Evaluation Criteria 190000000100.pdf

PDF 177 KB Posted

Attached to
Student Footwear for MCTI
Solicitation number
RFP 491 190000000100 1
Issued by
Allegan County, Michigan

About this file

This is an Evaluation Criteria document for a state and local contract opportunity involving the provision of shoes and boots to students at MCTI (a state institution). The contract requires vendors to supply footwear made of leather or acceptable alternates, available in a full range of sizes including size 15 and above, and offered in both male and female options. The shoes and boots must meet specific requirements regarding color, sole type, safety features, leather uppers where applicable, and closure mechanisms. Vendors must demonstrate the ability to measure and fit students on-site during registration or within 48 hours thereof, with delivery of footwear within 10 days of measurement. The contract establishes service capabilities requiring vendors to address any shoe or boot problems within 48 hours of complaint receipt and complete repairs or exchanges within five business days.

The evaluation criteria are weighted across nine categories totaling 150 points: Product Quality (48 points), Service Capabilities (22 points), Delivery Capabilities (15 points), Company Information and Capabilities (37 points), Prior Experience (10 points), Vendor Performance (6 points), Timeframes and Staffing (6 points), and Samples (6 points). Vendors must provide samples as indicated in proposal instructions and demonstrate relevant experience, including at least three years of gross annual sales data and three relevant prior experiences. The contract requires vendors to maintain a toll-free customer service line available 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. EST, accept multiple ordering methods (electronic, phone, fax, and written), and utilize electronic funds transfer for invoicing. Service-disabled veteran-owned business status receives bonus consideration with an additional 10 points.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Product Quality – Schedule A Section 1.1 Weight

The shoes/boots made of leather or acceptable alternate 6

The correct shoe color 6

The types of soles as indicated 6

Safety toes where indicated (boots) 4

High leather uppers (boots) 4

Have laces or approved type of closure 6

Brand name was included in the bid 6

Shoes in sizes 15+ (i.e., full range of sizes) and able to provide male and female shoes 10

Total: 48

Service Capabilities – Schedule A Sections 1.2/3.2/4.3/5.2/5.4 Weight If there are problems with the shoes/boots, the contractor will meet with the student at MCTI within

48 hours of receipt of complaint (1.2)

Shoes/Boots will be repaired or exchanged within five business days (1.2) 4

A toll free # was identified & a representative will be available 8 am to 5 pm EST (3.2) 6 If there are temporary, promotional or special pricing lower than the contract price, that pricing will be given to the state (4.3) 2

Capacity to order electronically, by phone, fax and by written order (5.2) 4

The number of shoes/boots ordered is determined by the number of students enrolled (5.4) 2

Total: 22

Delivery Capabilities – Schedule A Sections 2.2/2.3/6.1/8.1/8.2 Weight

Contractor can deliver footwear within 10 days of measurement (2.2) 4

The list of student names and sizes can be provided prior to delivery date (2.3) 4

The delivery and transportation method are explained (6.1) 4

The Contractor agrees to prepare the invoices as indicated (8.1) 2

The Contractor agrees to accept EFT (8.2) 1

Total: 15

Company Information/Capabilities – Vendor Questions Worksheet #1/2/4 Weight

The sole contact during the RFP process was identified (#1) 1

The authorized person to receive and sign any resulting contract was identified (#1) 1

Business name/address phone #, etc. identified (#2) 1 Is contractor a service disabled business owner/has required documentation been provided (Yes or

No) [If veteran, +10] (#2)

Organizational structure or a change of control described (#2) 1

A brief description of company background was provided (#2) 5

Three years of gross annual sales identified (#2) 3

Explanation of how Contractor will scale up to manage an increase, if over 25% of last year's sales (#2) 5

Three relevant experiences and supporting information provided (#5) 15

Experience of of representative fitting and measuring on-site (#5) 5

Total: 37

Prior Experience – Vendor Questions Worksheet #5 Weight

Experience working with the State (#5) 5

Technical Evaluation Criteria

A list of contracts was provided (#5) 5

A list of termination contracts was provided (#5) [if there are any -5]

Vendor Performance Issues (#5) [if there are any -5]

Total: 10

Vendor Performance – Vendor Questions Worksheet #6 Weight

The vendor has read and agrees with the Standard Contract Terms (#6) 3

If does not agree, the specific exceptions were listed and a redline version was provided (#6) 3

Total: 6

Timeframes and Staffing – Schedule A Section 2.1/3.1 Weight

A representative will be on campus on registration day or within 48 hours (2.1) 2

The key personnel was identified and their roles and responsibilities were identified (3.1) 2

The customer representative has been designated to service the account (3.1) 2

Total: 6

Samples – Proposal Instructions #1 Weight

Samples were provided as indicated in the proposal instructions 6

Total: 6

150Grand Total:

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .