Exhibit_06_Evaluation_Criteria_and_Scoring_Framework.docx
DOCX document 107 KB Posted
- Attached to
- RFP for State Based Exchange Contact Center
- Solicitation number
- EV00000990
- Issued by
- Oklahoma
About this file
Evaluation Criteria and Scoring Framework for Oklahoma State Based Exchange Contact Center RFP
This document is the evaluation criteria and scoring framework for a Request for Proposals issued by the Office of Management and Enterprise Services Central Purchasing division on behalf of the Oklahoma Insurance Department to establish a Contact Center providing consumer assistance for Oklahoma's State Based Exchange (SBE) Marketplace. The Contact Center will deliver frontline consumer support and specialized operational assistance, including inquiry routing, case management, and escalation to appropriate personnel or entities. Proposals will be evaluated through a structured four-stage process: Stage 1 (Administrative Review), Stage 2 (Technical and Business Proposal Evaluation), Stage 3 (Oral Presentations, Reference Checks, and Best and Final Offers), and Stage 4 (Apparent Successful Bidder Selection and Contract Negotiation). The evaluation process will be conducted by an Evaluation Committee comprising State staff and subject matter experts, with award determined on a best-value basis rather than lowest cost alone.
Stage 2 evaluation employs a standardized five-point scoring scale (5 = Significantly Exceeds Requirements through 1 = Does Not Meet Requirements) across six technical and business categories: Bidder Experience and Qualifications, Service Delivery and Operating Model, Technical Solution and Integration, Implementation and Workforce Staffing, Governance and Security/Privacy/Compliance, and Cost. Mandatory qualifications include minimum five years of enterprise Contact Center as a Service experience, three years of State Based Exchange or health insurance customer support experience within the last ten years, modern cloud-based contact center technology platform experience, workforce and operational management capabilities, and security and compliance experience with HIPAA, CMS, and PII protection requirements. Cost proposals will be evaluated using normalized scoring methodology with price realism assessment, considering alignment between staffing levels, seasonal scaling assumptions, and pricing. The State reserves the right to establish minimum score thresholds, verify information through reference checks, request clarifications at any time, and conduct discussions or Best and Final Offers with qualified bidders, with all Stage 3 activity costs borne by participating bidders.
View the file
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| Exhibit_01_Executive_Summary_and_Company_Information.xlsx | XLSX spreadsheet | |
| OMESformCP076.pdf | ||
| Exhibit_08_Service_Level_Agreements.docx | DOCX document | |
| omes-form-cp004.docx | DOCX document | |
| Attachment_D_-_IT_Terms.docx | DOCX document | |
| Exhibit_02_Cost_Proposal_Form.xlsx | XLSX spreadsheet | |
| Amendment_1.docx | DOCX document | |
| Attachment_A.pdf | ||
| Exhibit_07_Mandatory_Qualifications_and_Project_Examples.docx | DOCX document | |
| Exhibit_04_Reference_Form.docx | DOCX document | |
| Agency_Bidder_Instructions.pdf | ||
| Attachment_B_-_State_Terms.docx | DOCX document | |
| Exhibit_05_Third_Party_Supplier_Information.xlsx | XLSX spreadsheet | |
| Exhibit_09_Solution_Requirements_Matrix.xlsx | XLSX spreadsheet | |
| Exhibit_03_SBE_Contact_Center_SOW.docx | DOCX document | |
| Exhibit_10_Technical_and_Operations_Response_Narrative.docx | DOCX document |
Show all 16
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Exhibit 06 – Evaluation Criteria and Scoring Framework
Evaluation and scoring methodology The State of Oklahoma will evaluate all proposals in accordance with the evaluation criteria and procedures described in this Section. The purpose of this methodology is to ensure an objective, transparent, and consistent evaluation process that results in the selection of the Proposal that provides the best value to The State of Oklahoma.
Evaluation Overview Proposals will be evaluated by an Evaluation Committee comprised of State staff and subject matter experts.
Evaluations will be conducted solely on:
· Submitted Proposal materials as defined in the Proposal Submission Requirements and Solution Requirements Matrix
· Responses provided within required templates and submission components
· Clarifications requested by the State, if applicable
· Oral presentations or demonstrations, if requested
A Proposal must be determined to be both responsive and submitted by a responsible Bidder to be considered for award. A responsive Proposal is one that conforms in all material respects to the requirements of this RFP. A responsible Bidder is one that demonstrates the capability, integrity, and reliability to perform the requirements of the Contract.
All members of the Evaluation Committee will be required to disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest prior to participating in the evaluation process. Any evaluator with a conflict of interest may be removed or recused from participation at The State of Oklahoma’s discretion. Evaluators will be required to maintain the confidentiality of all Proposals and evaluation materials and may not disclose or discuss such information outside of the official evaluation process.
Bidders must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest in their proposal. The State of Oklahoma will evaluate disclosed conflicts to determine whether a conflict exists and whether it can be mitigated. The State of Oklahoma reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to determine that a conflict of interest renders a Bidder ineligible for award or to require appropriate mitigation measures as a condition of continued participation.
Best Value Determination Award will be given to the responsive and responsible Bidder, whose proposal is determined to provide the best value to the State of Oklahoma.
Best value will be determined based on the combined evaluation of technical and cost factors as described herein.
The State of Oklahoma is not obligated to select the Proposal with the lowest cost.
Evaluation Basis and Submission Dependency Evaluation will be conducted exclusively on the Bidder’s submitted Proposal materials as defined in the Proposal Submission Requirements and Solution Requirements Matrix.
Pre-award submissions represent binding representations of the Bidder’s proposed approach but do not constitute final Contract deliverables. Consistent with the SOW’s Pre-Award Submissions and Contract Deliverables provisions, evaluation will assess the feasibility, completeness, and credibility of the Bidder’s proposed approach to delivering the outcomes described in the SOW, which the selected Supplier will subsequently refine into State approved baseline deliverables upon award.
evaluation approach Proposals will be evaluated using a structured, multi-stage evaluation process. Advancement to subsequent stages will be based on results of the preceding stage.
The State of Oklahoma reserves the right to determine which Bidders advance at each stage.
The State of Oklahoma reserves the right to modify, combine, or skip any stage or step if determined to be in the best interest of The State of Oklahoma.
The evaluation process consists of four stages:
· Stage 1: Administrative Review
· Stage 2: Technical and Business Proposal Evaluation
· Stage 3: Oral Presentations, Reference Checks, and Best and Final Offers (BAFO) (if applicable)
· Stage 4: Apparent Successful Bidder Selection and Contract Negotiation
Stage 1: Administrative Review The State of Oklahoma will conduct an initial compliance review to confirm that Proposals:
· Include all required forms and documentation
· Meet Minimum Mandatory Qualifications
· Are responsive to RFP requirements
Responses that are incomplete, unsigned, or fail to meet mandatory requirements may be rejected without further evaluation, unless the State of Oklahoma elects to waive such issues as minor administrative irregularities. The State of Oklahoma may request clarification from Bidders during this stage.
Only responsive and qualified Bidders will advance to Stage 2. The State of Oklahoma’s determination of a Bidder’s responsibility is not limited to a single stage of the evaluation process. The State of Oklahoma reserves the right to evaluate and re-evaluate a Bidder’s qualifications, financial condition, past performance, and ability to successfully perform the Contract at any time prior to award.
Minimum Mandatory Qualifications Review
The State of Oklahoma will evaluate whether each Bidder meets the Minimum Mandatory Qualifications specified in Section 4.0 of Exhibit 03 – SBE Contact Center Statement of Work (SOW) and Exhibit 07 – Mandatory Qualifications and Project Examples. Only Bidders meeting all such qualifications will advance.
The apparent successful / selected Bidder must meet the minimum qualifications listed below:
| Mandatory Requirement Category |
| Pass / Fail |
Contact Center Experience
Bidder must demonstrate a minimum of five (5) years of experience providing enterprise Contact Center as a Service (CCaaS), managed contact center services, or comparable contact center services, including implementation and ongoing operation of consumer-facing contact centers supporting complex service environments, including experience managing periods of significant or seasonal demand.
