DTMB-0427 Attachment Pt 2 of 3.pdf

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 56 Lower Falls – Park Store and Bathroom Building

GENERAL BUILDING UPGRADES

(For Options #1, #2, #4 and #5)

PRELIMINARY ESTIMATE OF PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST

STATE OF MICHIGAN

DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES

TAHQUAMENON FALLS STATE PARK

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP Index No. 52130 Contract No. Y 18291

Prepared by: Sanders & Czapski Associates, PLLC Date: July 5, 2018 Marquette, Michigan

ITEM DESCRIPTION COST

A) Replace asphalt shingle roof with new metal roof (60 squares) $ 110,000

B) Relocate (recessed) door on south wall; repair floor $ 10,000

C) Replace door leading to exterior deck $ 5,000

D) Install new exterior ramp at deck, eliminating step $ 5,000

E) Repair damaged wood siding and trim $ 20,000

F) Stain wood siding and trim $ 12,000

G) Replace metal sash windows $ 60,000

H) Masonry foundation repairs $ 12,000

I) Repair gutters and downspouts $ 15,000

J) Foundation drainage system $ 10,000

K) Miscellaneous $ 10,000

Sub-total $ 269,000

L) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 40,000

M) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 11,000

Total Estimated Cost $ 320,000

Notes:

This estimate does not include DTMB fees or architectural/engineering fees.

This estimate is based upon construction occurring in 2020.

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 57

NEW BATHROOM BUILDING

TAHQUAMENON FALLS STATE PARK

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

ITEM DESCRIPTION COST

A) New bathroom building 1,800 sq. ft. at $300 to $350 / sq. ft. $ 540,000 to $ 630,000

B) Site utilities $ 100,000

C) Sitework $ 150,000 to $ 200,000

D) Water treatment system $ 15,000

Sub-total $ 805,000 to $ 945,000

E) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 120,000 to $ 142,000

F) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 15,000

G) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 94,000 to $ 110,000

Total Estimated Cost $1,034,000 to $1,212,000

This estimate does not include DTMB fees.

This estimate assumes a single story, slab-on-grade construction.

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 58

NEW CONCESSION BUILDING

TAHQUAMENON FALLS STATE PARK

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

A) New concession building 6,500 sq. ft. at $200 to $225 / sq. ft. $1,300,000 to $1,463,000

B) Site utilities $ 100,000

D) Water treatment system $ 12,000

Sub-total $1,562,000 to $1,775,000

E) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 234,000 to $ 266,000

G) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 180,000 to $ 204,000

Total Estimated Cost $1,991,000 to $2,260,000

This estimate assumes a single story, slab-on-grade construction

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 59

NEW COMBINED BATHROOM & CONCESSION BUILDING

TAHQUAMENON FALLS STATE PARK

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

A) New public bathroom area 1,450 sq. ft. at $300 to $350 / sq. ft. $ 435,000 to $ 507,500

B) Concession space and other areas 6,550 sq. ft. at $200 to $225 / sq. ft. $1,310,000 to $1,474,000

B) Site utilities $ 100,000

D) Water treatment system $ 15,000

Sub-total $2,010,000 to $2,296,500

E) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 301,500 to $ 345,000

G) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 231,000 to $ 265,000

Total Estimated Cost $2,557,500 to $2,921,500

This estimate assumes a single story, slab-on-grade construction

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 60

OPTION #1

(Repair/renovate the existing building for continued use as a Concession Building and construct a new Bathroom Building at a new location)

STATE OF MICHIGAN - DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES

TAHQUAMENON FALLS STATE PARK

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

A) General Building Upgrades (see breakdown) $ 320,000

B) Minor demolition in bathroom wing $ 25,000

C) Construct new bathrooms to serve concession use only $ 125,000

D) Renovations in existing basement below bathrooms $ 40,000

Sub-total $ 510,000

E) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 76,000

F) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 20,000

G) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 60,000

Total cost for existing building $ 666,000

Other work required for Option #1:

H) Construct new Bathroom Building (1,800 sq. ft.) $ 1,034,000 to $ 1,212,000

Total Estimated Project Cost – OPTION #1 $ 1,700,000 to $ 1,878,000

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 61

OPTION #2

(Repair/renovate the existing building for continued use as a Concession Building and construct a new Bathroom Addition)

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

A) General Building Upgrades $ 320,000

B) Demolish existing bathroom wing $ 70,000

C) Construct new lift station $ 100,000

D) Construct new building addition for public bathrooms 1,800 sq. ft. at $300 to $350 / sq. ft. $ 540,000 to $ 630,000

E) Water treatment system $ 15,000

F) Sitework $ 120,000 to $ 150,000

Sub-total $1,165,000 to $1,285,000

G) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 175,000 to $ 193,000

H) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 20,000

I) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 136,000 to $ 150,000

Total Estimated Project Cost – OPTION #2 $1,496,000 to $1,648,000

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 62

OPTION #3

(Demolish the existing building and construct a new combined Bathroom and

Concession Building)

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

A) Demolish the existing park store / bathroom building $ 120,000

B) Site restoration $ 75,000

C) Abandon site utilities $ 25,000

Sub-total $ 220,000

D) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 33,000

E) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 20,000

F) Professional Fees @ 6% (for demolition work) $ 16,000

Total $ 289,000

G) Construct new combined bathroom and concession building (see estimate on page 50) $2,557,500 to $2,921,500

Total Estimated Project Cost – Option #3 $2,846,500 to $3,210,500

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 63

OPTION #4

(Demolish portions of the existing building and renovate for new use; construct a new combined Bathroom and Concession Building)

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

B) Demolish existing bathroom wing $ 70,000

C) Site restoration at former bathroom wing $ 20,000

D) Minor interior demolition $ 10,000

E) Construct new bathrooms and office $ 100,000

Sub-total $ 476,000

F) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 71,000

G) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 15,000

H) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 55,000

Total cost for existing building $ 617,000

Other work required for Option #4:

I) Construct new combined bathroom and concession building (see estimate on page ) $2,557,500 to $2,921,500

Total Estimated Project Cost – Option #4 $3,174,500 to $3,538,500

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 64

OPTION #5

(Renovate the existing building for continued use as the Park Store and Bathroom

Building; retail space is reduced)

LOWER FALLS – PARK STORE AND BATHROOM BUILDING ASSESSMENT

Paradise (Chippewa County), Michigan

File No. 751 / 18086.TAP

B) Renovate existing bathroom wing for interpretive use (658 sq. ft.) $ 150,000

C) Renovate existing retail space for public bathrooms (1,200 sq. ft.) $ 275,000

D) New roof structure and concession space entrance upgrades $ 100,000

E) Site demolition / remove deck and sidewalks / site restoration $ 40,000

F) New deck for outdoor dining area $ 30,000

G) New sidewalks at entrance $ 15,000

H) Landscaping $ 5,000

I) Lift station upgrades (allowance) $ 50,000

Sub-total $ 985,000

J) Construction Contingency @ 15% $ 148,000

K) Testing / Permits / Fees $ 15,000

L) Professional Fees @ 10% $ 115,000

Total cost to renovate the existing building $1,263,000

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 65

Conclusion

Based on the five options presented, it is the opinion of Sanders & Czapski Associates, PLLC that

Option #3 (new construction) and Option #5 (renovation) will offer the best value to the State of

Michigan. Selecting an option will depend upon the available project funds. In further evaluating these two options, ongoing operational and maintenance costs and the life expectancy of the building must be considered.

Option #3 involves demolition of the existing building in its entirety and construction of a new park store and bathroom building. New construction will result in a fifty-plus year life span with significantly reduced operating costs and maintenance costs during its initial twenty to twenty five years. This option will also allow the size of the concession space to remain similar to its present size so revenue from the concession lease would remain constant.

Option #5 involves the renovation of the existing building in its present configuration. To allow for the construction of new public bathrooms the size of the retail space is significantly reduced which will impact revenue from this leased space. While renovation will result in upgrades and improvements, the age of the structure remains at 60 plus years. With renovations, the life expectancy of the building is extended twenty to twenty five years.

Tahquamenon Falls State Park 66

APPENDIX A

Asbestos Material Survey by ATC dated June 18, 2018

Asbestos Material Survey

Prepared for:

State of Michigan Department of Natural Resources

June 18, 2018

State of Michigan Department of Natural Resources

41382 West M-123 Paradise, MI 49768

188BS18337

State of Michigan

June 18, 2018 ATC ii

Document Information

Prepared for State of Michigan Department of Natural Resources

Project Name State of Michigan

File Reference ACM.Template

Job Reference 188BS18337

Date June 18, 2018

Contact Information

ATC Group Services LLC

46555 Humboldt, Suite 100

Novi, Michigan 48377

Telephone: 248.669.5140

Facsimile: 248.669.5147 www.atcgroupservices.com

Document Control

Version Date Author Author Initials

Reviewer Reviewer Initials

V1 6/18/2018 Ryan Rae RR Robert Smith RS

Ryan Rae Robert Smith Project Manager Building Sciences Department Manager for ATC for ATC Direct Line +1 248-669-5140 Direct Line +1 248-669-5140 Email: ryan.rae@atcgs.com Email:robert.smith@atcgs.com

June 18, 2018 ATC iii

Executive Summary

ATC has completed the pre-demolition asbestos survey for the commercial property located at 41382 West M-

123, Paradise, Michigan. The property building is located in Tahquamenon Falls Michigan State Park, Paradise, Michigan and ATC understands this structure will be demolished.

One hundred and ten (110) samples, taken from fifty (50) homogenous areas, were collected and submitted for analysis by PLM. The results of laboratory testing during the pre-demolition asbestos survey conducted at the property indicate that seven (7) of the materials sampled were found to contain asbestos.

Non-friable, ACM’s such as roofing materials shall not be subjected to abrasion, grinding, sanding or any other processes during demolition activities which will render these non-friable materials friable.

Based on the NESHAP (National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants) “non-friable” Category I ACM and Category I “non-friable” PACM roofing materials that are asphalt/tar based can be demolished with a building so long as it is in good condition and will not be cut, pounded, sanded, or grinded during demolition, and that measures are taken to ensure that it does not become friable, at which point will be considered RACM. This material can also be disposed off-site in a Class III, construction and demolition (C&D) debris, landfill within the framework of local/state regulations. In addition all roofing materials shall not be recycled if they contain Category

I ACM.

Lead Based Paint sampling was not conducted as part of the scope of work and Contractors performing work at the site should assume materials within the building contain levels of lead above the detection limit. ATC recommends that contractors working onsite follow the OSHA Lead in Construction Standard to ensure the protection of their workers during demolition activities.

June 18, 2018 ATC iv

Table of Contents

Executive Summary iii

1 Introduction 5

1.1 Purpose 5

1.2 Pre-Demolition Asbestos 5

2 General Site Conditions 6

2.1 General Property and Building Information 6

2.2 Exterior Finish Descriptions 6

2.3 Interior Building Descriptions 6

3 Pre-Demolition Asbestos Survey 7

3.1 Homogeneous Areas 7

3.2 Hazard Assessment Factors 7

3.3 Laboratory Analytical Methodology 7

3.4 Sampling Results 8

4 Conclusions and Recommendations 11

4.1 Asbestos-Containing Materials 11

Tables

Table 2-1 General Property and Building Information 6

Table 3-1 ACM Sampling Results 8

Figures

Property Diagrams

Appendices

APPENDIX A ASBESTOS LABORATORY REPORTS

APPENDIX B PHOTO LOG

APPENDIX C QUALIFICATIONS

June 18, 2018 ATC 5

1 Introduction

1.1 Purpose

The purpose of this project was to conduct a pre-demolition asbestos survey at the State of Michigan Department of Natural Resources Commercial Property located at 41382 West M-123, Paradise, Michigan, (herein referred to as “the property”).

1.2 Pre-Demolition Asbestos

The scope of the pre-demolition asbestos survey included the following:

> Review of existing asbestos reports for the building, if available;

> Survey of the property building(s);

> Identification of accessible suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACMs);

> Collection and analysis of bulk samples of suspect friable and non-friable materials.

June 18, 2018 ATC 6

2 General Site Conditions

2.1 General Property and Building Information

General property and building information is presented in the following table:

Table 2-1 General Property and Building Information

Date of Inspection: May 11, 2018

Inspector Andrew DeLodder. Inspector Number A48677

Property Address: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, Michigan, 49768

Property Owner State of Michigan Department of Natural Resources

Property Owner Address Tahquamenon Falls State Park & Newberry Field Office

Property Owner Telephone No. 906-492-3415

Building Description: A one story, block, stone and wood frame building with basement and attic.

2.2 Exterior Finish Descriptions

The structure targeted for demolition are currently occupied commercial buildings. The property buildings are constructed of concrete block and stone foundation with a wood frame structure with sloped roofing. No sub-grade level was observed in the buildings. Exterior finish materials noted during the property inspection include cement blocks, stone, wood, steel and glass.

2.3 Interior Building Descriptions

The interior of the property consists of a retail areas, restrooms, storage rooms, mechanical rooms, and office areas. Interior finish materials noted during the property inspection include wallboard/drywall with associated joint compound, base cove and associated mastic, ceramic floor tile and associated grout and mortar, acoustical ceiling tiles (ACTs), paint, concrete, metal, steel and glass.

June 18, 2018 ATC 7

3 Pre-Demolition Asbestos Survey

ATC representative, Mr. Andrew DeLodder, conducted the pre-demolition asbestos inspection of the property buildings on May 11, 2018. Mr. DeLodder is a State of Michigan Certified Asbestos Inspector’s (Certification No.

A48677). A site sketch identifying sampling locations and general building details is included as Figure 1. The property buildings were visually inspected for the presence of building materials that are suspected to contain asbestos. Bulk samples of suspect ACMs were collected and placed into individual containers for transport to a

National Voluntary Lab Accreditation Program (NVLAP)-accredited laboratory for analysis. Materials typically known as non-asbestos items (i.e. fibrous glass, foam rubber, wood, etc.) were not sampled. The asbestos inspection consisted of the following three basic procedures:

> Conducting a visual inspection of the structures;

> Identifying homogeneous areas (HAs) of suspect surfacing, thermal system insulation, and miscellaneous materials; and

> Sampling accessible, friable and non-friable suspect materials.

3.1 Homogeneous Areas

Prior to collecting any samples, homogenous areas (HAs) were identified. A homogeneous sampling area can be described as one or more areas of material that are similar in appearance and texture and that have the same apparent installation date, appearance and function. Actual number of samples collected from each homogeneous sampling area may vary, based on the type of material and professional opinion of the inspector.

3.2 Hazard Assessment Factors

From the list of suspect homogeneous areas, a physical assessment was performed for each material on the list.

A physical assessment includes evaluating the condition, assessing the potential for disturbance, and determining the friability of each material. By definition, "friable" materials are those that can be crumbled or reduced to powder by hand pressure when dry. Each material identified was further classified into one of three categories: surfacing materials, thermal systems insulation (TSI) and miscellaneous materials. Each of the three categories have specific sampling requirements, outlined below.

> Surfacing Materials: Refers to spray-applied or troweled surfaces such as plaster ceilings and walls, fireproofing, textured paints, textured plasters, and spray-applied acoustical surfaces.

> Thermal System Insulation: Refers to insulation used to inhibit heat gain or loss on pipes, boilers, tanks, ducts, and various other building components.

> Miscellaneous Materials: Refers to friable and non-friable products and materials that do not fit in any of the above two categories such as resilient floor covering, baseboards, mastics, adhesives, roofing material, caulking, glazing, and siding. This category also contains wallboard and ceiling tile.

All materials were assessed related to their condition in one of the three categories: good (intact), fair (damaged) or poor (significantly damaged) per Title 40 Code of Federal Regulations Part 763. Material with localized, significant damage was also assessed as poor.

3.3 Laboratory Analytical Methodology

Bulk samples were analyzed by Apex Research, Inc., 11054 Hi Tech Drive, Whitmore Lake, Michigan 48189, using polarized-light microscopy (PLM) and dispersion staining (Method Reference: 40 CFR Part 763, Volume 47, No.

103, May 27, 1982 pg. 23376). This laboratory participates in the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation

Program (NVLAP #102118-0), a quality assurance program for PLM analysis, and is accredited by the National

Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) as well as accreditation requirements under 15 CFR Part 25.

Copies of the laboratory analytical report and corresponding chain-of-custody forms are included in Appendix A.

Positive sample results are reported in percent asbestos by volume of the sample and the type of asbestos material

June 18, 2018 ATC 8 within the sample. Other common non-asbestos components may also be noted on the analytical reports.

Inspector and laboratory accreditations are provided in Appendix C.

3.4 Sampling Results

Bulk samples were collected from the site building and analyzed by polarized light microscopy (PLM), EPA Method

600/R-93/116. Seven (7) of the materials sampled were found to contain concentrations of asbestos.

The following table provides a summary of accessible suspect and confirmed ACMs from the Site buildings:

Table 3-1 ACM Sampling Results

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY

41382 WEST M-123

PARADISE, MICHIGAN 49768

SAMPLED MAY 11, 2018

Sample ID/Material Location of Materials Condition Friable

Yes/No Estimated Quantity Asbestos Content

1-VP-A,B

Vapor Paper

Under wood siding

EA-8

Good No 250 SF ND

2-VP-A,B

Vapor Paper

Under wall board

FS-14

Good No 1,5000 SF ND

3- VP-A,B

Vapor Paper

Exterior wall footing

EA-6

Good No 250 SF ND

4-VP-A,B

Vapor Paper

Under wood siding, black-hall FS-26

Good No 200 SF ND

5-VP-A,B

Vapor Paper

Ceiling FS-22 Good No 720 SF ND

6-WG-A,B

Window Glaze

Basement Windows

EA-9, 10

Good No 30 SF Chrysotile 2%

7-WG-A,B

Window Glaze

Utility Closet EA-9, FS-

Good No 10 LF Chrysotile 5%

8- WG-A,B

Metal Windows- Addition EA-6

Good No 25 LF

9- WG-A,B

Metal Windows- Original EA-7, EA-8

Good No 350 LF

10- WG-A,B

Metal Windows Restroom EA-8, EA-10

Good No 100 LF

11-EC-A,B

External Caulk

Utility Plug, grey EA-2 Good No 1 LF ND

12- EC-A,B

External Caulk

Window Trim EA-3 Good No 20 LF ND

13- EC-A,B

External Caulk

Brown, Doors/Windows

EA-4,5

Good No 175 LF ND

14- EC-A,B

External Caulk

Black, Foundation

EA-7

Good No 60 LF

15- EC-A,B

External Caulk

Bathroom Window Frames

EA-8,EA-9

Good No 350 LF

16-WBS-A,B,C,D,E

Wall Board System, Tape/Mud FS-12

Good No 2500 SF ND

17- WBS-A,B,C,D,E

Wall Board System, No Tape or Mud FS-14

Good No 1500 SF ND

18-CP-A,B

Ceiling Panel

Ceiling Panel, White, Pinhole FS-12

Good No 75 SF ND

19-CP-A,B

Ceiling Panel

Ceiling Panel, Beige, Pinhole FS-12

Good No 100 SF ND

June 18, 2018 ATC 9

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY

41382 WEST M-123

PARADISE, MICHIGAN 49768

SAMPLED MAY 11, 2018

Sample ID/Material Location of Materials Condition Friable

Yes/No Estimated Quantity Asbestos Content

20- CP-A,B

Ceiling Panel, Wall Board Panel, White, Vinyl cover FS-12

Good No 140 SF ND

21-GM-A,B

Grout, Mortar Ceramic Tile

Ceramic Tile, Grout, Mortar, Grey FS-12

Good No 1400 SF ND

22-CP-A,B

Ceiling Panel, White, Pinhole FS-12

Good No 1200 SF ND

23-GM-A,B

Grout, Mortar Ceramic Tile

Red Ceramic Tile, Grout, Mortar, FS-16

Good No 700 SF ND

24-GM-A,B

Grout, Mortar Ceramic Tile

White Ceramic Tile Wall, Grout, Mortar, FS-18

Good No 700 SF ND

25-CBP-A,B

Cement Board

Cement Board Panel under tile, FS-16,18

Good No 1500 SF ND

26-CA-A,B

Construction

Adhesive

Construction Adhesive, behind fiberglass panelling, FS-12

Good No 1500 SF ND

27-BM-A,B

Brick Mortar

Brick Mortar, concrete block addition EA-3,4,5

Good No 4 CY ND

28-BM-A,B

Brick Mortar

Brick Mortar, concrete block foundation EA-1,2, FS-20

Good No 35 CY ND

29-FSC-A,B

Foundation Skim

Coat

Foundation Skim Coat on concrete block EA-

1,2 Good No 350 SF ND

30-BM-A,B

Brick Mortar

Brick Mortar, stone foundation EA-8,9,10

Good No 40 CY ND

31-CC-A,B

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip basement slab FS-20

Good No 30 CY ND

32-CC-A,B

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip slab FS-

Good No 30 CY ND

33-CC-A,B

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip slab FS- 16,17,18

Good No 20 CY ND

34-CC-A,B

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip utility room slab FS-22

Good No 15 CY ND

35-CC-A,B

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip skim coat on stone wall FS-22

Good No 10 CY ND

36-RI-A,B

Rolled-in Insulation

Rolled-in Insulation, yellow FS-24,25

Good No 200 SF ND

37-RI-A,B

Rolled-in Insulation

Rolled-in Insulation, pink

FS-25

Good No 2000 SF ND

38-RI-A,B

Rolled-in Insulation

Rolled-in Insulation, red

FS-23

Good No 1400 SF ND

39-RI-A,B

Rolled-in Insulation

Rolled-in Insulation, grey

FS-12

Good No 100 SF ND

40-RI-A,B

Rolled-in Insulation

Rolled-in Insulation, pink

FS-24

Good No 1400 SF ND

41-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, White on window frame

Good No 50 LF ND

June 18, 2018 ATC 10

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY

41382 WEST M-123

PARADISE, MICHIGAN 49768

SAMPLED MAY 11, 2018

Sample ID/Material Location of Materials Condition Friable

Yes/No Estimated Quantity Asbestos Content

42-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, brown on door frame FS-14

Good No 50 LF ND

43-CB-A,B

Cove Base

Cove Base, beige with mastic FS-12

Good No 200 LF ND

44-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, beige on counter FS-14

Good No 15 LF ND

45-CB-A,B

Cove Base

Cove Base, on counter base FS-14

Good No 15 LF ND

46-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, white/ brown FS-15

Good No 50 LF ND

47-CB-A,B

Cove Base

Cove Base, black around counter FS-15

Good No 200 LF ND

48-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, beige FS- 16,18

Good No 200 LF ND

49-IC-A,B

Interior Caulk

Interior Caulk, off white

FS-16,18

Good No 150 LF ND

50-JC-A,B

Joint Compound

Joint Compound, black

FS-26

Good No 26 LF ND

ND: None Detected s.f./l.f.: square feet/linear feet VFT: Vinyl Floor Tile

NA: Not Applicable M: Miscellaneous S: Surfacing

TSI: Thermal System Insulation PACM: Presumed ACM

NESHAP

RACM: Regulated ACM Cat. I: Category I Non-Friable ACM Cat. II: Category II Non-Friable ACM

In the event additional suspect material is discovered during demolition activities, this material should be treated as presumed asbestos-containing material (PACM) in accordance with regulations 29 CFR 1926.1101 and

1910.1001 and other applicable state and local regulations and either sampled to confirm or nullify asbestos content or be treated as ACM and handled accordingly.

June 18, 2018 ATC 11

4 Conclusions and Recommendations

4.1 Asbestos-Containing Materials

The results of laboratory testing during the pre-demolition asbestos survey conducted at the property indicate that seven (7) of the materials sampled were found to contain asbestos. If materials identified to contain asbestos can be removed safely they should be removed prior to demolition by a licensed abatement company. If these materials cannot be removed safely prior to demolition, the Contractor performing the work should comply with all requirements of OSHA and all building materials should be treated as ACM waste and disposed according to the requirements of NESHAP.

Non-friable ACM’s shall not be subjected to abrasion, grinding, sanding or any other processes during renovation activities which will render these non-friable materials friable.

Based on the NESHAP (National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants) non-friable Category I ACM and Category I non-friable PACM roofing materials that are asphalt/tar based can be demolished with a building so long as it is in good condition and will not be cut, pounded, sanded, or grinded during demolition, and that measures are taken to ensure that it does not become friable, at which point will be considered RACM. This material can also be disposed off-site in a Class III, construction and demolition (C&D) debris, landfill within the framework of local/state regulations. In addition all roofing materials shall not be recycled if they contain Category

I ACM.

Regulated Materials identified in Section 4 should be removed prior to demolition activities and disposed in accordance with the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) requirements as applicable.

This statement is in lieu of other statements either expressed or implied. This report does not warrant against changes to material from future operations or conditions, nor does it warrant against operations or conditions against present

ACM materials.

The scope of services performed in execution of this evaluation may not be appropriate to satisfy the needs of other users, and use or re-use of this document or the findings, conclusions, or recommendations is at the risk of said user.

Asbestos & Regulated Material Survey

June 15, 2018

FIGURES

Site Plan: Main Floor

State Of Michigan Department of Natural Resources

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

DRAWN BY: AHD

LEGEND:

N =20 feet

EA-1

E A-

2 E A-

EA-7

E A-

EA-9

E A-

Roof: EA: 11

FS-12

FS

-1

FS-14

FS-15

FS

-1

FS

-1

FS

-1

FS-26

=Window

Sample Location Map: Main Floor

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

1-VP-A

1-VP-B

2-VP-A

2-VP-B

3-VP-A

3-VP-B

4-VP-A

4-VP-B

7-WG-A 7-WG-B

10-WG-A

8-WG-A

9-WG-A

9-WG-B

8-WG-B

10-WG-B

11-EC-A

11-EC-B

12-EC-A

12-EC-B

13-EC-A

13-EC-B

14-EC-A 14-EC-B

15-EC-A

15-EC-B

16-WBS-A

16-WBS-B

16-WBS-C

16-WBS-D

16-WBS-E

17-WBS-B

17-WBS-A

17-WBS-C

17-WBS-D

17-WBS-E

18-CP-A

18-CP-B

19-CP-A

19-CP-B

20-CP-A

20-CP-B

22-CP-A

22-CP-B

21-GM-A

21-GM-B

23-GM-A

23GM-B

24-GM-A24-GM-B

25-CPB-A

25-CPB-B

26-CA-A

26-CA-B

32-CC-A32-CC-B

33-CC-A

33-CC-B

41-IC-A

41-IC-B

42-IC-A

44-IC-A,B

46-IC-A

48-IC-A

49-IC-A

42-IC-B

46-IC-B

48-IC-B

49-IC-B

43-CB-B

43-CB-A

45-CB-A,B

47-CB-A,B

50-JC-A,B

=Window

Site Plan: Basement

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

FS-22

FS-20

FS

-2

FS-19

FS

-1

Sample Location Map: Basement

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

FS-22

FS-20

FS

-2

FS-19

FS

-1

5-VP-A

5-VP-B

6-WG-A

6-WG-B

27-BM-A

27-BM-B

28-BM-A

28-BM-B

29-FSC-A

29-FSC-B

30-BM-A

30-BM-B

31-CC-A

31-CC-B

34-CC-A

34-CC-B

35-CC-A

35-CC-B

Site Plan - Attic

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

FS-25

FS-24

FS-23

Sample Location Map - Attic

41382 West M-123

Paradise, Michigan 49768

PROJECT NO.: 188BS18337

36-RI-A

37-RI-A

38-RI-A

39-RI-A

40-RI-A

36-RI-B

37-RI-B

38-RI-B

39-RI-B

40-RI-B

FS-25

FS-24

FS-23

36-RI-C

37-RI-C

38-RI-C

39-RI-C

40-RI-C

Asbestos & Regulated Material Survey

June 15, 2018

APPENDIX A

ASBESTOS LABORATORY REPORTS

Summary of Analysis Apex Project: 4

Report To: Total Samples 111 ARI Report #:

Mr. Andrew DeLodder 1st Layers 104 Date Collected:

ATC Group Services, LLC Additional Layers 23 Date Received:

4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Total Layers 127 Date Analyzed:

Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Total Point Counts 0 Date Reported:

Total Not Analyzed 7

Cust # Asb? PC? N/A? 1st Add N/A PC

77064 01 1-VP-A 1 1 NO 1

77064 02 1-VP-B 1 1 NO 2

77064 03 2-VP-A 1 1 NO 3

77064 04 2-VP-B 1 1 NO 4

77064 05 3-VP-A 1 1 NO 5

77064 06 3-VP-B 1 1 NO 6

77064 07 4-VP-A 1 1 NO 7

77064 08 4-VP-B 1 1 NO 8

77064 09 5-VP-A 1 1 NO 9

77064 10 5-VP-B 1 1 NO 10

77064 11 6-WG-A 1 1 YES 11

77064 12 6-WG-B N/A 1

77064 13 7-WG-A 1 1 YES 12

77064 14 7-WG-B N/A 2

77064 15 8-WG-A 1 1 YES 13

77064 16 8-WG-B N/A 3

77064 17 9-WG-A 1 1 YES 14

77064 18 9-WG-B N/A 4

77064 19 10-WG-A 1 1 YES 15

77064 20 10-WG-B N/A 5

77064 21 11-EC-A 1 1 NO 16

77064 22 11-EC-B 1 1 NO 17

77064 23 12-EC-A 1 1 NO 18

77064 24 12-EC-B 1 1 NO 19

77064 25 13-EC-A 1 1 NO 20

77064 26 13-EC-B 1 1 NO 21

77064 27 14-EC-A 1 1 YES 22

77064 28 14-EC-B N/A 6

77064 29 15-EC-A 1 1 YES 23

77064 30 15-EC-B N/A 7

77064 31 16-WBS-A 1 2 NO 24

77064 31a 16-WBS-A 2 2 NO 1

77064 32 16-WBS-B 1 2 NO 25

Project: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI Project #: 188BS18337

Apex Sample # Layer _ of _

Vapor Paper, Black

Ext. Caulk, Around Bath Window F

External Caulk

External Caulk

External Caulk, Brown

External Caulk, Brown

External Caulk, Black

External Caulk, Black

External Caulk, Grey

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

Window Glaze

External Caulk

External Caulk

External Caulk, Grey

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper, Black

Material

Vapor Paper

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper, Black

Vapor Paper

18-77064 05/11/18 05/18/18 05/22/18 05/23/18

Ext. Caulk, Around Bath Window F

Wallboard/Drywall

Joint Compound

Wallboard/Drywall

Report To: Total Samples 111 ARI Report #:

Mr. Andrew DeLodder 1st Layers 104 Date Collected:

ATC Group Services, LLC Additional Layers 23 Date Received:

4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Total Layers 127 Date Analyzed:

Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Total Point Counts 0 Date Reported:

Total Not Analyzed 7

Cust # Asb? PC? N/A? 1st Add N/A PC

Project: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI Project #: 188BS18337

Apex Sample # Layer _ of _ Material

18-77064 05/11/18 05/18/18 05/22/18 05/23/18

77064 32a 16-WBS-B 2 2 NO 2

77064 33 16-WBS-C 1 2 NO 26

77064 33a 16-WBS-C 2 2 NO 3

77064 34 16-WBS-D 1 2 NO 27

77064 34a 16-WBS-D 2 2 NO 4

77064 35 16-WBS-E 1 2 NO 28

77064 35a 16-WBS-E 2 2 NO 5

77064 36 17-WBS-A 1 1 NO 29

77064 37 17-WBS-B 1 1 NO 30

77064 38 17-WBS-C 1 1 NO 31

77064 39 17-WBS-D 1 1 NO 32

77064 40 17-WBS-E 1 1 NO 33

77064 41 18-CP-A 1 1 NO 34

77064 42 18-CP-B 1 1 NO 35

77064 43 19-CP-A 1 1 NO 36

77064 44 19-CP-B 1 1 NO 37

77064 45 20-CP-A 1 1 NO 38

77064 46 20-CP-B 1 1 NO 39

77064 47 21-GM-A 1 2 NO 40

77064 47a 21-GM-A 2 2 NO 6

77064 48 21-GM-B 1 2 NO 41

77064 48a 21-GM-B 2 2 NO 7

77064 49 22-CP-A 1 1 NO 42

77064 50 22-CP-B 1 1 NO 43

77064 51 23-GM-A 1 3 NO 44

77064 51a 23-GM-A 2 3 NO 8

77064 51b 23-GM-A 3 3 NO 9

77064 52 23-GM-B 1 3 NO 45

77064 52a 23-GM-B 2 3 NO 10

77064 52b 23-GM-B 3 3 NO 11

77064 53 24-GM-A 1 3 NO 46

77064 53a 24-GM-A 2 3 NO 12

77064 53b 24-GM-A 3 3 NO 13

Grout

Mortar

Mortar

Ceramic Tile, Red Tile Floor

Grout

Mortar

Ceramic Tile, White Wall Tile

Grout/Mortar

Ceiling Panel - White, Pinhole & F

Ceiling Panel - White, Pinhole & F

Ceramic Tile, Red Tile Floor

Grout

CP, Wallboard Panel w/ White Cov

CP, Wallboard Panel w/ White Cov

Ceramic Tile, Grey

Grout/Mortar

Ceramic Tile, Grey

Wallboard/Drywall

Ceiling Panel, White, Pinhole/Fiss

Ceiling Panel, White, Pinhole/Fiss

Ceiling Panel, Beige, Pinhole/Fiss

Ceiling Panel, Beige, Pinhole/Fiss

Joint Compound

Wallboard/Drywall

Wallboard/Drywall

Wallboard/Drywall

Wallboard/Drywall

Wallboard/Drywall

Joint Compound

Wallboard/Drywall

Joint Compound

Wallboard/Drywall

Joint Compound

Report To: Total Samples 111 ARI Report #:

Mr. Andrew DeLodder 1st Layers 104 Date Collected:

ATC Group Services, LLC Additional Layers 23 Date Received:

4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Total Layers 127 Date Analyzed:

Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Total Point Counts 0 Date Reported:

Total Not Analyzed 7

Cust # Asb? PC? N/A? 1st Add N/A PC

Project: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI Project #: 188BS18337

Apex Sample # Layer _ of _ Material

18-77064 05/11/18 05/18/18 05/22/18 05/23/18

77064 54 24-GM-B 1 3 NO 47

77064 54a 24-GM-B 2 3 NO 14

77064 54b 24-GM-B 3 3 NO 15

77064 55 25-CBP-A 1 2 NO 48

77064 55a 25-CBP-A 2 2 NO 16

77064 56 25-CBP-B 1 2 NO 49

77064 56a 25-CBP-B 2 2 NO 17

77064 57 26-CA-A 1 1 NO 50

77064 58 26-CA-B 1 1 NO 51

77064 59 27-BM-A 1 1 NO 52

77064 60 27-BM-B 1 1 NO 53

77064 61 28-BM-A 1 1 NO 54

77064 62 28-BM-B 1 1 NO 55

77064 63 29-FSC-A 1 2 NO 56

77064 63a 29-FSC-A 2 2 NO 18

77064 64 29-FSC-B 1 2 NO 57

77064 64a 29-FSC-B 2 2 NO 19

77064 65 30-BM-A 1 1 NO 58

77064 66 30-BM-B 1 1 NO 59

77064 67 31-CC-A 1 1 NO 60

77064 68 31-CC-B 1 1 NO 61

77064 69 32-CC-A 1 1 NO 62

77064 70 32-CC-B 1 1 NO 63

77064 71 33-CC-A 1 1 NO 64

77064 72 33-CC-B 1 1 NO 65

77064 73 34-CC-A 1 1 NO 66

77064 74 34-CC-B 1 1 NO 67

77064 75 35-CC-A 1 1 NO 68

77064 76 35-CC-B 1 1 NO 69

77064 77 36-RI-A 1 1 NO 70

77064 78 36-RI-B 1 1 NO 71

77064 79 36-RI-C 1 1 NO 72

77064 80 37-RI-A 1 1 NO 73

Concrete Chip, Skim Coat

Rolled In Insulation, Yellow Fiberg

Rolled In Insulation, Yellow Fiberg

Rolled In Insulation, Yellow Fiberg

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip, Skim Coat

Brick Mortar

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Concrete Chip

Foundation Skim Coat/Tar Materia

Concrete

Foundation Skim Coat/Tar Materia

Concrete

Brick Mortar

Construction Adhesive

Brick Mortar

Brick Mortar

Brick Mortar, Concrete Block

Brick Mortar, Concrete Block

Cement Board Panel, Under Tile

Mortar

Cement Board Panel, Under Tile

Mortar

Construction Adhesive

Ceramic Tile, White Wall Tile

Grout

Mortar

Report To: Total Samples 111 ARI Report #:

Mr. Andrew DeLodder 1st Layers 104 Date Collected:

ATC Group Services, LLC Additional Layers 23 Date Received:

4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Total Layers 127 Date Analyzed:

Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Total Point Counts 0 Date Reported:

Total Not Analyzed 7

Cust # Asb? PC? N/A? 1st Add N/A PC

Project: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI Project #: 188BS18337

Apex Sample # Layer _ of _ Material

18-77064 05/11/18 05/18/18 05/22/18 05/23/18

77064 81 37-RI-B 1 1 NO 74

77064 82 37-RI-C 1 1 NO 75

77064 83 38-RI-A 1 1 NO 76

77064 84 38-RI-B 1 1 NO 77

77064 85 38-RI-C 1 1 NO 78

77064 86 39-RI-A 1 1 NO 79

77064 87 39-RI-B 1 1 NO 80

77064 88 39-RI-C 1 1 NO 81

77064 89 40-RI-A 1 1 NO 82

77064 90 40-RI-B 1 1 NO 83

77064 91 40-RI-C 1 1 NO 84

77064 92 41-IC-A 1 1 NO 85

77064 93 41-IC-B 1 1 NO 86

77064 94 42-IC-A 1 1 NO 87

77064 95 42-IC-B 1 1 NO 88

77064 96 43-CB-A 1 2 NO 89

77064 96a 43-CB-A 2 2 NO 20

77064 97 43-CB-B 1 2 NO 90

77064 97a 43-CB-B 2 2 NO 21

77064 98 44-IC-A 1 1 NO 91

77064 99 44-IC-B 1 1 NO 92

77064 100 45-CB-A 1 1 NO 93

77064 101 45-CB-B 1 1 NO 94

77064 102 46-IC-A 1 1 NO 95

77064 103 46-IC-B 1 1 NO 96

77064 104 47-CB-A 1 2 NO 97

77064 104a 47-CB-A 2 2 NO 22

77064 105 47-CB-B 1 2 NO 98

77064 105a 47-CB-B 2 2 NO 23

77064 106 48-IC-A 1 1 NO 99

77064 107 48-IC-B 1 1 NO 100

77064 108 49-IC-A 1 1 NO 101

77064 109 49-IC-B 1 1 NO 102

Interior Caulk, Beige

Interior Caulk, Off White

Interior Caulk, Off White

Cove Base/Stair Tread, Black

Adhesive

Cove Base/Stair Tread, Black

Adhesive

Interior Caulk, Beige

Interior Caulk/Paint Layers, Beige

Cove Base, Black

Cove Base, Black

Interior Caulk, White/Brown

Interior Caulk, White/Brown

Cove Base, Beige

Mastic

Cove Base, Beige

Mastic

Interior Caulk/Paint Layers, Beige

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Interior Caulk, White

Interior Caulk, White

Interior Caulk, Brown

Interior Caulk, Brown

Rolled In Insulation, Grey Fibergla

Rolled In Insulation, Grey Fibergla

Rolled In Insulation, Grey Fibergla

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Pink Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Red Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Red Fiberglas

Rolled In Insulation, Red Fiberglas

Report To: Total Samples 111 ARI Report #:

Mr. Andrew DeLodder 1st Layers 104 Date Collected:

ATC Group Services, LLC Additional Layers 23 Date Received:

4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Total Layers 127 Date Analyzed:

Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Total Point Counts 0 Date Reported:

Total Not Analyzed 7

Cust # Asb? PC? N/A? 1st Add N/A PC

Project: 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI Project #: 188BS18337

Apex Sample # Layer _ of _ Material

18-77064 05/11/18 05/18/18 05/22/18 05/23/18

77064 110 50-JC-A 1 1 NO 103

77064 111 50-JC-B 1 1 NO 104

Joint Compound, Black

Joint Compound, Black

Certificate of Laboratory Analysis Test Method, Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM)

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 01 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 1-VP-A No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wood Siding, EA 8 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 02 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 1-VP-B No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wood Siding, EA 8 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 03 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 2-VP-A No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wallboard, FS 14 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Project # :188BS18337

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

NVLAP Lab Code 102118-0

APEX Research Inc., 11054 Hi Tech Drive, Whitmore Lake, MI 48189

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 1 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 04 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 2-VP-B No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wallboard, FS 14 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 05 Asbestos Present: NO Fiberglass - 20% Cust. #: 3-VP-A No Asbestos Observed Other - 80% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Exterior Wall Footing, EA 6 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 06 Asbestos Present: NO Fiberglass - 20% Cust. #: 3-VP-B No Asbestos Observed Other - 80% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Exterior Wall Footing, EA 6 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 2 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 07 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 4-VP-A No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wood Siding, FS 26 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 08 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 4-VP-B No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper, Black Location: Under Wood Siding, FS 26 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 09 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 5-VP-A No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper Location: Ceiling, FS 22 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 3 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 10 Asbestos Present: NO Cellulose - 35% Cust. #: 5-VP-B No Asbestos Observed Other - 65% Material: Vapor Paper Location: Ceiling, FS 22 Appearance: black,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 11 Asbestos Present: YES Other - 98% Cust. #: 6-WG-A Chrysotile - 2% Material: Window Glaze Location: Basement Windows, EA 9, 10 Appearance: grey,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 12 Asbestos Present:

Cust. #: 6-WG-B Material: Window Glaze Location: Basement Windows, EA 9, 10 NOT ANALYZED Appearance:

Layer: of

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 4 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 13 Asbestos Present: YES Other - 95% Cust. #: 7-WG-A Chrysotile - 5% Material: Window Glaze Location: Utility Closet, EA 9, FS 17 Appearance: grey,fibrous,nonhomogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 14 Asbestos Present:

Cust. #: 7-WG-B Material: Window Glaze Location: Utility Closet, EA 9, FS 17 NOT ANALYZED Appearance:

Layer: of

Lab ID #: 77064 - 15 Asbestos Present: YES Other - 98% Cust. #: 8-WG-A Chrysotile - 2% Material: Window Glaze Location: Metal Windows on Addition, EA 6 Appearance: beige,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 5 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 16 Asbestos Present:

Cust. #: 8-WG-B Material: Window Glaze Location: Metal Windows on Addition, EA 6 NOT ANALYZED Appearance:

Layer: of

Lab ID #: 77064 - 17 Asbestos Present: YES Other - 98% Cust. #: 9-WG-A Chrysotile - 2% Material: Window Glaze Location: Metal Windows on Original, EA 7, 8 Appearance: beige,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 18 Asbestos Present:

Cust. #: 9-WG-B Material: Window Glaze Location: Metal Windows on Original, EA 7, 8 NOT ANALYZED Appearance:

Layer: of

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 6 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 19 Asbestos Present: YES Other - 98% Cust. #: 10-WG-A Chrysotile - 2% Material: External Caulk Location: Metal Restroom Windows, EA 8, 10 Appearance: beige,fibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 20 Asbestos Present:

Cust. #: 10-WG-B Material: External Caulk Location: Metal Restroom Windows, EA 8, 10 NOT ANALYZED Appearance:

Layer: of

Lab ID #: 77064 - 21 Asbestos Present: NO Other - 100% Cust. #: 11-EC-A No Asbestos Observed Material: External Caulk, Grey Location: Utility Plug, EA 2 Appearance: grey,nonfibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

For Layered Samples, each component will be analyzed and reported separately.

Robert T. Letarte Jr., Laboratory Director

Test Method EPA 600/R-93/116 was used to analyze the above samples. Matrix interference and/or resolution limits may yield false/negative results in certain circumstances. Suspect floor tiles containing <1% should be tested with SEM or TEM. This certificate of analysis relates only to the samples tested and to insure the integrity of the results, may only be reproduced in full. This certificate must not be used by the customer to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP, NIST, or any agency of the Federal Government. APEX Research Inc. is not responsible for the accuracy of the results for layered samples or samples comprising multiple materials. Liability limited to cost of analysis.

(734) 449-9990, Fax (734) 449-9991 Page 7 of 45

Report To: ARI Report # 18-77064 Mr. Andrew DeLodder Date Collected: 05/11/18 ATC Group Services, LLC Date Received: 05/18/18 4519 Broadmoor Ave SE Date Analyzed: 05/22/18 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 Date Reported: 05/23/18

Project # :188BS18337 Project : 41382 West M-123, Paradise, MI

Sample Information Asbestos Type/Percent Non-Asbestos Material

Lab ID #: 77064 - 22 Asbestos Present: NO Other - 100% Cust. #: 11-EC-B No Asbestos Observed Material: External Caulk, Grey Location: Utility Plug, EA 2 Appearance: grey,nonfibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 23 Asbestos Present: NO Other - 100% Cust. #: 12-EC-A No Asbestos Observed Material: External Caulk Location: Around Window Trim, EA 3 Appearance: brown,nonfibrous,homogenous Layer: 1 of 1

Lab ID #: 77064 - 24 Asbestos…