Attachment 4 Environmental Impact Analysis (2021).pdf

AF IMT 813, 19990901, V1 THIS FORM CONSOLIDATES AF FORMS 813 AND 814 PAGE OF

PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF FORMS ARE OBSOLETE

REQUEST FOR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ANALYSIS

Report Control Symbol

RCS:

SECTION I - PROPONENT INFORMATION

1) TO: (Environmental Planning Function) 2) FROM: 2a) Telephone No.:

3) TITLE OF PROPOSED ACTION:

4) PURPOSE AND NEED FOR ACTION: (Identify decision to be made and need date)

See continuation sheet

5) DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED ACTION AND ALTERNATIVES (DOPAA) (Provide sufficient details for evaluation of the total action)

See continuation sheet

6) PROPONENT APPROVAL: (Name and Grade) 6a) SIGNATURE: 6b) DATE:

SECTION II PRELIMINARY ENVIRONMENTAL SURVEY. (Check appropriate box and describe potential environmental effects including cumulative effects) (+ = Positive Effect; 0 = No Effect; - = Adverse Effect; U = Unknown Effect)

+ 0 - U

7) AIR INSTALLATION COMPATIBLE USE ZONE/LAND USE (Noise, accident potential, encroachment, etc.)

8) AIR QUALITY (Emissions, attainment status, state implementation plan, etc.)

9) WATER SOURCES (Quality, quantity, source, etc.)

10) SAFETY AND OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH (Asbestos/radiation/chemical exposure, explosives safety quantity-distance, etc.)

11) HAZARDOUS MATERIALS/WASTE (Use/storage/generation, solid waste, etc.)

12) BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES (Wetlands/floodplains, flora, fauna, etc.)

13) CULTURAL RESOURCES (Native American burial sites, archaeological, historical, etc.)

14) GEOLOGY AND SOILS (Topography, minerals, geothermal, Installation Restoration Program, seismicity, etc.)

15) SOCIOECONOMIC (Employment/population projections, school and local fiscal impacts, etc.)

16) OTHER (Potential impacts not addressed above)

SECTION III ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS DETERMINATION

17) PROPOSED ACTION QUALIFIES FOR CATEGORICAL EXCLUSION (CATEX) # _______________; or

PROPOSED ACTION DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR A CATEX; FURTHER ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS IS REQUIRED

18) REMARKS:

19) ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING FUNCTION

CERTIFICATION:

19a) SIGNATURE: 19b) DATE:

ALBA.TIMOTHY.WARR

EN.1236235072

Digitally signed by

ALBA.TIMOTHY.WARREN.1236235072

Date: 2021.01.08 15:27:34 -08'00' 08-Jan-21Timothy Alba, GS-13

Demolition of Vandenberg Chapel (B13022) (XUMU131066)

(805) 606-1932

Tracy Curry, GS-12, Environmental Planner 03-Mar-21

813-21-009

✔ A2.3.8

30 CES/CENPD30 CES/CEIEA

1 4

Project qualifies for the following CATEX. Follow all comments attached, if anything changes the project may not still qualify for a CATEX.

AF FORM 813 CONTINUATION SHEET

1. Project Name:

Demolition of Building 13022

2. Project Number:

XUMU131066

3. Title of Proposed Action

Demolition of Vandenberg Chapel (B13022)

4. Purpose and Need for Action:

The purpose of the action is to demolish an abandoned structure that was built in 1942 and has outlived its life cycle.

AFMAN 32-1084 supports the divesting of inadequate buildings that are in excess to mission requirements. This action will result in enhanced base bea tification.

5. Description of Proposed Action and Alternatives (DOPAA):

Building 13022 is a wood structure built in 1942 on a post and beam foundation and is estimated to be 4,900 square feet.

The demolition of this facility will include removal of all ACM material by a licensed asbestos abatement contractor as stated in asbestos inventory by Tetra Tech EM Inc 2008-2009 survey.

The demolition of this facility will include the wood structure, post and beam foundation, basement, surrounding vegetation, irrigation system, and approximately 2148 square feet of surrounding concrete walkways. All utilities serving the facility will be cut and capped as close to the building as possible and abandoned in place. The main-line of the irrigation system will be cut and capped.

All ground depression resulting from demolition process will be filled with approved material to match existing grade and hydro-seeded with an approved seed mix to blend with the surrounding environment.

5.1.

5.2.

5.3.

Location and Site Map:

See Attachment 1

Construction Footprint:

See Attachment 1

Construction Schedule:

This is scheduled for FY21

5.4. Ground Disturbance:

Ground disturbance will result from the removal of the building foundation, surrounding concrete sidewalks/ paving vegetation removal and the capping of utilities serving the facility.

5.5. Construction Equipment:

Construction equipment include small excavator equipment, backhoe , loading equipment dump trucks and small graders.

AF FORM 813, AUG 93 (EF-V1) (PerFORM PRO) THIS FORM CONSOLIDATES AF FORMS 813 AND 814 PAGE 2 OF __4___ PAGES

AF FORM 813, AUG 93 (EF-V1) (PerFORM PRO) THIS FORM CONSOLIDATES AF FORMS 813 AND 814 PAGE 3 OF __4___ PAGES

AF FORM 813, SEP 99, CONTINUATION SHEET

5.6. Fill material:

Fill material could be crushed rock for deep depressions and capped with an approved growing medium to matching adjacent grade for planting, hydro-seeding.

5.7. Vegetation Disturbance:

Surrounding planted vegetation associated with this facility will be removed. Disturbed areas will be graded to match surrounding grades and hydro-seeded with an approved material.

5.8.

5.9.

5.10.

5.11.

5.12.

5.13.

5.14.

5.15.

5.16.

Demolition of Load-bearing Walls: N/A Asbestos and Lead-based Paint Remediation: Yes – See attached report by Tetra Tech EM Inc 2008-2009 Corrosion Methods: N/A Coatings and Sealants: N/A Fluorescent Light Fixtures and Ballast Removal: N/A Identification and Removal of Polychlorinated Biphenyl (PCB): N/A Hazardous Materials: See Tetra Tech EM Inc. 2008-2009 report.

Hazardous Wastewater Generation: N/A Industrial Wastewater Produced: N/A

It is not expected that industrial wastewater will be produced during this project. Contractor activities will be monitored, and if the issue arises, mitigation measures will be developed.

5.17. Solid Waste Management:

The contract between the U.S. Government and Contractor will describe in detail how solid waste generated during normal construction activities will be handled. Generally, solid waste is hauled off site by the Contractor. If required, log books can be developed identifying all types of solid waste listing quantity, unit of measure, and the disposal site

Alternatives:

CoA 1: Status Quo – This building will remain abandoned and continue to deteriorate.

CoA 2: Remove the facility which supports base bea tification and the divesting of inadequate buildings that are in excess to mission requirements.

AF FORM 813, AUG 93 (EF-V1) (PerFORM PRO) THIS FORM CONSOLIDATES AF FORMS 813 AND 814 PAGE 4 OF __4___ PAGES

AF FORM 813, SEP 99, CONTINUATION SHEET

7. Coordinating Agency Official Comments:

Per AF332 documentation, the following Notes and Comments were made:

Alarcon, Christian E-5 – Bio-Environmental (11/17/2012) Valid work

Weller, Darlene CTR – Communications (12/7/2012 Valid work, AF 103 required

Curry, Tracy CIV – Environmental (12/13/2012) Valid work. 813 and 103 required.

Please provide a map of where this building is located (11/30/2012)

Sassenberg, Paul GS-9 – Base Plans (11/29/2012) Valid work

Griswold, Kenneth GS-13 – Facility Excellence (11/29/2012) Valid work Recommend running this past 30 CES/CEANC, Jim Carruci, to verify historical significance of facility (older than 50 years) (12/5/2012)

Guerrero, Kerrie CTR – Real Property (12/11/2012) Valid work Real Property will require 180 days before demo for relocation of occupants and for HUD reporting (N/A)

Hansen, Patrick GS-11 – Safety/Ground (11/15/2012) Valid work

Weller, Darlene CTR – Coordinating Agency Official (12/7/2012) Comm needs time to remove cables and equipment from building. Please give 2-week notice before demo starts

Leveck, Samuel CIV – Planner/Estimator (12/13/2012) Recommend Project

This project includes all demolition, site work, site blending improvements, disposal, and all other supporting work necessary to make a complete and useable project.

Attachment 1

30 CES/CEIE ENVIRONMENTAL COMMENT FORM

DOCUMENT AUTHOR: 30 CEI Staff DOCUMENT TITLE: PROJECT NAME:

COMMENTOR: Multiple DATE OF COMMENTS:

ITEM

NO. STAFF COMMENT

1 Ryan/Loetzerich (Cultural) 805-605-0748 / 805-606-9687

Section 106 complete. However, if any changes to the design of the project are made with the potential to affect a historic property, or, project implementation results in a discovery during construction, VAFB will re-open Section 106 consultation for this project."

2 Evans (Natural) 805-606-4198

Any trenches or holes left open must be properly covered or have a ramp in place to prevent the entrapment of animals. No additional NR concerns.

3 Lum (Wetlands) 805-606-5299

Coordinate on native plant seed mix for appproval.

4 Harding (Air) 805-606-6863

As described this project is not expected to cause an exceedance of any federal or state ambient air quality standard. Project must be accomplished in accordance with all federal, state and local air quality requirements. All combustion equipment must comply with the applicable CARB air toxic control measures.

5 Wiskowski (Clean Water Act 401,402) 805-606-7541

See attached water comments below

6 Kalata (Drinking Water/ Wastewater/) 805-605-0342

Any activity that may require the installation, replacement, or affect the proper operation, inspection, testing, or repair of backflow prevention assemblies shall require the approval and coordination of the Vandenberg Cross Connection Control and Backflow Prevention Program Manager (Backflow Manager), Mr. Robert Coward, 30 CES/CEOIU, 805-606-5885.

7 Naputi (Tanks/ Greenhouse gases/Ozone Depleting Substances) 805-606-2068

No comments

8 Narciso (Hazardous Materials) 805-605-7573

Contractors and sub-contractors must submit all hazardous materials including pesticides or herbicides with current Safety Data Sheet (SDS) for registration and approval thru HAZMART Environmental Support, Bldg 5500, Bay "C", Room 10, and telephone number (805) 605-3870, 605-3976 or 605-7573. Current SDS must be a least earlier than five years old. References: AFI 32- 7086, VAFB Air permit, EO 13423 and 40 CFR Part 372, Section 313.

9 Carson (Hazardous & Solid Waste) 805-606-2359

Low-level hazardous waste (Light ballasts, bulbs, and mercury thermostats) will be generated as a result of this demo. Contact the 30 CES/CEI HW P.M. (606-2359) for management and disposal assistance. ACM management, waste-profiles, and off-base transport and disposal must also be approved/coordinated under the VAFB HW Program. No exceptions.

ITEM

NO. STAFF COMMENT

10 Newberry (Asbestos/ Lead Based Paint) 805-605-0408

The ACM survey in the file was a snapshot of the HMMIS file not the complete survey. Please use the complete Tetra Tech survey I added to the file as this will need to be used by the ACM abatement contractor. Renovations and demolitions require permits. Asbestos abatement and demolition activities are a permitted processes! Asbestos disturbance, abatement, and demolition work orders, work clearances, and projects must be reviewed by 30 CES/CEIEC. These processes are regulated by 40 CFR 61 the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Materials (NESHAP) and the Santa Barbara Air Pollution Control District (SBAPCD). Other regulations that affect projects are OSHA and Cal-OSHA asbestos standards in 29 CFR Parts 1910, 8 CCR, 29 CFR 1926, and 40 CFR 763 for asbestos materials in schools and banned asbestos. Under NESHAP and SBAPCD, prior to commencement of a renovation or demolition project, the area shall thoroughly be inspected for the presence of asbestos.

Also prior to project start, all regulatory notifications and abatement plans must be reviewed by 30 CES/CEIEC. You must also provide 30 CES/CEIEC a copy of the approved SBAPCD Notification for Renovation and Demolition form ENF-28.

11 Atta (Installation Restoration Program/Military Munitions Response Program) 805-605-7249

NO IRP or MMRP issue

12 Curry/Kaisersatt (Environmental Planners) 606-2044/605-0392

The proponent for this action is responsible for implementing all applicable management requirements identified in the referenced Environmental comments attached. If the proponent is unable to accommodate these requirements, the proposed action will require additional environmental analysis and this CATEX will not apply.

Comments, Demolition of Chapel 2 (B13022) 813 21-009

Implement Best Management Practices (BMPs) to prevent soil, chemicals or other pollutants from entering into the storm water system, natural surface water drainages or groundwater. BMPs will include erosion and sediment controls, storm drain inlet protection, tracking controls, vehicle and equipment fueling and maintenance, spill prevention and control, solid waste management, liquid waste management, concrete waste management, stockpile management and septic waste management as applicable. BMPS shall be effectively implemented and maintained as described in a current California Stormwater BMP Manual (California Stormwater Quality Association or similar).

1.1.1 - CONTAIN ALL CONSTRUCTION TRASH. PROPERLY DISPOSE OF ANY TRASH AS SOLID WASTE.

1.1.2 - ANY NON-BIODEGRADABLE SEDIMENT CONTROLS SHALL BE REMOVED PRIOR TO PROJECT CLOSE-OUT.

Exposed soils shall be permanently stabilized with vegetation to prevent erosion.

Prepare soil prior to any revegetation efforts. The soil surface shall be loosened and amended as needed to sustain plant life or weed-free topsoil added to a sufficient depth to allow for seed germination. Apply weed-free wood fiber mulch covering 80% of soil surface. Use irrigation as needed to achieve germination as appropriate for the seed mix and the season.

Begin maintenance immediately after seeding or vegetation has been installed. Inspect the vegetation at least once a week and perform needed maintenance promptly. Water, reseed, mulch and perform other operations necessary to promote plant growth and vigor, establish self-sustaining vegetation and prevent bare soil spots. Bare spots shall not be in areas subject to significant erosion. Repair erosion in all seeded areas. Eroded areas may need to be filled with amended topsoil and replanted with the same plant species. Maintain the performance of erosion control materials and protect installed areas from traffic.

Tara Wiskowski 30 CES/CEIEC Water Resources 805-606-7541

ASBESTOS SURVEY REPORT

FOR

VANDENBERG AIR FORCE BASE, CALIFORNIA

BUILDING NO. 13022

Prepared for:

Mr. Joseph Naputi

30 CES/CEVCC

1028 Iceland Avenue Vandenberg Air Force Base, California 93437-6010

Ms. Carol Cromer

CESAM-EN-GE

U.S. Army Engineer District, Mobile Post Office Box 2288

Mobile, Alabama 36628-0001

Prepared by:

TETRA TECH EM, INC.

10860 GOLD CENTER DR. SUITE 200

RANCHO CORDOVA, CALIFORNIA 95670

Contract No. FA4890-04-D-0006, ECAS Log No. 658, Task Order CK 18, FY08 Environmental Compliance and Miscellaneous Technical Support for AFSPC

January 23, 2009 i

CONTENTS

Section Page

1.0 SITE STRUCTURE

2.0 FINDINGS

3.0 ASSUMPTIONS AND DEVIATIONS

APPENDICES

Appendix

A FIGURES

B PHOTOLOG

C LABORATORY REPORTS AND CHAIN-OF-CUSTODY FORMS

TABLES

Table

1 ACM SAMPLE SUMMARY

2 NON-ACM SAMPLE SUMMARY

1.0 SITE STRUCTURE

Building 13022 is a single-story, approximately 4,196 sq. ft. structure. The building is constructed of a wood frame on a stone base. Interior finishes include drywall walls. Flooring materials include carpet, sheet vinyl flooring, and floor tile with associated mastic. Bathrooms have ceramic tile on the walls and floors.

The building was split up into three areas; the main chapel, the choir loft and the basement. The main choir loft includes a kitchen, offices, a chapel, and bathrooms. The choir loft is a small seating area above the main chapel on the north side of the building. The basement is below the main chapel in the southwest corner of the building and is accessible from the exterior of the building. Homogenous materials were identified in each section and sampled accordingly.

2.0 FINDINGS

Twelve homogenous materials were identified in the assessment areas with a total of 16 samples being analyzed by the laboratory. Samples that exceed the EPA-defined asbestos containing material (ACM) level of 1.0% by polarized light microscopy (PLM) testing are summarized in Table 1 for all areas. Table

2 identifies all samples taken in each area that according to laboratory results do not contain asbestos.

The laboratory report shown in Appendix C contains the PLM results for all the suspect ACM samples collected from the building.

TABLE 1

ACM SAMPLE SUMMARY

Sample No. Material Description

Material Locations and Room Condition (G, P, or

S)

Analytical Result

(% ACM)

Quantity (Sq. Ft.

or Lin. Ft.)

Friable (Yes/No)

Material Condition (G, P, or S) and Potential for

Disturbance (L, M, or H)

NA TSI Basement area – G PACM 50 Lin. Ft. Yes P - M

NA 9x9 Floor Tile Choir loft and main chapel area – G PACM 300 Sq. Ft. No G – L

Notes:

ACM Asbestos-containing material PACM Presumed Asbestos-containing material Sq. Ft. Square feet Lin Ft Linear feet NA Not applicable G Good Condition P Poor Condition S Significant Damage L Low Possibility of Disturbance M Medium Possibility of Disturbance H High Possibility of Disturbance

Based on survey observations or the sample analytical results, Tetra Tech recommends removal of all

ACM listed in Table 1 by a licensed asbestos abatement contractor before any work disturbs the materials. If the ACM is not disturbed during any renovation processes, the ACM may be left in place.

TABLE 2

NON-ACM SAMPLE SUMMARY

Figure ID Number* Sample No. Material

Description Analytical Result

(% ACM)

1 V13022-1-K--NW-SC-001 Skim Coat ND 2 V13022-1-K-NW-SC-002 Skim Coat ND 3 V13022-1-K-NW-SC-003 Skim Coat ND 4 V13022-1-K-NW-JC-001 Joint Compound ND 5 V13022-1-K-NW-JC-002 Joint Compound ND 6 V13022-1-K-NW-JC-003 Joint Compound ND 7 V13022-1-K-NW-CBM-001 Cove Base Mastic ND 8 V13022-1-K-SU-001 Sink Undercoat ND 9 V13022-1-F-SF-CA-001 Carpet Adhesive ND

10 V13022-1-WB-EF-CRG-001 Ceramic Tile Grout ND 11 V13022-1-B-DW-001 Drywall ND 12 V13022-1-K-NW-CB-001 Cove Base ND 13 V13022-1-WB-EF-CR-001 Ceramic Tile ND 14 V13022-1-1R-EF-LIN-001 Linoleum ND

Notes:

ACM Asbestos-containing material ND Non-Detect for Asbestos

* This ID number corresponds to the ID numbers listed on the figure identifying were the sample was taken.

Based on these sample analytical results, Tetra Tech recommends no further action be taken if the non-

ACMs listed in Table 2 are disturbed.

3.0 ASSUMPTIONS AND DEVIATIONS

The following suspect and/or assumed ACMs were identified but not sampled for one or more of the following reasons: limitations on access; limitation on destructive sampling in a specific area because of use; prospect of damage unable to be repaired, thus leaving the possibility of a future asbestos fiber release; or previous analytical reports identifying the material as containing asbestos (PACM).

• Destructive Sampling Limitations: Paper (vapor barrier) under the wood floors in the main chapel area, and possible electrical wiring wrap throughout all areas of the building (safety issue).

• PACM: Thermal system insulation (TSI) in the basement area on the air ducts, and 9x9 floor tile in the offices under the carpet of the main choir area and under the carpet in the choir loft.

The roof was not accessible, but appeared to be covered with wood.

Samples of the suspect ACMs not sampled during this survey should be taken by a licensed asbestos inspector, prior to any disturbance of the materials to determine if the material contains asbestos.

APPENDIX A

FIGURES

Figure 1 Building 13022

X :\S

\0

0\

FH

\F ig ur e1 _1

.F H

Asbestos Survey Vandenberg Air Force Base near Lompoc, California

Date: 01/05/09 Drawn By: Ingrid Tobar Project No: 103I0770.001

Annex

Not to Scale

LobbyKitchenCloset

Storage Office

Basement below

PACM (TSI)

Stairwell

Infant Room

RestroomFoyerRestroom

Choir Loft Above (PACM - 9x9 floor tile)

PACM

(9x9 floor tile)

Equipment Room

1-3

4-6

Legend Non-asbestos Containing Material (sample number corresponds to sample’s taken listed inTable 2 of the report, that do not contain asbestos) Asbestos Containing Material Pressumed Asbestos Containing MaterialsPACM

APPENDIX B

PHOTOLOG

Asbestos Survey Report Building No. 13022

Vandenberg Air Force Base, California

TETRA TECH

This photograph shows main chapel room, with the choir loft in the background where 9x9 asbestos containing floor tile is located under the carpet. Date

12/18/08

DESCRIPTION

TETRA TECH

This photograph shows linoleum, drywall, joint compound and cove based mastic all suspect materials sampled.

Date 12/18/08

DESCRIPTION

APPENDIX C

LABORATORY REPORTS AND CHAIN-OF-CUSTODY FORMS

Asbestos survey info for Building 13022