P/F
State Based Exchange or Healthcare Experience
Within the last ten (10) years, Bidder must have a minimum of three (3) years of experience providing customer support center services for at least one State Based Exchange (SBE) or at least two health insurance clients.
P/F
Contact Center as a Service Technology Experience
Bidder must demonstrate experience implementing, integrating and operating modern cloud-based Contact Center technology environments, including cloud based contact center platforms, IVR, ACD, CRM integrations, case management solutions, workforce management, quality management, reporting and analytics, and digital channels such as chat or messaging.
P/F
Workforce and Operational Management Experience
Bidder must demonstrate experience establishing and managing the workforce and operational capabilities necessary to support consumer-facing Contact Center services, including recruiting, training, and managing customer service representatives; scaling staffing models for seasonal enrollment or peak demand periods; and establishing workforce management practices including forecasting, scheduling, monitoring, and performance management.
P/F
Security and Compliance Experience
Bidder must demonstrate experience operating Contact Center services in environments subject to significant security, privacy, data protection, accessibility, and regulatory requirements, including HIPAA or healthcare privacy requirements, CMS security expectations, PII protection requirements, State government security requirements, and accessibility requirements.
P/F
Stage 2: Technical and Business Proposal Evaluation Proposals that pass Stage 1 will be evaluated in Stage 2. The State of Oklahoma will evaluate Technical and Business Proposals to identify those that best align with the Exchange’s objectives and provide the greatest overall value.
Each evaluator will independently score Proposals using a standardized scoring scale. Scores will be averaged to determine final scores.
Scoring Methodology Proposals will be scored using a standardized scale:
· 5 – Significantly Exceeds Requirements
· 4 – Exceeds Requirements
· 3 – Meets Requirements
· 2 – Partially Meets Requirements
· 1 – Does Not Meet Requirements
Scores will be weighted and combined to produce a final total score for each Proposal.
Stage 2: Technical and Business Proposal Evaluation Scoring Criteria
| Category |
| Evaluation Focus (Unified Scoring Narrative) |
| Related Deliverables |
| Bidder Experience and Qualifications |
| Evaluation assesses Bidder’s organizational experience and demonstrated track record in delivering and operating consumer facing Contact Center services comparable in scope, complexity, and regulatory environments to the Oklahoma Health Insurance Marketplace Contact Center. |
Higher scores will be awarded for depth, breadth, and recency of experience within State Based Exchanges (SBE) or the health insurance industry that goes meaningfully beyond the minimum threshold established in the Mandatory Qualifications, particularly experience managing significant seasonal or peak-demand periods comparable to Open Enrollment. Bidders whose SBE or health insurance-specific experience is limited to, or only narrowly exceeds, the minimum required under the Mandatory Qualifications should generally not be evaluated above Meets Requirements on this dimension, regardless of the scale of the Bidder's general (non-Marketplace) contact center experience.
Consideration will be given to experience operating in environments subject to HIPAA, CMS, or comparable security, privacy, and accessibility requirements, and to demonstrated experience coordinating with multiple external stakeholders, such as issuers, enrollment partners, and government agencies, in a manner comparable to Oklahoma's Exchange ecosystem.
Exhibit 01 – Executive Summary Worksheet
Exhibit 07 –Mandatory Qualifications and Project Examples
Three (3) Exhibit 04 - References
| Service Delivery, Consumer Support, and Operating Model |
| Evaluation assesses the maturity and credibility of the Bidder’s proposed approach to consumer facing Contact Center service delivery, including the tiered / skill based support model, consumer education and application assistance, escalation and referral management, across OKEPs, brokers, issuers, and other Exchange partners, and inbound mail and document processing where proposed. |
Higher scores will be awarded for approaches that demonstrate clear alignment with the Exchange’s Tier 1 / Tier 2 operating model, well defined warm handoff processes to OKEPs and external partners, and a credible approach to ongoing service management, performance monitoring, and continuous improvement.
Consideration will be given to approaches that address scalability of service hours and channels during Open Enrollment and Special Enrollment Periods, and to the Bidder’s proposed approach to inbound mail and document processing, where in scope.
Exhibit 10 – Technical and Operational Response Narrative
Exhibit 09 – Solution Requirements Matrix
| Technical Solution and Integration |
| Evaluation assesses the strength and maturity of the Bidder’s proposed Contact Center technology environment, including CCaaS platform capabilities, IVR / ACD design, CRM and case management functionality, workforce and quality management tooling, and reporting and analytics capabilities. |
Higher scores will be awarded for modular, cloud based solutions capable of real time integration with the Exchange eligibility and enrollment platform and supporting seamless bidirectional data exchange.
The evaluation will consider the Bidder’s approach to integration governance and coordination with the future Exchange technology platform vendor, and the Bidder’s demonstrated track record maintaining productive working relationships with SaaS and platform vendors in comparable multi-vendor environments.
Additional consideration will be given to the completeness and responsiveness of the Bidder’s Solution Requirements Matrix responses, and to the extent the proposed technology environment supports first contact resolution, self service capabilities, and consumer accessibility, including Section 508 and ADA Title II compliance.
Exhibit 10 - Technical and Operational Response Narrative
| Implementation, Workforce, and Staffing |
| Evaluation assesses the strength, scalability, and realism of the Bidder’s proposed implementation approach and staffing model across implementation and ongoing operations. |
Higher scores will be awarded for a credible, well sequenced implementation work plan addressing configuration, testing, training, workforce ramp-up, and production transition within the Exchange’s targeted go live timeline, along with a staffing model that clearly identifies key personnel, staffing ratios, and forecasting / scaling methodology for Open Enrollment, Special Enrollment Periods, and unanticipated demand fluctuations.
The evaluation will consider the Bidder’s approach to recruiting, training, and retaining Contact Center staff, including proposed use of Oklahoma based staffing where practical, and the strength of the proposed key personnel roles, responsibilities, and qualifications. Rather than prescribing a specific staffing structure or set of titles, the Exchange expects Bidder’s to draw on their operational expertise to propose the staffing structure, organizational model, and key personnel roles they believe will best support successful implementation and operation of the Contact Center.
Additional consideration will be given to knowledge transfer, succession planning, and subcontractor management approaches, where applicable.
Exhibit 10 – Technical and Operational Response Narrative
| Governance, Security, Privacy, and Compliance |
| Evaluation asses where the Bidder’s proposed governance structure and framework for protecting system integrity, security, privacy, and regulatory compliance across the full scope of Contact Center operations. |
Higher scores will be awarded for a clearly defined organizational and governance structure with defined roles, decision making authority, and escalation paths, and for a security and compliance approach that addresses HIPAA, CMS security expectations, PII protection, MARS-E / ARC-AMPE alignment where applicable, and applicable State security and accessibility requirements.
The evaluation will also consider the Bidder’s approach to quality assurance and call monitoring, data classification and protection, business continuity and disaster recovery planning, and audit readiness, as well as the Bidder’s ability to support the Exchange’s oversight and reporting needs throughout the Contract term.
Exhibit 10 – Technical and Operational Response Narrative
Cost Evaluation and Price Realism Cost Proposals will be evaluated using a normalized scoring methodology, in conjunction with an assessment of cost realism and alignment with the Proposal’s proposed operating and staffing model.
The lowest cost proposal will receive the maximum available points. Other proposals will be scored proportionally. In addition to mathematical scoring, The State of Oklahoma will evaluate whether proposed pricing, staffing levels, and timelines are reasonable, achievable, and consistent with the Bidder’s Proposal, particularly given the seasonal and Open Enrollment driven nature of Contact Center demand.
The State of Oklahoma discourages Bidders from proposing pricing or timelines that cannot reasonably be achieved with the expectation that costs will be recovered through change orders or other post-award mechanisms.
Cost evaluation will include consideration of:
· Alignment between proposed staffing levels, seasonal scaling assumptions, and pricing across the Implementation & Readiness, Ongoing Operations & M&O, and Inbound Mailroom cost components
· Consistency between the Cost Proposal and the Bidder’s Technical and Operational Readiness and Staffing Model
· Completeness of cost components across all required Cost Proposal tabs, including Implementation & Readiness, Ongoing Operations & M&O, Mailroom, and Optional Services / Rate Card
· Reasonableness of proposed rates for key staffing positions relative to proposed service levels and seasonal ramp-up / ramp-down assumptions
If a Cost Proposal is determined to be unrealistic, unbalanced, or not aligned with the Proposal, The State of Oklahoma may adjust scoring, request clarification, or determine the Proposal to present elevated performance risk.
