Tally Sheet _ RFP 25_005 Fire Station 2 Build.xlsx

This is a bid evaluation tally sheet for RFP 25-005 Fire Station 2 Buildout project, evaluating proposals from two companies: Skye Construction and Davko Services. The evaluation was conducted using a 100-point scoring system across four main categories: Background/Experience (20 points), References (10 points), Approach to Project (20 points), and Overall Cost & Pricing (50 points). The scores represent averages from four evaluators identified as DP, DA, JS, and AS.

The pricing submitted shows Skye Construction with a base price of $384,056 and Davko Services with $540,096. Skye Construction scored higher overall with 79.75 points compared to Davko Services' 65.25 points, performing better in all categories except References, where both companies received full points. The most significant scoring difference was in the Overall Cost & Pricing category, where Skye Construction received 37.5 points compared to Davko's 25 points, reflecting their lower bid price.