 123, 124, 133, 223, 224 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile 17C 223 Rooms 123, 124, 133, 223, 224 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile 18A 123 - 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 18B 133 - 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 18C 223 - 9"x9" Brown Floor Tile Mastic TR - - - - 19A Stairwell - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile NAD - - - - 19B 17 - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile NAD - - - - 19C Bathroom - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile NAD - - - - 20A Stairwell - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 20B 17 - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 20C Bathroom - 12"x12" White Streaked Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 21A 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile 3% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4 21B 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile 21C 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile 22A 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4 22B 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile Mastic 22C 112 Room 112- Bathroom 9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile Mastic 23A Front Porch - 2'x4' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 23B Front Porch - 2'x4' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 23C Front Porch - 2'x4' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 24A 112 - Cove Base Mastic NAD - - - - 24B 112 - Cove Base Mastic NAD - - - - 24C 112 - Cove Base Mastic NAD - - - - 25A Hallway - Drywall NAD - - - - 25B Foyer - Drywall NAD - - - - 25C Hallway - Drywall NAD - - - -

Table 4 - Mabbett 2010 - Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

VISN 1

RISK

Hazard Category

1-4*

Sample No.

Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity Condition

Stop Positive See 4A

Stop Positive See 5A

Stop Positive See 21A

Stop Positive See 10A

Stop Positive See 8A

Stop Positive See 10A

Stop Positive See 5A

Stop Positive See 6A Stop Positive See 6A

Stop Positive See 7A

Stop Positive See 1B

Stop Positive See 2A Stop Positive See 2A

Stop Positive See 3A Stop Positive See 3A

Stop Positive See 4A

Stop Positive See 7A

Stop Positive See 8A

Stop Positive See 12A Stop Positive See 12A

Stop Positive See 14A Stop Positive See 14A

Stop Positive See 17A Stop Positive See 17A

Stop Positive See 21A

Stop Positive See 22A Stop Positive See 22A

©2016, Mabbett Associates, Inc. Page 2 of 3

Table 4

Amount Units

Table 4 - Mabbett 2010 - Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

VISN 1

RISK

Hazard Category

1-4*

Sample No.

Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity Condition

25D Hallway - Drywall NAD - - - - 25E Hallway - Drywall NAD - - - - 26A Hallway - Joint Compound NAD - - - - 26B Foyer - Joint Compound NAD - - - - 26C Hallway - Joint Compound NAD - - - - 26D Hallway - Joint Compound NAD - - - - 26E Hallway - Joint Compound NAD - - - - 27A Hallway - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type II NAD - - - - 27B Hallway - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type II NAD - - - - 27C Hallway - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type II NAD - - - - 28A 119 - 2'x'2' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 28B 119 - 2'x'2' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 28C 119 - 2'x'2' White Ceiling Tile NAD - - - - 29A 13 Throughout Building Fire Door Insulation 5% Chrysotile, 25% Amosite 12 EA Good 4 29B 13 Throughout Building Fire Door Insulation 29C 13 Throughout Building Fire Door Insulation 30A 231 - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type III NAD - - - - 30B 237 - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type III NAD - - - - 30C 232 - 2'x4' Ceiling Tile Type III NAD - - - - 31A 206 Room 206- Kitchen 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II 2% Chrysotile 220 SF Good 4 31B 206 Room 206- Kitchen 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II 31C 206 Room 206- Kitchen 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II 32A 206 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II Mastic NAD - - - - 32B 206 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II Mastic NAD - - - - 32C 206 - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II Mastic NAD - - - - 33A Stairwell Stairwell 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III 2% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4 33B Stairwell Stairwell 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III 33C Stairwell Stairwell 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III 34A Stairwell - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III Mastic TR - - - - 34B Stairwell - 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III Mastic TR - - - - 34C Stairwell Stairwell 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III Mastic 2% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4 35A 204 - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35B Hallway - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35C 17 - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35D Hallway - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35E 128 - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35F Hallway - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 35G Hallway - Plaster Base Coat NAD - - - - 36A 204 - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36B Hallway - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36C 17 - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36D Hallway - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36E 128 - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36F Hallway - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 36G Hallway - Plaster Skim Coat NAD - - - - 37A Stairwell - Stair Tread Mastic NAD - - - - 37B Stairwell - Stair Tread Mastic NAD - - - - 37C Stairwell - Stair Tread Mastic NAD - - - - 38A Hallway Basement Foyer 9"x9" Black Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 150 SF Good 4 38B Hallway Basement Foyer 9"x9" Black Floor Tile 38C Hallway Basement Foyer 9"x9" Black Floor Tile 39A Hallway - 9"x9" Black Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 39B Hallway - 9"x9" Black Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 39C Hallway - 9"x9" Black Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 40A Hallway Throughout Basement 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile 3% Chrysotile 3,200 SF Good 4 40B Hallway Throughout Basement 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile 40C Hallway Throughout Basement 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile 41A Hallway - 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 41B Hallway Throughout Basement 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile Mastic 5% Chrysotile 3,200 SF Good 4 41C Hallway Throughout Basement 9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile Mastic 42A Hallway Throughout Basement Hard Block Pipe Insulation 10% Chrysotile, 20% Amosite 1,800 LF Good 4 42B Hallway Throughout Basement Hard Block Pipe Insulation 42C Hallway Throughout Basement Hard Block Pipe Insulation 43A Hallway Basement Front Hall to Stair 1'x1' White Ceiling Tile 5% Amosite 190 SF Good 1 43B Hallway Basement Front Hall to Stair 1'x1' White Ceiling Tile 43C Hallway Basement Front Hall to Stair 1'x1' White Ceiling Tile 44A Mechanical

Room - Gray Penetration Sealant NAD - - - - 44B Mechanical

Room - Gray Penetration Sealant NAD - - - - 44C Mechanical

Room - Gray Penetration Sealant NAD - - - - 45A Mechanical

Room - Red Firestop NAD - - - - 45B Hallway - Red Firestop NAD - - - - 45C Mechanical

Room - Red Firestop NAD - - - - 46A Hallway Throughout Basement Air Cell Pipe Insulation 50% Chrysotile 250 LF Good 4 46B Hallway Throughout Basement Air Cell Pipe Insulation 46C Hallway Throughout Basement Air Cell Pipe Insulation

Stop Positive See 29A Stop Positive See 29A

Stop Positive See 31A Stop Positive See 31A

Stop Positive See 33A Stop Positive See 33A

Stop Positive See 38A Stop Positive See 38A

Stop Positive See 40A Stop Positive See 40A

Stop Positive See 41B

Stop Positive See 42A Stop Positive See 42A

Stop Positive See 43A Stop Positive See 43A

Stop Positive See 46A Stop Positive See 46A

©2016, Mabbett Associates, Inc. Page 3 of 3

Table 4

Amount Units

Table 4 - Mabbett 2010 - Summary of ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

VISN 1

RISK

Hazard Category

1-4*

Sample No.

Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material Percent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity Condition

47A Hallway Throughout Basement Pressed Paper Pipe Insulation 5% Chrysotile 250 LF Good 4 47B Hallway Throughout Basement Pressed Paper Pipe Insulation 47C Hallway Throughout Basement Pressed Paper Pipe Insulation 48A Hallway Throughout Basement Fitting Insulation 60% Chrysotile 200 EA Good 4 48B Hallway Throughout Basement Fitting Insulation 48C Hallway Throughout Basement Fitting Insulation 49A Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile NAD - - - - 49B Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile NAD - - - - 49C Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile NAD - - - - 50A Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 50B Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 50C Dining Area - 12"x12" Cream Floor Tile Mastic NAD - - - - 51 Hallway 2nd Floor Ceiling Glue Daub 5% Chrysotile 500 SF Good 4 52 Basement - 1'x1' Fissured Ceiling Tile NAD - - - -

Notes:

NAD - No Asbestos Detected (PLM) TR - Trace SF - Square Feet EA - Each LF - Linear Feet CF - Cubic Feet

Stop Positive See 48A

* - The VISN 1 hazard assessment scale 1 – 4 is a relative indicator of the risk and need for response/remediation. (1) represents the highest priority (e.g. removal or encapsulation) whereas a (4) represents the lowest priority (monitor as part of 6 month O&M program). The rating, assigned by an Asbestos Management Planner, takes into account the following criteria:

condition, friable vs. non-friable, accessibility, occupancy (e.g. continuous, intermittent or occasional, patients/staff/visitors), potential for air erosion, potential for vibration damage, potential for disturbance/damage (e.g. exposed and in an accessible location), and potential for water damage.

Stop Positive See 47A Stop Positive See 47A

Stop Positive See 48A

Table 5

Amount Units 04B 04C

B20-14A 2016 ATC 125 Throughout Leveler/Black Mastic 4% Chrysotile 21,000 SF Good 4 01B 01C 02A 02B 02C 03A 127 03B 129 03C 237 04A 127 04B 129 04C 237 05A 05B 05C 06A 06B 06C 07A 07B 07C 08A 08B 08C 10A Stairwell 10B 225 10C 225 12A Stairwell 12B Foyer 12C Foyer 14A 14B 14C 17A 123 17B 133 17C 223 21A 21B 21C 22A 22B 22C 29A 29B 29C 31A 31B 31C 33A 33B 33C 34C 2010 Mabbett Stairwell North Stairs 12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III Mastic 2% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4 38A 38B 38C 40A 40B 40C 41B 41C 42A 42B 42C 43A 43B 43C 46A 46B 46C 47A 47B 47C 48A 48B 48C 51 2010 Mabbett Hallway 2nd Floor Ceiling Glue Daub 5% Chrysotile 500 SF Good 4

Notes:

NAD - No Asbestos Detected (PLM) TR - Trace SF - Square Feet EA - Each LF - Linear Feet CF - Cubic Feet

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Sampler

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Mabbett

Good 4

Sample Date

2016 Attic Throughout Sprinkler Pipe Thread Sealant TR Chrysotile 2,200 EA

Good 4Fitting Insulation 60% Chrysotile 200 EA

Air Cell Pipe Insulation 50% Chrysotile

Pressed Paper Pipe Insulation 5% Chrysotile 250 LF

250 LF Good 4

Good 4

Good 41,800 LF

Good 11'x1' White Ceiling Tile 5% Amosite 190 SF

Hard Block Pipe Insulation 10% Chrysotile, 20% Amosite

9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile 3% Chrysotile

9"x9" Red/Brown Floor Tile Mastic 5% Chrysotile 3,200 SF

12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type II 2% Chrysotile

9"x9" Black Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile

Good 4

3,200 SF Good 4

12"x12" Tan Floor Tile Type III 2% Chrysotile 80 SF Good 4

150 SF

Good 4

Good 4

Good 4

Good 4

80 SF

80 SF

220 SF

12 EA

9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile

Good 4

12"x12" Tan Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile

9"x9" Light Green Floor Tile 3% Chrysotile

Fire Door Insulation 5% Chrysotile,25% Amosite

Good 4

Good 4

Good 4

Good 4

400 SF

300 SF

9"x9" Brown Floor Tile 5% Chrysotile

12"x12" White Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 100 SF

9"x9" Dark Brown Floor Tile 5% Chrysotile 400 SF

300 SF Good 4

Good 4300 SF

Good 4300 SF

Good 4

10,000 SF

9"x9" Gray Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile 300 SF

9"x9" Gray Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile

9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile 10,000 SF Good 4

LF2,200Window Caulk

Good 4

Perimeter of Windows

VISN 1 RISK

Hazard

Category 1-4*

Door Caulk 2% Chrysotile 120 LF Damaged 3

Table 5 - Summary of All Positive ACM Building Survey Results Northampton VA Medical Center, Building 20

Sample No.

Sample Location ACM Location Description of Material ConditionPercent and Type of Asbestos

Estimated Quantity

Good

13 Throughout Building

Exterior Doors

Exterior 3% Chrysotile

9"x9" Light Brown Floor Tile Mastic 5% Chrysotile

9"x9" Tan Floor Tile 2% Chrysotile

103 Room 103 & 125

Rooms 123, 124, 133, 223, & 224

Room 112- Bathroom

Room 112- Bathroom

9"x9" Tan Floor Tile Mastic 10% Chrysotile

Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor

Throughout 1st & 2nd Floor

1st & 2nd Floor Hall

1st & 2nd Floor Hall

1st & 2nd Floor Hall

1st & 2nd Floor Hall

Basement FoyerHallway

Throughout BasementHallway

Hallway

Hallway

Hallway Throughout Basement

Stairwell

Hallway

Hallway

Hallway

Hallway

North Stairs & Room 225

Main Stair & 1st Floor Foyer

206 Room 206- Kitchen

North Stairs

* - The VISN 1 hazard assessment scale 1 – 4 is a relative indicator of the risk and need for response/remediation. (1) represents the highest priority (e.g. removal or encapsulation) whereas a (4) represents the lowest priority (monitor as part of 6 month O&M program). The rating, assigned by an Asbestos Management Planner, takes into account the following criteria: condition, friable vs. non-friable, accessibility, occupancy (e.g. continuous, intermittent or occasional, patients/staff/visitors), potential for air erosion, potential for vibration damage, potential for disturbance/damage (e.g. exposed and in an accessible location), and potential for water damage.

Throughout Basement

Hallway

Hallway

Throughout Basement

Basement Front Hall to Stair

Throughout Basement

Hallway Throughout Basement

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20 VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Figures

Figures

Northampton VAMC - Building 20 Asbestos Survey Rpt Northampton Bldg 20 VA Project No. 631-16-040 9 June, 2016 ©2016, Mabbett & Associates, Inc. Appendix A

Appendix A

Laboratory Analytical Reports

EMSL Analytical, Inc.

307 West 38th Street New York, NY 10018

Phone/Fax: (212) 290-0051 / (212) 290-0058 http://www.EMSL.com / manhattanlab@emsl.com

ATC62

031607875

11-81-0030

EMSL Order ID:

Customer ID:

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Attn:

Proj: 11-81-0030/ VA MEDICAL CENTER/ BUILDING 20

Phone: (413) 781-0070

Fax: (413) 781-3734

Collected: 3/20/2016

Received: 3/22/2016

Analyzed: 3/29/2016

Edward Kolodziej

ATC Group Services LLC

73 William Franks Drive

West Springfield, MA 01089

Summary Test Report for Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method via

Polarized Light Microscopy

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0001

ROOM 107/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01A-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0001A

ROOM 107/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01A-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0002

ROOM 217/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01B-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0002A

ROOM 217/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01B-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0003

ROOM 232/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01C-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0003A

ROOM 232/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01C-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0004

BASEMENT (FIREPLACE ROOM)/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01D-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Test Report:EPAMultiTests-7.30.8.a Printed: 3/29/2016 06:25AM Page 1 of 8

Phone/Fax: (212) 290-0051 / (212) 290-0058 http://www.EMSL.com / manhattanlab@emsl.com

ATC62

031607875

11-81-0030

EMSL Order ID:

Customer ID:

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Summary Test Report for Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method via

Polarized Light Microscopy

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0004A

BASEMENT (FIREPLACE ROOM)/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01D-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0005

MAIN STAIRWELL/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01E-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0005A

MAIN STAIRWELL/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01E-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0006

1ST FLOOR HALL (BY ROOM 135)/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01F-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0006A

1ST FLOOR HALL (BY ROOM 135)/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01F-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Brown/Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0007

ROOM 14/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01G-Skim Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0007A

ROOM 14/PLASTER CEILING

B20-01G-Rough Coat

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0008

BASEMENT ROOM 16/BLACK SINK UNDERCOAT

B20-02A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Black None Detected

Test Report:EPAMultiTests-7.30.8.a Printed: 3/29/2016 06:25AM Page 2 of 8

Phone/Fax: (212) 290-0051 / (212) 290-0058 http://www.EMSL.com / manhattanlab@emsl.com

ATC62

031607875

11-81-0030

EMSL Order ID:

Customer ID:

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Summary Test Report for Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method via

Polarized Light Microscopy

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0009

BASEMENT ROOM 13/BLACK SINK UNDERCOAT

B20-02B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 15% 85%PLM Black None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0010

BASEMENT ROOM 9/WHITE SINK UNDERCOAT

B20-03A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 2% 98%PLM White/Black None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0011

ROOM 108/BLACK COATING ON BRICK

B20-04A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Black None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0012

ROOM 219/BLACK COATING ON BRICK

B20-04B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 0% 100%PLM Black None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0013

ROOM 16/1'X1' WHITE PERFORATED CEILING TILE

B20-05A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 80% 20%PLM Brown/White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0014

ROOM 16/1'X1' WHITE PERFORATED CEILING TILE

B20-05B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 72% 28%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0015

ROOM 16/GLUE DAUB ASSOCIATED WITH 1'X1' CEILING TILE

B20-06A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 2% 98%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0016

ROOM 16/GLUE DAUB ASSOCIATED WITH 1'X1' CEILING TILE

B20-06B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 12% 88%PLM Brown Sample in same bag labeled "16B".None Detected

Test Report:EPAMultiTests-7.30.8.a Printed: 3/29/2016 06:25AM Page 3 of 8

Phone/Fax: (212) 290-0051 / (212) 290-0058 http://www.EMSL.com / manhattanlab@emsl.com

ATC62

031607875

11-81-0030

EMSL Order ID:

Customer ID:

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Summary Test Report for Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method via

Polarized Light Microscopy

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0017

BASEMENT ROOM 13/REINFORCED WINDOW GLAZING

B20-07A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Tan None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0018

BASEMENT ROOM 15/REINFORCED WINDOW GLAZING

B20-07B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 0% 100%PLM White None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0019

ROOM 235/SOFT CONCRETE FLOOR

B20-08A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Brown None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0020

2ND FLOOR HALL BY ROOM 213/SOFT CONCRETE FLOOR

B20-08B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016PLM Not Submitted

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0021

BASEMENT ENTRANCE LOBBY/1"X1" TAN CERAMIC FLOOR TILE THIN-SET/ ADHESIVE

B20-09A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Tan None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0022

BASEMENT ENTRANCE LOBBY/1"X1" TAN CERAMIC FLOOR TILE GROUT

B20-10A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0023

ROOM 125/CERAMIC FLOOR TILE GROUT

B20-11A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0024

ROOM 214/CERAMIC FLOOR TILE GROUT

B20-11B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 16% 84%PLM Gray None Detected

Test Report:EPAMultiTests-7.30.8.a Printed: 3/29/2016 06:25AM Page 4 of 8

Phone/Fax: (212) 290-0051 / (212) 290-0058 http://www.EMSL.com / manhattanlab@emsl.com

ATC62

031607875

11-81-0030

EMSL Order ID:

Customer ID:

Customer PO:

Project ID:

Summary Test Report for Asbestos Analysis of Bulk Material via EPA 600/R-93/116 Method via

Polarized Light Microscopy

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0025

ROOM 125/CERAMIC FLOOR TILE THIN-SET/ ADHESIVE

B20-12A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0026

ROOM 214/CERAMIC FLOOR TILE THIN-SET/ ADHESIVE

B20-12B

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/29/2016 0% 100%PLM Gray None Detected

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0027

ROOM 233 BATH/12"X12" FLOOR TILE MASTIC

B20-13A

DateTEST Non-Fibrous Asbestos CommentColor Fibrous

Non-AsbestosAnalyzed

03/28/2016 0% 96% 4% ChrysotilePLM Black

Client Sample ID:

Sample Description:

Lab Sample ID: 031607875-0028

ROOM…