Evaluation Results.pdf

This document is an Evaluation Score Sheet for the Scio School District No. 95, dated 3/19/2025, detailing the scoring results for a remodeling project to convert an existing house into a public office for the school district. The evaluation involved five construction contractors who were scored by three individuals, with the scoring system designed so that fewer points indicate a higher ranking. The participating contractors were CMH Remodeling, Melben Smith, Randell Construction, Castle Construction, and Bergby Construction.

The scoring results show CMH Remodeling received the top ranking with 14 points (5, 5, 4), followed by Melben Smith with 13 points (4, 4, 5), Randell Construction with 9 points (3, 3, 3), Castle Construction with 5 points (2, 2, 1), and Bergby Construction with the lowest score of 4 points (1, 1, 2). This scoring method suggests a comprehensive evaluation process that likely considered multiple aspects of each contractor's bid, though the specific criteria for scoring are not detailed in this document.