SCRSRF CMGC EvaluationScoreMatrix ITA.xlsx

This document is an evaluation score matrix for a Construction Manager/General Contractor (CM/GC) solicitation issued by an unnamed public agency for the South Coast Regional Seismic Ready Facility project (RFP Number S-73000-00006520). The evaluation process included five team members who scored proposals across multiple criteria categories, conducted interviews with shortlisted firms, and evaluated cost submissions. Two contractors advanced to the final evaluation phase: Gerding Builders and Bremik Construction. The evaluation encompassed technical criteria including general construction experience, CM/GC experience, specialized building types, project team qualifications, pre-construction and construction service plans, and project scheduling with a maximum proposal score of 215 points. Interview evaluations were conducted separately with a maximum score of 150 points.

Gerding Builders was selected as the highest-ranked firm with a final score of 365 points, combining proposal (164 points), interview (122 points), and cost (79 points) evaluations. Gerding Builders submitted a Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) of $38,000,000 with total CM/GC costs of $4,789,275, including preconstruction services of $122,050, a CM/GC fee of $1,425,000 (3.75%), bonding and insurance of $672,600 (1.77%), and general conditions of $2,569,625. Bremik Construction ranked second with a final score of 326 points and submitted a lower total CM/GC cost of $4,541,964 with an identical GMP of $38,000,000, but received a higher cost score (99 versus 79) due to reduced line-item costs across preconstruction services, CM/GC fees, and general conditions.