Clarifications requested by The State of Oklahoma are intended to resolve minor ambiguities or inconsistencies and do not permit material changes to the Proposal. Discussions or negotiations, if conducted, may allow Bidders to revise or modify their Proposals as directed by The State of Oklahoma.
| Cost Evaluation Category |
| Description |
| Cost Proposal Completeness and Alignment |
| Verifies that all required cost components across the Implementation & Readiness, Ongoing Operations & M&O, Inbound Mailroom, and Optional Services / Rate Card tabs are present and consistent with the proposed scope, staffing, and timeline. Flags incomplete cost submissions, missing line items, or inconsistences between the Cost Proposal and the Technical and Operational Response or Staffing Model. |
| Price Realism and Reasonableness |
| Assesses whether proposed pricing, staffing levels, and timelines are realistic and achievable, particularly given the seasonal and Open-Enrollment-driven nature of Contact Center demand. Notes any pricing that appears understated relative to proposed scope or staffing, or that may indicate intent to recover costs through post-award change orders. |
| Staffing and Operational Cost Alignment |
| Evaluates the alignment between proposed staffing levels, seasonal scaling assumptions (Open Enrollment, Special Enrollment Periods, unexpected demand events), and pricing across the full contract term. Considers whether the proposed rate structure and staffing ratios are consistent with the Bidder's proposed operating and workforce management approach. |
Combined Scoring Technical and Cost scores will be combined to determine overall scores. These scores will be used to establish a competitive range and determine which Bidders advance.
Stage 3: Oral Presentations, Reference Checks, and Best and Final Offers (BAFO) The State of Oklahoma may establish a competitive range consisting of the highest-rated Proposals. Only Bidders within the competitive range may be invited to participate in Stage 3.
Stage 3 will include:
· Oral Presentations with Contact Center solution demonstration and staffing / leadership discussion
· Reference checks
· Site Visits (if applicable)
· Best and Final Offers (BAFO) The State of Oklahoma will provide advance notice and instructions for any such activities. Failure to participate in requested Stage 3 activities may result in elimination from further consideration.
The State of Oklahoma reserves the right to:
· Request clarifications at any time
· Conduct discussions or negotiations
· Request BAFOs from any or all Bidders
· Require Oral Presentations and/or Site Visits as part of the evaluation process, including evaluation of key personnel, proposed solutions, and operational capabilities
All costs incurred by Bidders in connection with Oral Presentations, Site Visits, BAFO submissions, or any other Stage 3 activities shall be the sole responsibility of the Bidder. The State of Oklahoma shall not be responsible for any travel, lodging, preparation, or related expenses. A request for BAFO does not guarantee award or further negotiation. BAFO submissions must clearly identify all revisions and will be evaluated using the established criteria.
Stage 4: Apparent Successful Bidder Selection and Contract Negotiation The State of Oklahoma will identify an Apparent Successful Bidder (ASB) based on the evaluation results. Following selection, The State of Oklahoma will enter into contract negotiations with the ASB. Contract negotiation is considered part of the overall evaluation process and must be successfully completed prior to final award.
The ASB must provide authorized representatives with full authority to negotiate all contractual terms. If The State of Oklahoma is unable to reach agreement within a reasonable timeframe, The State of Oklahoma may terminate negotiations and proceed to the next highest-ranked Bidder or the Bidder determined to provide the next best value.
Final award is contingent upon successful negotiation and execution of a contract in accordance with State requirements.
Additional Evaluation Provisions The State of Oklahoma reserves the right to:
· Verify information through reference checks and third-party sources
· Consider past performance and experience
· Establish minimum score thresholds
· Request clarification at any time during the process
Information obtained through these methods may be used in scoring and responsibility determinations.
The State of Oklahoma will maintain appropriate documentation of the evaluation process, including scoring, supporting rationale, and any adjustments made during evaluation, to ensure transparency, consistency, and auditability of the procurement process.
2 | Page image1.png
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .