Attachment10_USDA_NEPARegs_InterimRule_July2025.pdf
PDF 538 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- 1168154
- Issued by
-
Department of Agriculture Forest Service
About this file
This file is an interim final rule issued by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) modifying its National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) implementing regulations, effective July 3, 2025. The rule responds to the Council on Environmental Quality's rescission of its NEPA implementing regulations (effective April 11, 2025), statutory amendments to NEPA under the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, and the Supreme Court's decision in Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, Colorado (2025), which characterized NEPA as a "modest procedural requirement" and rejected its transformation into a substantive environmental roadblock. USDA consolidates and revises its department-level NEPA regulations at 7 CFR Part 1b to provide a uniform framework for all USDA subcomponents, eliminating the need for individual agency-specific NEPA regulations. The rule rescind regulations previously codified at 7 CFR Parts 372, 520, 650, 799, 1970, 3407, and 36 CFR Part 220, transferring relevant categorical exclusions and emergency action provisions to the revised 7 CFR Part 1b.
Key changes include establishing streamlined procedures for environmental assessments and environmental impact statements aligned with congressional mandates for deadlines and page limits; clarifying that NEPA does not apply to non-Federal actions or actions lacking significant Federal involvement or funding; introducing a "finding of applicability and no extraordinary circumstance" (FANEC) determination for categorical exclusions; eliminating requirements for draft environmental impact statements and formal responses to comments (focusing instead on documenting how substantive issues were addressed); and establishing best practices for efficient environmental reviews. The rule emphasizes that NEPA is purely procedural and does not mandate particular substantive outcomes. USDA provides a transition period allowing subcomponents discretion to continue applying prior procedures for proposals already in progress, while expecting application of revised 7 CFR Part 1b for new proposals and applications upon the final rule's effective date. The public comment period extends to July 30, 2025. The related federal contract opportunity is the Harris South Project Environmental Impact Statement, which involves timber harvest on Forest Service lands to achieve desired forest conditions and economic sustainability objectives.
View the file
Other files
Show all 15
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
<RULE>
<PREAMB>
[3410-90-P]
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
7 CFR Parts 1b, 372, 520, 650, 799, 1970, 2407
36 CFR Part 220
[USDA-2025-0008]
RIN 0503-AA86
National Environmental Policy Act
AGENCY: Agriculture (USDA).
ACTION: Interim final rule; request for public comment.
SUMMARY: This interim final rule modifies the U.S. Department of Agriculture
(USDA) regulations implementing the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and removes various USDA agency regulations for implementing NEPA. USDA is taking this action in response to the Council on Environmental Quality’s rescission of its NEPA implementing regulations (which USDA’s NEPA regulations were designed to supplement), statutory changes to NEPA, executive orders, and case law. Comments are voluntarily requested on this action to inform USDA’s decision-making.
DATES: This rule is effective [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN THE FEDERAL
REGISTER]. Comments concerning this rule must be received by July 30, 2025.
ADDRESSES: Comments, identified by USDA-2025-0008, should be sent via one of the following methods:
• Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov. Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
• Mail: USDA, 1400 Independence Ave. SW, Washington, DC 20250-0108.
Comments should be confined to issues pertinent to the interim final rule, explain
This document is scheduled to be published in the Federal Register on 07/03/2025 and available online at https://federalregister.gov/d/2025-12326, and on https://govinfo.gov the reasons for any recommended changes, and reference the specific section and wording being addressed, where possible. All timely comments will be placed in the record and be available for public inspection at https://www.regulations.gov, including any personal information provided. Do not submit any information you consider to be private, confidential business information, or other information whose disclosure is restricted by statute.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Scott Vandegrift, Chief
Environmental Review and Permitting Officer, Office of the Secretary, 202-720-5166, SM.OSEC.NRE.NEPA@usda.gov. Individuals who use telecommunications devices for the hearing-impaired may call 711 to reach the Telecommunications Relay Service, 24 hours a day, every day of the year, including holidays.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
On February 25, 2025, CEQ issued an interim final rule rescinding their regulations in response to Executive Order (E.O.) 14154, Unleashing American Energy.
CEQ’s interim final rule rescinded its NEPA implementing regulations, including
40 CFR parts 1500, 1501, 1502, 1503, 1504, 1505, 1506, 1507, and 1508. The effective date of CEQ’s interim rule was April 11, 2025. The background of CEQ’s regulations, recent litigation, and relevant executive orders leading up to their February 25, 2025, interim final rule support the rationale underlying this interim final rule.
The Department of Agriculture (USDA) is issuing this interim final rule to revise, move and republish, or remove portions of USDA’s existing regulations for implementing the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969, 42 U.S.C. §§
4321-4347, as amended by the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, as well as add new portions to the USDA NEPA implementing regulations for three independent reasons.
First, CEQ’s regulations were repealed effective April 11, 2025; see Removal of
National Environmental Policy Act Implementing Regulations, 90 Fed. Reg. 10610 (Feb.
25, 2025). USDA and its agencies’ regulations were promulgated as a “supplement” that
“incorporates and adopts” the CEQ’s NEPA regulations, see 7 CFR 1b.1(a). However, the CEQ regulations (40 CFR parts 1500 through 1508) no longer provide a valid foundation for USDA NEPA regulations. Second, Congress recently amended NEPA in significant part, in the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 (FRA), Public Law 118-5, signed on June 3, 2023, in which Congress added substantial detail and direction in Title
I of NEPA regarding procedural issues that CEQ and individual acting agencies had previously addressed in their own procedures. USDA recognized the need to update its regulations considering these significant legislative changes. Since USDA’s regulations were originally designed as a supplement to CEQ’s NEPA regulations, USDA had been awaiting CEQ action before revising its regulations, consistent with CEQ direction. See
40 CFR 1507.3(b) (2024); see also 86 FR 34154 (June 29, 2021). However, with CEQ’s regulations now rescinded, and with USDA’s NEPA implementing procedures still unmodified more than two years after this significant legislative overhaul, it is exigent that USDA move quickly to conform its procedures to the statute as amended. And third, the U.S. Supreme Court recently issued a landmark decision in Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, Colorado, 145 S. Ct. 1497 (2025), in which it decried the “transform[ation]” of NEPA from its roots as “a modest procedural requirement,” into a significant “substantive roadblock” that “paralyze[s]” “agency decision-making.” Id. at 1507, 1513 (quotations omitted). The Supreme Court explained that part of that problem had been caused by decisions of lower courts, which it rejected, issuing a “course correction” mandating that courts give “substantial deference” to reasonable agency conclusions underlying its NEPA process. Id. at 1513-14. But the
Court also acknowledged, and through its course correction sought to address, the effect on “litigation-averse agencies” which, in light of judicial “micromanage[ment],” had been “tak[ing] ever more time and [] prepar[ing] ever longer EISs [environmental impact statements] for future projects.” Id. at 1513. USDA incorporated this case’s holdings into these procedures, availing itself of the latest information and guidance from the Court for its future NEPA application.
These reasons now prompt USDA to publish this interim final rule to revise, move and republish, or remove portions of the USDA NEPA implementing regulations, as well as add new portions, given the CEQ NEPA regulations no longer provide a foundation for USDA NEPA regulations and leave the Department without necessary interpretation of, and implementing procedures for, NEPA. NEPA is a vital part of
Federal agency planning and decision-making, and USDA agencies need clear standards and guidelines as soon as possible to conduct the work of providing critical services and funds to Americans, as directed by Congress. Conducting a standard rulemaking process would impede USDA’s planning and decision-making for longer than necessary and would be impracticable and contrary to the public interest. For these reasons, USDA is using the interim final rule process. (Also see discussion under Section III. for additional rationale for using the interim rule process.)
National Environmental Policy Act
Congress enacted NEPA to declare a national policy “to use all practicable means and measures, including financial and technical assistance, in a manner calculated to foster and promote the general welfare, to create and maintain conditions under which man and nature can exist in productive harmony, and [to] fulfill the social, economic, and other requirements of present and future generations of Americans.” 42 U.S.C. 4331(a).
As amended by the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023, Public Law 118-5, NEPA furthers this national policy by requiring Federal agencies to prepare a “detailed statement” for proposed “major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment.” 42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C). This statement must address: (1) the reasonably foreseeable environmental impacts of the proposed agency action; (2) the reasonably foreseeable adverse environmental impacts that cannot be avoided; (3) a reasonable range of alternatives to the proposed agency action that are technically and economically feasible and meet the purpose and need of the proposal, including an analysis of any negative environmental impacts of not implementing the proposed agency action in the case of a no action alternative; (4) the relationship between local short-term uses of man’s environment and the maintenance and enhancement of long-term productivity; and (5) any irreversible and irretrievable commitments of resources that would be involved in the proposed action (or action alternatives). 42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C).
NEPA further mandates that Federal agencies ensure the professional and scientific integrity of environmental documents; use reliable data and resources when carrying out NEPA; and study, develop, and describe technically and economically feasible alternatives. 42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(D)-(F). NEPA provides procedures for making threshold determinations about whether an environmental document must be prepared and, if so, which type of environmental document. 42 U.S.C. § 4336(a)-(b).
NEPA identifies three levels of review – categorical exclusion, environmental assessment, and environmental impact statement. NEPA § 107, 42 U.S.C. § 4336a. A categorical exclusion is a “a category of actions that a Federal agency has determined normally does not significantly affect the quality of the human environment within the meaning of [NEPA] section 102(2)(C).” NEPA § 111(1), 42 U.S.C. § 4336e(1). An environmental assessment is a “concise” document “set[ting] forth the basis of [an] agency’s finding of no significant impact or determination that an environmental impact statement is necessary,” prepared in connection with a proposed agency action that does not have a significant impact or the significance of whose impact is unknown. NEPA §
106(b)(2), 42 U.S.C. § 4336(b)(2). An environmental impact statement is a detailed statement analyzing a proposed agency action with reasonably foreseeable significant impacts, governed by the provisions of NEPA §§ 102(2)(C), 106(b)(1); 42 U.S.C. §§
4332(2)(C), 4336(b)(1).
NEPA does not mandate particular results or substantive outcomes. Seven County, 145 S. Ct., at 1510. Rather, NEPA requires Federal agencies to consider the environmental effects of proposed actions as part of Federal agency decision-making processes. As amended by the Fiscal Responsibility Act, NEPA provides additional requirements to facilitate timely and unified Federal reviews, including provisions clarifying lead, joint lead, and cooperating agency designations, generally requiring the development of a single environmental document, directing agencies to develop procedures for proposal sponsors to prepare environmental assessments and environmental impact statements, and prescribing page limits and deadlines. NEPA §
107, 42 U.S.C. § 4336a. NEPA also sets forth the circumstances under which agencies may rely on programmatic environmental documents, NEPA § 108, 42 U.S.C. § 4663b, and adopt and use another agency’s categorical exclusions, NEPA § 109, 42 U.S.C. §
4336c.
II. Basis for Consolidating and Revising USDA’s NEPA Regulations
A. USDA NEPA Regulations
In 1974, the Secretary of Agriculture issued Memorandum No. 1695, Supplement 4 (Revised), to establish guidelines for the preparation of environmental impact statements and compliance with other procedural requirements of §102(2) of the
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). On May 1, 1979 (44 FR 25606) and July 30, 1979 (44 FR 44802), the Department of Agriculture (USDA) proposed and finalized rules setting forth policies and procedures for compliance with NEPA and the Council on
Environmental Quality’s (CEQ) implementing regulations (40 CFR parts 1500 through
1508). On occasion, the Department has further amended its NEPA regulations to refine and adjust to better meet its organizational and program needs. See 44 FR 44802, 46 FR
47747, 48 FR 11403, 60 FR 66481, 76 FR 4802.
USDA promulgated its current regulations in 1995 (60 FR 66481, Dec. 22, 1995), to “[supplement] the regulations for the implementation of the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA), for which regulations were published by the CEQ in 40 CFR parts
1500 through 1508 [and incorporate and adopt] those regulations.” Subtitle A, part 1b.1 of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 1b). USDA NEPA regulations were dependent upon provisions in the 1978 CEQ regulations. Similarly, individual USDA agency NEPA regulations expressly state that their “purpose” is to supplement and implement CEQ regulations:
1) Agricultural Research Service, subtitle B, chapter V, part 520, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 520): “These procedures incorporate and supplement, and are not a substitute for, CEQ regulations under
40 CFR parts 1500–1508, and Department of Agriculture NEPA Policies and
Procedures under 7 CFR part 1b.” (7 CFR 520.1);
2) Animal Plant Health and Inspection Service, subtitle B, chapter III, part
372, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 372): “These procedures implement section 102(2) of the National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) by assuring early and adequate consideration of environmental factors in
Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service planning and decision-making and by promoting the effective, efficient integration of all relevant environmental requirements under NEPA. The goal of timely, relevant environmental analysis will be secured principally by adhering to NEPA implementing regulations (40
CFR parts 1500–1508), especially provisions pertaining to timing (§ 1502.5), integration (§ 1502.25), and scope of analysis (§ 1508.25).” (7 CFR 372.1);
3) Farm Service Agency, subtitle B, chapter VII, subchapter G, part 799, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 799): “This part:
...(2) Establishes FSA procedures to implement the (i) National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969, as amended (42 U.S.C. 4321 through 4370); (ii)
CEQ regulations (40 CFR parts 1500 through 1518); and (iii) USDA NEPA regulations (§§ 1b.1 through 1b.4 of this title).” (7 CFR 799.1);
4) National Institute of Food and Agriculture, subtitle B, chapter XXXIV, part 3407, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 3407):
“The purpose of this regulation is to supplement the regulations for implementation of NEPA established by the CEQ and codified at 40 CFR parts
1500–1508, as adopted by USDA in 7 CFR part 1b.” (7 CFR 3407.1);
5) Natural Resources Conservation Service, subtitle B, chapter VI, subchapter F, part 650, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7
CFR 650): “The procedures included in this rule supplement CEQ’s NEPA regulations, 40 CFR parts 1500–1508. CEQ regulations that need no additional elaboration to address NRCS-assisted actions are not repeated in this rule, although the regulations are cited as references. The procedures include some overlap with CEQ regulations. This is done to highlight items of importance for
NRCS. This does not supersede the existing body of NEPA regulations.” (7 CFR
650.1);
6) Rural Development, subtitle B, chapter XVIII, subchapter H, part 1970, of title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations (hereinafter 7 CFR 1970): “This part also supplements the CEQ regulations implementing the procedural provisions of
NEPA, 40 CFR parts 1500 through 1508. To the extent appropriate, the agency will take into account CEQ guidance and memoranda.” (7 CFR 1970.1); and
7) U.S. Forest Service, chapter II, part 220, of title 36 of the Code of
Federal Regulations (hereinafter 36 CFR 220): “This part establishes Forest
Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) procedures for compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 (42 U.S.C. §§4321-4347) and the CEQ regulations for implementing the procedural provisions of NEPA
(40 CFR parts 1500 through 1508) ... This part supplements and does not lessen the applicability of the CEQ regulations and is to be used in conjunction with the
CEQ regulations and USDA regulations at 7 CFR part 1b.” (36 CFR 220.1).
Departmental and agency NEPA regulations have been largely organizational and technical, with limited substantive content. The Department’s past judgment has been that effective NEPA implementation could be achieved by reliance on a policy statement in 7 CFR 1b.2 and individual USDA agency NEPA regulations for tailored technical procedures. For the reasons described above, the Department now believes that a change is necessary to advance the Department’s mission in an efficient, flexible, and innovative manner while ensuring the conservation and protection of the environment.
USDA has analyzed how best to respond to the CEQ’s interim final rule and fulfill NEPA’s statutory requirements while allowing for efficient program implementation. In the Department’s judgment, given that NEPA is a procedural statute that simply directs consideration of reasonably foreseeable environmental impacts, it is sufficient for the Department to issue a set of uniform procedures, and it is not necessary for each agency with NEPA responsibilities across the Department to supplement the
Department NEPA regulations. Therefore, USDA is proposing to correct course and right-size its NEPA regulations consistent with applicable law.
B. USDA Agency-Specific NEPA Regulation Summaries
1. Statement of Purpose
USDA’s new NEPA implementing procedures, as adopted via this interim final rule, are a more faithful implementation of the statute as amended in 2023 than its old procedures. These procedures implement major structural features of the 2023 amendments, such as deadlines and page limits for environmental assessments and environmental impact statements, as directed at NEPA § 107(g), 42 U.S.C. § 4336(g), and provide that USDA will complete preparation of these documents within the maximum length and on the timeline that Congress intends. They incorporate Congress’s definition of “major Federal action” and the exclusions thereto, as codified at NEPA
§111(10), 42 U.S.C. § 4336e(10). They incorporate Congress’s mandated procedure for determining the appropriate level of review under NEPA, as codified in NEPA § 106, 42
U.S.C. § 4336. They incorporate Congress’s direction with respect to establishment, adoption, and application of categorical exclusions, as codified at NEPA § 111(10), 42
U.S.C. § 4336e(10). They provide procedures governing project-sponsor-prepared environmental assessments and environmental impact statements, as directed at NEPA §
107(f), 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(f). And they incorporate Congress’s revision to the requirements for what an agency must address in its environmental impact statements, as codified at NEPA § 102(2)(C), 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(C), and Congress’s requirement that public notice and solicitation of comment be provided when issuing a notice of intent to prepare an environmental impact statement, as directed at NEPA § 107(c), 42 U.S.C. §
4336a(c). All of these are crucial features of Congress’s policy design and its purpose in the 2023 amendments that NEPA review be more efficient and certain.
Moreover, all of these respond to the President’s directive in E.O. 14154; and all of these reflect the Supreme Court’s recent and unequivocal statement that NEPA is a purely procedural statute. The Department is conscious of the Supreme Court’s admonition that NEPA review has grown out of all proportion to its origins of a “modest procedural requirement,” creating, “‘under the guise’ of just a little more process,”
“[d]elay upon delay, so much so that the process seems to ‘borde[r] on the Kafkaesque.’”
Seven County, 145 S. Ct. at 1513-1514. These procedures, therefore, are intended to align
NEPA with its Congressionally mandated dimensions, reflecting the guidance given also by the President and the Supreme Court, and making review under it faster, more flexible, and more efficient.
In reaching this decision, USDA acknowledges that third parties may claim to have reliance interests in USDA’s existing NEPA procedures. But revised agency procedures will have no effect on ongoing NEPA reviews, where USDA, following CEQ guidance, has held it will continue to apply existing applications. Moreover, as the
Supreme Court has just explained, NEPA “is a purely procedural statute” that “imposes no substantive environmental obligations or restrictions.” Seven County, 145 S. Ct. at
1507. Any asserted reliance interests grounded in substantive environmental concerns are not in accord with the best meaning of the law and are entitled to “no… weight.” Dep’t of
Homeland Sec. v. Regents of the Univ. of California, 140 S. Ct. 1891, 1914 (2020).
Because reliance interests are inherently backward-looking, it is unclear how any party could assert reliance interests in prospective procedures. To the extent such interests exist, the Department holds that they are “outweigh[ed]” by “other interests and policy concerns.” Id. Namely, the complex web of regulations that preexisted the 2023 amendments to NEPA and the new Procedures repeatedly “led to more agency analysis of separate projects, more consideration of attenuated effects, more exploration of alternatives to proposed agency action, more speculation and consultation and estimation and litigation,” which in turn has meant that “[f]ewer projects make it to the finish line,” or even “to the starting line.” Seven County, 145 S. Ct. at 1513-14. This has increased the cost of projects dramatically, “both for the agency preparing the EIS and for the builder of the project,” resulting in systemic harms to America’s infrastructure and economy. Id.
Correspondingly, the wholesale revision and simplification of this regime, effectuated by these procedures, is necessary to ensure efficient and predictable reviews, with significant upsides for the economy and for projects of all sorts. This set of policy considerations drastically outweighs any claimed reliance interests in the preexisting procedures.
USDA has revised its NEPA implementing regulations to conform to the 2023 statutory amendments, to respond to President Trump’s direction in EO 14154 to, “[c]onsistent with applicable law, prioritize efficiency and certainty over any other objectives, including those of activist groups, that do not align with the policy goals set forth in section 2 of [that] order or that could otherwise add delays and ambiguity to the permitting process,” and to address the pathologies of the NEPA process and NEPA litigation as identified by the Supreme Court. Where USDA has retained an aspect of its preexisting NEPA implementing procedures, it is because that aspect is compatible with these guiding principles; where USDA has revised or removed an aspect, it is because that aspect is not so compatible.
2. General Overview of Changes
USDA is modifying the department-level NEPA regulations found at 7 CFR 1b to provide a valid foundation from which USDA mission areas, agencies, and staff offices
(or subcomponents) implement NEPA. 7 CFR 1b would primarily retain and move the placement of the following information currently contained in 7 CFR 1b and the individual agency NEPA regulations below: categorical exclusions, which includes a list of USDA agencies and offices excluded from completing an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement; and emergency action provisions. Some additional sections from agency-specific regulations are also retained, as described in the agency-specific regulation discussions listed below. Except for the information to be moved to the revised 7 CFR 1b regulation, the following individual agency NEPA regulations will be rescinded in full:
– Agricultural Research Service: 7 CFR 520;
– Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service: 7 CFR 372;
– Farm Service Agency: 7 CFR 799;
– National Institute of Food and Agriculture: 7 CFR 3407;
– Natural Resources Conservation Service: 7 CFR 650;
– Rural Development: 7 CFR 1970; and
– U.S. Forest Service: 36 CFR 220.
The following summaries capture additional specific changes that are occurring for each affected USDA regulation. For all regulations, references to CEQ’s rescinded
NEPA implementing regulations (40 CFR parts 1500 through 1508) were removed.
Where USDA agency NEPA regulations cited portions of the agency regulation that are now being rescinded, those references were also removed and revised to refer to the applicable section in the revised 7 CFR 1b regulation. Where USDA agency NEPA regulations used agency-developed terms, such as those associated with agency-developed forms and other document types, these have been generalized to allow for the application of consistent Department implementing procedures for NEPA. As discussed previously, USDA agencies will be able to issue agency-specific procedures through technical and program guidance that aligns with NEPA and the Department regulations at
7 CFR 1b.
3. USDA Departmental NEPA Regulations (7 CFR 1b)
USDA is revising the department-level NEPA regulations at 7 CFR 1b to provide necessary guidance and direction for implementing NEPA in the absence of the CEQ
NEPA implementing regulations, as rescinded effective April 11, 2025.
With the CEQ NEPA implementing regulations having been rescinded, USDA identified opportunities to reduce redundant and duplicative regulation revision efforts for agency-specific NEPA regulations and instead establish necessary direction at the department-level. This allows the Department to establish consistency across the subcomponents, where desired, in how NEPA is implemented.
The following provides a summary of what is included or being revised in each section of the department-level NEPA regulations, as well as the rationale for the changes.
7 CFR 1b.1 – Purpose: Previous paragraphs (a) and (b) in this section are removed. Paragraphs (a) through (d) are added and this section is now revised to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.1.
In this section, USDA removes reference to CEQ NEPA regulations at 40 CFR parts
1500 through 1508 and adds clarification of the purpose of the revised departmental
NEPA regulations. This section specifies the mission areas, agencies, and staff offices
(hereinafter USDA subcomponents or subcomponent) the part applies to.
7 CFR 1b.2 – Policy: Previous paragraphs (a), (b), (c), and (d) in this section are removed. Paragraphs (a) through (i) are added and this section is now revised to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.2. In this section, USDA outlines the Department’s policy on complying with NEPA and specifies roles and responsibilities at the Department for managing NEPA compliance. The Under Secretary of Natural Resources and
Environment continues to hold responsibility for ensuring overall Department compliance with NEPA. This section provides clarification on the issuance of agency-specific NEPA guidance for processes and practices that address agency-specific laws and program efficiency.
USDA adds requirements to this section to submit to Congress on an annual basis a report that identifies any environmental assessment and environmental impact statement that such lead agency did not complete by the deadline described in NEPA § 107(g), 42
U.S.C. § 4336a(g), as amended in 2023, and provide an explanation for failure to meet deadlines. Specifies USDA roles and responsibilities for completing this report.
This section adds the process for how USDA subcomponents will determine when
NEPA does not apply. Consideration of whether the action is a major Federal action is added, as the definition of major Federal action was added to NEPA, as amended by the
Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023. NEPA does not apply to “non-Federal actions”;
therefore, under the terms of the statute, NEPA does not apply to actions with no or minimal Federal funding, or with no or minimal Federal involvement where a Federal agency cannot control the outcome of the proposal. A but-for causal relationship is insufficient to make an agency responsible for a particular action under NEPA. See Dept.
of Transp. v. Pub. Citizen, 541 U.S. 752, 767 (2004). By the same token, minimal Federal funding or involvement, which may in a causal sense be a but-for cause of an action, does not by itself convert that action into a Federal action within the meaning of the language of the statute.
This section adds the process for how USDA subcomponents will determine the level of NEPA that applies. Where some agency-specific NEPA regulations identified categories of actions generally requiring an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement, these sections have not been carried forward into 7 CFR 1b. NEPA does not require the identification of categories of actions other than those actions that are categorically excluded from documentation in an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement when a Federal agency has determined the actions normally do not significantly affect the quality of the human environment within the meaning of NEPA § 102(2)(C), 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(C), NEPA § 111(1), 42 U.S.C. §
4336e(1)). Because the determination of no significance was made during the process of establishing the categorical exclusion, it is the consideration of whether an extraordinary circumstance exists that may preclude the use of the category (see 7 CFR § 1b.3(f)). In determining whether a categorical exclusion applies to a proposed action, and therefore does not require preparation of an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement, an agency should evaluate the action for extraordinary circumstances that indicate a normally excluded action is likely to have reasonably foreseeable significant adverse effect. Determinations of whether to prepare an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement should be based on the anticipated degree of effect, in accordance with NEPA, not on the type of action. An environmental assessment shall be prepared when a Federal agency finds that a categorical exclusion does not apply to an action and the action does not have a reasonably foreseeable significant impact on the quality of the human environment, or the significance of such effect is unknown (NEPA
§ 106(b)(2) (42 U.S.C. § 4336(b)(2); 7 CFR 1b.2(f)(iv)(A)) and 1b.5(a)). An environmental impact statement shall be issued when a Federal agency finds that a categorical exclusion does not apply and determines an action has a reasonably foreseeable significant impact on the quality of the human environment (NEPA §
106(b)(1)42 U.S.C. § 4336(b)(1); 7 CFR 1b.2(f)(iv)(B) and 1b.7(a)). This policy accurately reflects the statutory requirements of NEPA for determining the appropriate level of NEPA review (categorical exclusion, environmental assessment, or environmental impact statement).
This section also includes the new considerations for whether the effects of the proposed action (or alternatives) are significant (7 CFR 1b.2(f)(3)). When defining considerations for significance, USDA is using the concept of “affected environment” and a list of types of effects that include both short- and long-term effects, both beneficial and adverse effects, effects on public health and safety, economic effects, and effects on the quality of life of the American people.
With regards to the rationale the responsible official provides as to whether the degree of effect is significant, USDA is aligning considerations of significance with the statutory items that must be disclosed in an environmental impact statement, per NEPA §
102(2)(C)(i-v) (42 U.S.C. § 4332), such as disclosure of reasonably foreseeable environmental impacts (as both short- and long-term effects), consequences of not implementing the action, irreversible or irretrievable commitment of Federal resources, and long-term productivity of the human environment. Instead of leaving the list of types of effects as disparate disclosures, USDA finds it logical to bring these together when it comes to considerations for significance. The terms “compares to” and “contributes to,” as included in the considerations for significance, provide the necessary precision or focus for conducting the analysis of the effects and considering how the potential impacts compare to the consequences, especially as it relates to effects on public health and safety, economics, and the quality of life of the American people, as well as identifying irreversible and irretrievable commitments and how these contribute to loss of long-term productivity for the human environment. Outlining the significance considerations in this manner allows those conducting effects analysis to better focus on the issues to be analyzed in detail for reasonably foreseeable significant impacts and allows the responsible official to better communicate their rationale for deciding how to proceed and why.
Specifies that as part of USDA subcomponent decision-making, NEPA should be integrated with other environmental analyses to demonstrate compliance with other laws.
Also adds limitations on actions taken during the NEPA process.
7 CFR 1b.3 – Categorical Exclusions and Findings of Applicability and No
Extraordinary Circumstance: Revises the title of this section from “Categorical
Exclusions” to “Categorical Exclusions and Findings of Applicability and No
Extraordinary Circumstance”. Department-level categorical exclusions previously included in paragraph (a) of this section are moved to § 1b.4, with revisions occurring to these as described in the discussion of changes for § 1b.4. Previous paragraphs (b) and (c) in this section are removed. Paragraphs (a) through (j) are added and this section is now revised to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.3.
Adds procedures for establishing, revising, adopting, removing, and applying categorical exclusions, as well as relying on other agency categorical exclusion determinations.
Adds clarification that USDA subcomponents may use any of the categorical exclusions listed at 7 CFR 1b.4, as well as use non-USDA categories that were adopted by any other USDA subcomponent. The USDA NEPA regulations have always included
Department-wide CEs (now moved to § 1b.4). See 48 FR 11403 (March 18, 1983) and 60
FR 66481 (Dec. 22, 1995). Given the issuance of one set of departmental NEPA regulations to provide consistency for all USDA subcomponents implementing NEPA, the recission of agency-specific NEPA regulations, and the overlap of similar programs and activities across USDA mission areas and agencies, the Department finds it is appropriate for USDA subcomponents to apply the same categorical exclusions where it makes sense to do so for the actions proposed by the subcomponent.
Adds procedures for considering extraordinary circumstances, explanation of what constitutes an extraordinary circumstance, and clarification for how the subcomponent should proceed based on the determination of whether there are extraordinary circumstances. Clarifies an extraordinary circumstance means a unique situation exists in which actions that normally do not have significant impacts and are therefore categorically excluded from documentation in an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement, create uncertainty whether the degree of the impact is significant for the relevant resources considered (7 CFR 1b.11(a)(17)). Previously, some agencies had mandated lists of resources to consider for extraordinary circumstances while other agencies had no list. Adds a list of resources (based on the previously existing lists in some USDA agency-specific NEPA regulations) a responsible official may consider for extraordinary circumstances but does not mandate any of these must be considered. Considerations for extraordinary circumstances will be made at the responsible official’s sole discretion and determined on a case-by-case basis, considering the nature of the proposed action and the potentially affected environment. Adds clarification on what constitutes the existence of an extraordinary circumstance and specifies that effects analysis completed to demonstrate compliance with other applicable laws also can be relied on to determine no extraordinary circumstance exists.
Adds the concept of a finding of applicability and no extraordinary circumstance
(FANEC), which applies to all categorical exclusions. For those categories requiring
NEPA documentation, specifies that these determinations must be documented to demonstrate the appropriate use of the category, adequate consideration of extraordinary circumstances, and a determination that no extraordinary circumstance exists. Gives agencies flexibility on how to document these determinations so long as certain items are addressed. Clarifies documentation considerations for other applicable environmental laws and regulations and timing of action.
7 CFR 1b.4 – Categorical Exclusion of USDA Subcomponents and Actions:
Revises the title of this section from “Exclusion of Agencies” to “Categorical Exclusion of USDA Subcomponents and Actions”. Previous paragraphs (a) and (b) are combined into one paragraph, now paragraph (a), which is revised to read as indicated in 7 CFR
1b.4. This section is revised to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.4. Paragraphs (b), (c), and
(d) are added to this section.
Paragraphs (a) include the list of USDA subcomponents generally excluded from preparing an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement and adds general offices of the Department to this list.
The department-level categorical exclusions previously listed in § 1b.3 have been moved to paragraph (c) in this section. Examples of actions that fit the category were added to some of the department-wide categories, as further described under the agency-specific regulation changes discussed below. Some agencies had categorical exclusions that were duplicative of the department-wide categories or served as examples of those categories; therefore, these were removed as separate categories and added as examples of the department-wide categories where applicable.
Categorical exclusions previously codified in USDA agency-specific NEPA regulations are now consolidated under paragraphs (c) and (d) in this section. Any changes to the categorical exclusion language, as previously documented in agency-specific NEPA regulations, are discussed under the applicable agency-specific justification sections below. Other than these few modifications to categories, the majority of categories remain unchanged as originally promulgated and are simply moved from one section of USDA’s regulations to another. Categories are organized by those that do or do not require NEPA documentation. New numbering was assigned to each categorical exclusion to make it easier to reference categories across the Department as any USDA subcomponent may utilize the categorical exclusions listed in 7 CFR 1b.
Numbering includes acronyms at the end indicating the agency that initially established the category to help agency personnel more readily locate the categories they are likely to continue using frequently.
7 CFR 1b.5 – Environmental Assessments: This section is added to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.5.
Adds procedures for issuing environmental assessments. Reinforces the role of an environmental assessment (EA). Gives agencies flexibility on how to format the EA so long as certain items are addressed. Provides clarification on requirements for analysis of alternatives for an EA and reiterates the importance of deadline and page limit requirements from NEPA, as amended in 2023. Consideration of taking no action shall be included as part of the environmental impacts analysis to contrast the potential impacts of the proposed action, and any alternative(s) if developed, with the current condition and expected future condition if the proposed action or alternative were not implemented (7
CFR 1b.5(c)(2)(i)). This is necessary to inform aspects of the consideration of significance, as specified in 7 CFR 1b.2(f)(3).
States that subcomponents are to adhere to the statutory deadlines and publish an
EA “in as substantially complete form as is possible.” Requires responsible officials to certify that they made a good faith effort to satisfy the requirements in the statute.
Clarifies when seeking an extension to the deadline is appropriate. These new additions provide the Department’s policy on how it will apply the new statutory deadlines in 42
U.S.C. § 4336a(g) and page limits in 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(e). This policy is based on the rationale that NEPA is governed by a “rule of reason.” Dept. of Transp. v. Pub. Citizen, 541 U.S. 752 (2004). In establishing deadlines for the environmental assessment process in the 2023 revision of NEPA, Congress supplied the measure of that reason in NEPA §
107(g), 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(g). “Time and resources are simply too limited for us to believe that Congress intended” consideration under NEPA to extend indefinitely. Metro.
Edison Co. v. People Against Nuclear Energy, 460 U.S. 766, 776 (1983) (citing Vermont
Yankee Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519, 551 (1978)). Clarifies when it may be appropriate to publish a notice of intent to prepare an EA. Provides direction on making the EA available to the public.
7 CFR 1b.6 – Finding of No Significant Impact: This section is added to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.6.
Adds procedures for issuing findings of no significant impact. Reinforces the role of a finding of no significant impact (FONSI). Gives agencies flexibility on how to format the FONSI so long as certain items are addressed. Provides direction on making the FONSI available to the public, providing notifications, and timing of the action.
7 CFR 1b.7 – Environmental impact statements: This section is added to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.7.
Adds procedures for issuing environmental impact statements.
Reinforces the role of an environmental impact statement (EIS). Provides direction on lead agency responsibilities for publication of the notice of intent, and scoping if conducted, including how to address delays, pauses, or withdrawals regarding intent to prepare an EIS.
Adds clarity on the process for requesting comments during preparation of an EIS to align with statutory requirements in NEPA (§ 102(2)(C), 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(C);
(NEPA § 107(c), 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(2)(C)).
Specifies that a request for comment may be undertaken at any time that is reasonable in the process of preparing an EIS, as the publication of a draft EIS is no longer required. NEPA (the Act itself) does not require publication of a draft EIS, and filing a draft EIS with the Environmental Protection Agency and publishing the notice of availability in the Federal Register adds time and unnecessary process. Responsible officials still have the discretion to publish a draft EIS on a USDA website, along with any other pre-decisional materials that, in their judgment, may assist in fulfilling their responsibilities under NEPA and in facilitating the request for comments.
Reiterates that USDA subcomponents must ensure the process of obtaining and addressing comments and the publication of draft or pre-decisional materials must not cause the subcomponent to violate the Congressionally mandated deadline for completion of an EIS. Specifies that subcomponents shall consider comments and should address comments raising substantive issues or recommendations. Focuses the subcomponent on addressing comments by capturing the action the responsible official took in response to the issue raised or recommendation made. Recommends documentation of how comments were addressed should be included as an appendix in the EIS.
Requires electronic publication of substantive comments and provides an alternative course of action if USDA subcomponents do not have the capability or capacity to electronically publish comments.
Specifies that USDA subcomponents shall consider substantive comments but leaves discretion for addressing substantive comments in writing. There is no requirement in NEPA to address comments in writing; however, documentation of how comments were considered is highly encouraged to demonstrate the rationale for how the responsible official decides to proceed during the iterative development of the proposed action and action alternatives and the iterative analysis process. This documentation of how the responsible official proceeded and why is advantageous to demonstrating that decisions made during the iterative NEPA process are not arbitrary or capricious;
however, experience implementing the previous CEQ NEPA regulation requirement for responding to comments has demonstrated this process led to burdensome and time-consuming efforts that routinely prevented USDA subcomponents from meeting the 2-year deadline for completing an EIS, which is now mandated in NEPA § 107(g)(1)(A), 42 U.S.C. 4336a(g)(1)(A). Additionally, the approach to “response to comments” that has been employed by some USDA subcomponents was not always the most effective in that it did not focus on demonstrating the action the responsible official took in response to the substantive issue raised and/or recommendation made. In some cases, the “response to comments” documentation generated levels of paperwork that exceeded the page count of the environmental document itself, defying one of the key principles of NEPA to generate “better decisions, not better documents”. For this reason, this section also clarifies that if documentation is completed to demonstrate how comments were considered and addressed, the documentation should focus on capturing the actions taken, as specified at 7 CFR 1b.7(f)(2), to facilitate a more efficient and effective approach to demonstrating how the responsible official responded to the substantive issue raised and/or recommendation made to improve the decision made on how to proceed (for example, issues to be analyzed in detail, alternatives to be considered or analyzed, or the alternative selected for implementation).
Gives subcomponents flexibility on how to format the EIS so long as certain items are addressed. Eliminates some aspects of EIS formatting previously required in the
CEQ NEPA Implementing Regulations, such as the summary, table of contents, list of preparers, and index. These sections also add additional time and process that do not meaningfully inform decision-making and were more relevant when documents were primarily issued in hard copy instead of electronically.
Reiterates deadline and page limit requirements from NEPA, as amended in 2023.
Specifies the requirement to file the EIS with the Environmental Protection Agency is still the primary means for making the completed EIS available to the public, in addition to publishing the EIS on a USDA website. States that agency officials are to adhere to the statutory deadlines and publish an EIS “in as substantially complete form as is possible” and requires responsible officials to certify that they made a good faith effort to satisfy the requirements in the statute. Clarifies when seeking an extension to the deadline is appropriate. These new additions provide the Department’s policy on how it will apply the new statutory deadlines in NEPA § 107(g), 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(g) and page limits in
NEPA § 107(e), 42 U.S.C. § 4336a(e). This policy is based on the rationale that NEPA is governed by a “rule of reason.” Dept. of Transp. v. Pub. Citizen, 541 U.S. 752 (2004). In establishing deadlines for the environmental impact statement process in the 2023 revision of NEPA, Congress supplied the measure of that reason in NEPA § 107(g), 42
U.S.C. § 4336a(g). “Time and resources are simply too limited for us to believe that
Congress intended” consideration under NEPA to extend indefinitely. Metro. Edison Co.
v. People Against Nuclear Energy, 460 U.S. 766, 776 (1983) (citing Vermont Yankee
Nuclear Power Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S. 519, 551 (1978)).
7 CFR 1b.8 –Records of decision: This section is added to read as indicated in 7
CFR 1b.8.
Adds procedures for issuing records of decision. Gives subcomponents flexibility on how to format the record of decision (ROD) so long as certain items are addressed.
Specifies requirements to make the ROD available to the public and provide notification to certain parties.
Clarifies timing of action. Notwithstanding other statutory or regulatory requirements, there is no longer a requirement to delay implementation of the action once the Environmental Protection Agency has published the notice of availability for the EIS, the ROD has been made available to the public, and necessary notifications are provided.
7 CFR 1b.9 – Efficient and effective environmental reviews: This section is added to read as indicated in 7 CFR 1b.9.
Adds best practices for efficient and effective environmental reviews.
Provides best practices for managing the proposal record. Includes recommendations for assembling and managing documentation developed during the environmental review process, responding to Freedom of Information Act requests, managing potential withholdings and privileges, and managing classified information.
Outlines best practices for reducing paperwork. For clarity, USDA has revised its usage of the terms “tiering” and “adopting,” which were described in the now rescinded
CEQ NEPA Implementing Regulations. The term “rely” or “relying” is used (instead of adopting) as this is the term used in NEPA when referring to programmatic documents
(NEPA § 108; 42 U.S.C. 4336b) and expands the original concept of “adopting” (now relying) to include not only whole environmental documents but also portions thereof, to include supporting analysis that may not be included in an environmental, finding, or decision document in whole. To avoid confusion with NEPA § 109, the term “adopting” is only used in reference to adopting another Federal agency’s categorical exclusions (the subject of NEPA § 109) and is no longer used in the context of adopting analyses.
Additional clarification is provided regarding reliance on programmatic documents, to align with language added to NEPA, as amended in 2023. The terms “incorporating” or
“incorporating by reference” continue to apply and are included in the regulations.
Outlines best practices for reducing delay.
Emphasizes the importance of interdisciplinary…
This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .