Evaluation Criteria.pdf

PDF 128 KB Posted

Attached to
Design and Wayfinding Standards Manual
Solicitation number
2027-RFP-917
Issued by
New Mexico

About this file

This evaluation criteria document outlines the scoring framework for proposals submitted in response to New Mexico State University's request for a Design and Wayfinding Standards Manual for the Institute for Excellence in Education. The evaluation criteria are structured across six primary categories: Firm Qualifications and Relevant Experience (25 points), Project Team Qualifications (25 points), Technical Approach and Understanding of the Project (20 points), Wayfinding and Signage Expertise (10 points), Stakeholder Engagement and Coordination Strategy (10 points), and Quality Control and Implementation Tools (10 points), for a total of 100 possible points. Proposals must address all criteria requirements, and failure to adequately address the requirements may result in the proposal being deemed non-responsive. The document specifies that respondents should demonstrate experience with campus design standards manuals, higher education facilities, consolidating multiple standards documents, and facility operations; present qualified project managers, technical leads, wayfinding specialists, and graphic designers; and articulate a clear methodology for reviewing existing documents, developing comprehensive standards, and implementing quality assurance procedures.

New Mexico resident businesses and resident veteran businesses are eligible for preference points under NMSA 13-1-21, with resident businesses receiving eight additional points and resident veteran businesses receiving ten additional points, bringing the total possible points to 110. Respondents claiming resident or resident veteran business status must submit a certificate issued by the State of New Mexico Taxation & Revenue Department with their proposal. A respondent cannot be awarded both a resident preference and a resident veteran business preference. The document does not specify pricing terms, contract duration, or other financial details in the evaluation criteria section provided.

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
SOW.pdf PDF
1466961-event.pdf PDF
NMSU Standard Terms and Conditions UGC 2.21.24.pdf PDF

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

EVALUATION CRITERIA

Proposals must address each of the following criteria. Each proposal may be awarded points up to the numeric value listed. Points will be awarded in compliance with NMSA 13-1-21 for New Mexico In- State Resident/Native American Resident Business and Resident Veteran/Native American Veteran Business. If proposal is Joint Venture, Respondent shall state in submitted proposal the percentage of work that will be performed by Resident Business and/or Resident Veteran Business. Please Note: A Respondent cannot be awarded both a resident preference and a resident veteran business preference.

Respondent shall include in their proposal a copy of certificate issued by State of New Mexico Taxation & Revenue. Note: FAILURE to adequately address and meet the above requirements may be cause for the proposal to be deemed non-responsive by the procurement officer.

Possible

Points Firm Qualifications and Relevant Experience

• Experience developing campus design standards manuals, facilities standards, design guidelines, owner design requirements, or similar documents.

• Experience with higher education campuses, public agencies, municipalities, large institutional clients, or complex multi-building environments.

• Experience consolidating multiple standards documents into a single comprehensive standards manual.

• Demonstrated understanding of facility operations, maintenance, asset management, and lifecycle planning.

• Quality and relevance of completed projects provided as references.

Project Team Qualifications

• Qualifications of the Project Manager.

• Qualifications of technical discipline leads.

• Qualifications of wayfinding/signage specialists.

• Qualifications of graphic design personnel.

• Availability and commitment of key personnel.

• Experience of proposed team members on similar projects.

Technical Approach and Understanding of the Project

• Understanding of NMSU's objectives.

• Methodology for reviewing existing documents and conducting gap assessments.

• Approach to developing comprehensive campus design standards across all applicable CSI divisions.

• Approach to identifying preferred systems, products, and performance standards.

• Understanding of facility operations, maintainability, accessibility, sustainability, resilience, and lifecycle considerations.

• Ability to develop standards that are practical, enforceable, searchable, and easy to maintain.

• Project schedule and ability to meet milestones

Wayfinding and Signage Expertise

• Experience developing campus-wide wayfinding systems.

• Experience with sign hierarchies, campus navigation systems, branding integration, and accessibility requirements.

• Ability to develop technical standards for fabrication, installation, maintenance, and lifecycle management.

• Quality of previous wayfinding and signage projects.

Stakeholder Engagement and Coordination Strategy

• Proposed stakeholder engagement process.

• Workshop, interview, and facilitation methodology.

• Ability to work with diverse internal stakeholders.

• Process for collecting, tracking, and incorporating comments.

• Communication and coordination plan.

Quality Control and Implementation Tools

• Proposed quality assurance/quality control procedures.

• Approach for developing implementation tools.

• Approach for creating user-friendly, sustainable, and maintainable standards documentation

Total Possible Points

New Mexico Resident/Native American Business Preference:

Eight percent of the total possible points to a resident business.

Respondent shall include a copy of their Resident/Native American Certificate issued by State of New Mexico Taxation & Revenue Department.

8, or

Veteran New Mexico Resident/Native American Business Preference:

Ten percent of the total possible points to a resident veteran business. To qualify a Respondent shall include a copy of their Resident Veteran/Native Veteran Certificate issued by State of New Mexico Taxation & Revenue Department.

Total Possible Points and Preference Points: 100-110

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .