Consultant Findings of Current System and Recommendations (1).pdf
PDF 138 KB Posted
- Attached to
- UNH - Offsite Signaling System Upgrade for Campus Fire Alarm and Security Signal Transmission System
- Solicitation number
- 2120271018
- Issued by
- New Hampshire
About this file
This document is a consultant's evaluation letter regarding the University of New Hampshire (UNH) Dispatch Center facility located in Durham, New Hampshire, which serves the UNH Police Department, Town of Madbury Police Department, Towns of Lee and Madbury Fire Departments, Town of Barrington Fire and Ambulance Departments, and McGregor Ambulance Corp. The consultant conducted a site survey on March 25, 2025, to assess the existing dispatch center's compliance with NFPA 1221 standards for emergency services communications systems. The facility is a modular structure currently equipped with a Keltron dispatching system featuring three workstations (one non-operable), redundant network interface systems in a server room, fire alarm detection and notification systems, uninterruptible power supply (UPS) with automatic transfer switch, and backup natural gas-fueled generator power. The evaluation focused on fire protection, life safety systems, construction, climate control, security, power systems, lighting, and lightning protection compliance.
The consultant's findings indicate that while the dispatch center demonstrates compliance in foundational areas including Type II construction classification, artificial and emergency lighting, two-hour fire-rated barriers with 90-minute fire doors, fire extinguishers, fire alarm systems, and backup power infrastructure, several critical deficiencies require remediation. The facility lacks an automatic sprinkler system and clean agent fire suppression for electronic equipment rooms, both mandated by NFPA 13 and 75 standards. Additionally, compliance remains unknown or unverified in multiple areas including lightning protection per NFPA 780, emergency lighting performance criteria, HVAC system compliance with NFPA 90A and 90B, security measures against vandalism and terrorism, and interior finish flame spread and smoke development ratings. The consultant recommends transitioning from the aging Keltron system to a modern, code-compliant alarm monitoring solution, including options such as IP- or cellular-based communicators, mesh radio systems like AES-IntelliNet, or integration with a UL-listed third-party central monitoring station with Municipal Alarm Receiving System (MARS) capabilities to improve reliability, scalability, and NFPA 72 compliance.
View the file
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| RFP 2120271017 - UNH Campus Fire Alarm and Security Signal Transmission System.pdf | ||
| Appendix C - USNH CD200 (1).docx | DOCX document | |
| 1466221-event.pdf | ||
| Additional Technical Requirements for System (1).pdf |
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
RE: UNH – Dispatch Center – Evaluation
To Whom It May Concern:
Consultant has prepared this letter for the University of Hampshire’s Facilities regarding the compliance/findings regarding the existing dispatch building currently serving the campus in Durham, NH. This letter summarizes CONSULTANT’s evaluation of the existing system following a site survey conducted by CONSULTANT personnel on March 25th, 2025, an evaluation of the applicable codes and standards, and a review of supplemental documentation submitted by the client.
Scope of Review
It is CONSULTANT’s understanding that the UNH dispatch center serves the UNH Police Department, Town of Madbury PD, the Towns of Lee and Madbury Fire Departments, the Town of Barrington Fire and Ambulance Departments, and the McGregor Ambulance Corp. Per NFPA 1221 – Standard for the Installation, Maintenance, and Use of Emergency Services Communications Systems, the Dispatch Center is classified as a “Communications Center” which is defined as the following:
“A building or portion of a building that is specifically configured for the primary purpose of providing emergency communications services or public safety answering point (PSAP) services to one or more public safety agencies under the authority or authorities having jurisdiction.”
As such, this letter evaluates the center for compliance with Chapter 4 of NFPA 1221 which is directly applicable to Communication Centers. While NFPA 1221 is not specifically adopted in NH, it is the recognized standard for the building and it is reasonable to use it to evaluate the building.
Stakeholders can then use the information to make informed decisions regarding constriction maintenance, and operational decisions.
CONSULTANT’s survey included a visual assessment of the existing Dispatch Center facility and its current fire protection and life safety systems (i.e. fire alarm system, sprinkler system). The survey did not include an assessment of the Dispatch Center’s operations, staffing, policies, or procedures.
Additionally, CONSULTANT did not interview staff/personnel or analyze existing data from the system such as number of calls, system logging, or similar criteria.
Building Overview
The building is a modular structure and is currently provided with a fire alarm system that includes notification via horn/strobe devices and detection throughout the building. The server room housing the network interface hardware is provided with an Ansul Clean Guard fire extinguisher. No other automatic suppression system was observed within the building (sprinkler or alternative suppression).
System Overview
The dispatch center is currently provided with a Keltron system for supervision of the campus fire alarm system and dispatching emergency services. The system includes three (3) workstations for receiving emergency calls. However, one of these workstations is currently non-operable. The remaining two workstations are fully functional but are running on older generations of Windows operating systems.
There are two network interface systems located within the server room which are redundant to one another. The system also included a printer within the server room which was maintained by the contractor responsible. However, in recent years, the log is no longer maintained by UNH personnel or the contractor responsible.
The system is provided with a UPS which also includes an Automatic Transfer Switch. However, facilities has noted issues with power transfer in the past. Lastly, the system is provided with backup power via a natural gas-fueled generator located on the exterior of the building on emergency and optional standby power.
Dispatch Center and Services – Chapter 4 NFPA 1221 Applicability
Exposure Hazards
Buildings housing a communications center that area also adjacent to another structure are required to protect their exterior walls in accordance with the building code legally in effect, whichever is more restrictive. CONSULTANT noted that the nearest building is greater than 30 feet away and would not present an exposure hazard.
Per NFPA 1221, the lowest floor elevation of the communications center is required to be above the 100-year flood plain established by the Federal Emergency Management Agency. CONSULTANT performed a high level study of the FEMA 100-year floor plain and it does not appear that the building would fall below the elevation.
Construction
In accordance with NFPA 1221, communications centers must be located in buildings constructed of Type I or Type II construction. As previously noted, the subject building is a modular structure that appears to be constructed of steel and other noncombustible materials, which is consistent with a Type II construction classification.
NFPA 1221 Section 4.3.2 also requires buildings housing communications centers to have Class A roof coverings. While CONSULTANT did not conduct an evaluation of the roof covering itself, visual observations indicate that it aligns with the characteristics typical of Type II construction.
Furthermore, communications centers must be separated from other areas of the building not used for emergency communications by fire barriers with a minimum two-hour fire-resistance rating.
Since the dispatch center is located within the UNH Police Department, these separation requirements apply. CONSULTANT observed that the dispatch room, network interface room, and electrical room were equipped with 90-minute rated fire doors, which suggests that the surrounding wall assemblies are likely constructed to meet the required two-hour fire barrier rating. However, CONSULTANT did not perform any destructive testing to confirm the fire-resistance rating of these wall assemblies.
NFPA 1221 also specifies limits on the flame spread and smoke development indices of interior wall and floor finishes. CONSULTANT’s scope of work did not include destructive testing to verify these finish ratings.
Climate Control
HVAC systems serving the communications center must comply with NFPA 90A and 90B. They are required to maintain temperature and humidity within limits specified by the equipment manufacturers, and must be dedicated systems that do not serve any other areas of the building.
Separate temperature and humidity controls must be provided for each equipment room, operations room, office area, and any other space identified by the AHJ. This ensures environmental stability for each critical area.
Where HVAC systems include fresh air intakes, they must be designed to minimize smoke intake during a fire and prevent intentional introduction of toxic or irritating substances. Emergency controls to shut off outside air must be accessible from the operations room.
Backup HVAC systems are required for the operations room and any other areas housing essential electronic equipment as determined by the AHJ. These systems must be capable of operating from both the normal and alternate power sources, and must support uninterrupted operation even if the largest HVAC component fails.
Primary and backup units must be located to prevent tampering, vehicle impact, or exposure to hazardous substances. Their design must ensure continued, secure operation under all expected conditions.
CONSULTANT’s scope did not include an evaluation of the existing HVAC systems.
Fire Protection
The communications center is required to be provided with fire extinguishers that meet the requirements of NFPA 10. Additionally, the communications center and spaces adjoining the communications center are to be provided with an automatic fire detection, alarm, and notification system in accordance with NFPA 72. CONSULTANT did not evaluate all system components for compliance with NFPA 10 and NFPA 72 but was able to confirm the presence of fire extinguishers the fire alarm system. These systems appeared to be installed inline with their respective standard.
Per NFPA 1221 Section 4.5.3, a building housing the communications center is required to be protected throughout by an approved, supervised automatic sprinkler system that complies with NFPA 13 properly supervised by the building fire alarm. Additionally, electronic computer and data processing equipment shall be protected in accordance with NFPA 75. CONSULTANT noted that no sprinkler system is currently present and also that no clean agent system or similar was provided within the computer/processing rooms.
Security
Per NFPA 1221 Section 4.6.1, the communications center and other buildings that house essential operating equipment must be protected against damage from vandalism, terrorism, and civil disturbances. CONSULTANT did not evaluate the existing level of security provided for compliance.
Power
In general, a communications center must be provided with a critical operations power system in compliance with NFPA 70. This includes the operations room, information technology (IT) rooms, telephone rooms, electrical equipment rooms, mechanical equipment rooms, fire protection equipment rooms, sanitary facilities, and other spaces.
At least two independent and reliable power sources must be provided with one primary and one emergency, each of adequate capacity.
As previously discussed, the system is provided with a UPS which also includes an Automatic Transfer Switch with backup power provided via a natural gas-fueled generator located on the exterior of the building.
Lighting
NFPA 1221 requires that artificial lighting be provided for staff to conduct their duties. CONSULTANT noted artificial lighting was present.
Additionally, emergency lighting is required. CONSULTANT was able to confirm the presence of emergency lighting but did not perform any testing of activation time or illumination.
Lightning
Buildings housing a communications center are required to be protected from lightning in accordance with NFPA 780. CONSULTANT did not evaluate the building for compliance with these criteria.
Summary of Findings – Recommendations
The communications center generally appears to align with key NFPA 1221 requirements, including construction type, artificial and emergency lighting, and power sources with UPS and a backup natural gas generator. Fire extinguishers and a fire alarm system are in place, suggesting partial compliance with NFPA 10 and 72. Fire barriers appear to meet the required 2-hour rating based on the presence of
90-minute fire doors, but no wall assembly verification was performed.
However, several critical areas do not meet current code. Notably, the building lacks an automatic sprinkler system and clean agent fire suppression in rooms with electronic computer and data processing equipment, which are required by NFPA 13 and 75.
Additionally, compliance with lightning protection is unknown as well as, emergency lighting performance criteria, HVAC compliance, security compliance, and interior finish compliance. Overall, the facility demonstrates compliance in some foundational areas, further evaluation and upgrades would be recommended to fully meet NFPA 1221 and associated standards.
Part of CONSULTANT’s evaluation was also focused on general compliance of the existing Keltron system.
Based on concerns expressed by the operating personnel as well as concerns with the existing hardware/software, it is recommended that a transition to a more modern, code-compliant alarm monitoring system be pursued. Options include IP- or cellular-based communicators, mesh radio systems like AES-IntelliNet, or integration with a UL-listed third-party central monitoring station. If direct alarm receipt by dispatch is needed, upgrading to a compatible Municipal Alarm Receiving System (MARS) with IP/cellular capabilities is advised. These alternatives provide greater reliability, scalability, and compliance with NFPA 72.
| Scope of Review |
| Building Overview |
| System Overview |
| Dispatch Center and Services – Chapter 4 NFPA 1221 Applicability |
| Summary of Findings – Recommendations |
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .