RFB 8669 Proposal Summary.xls

This is a proposal summary for RFB 8669 issued by the State of Wisconsin for masonry repairs to the John Catlin Chapel at Forest Hill Cemetery in Madison. The project involves repairs to historic Madison sandstone interior walls that have undergone deterioration due to moisture issues. The scope of work includes redressing existing sandstone in situ, removing and replacing salvageable sandstones, replacing severely deteriorated stones with new glacier buff limestone, installing pins and strap anchors for wall stabilization, and repointing mortar joints in repair areas. The specific bid line items consist of replacing 26 stones with removal of 6 stones and inspection and reset work, as well as redressing in situ work on 32 stones at a unit price basis. The proposal was dated October 6, 2017.

Four vendors submitted proposals for the project: A&M Masonry, B&B Quality Building Restoration of Wisconsin, Made by Greer Construction, and RD Woods. A&M Masonry was selected as the winning proposer with a total bid of $22,495.00, which included $16,895.00 for the stone replacement and inspection work and $5,600.00 for the redressing in situ work at $175.00 per unit. B&B Quality Building Restoration of Wisconsin, identified as a local vendor, submitted the second-lowest proposal at $23,100.00. The local vendor factor adjustment of $22,869.00 was applied in the evaluation process. Made by Greer Construction and RD Woods submitted bids of $26,420.00 and $42,300.00 respectively, with RD Woods providing no unit pricing for the redressing work.